Ideologically Captured! with Peter Boghossian (Why we believe what we believe)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 73

  • @drpeterboghossian
    @drpeterboghossian 26 днів тому +31

    Thanks for having me on your show, Mark. I appreciate it.

  • @w1cked001
    @w1cked001 22 дні тому +4

    I’m grateful to Dr Boghossian for reigniting my love for philosophy after college. And also for introducing me to the doctor of bjj Matt Thornton

  • @DarrenFMagee
    @DarrenFMagee 18 днів тому +3

    Interesting conversation guys thank you

  • @m.talley1660
    @m.talley1660 19 днів тому +3

    The algorithm brought me here - following Mr. Boghossian (Dr). This conversation is much appreciated.
    Seems the best seekers are ones who have left behind a religion, cult, or institution.

  • @9ja9ite
    @9ja9ite 22 дні тому +5

    Hey Mark. Great video. Thrilled that you had Peter on. First time seeing your channel. Your content looks up my alley so I’m gonna sub since you had my man Peter on. Good luck growing the channel. I’m gonna keep my eye on you 😂 🤙

  • @fifidownunda
    @fifidownunda 24 дні тому +7

    Peter Boghossian, you are a legend!

  • @justanotherhuman42_
    @justanotherhuman42_ 24 дні тому +3

    This came up on my recommended bc I love Boghossian - Unrelated to him, but I just have to say, thank you for your instrumental part in taking down NXIVM! subscribed.

  • @Traderbear
    @Traderbear 21 день тому +5

    Great conversation gentlemen, and I love the set and vibe 😊

  • @psychicconsultant453
    @psychicconsultant453 25 днів тому +6

    I always enjoy your conversations, and Peter Boghossian was a great guest to have on

    • @markvicente7
      @markvicente7  25 днів тому +2

      Thank you so much for listening!

  • @johannalove2jojo
    @johannalove2jojo 22 дні тому +3

    I LOVE THE TWO OF YOU JAZZING IT OUT!!!!!!!!!! MORE !!!!! 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

  • @KnellzBellz
    @KnellzBellz 22 дні тому +1

    @19:40 it's not a fact. It's your experience. I've had a very different experience. The shunning goes both ways.
    @32:00 Humility ftw. 🎉
    @39:30 ❌️ Blanket statements like this are why people tune people out.
    @46:45 🎯
    @57:15 So which is it? Do we surround ourselves with fellow intellectuals because they'll challenge wrongthink or because they'll join us in our rationalization? I'd argue that the root of our problems is pride, regardless of accumen.
    @01:05:55 💯👏🏻... @01:06:05 Noooo!! 🤣
    Interesting discussion. Thank you, both. ☺️

  • @felicityfourie1785
    @felicityfourie1785 26 днів тому +5

    Once I was confident that I knew the truth. That was comfortable. Now all I know is that the truth is beyond my ability to comprehend. That is also comfortable!

  • @ferkinskin
    @ferkinskin 16 днів тому +2

    And the highest sin is to doubt!!

  • @tmftt9087
    @tmftt9087 23 дні тому +1

    Good interviewer with questions that seemed to genuinely interest PB. I would have liked some inquiry of why he thinks govt debt is the most troubling thing facing humanity. And justification for why Harris and Trump are equally horrific options.

  • @louiseroherty4694
    @louiseroherty4694 24 дні тому +1

    There is so much that a gained from listening to this conversation but rather than that, I want to mention something that seems very matter of fact, that helped me, to help my mind move from “an amydala response to a prefrontal cortex response “ … It was the idea of bringing to consciousness the commonalites you share with a person with whom you have a conflicting theory to explore. Thank you.

  • @nubosite
    @nubosite 23 дні тому +1

    The way he quotes Aristotle for virtually everything makes me wonder, he appears to have more faith in the guy than Christians have in their God. He’s no atheist, but a man of Faith.

  • @waters-above
    @waters-above 26 днів тому +1

    Great title!! It certainly captured my attention, and I clicked right away!

  • @DorotheaAntonio
    @DorotheaAntonio 26 днів тому +3

    A great guest!!! 😊

  • @ronkrate609
    @ronkrate609 24 дні тому

    I forgot, I'm not watching him anymore -- -Johny one note Pete

  • @Traderbear
    @Traderbear 21 день тому +2

    I’ll say it, it has been UCLA, and I die a little every time as an alum.

  • @edbop
    @edbop 24 дні тому

    To reassure you the US, much like the UK and other countries with their own currency and central bank, cannot be forced into default on debt denominated in their own currency. If the interest payments get too hard to manage the government could simply pay off the bonds and not issue new ones. Bonds are issued as a bung to the wealthiest, they are not required; put another way the govt does not have to match deficit spending with bond issues. Now if you want to stop everything going to pot we have to stop using bank credit and stop the banks from creating new money.

  • @KnellzBellz
    @KnellzBellz 22 дні тому

    @01:08:15 Lmao two minutes ago, dismissing entire groups of people for their lack of intellect. Now, "Why would that be important to anybody?" *sigh*
    Okay but nailed it right at the end.
    God bless us. Every one. 😂 #OysterParty

  • @HomeFromFarAway
    @HomeFromFarAway 24 дні тому +2

    Peterson exhibits so many personality cult tendencies, if not directly then just looking at his fanbase and the rabid defence of him in totality. you're not allowed to dislike him until youve listened to every single one of his thousand-hour monologues with circular reasoning and theistic nonsense.
    The only way I can endure him is when Sam Harris is firmly steering the converswtion back to reality

  • @GiovanniAdami
    @GiovanniAdami 21 день тому

    "But liberalism isn't ideology! You can't be ideologically captured by our religion of liberalism!"

  • @speculativereality
    @speculativereality 25 днів тому

    There is an honesty to being unapologetic. Immediate & Commensurate Accountability is the way to at least inspire sincere repentance, contrition, and amendment.

  • @wadetisthammer3612
    @wadetisthammer3612 19 днів тому +1

    17:45 to 21:25 - How free speech got associated with fascism (not sure the question was fully directly answered).
    56:29 to 56:51 - That kind of makes it sound like they'd be more susceptible to ridiculous ideas.

  • @angelcitystudio
    @angelcitystudio 23 дні тому +3

    I dont really care about how crazy and polarized people are politically... I only know that as a humanist, the bible thumping crowd won't get my vote. And you cant discuss anything with them because they are driven by faith, not facts and data. Not much more to say.

  • @johnharmon536
    @johnharmon536 21 день тому +1

    Peter is just like the rest of these content creators. They find the one topic that makes the money and they never talk about anything else.

    • @Rogerholberg
      @Rogerholberg 18 днів тому +1

      You obviously know nothing about him. He may specialize but has thousands of videos and interviews just on UA-cam in which he discusses a myriad of subjects, utterly refuting your comment.

    • @johnharmon536
      @johnharmon536 17 днів тому +1

      @@Rogerholberg If you really don't think he has found his lane with the anti woke and anti trans topics and is pushing the print money button with it, I can't help you see what is right in front of you.

    • @Orson2u
      @Orson2u 10 днів тому +1

      So. A channel ought to be a variety show instead?

    • @Orson2u
      @Orson2u 10 днів тому +1

      So. His channel ought to be a variety show instead?

  • @JanessaRick
    @JanessaRick 3 дні тому +1

    So he thinks we should communicate with people we disagree with but he calls people “ stupid”.. not the best way to connect
    Why didn’t you ask him
    I think he sounds interesting I disagree with him about certain things.. it “ stupid” not exactly helpful to his goals!!!

    • @markvicente7
      @markvicente7  2 дні тому +1

      Yes. Apparently we humans are full of contradictions.

  • @Nyabungu
    @Nyabungu 8 днів тому

    This is like a bully who for 300 yrs beat up others in the playground but when the victims get handed whipping sticks(DEI), he cries foul(plagiarism).He reminds me of Goebbels.

  • @Camelrider-om1ei
    @Camelrider-om1ei 26 днів тому +5

    Has Peter Boghossian ever changed his mind or apologized for any mistakes he has made? The interviewer might've asked him that but of course not. He was too busy fawning.

  • @timolsen8252
    @timolsen8252 24 дні тому

    Secularism as a religion without mercy or redemption?

  • @Camelrider-om1ei
    @Camelrider-om1ei 26 днів тому +6

    Peter Boghossian is trying to "spark open conversation?" This is a guy who routinely calls his political opponents "mentally ill", "deranged"," delusional." Yup, that's a great way to spark open conversation

    • @ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
      @ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh 25 днів тому +2

      That's fair, but do you have an arguments against his points or do you just dislike the way he makes them?

    • @HomeFromFarAway
      @HomeFromFarAway 24 дні тому +1

      ​@@ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh This is the first time I have heard him but, while I admire an obviously good mind and some sensible points, I definitely get a lot of "cluster B"

    • @martinsanders1283
      @martinsanders1283 24 дні тому +2

      He doesn’t call his political opponents mentally ill. He calls their ideas idiotic. That’s because they are idiotic. Logic, you see.

    • @Camelrider-om1ei
      @Camelrider-om1ei 24 дні тому +2

      @@martinsanders1283 except that he has called a mentally ill on numerous occasions so you're just wrong. But I can tell you're a fan boy so let's not carry this on any further.

    • @Camelrider-om1ei
      @Camelrider-om1ei 24 дні тому +1

      @@ashhhhhhhhhhhhhhh I have numerous issues with his points, but a full discussion of that would take far longer than possible in a UA-cam thread. But "that said "this blatant hypocrisy should give anybody a clue as to what he is all about.