@@machanurunaveen2325 @punna28 said ‘this woman’ specifically and not ‘women’ as in general terms. Pls learn English properly and don’t be misconstrued
I fully agree. She is clearly avoiding discussion when she is unable to answer and takes cover under her lack of knowledge of the law or of the constitution. This woman must answer if the Board is not as big as God, then is the Govt bigger than God.
@@machanurunaveen2325Now Sudha Murthy who had a few months ago said that "Rakshabandhan was started from Mughal times is an ideal Hindu woman?" The whole Murthy family is crypto Christian. Has she or anybody from her family raised their voices against the plight of Hindus in Bangladesh, or this Tirupati issue? The proof is in the pudding. They are cryptos
What an idiotic panellist they have gotten in the form on Nundy.... Her views are baffling and hard to believe she's a supreme court lawyer! Dushyanth Sridhar on the other hand was at least able to articulate his views in a logical manner
Thank you to Pawan Kalyan for raising his voice for freeing Hindu temples from the clutches of the government. Why this injustice with only Hindus when other religions worship places are free?
Temples cannot be free because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
Jagan's YSRC had been supporting Modi in the Rajya Sabha to get pass every controversial bills and TDP is now part of NDA lead by BJP. Further, it is self boasting Hindu hridaya samrat modi have been ruling the country since 2014. It looks Hindus and Hindu beliefs are more challenged and under threat under present ruling dispensation at the center and state.
Rightly said Dushantji. We need literate people like you on the debate who make the debate more sensible and meaningful. Salute to you. Everything you said was to the point.
Don't even dignify her by calling her madam when she kept calling Dushyanth Sridhar as "previous speaker" instead of calling him by his name. She looked arrogant and looked quite disdainful of the Sanatan way of life. She wouldn't even possess as much knowledge as Dushyanth ji on Vedas. Such so called secular people will never even help Hindus. Forget it.
@@Neo_Shankarthese pseudo seculars and uprooted people from their own culture seems dangerous to society and hindu culture which has kept our country united and democratic..i just want to ask karuna nandy that will she be able to talk freely in an Islamiccountry??
And this Karuna Nandy 's haughty, condescending attitude - she keeps addressing Dushyant Sridhar as the other speaker 😂! Also she doesnt even give an opinion on the equity of only Hindu temples being administered by the government !
Very right questions it is high time we discuss and highlight in a so called Secular nation! Hats off to you Dushyanth Sridhar, a very well handled debate. If only the people associated with the SC could learn from you as to how to navigate a debate 🙂
Temples cannot be free because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
2 months back I commented in 'pgurus' channel, as: "after the new govt.came in power, the quality of Laddus has improved drastically and this was my real experience". Many had supported my view.
It is absolutely not about the quality of the taste. It is criminal cheating, deceit of the sentiments of the devotees. Extremely serious criminal breach of trust and deceit.
@@Subuhi61Forcefully taking milk from cow in dairy farm or milkman's farm and claiming it is vegetarian? is cow milk not having animal fat? Does this whole dairy product usage make any sense as vegetarian, pure, sacred? Cow keeps quiet as it has no other option. Forcefully give birth to calf and have to produce milk.
@@mageshmac4716It's a matter of degrees of cruelty. Taking Milk from an animal is not as cruel as chopping it off or its calf , or for that matter any other animal, to satisfy one's hunger / taste buds. Hope you are able to see the difference.
We Demand FreeHinduTemples From Secular Govt ASAP. Much needed to stop all the lootings of devotees money from temple fund and diverting it to other religions...ridiculous law made by our great dynasty as they owned India...
It is not a ridiculous law. The temples are still free and still spread brahmavad. Freeing temples means supporting Brahmavad - which will destroy India again just like past.
So glad i am not the only one asking this question. She just runs rhetorics....trans rights and womens rights.....can she name any other religion that gives the same rights and right to live atleast other than hinduism 😅 doesnt have her facts....empty head
స్వామి దర్శనానికి టికెట్లు టాయిలెట్ టికెట్లు పార్కింగ్ టికెట్లు ఇతర ఆరాధన సంస్థలలో ఉండవు ఒక్క హిందూ దేవాలయాల్లోని ఈ దోపిడి జరుగుతున్నది సిగ్గుచేటు ఒక్క రాజకీయ నాయకుడు ఒక మీడియా కూడా ఖండించు ఖండించు
This advocate claims to have no clear view of so many things. Can you believe it? Why cant you have knowledgeable panelists to have a meaningful discussion?
@@vinsin328 caste is your identity. Example kanyakumari one particular Church owned by Nadar caste Christians or a single other caste. Kanyakumari one particular temple means 8000 Tamil caste people own it. So which caste will control it???? All caste people will fight.
@@vinsin328in kerala jacobite and Syrian orthodox keep on fighting, one protestant officer was not allowed to be burried in RC grave, one little boy was not allowed to be burried because his mother was associated with another church, one man is fighting alone in Tamilnadu as he is sc Christian
In what capacity was Karuna Nandy invited to this debate, I couldn’t make out, may be she was alleging that Hindu temples should be managed by LGBTQ++- to get fair reflection & representation of social spectrum in temples board management. In fact all socialist, reformist experiments must be strictly limited to Hindu temples *only* without disturbing the social fabric & secular structure of other faiths.🙄🙏🏻
The news is most devastating for Hindus after 1856 sipayi mutiny . At that time army rebelled against usage of beef fat in cleaning guns . It became first freedom struggle for the country Jagan is Christian and he should not have interfered in appointments of TTD . Subba reddy and karunakar reddy were also having bad credentials as there were photoes circulating of thier visits to churches praying there . How can you appoint such people to TTD board ! Jagan never signed in the register certifying his belief in god Venkateswara inspite of his visits to tirumala as CM. His wife is also Christian . His sister sharmila is a Christian and his brother in law is big pastor controlling Christian conversions . How can we allow this nonsense . Sharmila is now issuing statements as if she was not part of Jagan party till recently . Jagan did every possible act to distroy Hinduism during his tenure. He banned the canteens of Akshaya Patra foundation giving food to poor people just because some church missioneries opposed them on the ground that no villager is coming forward for conversion as food served in packets by Christians just to lure poor Hindus was no more welcome . Jagan banned food Boeing served by Akshaya Patra foundation in Anna canteens 300 temples were attacked and no case was allowed to prosecute the culprits . People were complaining about things that were happening at Tirupathi for the last five years as there were very bad in every action that was taking place whether it if food service or tickets or diversion of TTD funds to non religious activities There is no way to get out of this mess except hand over to noted hindu maths in similar line that Udipi was being managed . We can also allow seven famous /pious maths to manage the TTD in turns of every two years Let centre force an act got all temples in india compulsorily . Tamil Nadu in perticular was suffering as the temples there were not allowed to managed by mutts by dmk . We have to forcibly take over the temple admn and make them managed by mutts only
Army didn't rebel, some brahmavadi did. It was not a freedom struggle but a fight to kill humans do that cows can rule. Hinduism destroyed by Brahmavadi. You try to force Brahmaavd and untouchability there would be another partition.
She is applying different frames to Hindu. Lady, aasmani kithab people came much later to this land and waqf board even much later. Blinds can get the operation done to fix their vision but these left laal salam people are blind even with properly working organs.
Temple should be made independent of governments. Why should governments involve into temples? How are they selecting key officials who make decisions and what kind of awareness they have on the temple and it's traditions?
Jagan is not on the board of ttd. He is not a christian. He professed hindu faith by dipping in ganga. He has a hindu guru whom he reveres. No chrisitan does this. This itself is an example. Please dont call him a christian.Jagans fault is appointing his family memebers. Britishers also managed ttd at one time. Dont blame the religions fir the fault of persons.
All the temples in the country were and are created by the people and governed by the leaders and followed by the government today. It's not by particular group or by private body.
No temple board can be formed..because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
I think there is 3 major things to be considered... 1. Temple management.. 2.Temple rituals, prasad, annadanam.. 3. Temple maintenance, house keeping etc... Mansgement must be by professionals.. Ritials etc by experianced and qualified priests.. Maintnance etc by committee of devotees.. Please do remember that there are a lot of temple's who do not have that much income... As it is TTD we are discussing about it.. The Andhra politics is another reason why we discuss about it. In my little experiance / knowledge nobody is worried about quality and purity of Pooja material in Government controlled temples or Private temples or temples being run by trusts /ashrans etc.. oil, milk, butter, Sandle wood, kalabham, vibhoithi /bhasma, camphor, what is being manufacturered and marketed is consumed as it is Also we have to resolve the discrimination amoung ourself based on cast in temples
Dushyanth ji, we respect & love you..❤ India Today, please choose a panelist worthy of being a co-panelist with DS ji. This lady seems lost on what to say. Are you sure she is a lawyer?? ...
Karuna Nundy seems to be living in a dream-world. You should have called someone who knows the issues. She seems to have just waked in without ascertaining the issues.
The main problem with lawyers is that they feel the laws written in the constitution are unchangeable like laws of physics. Even physics laws have undergone changes, then what's the question of sitting and interpreting human written laws again and again. If required, just change it to make more logical sense.
Thanks to Mr. Chander babu Nauru for bringing this henious act to light. No wonder Tirumala lately changed 180 degrees and did not seem to generate the once great spiritual aura it offered..
To sum up the debate while Mr Shridhar was stating facts and giving pretty great suggestions.... The other one was just making some factless statements and trying to just oppose Mr Shridhar.... I've never seen such a senseless panelists..... She was just there because she's fluent in English... That's all..... And I support the notion made by Mr Shridhar that our temples should be out of government control. Jay Shri Ram ⛳
Ms. Nandy, Appreciate the candour. Clearly stated what she was asked to speak about? What are some legal implications of these issues? what are her personal opinions on them and government interventions...
Everybody is talking about freeing temples from the govt., But you will free them and give them to whom?? The old social structures have been demolished and most of the families that used to take care of these temples have migrated to other areas, cities. The problem is finding right people to give the temples to.
That is also not the issue, slowly the Brahmavad will start taking care of these temples again and then will stop beef eating Hindus and will promote untouchability.
@@vinsin328 A beef eater is not Hindu. and must not be allowed inside the temples. especially other religions and faiths. its funny that you don't have problem with other religions calling the people who don't follow their rules a kafir, a heathen or a gentile but you have problem with the homegrown one. kya liberal bhai saab wah.
@@vinsin328 yeah we know this problem. But thats why we are talking about creating a individual body a board either a national or state level board that controls hindu temples of that particular state like Shiromani gurudwara commitee that controls all gurudwaras . Because every temple has its own set of culture and practice which belongs to that particular area or state so state level bodies should be formed. But the govt must ensure that caste discrimination doesn't happen. I will even go to an extent to say that the big temples like tirupati, jagannath puri , rameswaram, ayodhya, dwarkadish, siddhivinayak, kamakhya should have there state level gurukuls The gurukuls should give education on math , science along with all vedas , upanishads , Purana, parampara, shashtra, niti and customs related to that temple. Anyone can join that. Whoever passes the exams on vedas and all will have the upanayan sanskar and will be officially made a Brahmin. The Brahmins with very good score and talent will be taken in by big temples while the remaining will be given responsibility of different smaller and local big temples. The big temples must pay the small temples to run them . This will also be a step to bring back the old system where caste is not hereditary but fluid anyone with proper caliber and morality can become Brahmin.
It's better to hand over the control of temples to religious bodies. It won't put an end to corruption or mismanagement. Where there's money, there will be crooks trying to grab it. At least, the government can escape the blame.
Namaste, The news has shaken Sanatanis globally. Only Hindus understand the sensitivity and the gravity of commotion which is on the verge. How can non Hindus decide and alter on spiritual practices? We demand " Sanatana Board" and release from the God damned Endowment Commission that sucks Hindus of their contributions and is a stalemate in this gruesome endeavour. 🚩Jai Shree Ram 🚩
The Temples must be seperated from government control. The Home Minister and Pm promised that steps will be taken to protect the Temples from political and government control during Shabarimala agitation. But the government has done nothing in this direction.
I urge CM & Dy.C.M of AP must release Temples from Govt of AP as a first examplary state in India. Would Mr.Naidu and Mr.Pawan make this changes into Hindu Temples in Andhra Pradesh now because they are in power??? If they don't do it, they are making false allegations and they remain as anti-hindus and anti-indian.
TDP along with the BJP is trying to ignite religious tensions that never existed before in AP. YSRCP is asking for an CBI enquiry, what is stopping them to do that??
Government should introduce a policy on all the temples and form trustees for every temple to ensure proceedings and other management requirements meets its due diligence. This way, Government will able to monitor on the trustees appointed. Trustees should be well versed in Temple management. Government should facilitate the needs of a temple and ensure they are well received by the trustees.
The UPA and its aides have sticked on to one narration and that is to speak about fssai and keep it as neutral as possible and show that sananthana dharma is just fine and hindus who are overreacting are extremists . 👍 Nice
The daily wage earners in Karnataka and Andhra are targeted and getting converted in large scale. Our maid in Karnataka got converted two years back and now she doesn’t touch prasadam or follow the tradition that she has been following for ages! Also her entire family and neighborhood got converted..
See Thiruvanna malai temple I personally fitnesses the poor management and temple is in very bad shape today when compared to twenty years ago Why Why temple fund is not utilised for temple management ?
Yes.. When even Prasad they cannot monitor what is the use of TTD and members... Scrap it and hand over to those who are directly maintaining the sanctity of the temple..
Government not handling any funds or activities there. It was handled by Devastanam board. That board only decide, what to do over there. That commitee only decides, what the temple needs.
This woman is a supreme court lawyer? Really ? She talks like a primary school student. Dushyant Sridhar is very clear in his explanation. Also Dushyant makes a good point that Pawan Kalyan's Hindu Rakshana Board may be a temporaty band aid solution But the problem of temples being under state control wont go away until Hindus are allowed to managed their temples, just as muslims are allowed to managed mosques and Christians allowed to manage churches. Why should Christians be allowed on Thiurmala Thirupathi board. Will Hindus be allowed on any church board?
So hindus if YSR and YSS takes this matter to CJI and SC we can expect more or less this type of view and another disappoinment ... This is just trailer...
This woman proved herself to be totally unfit to discuss this matter.
@@machanurunaveen2325 @punna28 said ‘this woman’ specifically and not ‘women’ as in general terms. Pls learn English properly and don’t be misconstrued
@@siva-sivA💯
I fully agree. She is clearly avoiding discussion when she is unable to answer and takes cover under her lack of knowledge of the law or of the constitution. This woman must answer if the Board is not as big as God, then is the Govt bigger than God.
@@siva-sivAwell said Sir….this so called Supreme court lawyer is clueless and she’s talking as though she is from USA…
@@machanurunaveen2325Now Sudha Murthy who had a few months ago said that "Rakshabandhan was started from Mughal times is an ideal Hindu woman?"
The whole Murthy family is crypto Christian. Has she or anybody from her family raised their voices against the plight of Hindus in Bangladesh, or this Tirupati issue? The proof is in the pudding. They are cryptos
The lawyer madam on the panel has absolutely no clue of the subject. Please chose your panelists carefully .
naxal hee
She is a leftist brainwash. They are a curse on the society
What an idiotic panellist they have gotten in the form on Nundy.... Her views are baffling and hard to believe she's a supreme court lawyer! Dushyanth Sridhar on the other hand was at least able to articulate his views in a logical manner
Sir, the way the supreme court has reduced in their level, only people like karuna nandy can become supreme court judges😅
Thank you to Pawan Kalyan for raising his voice for freeing Hindu temples from the clutches of the government. Why this injustice with only Hindus when other religions worship places are free?
This temple already governed by 3 % wala 😂😂😂
No religion must be under control of govt whose majority is rascals
Why do you care mr.soloman you are a christian... @@johnsolomonprince5972
Temples cannot be free because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
Jagan's YSRC had been supporting Modi in the Rajya Sabha to get pass every controversial bills and TDP is now part of NDA lead by BJP. Further, it is self boasting Hindu hridaya samrat modi have been ruling the country since 2014. It looks Hindus and Hindu beliefs are more challenged and under threat under present ruling dispensation at the center and state.
This is the wake up call for all sanatani .
There have been many wake-up calls since the Ramayana. We are still divided. I don't know when we will be together
@@Sketcher868000 castes in andra😂😂😂😂
Which caste ? Pahale Hindu baad me sanatan , pata nai kal kya 😂
@@SHANSHOW- porimona anba kunnaya nee parayunna
@@SHANSHOW- u r north Indian landlocked people and no exposure
Rightly said Dushantji. We need literate people like you on the debate who make the debate more sensible and meaningful. Salute to you. Everything you said was to the point.
Karuna Madam dont even know which state Tirupathi located .
Don't even dignify her by calling her madam when she kept calling Dushyanth Sridhar as "previous speaker" instead of calling him by his name. She looked arrogant and looked quite disdainful of the Sanatan way of life. She wouldn't even possess as much knowledge as Dushyanth ji on Vedas. Such so called secular people will never even help Hindus. Forget it.
@@Neo_Shankarthese pseudo seculars and uprooted people from their own culture seems dangerous to society and hindu culture which has kept our country united and democratic..i just want to ask karuna nandy that will she be able to talk freely in an Islamiccountry??
@@Neo_ShankarShe is left leaning supremacist who has a strong dislike for Hindus. Don't get fooled by their Hindu names.
She is hawt
What can u expect from modern, secular and west influenced women
Dushyant rocks! Clear. Precise.
Now I know which lawyer I should NOT engage in the Supreme Court for any legal issues 😳
Great comment. Hurrah.
😂😂😂
U r intelligent and positive mind man,your family is lucky having u.
And this Karuna Nandy 's haughty, condescending attitude - she keeps addressing Dushyant Sridhar as the other speaker 😂! Also she doesnt even give an opinion on the equity of only Hindu temples being administered by the government !
Very right questions it is high time we discuss and highlight in a so called Secular nation! Hats off to you Dushyanth Sridhar, a very well handled debate. If only the people associated with the SC could learn from you as to how to navigate a debate 🙂
Temples cannot be free because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
Who is this lawyer? Can be a great actor!
After Meena Kumari 😂
Fair skin. Only qualification.
I agree 👍🏻 .. free up the temples from govt bodies and give it to the people who practicing agama sastra strictly.
Who is this Karuna Nandy? You could have chosen a more involved person instead of a person who has zilch knowledge
2 months back I commented in 'pgurus' channel, as: "after the new govt.came in power, the quality of Laddus has improved drastically and this was my real experience". Many had supported my view.
It is absolutely not about the quality of the taste. It is criminal cheating, deceit of the sentiments of the devotees. Extremely serious criminal breach of trust and deceit.
@@Subuhi61Forcefully taking milk from cow in dairy farm or milkman's farm and claiming it is vegetarian? is cow milk not having animal fat? Does this whole dairy product usage make any sense as vegetarian, pure, sacred?
Cow keeps quiet as it has no other option. Forcefully give birth to calf and have to produce milk.
@@mageshmac4716It's a matter of degrees of cruelty. Taking Milk from an animal is not as cruel as chopping it off or its calf , or for that matter any other animal, to satisfy one's hunger / taste buds. Hope you are able to see the difference.
We Demand
FreeHinduTemples From Secular Govt ASAP.
Much needed to stop all the lootings of devotees money from temple fund and diverting it to other religions...ridiculous law made by our great dynasty as they owned India...
Then RSS brahmins and co politician loot all the money
I support u r words.
@@molakathalasubha951stupidity. 5000 castes in Andra. Who will manage😂😂😂
It is not a ridiculous law. The temples are still free and still spread brahmavad. Freeing temples means supporting Brahmavad - which will destroy India again just like past.
@@vinsin328very true if we free temples it's impossible to make India bible country for missionaries it will be very hard to convert
Is she winning any cases in the court?
@@Shashi3577 🤣🤣
So glad i am not the only one asking this question. She just runs rhetorics....trans rights and womens rights.....can she name any other religion that gives the same rights and right to live atleast other than hinduism 😅 doesnt have her facts....empty head
@@Shashi3577 Utter failure
Pro-Muslim and pro-Christian cases , she does win
It's disgusting watching such people from our own community
She says various frame can be applied. They have called an entire village as wqft land. Tbis lady debator is a waste of time. She is very ineffective.
Who is this Karuna Nundy who is talking without any knowledge or care or empathy
Mr. Dushyanth Sridhar has very articulately expressed the Hindu point of view! 🙌🏻
India Today should bring in people with adequate knowledge, not just for arguments or to raise TRP ratings
Karuna Nundy will not even know which end she should be eating from , poor choice by the channel.
స్వామి దర్శనానికి టికెట్లు టాయిలెట్ టికెట్లు పార్కింగ్ టికెట్లు ఇతర ఆరాధన సంస్థలలో ఉండవు ఒక్క హిందూ దేవాలయాల్లోని ఈ దోపిడి జరుగుతున్నది సిగ్గుచేటు ఒక్క రాజకీయ నాయకుడు ఒక మీడియా కూడా ఖండించు ఖండించు
That's why we want free hindu temple from government
Even in Ambaji temple Gujarat no free Prasad for devotees also 😅😮😮 fucking even after received too much donation from devotees
@@dev7155g because secular government taxing high on our temple.
@@Bharatyodhha In Gujarat BJP government, people must ask where and how they spend donation money?
@@dev7155g are you nuts? Don't you see Hindus demanding free temple from government. And are you Hindu ?
This advocate claims to have no clear view of so many things. Can you believe it? Why cant you have knowledgeable panelists to have a meaningful discussion?
It's because of woke people like her that Hindus are suffering and other religions are exploding in population
When Tamilnadu govt wants to end sanatan dharma,it has no right to control temples
8000 castes in TN😂😂😂
@@IvanMendnee ellam poi savu
Missionaries agent
Church and mosque should be in government hand
Each Church one caste. Andra 8000 castes😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why? for what? Churches do not discriminate people based on food habits, gender, caste and profession.
@@vinsin328 caste is your identity. Example kanyakumari one particular Church owned by Nadar caste Christians or a single other caste. Kanyakumari one particular temple means 8000 Tamil caste people own it. So which caste will control it???? All caste people will fight.
@@vinsin328in kerala jacobite and Syrian orthodox keep on fighting, one protestant officer was not allowed to be burried in RC grave, one little boy was not allowed to be burried because his mother was associated with another church, one man is fighting alone in Tamilnadu as he is sc Christian
@@SR-mv6wn caste is your identity not religion
Sanatan rakshana board is needed in India
Andra 8000 castes😂😂😂
In what capacity was Karuna Nandy invited to this debate, I couldn’t make out, may be she was alleging that Hindu temples should be managed by LGBTQ++- to get fair reflection & representation of social spectrum in temples board management. In fact all socialist, reformist experiments must be strictly limited to Hindu temples *only* without disturbing the social fabric & secular structure of other faiths.🙄🙏🏻
The news is most devastating for Hindus after 1856 sipayi mutiny . At that time army rebelled against usage of beef fat in cleaning guns . It became first freedom struggle for the country
Jagan is Christian and he should not have interfered in appointments of TTD . Subba reddy and karunakar reddy were also having bad credentials as there were photoes circulating of thier visits to churches praying there . How can you appoint such people to TTD board ! Jagan never signed in the register certifying his belief in god Venkateswara inspite of his visits to tirumala as CM. His wife is also Christian . His sister sharmila is a Christian and his brother in law is big pastor controlling Christian conversions . How can we allow this nonsense . Sharmila is now issuing statements as if she was not part of Jagan party till recently . Jagan did every possible act to distroy Hinduism during his tenure. He banned the canteens of Akshaya Patra foundation giving food to poor people just because some church missioneries opposed them on the ground that no villager is coming forward for conversion as food served in packets by Christians just to lure poor Hindus was no more welcome . Jagan banned food Boeing served by Akshaya Patra foundation in Anna canteens
300 temples were attacked and no case was allowed to prosecute the culprits
.
People were complaining about things that were happening at Tirupathi for the last five years as there were very bad in every action that was taking place whether it if food service or tickets or diversion of TTD funds to non religious activities
There is no way to get out of this mess except hand over to noted hindu maths in similar line that Udipi was being managed . We can also allow seven famous /pious maths to manage the TTD in turns of every two years
Let centre force an act got all temples in india compulsorily . Tamil Nadu in perticular was suffering as the temples there were not allowed to managed by mutts by dmk . We have to forcibly take over the temple admn and make them managed by mutts only
Army didn't rebel, some brahmavadi did. It was not a freedom struggle but a fight to kill humans do that cows can rule. Hinduism destroyed by Brahmavadi. You try to force Brahmaavd and untouchability there would be another partition.
She is applying different frames to Hindu. Lady, aasmani kithab people came much later to this land and waqf board even much later. Blinds can get the operation done to fix their vision but these left laal salam people are blind even with properly working organs.
Yes.....cruel politicians should not have managed control in temple
Temple should be made independent of governments. Why should governments involve into temples? How are they selecting key officials who make decisions and what kind of awareness they have on the temple and it's traditions?
Free Temples From Govt Control - ABSOLUTELY!
Kiska temple . Yo raaja kaun tha ? Kiss caste ka tha ?
Yes Hindu Temples should be free from Govt Control like churches and Majid .Only
Karuna Nundy = Karunanidhi?
In drag 😂😂😂
There are many irregularities taken place in TTD during the regime of Jagan Reddy who hs a Christian and so there is clear impact on TTD 😢😢😢😢😢
Jagan is not on the board of ttd. He is not a christian. He professed hindu faith by dipping in ganga. He has a hindu guru whom he reveres. No chrisitan does this. This itself is an example. Please dont call him a christian.Jagans fault is appointing his family memebers. Britishers also managed ttd at one time. Dont blame the religions fir the fault of persons.
@@Rajraj-rh1kfandra 8000 castes😂😂😂
It is time to free temple from government control. Government can only review accounts can not decide anything.
They can to fight against Brahmavad.
this lawyer knows everything but its her ideology which is not allowing to speak truth. Now u understand why criminals get released from supreme court
fabulous justification as always by mr dushyanth.
kudos.
TN hindus are treated badly . feeling v low about it
How is India a secular nation when govt handles Hindu temples?
It is a Hindu nation. Period.
Andra 8000 castes😂😂😂😂 what hindu man😂😂
Nope, it is not a Hindu nation. Govt control temples to save from Brahmavad. Learn some history.
Hindu is not religion , it is jaatiyon ka mela .
Yes temples shall have an independent Board as Universities have.
But at the control of the government
All the temples in the country were and are created by the people and governed by the leaders and followed by the government today. It's not by particular group or by private body.
@@pakkirisamypon4974no...
No temple board can be formed..because for opposition parties and one sided secular Supreme Court wants hindu temple money to build and support churches and masjids i n the name of secularism 🎉
@@pakkirisamypon4974andra 8000 castes😂😂😂 what hindu 😂😂
I think there is 3 major things to be considered...
1. Temple management..
2.Temple rituals, prasad, annadanam..
3. Temple maintenance, house keeping etc...
Mansgement must be by professionals..
Ritials etc by experianced and qualified priests..
Maintnance etc by committee of devotees..
Please do remember that there are a lot of temple's who do not have that much income...
As it is TTD we are discussing about it.. The Andhra politics is another reason why we discuss about it.
In my little experiance / knowledge nobody is worried about quality and purity of Pooja material in Government controlled temples or Private temples or temples being run by trusts /ashrans etc..
oil, milk, butter, Sandle wood, kalabham, vibhoithi /bhasma, camphor, what is being manufacturered and marketed is consumed as it is
Also we have to resolve the discrimination amoung ourself based on cast in temples
Dushyanth ji, we respect & love you..❤
India Today, please choose a panelist worthy of being a co-panelist with DS ji. This lady seems lost on what to say. Are you sure she is a lawyer??
...
Karuna Nundy seems to be living in a dream-world. You should have called someone who knows the issues. She seems to have just waked in without ascertaining the issues.
Let the effort start all will support 💪
People were fooled earlier,now we have brains and pinpoint their selfish narrative i condem that man ,for what he is speaking.
The main problem with lawyers is that they feel the laws written in the constitution are unchangeable like laws of physics. Even physics laws have undergone changes, then what's the question of sitting and interpreting human written laws again and again. If required, just change it to make more logical sense.
Karuna has no grounds to talk about this issue.
All state govts in India may take over all the places of worship from private.
Thanks to Mr. Chander babu Nauru for bringing this henious act to light. No wonder Tirumala lately changed 180 degrees and did not seem to generate the once great spiritual aura it offered..
To sum up the debate while Mr Shridhar was stating facts and giving pretty great suggestions.... The other one was just making some factless statements and trying to just oppose Mr Shridhar.... I've never seen such a senseless panelists..... She was just there because she's fluent in English... That's all..... And I support the notion made by Mr Shridhar that our temples should be out of government control. Jay Shri Ram ⛳
Only solution and time is now.
Ms. Nandy,
Appreciate the candour.
Clearly stated what she was asked to speak about? What are some legal implications of these issues? what are her personal opinions on them and government interventions...
It is time to do justice to major revenue resources of large hindu temples
Everybody is talking about freeing temples from the govt., But you will free them and give them to whom?? The old social structures have been demolished and most of the families that used to take care of these temples have migrated to other areas, cities. The problem is finding right people to give the temples to.
That is also not the issue, slowly the Brahmavad will start taking care of these temples again and then will stop beef eating Hindus and will promote untouchability.
@@vinsin328 A beef eater is not Hindu. and must not be allowed inside the temples. especially other religions and faiths. its funny that you don't have problem with other religions calling the people who don't follow their rules a kafir, a heathen or a gentile but you have problem with the homegrown one. kya liberal bhai saab wah.
@@vinsin328 yeah we know this problem. But thats why we are talking about creating a individual body a board either a national or state level board that controls hindu temples of that particular state like Shiromani gurudwara commitee that controls all gurudwaras . Because every temple has its own set of culture and practice which belongs to that particular area or state so state level bodies should be formed.
But the govt must ensure that caste discrimination doesn't happen.
I will even go to an extent to say that the big temples like tirupati, jagannath puri , rameswaram, ayodhya, dwarkadish, siddhivinayak, kamakhya should have there state level gurukuls
The gurukuls should give education on math , science along with all vedas , upanishads , Purana, parampara, shashtra, niti and customs related to that temple.
Anyone can join that. Whoever passes the exams on vedas and all will have the upanayan sanskar and will be officially made a Brahmin.
The Brahmins with very good score and talent will be taken in by big temples while the remaining will be given responsibility of different smaller and local big temples.
The big temples must pay the small temples to run them .
This will also be a step to bring back the old system where caste is not hereditary but fluid anyone with proper caliber and morality can become Brahmin.
Atleast temple in tirupathi is far clean when compared with tamil nadu temples
The demand for freeing temple from government should be done .if it's under government it will go into waft board
Nope, non-Brahmins should be allowed in the temples also.
What a waste of time to call that clueless lawyer. Her disdain for equal rights for hindu places of worship is also staggering. Absolutely disgraceful
The lawyer don’t have an answer to the question of temples controlled by government.
Don’t you have a better person to debate?
It's better to hand over the control of temples to religious bodies. It won't put an end to corruption or mismanagement. Where there's money, there will be crooks trying to grab it. At least, the government can escape the blame.
Problem is these temples again will come under some Brahmavadi who will stop banning non-Brahmavadi.
Yes the caption head that is free from govt and politics regarding the management of any temple as we see thirupathi laddu issue
Namaste,
The news has shaken Sanatanis globally.
Only Hindus understand the sensitivity and the gravity of commotion which is on the verge. How can non Hindus decide and alter on spiritual practices?
We demand " Sanatana Board" and release from the God damned Endowment Commission that sucks Hindus of their contributions and is a stalemate in this gruesome endeavour.
🚩Jai Shree Ram 🚩
Yes, sanatan dharm's mandirs must be free from the control of government
The people deserve freedom to manage as true devotees
Temples should not in control of govt also there should be private military service to protect temples across the world
The Temples must be seperated from government control. The Home Minister and Pm promised that steps will be taken to protect the Temples from political and government control during Shabarimala agitation. But the government has done nothing in this direction.
Because the Brahmins want the temples and ban on non-Brahmins. Are you a Brahmavadi?
❤great decision
I urge CM & Dy.C.M of AP must release Temples from Govt of AP as a first examplary state in India. Would Mr.Naidu and Mr.Pawan make this changes into Hindu Temples in Andhra Pradesh now because they are in power??? If they don't do it, they are making false allegations and they remain as anti-hindus and anti-indian.
Government is involved as there is too much money.
Thank you for taking up this Topic sir
Free Temple from government control... country economy depend on temple funds
Yes Sir, Temple’s control should be given back to Hindus. But only “Harijan” or “Dalit” Hindus. Will Dushyant agree to it?
I lsecond Mr.Pawan Kalyan’s proposal. Why are dubious people in charge of running such important religious places ? It’s shocking!
We want our temple 💪💪😊
Those are temples of Hindus not your personal property.
Why temple alone, take governance itself away from the govt.
TDP along with the BJP is trying to ignite religious tensions that never existed before in AP. YSRCP is asking for an CBI enquiry, what is stopping them to do that??
Tamil hindus yet will only vote for DMK. Loyalists
Yes because they do not want to support Brahmavad.
Please Gaurav - Ensure the panelists invited are knowledgeable. The advocate was seen not addressing the problem but disappointing to say the least.
Government should introduce a policy on all the temples and form trustees for every temple to ensure proceedings and other management requirements meets its due diligence. This way, Government will able to monitor on the trustees appointed. Trustees should be well versed in Temple management. Government should facilitate the needs of a temple and ensure they are well received by the trustees.
Brahmavadi will never agree. They have not agreed on that from last 1800 yrs why do you think they will now.
Ask Kalyan ji to stop all VIP visits, ask everyone to come in the normal queues..
The lady is such a coward...
Why can't the temple have its own Cows.
The UPA and its aides have sticked on to one narration and that is to speak about fssai and keep it as neutral as possible and show that sananthana dharma is just fine and hindus who are overreacting are extremists . 👍 Nice
EDUCATE PEOPLE ABOUT THEIR RIGHTS
The daily wage earners in Karnataka and Andhra are targeted and getting converted in large scale. Our maid in Karnataka got converted two years back and now she doesn’t touch prasadam or follow the tradition that she has been following for ages! Also her entire family and neighborhood got converted..
This lady be like
Hinduism..i don't care about your emotions 😅😅
And why should she?
Hinduism , ye kya he ? 😂
See Thiruvanna malai temple
I personally fitnesses the poor management and temple is in very bad shape today when compared to twenty years ago
Why
Why temple fund is not utilised for temple management ?
Yes.. When even Prasad they cannot monitor what is the use of TTD and members... Scrap it and hand over to those who are directly maintaining the sanctity of the temple..
Mam what is your take... I don't know I have to see.....😅
Governments shouldn't involve temples matters.. soon temples funds go under political parties
Government not handling any funds or activities there. It was handled by Devastanam board. That board only decide, what to do over there. That commitee only decides, what the temple needs.
Dushyanth Shridharji... You hit the nail on its head.
Big Temples are constructed by Kingdom.
Some small Temples are by Induviduals.
So Temples can be controled by Government Not by Archagas (Emplloyes).
The lady is clearly beating around the bush. She is nota sanatani
PM Modiji and Team owe it to the Hindu Community for their opportunity to represent the Hindus and should implement laws which are equal for all
Dushyant is on the point.
Hats off dushyant ji
She didn't know about temple in Tamil Nadu but spoke of other temples
Such persons must not called to speak on National TV
This woman is a supreme court lawyer? Really ? She talks like a primary school student.
Dushyant Sridhar is very clear in his explanation.
Also Dushyant makes a good point that Pawan Kalyan's Hindu Rakshana Board may be a temporaty band aid solution
But the problem of temples being under state control wont go away until Hindus are allowed to managed their temples, just as muslims are allowed to managed mosques and
Christians allowed to manage churches. Why should Christians be allowed on Thiurmala Thirupathi board. Will Hindus be allowed on any church board?
So hindus if YSR and YSS takes this matter to CJI and SC we can expect more or less this type of view and another disappoinment ... This is just trailer...