Explained: Why farmers don’t trust Modi government’s word on farm laws
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Why are #farmers worried about #MSP, or minimum support price, not being written into the new farm laws when it never had legal backing? Aren’t middlemen exploiting farmers? And if they are removed through the new laws, as the Narendra #Modigovernment claims they will be, is that not good? Aren’t private companies in a better position to offer a higher price for a farmer’s produce than APMCs? Basically, why are the protesting farmers angry? After all, isn’t the government only trying to help them?
These are all seemingly simple questions with complicated answers. After spending two weeks speaking to the protesting farmers at the Singhu border, the focal point of the ongoing protests, Nidhi Suresh attempts to understand the anger, emotions and nuances driving the demands of the farmers.
Watch.
You can find a text piece on the same on our website: www.newslaundr...
--
Sign up for our all-new media newsletter: bit.ly/StopPre...
Support independent media and subscribe to Newslaundry: bit.ly/paytokee...
To watch this and many more videos, click on www.newslaundry...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
She explained it really well. She would be a very good teacher. I would like to see more of her in coming videos.
M - Murderer
O - Of
D - Democracy
I - India
Hell yeah..Listening her felt like someone hypnotized me.
@@Sachin-pt1op did you go into trance?
@@manujohn99 big time 😅
What I could understand from your presentation is that the fear of farmers from Punjab and Haryana are based on imaginary assumptions which are yet to realize. May be they should try the new bill for 3 to 4 years and if the bill is turning against then there is always an option to vote out the Govt. Remember the Govts are not forever.
The bill has support from majority of the farmers from other parts of the country. This is a fact. Also, the subsidies enjoyed by Punjab and Haryana actually are robbing the subsidies of farmers from other region. This must stop. In the garb of MSP the farmers of these two states dumps their substandard produce to Mandis. Basmati rice they never sell in Mandis. They are already selling high cost rice like basmati directly to corporates. The rice and wheat that we get from PDS (ration shop) are actually are the grains that Govt is forced to buy even though the supply is more than demand. Try eating the rice and wheat from ration shop then you will know what I am talking about. Currently since there is guaranteed MSP they produce quantity but not quality and dump those to Mandis. I want to support genuine farmer but surely would not support who are just behind money and does not care anything about quality. Currently this is the case of farmers from Punjab and Haryana.
No use with logic with these illiterate jurnos.
You've raised some pertinent questions:
- How did you arrive at the 2.5% commission being given to the middlemen? On the ground facts says that it is somewhere between 6-8%
- At what interest rate are the middlemen paying money to the farmers?
- Farmers unable to pay middlemen's money, isn't that the reason for farmer's suicides?
- If it only the farmers who are protesting, why are they not coming to a negotiation with the govt?
- Why did the protestors ignored SC commission?
- And, most importantly, if this is only farmer's protest, what's the role of "Khalistanis" in this?
Bro shhhhh, how else will dalal youtube channels like news laundry will make money from george soros donations?
Seriously love the tone of these reporters. Don't ever want to watch the TV news crap again.
Yep
Modi Shah and BJP members tone and language are very repulsive
@@noanarchy Punjaab "Farmers" are producing something that's already in excess, wheat and paddy, and want a decent price from it too, at taxpayers expense.
No, not sustainable in long term, discouraging to innovative and industrious farmers and Bad economics, Despite all of newslaundry's emotional appeal and fallacies.
Sometimes I do watch arnab, just to make the balance.
@@msgstoas give them msp on other crops,then talk
She is great! Confident and explained the concept with an ease! Isko meghnad ke saath me rakho, we want her to be in more episodes.
Really dmb analysis! She's merely parroting the fake narrative that'll ultimately hurt the farmers:
- The suggestion in the farm bill to have contract disputes resolved by a DM in 30 DAYS in actually in farmers' favor. Farmers insisting on court option is really dmb as it favors the corporates. Corporates can afford lawyers and wait out 1-2 years for the courts to decide on the matter, but the poor farmer will go belly up in that time (nor can he afford top class lawyers)! Arbitration/Adjudication by the DM heavily favors the farmers
- Middlemen providing 'service' is so st00pid! They're actually eulogizing the loan sharks?
- Mandis won't collapse, definitely not in Punjab. In Punjab, corporate buyers will NEVER buy rice & wheat from the farmers in private sales or in mandi middlemen. The obscenely excess amount of unwanted rice and wheat that Punjab farmers produce has no market value (Center buys them at exorbitant prices to literally throw it away). Center will continue to perform the immoral exercise of wealth transfer from rest-of-India to Punjab (and let them have 3x -5x national avg incomes). Net-net the Farm bills don't change anything for Punjab farmers, but they're holding the upliftment of 99% non-Punjab farmers as hostage in return for ransom (free diesel, no-ban on stubble burning, release of Khalistanis & jihadis etc etc)
@@omnicurious2949 so smartass dm cant be bribed by rich corporates??
@@omnicurious2949 when you say excess amount you mean there is no 'profit' to be made in wheat and rice. Trust me there are people who need that wheat and rice. The government does not distribute it efficiently which is why there is still hunger in the country. Obviously private players would consider that 'excess' capacity that can be used to grow something that they can sell for a profit.
@@jammRJ Firstly, why does every communist, Islamist & khalistani think 'private corporates' are something that belong to a different planet who will now descend on Earth bcos of the Farm bill? They already function in India...only by buying thru the Middlemen (the legal way allowed).
Secondly, there really isn't 'hunger'. Rice and Wheat is available across India for Rs 1 to Rs 2 a kilo.
Thirdly, 'private players' cannot decide what the farmer will grow. Farmers will grow what they think is profitable. Right now, in Punjab, growing Rice & Wheat is super easy and super profitable (free water, electricity, subsidized fertilizer.....and an assured buyer at a price that's many times higher than the market supports). Farm bill that gives an OPTION to sell outside mandis will NOT change that.
@@Adolfofficial9 If you can bribe the DM, you can't bribe a judge? Your strawman arguments as facile. Even if ALL judges are honest, upright and fair, court option is a losing proposition for farmers. Having to hire a lawyer, wait for years and not to mention run around the courts. Also, it's easy to launch an investigation on a corrupt DM than on a sitting judge! There's a reason why Farm Bill suggests arbitration by DMs...it's in farmers interest. Modi has no special love for DMs that he wanted them in the process.
She's soooo beautiful 🥰🥰😍
I watched a video of 50 min on the same topics. Im telling you that this girl explained 200% better than them only in just 10 min or so.
Khan sir ki baat kr re na?
This protest is actually becoming more and more powerful. They might actually win
Might? They are cooking rotis on boulders that were placed to block their spirits. Might? They brought soaps to wash themselves when modi orders water cannons. Modi messed with people who dont sell Zameer and their motherland. And we wont talk about why 75% of Punjabs water is being sent tp other states by nehru n india gandhi ordered to dig canals. Who would like to give main source of income n prosperity 75% every day and be labeled terrorists????
@Abhijit Pathak Your participation and support is requested. Ab bolo warna pushte goongi ho jayengi! Modi ne jaise apna ghar sambhala, na wo suhagan, na bewa! Wo uska saga na hua, desh ka saga kya hoga! Fact hai! Bolne pe bhi sharam aati hai🙏.
@Abhijit Pathak Thank you. Our 80+ old grandparents are sitting on cold streets because they told their villagers, " ek gareeb kisaan ki, ek gareeb mazdoor ki.... Fateh hogi". Koi gareeb badi gaadi aage, bade saaahib aage majdoori karke haath nahi jodega.
Jai Jawan, Jai Kisaan. Not maar jawan, not maar kisaan. Shukriya.
I think there is need to reduce trust deficit....... Government and Kisan leaders should sit and talk
They actually won when Home minister told them that this bill have lot of flaws!
Sincere request to newslaundry channel to open in other regional languages also to reach more people. Especially southern languages.
Fan fact only 14% farmer sale there product at msp. More than 80%+ farmer never know there is msp also😔
One thing i want add that even former farmer bill is not benefited because lack of implementation and middleman who selling 50% profit margin giving farmer less amount 🙄. Only bajra crops getting msp which also benefited only 14% who have an power in apmc. If everyone protesting against new law they how to protect against last bill also.
Conclusion :we have to educate our farmers regarding msp and there rights. Politician should stop fooling farmer's.
you are new🤔🤔 but great🔥
She is not new, and of course she is great! 💯
@@pratik6986 🤔kaise ?
@@adv.tanmaymalikOfficial She is working for Newslaundry since long!
@@pratik6986 shes new for us. We saw her first time.
Who's bigger middlemen than Modi himself?
Wrong, think again!
💯
You and Ambani are Indians and Modi is your PM just like for the rest of 1.3 billion Indians. Hope you get this right!
Lol lol he calls himself chowkidar so we better recognize the owner.
Oh bhaiii
Vote for us to get fuel at 20₹...!!! Why would anyone trust...???
@sanju b .chinese army entered India easily....one more thing.....when grains will not b purchased by govt, how will the govt operate the PDS (ration)....slowly ration will b distributed at reliance mart.....with no subsidy.......this will as good as gas chambers in germany
@@raupatil874 easy, right now reliance is the silent gov stake holder.
In future it will be the government.
Kisan majdoor ekta zindabad ✊🏽
@@raupatil874 no lo
@@raupatil874 arre arre jyada bol gaye bhai
@@akashsharma-yy9bb bhai.....jhuta nahi hai na.....mujhe nafrat hai jhut se.....🤣
The title should be how zamindari system helped farmers. 😂
She is beautiful ... Plus her eyes !! Damn... Upro andh bhagat v ni aa... Kudi nirri agg aa g 😂🔥🔥🔥
8:21 laws are completely constitutional... Liberandus ko aise khush na karo
While i agree with most of what has been mentioned in the video there are certain things that i would like to know further about as they were not cleared by the speaker.
1. Per my understanding The new laws do give options to private buyers and farmers to deal directly and which as mentioned correctly in the video may cause the buyers to dictate terms in certain aspects however the Concept of APMC is not being eradicated and it is a parallel system that is being created to provide more options. The farmers are still at the helm and are the ones who decide which route they wish to choose. Please correct me if i am wrong!
2. Time 4:45 .. as per my understanding the prices, quantity and quality of the product in contract between the farmer and the buyer is pre-determined as per the law. Hence supply and demand doesn’t effect it. As pointed out correctly the surplus produce may not be accepted by the buyer at the same rate however that is where the APMC platform comes into picture again where the MSP is still applicable. Please correct me if I misunderstood the law.
3. I do agree that there will be an increased intervention by private players in the farm produce sector however at every point the farmer is the decision making authority wether they wanna deal at APMC mandis or Direct to buyer and wether they wanna get into a finite contract with a private buyer or they wish to sell their produce as they have been doing all this while.
4. As per my understanding The point about small ticket loans provided by APMC is not as simple a concept as put forward in the video. It exists in various industries and is a concept that is absolutely based upon day to day dealings and trust developed among various merchants over a span of time in a community. This concept is what was termed as “Sahukars” in the olden days and was a widely accepted practice prior to development of banking system. Yes it may provide a quick resolve most days but was also a reason of exploitation most often than not. Please let me know if i have misunderstood this in anyway.
5. The third law about amendment in the essential commodity law was never referred to.
While i have utmost respect for everyone’s perspective and also understand completely the fear that Farmers have of being absolutely buldozed by private sector if things do not work the way govt has anticipated. As a response they do not wish to accept these changes and its their right not to.. however what i do not understand is oversimplification and having a myopic view.
Specially addressing the mentioned job loss point in the video - Jobs were lost when things started getting computerized but then new jobs were created due to the same fact aswell.
With all due respect to everyone the comment is only for the video.Please ignore any spelling or grammatical errors just penned my thought.
Well put
I am women.. but this women is beautiful and eloquent.. would love to see this reporter a lot more on NL..
We will undoubtedly
Women supporting other women has always been encouraged :)
@@advocatevarunrathi2831 wrong choice of word. Please be respectful, somebody is out to work.
Why do you use 'but'..?
ua-cam.com/video/i09fsYkSXfk/v-deo.html
Notebandi,Gst were also for the betterment of Indians. BUT ......
But bhakts couldn't be able to see it that's the problem
Ek tym aayega jab poora India is modi par belive nahi karega.
Only growth seen in country now is modies beard 🧔🏼
you missed a couple of things which have grown.
amit shah's tummy and his son's wealth and influence.
lawlessness and goonda raj has grown tremendously.
his so called bania bhai's wealth has grown manifolds.
chaatukaar patrakaar and kalaakaar , president and governors has seen a fair growth.
inflation and unemployment and negative GDP has seen roof shattering growth.
India's name and fame has become a laughing stock in the world we have seen growth in that.
I can go on and on and i believe public knows all of these and much more than this, i did this just to draw your attention.
LOL killed it
@@1101smartkooldude also the fear of jihadis wanting to cause terrorism in india has come down as shah has managed to keep the jihadis and anti india Islamic forces in a tight leash.
He looks funny..
Population
People forgot how this bill was passed.
@Arjun Kumar Still doesn't help that argument on the way it was passed.
Also use the same video pointer and read up more on the why and hows, it is so biased its irritating.
@Arjun Kumar Exactly the same BJP was opposing this bill, why did they pass it then?
If they hated then Bill, why now?
If you say they changed the Bill, this invalidates your point saying Congress wanted to pass this bill.
@Arjun Kumar It passed legally in the most illegal/unruly manner.
@Arjun Kumar Thats cheating! You can't "coin, each his own" reply to my reform reply lol
@Arjun Kumar Exactly, that's the fucked up thing about politics lol
Yr eh kudi di akhan kinni sohni aa❤️😜
lol Gal v sohni kardi aa , To the point ;)
@@janab009 exactly bro👍🏻
😂😂 mai v akha hi dekhda reh gea... 😂😂😝 Topic ta phlaa hi punjabia nu ptaa!!!
😂😂😂 Aho bai mai v ohi soch rha c😂😂
@@dipinsharma25 Eh gall apne ch hi rahe, bahar na jaan deyo. 🤫
1. In some places there was no mandis are there, please inform that. this is called a biased opinion.
2. Kerala, Bihar doesn't have mandis(APMC).
3. who started aarhits? why to pay when u have alternative.
4. In AP/Karnataka, there is no restrictions to sell outside.
5. Arthi is like a pawn broker. so why in case u have banks.. this is fallucy.
6. Dispute resolution> what are u talking, many
7. Who Is they ? ITS proxy war..its not farmer CONG agents
Farmers are happy with the old system. Government is trying to do the same like what they did in telecom.
Just like demonetisation and gst, this law will definitely be a historical law😆
Listen about the stalin and hen ...story
Yah, historical blunder
& after that bhakts be like ohh it's ok it happens move on..Modi modi !!
Gst?
and a failure too
Please CORRECT yourself the tax 8.5% per quintal is paid by purchaser not by seller(farmers). I know this cause currently I m working as Punjab govt. employee who purchase and stock Paddy nd Wheat AND I m a FARMER TOO. The farmers get full 1888 per quintal(Paddy(rice)) in the A.P.M.C. mandi's in zPunjab & Haryana nd some parts of western U.P. nd some eastern border areas(with Punjab & Haryana) of Rajasthan. As u r a very responsible news media company so please check facts correctly before have any say on it..Thank you..
Nidhi, you should host more videos. Crisp delivery backed by good ground research, and unlike a lot of the other NL staff (whom I like regardless) you are careful not to throw in gratuitous Hindi, which I appreciate as another South Indian. Kudos
Yes, why only Punjabi farmers have a problem with the laws and NOT THE OTHER FARMERS ALL OVER THE INDIA?? Are only Punjabi's a farmers in India? Why no one stressing on how the created a chaos and beat police. Why no one stressing upon the fact that the other farmers of India protested against these punjabi farmers and Said that if the other farmers of India have no problem with this then why there is a problem with only these?? This is too much of partiality. Congress purposely doing these bad games.
But aren't private companies already free to directly buy form farmers, why do we need a new law for that? can anybody explain.
Agriculture is a state subject. Some states have done away with Mandi system, and with mixed results. Bihar, for one, is very good example of agrarian state that suffers from lack of MSP, while Kerela has decent farm income even in private system, but I am not sure about how farming is done in Kerela. Anyways, punjab, haryana and rest of Kisans identify themselves more with Bihar's Kisan instead of Kerela's.
Central govt. decided to bulldoze a Central farm law for EVERY state, using certain questionable clauses. In spirit, that is 100% unconstitutional, as agriculture is state subject, but now it's for courts to decide
There is no ban to sell to private parties, due to MSP they sell to Marketing societies.
@@kirathekillernote2173 correct,they hijack the rights of state, every state has differant land pattern and farm produces,so central govt should leave to state governments.
@@kirathekillernote2173 yes i understand what you are saying but i am asking you or the public one question which law this government has passed in the last 6 years 7 months has been constitutional and through proper parliamentary process?
3/ 4 southern states like tamil nadu, andhra, telengana, kerala have a good MSP and mandi system with both government and private dealers at work and all the stake holders are happy because the private dealers are not big corporate sharks but once those sharks enter this territory then they will eat both mandi's and private dealers and that is the biggest concern. in the earlier version it was a win win situation to all the stake holders where producers are happy because they get their value for their efforts, middlemen make a few bucks for their efforts and everyone in that chain takes their share and consumer is happy because no one in the chain can manipulate the quantity or price but when these huge sharks enter their prime motive is to kill competition of all sorts, shapes and sizes and make it their monopoly and then the producers are at the mercy of those guys and there is no such law holding them answerable or binding them to pay certain price and the officers and politicians will wag their tails as they are already doing in front of these big sharks and that is the point to worry.
@@kirathekillernote2173 Punjaab "Farmers" are producing something that's already in excess, wheat and paddy, and want a decent price from it too, at taxpayers expense.
No, not sustainable in long term, discouraging to innovative and industrious farmers and Bad economics, Despite all of newslaundry's emotional appeal and fallacies.
Has the government banned Mandi system? No. Then why can't the protesting farmers continue the old system. Let both prevail.
Absolutely love the way she spoke and explained. Please do more of these 🙏❤️
She will..They read comments. She will do more videos.
Haha that's the problem with u librandus...talks of farmers laws..but mentions problem about middle men. 🤦
If chaiwala can become a PM twice of a country then farmers know farming than anyone else.
Farmers in general and Punjaab "Farmers" in particular are producing something that's already in excess, wheat and paddy, and want a decent price from it too, at taxpayers expense.
No, not sustainable in long term, discouraging to innovative and industrious farmers and Bad economics, Despite all of newslaundry's emotional appeal and fallacies.
@@msgstoas there are 23 crops have msp but in Mandis only two crops who have assured with msp that wheat and paddy. It is not a fault of farmers ,it is fault of policy makers who do not make this policy about thinking with diversification
@@anmoldagur200 these laws, my friend, are policy correction ...
@@anmoldagur200 free market, my friend, are the best way to supply to demands and diversification
@@msgstoas but there are many loopholes in farm bills now they will remove middle men from the context so there is no individual to individual relation there is individual to corporation relation when there is dispute between individual and corporation. Individual doesn't have right this dispute proceed civil court and also market rate of paddy 800rs/quintal but in apmc mandi it about 1900rs/quintal there is a loss of farmers in that case.
Farmers in the Other Parts of India don't have a single problem and why do these punjab farmers have a problem? Congress the opposition government is creating chaos in India against BJP and Narendra Modi. And the Farmers of the Rest of the India came to protest against these farmers protesting for no reason. Making innocent faces won't make you great and develop stympathy for these fake farmers in no smart person's heart. These are Khalistani people and kisan andolan is just a name but they are the Khalistani supporters. These people protested with the Khalistani flag in USA also at the same time and they said it was all linked and planned.
And why would any farmer stay antil their need in their farms? Why will they remain wasting their time in protests during their Sowing and Harvesting season. No farmers who would actually be suffering would wait for so long for any purpose during their Sowing and Harvesting season. Starting from 9th August and continued for 7 months and 2 days. Can any farmer stay for so long. No they can't. Then who are these? They are the fake farmers or Not an Indian. Because no Indian would create Chaos on the Republic Day of his/her country India!
"Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" is a slogan famous in India. Now will any True Indian and a True Kisan (farmer) create a chaos on the Red Fort in India that too on an important day for India which is it's Republic Day. These fake farmers on that day beated the police, destroyed the government things and harmed at the Red Fort. Why is this not highlighted. Why is it not highlighted that how come only Farmers from Punjab have issues with the new law introduced?????
This is all dirty plans of Congress.
This is JOURNALISM. Will surely subscribe to Newslaundry after getting my first job
Go look "string" youtube channel with an open mind. Thats called true investigative journalism. This is child's play compared to that.
@@divyanshukumar2243 mein right wing ka gobar walaa propaganda follow nehi karta. Investigative journalism k naam pe jo gobar paros raahe hein wo tumhi ko mubarak
@@divyanshukumar2243 I tried some videos but it's just conspiracy videos
Who will pay for surplus crop that you mentioned ? The common man of India through various system of taxes ? People pay taxes for development of the country , not to see part of their hard earned money to rot in FCI warehouses. Buffer stock of Rice / Wheat , is already more than double now . Second point , as you rightly mentioned , who will finance the small and marginal farmers for their crops ? Here , the suggestion is , let the Govt. make dedicated NBFCs for farm loans with financial incentives to make them not only Viable but lucrative to lend. Presently , these small farmers are funded by large farmers and middleman , instantly , but at much higher rate of interest than the market , and if crops fail , these large farmers are no better than " Shylock ". The small farmer commits suicide . Not a single Farm Leader and/or Politician has mentioned about thousands committing Suicide every year from these two and a half States . Please don't raise there are Suicide in other states as well. Let us take one issue at a time. Third point , Govt. need to device concrete plans for small farmers , including a financial package to switch over to other crops , from paddy and wheat , which is surplus. Or improve the technology (PVT. Sector required here ) , produce at a competitive rate and Export the surplus.The fourth point , consumer purchase potato at Rs. 30 per kg. The actual farmer who uses his arms to produce gets only Rs 3 per kg . The whole Idea of reform , in a nutshell is , let the farmer get Rs. 6 per kg and the consumer at Rs 20 per kg. Let the gap reduce. If your intentions are not aligned with any political Party , then please make a video ,basis, whatever explained.------- Common Man
Like bsnl ke samne jio
And we all know what happened to bsnl 🤔
Farming is a private Business right before independence. Don't compare that with BSNL . Govt doesn't own any Farm land .
@@ranjitramkumar2072 here, bsnl is APMC mandi and jio is private mandi... It's just a comparison
@@priyanshupriyam5996 Fine if Farmers, Middleman & Traders want to do Business in Mandi they can do so. Boycott private companies. Govt has not closed Mandi's nor have they said they will stop MSP support in Mandi.
@@ranjitramkumar2072hav u opted BSNL when jio was giving its free services? Justasking🙏
@@NeerajChaudharyHR No I have not taken Jio , But if I get great offers in Future I will take it. It's upto the consumer what they want. My point is simple Farming is a private entity & not a Govt company ,let the Farmer decide what's best for him.
According to you APMC is a flawless system . if so , why every day 30 farmers are killing themselves? why lakhs of farmers suicide due to debt ?
1.the whole assumption of your video is that the mandi system is flawless, non corrupt and an angel to our farmers.
2. you spoke about MSP . In the Mandi system only 6% of the farmers were benefited with MSP or only 6% of them sold their crops at MSP price or above. (stastics from Sharada committee
3. as you said the farmers must keep good relations with the arthiya, he will lend him money with trust. you are indirectly saying that the farmers are at the mercy of the artiyas.. SO they must have a setting or Jugaad to secure their rights with the arthiya ..
4. why should the farmers hands be tied to sell their crops in the mandi and why do they have no freedom to sell it wherever they want in your beloved APMC ? yu and your "comrades" know why ..
5. why did you not mention about the (not required) trasaction agents and commision agents who are middlemen to traders and not even retailers. why do you need an agent to take your goods to a distributer ? simply to raise the price of the goods for customers ? and reduce the price for the farmer. ?
6. can you and I become a trader in the mandi system ? traders are usually politicans or politicans contacts ..
7. you hardly mentioned about the state govt involvement. many state govt whose income is low (especially underdeveloped) earn from mandi taxes.. in this case punjab mandi system taxes is one of the highest among all states.
8. LAST STRONG POINT : as you mentioned the mandi system and farm bills passed are going to run paralelly, why are those so called "farmers" whining and crying and afraid that the mandi system will stop . if farmers love Mandi system , they will only sell through mandi system right ? and mandi system shall prevail. the people "so called farmers" are afraid that their syndicate of corrupt practices will stop in the mandi system..
Finally a good analysis and which highlights the actual issues. A few questions
1. Considering the current sample is from a single state, how does other farmers feel about the laws
2. Do other state farmers have an issue of middleman.
3. Where the mandis are few in between, do these laws help those farmers
So, can you please also explain why mostly farmers from Punjab are only protesting against the laws? Why don't you highlight the real reason behind such conjectures of fear? Why don't you highlight what the condition of the farmers were during the time of the Congress government? And also please tell me the who the farmers you actually spoke to.
Brilliantly explained. I've followed newslaundry for some time now...and I am compelled to comment and appreciate the content. Keep rocking :)
Yaar simple si baat hai the farmers should demand their respective State governments to do away with taxes levied on APMC transactions... This will put APMC on a fair play ground 🙏
I find the anchor too beautiful ❤️
Man, that sounds so creepy.
Me too 😅
Me 3
Yes it does
Me 4
A couple of hours ago PM Modi announced that the farm laws will be scrapped. So i took up an interest to study the topic. You said that the middlemen ("from whom the government is desperately trying to protect the farmers from") don't exploit the farmers and they are usually good people. How can u speak on the behalf of all middlemen? i mean you don't know all of them personally right. Secondly if they are lending money on a personal basis what difference does it make whom the middlemen are working for? anyways they are lending the personal money right. I am not criticizing what you said its just an observation. Thank you for the video
Every one in this nation is protesting be it doctors , nurses , teachers , students , farmers etc etc.... god bless this nation
True bhi sabka passa ramdev, ambani, BJP kha gai ha
Hi...I was knowing what u said earlier but then also I watched this entire video just to see you speaking. The way u speak and present yourself and if u continue to do the same, I ll fall in love with you. I didn't hear what ever you said but I was only looking at you and admiring your beauty. And otherwise thank you for the work you are doing and God Bless. Can u give me ur number please. Please..........Hye oye Kini Soni Kudi eh tu....
It requires entirely new policy’s. I think govt is in right direction
I'm from a farmer family based in Gujarat.... I was lucky I got a chance to study in Canada and also explore other countries around the world.... Farmers in western countries are making millions and they work through a system that Indian government want's to implement.
There can be flaws in the current bill that the government has passed but I see this as a very necessary and effective step Indian government has taken and in the long run will help farmers to earn way more money then they are earning right now...
Farmers who are protesting against this laws are not seeing the benefits they will be getting in the long run.... It looks like they want to be dependent on the middle men and govt. subsidies but the current bill allows them to free themselves and grow more....
Also many people are commenting on how this bill will take away there right to go to court in case of dispute but the truth is this bill provides a proper legal framework that is being created to protect the farmers of India and not the big private companies....
Everyone who thinks that this bill is for the benefit for Big Private Corporations are wrong. Yes, Big Corporation will be benefited from this bill but farmers are the one who will be availing the actual benefit from this bill..
*Farmers had pizza at protest site*
Media: How can farmers have pizza. Who is funding them?
*Farmers going on a fast for a day*
Media: Anushka spotted at hospital.
Thaali ke baigan hain godi media wale
Fasting just for one day? Just enough to burn off all the cheesy pizza?
The government would have anyway passed the laws bcoz they have a clear majority. Laws are Constitutional and you can't question that. You seem more concerned about the people of APMCs than farmers. Yes some ammendments are necessary as you said about the settlement of disputes but you can't reject the laws by putting your narrative 🙄.
Laws will favour the farmers only if you let them come out of traditional ways of growing and selling crops🙃
Private bigger companies will be Jio for the formers. They know very well. This government has promoted Amabni's Jio and now Jio has monooply and can raise prices in telecome as they wish. This is 100% Adani and Amabni government. Government is there for poor till Elections, Once elections over it becomes only for industrialists specially for Adani and Amabani.
But because of JIO we are getting telecom for cheap prices in India 🧐
@@shubhamsaukarya7374 So you want Data cheaper and want our farmer get killed at the hands of Adani and Amabni. Think rational. Also still lot of people in this country are dependent on agriculture.
I want to get quality food for cheaper prices, anyways the tax which I am paying only are given as MSP to the farmers so I have right to demand for cheaper prices
@@vinodkewat1759 sir, don’t glorify agriculture, every profession even scavenging is equally beautiful
@@shubhamsaukarya7374 I know that every profession is profession. Even I'm in IT and earning handsome salary, But you can not turn blind eye from the truth. Everybody know how this goverenment is scewing every one. You may not be aware in previous lockdown government increased 13 Rs. as taxed as people were busy in lockdown and pandemic.
1. First roads are not made by mandis but the government.
2. The mandi middlemen have always formed their gangs and always buy products at MSP or sometimes at less than MSP price saying consumables will go bad soon. That is why farmers dont get their invested money and commit suicide.
3. Contract farming is about crops, when buying party whether individual or company invests on crop their will be an agreement one season prior on how much land will be required, seeds used in an agreement with more favourable conditions to farmers.
4. If this new laws are implemented then mandi will get competition so in order for mandi to run the traders, middlemen and agents have to give farmers better price.
5. It is not compulsory that every farmer will sell his product to private companies, their will be many who will come to mandi, so agents will have to provide a better price so that mandi's run. That way farmers will not get short end of stick which they have been getting till now.
6. Don't look at her face and voice, please learn what the 3 agricultural laws are.
"चौकीदार चोर ही नहीं वह महाचोर है।
Punjaab "Farmers" are producing something that's already in excess, wheat and paddy, and want a decent price from it too, at taxpayers expense.
No, not sustainable in long term, discouraging to innovative and industrious farmers and Bad economics, Despite all of newslaundry's emotional appeal and fallacies.
Let the government buy products of farmer and sell it to private players and earn profit..... Why government do this...
@@ਘੋੜੇ-ਵਾਲਾ-ਪਟਵਾਰੀ It will only lead to more corruption and no economic progress. its better and more profitable for farmers if they directly sale their produce to private players.
If government in not able to control corruption,.... For what government is required
Than make everything private,. Why they are keeping there security with NSG AND OTHERS, THEY SHOULD HIRE PRIVATE FOR THESE
Very well explained!!..thumbs up
Support kisan
support fight for justice
Thanks for sharing the details. In the solution, you mentioned as Govt has assured getting MSP.
we are border districts ok karanrata due to mandi system. we cant sell our group to another state where the price is much higher.
another problem is if all farmers start growing only one crop that has the highest MSP then when will happen to FCI. because most mos the farmer is going single corp then water consumption is more.
Most of the mandi under control of local politician we are getting a better price.:( I feel current laws new law is better than existing law
She is beautiful and explained very well. Thank You❤️
Cuteness overloaded 😍10:14
What's your insta?
Whatever happens, still BJP and Modi will win. We have started to resemble Russia and China.
@Abhijit Pathak yes you are right, we have seen this in the past few years and it is bound to happen when any kind of suppression, oppression and arrogance exceeds a certain limit where the dam of patience and tolerance breaks and there is a flood of revolution which can derail and uproot any so called strong government and history has shown us that as well that too in the most recent past.
@@1101smartkooldude Punjaab "Farmers" are producing something that's already in excess, wheat and paddy, and want a decent price from it too, at taxpayers expense.
No, not sustainable in long term, discouraging to innovative and industrious farmers and Bad economics, Despite all of newslaundry's emotional appeal and fallacies.
@@msgstoas ye chodu log carl marx ko padhke hamesa govt ko topple ki baat karte rehte hain. Jawani ki garmi hai aur kuch nahi... inke paas big picture ko analyze karna aur foresight skills nahi hai. Kuch bhi hogaya bas govt girado aur anarchy le aao
@@msgstoas first of all don't even talk about at taxpayers expense ok that is a fallacy created by politicians to alienate a certain section of the population. First all the salaries and perks of this neta's are way too exhorbitant and a huge burden on tax payers money they would not cut on that and they would not even talk about it and they want to enjoy their lives and lifestyles at taxpayers expenses. second thing please study and research on agricultural economy then you will understand why there is so much poverty and suicides among farmers and most importantly you say they are already producing in excess then what is the duty of the government? to see what is in shortage and to educate , encourage and train the farmers through co-perative movements or camps to produce those stuff so that we don't need to import those stuff saving lots of forex and also suplementing the farmers income and also export the excessive stuff to earn forex and the government is not doing that and not even investing in infrastructure not working constructively for the development, I am not sure why you are blaming newslaundry or some other instead of understanding the hidden agenda and motive of this government. I would request you to study economics and specially agro economics of world and india in particular to understand the underlying problems. and last but not the least in the last 6 and half years the government has tried to destroy the constitution and all the institutions and each and every law passed without much parliamentary process and procedures followed and always say it is in the interest of the nation and the public but on the contrary it is the other way around and people have understood that now it took them 6.5 years of bearing the burden of the false and rosy looking promises which were never fulfilled. Whom you are trying to defend bro? if you get hit below your belt then only you will understand i guess because it is human nature until and unless they get affected they do not speak. Anyway sorry for boring you with this long write up. If i make you understand all what i said then i will think my time and energy was well spent. otherwise it is still ok because i tried to do some good thing and i can feel satisfied that i did my part as a human being and as a responsible citizen of india.
@@1101smartkooldude emotions ridden passage written / pasted by you, full of fallacies
Anyway my first comment was based economic principle
My second argument is based on personal freedom
The govt or the legislature can't force me to sell my produce to any particular person or organisation (mandi in this case), and I must be free to sell my produce to anyone company or individual at my will ...
I am so surprised that you are talking about lending money by these middlemen(artis??) on personal basis. There is no legal framework to support the farmers and In fact you could task corporations to support a minimum viable price and not extort the farmers. You are speaking one sided . Though I understand market pressure will come in to force and drive prices based on demand and supply, but this does not mean MSP and Mandi are viable options. Imagine this kind of price control exist in other commodities. It does not support the economics or farmers. The developed nations don’t have this system and done away with it and Indian farmers receive a lot of perks. Those having vested interest support it out of greed. Hope the farmers understand the long term benefits. Concerns can be addressed when corporations invest in the sector and contracts could be mutually inclusive.
Nidhi Suresh's work is astonishingly awesome, but I'm a Manisha Pande Man.
what does that even mean?
@@himanshumishra6253 I guess n I hope he wanted to say fan.
@@himanshumishra6253 11 other people got what I said. No sweat.
@@Sachin-pt1op you guessed and hoped right. But that's too much work for a random comment.
@@Solonyx he was confused so I just helped. Peace.
Just my opinion(may not be a popular one), lets us assume that even these laws are repealed, it is not going to solve the fundamental problem of over dependence on grain production and less diversification in agriculture. Moreover MSP is not implemented uniformly across India and too much reliance on MSP may discourage farmers from cultivating alternate crops. Dependence on MSP and excessive grain production is not good for India in the long term.
Explained , How GIO came in Indian market... from free calls ,free data and now you know what happened to GIO customer.....this is the same monopoly of farmer bill.
@Heartthrob Goswamy heartthrob matlab?
But Jio bills are lot more cheaper than what bsnl used to charge for crappy services and thier data less packs.
To help you with gain knowledge :- India has one of the most cheap data available in world... i.e rupees 200 per month..
India has the world's lowest data rates....you should thank someone for that.....
@@blissfullife5528 😂😂😂😂 i am using bsnl i paid rs 400 for three months unlimited calling and 5gb data per day ans its fast here✌✌✌ win win
Great explanation. But just one suggestion, when you are metioning the People in a prominent position, you should be adding their designation with their name. Doing this "Modi, Modi" makes you look like a biased one.
Fun thing is that only 6% of farmers benfits from MSP - These are recent stats
And that is the thing that needs correction. There are two few APMCs
This protest is if and then protest
She is beautiful and has a lovely voice.
It is ironic that PM is talking about removing middlemen where as he is the biggest middleman in slang it is called dalaal, can he deny that? isn't he doing the middleman's job for his crony capitalist buddies by destroying government PSU's (there is a big list of such enterprises) and promoting and benefitting private enterprises belonging to the people whom he calls his bhai's. Show me one country or one industry in the world or market in the world where there are no middlemen's? It is these middlemen's chain who facilitates and act as bridges connecting the producer with the ultimate consumer
"bhediya aaya bhediya aaya" story aptly applies to Govt especially on Why they don't trust Govt.
Note: Cheaper fuel, 15 lakh, demonetization for corruption & terrorism, GST, etc.
In all protest based on fear.. fear of change but why would they not fear...they feel under represented and bad execution can cost them their lives...I think this all boils down to trust. Trust is so imp in a system!
Nidhi, appreciate you so much for not forcing Hindi on us in your reportage or commentary.
I hope 143k people who watched this video will support farmers
YOU ARE SO BEAUTIFUL
The way the talk about any Topic is too good, they are like ''there is no need to shout for proving yourself right'' the way Arnab Goswami do.
Wooow this girl is so beautiful! ❤️
True...not to mention looks smart too
All for the farm laws. All I hear are 'maybes', 'mights', 'ifs' and 'coulds'. These farmers in Punjab and Haryana are spoilt and do not know the plight of farmers in other states of our country.
Lol that's why they are protesting they are not spoiled they just get paid according to their work and the farmers from other states are just Fucked by government
A spoilt community. Used to freebies in the form of electricity, water etc
@@s.mkamath3819 indeed.
@@s.mkamath3819 than why don't you provide jobs to those spoiled brats who are living in poverty ? It's very easy to just say someone spoiled when got some basic necessities from government who can a poor person get a high paying job when he doesn't even have the privilege to study in good colleges ?
I luv this girl ❤❤
Ye Modi kitna jhut bolta he. He is a true liar.
so well explained thank you
1) If all farmers are against this bill means they will not sell there produce to private mandis , then how can these private mandi can exploit them.
2) This law increases competition among artiyas and private firms , if private firms offer higher prices of crops then it will forces artiyas to increase there prices also.
I am in love with your style of Reporting ma'am ❤️
Do you have data like over a period of 10 years how much farmers weath against middlemen
Don't the farmers know what they doing? Within a few days, news media became experts in farm laws. Jai Kisan!
They're partly misled & partly acting on their excessive greed.
- Mandis won't collapse, definitely not in Punjab. In Punjab corporate buyers will NEVER buy rice & wheat from the farmers in private sales or via mandi middlemen. The obscenely excess amount of unwanted rice and wheat that Punjab farmers produce has no market value (Center buys them at exorbitant prices to literally throw it away). Center will continue to perform the immoral exercise of wealth transfer from rest-of-India to Punjab (and let them have 3x -5x national avg incomes). Net-net the Farm bills don't change anything for Punjab farmers, but they're holding the upliftment of 99% non-Punjab farmers as hostage in return for ransom (free diesel, no-ban on stubble burning, release of Khalistanis & jihadis etc etc)
- The suggestion in the farm bill to have contract disputes resolved by a DM in 30 DAYS in actually in farmers' favor. Farmers insisting on court option is really dmb as it favors the corporates. Corporates can afford lawyers and wait out 1-2 years for the courts to decide on the matter, but the poor farmer will go belly up in that time (nor can he afford top class lawyers)! Arbitration/Adjudication by the DM heavily favors the farmers
- Middlemen providing 'service' is so st00pid! They're actually eulogizing the loan sharks!
@@omnicurious2949 Nicely Explained
@@omnicurious2949 😂😂😂😂 dekh bhai mtlb kuch bhi
@@omnicurious2949 take my advice buddy. The country is in a phase where it has romanticized protest to a dangerous extent. If you are gonna speak against the protest even partly, you are invariably inviting hate. Better be mum!
@@omnicurious2949 You are also partly misled and partly commenting without knowing the ground realities.
Parallel markets dont really work well for govts, they always lose out against private players in long run. So, just going on and concluding that mandis won't collapse is just your misunderstanding on the working of markets. And calling farm produce procurement by govt for the PDS an "Immoral exercise", just shows how little you understand the contribution that Punjab and Haryana make in food security and providing basic nutrition to the nation.
As for the DM resolution, farmers are just asking for the option to go to courts as well. Govt is bringing in these laws as "more options to farmers" and don't want to provide the option for farmers to go to courts as well? The security and resolution net needs to be more detailed out and protective to farmers. Sometimes only arbitration is not the option. There are legal battles needed to be fought by them those who can, so that the interpretation of a situation by the court gets converted to a law. So, just calling out farmers dumb doesn't make your case any stronger when they clearly know what they are doing more than you.
Middlemen name calling is done by govt and the media narrative. I agree there are many predatory people in all sectors, but just starting name calling is just misleading the people. As clearly explained in the video there are many nuances to things and farmers are not the ones who are calling adhtiyas as middlemen. They heavily rely on that relationship which came into existence organically, if the govt is trying to forcefully engineer them out of the framework, they will just end up bringing up more powerful middlemen which'll serve more to corporations than farmers.
Because government isn’t trustworthy 🙏🏼jumla party😂😂😂😂😂
What! a mellifluous voice she has
Repeals all 3 farm laws. BoycottBJPModiShah, BoycottAmbaniJiyoReliance, and BoycottAdaniProducts Fortune, King's, Bullet, Raag, Avsar, Pilaf, Jubilee, Fryola, Alpha and Aadhar and Boycott Ramdev ki patanjli. kab bhagwan utheyga modi/shah ko -poochta hai bharat?
i love the way she speaks...…its so beautiful!!!
Only thing to worry here is Corporatisation rest all is bullshit
#Mathematics समझिये A²+B² करे तो क्या आता है लेकिन मान लीजिये A+Bײ()² करे तो रिज़ल्ट आता है A²+2AB+B²
एक्स्ट्रा 2AB मिलता है कि नही⁉️ मिलता है कि नही⁉️ मिलता है ना भाईयो❗ एक्स्ट्रा 2AB कहाँ से आया❓ यही 2AB बिचौलिये, आढ़तिये, सेठ साहूकार दबाकर बैठे रहते है, जिसका सीधा नुकसान हमारे किसान भाई को होता है।
#kishanbill2020 #किसानविरोधीसरकार #ढोंगीसरकार
#PP157___✍️
Wow. Good one
Now FARMER'S of INDIA...
DON'T believes Modi Govt...😂
Modi already failed Candidate of bringing blackmoney back..
Watching this news anchor first time. She is very impressive and expresses herself well naturally. She will go a long way
मेरी हर देशभक्त भारतीय से गुजारिश है कि वह जिओ का फोन तुरंत पोर्ट कराएं या बंद कराएं, गलती से भी पतंजलि का कोई भी सामान ना खरीदें, रिलायंस फ्रेश का इस्तेमाल ना करें, रिलायंस पेट्रोल पंप से पेट्रोल ना भराए, फार्च्यून कुकिंग ऑयल का इस्तेमाल तुरंत बंद करें और यह बात ज्यादा से ज्यादा लोगों को बताएं ...
अगर आप देश भक्त हैं तो मेरा सलाम आपको ...
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
देशद्रोही लोग जैसे कि अंधभक्त कृपया करके पाकिस्तान चले जाएं ...
😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
Nevermind what law we are talking about. The fact that Modi Shah point their finger at you while talking about ANYTHING is outright bad etiquettes.
M - Murderer
O - Of
D - Democracy
I - India
ABSOULUTELY SECOND THAT.
SHEER ARROGANCE!!!!
Hindi me bhi bol diya karo 🤷♂️🤷♂️
I don't understand why all liberandu speak only English???
I don't understand. The smaller farmers will be screwed. How doesn't have the logistics funds to get out of the state and sell the crop.
Today who is stopping...them to sell there crop... Even today We farmer can sell our crops to any one.....anywhere in the country.
Feku Modi htao desh bchao
They want the small farmer to come to new cities and work as a industrial worker. Increase his own livelihood and country’s. We have surplus agricultural produce. We do not need such a huge work force in agriculture. So, we need to improvise the storing processing/ value addition technology where private entities will be of help. So that the labour of farmers will not be wasted year on year. Now, with such a system, a lot of agri labourers will be forced out of the system and pushed towards industry. Migration is the idea.
@@archwidbik You know what is the unemployment % / number in INDIA.... Its highest since 40 years.... data is... (before the corona period and now it's highest is the world).... Its not time for such useless laws.
[Indian rank in global hunger index
55 (in 2014) vs 90+ (2020)]
These laws are full failure even in countries like US, CANADA EUROPE....
In our country 60_70 crore people depends on farming for there livelihood.
Do you even know how these bill were passed in rajya sabha... राज्य सभा...
If not... Then please watch this video and then replay... I will wait for your reply 😊...
ua-cam.com/video/i9IjiW5pULc/v-deo.html
👆 👆 👆 👆 👆 👆 👆 👆 👆
MODI'S ULTIMATE gol IS TO SELL EVERYTHING TO #ADANI #AMBANI...from farmers, railway, airports, ongc, bsnl, BP, banks, LIC,... Everything which our country made from 70 years to hard work.... Even he looted the RBI's... ₹175000000000 just to waived #ambani and other 3/4 friends...
Modi work = only hindu /Muslim... Pakistan/China... Sell Indian resources to adani and ambani...
#SupportFarmersProtest
#JaiJawanJaiKissan #BycottGodiMedia #bycottmodigovernment #ModiHtaoDeshBchao
Lol try living with small farmers you will understand.
Hate thier shitty laws and system.
MODI, AMIT SHAH, BJP MURDABAD
One of the best explanations on the actual concerns of farmers.
पंजाब में सभी किसानों का आड़तीयों के साथ परिवार जैसा रिश्ता है और ज्यादातर आड़तीये भी किसान ही हैं। और पंजाब में 80% से ज्यादा किसान कम जमीन वाले किसान हैं जिनको बोने से लेकर कटाई तक पैसे की जरूरत पड़ती है तो उनके पास एक ही विकल्प होता है आड़तीया। और सिर्फ फसल ही नहीं और भी कोई काम हो तो आड़तीया ही उनके काम आता है। क्योंकि आड़तीया सिर्फ एक फोन कॉल की दूरी पे होता है वरना किसान को कमाई तो छह महीने में आती है तो क्या अगर उसे हस्पताल जाना है यां बच्चों की शादी करनी है तो वह पहले फसल की प्रतीक्षा करेगा। बाकी अगर किसान कहीं और से पैसे लेना भी चाहे तो सिस्टम इतना करप्ट है कि उसके लिए भी उसे पहले पैसे खिलाने पड़ेंगे फिर कुछ हल होगा ऐसे में सरकार किसानों का एकमात्र सहारा भी छीन लेगी तो किसान क्या करेंगे। और किसान तो छोड़ो आड़तीये के साथ काम करने वाले दिहाड़ी मजदूर की रोटी छीन लेंगे आप।
You forgotten the hoarding of essential goods which declared non-essential
In that not only stock govt only interfere if the rate is 100% increase. For example if the selling rate of door dhall is 80/ now, after that the govt will interfere if the selling rate increases to 160/.up to 159/ they can sell
at this rate
7:30 Adhati/Arathi bails* out farmer! Lol. These are otherwise called zamindars, sahukars who charge humongous interest rates from farmers.
Bank i.r. (at Priority Sector Lending) could be ~7%
Adhati would give interest at 17%
Bail out!!? Lol how generous of adhatis. Adhatis lend at pure trust!😂 Is it some charity? I mean people are even buying this bs!
Farmers have no choice!
Its funny how all leftists are advocating for zamindars today!!
I guess you never heard the term fractional reserve system, Banks create money, they can lend at 1% and still make profit,
whereas common people lending at 10% or 12% would lose "Value, " a 100 rupees today has greater value then a 100 next year", of their money because of inflation, so a 17% per year rate is a very generous rate. And banks only lend against collateral, unless ofcourse you are a A or A, and charge for the paperwork at .5%, and you have to include the cost of atleast one pair of slippers for doing rounds to bank. I dont know where you copied that comment and pasted it for your daily wage/pocket money, farmer pay even higher interest rates [because banks wont help farmers who have no land], and small business people like the pan wahallas are charged 5% by lenders permonth that is 60% per year. I hope your masters pay you even though you posted the wrong comment, enjoy your hard earned money. have fun.