Who Killed Father Stan Swamy? || Midweek Matters 20 || Parakala Prabhakar​

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
  • #StanSwamy #FatherStanSwamy #UAPA #BhimaKoregaon #ElgarParishad #BJP #Congress
    Description:
    Should Father Stan Swamy have died? Died in this way? Why did it happen? Who is responsible for it? Was the Indian State threatened by Stan Swamy? Why was it threatened? Is our Republic safer today with his death? These questions haunted Dr Parakala. He tried to search for answers. In this Episode, Parakala tells you where the search led him to.
    For Other Episodes
    Amrutmahotsav, IMF & Reimagining Indian State:
    • Amrutmahotsav, IMF & R...
    BJP & State Elections 2021: Saffron Surge?:
    • BJP & State Elections ...
    Poverty Data & Data Poverty:
    • Poverty Data & Data Po...
    Bonsai Universities & Ripped Jeans:
    • Bonsai Universities & ...
    PSU Mega Sale & Vizag Steal:
    • PSU Mega Sale & Vizag ...
    Narendra Modi Vs Sardar Patel:
    • Narendra Modi Vs Sarda...
    A Spectre Is Haunting This Government - The Spectre Of Digital News: • A Spectre Is Haunting ...
    Covid Surge, National Numbing & Accountability -
    • Covid Surge, National ...
    India is crying for #Maitri: Maitri from its Government -
    • India is crying for #M...
    2021 State Elections: Make No Mistake, It’s A Saffron Surge! -
    • 2021 State Elections: ...
    Covid-19, Governance & Mother's Day -
    • Covid-19, Governance &...
    Covid Agony: The Unseen Psychological
    • Covid Agony: The Unsee...
    Vaccine Mess, Moral Paralysis & Egocratic Government
    • Vaccine Mess, Moral Pa...
    An Independent Public Inquiry - We Must Have
    • An Independent Public ...
    Mired in Past, Messing with Present, Muddled about Future
    • Mired in Past, Messing...
    Cabinet Reshuffle Or Farm Laws Reset: What’s The Priority?
    • Cabinet Reshuffle Or F...
    India's Covid Children
    • India's Covid Children...
    Religious India, Political India & PEW Report
    • Religious India, Polit...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @flaviavengurlekar8884
    @flaviavengurlekar8884 5 місяців тому +117

    We require more such honest and brilliant people like Dr. P. Prabhakar.❤❤❤

    • @yesbhadra6696
      @yesbhadra6696 4 місяці тому +1

      Remember, he was also the only voice which opposed continuously the world's greatest lie and thirdclass movement called Telangana movement for separate state. He was tortured and beaten by Goons (Telangana people, most of them as they all believed lies spread by their professors and politicians) KCR, KTR and others. He is the only Gem of India that is still alive. Jai Thoolanjana, Donga Udhyamala Adda, Naa Thooolanjana Gedda

  • @aminarassai4282
    @aminarassai4282 5 місяців тому +1

    Dr. Parakala Prabhakarji my hats off to you for being so honest and supporting the truth

  • @meerakarthikeyan8292
    @meerakarthikeyan8292 5 місяців тому +1

    Thank u from the depth of my heart sir for speaking of stan swamy..its really heartbreaking to know that he died a Martyr's death for serving the helpless tribals..It really takes immense guts to speak up for a person like him inspite of your status in society😢 we will join hands with u to fight this ruthless corrupted system...May justice prevail!!!!

  • @elizabethfargose161
    @elizabethfargose161 5 місяців тому

    Persons like honourable parakala sir are true gems of India. I appreciate his courage

  • @MrPraveenvaz
    @MrPraveenvaz 5 місяців тому

    He was chained on his death bed in hospital. How cruel can ruling government be? The so called protector of Hindutva. God Bless them. They know not what they are doing.

  • @aliceserrao1125
    @aliceserrao1125 5 місяців тому

    Sir, I salute you, for your honesty, for your courage and exposing the truth. 🙏 God sees the truth, but waits. Now fr, swamy is enjoying Paradise..but God will punish the culprits. 🙏 God Please save our Country from these dangerous people. 🙏 Bless my India with real Peace. 🙏 THANKYOU Lord. 🙏

  • @mohemmedansari8664
    @mohemmedansari8664 3 роки тому

    Sad. We all have blood on our hands. This is not what we exercised our franchise for.
    I recall Siddhartha Vardharajan warning us when this law, and its amendments were brought in..that we should all be worried.
    If our choosen representatives work this way... and have worked this way...and will continue to work this way... what is the way out? Who is the keeper of conscience?
    All said, now what?
    What can we do... to get this wrong corrected. Perhaps courts...how to bring it on top to be considered by them.

  • @AshimDas-s4p
    @AshimDas-s4p 5 місяців тому +101

    Thank you Sir. I feel ashamed as an Indian to have such behaviour meted out to Father Stan Swamy.

  • @y.danielwilson3568
    @y.danielwilson3568 5 місяців тому +188

    It really pains me that an innocent father Stainswamy was intentionally arrested by the BJP govt on the ground that he is opposing the proposal of government to hand over the forest land of tribal people to Adhaani and other corporates.What a shame on Indian judiciary and administration that even a small straw for drinking was denied to a 84 year old father.What a great pity.God is watching every thing.The people responsible for these injustices rendered against father will pay heavy price soon.Our God is living God will judge righteously.Really Dr Prakala prabhakar is righteous person who has guts to expose truths although he is husband of Indian finance minister.God will bless you and you will be placed at top in future sir.

    • @silvepereira9221
      @silvepereira9221 5 місяців тому +10

      Jesus will bring justice soon

    • @laddhasun5964
      @laddhasun5964 5 місяців тому +13

      Same thing is happening with Shri Arvindji Kejriwal

    • @ivangomes2411
      @ivangomes2411 5 місяців тому +4

      No wonder the Pegasus issue was hushed up by the BJP govt.

    • @mercydodda6510
      @mercydodda6510 5 місяців тому +6

      I feel sorry for our honourable Prime minister and all his supporters and associates and all those multi billionaires. Please come to the saving grace of Christ the Lord. Ask for forgiveness and get into His eternal life

    • @georgekuttychacko3412
      @georgekuttychacko3412 5 місяців тому

      ❤❤❤

  • @antoniofernandes5199
    @antoniofernandes5199 5 місяців тому +88

    Dr. Parakala I never knew you are a righteous man who is unafraid of speaking the Truth.
    May the soul of Fr. Stein protect you and intercede for your wellbeing.❤

    • @JD-ce1mj
      @JD-ce1mj 5 місяців тому +7

      God sees the truth but Waits post 4th June!

    • @sateeshum394
      @sateeshum394 5 місяців тому +4

      Well said, nothing is over being just, righteous and humanity..

    • @marthoopa1784
      @marthoopa1784 5 місяців тому +3

      Keep up your integrity and uprightness and ^ģod bless and protect you always

    • @mariammak
      @mariammak 5 місяців тому +2

      Leave GodTHE RIGHTIOUS judge

    • @yesbhadra6696
      @yesbhadra6696 4 місяці тому

      Remember, he was also the only voice which opposed continuously the world's greatest lie and thirdclass movement called Telangana movement for separate state. He was tortured and beaten by Goons (Telangana people, most of them as they all believed lies spread by their professors and politicians) KCR, KTR and others. He is the only Gem of India that is still alive. Jai Thoolanjana, Donga Udhyamala Adda, Naa Thooolanjana Gedda

  • @benjaminjohn4980
    @benjaminjohn4980 3 роки тому +74

    84 year Fr. Stan Swamy, my head down in shame. Whether it's court are political people and goverment did not have any humanity and that Father is voice to below poverty for Jarkand people. Arnob Ghosh swamy from Republican TV arrested and bailed in one day. No body can escape punishment from God. 😭😭😭🙏

    • @rosefernandes4239
      @rosefernandes4239 5 місяців тому +2

      Arnab Ghosh , he will be punished by God one day .... karma

  • @sarika3759
    @sarika3759 3 роки тому +73

    We love you father STAN SWAMY you are the recent new saint of india.let india receive the Nobel prize for your wonderful service.bless our country

    • @govinddubaiabhy9711
      @govinddubaiabhy9711 3 роки тому +2

      This can instantly happen if,
      The congress followers bring them to power.
      And if Stan supporters convince Gandhi family that,they will be heavily benefited in politics!!! Not for any other reasons.!!

  • @inacarmelitadsouza4232
    @inacarmelitadsouza4232 3 роки тому +62

    Fr Stan Swamy should have bailed out and brought for hearings as and when required at that age. A respect given to senior citizen

  • @srputtysrputty6044
    @srputtysrputty6044 5 місяців тому +48

    Fr. Stan Swamy forever remains in the hearts of people he loved & served. May he obtain the grace of truly democratic India & leaders who are selfless & just. May God save our country.

  • @cinderellamiranda9864
    @cinderellamiranda9864 5 місяців тому +34

    Whatever our Priest work for marginalized is never for their interest but bring awarness amongst the illterate for their right. Thank Dr. PRABHAKAR. MAY FR. STAN SOUL REST IN PEACE.

  • @royfernandes8175
    @royfernandes8175 5 місяців тому +122

    God Bless you Dr.Parakala Prabhakar 🙏 for speaking on this topic & also tons of gratitude to you for speaking out in the last couple of months about the illegalities and the total collapse of our pillars of democracy. Fr.Stan Swamy was an example of how ruthless this govt has been, not only for its extremism, lies but also the way how this govt has treated our farmers our wrestlers and tribals. We need more such guardians of this nation who continue to speak out against all odds. It's been a tough journey of patience for all secular,peace, harmony and democracy loving citizens. We all collectively are trying to do our best to protect our constitution by making awareness videos against this cruel and dictatorial govt of thugs. Once again keep up your honest talks, because it gives strength to thousands of us to be inspired to the same and not give up. Peace out 🙏

    • @pondorinaique6335
      @pondorinaique6335 5 місяців тому +8

      Thank you sir for awakening people of this republic how brutal our laws are .

    • @bsr3509
      @bsr3509 5 місяців тому

      Sir I am a great fan of you since you with Etv -2 Pratidhwani.May be India is going to dictatorship with in a 2-3yrs if present government continues.But most of the religious toothed people doesn't understand whichever is going in recent past governments activities

  • @vattamma20
    @vattamma20 3 роки тому +71

    This is super insane that bills and laws are made overnight....Father Stan Swamy who lives on in the struggle for the rights of the poor the exploited...You are so right and powerful to dedicate this show for him and others who did not die in the normal course but we're killed.Thank you .

  • @DeeJayArt001
    @DeeJayArt001 Рік тому +31

    Thanks for this video, I was thinking I'm the only one who cant get over Father Stan Swami's death in prison.

  • @jordanscott6521
    @jordanscott6521 3 роки тому +37

    Fr stan swamy is resting in Jesus n soon he will be a saint for helping the people involved in their voices heard

  • @ashokdas7041
    @ashokdas7041 5 місяців тому +33

    The video on Father Stan Swamy,who dedicatedly worked for the downtown Aadivasi & who died in a jail custody at the age of 84 with out any proper medical care reminds me the name of Graham Stuart Stains who were burn to death along his two teenagers sons by the relegious fanatics from Bajrang dal . We express our condolences & demand proper punishment against the culprits from the authorities & justice system of the Country.

  • @304Gopal
    @304Gopal 3 роки тому +180

    Hanging my head in shame...There is no public outrage... Thanks for your effort to bring out the facts,

    • @jerlyjacob4748
      @jerlyjacob4748 3 роки тому +11

      Yes, there is no public outrage. The protests for his release was also not violent. It hurts within.

    • @praaj4138
      @praaj4138 5 місяців тому +3

      True

    • @ranjanpattayat9916
      @ranjanpattayat9916 5 місяців тому +6

      A deep feeling of sorrow shame , anger at the same helplessness engulfed me . That human cruelty and utter insensitiveness could take such dastardly shape.

    • @georgekuttychacko3412
      @georgekuttychacko3412 5 місяців тому

    • @georgekuttychacko3412
      @georgekuttychacko3412 5 місяців тому +4

      It is a shame for the Govt and court for not giving him a fair trial not even give him water to drink for a man of very serious disease ,
      ഇതിന്റെ ഒക്കെ പാപഭാരം
      ഇത് ചെയ്തവർ കണിശമായും അനുഭവിക്കും , അനുഭവിക്കാൻ തുടങ്ങി .........

  • @elizabeththomas6870
    @elizabeththomas6870 3 роки тому +41

    Sir, very clearly you have explained to us, the helpless lot. We're watching, listening to what's going around us...
    My concern is about the dumb government... Nothing concrete is said.. No action taken so far??
    Was asking a sipper by a 84 year old a sin? crime? A national debate was required?
    Pathetic and disgusting... How long will this continue??? How much more we will have to see?? Country has gone to the dogs for sure!!!!

  • @mscft4104
    @mscft4104 3 роки тому +29

    Thanks a lot for discussing this topic. Your discussion always makes me think objectively. Now we all should question the brutality of the government’s functioning. They are punishing people who have not been facilitated with trial even and no proper charges defended by evidence. Is this a way to threat the citizens, also creating fear of imprisonment. It’s sad. Thanks a lot for discussing this topic. Your discussion always makes me think objectively. Now we all should question the brutality of the government’s functioning. They are punishing people who have not been facilitated with trial even and no proper charges defended by evidence. Is this a way to threat the citizens, also creating fear of imprisonment. It’s sad.

  • @valence5047
    @valence5047 3 роки тому +28

    God bless you Dr prabhakar and many like you should be born for our nation

  • @sujatajena4751
    @sujatajena4751 3 роки тому +100

    Dear Dr Parakala Prabhakar your commentary on Fr Stan Swamy's death is quite hard hitting. It is quite assuring to restore justice. You being upper hand, I believe you can play a great role in repealing this unjust, biased, rediculous act that mostly attacks minorities, tribal and Dalits and those working for their rights. Please!

  • @68sukesh
    @68sukesh 3 роки тому +31

    Indian laws & judiciary is slap on the face of Indian citizens

  • @veraderozario501
    @veraderozario501 3 роки тому +91

    Well spoken ..the truth..its a known fact Who killed Fr Stan Swamy ,

  • @dollyprasad385
    @dollyprasad385 3 роки тому +87

    Sir just like you, I was also really feeling so sad when I heard about Fr. Stan Swamy's demise. I don't know this person, but he was one who chose live his life in service of the tribals. It was really sad the way he was treated at this age, just like how a criminal would have been treated. Just like you mentioned, there are others in similar situations. Have our leaders lost their minds and become so hard hearted to treat a man so?
    I wonder if you read this. I got it as a WhatsApp forward.
    From
    Valson Thampu
    Former Principal
    St. Stephen's College, Delhi
    I AM HAPPY FOR FR. STAN SWAMY... Also for the present dispension, for I am a patriot.
    Fr. Stan Swamy is no more. I feel awkward about mourning his death. Instead, I feel a strange sort of happiness. Am eerie sort of relief, if you don't mind.
    Who are we to mourn his death? We, who dare not utter a word, fearing for our skin?
    Who are we to feel sorry for the loss of this noble soul, when our concerns rarely go beyond the stomach?
    Surely, Fr. Stan must have been somebody! At 84, and unsteady on his feet with the Parkinson's, he was such a threat to national security that he had to be shut up in a prison.
    What was the threat he posed?
    Well, very grave indeed, if you think of it. He sympathised with those who were struggling for their basic rights and dignity. Can there be anything more subversive?
    I feel sorry for those of us who are left behind. We may not be shut up in prisons. There is no need to. We are our own prisons.
    So, we survive like scarecrows. But prisons too have their days; and then they will be no more. A new sun will arise, and mock its debris.
    There is only one practical problem left now. How will they dispose of the body of Fr. Stan?
    He is still an accused under the UAPA. He is not entitled to bail. Unless the court grants bail to his dead body, how will he be buried or cremated? Only one thing is lawful; his body has to be despatched to the prison, under armed escort.
    Let a speedy trial begin over the dead body, for God's sake. Let the truth about Fr. Stan be brought to light. Let the whole world know what the crime was for which Stan was shut up.
    There is a compelling reason for saying so. Under the UAPA, the accused is GUILTY UNTIL PROVEN INNOCENT. So, Fr. Stan has died guilty. That is to say, he died condemned without a trial: an injustice not done to any accused, under any law anywhere in the world, or in any period of the human history of rule of law.
    The State has a duty, besides, to prove the merit of its stand. Though, it is in the nature of the idea of the State itself that it is not accountable to anyone. All the more so, when it is patronised by a committed judiciary. That notion is of the very essence of the UAPA act and all other draconian laws.
    If UAPA is to make chilling sense, it should also be prescribed under its rubrics that an accused under its provisions should not be granted burial or cremation, unless his innocence is established. The bodies of the accused, when dead, should be preserved in a UAPA mausoleum under heavy guard. Just in case, the corpses escape and express solidarity with the poor and the powerless!
    Well, there is this other humanitarian thing, you know? The hospital, treating Fr. Stan, was ordered to 'do all it can' to save Fr. Stan, when he was critically ill. The thought of his soul flying away from the prison was unbearable, perhaps?
    But there is a humiliating truth in this. The State may have a seeming authority over the life of its citizens. But it has no authority over death. But, then, what has no authority over death, cannot have any authority over life too; for life is primary, and death is merely complementary.
    The truth is that the State has absolutely no authority over life and death. It merely pretends to have, till truth comes with its bodkin and pricks the bubbles of mundane pretensions.
    Sleep well, Fr. Stan. Your struggle is over. Ours remains; except that we are unequal to it. Our struggle now is only with ourselves; or, what is left of us.

    • @ritaranee4787
      @ritaranee4787 3 роки тому +1

      His body was buried at Ranchi ???

    • @parakalaprabhakar
      @parakalaprabhakar  3 роки тому

      🙏🏽

    • @ritaranee4787
      @ritaranee4787 3 роки тому +2

      @@parakalaprabhakar Thank God bless you

    • @alfredcoelho8718
      @alfredcoelho8718 3 роки тому +1

      @s pp Rita ranee: you are right his ashes were taken to ranchi to be buried among his own tribal people

    • @jacinthafernandes2562
      @jacinthafernandes2562 3 роки тому +10

      Sister by posting this you brought tears and guilt in my heart.The amount we are fighting for Fr.Stan Swamy now if we were doing while he was alive it would have been nice.Rest in Peace Father.You fought a good fight and you are wearing a crown which our LIRD JESUS CHRIST has preserved for you.LOVE U FATHER.

  • @EvolveWithJennifer
    @EvolveWithJennifer 5 місяців тому +23

    Dr. Prabhakar, for your open mindedness on this issue. Thank you

  • @francisdsouza4213
    @francisdsouza4213 5 місяців тому +29

    The agencies who were supposed to protect the innocent, were hands in glove with the state to protect it from its evil deeds.

  • @santhoshkurien9788
    @santhoshkurien9788 3 роки тому +47

    We lost a great man against unjust.

  • @elizabethambuja200
    @elizabethambuja200 2 роки тому +35

    Dr Parakala you are a prophet for our times ! A prophet is one who speaks for God
    Thank you for your courage.

  • @josephjames859
    @josephjames859 3 роки тому +43

    It takes real guts to present such a dispassionate analysis. It is touching to see such genuine compassion for poor old Fr. Stan. What a contrast from the obscene celebrations of his death by people who hardly knew him or his work. Is this what the great religion of Hinduism has come down to.

  • @1963munni
    @1963munni 3 роки тому +46

    Salute to you Sir! You are a light in the darkness! Your well studied analysis gives one some consolation and some hope!

  • @samthumati4091
    @samthumati4091 3 роки тому +20

    Parakala garu, hats off to you sir for the great analysys and exposition of truth. Long live sir. God bless you.🙏🙏🙏

  • @manojmahapure9524
    @manojmahapure9524 3 роки тому +36

    Parakala sir! the episode of father Stan swamy was very well explained by u, how does our legel system acquit the convict? is a million dollar question, poor father who was a person handpicked by god to work for the upliftment of tribals, in fact god was working through him for the upliftment of tribals, I really felt very sorry for father Stan swamy, do u think what has happened is right or wrong? how do we assess the judicial system of our country?

  • @jarenetharakan6595
    @jarenetharakan6595 3 роки тому +42

    There are very few people like you in India. Keep up the good work sir.

  • @nasreensyed6451
    @nasreensyed6451 3 роки тому +28

    🙏 Thank you for being unbiased and speaking truth, unless those responsible for arresting innocents are punished this will go on... 😢

    • @monikanoronha9069
      @monikanoronha9069 Рік тому +4

      Politicians will definitely pay the price for Innocent fr sten Swamy's blood.bhagwan ke ghar mai dher hai andher nahi. He is a saint.

  • @nhaokip6646
    @nhaokip6646 3 роки тому +20

    Judiciary too have blood on their hands 🙏🏽

  • @mohamedriaz9115
    @mohamedriaz9115 Рік тому +50

    A patriot son of India, You have a great heart to speak out the truth.God bless you

  • @yeenadsouza5881
    @yeenadsouza5881 3 роки тому +25

    Evil is stronger in this world, we have become slaves of evil.
    Bless this world Lord.

  • @gopinathnambiar9707
    @gopinathnambiar9707 3 роки тому +24

    Pray... intellectuals with true human values like you multiply thru social media. Wish your expressions are translated in atleast Hindi. That will be great.

  • @0rsan2010
    @0rsan2010 3 роки тому +227

    India has lost a true hero in Fr. Stan Swamy. Fr. Stan worked tirelessly till his final days for the upliftment of the poor and marginalised. Fr. Stan will forever live in our hearts and minds. ✨✨✨🙏

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 7 місяців тому

      Lol

    • @arun.sebastin
      @arun.sebastin 6 місяців тому

      ​@@Myanmartiger921 SONKI MONKEYS 🤡💩

    • @philipvarghese2366
      @philipvarghese2366 5 місяців тому +8

      ​​@@Myanmartiger921
      Laugh your heart out you evil agent.
      Btw- how much do you get paid for it?

    • @seasonwalk5776
      @seasonwalk5776 5 місяців тому +13

      BJP could give Sadhvi involved in Malegaon bomb blast treatment in hospital later bail and then acquit her🤔. They could give Dera Sacha Sauda Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh convicted of raping two Dera sadhvis, murder of journalist Ram Chander and follower Ranjit Singh payrole 7 times from 2022-2024. Forget bail, they did not even permit Fr.Swamy a sipper. Karma will catch up with all of them.

    • @AlfiaDcunha
      @AlfiaDcunha 5 місяців тому

      Your time will come soon..then we will laugh.​@@Myanmartiger921

  • @RJ-up3os
    @RJ-up3os 3 роки тому +49

    As Justice Madan Lokur said : Is any law like the UAPA above the Indian Constitution which holds that a person is innocent until proven guilty?

  • @pramodkul
    @pramodkul 3 роки тому +101

    Could the president have stopped signing of the bill n making it into a law? We know president's are rubber stamps. But I feel if we had proper president, it could have been stopped.

    • @joymascarenhas3491
      @joymascarenhas3491 3 роки тому +16

      India, needs a President like Abdul Kalam , a forward thinking modern genius, righteous and a exemplary character, not a saffron rubber stamp for fascists, ‘crying’ over the amt of IT he pays!

    • @jerrylawrence6944
      @jerrylawrence6944 3 роки тому +6

      Such a incapable Govt. Which does not understand difference between Good and evil.
      This incapable Govt. will never be Successful.

    • @shirlypanicker3367
      @shirlypanicker3367 3 роки тому +6

      It's so sad what happened to late very Rev. Fr. Stans Swamy, SJ. Anyway he is in a better place away from the trials and tribulations of this temporal and precious earthly pilgrimage. God knows what happened to him and the sufferings underwent🙏

    • @jeyedward837
      @jeyedward837 3 роки тому +6

      No president goes against the govt . Don't know why Ambedkar and party put the president a mere rubber stamp with no authority.
      Similarly the governor's and Lt governors who keep the elected state govts on tenterhooks at the behest of HMV. See pondy KB , was put there to ensure Narayan samy falls once the job was done she was changed ,see Delhi the LG does not allow CM to do any good to the people . After all LG does not have anything to loose during elections ....God save the country

    • @jacinthafernandes2562
      @jacinthafernandes2562 3 роки тому +6

      President is a puppet of modi

  • @pathupara
    @pathupara 3 роки тому +51

    From your excellent analysis, 2 facts are noteworthy: that the initial impetus to enact draconian laws as early as 1967 was to curb dissent from those representing the concerns of the working poor, and that the Congress and the BJP are equally guilty for the death of Stan Swamy and numerous undertrials over the decades. There should be a widespread movement for the repealing of the Anti-terrorist laws, for reasons you have excellently elucidated.

    • @arun.sebastin
      @arun.sebastin 5 місяців тому

      Both BJP and Congress are the culprits

  • @Dr.SD4079
    @Dr.SD4079 3 роки тому +35

    I was ignorant fool to believe the charges on Father Stan Swamy until yesterday Pegasus scandal happened but now indeed I realised who put all incriminating documents in all accused Laptops or Phones😡
    Every govts we’re culprits but present govt is shameless brazen in its act.
    Thanks for excellent insight and analysis 🙏🙏
    This law must go and is blot on democracy!

  • @DrSarahMathew
    @DrSarahMathew 3 роки тому +27

    I was really looking forward to hearing your point of view regarding the death of Fr Stan Swamy. Thank you for a very clear presentation of the facts. Pray that all those in positions of authority will act responsibly and accountability - across political parties

  • @AzharKaz
    @AzharKaz 3 роки тому +15

    You make us worry, Parakala. Very much worried. But your speaking out the truth gives some hope. Salute to your objectivity and ability to speak to the powers that be

  • @vandanakarnik8296
    @vandanakarnik8296 3 роки тому +39

    Very sad state of long trials and judicial trials.

    • @satyasatya6694
      @satyasatya6694 3 роки тому +1

      Trials can be long, it is easy to defend your government, your government can keep someone in a jail,
      All the allegations were not proved in any court, all he was asking was a straw ,

  • @Mabel-nd8mt
    @Mabel-nd8mt 4 місяці тому +3

    I am a senior citizen I
    Still have not forgotten
    Father Stan...l salute
    You for talking about
    Stan....God bless l
    Have heard you give
    Talks on many topics..
    You are an intellectual
    gem....so humble...
    Compassionate....truthful....a great humanitarian....God bless you truly a man
    With wisdom....Thanks
    For enlightening us....
    and using God given
    Talent for our nation....
    God bless you once
    again.....

  • @inacarmelitadsouza4232
    @inacarmelitadsouza4232 3 роки тому +13

    Some soothing words to wounded hearts 💕 by our brother country man. Our hearts are also are in deep grief and pain waiting who will sooth us. May God bless you Mr P Prabhakar 🙏❤🙌

  • @pranavkakkar7637
    @pranavkakkar7637 3 роки тому +15

    Well articulated Parakala ji. It was an institutional murder by the State. 🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @vandanakarnik8296
    @vandanakarnik8296 3 роки тому +141

    So,so sad that we treat ,or our political masters fear of, a old man doing such great service to the needy. It is a brutal murder by courts and political masters. Sad.

  • @gangadharhiremath7306
    @gangadharhiremath7306 3 роки тому +101

    Just 85 seconds in to this video.You pulled the strings in my heart.
    I feel you are the soul representing all of us.
    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @rajkumars2707
    @rajkumars2707 3 роки тому +18

    Sir, thank God for giving you the wisdom. Every episode you present is unbiased. We need many people like you to make this nation a worthy one. Best wishes sir..

  • @suvera
    @suvera 3 роки тому +83

    Well explained sir.
    Very detailed info.
    Yes we are all culprits for electing such brutal mindless leaders and all political parties are A1s.

    • @whythiskolaveridi1883
      @whythiskolaveridi1883 3 роки тому +1

      @Save India not only that the law should EMPOWER Indians not the people in power

    • @babahanuman83
      @babahanuman83 3 роки тому +2

      majority of indians did not vote for the prinitive hindusect.

    • @rakhimukerji7937
      @rakhimukerji7937 4 місяці тому

      MODI GOVT HAS BEEN AGAINST ALL GREEN ISSUES.They have stopped int national organisations from working with us.

  • @FixoFelixxx
    @FixoFelixxx 3 роки тому +40

    Fr Stan is gone to a better place. Now he is more powerful & no power on earth can do anything to him! God saved him from further prosecution!
    Now a church is demolished in Lado Serai Delhi, with an ongoing court case. The way it was demolished, by scattering all the sacred blessed items, statues & pictures is pathetic & disgraceful.
    Kindly find out who is behind this?

    • @janna5236
      @janna5236 3 роки тому +2

      So true

    • @janna5236
      @janna5236 3 роки тому +2

      God has saved him. Now man n power can touch him.he is in heaven.

    • @francisfernandes5615
      @francisfernandes5615 3 роки тому +1

      All those harm innocent, ignorant, poor, and God's people will loose peace on earth, in family and end up in hell

    • @verilog123
      @verilog123 3 роки тому

      Wow, also please find out who is out converting hindus all over India through money from abroad. do you care to do it? will you also restore the temples crushed by the protugese in Goa?

    • @francisfernandes5615
      @francisfernandes5615 3 роки тому +1

      Money, machinery, men, muscles, are not with Christians
      Only good will, peace, happiness and faith in true living God Jesus Christ

  • @ronnie202
    @ronnie202 3 роки тому +18

    Everybody was quiet, until he died. The perpetrators should be found out and justice be meted out to them.

  • @DrRaziyaParvin
    @DrRaziyaParvin 3 роки тому +15

    Good reflection as a responsible citizen. Thank you sir🙏

  • @idaraj8742
    @idaraj8742 3 роки тому +20

    Brilliant Analysis! Relevant Questions asked.
    Action is required to put an end to the brutal implementation of the UAPA Act till then all parties are culpable.
    However, I would pin more blame on the present dispensation because they seek the least opportunity to throttle opposition to their evil designs!

  • @papetlm2727
    @papetlm2727 5 місяців тому +4

    A Great and Honest Man who remembers and speaks about the Great Priest Fr.Stane Swamy.

  • @jmefer1
    @jmefer1 3 роки тому +133

    People like you restore hope... That evil cannot triumph however long it may take. . Bless you.

    • @parakalaprabhakar
      @parakalaprabhakar  3 роки тому +5

      🙏🏽

    • @shree709
      @shree709 3 роки тому +1

      Any death is matter of sorrow but nobody says whose father was he? We all have our fathers. Man accused of anti nationals acts and killing Hindu sadhus was in custody.... that's all.

    • @ClintonBorges
      @ClintonBorges 3 роки тому +2

      He is Nirmala Sitharaman husband. Yes you read it write

    • @marypaul1742
      @marypaul1742 3 роки тому +1

      Fool,ironhearted man

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 3 роки тому

      When hindus r murdered all silence

  • @SanjeeviNarasimhan
    @SanjeeviNarasimhan 3 роки тому +17

    Dear Mr Prabakar, Thanks for laying out very clearly how these laws encourage if not enable the authorities overstep cross the very feeble/thin line of individual rights (through abuse of law in these laws abuse cannot be proven though). But, can you throw some light under what circumstances a democratic country like India had to pass such enactments. What are the merits, if any?

  • @roshnasra8851
    @roshnasra8851 5 місяців тому +3

    Can an evil people give justice to such innocent soul. He reflects a true and brave human. But none of us have any power to do anything. Salute to such respectful and divine human.

  • @ivykurian4510
    @ivykurian4510 3 роки тому +114

    Really sad to think our dear country has turned into a state of such injustice & cruelty.... 😰😰

    • @dr.a.oliverjetti2556
      @dr.a.oliverjetti2556 3 роки тому +3

      Thank you for the analysis. Trust wisdom prevails and the nation regains its state of justice.

    • @ytadltspv
      @ytadltspv 3 роки тому

      its always been that way. only problem is what atrocities were done in the 1st 67 yrs have been done with more deadly effect in 7. dissenting indivs will be given a long rope jst to show that 'criticism is being allowed', but influencers-activists thatve been working with the oprressed for decades to get them some justice are being eliminated in creative ways. that way all their knowledge and experience will be lost for ever.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 3 роки тому

      When hindus r murdered all silence

    • @aliaa7510
      @aliaa7510 3 роки тому +1

      Yes do agree.
      But when voting day comes, before stepping out of your houses to vote, please pray for wisdom n guidance then ONLY VOTE. It is better to put your precious VOTES in the charity boxes than to vote n bring the wrong ones in power. Think twice before you vote.

    • @jotendrakumar2852
      @jotendrakumar2852 3 роки тому

      @@aliaa7510 U right. others in Congress like Manmohanji Chidambaramji Abhiskek Singhvi Manish Tiwari Sanjay Jha Anand Sharma Ajay Makhen Kapil Sibal Digvijay Singh Kamalnath Jyotiraditya Scindia Jayaram Ramesh Antony Shashi Tharoor Milind Deora Sachin Pilot r all uneducated illiterate no experience & useless in front of Sonia Rahul & Priyanka surely.
      So think vote only Rahul Priyanka Sonia as they r so highly educated experience & learned. Even the great Dr Abdul Kalam is a big zero in front of Sonia Priyanka Rahul isn't it. 😎 😎 😎

  • @joandmello660
    @joandmello660 3 роки тому +5

    Gods Wrath on the leaders , detaining people working for the downtrodden. RIP Fr. Swamy.

  • @shripkanth
    @shripkanth 3 роки тому +29

    A very comprehensive review sir! The heart bleeds to know of the way that a system can sanction such insensitive implementation. Liviathan in making indeed. I pray that a wave of sanity hits India for it to look at some fundamental flaws in the ability of country to stand for its people.
    Thank you sir for your rigour in the process of defining our country.

  • @bhagyalakshmita978
    @bhagyalakshmita978 3 роки тому +40

    The law makers n those who enforce it should meet with the same fate as that of Father Stan Swamy. It's disgrace to our nation & the world is watching our misdeeds. Where are we heading...?. The future realy looks very scary.

    • @ritaranee4787
      @ritaranee4787 3 роки тому

      What about the case of UA-cam blogger Karl Rock ????

    • @sujamaryvarghese4139
      @sujamaryvarghese4139 3 роки тому +4

      Father Stan I'm sure wouldn't want even his persecutors to meet the same fate as father did. Father Stan would only want a change of heart for our rulers - that they have a heart of flesh and not hearts of stone. Father spent a lifetime preaching the Mercy of God. If our rulers repent over their misdeeds Father would rejoice in heaven. Father Stan please pray for our country and it's rulers. Amen.

    • @ritaranee4787
      @ritaranee4787 3 роки тому +4

      @@sujamaryvarghese4139 Yes Ma'am .
      We have gained another Saint

    • @jenndesouza5312
      @jenndesouza5312 3 роки тому +2

      Fr. Stan Swamy is a Living Saint of present times..
      His earthly journey came to an end on 5th July 2021 at the hands of Pilates. The whole world has witnessed and monitored the saga of a Human Rights Activist. In the midst of grief, sorrow and pain, let us pray for the Persecutors, pray for Peace & Harmony in the land that teaches non-violence🙏🙏
      "Abba forgive them, they do not know what they do"
      (Lk 23:24)

    • @sabujoseph6072
      @sabujoseph6072 3 роки тому

      Bhagya Lakshmi, the world, including each one of us, has Just started turning hostile, and lost that duscrning power, slowly becoming slaves to everything that glitters. And this characteristics is so pronounced in the last couple of decades. So we need to collectively start searching for our soul, both at the individual and societal level

  • @surendrapachauri1676
    @surendrapachauri1676 3 роки тому +10

    Excellent Presentation about UAPA possible misuse by State.

  • @antoniapushparaj
    @antoniapushparaj 3 роки тому +34

    It was a hearty conversation sir! Thank you 🙏
    India .... The very core of constitution is shaken... The right to express, speech, practice any religion, the right to life.... Is redefined. Is India a democratic, secular and socialist country?! 😭😭😭 Dark pages of Indian history is Fr. Stan's death... Oldest human being's death in custody under trail 😭 Oh God..... 🙏🙏🙏

  • @prakashudyavar9811
    @prakashudyavar9811 3 роки тому +76

    Really sad 😢.
    The British were better even though they were from out side.
    The lawmakers, the Home Minister and the PM have blood on their hands. Fr. Swamy's sufferings are over now and he is in peace with God. But what about our country?

    • @leenashetty9741
      @leenashetty9741 3 роки тому +4

      The INDIA'S PM IS ALREADY WASE HIS HANDS HAVE BEEN WASHED HIS HANDS WITH THE INNOCENT'S BLOOD

    • @mp-sr2rm
      @mp-sr2rm 3 роки тому +6

      Country is dying it's slow death. No place for honest people in India. It's very clear that money and power can do anything in this country.

    • @agnettarodricks6169
      @agnettarodricks6169 3 роки тому +1

      👍❤️🙏

    • @atulkumar-lm7cg
      @atulkumar-lm7cg 3 роки тому

      yes , who can miss golden days of jaliyawala m bengal famine

    • @kavitagera6101
      @kavitagera6101 3 роки тому

      You are actually praising the British and their endless atrocities and Parakala is supporting you. Shame on you

  • @austinkannada
    @austinkannada 3 роки тому +11

    Thank you Sir so much for dedicating whole show for this. Again a very poignant, precise analysis🙏

  • @oswaldmachado5464
    @oswaldmachado5464 3 роки тому +23

    Sir I have no words to say. I'm in tears when you speak. So calm & forthcoming. You are truly a very intellectual man. May God bless you. You touch our hearts

  • @poonamdas1704
    @poonamdas1704 3 роки тому +16

    If good people are mercilessly killed,what will be the end of bad people?

    • @manojmahapure9524
      @manojmahapure9524 3 роки тому +2

      Bad people will be there till the day of atonement to face the punishment, father Stan swamy is definitely in the kingdom of god because he was chosen for a purpose.

    • @anniesebastian2520
      @anniesebastian2520 3 роки тому +1

      Bad people will reign in glory... misleading a nation of blind devotees, who are too brain dead to see the truth. Till one day these brain dead andh baths will become the target.

    • @bhagyalakshmita978
      @bhagyalakshmita978 3 роки тому

      @@anniesebastian2520 very well said👌👌

    • @poonamdas1704
      @poonamdas1704 3 роки тому

      Yes Fr.Stan Swamy is surely with Heavenly Father and this is the truth and real justice

    • @manojmahapure9524
      @manojmahapure9524 3 роки тому

      Truth shall prevail !@@poonamdas1704

  • @rajappaarulappa2258
    @rajappaarulappa2258 5 місяців тому +2

    A true son of India and an astute follower of Christ, who identified himself with the least and the lost of the society! Fr. Stan Swamy was and is a Prophet who preached the Truth and gave a living witness. Long live the spirit of Stanswamy 🙏

  • @johnalexander4982
    @johnalexander4982 3 роки тому +18

    Many of us had a wonderful education in Xavier's and Loyola institutions and have experienced first hand, unselfish service that Jesuit rendered to Society, especially the poor and disempowered. The Act is egregious, but what is truly terrible is how inhumanly Modi-Shah are now using it.

  • @sureshbabupv3863
    @sureshbabupv3863 3 роки тому +12

    Sir, you well explained to where India is moving. Rulers and political leaders who have fear on their own citizens really leads the country to a pathetic situation . Nobody can willfully think that he is safe. Tomorrow you may be caught uder this draconian law, day after tomorrow it may be me. What a pity situation is this.

  • @sheelababu6684
    @sheelababu6684 3 роки тому +11

    Thank you sir for your sincere attempt to expose this draconian law in detail. India is not outraged enough sir so I am afraid more Stan Swamy will happen!

  • @dsilva8796
    @dsilva8796 3 роки тому +7

    Very Good eye opener and clarification in the words of may person, and the dangerous path politicians are taking the citizens. Even the SC and judges are now showing concern.

  • @gregorygomes5509
    @gregorygomes5509 3 роки тому +6

    The world today has turned upside down. Everything Evil is right and everything good is bad.

  • @umjerbathiangchannel
    @umjerbathiangchannel 3 роки тому +2

    Brutally killed by the evil spirit of Indian judiciary .

  • @gchaudhury
    @gchaudhury 5 місяців тому +4

    One of the most shameful incident.
    Thank you for a reminder.

  • @krishnamohan2994
    @krishnamohan2994 3 роки тому +2

    Sir,
    There were many people in very high places who could have helped this old helpless man.
    But unfortunately none of these people chose to act or intervien.
    Death was the only help this man to get in such a situation.

  • @christosvd600
    @christosvd600 3 роки тому +6

    Its better all the intellectuals committed to human rights must join together and protect the Constitution of India.

  • @jagadishroy7516
    @jagadishroy7516 5 місяців тому +3

    My heartiest respect for you Sir. As a common man we have a lot to say but.............!

  • @samueljoseph2821
    @samueljoseph2821 3 роки тому +5

    Sir, there must be provision in law that if the person detained in prison is exonerated after a delayed and long trial under detention,the person should be compensated with good amount and Govt./authorities must be held responsible for such unauthorized detention. Let your video be an eye opener to the government. May God bless you sir for the impartial views.👃👃👃

  • @basavarajh1860
    @basavarajh1860 5 місяців тому +2

    Besharm BJP Karidliya election commission, ED, CBI, Court, EVM, Godi media, Paisa, SBI, electrol bond, aur bacha kyaa hai kharidne keliye 😂🤣🤣😭😭

  • @alijuddy5362
    @alijuddy5362 3 роки тому +34

    The tragedy is these laws are meant for and used for people who dissent rightfully. On the contrary the ruling dispensation can get away with almost anything!

  • @jonesedy65
    @jonesedy65 5 місяців тому +2

    The blood of the Poor innocent Father is in the hands of the ruling Government. Good speech sir 🙏

  • @lalithanarayan9079
    @lalithanarayan9079 3 роки тому +49

    This is TERRIBLE ACT , seems mainly to be used to silence Good People coming in the way of Rulers. Very Depressing. Who and how these people will be compensated for the wrongful punishment. Their Lives are totally ruined. Poor innocent souls suffering mentally and physically for what they were not a part of.
    Will there be REALLY GOOD PROSPECTIVE FUTURE, FULL OF HARMONY PEACE FOR OUR INDIA ? SHALL WE REMAIN OPTIMISTIC ?

    • @unconventionalcooking5826
      @unconventionalcooking5826 3 роки тому +5

      Worst than emergency period

    • @helenabara2092
      @helenabara2092 3 роки тому +1

      Inhuman and Cruelty done by
      Modi . Murderer of Fr Swami.
      He Is Saint whether any one believe Or not.

    • @santanodcosta3360
      @santanodcosta3360 3 роки тому +2

      India is doomed. The hand of God will punish the perpetrators of Fr Stan,s murder at the appropriate time."Vengence is mine says the Lord and I will repay".

  • @kvafsu225
    @kvafsu225 3 роки тому +8

    Sir you have balanced the provisions of the law while pointing out the tragedy of Fr.Stan Swamy a voice of the Adivasis and many many like him - victims. Shows how important it is to see both sides before making Laws and not be rushed, otherwise innocent people will fall victims. Very well researched.

  • @euginrobinson
    @euginrobinson 3 роки тому +20

    It is one of the saddest days of Indian Democracy. And only a few showed the courage to express solidarity and you are one among them, Even some of the alternative media channels did not show the courage to express shock and conveniently avoided even mentioning Fr. Stan Swamy. Thanks so much🙏 sir..

  • @rajappaarulappa2258
    @rajappaarulappa2258 5 місяців тому +2

    Hats off to you Dr. Prabhakar for your prophetic voice!

  • @ismailsindur7561
    @ismailsindur7561 5 місяців тому +3

    I really appreciate Dr.Parikala speaking on Fr.Swami,but l feel very sad for not giving bail petition or to hear.It was really very heinous act that government has done it.

  • @magdalenerani3481
    @magdalenerani3481 5 місяців тому +2

    It is indeed very painful to think of dear Fr.Stan Swamy ,'s unjust,inhuman , cruel death .His humanitarian service to the tribals in future will rise genuine judges to our country to fight against terrorism and religious fanaticism.May dear Fr Stan Swamy intercede the Lord to make our judiculiary system more hunan and holy.

  • @leslierodricks2701
    @leslierodricks2701 Рік тому +3

    Thank you Sir for your brilliant and sensitive analysis of the brutal and barbaric Act!

  • @lekhasuryan8871
    @lekhasuryan8871 3 роки тому +10

    Its high time that laws like uapa is re looked and abolished if possible as this is a hindrance to give timely law assistance to the accused. This was the reason for a lot of people being prosecuted without any trial.

  • @sanjeevchaganti6463
    @sanjeevchaganti6463 3 роки тому +5

    It's shame on the part of our legislature, the police (nia) and more of our glorious judiciary. It's a sort of legalised despotism. Both the UPA and the NDA should answer this..

  • @ravin8405
    @ravin8405 Рік тому +3

    Judicial inquiry should take place if new Govt comes in 2024😮