Good journalism will thrive if good people pay for it . Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/ This also includes the link for overseas subscribers.
"No one will really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems -- of which getting elected and re-elected are No. 1 and No. 2. Whatever is No. 3 is far behind" - Thomas Sowell, Economist
@@soumyaneelmanna3097 Thomas Sowell was incorrect about his view on slavery but that in no way discredits the truth of his statement above. Disentangle the human from the statement.
There are more than one ways how congress and Gandhi have humiliated netaji, Nehru even called him a mad fascist. It's time that we are taught the true history and not the one written by congress, tell me guys how many paragraphs were allocated to netaji in our school history books?
@18:00 Biggest joke of century- BJP has no internal democracy. BJP did not start after 2014 or 2019 elections. Jaswant Singh, Yaswant Sinha, Advani, Shatrughna Sinha, Sushma Swaraj and many more opposed Narendra Modi's candidature in 2013. Later, Modi was elected by parliamentary board Some of them left the party as well. All Presidents of BJP since 1980 are duly elected and from various backgrounds and regions.
BJp doesn't have an internal election process(which we know of). Post a link to numbers of such if so. They just declare so and so is the new president or portfolio member. They never will give you the number because there is no such thing.
@@venomfu007 there is difference between being democratic and holding election... Even communist party of China takes everybody's opinion from among it's cadre while making leadership decisions.... What r u talking about?
@@संदिपमांडे-य1य There is a difference between Election and Selection. Democracy (internal or external) has an election process to it. BJP has a selection process. Democracy and elections are not mutually exclusive.What are talking about? Greeks will revolt to this statement. Asking a few leaders for opinion is a Selection process. Like Monarchs used to be. That is no democracy. Asking EVERYONE in a systematic process(votiing) IS. It is widely known BJP doesn't have an internal democracy. But they are okay with it. China's Politiburo had an election process which was transparent until Xi Jin chnaged it recently. In other words, CCP was more democratic than BJP.
Not sure why everyone thinks there is no internal democracy in the BJP. www.google.com/amp/s/www.firstpost.com/politics/bjp-will-complete-its-election-process-for-its-national-president-before-31-december-says-jp-nadda-7184661.html/amp
@@abhiraj9470 okay first tell me any party president from Bjp who belongs to a single family JP Nadda,Amit Shah,Rajnath Singh,Nitin Gadgari....only one thing id common they all belongs from BJP... 🤣🤣🤣 congress sonia gandhi then rahul gandhi then again sonia gandhi then again rahul gandhi now again sonia.....Picture is clear and simple any dump can see this difference
Still waiting for how Bangalore riots happened, how congress sacrificed their 'dalit' MLA, and how BJP's govt let polarization happen to suit it's agenda. And i don't see your young reporters running around like they did during Delhi riots(NOT POGROM!) 😪
that for 2024, 2029 is open for all. after modi 2029 is not a easy game for BJP. they may need to face many local leaders and local issues, whatever good gov do, once local leaders become unhappy then you get punished. best example is Chandra babu in Andhra. his gov administration is not that much bad compare to other gov, but local leaders are not worthy, all money minded. who knows, 2029 how many young leaders will come. all old gang will go like Mamata, Lalu, Kcr, Babu, Pawar .. now kejriwal just sleeping, once Modi era finished, he will again start the secular game all over the country and gather the team. India is for politics.
@@ravishastri2276 I do not think Yogi can be a PM candidate. things will change by 2029, not all young Urban voters vote for Yogi same like Modi. may be some other young leaders like Devendra fadnavis , Tejasvi surya etc can emerge. Tejasvi surya can be best option if he can emerge. he can speak well, he knows multiple languages, he can balance both South and North, he has rss background. I see he can be a best futuristic leader, if bjp can promote him.
No it's not it is from all sections.........the biggest minority vote for mamta in Bengal, SP in UP RJD in bihar, KCR in telangana, YSR in Andhra..........and only around 20 percent muslims vote for congress
@@krishnarajagopalan528 i am talking about the 20 percent vote the congress gets.........muslims no longer vote for the congress........they opt for regional parties
I voted for BJP in the 2019 election. Not because of the BJP voter, but because I voted for a future India. India's biggest problem is, now we believe that we are voters of this party and that party. We live in a democratic country, not a communist country. Therefore do not behave like communists. For any democratic country, it is necessary to have democratic parties. Because every political party is not a private enterprise, they are the property of the country. So we have to take a stand to save all political parties from any one leader, any family and few people groups. So our biggest asset and also the oldest, is the Indian National Conference. So we have to start a social media movement to save the Congress. # Save Congress. Save Congress from a family. Save the Congress from the old leaders. Make Congress a democratic political party. I used Congress as a model of undemocratic party, RJD, JDU, SP, BSP and all other political parties should reform. Now the time has come that we need political reform, judicial reform, administrative reform and police reform.
Let the presidential style process roll out to elect the PM candidate representative for our Congress party.....I still support Rahul or Priyanka but I don't know why the Indians hate thier own family to take forward our indian dreams...... anyways meritocracy counts not the CWC or we....it's the larger indian electorate that deserves a absolute substitute.......be it whomever represent our secural values......
@@theliberalnationale5737 Free market capitalism is luv . Socialism and Welfarism has retched this country . Our huge industrial potential has been totally wasted , with no manufacturing industry to speak !! its a total shame . even free markets for agriculture were put off till 2020 !! which countries had amended in 1980-90
Well everyone knows , for decades SG remains the loyal Bulldog for Ghandis in the media. He knows if Ghandi s go down , well his days in the media will be countable . Oh Bring back Rahul sooner , so we all can witness the expiry date on Congress in the next few years .
@@monojdas-gupta5918 With all due respect, Mr. Das-Gupta, they did remember to send him mangoes through P. Chidambaram while sg was doing a story on Pratiba Patil.
"BJP has less internal democracy than congress"....Guptaji, what are you smoking ? No 2 presidents of the BJP are from the same family. A very ordinary worker became a prime minister. No one knows who the next party president would be. What else do you want ?? :) Also you missed the most important and one of the first instances of high command culture in Congress, when MK Gandhi quashed the election of Netaji. So its he who really set the high command culture rolling.
My state andhra...when ruled by congress... gandhi family used to send who is cm n sealed post... they used to change cm’s every two years..to make sure one gains power...
Who cares about nepotism. Where are the jobs? Where is Vikas? Where is our 15 lakhs? Where are the smart cities? Where is make in India? Rupees value??? Covid capital of the world? All we have is chai, pakora, paan mixed with spicy lies. Only Delhi is shining.
Sad to know, that even now you are trying to suggest that "Congress has some internal democracy " while it is nonexistent in BJP. Any ordinary worker from BJP can still dream of becoming BJP president if he or she has talent. Can you on any day think of such a thing happening in Congress? They are slaves of Italian mafia & spineless. Disappointing to hear such poor analysis from someone of your calibre. Infact it's a shame.
Democracy doesn't only mean anyone from the bottom of the pyramid becoming top and autocratic leader. Look at the BJP government now. No power is decentralized. Not even at cabinet ministers level. All instructions need to come from the top leader. Congress has a major issue with Gandhi family grabbing its leadership. It needs true leadership without lineage to Gandhi family to get stabilize it democratically.
@@sarsonsar0 Yes....but a BJP worker still serves under a meritocracy...meanwhile the Congress is a pure feudal Monarchy...with one royal family and a court of lackies jockeying for political favours...
Congress leaders want Non Gandhi president.. So, Possible contenders are: 1. Antonio Maino 2. Rahul Vinci 3. Priyanka Vadra And If they want a Gandhi Party President.. then contenders are: 1. Sonia Gandhi 2. Rahul Gandhi 3. Priyanka Gandhi.
@sivan ok lets conclude that all these are nomited not elected. How many prominent leaders BJP have, they have Rajnath singh,Venkaiya Naidu, Nithin Gadkari, Fadnavis, Yogi... these are leaders because they tell there opinion. What's with congress.. only one Rahul and to some extend Shashi tharoor
SG.. Pls come out of the Congress business, we know your interest in Indian politics. But it's almost the same story again with some minor changes. Let's invest time more prudently.
@@cis007ful bro JP Nadda is bound to become BJP president..look at the history of recent bjp presidents... people who work Hard in the party like Nadda,Ram Madhav, Modi,shah, gadkari,venkannaidu, Rajnath Singh etc they all came from Grassroots... Congress has to reform itself.. We need a credible opposition
@@Abhi-gx4lj JP nanda and Amit shah was "unanimously" elected, there is no election. Congress is in a mess, no doubt about that, but Consideing congress a family property, I disagree, there are a lot of parties in India which are run like a family property. The print I can see is more sliding towards right wing politics ....
@@cis007ful agree with you but right now We need to criticize Congress more and force them to change.. opposing bjp right now is of no use... Unless there's a credible opposition people will vote for bjp..all media houses are opportunistic .. they tend to go with ruling parties
@@cis007ful Scindia, Hemant Biswas, pilot ,are away from the party.. Congress has already lost mamata,pawar,Jagan,..good leaders in Congress doesn't see future or growth in Congress... courtesy Gandhi pariwar and High command culture
Real reason for missing yesterday's episode was figuring out the narrative for liberal left and taking the video down and reuploading it Be real SG. We are here for the truth
@Shekhaji and the print team, could you please do a CTC on what's going on in Kerala with the Gold smuggling case involving Chief minister's office. It's got national security, NIA, the politics between the left ruling government and BJP etc in the play. Today the office where important documents for this case were stored caught fire. It's possible that it might be a case of arson. So it would be great to get clarity on the issue.
Dear Shekhar, Despite knowing the fact that you have a soft corner for the Congress, which has been obvious all through who has been reading you or listening to you, I thought you will cut the clutter the way you do in all other topics with unbiased analysis. I was hugely disappointed with this episode of your “cut the clutter”. Honestly, to me either you are afraid of being frank when it comes to the Congress Party or you are biased in your analysis. I am sure, you would not have been so careful in choices of words if you had to declutter similar developments in the BJP. Are you still so afraid of the Sonia Congress?
Shekar Gupta ji, What happened? Are U Ok? Most unfortunate, we people are missing you a lot. You are such a great person, great journalist, great thinker. We can't miss you. Come with double strength
6 out of 10 congress votes are by non Hindu. They are basically anti BJP votes. Even the 4 Hindu votes also be anti BJP. If some strong anti BJP leader like Kejriwal emerge on national level, there is no congress vote
The tradition of "selection" by "high command" was started by the "original" Gandhi selecting Nehru to be PM over the democratic choice of Sardar Patel.
Even before that - Mohandas Gandhi's candidate Sitaramaiyya lost INC Presidency squarely to Subhas Bose - and MKG called Sitaramaiyya's loss his loss, and stonewalled Subhas Bose from working using the Gandhi-Nehru clique within the CWC. That was 1939, no wonder Quit India failed spectacularly in 1942, it was only British Macchiavelian policy later to plant stooges in MKG and JLN to give "Independence" after the British increasingly lost of control of the British Indian Army to Subhas Bose's INA and rebellions and mutiny became the norm. With the Germans having laid waste to Britain, Britain found a remote control puppet regime fighting with itself on sectarian lines (Partition) a better alternative than direct colonial control.
For those unfamiliar with the art of rhetoric, this piece had one major and three minor rhetorical objectives. Major objective - spread the blame, starting at the beginning of time with a laundry list of names, to shield Smt. Sonia Gandhi from charges of nepotism. Minor objective 1: To present young Mr. Gandhi in the same light as his father, thus elevating his status without explicitly saying so. Minor objective 2: To create an impression that young Mr. Gandhi's elevation to president-ship is a fait accompli. Minor objective 3: Hit some political targets in an oblique fashion, including Shri Narasimha Rao and the BJP.
Suggestion: please do a live chat once every month. All of us have many questions ranging scores of topics. Why wait for 500th episode or a birthday, please have it once a month.
To be fair to Rahul, he wants the entire outdated 70 yrs+ old guard nominated posts gang to retire gracefully & be replaced by fresh young blood. But the old guard refuses to withdraw gracefully & tries to stage manage such "revolts" to perpetuate the privileges they are enjoying.
Thank you SG for your overnight (sleeping over) analysis to cut the clutter. Very well presented and informative. Congress the Brand - franchise that the Gandhi's own vis-a-vis other stalwarts/ leaders !
@@ilandhiraiyannedunjeralaad7730 yes,SG has a dispassionate way of delivering the news. So I value his inputs,more than what the rest of the circus performs.
Thank you SG for acknowledgement of the power of dalit card. I have nothing against dalits or any minority for that matter but I am saying this with my personal experience that whenever I m having a discussion with my dalit friends and in the end if they don't have anything to argue the only thing they say is "we were oppressed for ages" and that goes unchanged.
Let me declutter on my side :--- Whenever sonia feels that her dynasty in danger she herself calls out this rogue Congress working committee members to opposed her !!!! How many times she does this still people of India want to believe her and the family!!! for the sake of God please spare me on this 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
9:11 India has failed to know about an honest politician called K Kamaraj.. Probably among the most powerful as well as Honest politician of this country! Do read abt him
You have given a solid explanation of working of the Grand Old Party.. It is like a lesson in history. Kudos to you for making history extremely interesting.
There are two three group 1) old man group 2) Middle aged group 3) Young group. Currently Oldman group do not want any internal democracy , they just want to relax and enjoy the current situation . They are not at all interested in forming Govt
Why do u waste so much time in stories of Congress party. Let this party finish in its own way. I am waiting 2024 LS election. Expecting Historical defeat.
I was waiting for this video's 🙏 You do least biased journalism in world of Indian journalism You are critical of left when the are wrong and praise the left when they are right You are critical of right when the are wrong and praise the right when they are right Same for the center Best journalist so far 😅
It is obvious how difficult he tries to somehow make a point that this high-command undemocratic DNA is not part of Sonia Gandhi family but a congress culture. However to sound genuine he just mentions that ofcourse this DNA was planted by Indira Gandhi. It does not matter how many times it happens, people like Shekar Gupta will always try to defend sonia gandhi family. But how much ever he tries to sound genuine it is so obvious that he is not.
As someone commented of the Court loyalists, "Like frightened children, senior Congress leaders old enough to have grand children and great-grand children of their own, tug on the Great Mother's hand, begging to please, please not abandon them."
I run textile industry In last ten year i have never seen so many people asking for labour work It used to be other way around So yes things are not going well
The kind of industry i am in, i get to see things very quickly From 2019 i started seeing things getting bed. Not just for me but here at my town balotra in Rajasthan 2000 units
Mr. Garg... Rajasthan has a state government as well ... Do you expect them to do anything to for local industries ?? Or we have them just for timepass ??
Shri.Sekar Guptajee don't say nothing happened in Congress meeting. Sonia told heself resigned as President of Congress to her; told to elect new leader and retained the President for 6 more months.
Very cheekily states "BJP's supposed democracy"... but no one can tell you who will be next BJP Party President & here we ahve whole 25 min episode telling who will be Congress President for Decades to come :D
For people saying there is an internal democracy in BJP. There is a difference between Election and Selection. Democracy (internal or external) has an election process to it. BJP has a selection process. Democracy and elections are not mutually exclusive. Greeks will revolt to this statement. Asking a few leaders for their opinion is a Selection process. Like Monarchs used to be. That is no democracy. Asking EVERYONE in a systematic process(votiing) IS. That is the DEMO in Democracy. It is widely known BJP doesn't have an internal democracy. But they are okay with it. Not a Congressi just against misinformation.
Though it is a selection, any xyz can still hope to be a party president or PM candidate someday. Atleast there is some reward for a performer. Point is there is no hope for a young leader in congress no matter what how much he works for them, while a young leader in BJP can dream of being a PM one day.
Shekarji taking a day or a two off is absolutely fine. We understand and appreciate your efforts. Keep ur health a top priority and keep us enlightened through ur videos :)
Good journalism will thrive if good people pay for it . Please subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/
This also includes the link for overseas subscribers.
BJP's internal democracy is it can select any deserving leader rather than a puppet from a family.
Which SG will never speak about as their willl be problem of funding for The Print... Do you want that CTC close?
@@DV-lh2ov Spot on
@@DV-lh2ov 99oo
@@DV-lh2ov oooo
"No one will really understand politics until they understand that politicians are not trying to solve our problems. They are trying to solve their own problems -- of which getting elected and re-elected are No. 1 and No. 2. Whatever is No. 3 is far behind" - Thomas Sowell, Economist
So true ...
When will they all think about the people is the question no one asks them.
Thomas Sowell, the guy who thinks slavery was good. Smh
Soumyaneel Manna did he say it exactly as you said it🤔
@@soumyaneelmanna3097 Thomas Sowell was incorrect about his view on slavery but that in no way discredits the truth of his statement above. Disentangle the human from the statement.
@@knaren9681 being black doesn't necessarily mean that his views will definitely be in accordance with the black cause. This argument is quite weak.
You missed the foremost example of high command dictatorship in Congress, which happened in 1939 when Gandhi quashed the election of Subhas Bose.
Sad many people are not aware about it.
There are more than one ways how congress and Gandhi have humiliated netaji, Nehru even called him a mad fascist. It's time that we are taught the true history and not the one written by congress, tell me guys how many paragraphs were allocated to netaji in our school history books?
and Patel too, dada
destroyer 007 --- that's because Gandhi was revered as a saint , incapable of committing any wrong!
true that
"Dalit card is the weapon of mass destruction in an argument"- wow didn't saw that coming.
that's true
It's the same thing with the OBC card, too.
yeah lower caste peeps are awful
@@av3704 Are you a white cross maamaa?
all castes cards are Weapons of destruction.
@18:00 Biggest joke of century- BJP has no internal democracy. BJP did not start after 2014 or 2019 elections. Jaswant Singh, Yaswant Sinha, Advani, Shatrughna Sinha, Sushma Swaraj and many more opposed Narendra Modi's candidature in 2013. Later, Modi was elected by parliamentary board
Some of them left the party as well. All Presidents of BJP since 1980 are duly elected and from various backgrounds and regions.
BJp doesn't have an internal election process(which we know of). Post a link to numbers of such if so. They just declare so and so is the new president or portfolio member. They never will give you the number because there is no such thing.
@@venomfu007 there is difference between being democratic and holding election... Even communist party of China takes everybody's opinion from among it's cadre while making leadership decisions.... What r u talking about?
@@संदिपमांडे-य1य There is a difference between Election and Selection. Democracy (internal or external) has an election process to it. BJP has a selection process.
Democracy and elections are not mutually exclusive.What are talking about? Greeks will revolt to this statement.
Asking a few leaders for opinion is a Selection process. Like Monarchs used to be. That is no democracy. Asking EVERYONE in a systematic process(votiing) IS.
It is widely known BJP doesn't have an internal democracy. But they are okay with it.
China's Politiburo had an election process which was transparent until Xi Jin chnaged it recently. In other words, CCP was more democratic than BJP.
Not sure why everyone thinks there is no internal democracy in the BJP. www.google.com/amp/s/www.firstpost.com/politics/bjp-will-complete-its-election-process-for-its-national-president-before-31-december-says-jp-nadda-7184661.html/amp
@@krishnarajagopalan528 I didn't mean to but the person I am replying to brought it up.
A party with no internal democracy is posing itself to be the Savior of Indian democracy. What a hypocrisy.
In congress you can raise your voice but BJP is all about dictatorship.
@@abhiraj9470 any proof ??
It's well known what they did with Bose Ji.
@@erenyeager4452 Who chooses BJP president. Tell me even in whole history of BJP.
@@abhiraj9470 okay first tell me any party president from Bjp who belongs to a single family JP Nadda,Amit Shah,Rajnath Singh,Nitin Gadgari....only one thing id common they all belongs from BJP... 🤣🤣🤣 congress sonia gandhi then rahul gandhi then again sonia gandhi then again rahul gandhi now again sonia.....Picture is clear and simple any dump can see this difference
Still waiting for how Bangalore riots happened, how congress sacrificed their 'dalit' MLA, and how BJP's govt let polarization happen to suit it's agenda. And i don't see your young reporters running around like they did during Delhi riots(NOT POGROM!) 😪
14 days have passed since those riots now don't even expect
@@virenparekh6712 still, worth putting forward.
For khangress only minorities are matter
Veeresh G
For congress only scams matters not minorities, if minorities matters minorities would not have been in so bad condition now.
@@veereshg3403 Not minority, but the so called minority, I hope you know which one.
It does not even matter now who becomes the president of Congress party, it is only Narendra Modi now who can defeat Narendra Modi.
Rahul will destroy Congress and Modi will destory india (both Work in Progress)
that for 2024, 2029 is open for all. after modi 2029 is not a easy game for BJP. they may need to face many local leaders and local issues, whatever good gov do, once local leaders become unhappy then you get punished. best example is Chandra babu in Andhra. his gov administration is not that much bad compare to other gov, but local leaders are not worthy, all money minded. who knows, 2029 how many young leaders will come. all old gang will go like Mamata, Lalu, Kcr, Babu, Pawar .. now kejriwal just sleeping, once Modi era finished, he will again start the secular game all over the country and gather the team. India is for politics.
@@mallianumula5643 BJP HAS YOGI. DONT FORGET RN HE IS THE MOST POPULAR CM OF INDIA.
@@KiranKumar-nb4nx Will???
@@ravishastri2276 I do not think Yogi can be a PM candidate. things will change by 2029, not all young Urban voters vote for Yogi same like Modi. may be some other young leaders like Devendra fadnavis , Tejasvi surya etc can emerge. Tejasvi surya can be best option if he can emerge. he can speak well, he knows multiple languages, he can balance both South and North, he has rss background. I see he can be a best futuristic leader, if bjp can promote him.
21:10 The so-called 20% vote is the minority vote which votes by the logic of "AnybodyButBJP".
True
No it's not it is from all sections.........the biggest minority vote for mamta in Bengal, SP in UP RJD in bihar, KCR in telangana, YSR in Andhra..........and only around 20 percent muslims vote for congress
@@msgstoas smart getting past the filtering 😎👍
@Kaushal Batavia Agreed but I only know about Bhagel.
@@krishnarajagopalan528 i am talking about the 20 percent vote the congress gets.........muslims no longer vote for the congress........they opt for regional parties
"Original lineage of Gandhis, Not Mahatma Gandhi" 😂
Ghandy probably
Yes, that was odd.
Common rule I follow is Gandhi for MK Gandhi, Gandhis for the Ghandy dynasty
@@divyanshushankar8134 Yes, it is.
@@sandeepcnath9541 👍🏿
Includes Gandhi
I voted for BJP in the 2019 election. Not because of the BJP voter, but because I voted for a future India. India's biggest problem is, now we believe that we are voters of this party and that party. We live in a democratic country, not a communist country. Therefore do not behave like communists. For any democratic country, it is necessary to have democratic parties. Because every political party is not a private enterprise, they are the property of the country. So we have to take a stand to save all political parties from any one leader, any family and few people groups. So our biggest asset and also the oldest, is the Indian National Conference. So we have to start a social media movement to save the Congress. # Save Congress. Save Congress from a family. Save the Congress from the old leaders. Make Congress a democratic political party. I used Congress as a model of undemocratic party, RJD, JDU, SP, BSP and all other political parties should reform. Now the time has come that we need political reform, judicial reform, administrative reform and police reform.
i think to solve countries problems we should pursue privatization
Indian National Congress*
Let the presidential style process roll out to elect the PM candidate representative for our Congress party.....I still support Rahul or Priyanka but I don't know why the Indians hate thier own family to take forward our indian dreams...... anyways meritocracy counts not the CWC or we....it's the larger indian electorate that deserves a absolute substitute.......be it whomever represent our secural values......
@@theliberalnationale5737 Free market capitalism is luv . Socialism and Welfarism has retched this country . Our huge industrial potential has been totally wasted , with no manufacturing industry to speak !! its a total shame . even free markets for agriculture were put off till 2020 !! which countries had amended in 1980-90
@@rahulmalik1083 hey mate I am personally a libertarian and the free market movement seems to be growing in India.
" congress has more internal democracy than the bjp , because they could write a letter to Rahul Gandhi" ...... Pass the weed SG
bhargav atluri that’s a most thug comment buddy..🤘🏻
Lol
bhargav atluri i can’t agree with you more. sG is a great congress lover and a person with a great bias against Modi
Lol.. you dont know anything
BJP also can write letter - but only they cannot send or share or tell anyone about that letter.
A dog chasing its tail, round and round ------ and so on. So what is there to declutter ?
Nothing really.
For this SG taken two days😃😃😃
Well everyone knows , for decades SG remains the loyal Bulldog for Ghandis in the media. He knows if Ghandi s go down , well his days in the media will be countable . Oh
Bring back Rahul sooner , so we all can witness the expiry date on Congress in the next few years .
@@mahanteshbhoostGo on knock me down with a feather ! Do the Gandhis in their ivory tower really aware that fans like SG exists?
@@monojdas-gupta5918 With all due respect, Mr. Das-Gupta, they did remember to send him mangoes through P. Chidambaram while sg was doing a story on Pratiba Patil.
"BJP has less internal democracy than congress"....Guptaji, what are you smoking ? No 2 presidents of the BJP are from the same family. A very ordinary worker became a prime minister. No one knows who the next party president would be. What else do you want ?? :) Also you missed the most important and one of the first instances of high command culture in Congress, when MK Gandhi quashed the election of Netaji. So its he who really set the high command culture rolling.
It is decades long ghulami.
My state andhra...when ruled by congress... gandhi family used to send who is cm n sealed post... they used to change cm’s every two years..to make sure one gains power...
But all from hand from RSS family?? Is it not??
Who cares about nepotism. Where are the jobs? Where is Vikas? Where is our 15 lakhs? Where are the smart cities? Where is make in India? Rupees value??? Covid capital of the world? All we have is chai, pakora, paan mixed with spicy lies. Only Delhi is shining.
High command culture, in hindi "Chamcha Culture".
😄
@@pavannoolvi4274 Do you still think "sometimes"?
Sad to know, that even now you are trying to suggest that "Congress has some internal democracy " while it is nonexistent in BJP. Any ordinary worker from BJP can still dream of becoming BJP president if he or she has talent. Can you on any day think of such a thing happening in Congress? They are slaves of Italian mafia & spineless. Disappointing to hear such poor analysis from someone of your calibre. Infact it's a shame.
Democracy doesn't only mean anyone from the bottom of the pyramid becoming top and autocratic leader. Look at the BJP government now. No power is decentralized. Not even at cabinet ministers level. All instructions need to come from the top leader. Congress has a major issue with Gandhi family grabbing its leadership. It needs true leadership without lineage to Gandhi family to get stabilize it democratically.
@@sarsonsar0 Yes....but a BJP worker still serves under a meritocracy...meanwhile the Congress is a pure feudal Monarchy...with one royal family and a court of lackies jockeying for political favours...
He has been practising it for quite long
Congress leaders want Non Gandhi president.. So, Possible contenders are:
1. Antonio Maino
2. Rahul Vinci
3. Priyanka Vadra
And If they want a Gandhi Party President.. then contenders are:
1. Sonia Gandhi
2. Rahul Gandhi
3. Priyanka Gandhi.
HAHAHA
@@kenny87ification Too late ...... this wont work either.... just like your sarcasm
😂😂😂
@@kenny87ification Too late for this. Rahul Gandhi tried this by becoming Janeudhari for few days😂😂😂
It started in 1939 with sidelining of Bose by a whining "original Gandhi"
Correct Gandhi ji wants Nehru but he was on vacation so he put other candidate and he lost.
SG, there are more important issues than this story of headless chickens!
Congress is the biggest opposition how is it not an important issues
What? Sushant singh suicide?
@@sonuEEE 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
When you have earned too much ,then you can not handover the estates to anyone else but children
So true:)
22 crores Indians who voted for BJP would like RG to lead Congress:)
Actually in Punjab, votes were for Amarinder Singh and not Rahul Gandhi
Depressing, 22 cr decide for 135 cr.
@@Opqrxyz 37 percent of 67 percent voter turnout of 90 cr eligible voters.
@@vishnu4234 I think he mentioned vote percentage for NDA as whole
@@045midhunsuresh3 cool... forgot the NDA side
Con party is 100% owned by a family
BJP is a public party which has many shareholders, the biggest shareholder is offcourse RSS
@sivan ok lets conclude that all these are nomited not elected. How many prominent leaders BJP have, they have Rajnath singh,Venkaiya Naidu, Nithin Gadkari, Fadnavis, Yogi... these are leaders because they tell there opinion. What's with congress.. only one Rahul and to some extend Shashi tharoor
@sivan yet it has more presidents than INC since 1991
The era of modi-shah will also be over ,the era of Gandhis will continue
SG.. Pls come out of the Congress business, we know your interest in Indian politics. But it's almost the same story again with some minor changes. Let's invest time more prudently.
"BJP has less democracy than congress".. really SG?
How was Nada posted as BJP chief???????
@@cis007ful bro JP Nadda is bound to become BJP president..look at the history of recent bjp presidents... people who work Hard in the party like Nadda,Ram Madhav, Modi,shah, gadkari,venkannaidu, Rajnath Singh etc they all came from Grassroots... Congress has to reform itself.. We need a credible opposition
@@Abhi-gx4lj JP nanda and Amit shah was "unanimously" elected, there is no election. Congress is in a mess, no doubt about that, but Consideing congress a family property, I disagree, there are a lot of parties in India which are run like a family property. The print I can see is more sliding towards right wing politics ....
@@cis007ful agree with you but right now We need to criticize Congress more and force them to change.. opposing bjp right now is of no use... Unless there's a credible opposition people will vote for bjp..all media houses are opportunistic .. they tend to go with ruling parties
@@cis007ful Scindia, Hemant Biswas, pilot ,are away from the party.. Congress has already lost mamata,pawar,Jagan,..good leaders in Congress doesn't see future or growth in Congress... courtesy Gandhi pariwar and High command culture
Real reason for delay in latest episode: they were busy taking down the delhi riots book deplatforming / cancel culture episode.
video on a letter that einstein sent to nehru
ua-cam.com/video/MXlAIVvjR78/v-deo.html
Real reason for missing yesterday's episode was figuring out the narrative for liberal left and taking the video down and reuploading it
Be real SG. We are here for the truth
Shekhar, would love to see you declutter the history of evolving West Bengal politics till recent times.
@subhadeep mandal not exactly true. WB was one of the richest Indian states today it is not in the top 10.
We need to understand West Bengal.
@@pratyushojha video on a letter that einstein sent to nehru
ua-cam.com/video/MXlAIVvjR78/v-deo.html
@@theelixirofwisdom2160 thanks.
@@pratyushojha anytime brother . please do subscribe
@Shekhaji and the print team, could you please do a CTC on what's going on in Kerala with the Gold smuggling case involving Chief minister's office.
It's got national security, NIA, the politics between the left ruling government and BJP etc in the play. Today the office where important documents for this case were stored caught fire. It's possible that it might be a case of arson.
So it would be great to get clarity on the issue.
I agree... We need a CTC on this @shekhargupta #cuttheclutter
Dear Shekhar,
Despite knowing the fact that you have a soft corner for the Congress, which has been obvious all through who has been reading you or listening to you, I thought you will cut the clutter the way you do in all other topics with unbiased analysis. I was hugely disappointed with this episode of your “cut the clutter”. Honestly, to me either you are afraid of being frank when it comes to the Congress Party or you are biased in your analysis.
I am sure, you would not have been so careful in choices of words if you had to declutter similar developments in the BJP. Are you still so afraid of the Sonia Congress?
Shekar Gupta ji, What happened?
Are U Ok?
Most unfortunate, we people are missing you a lot.
You are such a great person, great journalist, great thinker. We can't miss you. Come with double strength
6 out of 10 congress votes are by non Hindu. They are basically anti BJP votes. Even the 4 Hindu votes also be anti BJP. If some strong anti BJP leader like Kejriwal emerge on national level, there is no congress vote
Very well done. You tried your best to save Rahul's face
Look at Swamy. He challenges Modi more strongly than even RaGa. He literally calls out IT cell 😄
Gupta sir even at this stage you are not ready to leave Gandhi Family loyalty
Definition of insanity doing something over and over again but expecting different results. -
Albert Einstein
Don't worry Sg, you can take a break during the next CWC meeting as well. Just post a link to this video.
Haha. Good one.
This is not good for indian democracy "academically", but a weak congress (without any revival) good for India!!!
LOL
Without opposition any democracy will be a dictatorship
@@dwirajesh
So, what are you trying to say? Give BJP 70 years like how the country gave 70 years for congress?
Sonia should continue for 9 more months to deliver Rahul
BJP every four years president change none of them from dyanisty so how congress is comparable. In BJP no body indispensable even not Modi
What a shame!!!
You just justified the Sonia`s goondhagiri.
Slavery at it's best
basically he(SG) is one of the stooges/slave so nothing surprising.
Sir missing you for 3 days
इंतहा हो गयी इंतज़ार की
The tradition of "selection" by "high command" was started by the "original" Gandhi selecting Nehru to be PM over the democratic choice of Sardar Patel.
Even before that - Mohandas Gandhi's candidate Sitaramaiyya lost INC Presidency squarely to Subhas Bose - and MKG called Sitaramaiyya's loss his loss, and stonewalled Subhas Bose from working using the Gandhi-Nehru clique within the CWC. That was 1939, no wonder Quit India failed spectacularly in 1942, it was only British Macchiavelian policy later to plant stooges in MKG and JLN to give "Independence" after the British increasingly lost of control of the British Indian Army to Subhas Bose's INA and rebellions and mutiny became the norm. With the Germans having laid waste to Britain, Britain found a remote control puppet regime fighting with itself on sectarian lines (Partition) a better alternative than direct colonial control.
For those unfamiliar with the art of rhetoric, this piece had one major and three minor rhetorical objectives. Major objective - spread the blame, starting at the beginning of time with a laundry list of names, to shield Smt. Sonia Gandhi from charges of nepotism. Minor objective 1: To present young Mr. Gandhi in the same light as his father, thus elevating his status without explicitly saying so. Minor objective 2: To create an impression that young Mr. Gandhi's elevation to president-ship is a fait accompli. Minor objective 3: Hit some political targets in an oblique fashion, including Shri Narasimha Rao and the BJP.
This is called beating around the bush 😏
This was started by Mahatma Gandhi himself. When Subhashchandra boss got elected against Nehru.
Sir u should stop doing episodes on Congress party,the same drama Everytime it's too boring.
Suggestion: please do a live chat once every month.
All of us have many questions ranging scores of topics. Why wait for 500th episode or a birthday, please have it once a month.
Hi Mohit. Thank you for the suggestion. Do keep tuning in daily.
To be fair to Rahul, he wants the entire outdated 70 yrs+ old guard nominated posts gang to retire gracefully & be replaced by fresh young blood. But the old guard refuses to withdraw gracefully & tries to stage manage such "revolts" to perpetuate the privileges they are enjoying.
Year : 2021
CTC episode: 850
Some in comments section: Waiting to hear about bangalore riots
Dear Print team.. i am waiting for cut the clutter like a drug addict waiting for a fix. I hope shekhar is doing fine... regards from Australia
oh we love the entertainment, they are so talented, they should upgrade them selves from clowns to full time comedians ......
@ShekarGupta- are you ok, worried about your health🙏🏻🙏🏻. haven’t seen CTC or National Interest over the weekend which has been unusual.
A left wing party with a conservative approach😂😂..Congress is in shambles now..
One of the few channels in India, for unbiased and authentic news. Shekhar Sir is such a legend.
We missed your speech yesterday. Everyday is a learning process with cut the clutter
Dear Sir,
Are you not uploading episodes of cut the clutter? No episodes from last two days (30/08/2020 and 31/08/2020)
Congress is not India's Destiny. Pappu Pinki Antonio.. who cares anymore..
Thank you SG for your overnight (sleeping over) analysis to cut the clutter. Very well presented and informative. Congress the Brand - franchise that the Gandhi's own vis-a-vis other stalwarts/ leaders !
Couldn't sleep properly yesterday because of no CTC, especially when it was clear what you will be talking.
Finally the wait is over...Cut the Clutter is back. Even a one day gap was difficult to handle...
We should not forget how Nehru was selected and not elected. Internal democracy in Congress died at that time
Why did you take couple of days break
Blame the "ORIGINAL GANDHI's" not the Mahatma "GANDI"! Who really is original Gandhi?
ADVANCE HAPPY BIRTHDAY GUPTA JI💓💓⚓🥮🥮🥮🍰🍰🎉🎉
#cut the clutter ,💞
I was waiting for this!!!
Really?
Hi. Thanks for tuning in.
@@ilandhiraiyannedunjeralaad7730 yes,SG has a dispassionate way of delivering the news.
So I value his inputs,more than what the rest of the circus performs.
@@NehaPadhi He is better than the circus, yes. But, completely dispassionate? I don't think so.
Forgive my inability to agree with you.
@@ilandhiraiyannedunjeralaad7730 It is impossible for any human to be completely dispassionate,we all have our inherent biases of course!
Discussing democracy of the whole country is worthwhile rather than the internal democracy of political parties.
Make Capt Amrinder Singh the cwc president and give him full authority .
I agree Capt Amrinder is good leader
Shasi Tharoor is a good option
sreenath sasidharan nah image m
👏🏻always a great talk by shekhar ji
After hearing todays ctc , I feel SG shd retire, he has even forgotten who is the original Gandhi....
Thank you SG for acknowledgement of the power of dalit card. I have nothing against dalits or any minority for that matter but I am saying this with my personal experience that whenever I m having a discussion with my dalit friends and in the end if they don't have anything to argue the only thing they say is "we were oppressed for ages" and that goes unchanged.
Let me declutter on my side :---
Whenever sonia feels that her dynasty in danger she herself calls out this rogue Congress working committee members to opposed her !!!! How many times she does this still people of India want to believe her and the family!!! for the sake of God please spare me on this 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Rahul might be dim witted but he is the true heir to the congress party. And nobody can take that away from him 😉
Nehru vs Bose?
Nehru vs Patel?
MG was the original dictator, there was never any democracy in Congress
9:11 India has failed to know about an honest politician called K Kamaraj.. Probably among the most powerful as well as Honest politician of this country! Do read abt him
Sir, please do a ctc on today’s Supreme Court hearing on contempt case, your analysis will clear lot of clutter
Thanks for the suggestion.
You have given a solid explanation of working of the Grand Old Party.. It is like a lesson in history. Kudos to you for making history extremely interesting.
Why everything bad traces back it's origin to Ms. Gandhi.
There are two three group 1) old man group 2) Middle aged group 3) Young group. Currently Oldman group do not want any internal democracy , they just want to relax and enjoy the current situation . They are not at all interested in forming Govt
Why do u waste so much time in stories of Congress party. Let this party finish in its own way. I am waiting 2024 LS election. Expecting Historical defeat.
Because Mr. Gupta ne namak khaya since long. Kya kare
I was waiting for this video's 🙏
You do least biased journalism in world of Indian journalism
You are critical of left when the are wrong and praise the left when they are right
You are critical of right when the are wrong and praise the right when they are right
Same for the center
Best journalist so far 😅
The most boring episode of cut the clutter!
LOL .. how can people be still loyal to a family 🤣
Brilliant analysis yet again .... I wait eagerly each evening for your episodes . Makes my day ! Thank you as always .
Sir why are you not discussing coronavirus from many days.
Shekhar Gupta ji you are brilliant
It is obvious how difficult he tries to somehow make a point that this high-command undemocratic DNA is not part of Sonia Gandhi family but a congress culture. However to sound genuine he just mentions that ofcourse this DNA was planted by Indira Gandhi.
It does not matter how many times it happens, people like Shekar Gupta will always try to defend sonia gandhi family. But how much ever he tries to sound genuine it is so obvious that he is not.
150 years old party not having one single credible leader 😀😀😀
A very well deserved break SG :)
You’re allowed 2 breaks a week provided you make CTC 45+ mins and cover multiple topics 😬😬
As someone commented of the Court loyalists, "Like frightened children, senior Congress leaders old enough to have grand children and great-grand children of their own, tug on the Great Mother's hand, begging to please, please not abandon them."
When do you think bjp will think about economy as a issue
Or will they never take it as a issue?
I run textile industry
In last ten year i have never seen so many people asking for labour work
It used to be other way around
So yes things are not going well
The kind of industry i am in, i get to see things very quickly
From 2019 i started seeing things getting bed.
Not just for me but here at my town balotra in Rajasthan 2000 units
Mr. Garg... Rajasthan has a state government as well ... Do you expect them to do anything to for local industries ?? Or we have them just for timepass ??
CTC has become an essential morning fix along with my cup of coffee. One day break seems like something amiss in my routine. Glad to see CTC back.
Baat baat mai prashant bhushan ko b keech liye 😂
Shri.Sekar Guptajee don't say nothing happened in Congress meeting. Sonia told heself resigned as President of Congress to her; told to elect new leader and retained the President for 6 more months.
Can you please declutter the happenings in Kerala
Very cheekily states "BJP's supposed democracy"... but no one can tell you who will be next BJP Party President & here we ahve whole 25 min episode telling who will be Congress President for Decades to come :D
For people saying there is an internal democracy in BJP.
There is a difference between Election and Selection. Democracy (internal or external) has an election process to it. BJP has a selection process. Democracy and elections are not mutually exclusive.
Greeks will revolt to this statement.
Asking a few leaders for their opinion is a Selection process. Like Monarchs used to be. That is no democracy. Asking EVERYONE in a systematic process(votiing) IS. That is the DEMO in Democracy.
It is widely known BJP doesn't have an internal democracy. But they are okay with it.
Not a Congressi just against misinformation.
Though it is a selection, any xyz can still hope to be a party president or PM candidate someday. Atleast there is some reward for a performer. Point is there is no hope for a young leader in congress no matter what how much he works for them, while a young leader in BJP can dream of being a PM one day.
@@srichan7498 XYZ - { Muslim, Christian, Leftist Ideologue } can hope to be a party president or PM candidate someday.
Shekarji taking a day or a two off is absolutely fine. We understand and appreciate your efforts. Keep ur health a top priority and keep us enlightened through ur videos :)
Long story short...Congress party is Dalda 😂😂
I am amazed by this beautiful coincidence that whenever anything important occurs, SG happens to be present in the vicinity 😁
Perfectly ok to take a break 👍, need to come out of daily soap viewer's mode.