I'm a huge fan of your brothers vlogs "the shaytards" and discovered him and your family when I was pregnant and alone a lot so I watched his videos so much to the point where my now three year old son runs into the room when I'm watching his vlogs now and had to watch with me. He's listened to shays and collettes voice more then his own dads...lol. I always wondered about you and seen copper in a few shows. He's adorable by the way! I found this video while looking up other things and can relate to your experience. I got married young. Had a baby young and am now getting divorced. His father left us when he was 11 months old and it was such a hard time. We're now just starting to rebuild the bricks and start over. Trying to be friends with his dad after all the pain he caused is hard...but we're doing our best for Bentley...he's a beautiful blessing. Anyways! I just wanted to say thank you for making this video and to your family for being such a great laugh on a bad day and a word of wisdom and guidence when life throws you a struggle! Yall are awesome!!!!
I think it's amazing how respectful you are when speaking about Cooper's father, recognising that he is a good father to Cooper. Not many parents will be civil with each other it's definitely an admirable quality to have which I'm sure Cooper will appreciate very much as he gets older. Good on you Carlie!
Why did she not mention that she was like 8 months pregnant when she married Cristian? My mom was pregnant with me when she and my dad got married. (Granted they had been engaged a while before they found out they were expecting.) It's not a big deal, and it's part of their story.
The Cuz Club she or Shay has showed wedding photos and she's super pregnant in her wedding dress. She has talked about it before after this and was a lot more candid.
It's really not that important to mention it. I'm guessing the reason she didn't was because the youtube comment section is super judgemental and lots of people would probably be like "oh that's against her religion to have sex before marriage she's a bad person blah blah blah" Also, keep in mind this video was made 5 years ago, at that point she may not have shared it yet and she might not have been as comfortable with sharing stuff like that because many people do think it shouldn't be encouraged before marriage. Also, you said it yourself, it's not a big deal so why does it matter whether she shares it or not.
I still remember your first UA-cam vids with Cooper. You were so proud of him, and you were camera shy, like me. Now your a superhero to the cameras and they all love you, like me.
You know what I loved about this? How raw it was. She wasn't being silly or goofy like she normally is. We saw another side of Carlie in this video, and I think that was the point, and she succeeded. I'm so happy she shared a part of her story with us. She didn't have to, it's none of our business, but she did anyway. She did it with maturity and tact. She didn't bad mouth anyone. this isn't something that Cooper can look at later in life and judge his mom or dad for. Good job, Carlie.
Since watching your channel my repect level for you has increased so much...I didnt realise how thoughtful and and indepth you actually are. Thankyou so much for sharing this and starting this channel up because you really are such a lovely and beautiful person!
seeing this now and realizing how far you've come and funky yet grown up you are and how happy you are with your life now and blessed with everything - I'm just sooo happy for you. all the very best, always my dear💖
Love you! Hope you still find what you are looking for! You are an awesome mother and you are soo lucky to have the support and love that your family provides for you!
I'm glad Cooper still has a relationship with his dad. My parents divorced when I was around the same age, and moved to different provinces, so I spent the summers with my dad and the school year with my mom, sometimes the other way around. Divorced parents isn't the end of the world by any means! Glad you guys worked it out and Cooper has a strong relationship with both of you. Love you Carlie! xo
carlie, it means a lot for you to open up & share such a personal story with us. you're a very strong woman, and we really appreciate that you make great videos!
Cooper is so lucky to have a mother like you. Its good that your X and you can stay friends. Thanks for sharing your story. Have a great Christmas and who knows whats there for you in the new year. Only good I know.
Did you guys know that Cooper's father's name is Christian. I saw his twitter and his profile picture was him and cooper his twitter name is @batting4myboy
Carlie I'm sorry if I'm invading your privacy. If you are ok with the other people knowing then feel free to keep this comment on this video. If you are uncomfortable with other people knowing this without your permission then feel free to delete this comment. I'm truly sorry if you are not ok with this
***** i don't think she cares bc a lot of people already know i've seen people mention his name on the shaytards channel a lot and it doesnt seem like she's trying to hide who he is. it would be weird for her to mention his name in this video but i don't think she cares
It's real life and the sucky part of real life. If fighting is all it is then get counseling, cheating and abuse get out. That is what the Bible says. This is for young people that give up too easily these days, not you specifically Carlie, your explanation (as if one was needed) is perfect, one day your son will be searching and seeing everything you've put out there. No matter how horrible their father is or was, it's harmful for a child to hear about it. Badmouthing is for privacy with close friends who will help you deal with the pain. Take if from this vlog on how to speak of your ex, this way, and only this way, is classy.
I don't really have much else to add that anybody in these comments hasn't already said. I just wanted to send you more love and support because you are amazing. Not many people would be able to find the strength to put their whole past out there for a bunch of strangers to see, but you handle everything with such grace! You Go Glenn Coco!
I want to give you a hug just because you're a strong woman and you love us all so much that you were willing to share your personal life with us. We love you Carlie :')
I actually love your honesty and bravery! Made me tear up. You are so strong and I am genuinely happy that you are happy. Cooper is adorable and you have a wonderful family.
Thanks for sharing your story. There are quite a lot of families out there who have been through the same thing. So I am glad you decided to put it out there!
What I am glad to see is that both parents are involved in making Cooper a good man. A boy needs both parents and loving families even if the parents split up. Thanks for sharing, I knew it must of taken some courage especially after your first try at You Tube a while ago.
Nothing but respect for you Carlie :) Life does happen and you just have to go along with it. Though you don't 'owe' us anything - It is appreciated that you shared that side of your life with us and the question can stopped being asked. Tons of love to you and Cooper!!
Thanks for sharing Carlie! I think it's admirable that you can talk about it like that and say positive thing. My parents are divorced and what I hate the most is when they try to sneak in negative comment about the other one in our conversation like they "had to"....
Carlie, it really means a lot that you opened up to us like this. It takes a lot of trust and courage to do so, and you showed that really well through this video. It's nice to know that you love us like we love you♥ I wish you the best with Cooper and everything you two do!!
Carlie you are a wonderful mother and a great woman. You are very strong to talk about this private part of your life with us. We all respect you and support you. Everyone as a story behind them, that's what make us stronger. Thank you for sharing a little part of your life with us. Cooper is lucky to have you.
Well done Carlie! That can't have been the easiest thing in the world to share. You're so brave and an inspiration really - it's obvious you're a great mom to Cooper and a great sister and aunt as well.
I'm glad you finally came out with this video. I've been curious on the story for a while, and wanted to hear it whenever you were ready and if you wanted to share it at all. For the people beeing negative, enjoy yourself, you ain't getting much out of it. Thank you, Carlie!
props to you for being brave enough to share this with us, I always admire you and your personality! ps. Cooper is my favorite person in your whole family! love to see him more in the videos
There are probably many many many other people in the same situation as you, so you shouldn't have been nervous! Thank you for being honest and sharing!
Carlie, I think you're a fantastic mother. You've done an immaculate job with raising Cooper, and I think you should be 100% proud of yourself. He's such a beautiful little boy, with those big blue eyes and adorable smile. So many kids would give anything to have a mother like you. Keep doing what you're doing, honey, because I promise you God's gonna bless you more than you know for what you do.
Carlie, thank-you so much for sharing your story with us, I know it wasn't easy for you. I'm a big Shaytards fan and I've heard you mention concerns about UA-cam comments in the past. I'm so happy that you've been able to put the crazies aside and be true to yourself. You're such a great mom and Cooper is such a beautiful little boy. I look forward to watching the two of you grow over the next few years. Thanks again for sharing your story! There are many of us out there cheering you on :)
Sweet Carlie---Thank you for sharing a piece of your life. Never think you have to though. Nosey fans can mind their own business. We love you exactly where you are today. You are the most beautiful women inside and outside. Cooper is just tooooo cute. You are very blessed. God bless you both--and also ALL you love!! you have to share things cause weirdo's where you down. Love you Carlie--from a true fan forever. My wish this year is to be a grandma like your mom someday soon.
All this time I though Coppers dad was a jerk and just left. Glad to know that he is still part of his life. It is encouraging to know that despite what you have gone through you still are a great mother. So stay strong and be yourself and the rest will do itself
So glad you are clearing everything up. I have found that people will imagine far worse than the actual truth if left on their own. Although, sometimes it's none of their business.
Thank you so much Carlie for telling this story. It really means that you trust us and I mean just care about our questions and I love you for doing that thx
I just wanted to say that you are such a strong person and I really look up to you Carlie(: I'm 16 and hope to grow up and be as amazing of a mom as you, you're a great role model. Also when you sent my friend kimmi that nice tweet on twitter yesterday and followed me on tumblr last month that REALLY means A LOT to me so THANK YOU
You are so right! My parents divorced when I was 16 and they should've way before that. I witnessed a lot of verbal abuse to my mom that I shouldn't have as a child. You should be proud that you are such a wonderful mommy!
Thank you SO much for sharing Carlie. I grew up in a house where us kids would've been much better off if my parents had separated, so I just wanted to encourage you in your decision. Again, THANK YOU so much for being open with us, and we're here to support you in every step of your journey! :) Merry Christmas!
thank you for sharing this part of your life with us Carlie - Hopefully this will bring you peace and it will be easier to just move on and be you... the Carlie we all have grown to love!!!
We love you so much Carlie :) All we went is for you to be happy and you have an amazing family who is there for you. Glad we could all be here to help you along!
Carlie! You are amazingly courageous! It is a very hard thing to decide to put your son's happiness before you own and to accept that we aren't perfect and that our couple isn't perfect. You should feel prod ouf yourself for being such a wonderful mother!
I think we've all been waiting for this video ever since you got this channel up and running; I don't know about anyone else, but I think it's amazing that you found the courage to share such an intimate part of your life with the people who support you on youtube. Well done Carlie! I love your videos and you, of course! I didn't think it was possible to love you any more, but this video has just proved that I can. Can't wait for more videos - you're amazing
Awww thanks for sharing your story with us! It's also nice to hear that Cooper's dad is still in his life because I know what its like to not have a father figure in your life and its not always great. Love you Carlie and Cooper ;))
fantastic of you to share this. I am a young single mom as well and I can relate to everything you're saying, it's nice hearing someone else's story, thanks a lot, keep on doing what you're doing it has a great deal of meaning to me and a lot of other people
I know to you, we might seem like just the people on the Internet that watch your videos now and then, but I just wanted you to know that i think you are an amazing person. Thank you so much for sharing your story with us. I hope one day I can be as good a mother as you to my children. :) Love your videoss
Carlie, you're amazing. End of story. -3 you are a great mother and it's good to know Coopers dad is involved and that you are able to give Cooper the best life possible.
Thank you for sharing your story. I think a lot of people can relate, these days 2/3 of the US population come from broken homes, so we understand where you're coming from. You're such a beautiful person, someday you'll meet the guy who's right for you!
this made me cry because when you were describing your feelings you had for your ex. I know what you mean when you said about the movie thing and loving him so much because I loved like that once. I only hope you love again and not be like me closed off to it because you are still young and very beautiful. you and coop deserve someone special in your lives together. I dont mean that in a disrespectful way to his dad because he can never be replaced but you all derserve love in your lives.
Who would LEAVE her? She is BEAUTIFUL, FUNNY AND OUTGOING!
so agree
He didnt just leave her didnt you listen at all she said that they faught alot and that it wasnt working it was a mutual decision
..And five years later you are married and Cooper is very happy about it.
Exactly what I was going to comment 😱😝
and pregnant!!
Eva Lynn and now has elliot
Cooper is such an adorable boy! The bond you share with him is so sweet!
Love you Carlie, from one mother to another your doing a wonderful job your little boy is a true representation of you and the mother you are.
I'm a huge fan of your brothers vlogs "the shaytards" and discovered him and your family when I was pregnant and alone a lot so I watched his videos so much to the point where my now three year old son runs into the room when I'm watching his vlogs now and had to watch with me. He's listened to shays and collettes voice more then his own dads...lol. I always wondered about you and seen copper in a few shows. He's adorable by the way!
I found this video while looking up other things and can relate to your experience. I got married young. Had a baby young and am now getting divorced. His father left us when he was 11 months old and it was such a hard time. We're now just starting to rebuild the bricks and start over. Trying to be friends with his dad after all the pain he caused is hard...but we're doing our best for Bentley...he's a beautiful blessing.
Anyways! I just wanted to say thank you for making this video and to your family for being such a great laugh on a bad day and a word of wisdom and guidence when life throws you a struggle! Yall are awesome!!!!
I think it's amazing how respectful you are when speaking about Cooper's father, recognising that he is a good father to Cooper. Not many parents will be civil with each other it's definitely an admirable quality to have which I'm sure Cooper will appreciate very much as he gets older. Good on you Carlie!
I always wondered about this! Happy I found this video. Thank you for sharing!
And now she just got married to Jackson Wood!!!! Amazing!
I come from a home of a single mother and I understand the struggles you're going through. I think you're brave and a great mom.
Why did she not mention that she was like 8 months pregnant when she married Cristian? My mom was pregnant with me when she and my dad got married. (Granted they had been engaged a while before they found out they were expecting.) It's not a big deal, and it's part of their story.
How do you know that??
The Cuz Club she or Shay has showed wedding photos and she's super pregnant in her wedding dress. She has talked about it before after this and was a lot more candid.
jacquiebrownjb OH,thanks
It's really not that important to mention it.
I'm guessing the reason she didn't was because the youtube comment section is super judgemental and lots of people would probably be like "oh that's against her religion to have sex before marriage she's a bad person blah blah blah"
Also, keep in mind this video was made 5 years ago, at that point she may not have shared it yet and she might not have been as comfortable with sharing stuff like that because many people do think it shouldn't be encouraged before marriage.
Also, you said it yourself, it's not a big deal so why does it matter whether she shares it or not.
I still remember your first UA-cam vids with Cooper. You were so proud of him, and you were camera shy, like me. Now your a superhero to the cameras and they all love you, like me.
so happy you have cooper because he is SO CUTE! thanks for sharing
He's a treasure.
Carlie I am also LDS & have a child, unfortunately mine was out of wedlock, but just watching your story and how you're growing really makes me happy.
woah, carlie looks like logan here!
there brother an sister
i know that xD
That is soooooo true
What you meant to say is that Logan looks like Carlie. She's older than he is
nope, not what i meant to say. i didnt meant they look similar in general, just that she looked like him in this..
You know what I loved about this? How raw it was. She wasn't being silly or goofy like she normally is. We saw another side of Carlie in this video, and I think that was the point, and she succeeded. I'm so happy she shared a part of her story with us. She didn't have to, it's none of our business, but she did anyway. She did it with maturity and tact. She didn't bad mouth anyone. this isn't something that Cooper can look at later in life and judge his mom or dad for. Good job, Carlie.
that sucks i think thats probably the scariest part of getting married
Since watching your channel my repect level for you has increased so much...I didnt realise how thoughtful and and indepth you actually are. Thankyou so much for sharing this and starting this channel up because you really are such a lovely and beautiful person!
Carlie you're amazing
+Lopez shutup carlie is amazing
***** Fucked up
It's rare to come across beautiful, well-spoken, and educated women these days. Props to you for being just that.
Who is watching in 2016
Grace Hagerman me
Grace Hagerman me
SomeReal Nonsense 2017 😁
seeing this now and realizing how far you've come and funky yet grown up you are and how happy you are with your life now and blessed with everything - I'm just sooo happy for you. all the very best, always my dear💖
Answered all my questions.. btw I didn't think you were lesbian.
+Alishia .L i wasn't saying she was.
Thank you so much for sharing you life with us! We love and support you Carlie!
6 years later your happily married and having another baby and it's a boy
Love you! Hope you still find what you are looking for! You are an awesome mother and you are soo lucky to have the support and love that your family provides for you!
Lol this just came up in my suggestions, so funny! You look 18!
I'm glad Cooper still has a relationship with his dad. My parents divorced when I was around the same age, and moved to different provinces, so I spent the summers with my dad and the school year with my mom, sometimes the other way around. Divorced parents isn't the end of the world by any means! Glad you guys worked it out and Cooper has a strong relationship with both of you. Love you Carlie! xo
Anyone else watch shaytard and bratayley
I do
Me
carlie, it means a lot for you to open up & share such a personal story with us. you're a very strong woman, and we really appreciate that you make great videos!
Is there a vlog where he comes out in?? Either on the shaytards channel or here
The first ever video on the shaycarl channel showed Shay, Casey and her husband (back then) on helium
Cooper is so lucky to have a mother like you. Its good that your X and you can stay friends. Thanks for sharing your story. Have a great Christmas and who knows whats there for you in the new year.
Only good I know.
#TEAMSTEVECOOK
Cooper is lucky to have a wonderful Mother like you!
Did you guys know that Cooper's father's name is Christian. I saw his twitter and his profile picture was him and cooper his twitter name is @batting4myboy
Carlie I'm sorry if I'm invading your privacy. If you are ok with the other people knowing then feel free to keep this comment on this video. If you are uncomfortable with other people knowing this without your permission then feel free to delete this comment. I'm truly sorry if you are not ok with this
Saranggan T
If she was ok with it she would have released the information herself. -_-
True. That was a stupid move of me.
Well, your not Carlie. I would like her to ask me. I know I said it was a stupid move but doesn't mean I should delete it on you behalf.
***** i don't think she cares bc a lot of people already know i've seen people mention his name on the shaytards channel a lot and it doesnt seem like she's trying to hide who he is. it would be weird for her to mention his name in this video but i don't think she cares
Fantastic of you to put it out there Carlie. Coop is very lucky to have such a caring Mum like you.
She looks so much like Logan in this video!
That's because they're siblings.
I know that I am just saying she looks a lot more like Logan in this video than she usually does.
Actually logan would look like her because she is older than him
Thank you for sharing coopers life with us I love you
cooper looks like steve
Carlie thank you so much for sharing a little bit of your life... You're such a wonderful woman and a awesome mom.
It's real life and the sucky part of real life. If fighting is all it is then get counseling, cheating and abuse get out. That is what the Bible says. This is for young people that give up too easily these days, not you specifically Carlie, your explanation (as if one was needed) is perfect, one day your son will be searching and seeing everything you've put out there. No matter how horrible their father is or was, it's harmful for a child to hear about it. Badmouthing is for privacy with close friends who will help you deal with the pain. Take if from this vlog on how to speak of your ex, this way, and only this way, is classy.
I don't really have much else to add that anybody in these comments hasn't already said. I just wanted to send you more love and support because you are amazing. Not many people would be able to find the strength to put their whole past out there for a bunch of strangers to see, but you handle everything with such grace! You Go Glenn Coco!
yes and now you have Steve :P
SCUBA STEVE!!!
And now she has Jackson
Ms Alneaimi and now they're getting married :3
+grapefruit1992 and now they are almost married for a month
Eliza Ramirez and now she has elliot
it must have taken a lot for you to share something so personal. we're rooting for you Carlie. Cooper is adorable.
Marry Steve and have more butler babies!!!!!!!!! 😝😝😝😝😝😝 I'm just messing with you take your time and when it's right it will happen!
I want to give you a hug just because you're a strong woman and you love us all so much that you were willing to share your personal life with us. We love you Carlie :')
Is it just me or are Carlie's eyebrows uneven?
I think it's just you
Obah Farah They're just natural. You can see her real hair. They're really nice.
+JJ Thunder wtf
+Obah Farah we al have bad eyebrow days...
+Obah Farah Why does that matter..?
I actually love your honesty and bravery! Made me tear up. You are so strong and I am genuinely happy that you are happy. Cooper is adorable and you have a wonderful family.
if she didn't get a divorce, she's still maried (technically)
Yeah but she did so she's not 😛 😉
She said we DID get a divorce.
Thank you Carlie for sharing your story, you are a wonderful mother and Cooper looks really happy and loved! You rock!
Thanks for sharing your story. There are quite a lot of families out there who have been through the same thing. So I am glad you decided to put it out there!
What I am glad to see is that both parents are involved in making Cooper a good man. A boy needs both parents and loving families even if the parents split up. Thanks for sharing, I knew it must of taken some courage especially after your first try at You Tube a while ago.
Thank you for being brave in sharing your past. I really wish you all the best for your future. Cooper is lucky to have you as his mother.
Nothing but respect for you Carlie :) Life does happen and you just have to go along with it. Though you don't 'owe' us anything - It is appreciated that you shared that side of your life with us and the question can stopped being asked. Tons of love to you and Cooper!!
Thanks for sharing Carlie! I think it's admirable that you can talk about it like that and say positive thing. My parents are divorced and what I hate the most is when they try to sneak in negative comment about the other one in our conversation like they "had to"....
Carlie, it really means a lot that you opened up to us like this. It takes a lot of trust and courage to do so, and you showed that really well through this video. It's nice to know that you love us like we love you♥ I wish you the best with Cooper and everything you two do!!
Carlie you are a wonderful mother and a great woman. You are very strong to talk about this private part of your life with us. We all respect you and support you. Everyone as a story behind them, that's what make us stronger. Thank you for sharing a little part of your life with us. Cooper is lucky to have you.
I'm glad you feel comfortable sharing this with people.. not everyone is rude and immature
Well done Carlie! That can't have been the easiest thing in the world to share. You're so brave and an inspiration really - it's obvious you're a great mom to Cooper and a great sister and aunt as well.
I'm glad you finally came out with this video. I've been curious on the story for a while, and wanted to hear it whenever you were ready and if you wanted to share it at all. For the people beeing negative, enjoy yourself, you ain't getting much out of it. Thank you, Carlie!
props to you for being brave enough to share this with us, I always admire you and your personality!
ps. Cooper is my favorite person in your whole family! love to see him more in the videos
as a single mom too I can totally relate to what your saying . Thank you for sharing
There are probably many many many other people in the same situation as you, so you shouldn't have been nervous! Thank you for being honest and sharing!
Carlie, I think you're a fantastic mother. You've done an immaculate job with raising Cooper, and I think you should be 100% proud of yourself. He's such a beautiful little boy, with those big blue eyes and adorable smile. So many kids would give anything to have a mother like you. Keep doing what you're doing, honey, because I promise you God's gonna bless you more than you know for what you do.
Carlie, thank-you so much for sharing your story with us, I know it wasn't easy for you. I'm a big Shaytards fan and I've heard you mention concerns about UA-cam comments in the past. I'm so happy that you've been able to put the crazies aside and be true to yourself. You're such a great mom and Cooper is such a beautiful little boy. I look forward to watching the two of you grow over the next few years. Thanks again for sharing your story! There are many of us out there cheering you on :)
Carlie... Thank you so much for your candor and honesty... Love ya!
This just make me love Carlie even more! Just the fact that she wanted to share her life with us! I love u!
Thanks for opening your heart to us!! Cooper is blessed to have you as his mom! Good luck with your new chapters!
Sweet Carlie---Thank you for sharing a piece of your life. Never think you have to though.
Nosey fans can mind their own business. We love you exactly where you are today. You
are the most beautiful women inside and outside. Cooper is just tooooo cute. You are very
blessed. God bless you both--and also ALL you love!!
you have to share things cause weirdo's where you down. Love you Carlie--from a true fan forever. My wish this year is to be a grandma like your mom someday soon.
Thanks for sharing--who cares what other people say or think. You are brave and it is great you are taking a leap of faith in CA
All this time I though Coppers dad was a jerk and just left. Glad to know that he is still part of his life. It is encouraging to know that despite what you have gone through you still are a great mother. So stay strong and be yourself and the rest will do itself
no i have even more respect for you carlie!! you are a very strong woman and that's something you don't see enough these days!
you are such a wonderful mom no matter what! so proud and inspired!
So glad you are clearing everything up. I have found that people will imagine far worse than the actual truth if left on their own. Although, sometimes it's none of their business.
Thank you so much Carlie for telling this story. It really means that you trust us and I mean just care about our questions and I love you for doing that thx
I just wanted to say that you are such a strong person and I really look up to you Carlie(: I'm 16 and hope to grow up and be as amazing of a mom as you, you're a great role model. Also when you sent my friend kimmi that nice tweet on twitter yesterday and followed me on tumblr last month that REALLY means A LOT to me so THANK YOU
Thank You Carlie for finally sharing this story with us. It made my day.
Aw Carlie, we love you. Thanks for sharing this with us.
Thank you for putting this video up, I know how hard it is to admit something like that, but I'm proud of you for stepping out of your comfort zone!
You are so right! My parents divorced when I was 16 and they should've way before that. I witnessed a lot of verbal abuse to my mom that I shouldn't have as a child. You should be proud that you are such a wonderful mommy!
awww how sweet of you to make this video for everyone. You're so lovely and Cooper is very lucky he has a mummy like you xx
Thank you SO much for sharing Carlie. I grew up in a house where us kids would've been much better off if my parents had separated, so I just wanted to encourage you in your decision. Again, THANK YOU so much for being open with us, and we're here to support you in every step of your journey! :) Merry Christmas!
thank you for sharing! It's not an easy subject to talk about I'm sure especially in front of thousands of people, but we appreciate your honesty!
thank you for sharing this part of your life with us Carlie - Hopefully this will bring you peace and it will be easier to just move on and be you... the Carlie we all have grown to love!!!
Carlie, thank you for sharing this to us. You're really brave and strong. Sending lots of love to you and your family!
We love you so much Carlie :) All we went is for you to be happy and you have an amazing family who is there for you. Glad we could all be here to help you along!
That's brave, and from now on people should respect her and do not bother her with the same questions
Carlie! You are amazingly courageous! It is a very hard thing to decide to put your son's happiness before you own and to accept that we aren't perfect and that our couple isn't perfect. You should feel prod ouf yourself for being such a wonderful mother!
thanks for sharing your life carlie..this is really very brave of you to share it....stay strong..
I think we've all been waiting for this video ever since you got this channel up and running; I don't know about anyone else, but I think it's amazing that you found the courage to share such an intimate part of your life with the people who support you on youtube. Well done Carlie! I love your videos and you, of course! I didn't think it was possible to love you any more, but this video has just proved that I can. Can't wait for more videos - you're amazing
Thanks for sharing! I did wonder about this. Glad Cooper stays close to his dad despite you moving to Cali.
Carly you rock!! I'm glad you finally mentioned him, but I'm glad you feel comfortable talking about him to us. Thanks for letting us know!
Thanks so much for sharing -3 you are a great mommy. You have proved yourself to be very stong when dealing with hard times.
Awww thanks for sharing your story with us! It's also nice to hear that Cooper's dad is still in his life because I know what its like to not have a father figure in your life and its not always great. Love you Carlie and Cooper ;))
fantastic of you to share this. I am a young single mom as well and I can relate to everything you're saying, it's nice hearing someone else's story, thanks a lot, keep on doing what you're doing it has a great deal of meaning to me and a lot of other people
I know to you, we might seem like just the people on the Internet that watch your videos now and then, but I just wanted you to know that i think you are an amazing person. Thank you so much for sharing your story with us. I hope one day I can be as good a mother as you to my children. :)
Love your videoss
Thank you Carlie!!! We love you!!! Remember that your story is helping others dealing with the same things too
Carlie, you're amazing. End of story. -3 you are a great mother and it's good to know Coopers dad is involved and that you are able to give Cooper the best life possible.
TY for being so generous. I am glad it helps you close a chapter in your life. That is a big thing.
=) Sincerly, Mélanie xxx
Thank you for sharing your story. I think a lot of people can relate, these days 2/3 of the US population come from broken homes, so we understand where you're coming from. You're such a beautiful person, someday you'll meet the guy who's right for you!
Its nice that you feel so comfortable sharing with us now, and a side note your hair and make look amazing in the video
this made me cry because when you were describing your feelings you had for your ex. I know what you mean when you said about the movie thing and loving him so much because I loved like that once. I only hope you love again and not be like me closed off to it because you are still young and very beautiful. you and coop deserve someone special in your lives together. I dont mean that in a disrespectful way to his dad because he can never be replaced but you all derserve love in your lives.