I dont think u know what a MIDI actually is to be that disrespectful towards the original soundtrack that I actually have no emotioanl attachement to but still feel u discredit it for that.
I personally enjoyed the remastered version; when I played the original Final Fantasy X, THAT's how the song sounded in my head. People bitch about a lot, but there are actually a lot of games much worse than this one in the bad remasters category. Ignorance is bliss.
Original has something of a rhythm to it the arranged just kind of smooths over with this attempt at an epic sound that I think honestly is going to get a little tiring after a while, this is standard battle music after all and you hear this a lot in the course of one playthrough. I prefer to hear a snappy rhythm that I can groove to than get bombarded with music that’s constantly trying to be epic.
The sounds used in the original makes so much the personnality of FFX. Whitout it, it's not the same ! I played on PS3 the remaster and some songs are really good (Besaid theme, love it), but overall, the original sounds better and unique. Will probably buy it on switch now to replay the remaster with the original sountrack haha.
Well I don't know how I feel. because I played final fantasy x about a month or two before the HD remasters came out and enjoyed it then but I just bought the HD remaster for my vita and I love that too... I feel like this is what cheating feels like
As someone who is really new to JRPG’s. I started with Persona 5 Royal. I’m so happy I finally got to into Final Fantasy. I tried with 7 but it couldn’t grip me as much as 10 has so far. The arranged version goes really well with the visuals going on but original is still better for me
I hope you can give 7 another try! It was my first every FF and it's a clear favorite with the cast, music, themes, etc but even so it unironically took my 7 years to beat and I've always stopped at different points on several devices (mobile, steam, Kindle, Nintendo Switch, etc)
I know I'm very late to the party, but I've been occasionally gettin nostalgic to replay old FF games, Replayed 6 7 and 8 recently, need to finish 9, and I may do 10 and I have some contrasting opinions about the remaster music with FF6 vs FF10. I think FF6's remastered music is GREAT and faithful with selective additions to the songs to fill out where needed. Like the extra voice in Dancing Mad's first movement. I feel like FF10's remaster music went overboard. It's way too busy on some of the themes. The originals are a lot clearer and I feel have a bit more 'character' to it, where as the remaster added too many layers of extra 'epic' orchestration, which start to wash out a lot of the theme's core elements, particularly the bass instruments. I'm the type of person that like zoning into each instrument line to focus-listen to each one. The remaster is often muddy it's a lot harder to do that.
I finally got around to playing through FFX. I gotta say I prefer the new arrangement, except for the main battle theme. It just sorta "kicks" more in the original, if that makes any sense.
You have to be absolutely deaf or nostalgic if you prefer the original over the arranged... The ride cymbals in the second part of the original are so prominent precisely because the middle high spectrum needs to be filled with something... In the arranged that isn't neccesary because the song is an aural fest since the begining, although rides are there, subtly inserted into a mix that is finally proper audio and not just music info. I was recently finishing the HD remaster and I didn't recall battle theme being that good, even moving me to tears, so then I learned the music was arranged... And thankfully so! Also the added guitar parts absolutely rock and the toms from the drums are now the memorable part from percussion. Absolutely ADORE the arranged music and certainly takes the quality of the game to a new level.
Arranged soundtrack was engineered by a new age newbie.... its pure chaos which takes away from the epic vibe of the confrontation and has none of the emotional feel that the original had. they even had to sub in an electric guitar to make up for it, when the only electric guitar track was "Challenger" on the OS. not hating on it. but you had better believe as a die hard FFX fan i will NEVER be using the Arranged Orchestal Soundtrack. not by choice. P.S Challenger was forever the ultimate FFX Boss Battle Theme Change my mind.....
@@penguinlord9984The remaster is very muddled, the instruments are a bit difficult to make out which I think is a common problem with many orchestral versions. The original is clear and has excellent drums too which the remaster can’t really capture in the same way, also some of the synth sounds. Even the trumpet sound is better. I’ve seen fan made covers that are better than the remaster.
I remember watching the Dvd where Nobou Uematsu said that he made 14 songs in one hour. It may be amazing but I really wished he took it easy. We remember any themes in FF9 but not FFX. Maybe the Battle theme would have been better....
@@XDarket idk I think most people would recognize FFX songs over FF9 I've beaten 9 a few times over the years and the soundtrack never stood out at all. X was the last FF that had a great soundtrack that felt organic to the game. The only themes people would recognize from 9 was black mage village and the basic battle theme.
Ich finde den Sound auch nicht so berauschend, aber naja, vielleicht gewöhnt man sich ja noch dran... Mal schauen wie die anderen Stücke klingen. Eine Option zum wechseln zwischen altem und neuem Sound wäre trotzdem super. ^^
Hey :) Sicherlich lieb gemeint,allerdings wurde von Square Enix längst gesagt,dass der Release noch in diesem Herbst stattfinden soll...also in den nächsten Monaten! Das Amazondatum ist nur ein reiner Platzhalter,den ich auch schon kenne :) Trotzdem danke schön^^
Goooood I hated that battle theme, I was pretty much sold with the HD version, makes the game so much more enjoyable to be being that you hear that theme quite often.
Dann solltest du dir mal die ganzen veröffentlichten Screenshots angucken, es wurde ziemlich viel neu gemacht an den Texturen, den Hintergründen, den Charaktermodellen. SE hat ziemlich viel Arbeit da reingesteckt. So eine stark aufpolierte HD Version von einem PS2 Spiel hab ich bisher ehrlich gesagt noch nicht gesehen, wenn ich es mal mit den anderen HD Collections vergleiche, die ich kenne.
it just doesn’t fit the old style of the game and the instruments are just off for this, it feels like something that would be in ff7 remake and not ff10
Will always love & appreciate the original, but the remastered version is just a flat-out better version of it from a musical standpoint. Some may appreciate the ‘simplicity’ of the original though and I definitely understand that.
The nice thing about the remastered game is it gives you the choice between the original soundtrack or the remastered version. I _ALWAYS_ choose the original. Today is the first time I've heard the remastered version and....well.....you can keep it.
Wooow klingt super^^ Zwar gewöhnungsbedürftig als großer Fan des Teils,aber klingt frisch und angenehm!! Jetzt fehlt nur noch das verdammte Releasedatum :(
jedes mal wenn ich neue infos darüber sehe denk ich mir, warum um alles in der welt für die ps3, wo doch die ps4 auch bald erscheint.....? und wenn sie schon mal dabei sind hätt ich gern das sie auch ff8 neu auflegen, das ist mein liebling. übrigends finde ich kaum einen unterschied bei der musik, außer das die neue version irgendwie blechern klingt, könnt aber auch an meinem pc liegen.....
phillip handshoe Well... They will.. come on, if they enjoy what they play they'll play the older ones, I never played a FF game until the trailer for 15 dropped in 2015, I thought it looked cool so I instantly download an NES emulator and completed FF1, 2 and 3 then SNES emulator and 4,5,6,Mystic Quest, then PS1 emulator and FF7, 8,9 then PS2 emulator and 10,10-2,12 then played 13 trilogy and finally got to 15.
r/gatekeeping Pretty sure kids of today were probably babies of 17 years ago or not even born back then. Kids of today probably have had/will have a real final fantasy game. Having played this does not make you special ;)
?.,? ernsthaft dieser sountteppich der gitarren im hitnergrund ist naja sagen wir mal gewöhnungssache. hat da herr uematsu keine handhabe mehr über sein tun gehabt?
![[4K60ᶠᵖˢ] EVERY FINAL BOSS in FINAL FANTASY SERIES (1988-2023) FINAL FANTASY XVI 2023](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qGBssgrSOHk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K60ᶠᵖˢ] EVERY FINAL BOSS in FINAL FANTASY SERIES (1988-2023) FINAL FANTASY XVI 2023](/img/tr.png)
I like both, the original has that nostalgic Midi sound and the new is like more epic
I dont think u know what a MIDI actually is to be that disrespectful towards the original soundtrack that I actually have no emotioanl attachement to but still feel u discredit it for that.
@@Evilriku13 I think he meant Synth, no need to get all dramatic over it
How can it have a ''MIDI sound'' why both versions are litterly from a MIDI (as with every or MOST video game music)
@@DragonboltBlastter they meant synthesized compared to the arranged tracks
@@kyokonull Alright, got ya ;-)
00:00 original 1:39 remastered
I as a bassist have a strong opinion for the old soundtrack, because well... you can hear the bass much better!
imagine drowning out the best part of nobuo's songs
I personally enjoyed the remastered version; when I played the original Final Fantasy X, THAT's how the song sounded in my head.
People bitch about a lot, but there are actually a lot of games much worse than this one in the bad remasters category. Ignorance is bliss.
Original has something of a rhythm to it the arranged just kind of smooths over with this attempt at an epic sound that I think honestly is going to get a little tiring after a while, this is standard battle music after all and you hear this a lot in the course of one playthrough. I prefer to hear a snappy rhythm that I can groove to than get bombarded with music that’s constantly trying to be epic.
What I rememeber from this game is: OVERKILL. :)
Tidus:see ya then overkill
original wins by far i played this way back on ps2 i loved every second of the battle theme
Original stomps. I can actually hear the cymbals in that one.
i like the remaster, much more hype in the music
The sounds used in the original makes so much the personnality of FFX. Whitout it, it's not the same ! I played on PS3 the remaster and some songs are really good (Besaid theme, love it), but overall, the original sounds better and unique. Will probably buy it on switch now to replay the remaster with the original sountrack haha.
Well I don't know how I feel. because I played final fantasy x about a month or two before the HD remasters came out and enjoyed it then but I just bought the HD remaster for my vita and I love that too... I feel like this is what cheating feels like
As someone who is really new to JRPG’s. I started with Persona 5 Royal. I’m so happy I finally got to into Final Fantasy. I tried with 7 but it couldn’t grip me as much as 10 has so far.
The arranged version goes really well with the visuals going on but original is still better for me
I hope you can give 7 another try! It was my first every FF and it's a clear favorite with the cast, music, themes, etc but even so it unironically took my 7 years to beat and I've always stopped at different points on several devices (mobile, steam, Kindle, Nintendo Switch, etc)
Try 7 remake
Nobody:
Auron: YEET
New comment but man, the remaster is so good
Remaster sounds better imo
Ich finde es klingt sehr sehr gut, ein neuer frischer Touch für ein so oft gehörtes Battle Theme :)
The remaster is way over the top. The textures and such are great but the faces have lost the "Emotion Engine" style.
yeah i'v noticed that the faces of the HD remaster look wierd especialy Tidus's face he looks more japanese. i actually dont like it.
Smiles exactly I was thinking the same shit when I played the hd remaster the faces look downgraded n bright in colour
The bass guitar in the original hits super fantastic!!
For me the original 🔥
Don't need to put on airs. And adding the sound effects was just cheap.
I feel they added too much reverb in the remaster, or maybe the type of reverb doesn't suit quite well, makes most of the instruments muffled
Final fantasy x remaster was my first time playing the game, and I played it with the remaster ost so I feel more nostalgia for the remaster ost.
i dont care...i just love this battle song...i think this is no1 ff battle theme. no2 goes to ff9
If I play ffx again it'll most likely be bc Auron is my all time favorite character
i like original. but remaster better fit into the atmosphere in the game
Yeah, the original is 10 times better. I'm now glad I chose the original for my (first ever) playthrough.
No
@@superbroly2286 yes
I did the same and swapped when I felt like it (Xbox one X).
Auren takes the "imma hit you into oblivion" a bit too literal...
The original had sharper sounds. The remake music sounds like it's under water.
Nope I'm just listening with my epic headphones and the arranged one sounds better
@@crazys4173 Yep! Played the entire game with headphones on, and I can say, the arranged IS made for headphones and I personally prefer that
I love the song😍😍😍
Love both.
I know I'm very late to the party, but I've been occasionally gettin nostalgic to replay old FF games, Replayed 6 7 and 8 recently, need to finish 9, and I may do 10 and I have some contrasting opinions about the remaster music with FF6 vs FF10.
I think FF6's remastered music is GREAT and faithful with selective additions to the songs to fill out where needed. Like the extra voice in Dancing Mad's first movement.
I feel like FF10's remaster music went overboard. It's way too busy on some of the themes. The originals are a lot clearer and I feel have a bit more 'character' to it, where as the remaster added too many layers of extra 'epic' orchestration, which start to wash out a lot of the theme's core elements, particularly the bass instruments. I'm the type of person that like zoning into each instrument line to focus-listen to each one. The remaster is often muddy it's a lot harder to do that.
I finally got around to playing through FFX. I gotta say I prefer the new arrangement, except for the main battle theme. It just sorta "kicks" more in the original, if that makes any sense.
The only remastered version of FFX that i truly prefer over the original is Movement in green. Sweet nostalgic feel to it
the original cuz remind of the final fantasy sonic x5
In der 'alten' Version wurden definitiv einige Soundeffekte in diesem Video entfernt...
You have to be absolutely deaf or nostalgic if you prefer the original over the arranged... The ride cymbals in the second part of the original are so prominent precisely because the middle high spectrum needs to be filled with something... In the arranged that isn't neccesary because the song is an aural fest since the begining, although rides are there, subtly inserted into a mix that is finally proper audio and not just music info. I was recently finishing the HD remaster and I didn't recall battle theme being that good, even moving me to tears, so then I learned the music was arranged... And thankfully so! Also the added guitar parts absolutely rock and the toms from the drums are now the memorable part from percussion. Absolutely ADORE the arranged music and certainly takes the quality of the game to a new level.
Im the deafest motherfucker out there
Arranged soundtrack was engineered by a new age newbie.... its pure chaos which takes away from the epic vibe of the confrontation and has none of the emotional feel that the original had. they even had to sub in an electric guitar to make up for it, when the only electric guitar track was "Challenger" on the OS. not hating on it. but you had better believe as a die hard FFX fan i will NEVER be using the Arranged Orchestal Soundtrack. not by choice. P.S Challenger was forever the ultimate FFX Boss Battle Theme Change my mind.....
the new music needs the cymbals a nd then it would sound better
Agreed. The percussion was by far the best part about the song. Why remove the meat and cheese just to make the bread have alittle better seasoning?
The cymbals are there.
Love the original music. The remaster is just lacking in something.
It's been forever since I played FF 10, so I don't know if I would notice the difference.
Me gustan ambas. Increíble.
Warum hat Valfaris in der HD Version nen Hitexpander? xD Kein Unterschied zwischen den beiden Versionen, außer an der Stelle.
Original wins. Hands downs!
5 letters..... OG FTW
Wird man im Spiel optional auch den alten originalen Soundtrack einstellen können?
Sorry SquereEnix, but the new version sounds a bit weird. :-/
why does the screen shatter?
Because it was the late 1990s and early 2000s. It was cool
Original sounds better.
How?
@@penguinlord9984The remaster is very muddled, the instruments are a bit difficult to make out which I think is a common problem with many orchestral versions. The original is clear and has excellent drums too which the remaster can’t really capture in the same way, also some of the synth sounds. Even the trumpet sound is better. I’ve seen fan made covers that are better than the remaster.
I think the remaster sounds better
nobody: ....
Kimahri: MMMMM
Nah, I much prefer the original. Original is always best and the nostalgia is there ❤️
Original wins, but then again I am biased towards synth music. Plus, the "new" version is too different.
Also, my HDTV deinterlaces better than that.
When I was a kid I felt like the original ffx ps2 graphics were as good as the HD is now, but looking back I can see how bad they were lol
I remember watching the Dvd where Nobou Uematsu said that he made 14 songs in one hour. It may be amazing but I really wished he took it easy.
We remember any themes in FF9 but not FFX.
Maybe the Battle theme would have been better....
I thought FF9 had one of the weaker sound tracks I'm the series but the best basic battle theme.
@@xKillZone99 well they are memorable that even if you hear it in the streets you'll know it's from FF9.
Only very few are memorable in FFX.
@@XDarket idk I think most people would recognize FFX songs over FF9 I've beaten 9 a few times over the years and the soundtrack never stood out at all. X was the last FF that had a great soundtrack that felt organic to the game. The only themes people would recognize from 9 was black mage village and the basic battle theme.
Soulful SquareSoft vs Soulless Square-Enix
Cool!! Sounds like my SoundBlaster AWE 64!!
Ich finde den Sound auch nicht so berauschend, aber naja, vielleicht gewöhnt man sich ja noch dran... Mal schauen wie die anderen Stücke klingen. Eine Option zum wechseln zwischen altem und neuem Sound wäre trotzdem super. ^^
Diesen Herbst? Wow das wäre natürlich noch schöner :D
Danke für die info!
Hey :) Sicherlich lieb gemeint,allerdings wurde von Square Enix längst gesagt,dass der Release noch in diesem Herbst stattfinden soll...also in den nächsten Monaten! Das Amazondatum ist nur ein reiner Platzhalter,den ich auch schon kenne :) Trotzdem danke schön^^
The original is great but kind of underwhelming. I prefer the remaster, feels alot more grand.
Goooood I hated that battle theme, I was pretty much sold with the HD version, makes the game so much more enjoyable to be being that you hear that theme quite often.
Original any day
Dann solltest du dir mal die ganzen veröffentlichten Screenshots angucken, es wurde ziemlich viel neu gemacht an den Texturen, den Hintergründen, den Charaktermodellen. SE hat ziemlich viel Arbeit da reingesteckt. So eine stark aufpolierte HD Version von einem PS2 Spiel hab ich bisher ehrlich gesagt noch nicht gesehen, wenn ich es mal mit den anderen HD Collections vergleiche, die ich kenne.
Original way better
Old one...and it's NOT EVEN A CONTEST 😆. The new one sounds sooooo tacky
it just doesn’t fit the old style of the game and the instruments are just off for this, it feels like something that would be in ff7 remake and not ff10
Warum können die die Musik nicht einfach so lassen? Die HD Version hört sich im Vergleich zu SD sehr sehr schlecht an. 0 FF-Feeling
Arranged is far better imo
Aurons overdrive is just hilarious
Will always love & appreciate the original, but the remastered version is just a flat-out better version of it from a musical standpoint. Some may appreciate the ‘simplicity’ of the original though and I definitely understand that.
is it me or the new one sounds "too bright" ? I really annoys me...
The whole remastered soundtrack is whack
@@VictoriaSteelmountain I’m playing on Xbox one X for the first Time and glad I picked Original
wow at the end it looks like it sais Ject die limited edition
ist es besorgniserregend, wenn ich bei der freude auf ein spiel gänsehaut bekomme? :D
ohh shit hab vor kurzem durchgespielt jz will ich nochmal auf HD :)
Only good thing about the remaster was the music.
The original is the best way to enjoy this game. Original is.... MEH... Good but meh
Hardly an improvement, if anything the original sounds better to me.
ich denke mal sie haben einfach den track über das video glegt und die effekte dabei ignoriert...
Hey Hotfire :)
Das Release Datum müsste 27.12.13 sein, hab es mir bei Amazon schon vorbestellt. :D
The nice thing about the remastered game is it gives you the choice between the original soundtrack or the remastered version. I _ALWAYS_ choose the original.
Today is the first time I've heard the remastered version and....well.....you can keep it.
Trotzdem wenn das eine Vorschau auf die HD Grafik sein soll, dann sollten die das zumindest schon mehr HD-mäßig aussehen lassen...
Wooow klingt super^^ Zwar gewöhnungsbedürftig als großer Fan des Teils,aber klingt frisch und angenehm!! Jetzt fehlt nur noch das verdammte Releasedatum :(
jedes mal wenn ich neue infos darüber sehe denk ich mir, warum um alles in der welt für die ps3, wo doch die ps4 auch bald erscheint.....?
und wenn sie schon mal dabei sind hätt ich gern das sie auch ff8 neu auflegen, das ist mein liebling.
übrigends finde ich kaum einen unterschied bei der musik, außer das die neue version irgendwie blechern klingt, könnt aber auch an meinem pc liegen.....
Feel like the guitar is just a bit much
Original no doubt
Kaum unterschied? Ich könnte FFX auch auf nem emulator zocken und hätte genau die gleiche Grafik (1080p + anti alising)
Original is the best
Sounds exactly the same, the remix is just a bit more exciting than the original. I like the remix better
kids of today will never know how a real final fantasy game was
phillip handshoe Well... They will.. come on, if they enjoy what they play they'll play the older ones, I never played a FF game until the trailer for 15 dropped in 2015, I thought it looked cool so I instantly download an NES emulator and completed FF1, 2 and 3 then SNES emulator and 4,5,6,Mystic Quest, then PS1 emulator and FF7, 8,9 then PS2 emulator and 10,10-2,12 then played 13 trilogy and finally got to 15.
Especially since they changed many of the character models and now their faces look really different. Especially Yuna.
phillip handshoe real talk bro
Wrong I know and I was born in 2001 and love final fantasy.
r/gatekeeping
Pretty sure kids of today were probably babies of 17 years ago or not even born back then.
Kids of today probably have had/will have a real final fantasy game.
Having played this does not make you special ;)
Not really a fan of the new version. Sounds too busy.
mehrmals durchgespielt
Not very sure about the arranged. Original is much better.
best team is wakka, tidus and rikkou
?.,? ernsthaft dieser sountteppich der gitarren im hitnergrund ist naja sagen wir mal gewöhnungssache.
hat da herr uematsu keine handhabe mehr über sein tun gehabt?
The original is better.
In meinen Augen ist das neue viel besser.
Ich hatte jetzt irgendwie einfach ne Version von nem echten orchester eingespielt erwartet... DAS hier ist etwas lächerlich.
da bin ich ja erleichtert :D es gibt menschen, die verstehen meine euphorie nicht... komisch!
Gabs einen Grund für die neue Musik ?
Ich finds ehrlich gesagt kacke, ich würd das Spiel auch gerne so haben, wie ich es kenne. :(
Nein! ^_^
I prefer the original music. It's what I grew up with
Original is better YET
Ob nun für PS3 oder 4 ist doch egal, durch die PS 4 wird die Grafik auch nicht besser.
Arranged is much better imo