I am glad to have found a site that seems as credible as Project Farm. Not only is your information well presented, but by your jersey, I see you are either Science or Medical personnel for Star Fleet. That is obviously also why you are not aware that tires do not last indefinitely even if you don't ever drive, as rubber has a shelf life. Live long and prosper.
Can you make a video about the diamond compounds for stropping? Cheap vs expensive, grit sizes, emulsion vs paste, comparison on microscope vs green compound, etc
Been sharpening knives for 45+ yrs as part of my profession as a metal worker toolroom machinist and it wasn't until my son became a qualified chef that I appreciated the difference between sharp and properly sharp. Of all the UA-camr's I've watch here in virtual reality, I find some of the most worthwhile information I've come across, thanks for laconic senses of humour, and making the subject approachable. Thanks T
I've been sharpening knives and axes for friends and family since the early 1990s. Seeing the SHARPAL recommendation I purchased one and have been using it for about a month now. What a great value the SHARPAL has been, I'm very pleased with its quality and performance for the price. Especially nice is the heavy duty storage case that doubles and a tool holder/base.
Cleaning diamond stones - I use WD40 some times if they are heavily contaminated . Then wipe down with clean paper towel . If yours are aluminium plate , you can wash them ( soapy water ) .. All my diamond is on aluminium plate and I have had no issues over several years now . ( washing them ) .
I recently saw one of your older videos where you had a small squirt bottle that you intermittently added (water?) to a diamond stone. This is why I searched this video out. Thanks for updating your maintenance protocol
Great video as usual! I love my Snarpal 325X1200! The 325 is perfect for profiling new knives and flattening my waterstones. The 1200 side will sharpen an "almost sharp" knife in a few strokes, with a few more on hard leather and diamond paste to finish it off. I've had it 5 years, use it 3-4 times a month, and it's almost like new.
Gotta say......i made the mistakes of pull through sharpeners, the cheap shitty amazon blue/white whetstone, then i found this channel!! Bought the sharpal and couldn't be happier! So glad i bought it and found the channel!! Much love from the uk!!!
Wow, I think that's every question answered that Ive ever had. Truly timeless my friend. Hope you have a great time at blade show and a speedy recovery 💪
I took your advice and bought the S SATC diamond stone and the sharpal angle guide you showed a while back. Delivered at the end of May, and now only a week and a half later, I've been able to bring my dull pocket knife back to life. I'm not really into collecting knives, just own a chef knife and a couple of pocket knives. I do like to maintain what I have. The S SATC stone is cheaper than a new knife. Thanks for saving me a ton of money in the future!
@@intensecutn thank you but that was not the stone I wanted and bought. the sharpal stone I bought came w a base/case that he didn't mention. I'm glad you're happy w your purchase.
The rubber eraser works as well as a poly eraser and for finer Stones I would use a Gum Eraser and just roll it piece of dough across the stone I don't understand who started this Windex craze including any type of oil totally not necessary glad you brought this out well done Alex
Great video answered so many of my extra beginner questions. Someone probably already commented this but I don't read through all the comments, compressed air sounds like a solution for a lot of the corrosion and cleaning issues... Maybe
I use 2” pencil erasers. They do really a good job. They do a good job on Spyderco ceramics as well. Diamond Abrasives I like are ATOMA # 140, 400, 600, 1200; DMT in F, XF, XXF They last a long time. I also really like the Shapton DGLP for Waterstones; it’s expensive, sure, but it’s great for flattening. It will last many many years and maybe even a couple of decades as I don’t use it on stones under JIS 1000. For that I use ATOMA 140
6 місяців тому+1
I want to thank you a lot for teaching people how to sharpen properly. I used to watch a lot of videos with fancy setups and really expensive sharpening material, I even bought a Work Sharp precision adjust but it felt like a chore to use. After your recomendations I bought the Sharpal stone and a strop and 4 micron diamond paste and was able to get hair popping sharp edges without even using angle guides.
I have used water to lift grindings with my diamond stone for years sharpening multiple kitchen cutlery a couple of times a week. I have never seen any rust. I always wash the stone with hot tap water, towel dry it and let it finish drying on its own because it is hot. It is nickel based. I wonder if the rust others are seeing is actually rusted particles from the knives.... ?
Great video! After watching the review video of the Sharpal I caved and bought one. So far I've only done a few knives with it but I'm favorably impressed. My feeling based on a few uses is that the Sharpal's 325 side is slower/less aggressive than the Atoma 400 or even the S SATC coarse but this may change as I get more time on it. What I wasn't prepared for was just how great the case would be! OD55 kind of undersold it IMO. It's fairly substantial and well made. The bottom is very nicely rubberized and doesn't budge a bit, and the case is thick enough that there's plenty of knuckle clearance to use the stone. It's really shocking that this combo stone is still $70!
Agree that the case is a real selling point. It provides an excellent working surface. Its sturdy. It does not move around. And it stores the stone. And the cardboard box it came in has room for a strop, the bottle of compound. Its all good.
yet the case is badly designed, I see that OD55 actually removed the lid on his, probably by cutting it. I found a way to make it removable by removing the hinge pin and bending it at one end (under heat), and now the lid is removable, but I shouldn't be the one having to fix it.
I am totally hooked on..Now I need to break down all this info. Still not clear on which stone, how many stones needed to sharpen and stropping. Here we go…
I've got bleeding thumbs after having just got the 400#/1000# SATC stone. Keeping the knife angle consistent is evading me. Once I figure this out, I'll upgrade to a DMT or Sharpal. Thank you Alex.
Help, I’ve got a problem. I started watching Alex’s channel so I could sharpen all of my pocket knives. But they’re sharp now. So I went through all my kitchen knives and now they’re all sharp, too. I’ve started buying knives on eBay and I realized my primary reason for buying them is to sharpen them. Where does it stop?!? I’m sure my wife would like to know, too.
Thank you for the video. I bought the Sharpal diamond stone thanks to your review. The manufacturer claims that we can use honing oil so since honing oil is basically mineral oil, thats what im using to prevent rust mainly. I like to use mineral oil because i dont get that metal dust everywhere and i think the stone is easier to clean. To clean better a diamond stone simply use mineral spirits ODORLESS which is more refined than the regular one and stronger smell. Just use mineral spirits with a toothbrush and it will be super clean. For the most stubborn dirt, when the stone is dry the best option is a simple eraser.
A kneadable eraser may work well to clean stones, I use it for erasing when im drawing they get into the grooves of the paper quite well and don't leave residue
I used water on my sharpal before i knew better and put it in the ultrasonic cleaner with simple green and it seemed to get some of the staining off of it. Now I just keep my shop vac with brush attachment to clean off the stone when using it dry since I've got a HEPA filter in it
Getting good information on selecting such equipment is great. What I would like, actually, is some info on what to do with it after you buy one, the actual process of sharpening...
I very recently got into knife sharpening and your videos definitely helped, and I quickly got to sharpening to a shaving edge. I don't have a strop yet but I will get one soon. That said, money was a bit of an issue for me, so I ended up going with a locally available cheaper option than the sharpal ("sharpi" 600/1000, about half the price) - so far it does work but it almost certainly isn't nearly as good as the sharpal. It definitely seems to wear out around the edges pretty much during break in, so no recurve sharpening. If/when this one wears out, the next thing I get will definitely be sharpal though. Unfortunately, the S SATC stone isn't available locally and shipping costs kill it as an option (this is the one thing I hate about product recommendations on youtube - almost none of it applies to my country because shipping from amazon is often more than the cost of the item being shipped, and a lot of it just isn't available in my country)
Not using water raises a question: what about stone cleaning? I clean my stones using water and soap for dirty hands (auto mechanic soap) with citric acid and pumice. For harder soiling, vaseline oil (liquid paraffin) can provide additional help (it is also used to treat kitchen cutting boards). I let the stones soak for a while, repeat cleaning, and then rinse and dry the stones well. I faced rusting only on a couple old low-quality stones. However, I don't have much experience. Anyway, any advice would be very useful. I also tried a rubber cleaning stick. It is not at all bad on abrasives for wood, but it doesn't affect those diamond stones much. What do you think? Thank you!
Have you tried using minera oil? It should reduce friction on the diamonds and the plates will last longer and prevent rusting. Maybe not worth it because of the mess. I like oil for high grit natural stones but have no experience with diamond plates.
Great video, I really enjoyed it and learnt a lot! I'd like to contribute a content idea: Try to turn a really cheap and coarse diamond "stoney/plate into a flattening stone by fixing it to a flat surface. I'd love to see that! Keep up the good work and stay healthy!
Hey, watched a few of your videos after it popped up on my feed, really informative stuff I never knew what a burr is before I saw one of your videos and I did hear about people using strops but I always thought it wasn't really necessary and it was only for people who wanted their knives to look shinier or something. I've been using a whetstone (1000 grit) for a couple years now after trying a honing steel and a pull through knife sharpener and basically seeing no results with either on actually getting a better edge (maybe a tiny bit with the pull through knife sharpener but nothing compared to the whetstone). With the whetstone I was able to get really sharp edges but they would only last a couple of weeks before getting dull, this makes so much more sense after I saw your videos about stropping and removing the burr, I ordered one on amazon for $30 I know that's not exactly what you recommend but I saw it get some good reviews and I'm looking forward to trying it out. I didn't really feel like spending north of $50 on a belt + compound + contact cement and most of the stuff you link doesn't even ship to my country lol. thanks for the informative videos. One question I do have (I'm sure you probably covered it in one of your videos, sorry) is does it matter which side you push/pull your knife with on the stone? I always use a backwards direction (edge trailing as you put in one of your videos) with my whetstone, should I use a forwards direction for better results? I see that's how you do it in your videos.
I find that diamond stones do a much better job using fluid. It's much easier to not loose my angle when the chisel or handplane blade travels smoothly. I like using automotive window cleaning fluid because it has anti-corrosion agents. So far I have no issues with rust on my diamond plates.
interesting, Re the water. I have diamond plates to sharpen my woodworking tools, and I have been using water /glass cleaner on them, and not run into issues so far. I'll keep my eyes open, though! (and I have one of them diamond stones you like for the kitchen, which I have been using dry, as per your recommendation)
Just found your channel, very informative and fun to watch, I’d like to see your thoughts and comparisons of some of the newer blade steels like s35vn ,s90 ,magna cut.
I just bought one of those $20 Amazon stones as a set with the holder for $40 and a new Beaver Craft strop made in Ukraine and got all three for $56. Love all three, especially for the price...thanks for another great vid and answering both the questions I had Before I had a chance to ask them....lol
Can you do a video on victorinox. Maybe the steel they use for their knives or just your opinion on swiss army knives in general. Also leatherman's and other multi tools. 😊
Hey, I don’t know if you noticed, but SHARPAL just dropped a new diamond plate 167H. It looks exactly like the one you mentioned, but without the plastic box. At $45 it might be even better offer 😁
Thus far, I use fluid when sharpening. I think it makes it a bit simpler to remove the swarf. Most of the time I will use an automotive glass cleaner which does not have ammonia in it. Ammonia can bother the nickel plating material. Using water is not a problem, IF you dry them off. I will leave mine on their side and propped up on one end so all of the water drains off and there are only 2 tiny surfaces that are in contact with the wood I have mine on. I have CBN grinding wheels for all of my lathe tools. Under 'production' work, they are good for 5 or so years. I would expect diamond to last longer since it is a bit harder than the CBN.
Hi Alex, I would love to know your views on scalpels as to what mskes them so sharp and if they are sharper than the knives you've sharpened. Also, please provide your views on blade sharpness testers. Much love from Canada ❤
I purchased and learned to use the Sharpal stone and a strop following your instructions with great results. For the first time in my life, I can hand sharpen knives pretty well. Would a finer diamond stone be worth purchasing to obtain the "mirror finish" razor blade type edges, i.e., 3000 grit, etc.? If so, what do you recommend? Keep up the great videos. It has become one of my favorite channels. Thank you.
I would very much appreciate if you could make a video on sharpening "gentelmans knives" like CRKT CEO, Boker Kaizen/Nori/Kwaiken Air etc. I find them challenging due to the height of the blade being very minimalistic. I'm qurious if you have any tips specific to this type of knife.
Have you ever heard of or tried the MPOWER Tools diamond stone sets? They have different sets and I see Stumpy Nubs likes those a lot, and they seem practical,so if they're good, it might be a good deal.
Hi, can you explain in detail how to sharpen kitchen knife? I don't talk about those staight 1 dolar kitchen knife you show, I'm talking about curved kitchen knife. I know that "keeping angle" is most important but if you keep angle on straight part of knife and move your body, then, at least for me, on curved part knife just doesn't touch sharpening stone. I saw some short that said you need to move your elbow up and it helped a bit, but I would like to see your guide.
Love the channel. Just put together diy sharpener that I've seen on YT. Was wondering if you could recommend a 1" x (4" or 6") diamond stone(s) to use in the sharpener. Maybe some of you other sharpening junkies could tell what small diamond stones have worked for you. These will be use on my diy sharpener, router bits, ....thanks
Thanks for all your instruction! Is it then a false economy to start a sharpening session with too fine a grit? For the benefit of the knife and the stone, what are guidelines for starting and finishing grit? Yes I'm sure it depends on many variables, beginning with how bad the edge is in the first place...
Krud Kutter is the best option for use on diamond stones. They will not work as well if you don't use a lapping fluid. Never seen a quality stone have any sort of rust. Though I use Ultra Sharp stones and they are basically the best you can get. If you are using cheap junk from Amazon, you get what you pay for. Also if you dry the stones with a rag after using the stones. Another thing is you can contaminate the diamond stones simply by going from a 300 to a 600 without wiping your knife off first.
Since you said that some diamond plates are embedded with nickel on carbon steel that prone to rust thus fasten their degradation, what's your opinion about diamond sharpening stones as tool used for lapping, dressing, and/or flattening water stones ? On the same matter, is it better to use aluminum oxide/corondum based sand paper on a relatively flat medium such as glass? Since from economic aspect its far cheaper to replace sand paper that has little to none chance to rust. Also from hardness aspect, aluminum oxide/corondum falls only 1 point behind diamond on mohs scale. Thank you
As always, the best stone is the one you have 😉 I have different diamond stones, both the nickel plated ones and resin bound ones. The resin bound ones, I save for specialty knifes and carbide tools. The other ones I use on all other knifes but as a rule of thumb I save the expensive nickel plated stones for the harder steels only. Those real cheap diamond stones with the oval holes in the plates are the only ones I don't use anymore since I ruined the tip of more than one knife and chisel on those.
Very informative video. Could you please do a video of the Japanese King Stone 1000/6000 grit stones please. And a video of how to sharpen a long blade fish fillet knife thanks when you get the time 😊
Hey, Alex. Can you do a video about knife edge maintenance? Are there any do’s and don’ts of cleaning a knife? I heard some people don’t wash their knives and just wipe them with a rag. Thanks!
@@OUTDOORS55 I’ve been using it for years. It’s a great plate to progress into, from the 600. Gives you a nice refined finish, without taking any of the toothy feel away. A must have, IMO.
Have you had the chance to try a Dianova stone? It's a small Swedish make, so might be hard to find in the US. I have a small hand-style sharpener (300/600 grit) from them that I've been quite happy with, it's nice and flat, and the grit seems even. But I was looking for a bench stone that isn't the ultra-cheap oval-holed plate on plastic (I have one of those from Lidl, which is pretty good for what it is, but not quite as flat as I'd like). Then I remembered the Dianova, and found out they make decent sized 300/600 grit lap stone called "Önne", for under $50(!), so I figured it's worth a shot. Seems to be plastic core, but as long as the plates aren't super thin, it'll hopefully be quite flat. (They also make a 1200/strop version, but I wanted it mainly for shaping chisels and plane blades.) It's currently in the mail, so haven't been able to test it yet. (Their site is currently "under construction" which is slightly unnerving since I haven't got the delivery yet, but I figure it's just a website update hopefully. They've been around quite a while, so I don't think they're going away.) No affiliation, apart from being a Swede :)
I got to use a lubricant with my diamonds. usually water and dish soap. Friction at the apex is a thing with dry abrasives (less than micron thicc, thermal dynamics is the law) . Also metal and diamond dust gets into your lungs, since your nose is right above the grind stone. Just spray some dw40 after, its formulated to displace water and protect against rust. You are going to get contradicting views while giving sharpening advice, dont let your ego take over, its how we learn. I bugged cliff stamp as well (rip). Nylon brush can also clean the diamonds and they last forever. Rubber also releases dust, that you inhale, since your nose is at the grind stone
Dying for you to do a full test under the microscope of water vs honing fluid vs windex vs whatever else people say to use. I believe you, but there are a bunch of people that don’t and I’d like to see you show us what it takes to convince them.
@@vaguincolombia It’s on my wishlist, but haven’t bought one yet. Can you confirm if they say honing oil or honing fluid? I think there’s a difference but am not really sure, which is why I want him to do a deep microscopic dive.
For ski edging (which uses very similar diamond stones) I have always heard to use something like a 50/50 alcohol and water mix. Either ethanol or isopropyl alcohol.
@@PetesGuide The box says clearly "Honing oil". Honing oil is basically mineral oil USP grade which is for human usage and it is easy to clean with water and soap or if you want, you can use ODORLESS mineral spirits which is a more refined mineral spirits than the regular one with strong smell. Use the odorless mineral spirits with a toothbrush.
Thanks, this was a lot of information on diamond stones I wasn't aware of. Just because most kitchen knife sharpeners don't use this type of stones (some do use diamond stones that are more like powder on a typical ceramic stone) so they aren't very informed or don't see it worthwhile to talk about them a lot in depth. For example I've noticed you don't use water at all and wondered about it. Does one of those "eraser" stones (sabitoru I've seen some brand call it or maybe that was the brand name, Japanese package) used for cleaning kitchen utensils from rust help with rust on a diamond stone like that or is it just a lost cause to try? People sometimes clean their ceramic whetstones with those.
I wish you would review The Smiths 400 - 1,000 Grit, because it's supposed to be two stones bonded in plastic to keep grit contamination from happening. Also, is not having the diamond paste for the strop keeping me from getting hair splitting results?
I wonder if the Atoma 400 isn’t to fine to start the sharpening. I want to buy diamond stones to go faster, now I start on a 300 King stone. Thanks for the video 💪
Excellent video as usual!!! :-) I do have a question that is not that common with the subject of sharpening of the apex, but as chef we do have a problem with our fine cuttings especially vegetables that sticks on the side of the knife and the question is, is it a hollow edge going to help by moving those fine small pieces away from the side of the blade because of the curve of the apex or is it a way we can make the side of the blade hydrophobic so they don't stick whatever the geometry of the apex is? I found a paper about using Lazer to cut microscopic cuts on the surface so it become hydrophobic so since I don't have a Lazer that powerful in hand, I am wondering if we could make it hydrophobic by using the right size grain sandpaper. Just a thought that could change the way professionals use their knives. The problem is not only how sharp the apex is but also what the drag of the rest of the surface of the blade create, especially by applying force to move all those fine cuts upwards as we cut and finally they are released at the top of the knife. My respect and love, brothers and sisters!!! :-)
Really surprised you didn't even mention bonded diamond stones, a very different beast from the plated. I pretty much use bonded stones and I prefer them to the plated, but they need to be lapped before use and have different characteristics from plated stones.
Anyone else so hooked on this channels videos that they don't even care what the topic is about anymore they just want more videos?
Haha thanks for the kind words 🙏👍
Yep, I like his no nonsense presentation style and I’ve yet to see a duff vid from him.
The one and a half hour road trip video was downright therapeutic
HOWEVER... I would like to see some more knife making videos again... in good time, when Alex is feeling better and able to do so.
I have actually put on his entire playlist before while I'm at work and just let it play. The things I've learned from Alex are remarkable.
I am glad to have found a site that seems as credible as Project Farm. Not only is your information well presented, but by your jersey, I see you are either Science or Medical personnel for Star Fleet. That is obviously also why you are not aware that tires do not last indefinitely even if you don't ever drive, as rubber has a shelf life. Live long and prosper.
Lol 😂 👍
Can you make a video about the diamond compounds for stropping? Cheap vs expensive, grit sizes, emulsion vs paste, comparison on microscope vs green compound, etc
Been sharpening knives for 45+ yrs as part of my profession as a metal worker toolroom machinist and it wasn't until my son became a qualified chef that I appreciated the difference between sharp and properly sharp. Of all the UA-camr's I've watch here in virtual reality, I find some of the most worthwhile information I've come across, thanks for laconic senses of humour, and making the subject approachable. Thanks T
I've been sharpening knives and axes for friends and family since the early 1990s.
Seeing the SHARPAL recommendation I purchased one and have been using it for about a month now.
What a great value the SHARPAL has been, I'm very pleased with its quality and performance for the price.
Especially nice is the heavy duty storage case that doubles and a tool holder/base.
Thanks for the Info! A before & after of a sharp knife through a dishwasher cycle would be interesting under the scope.
I was just going to ask about that! :)
Indeed! Outdoors55, can you do that in the future please?
Ooo that's a good one since I frequently just toss my kitchen knives in the dishwasher.
Cleaning diamond stones - I use WD40 some times if they are heavily contaminated . Then wipe down with clean paper towel . If yours are aluminium plate , you can wash them ( soapy water ) .. All my diamond is on aluminium plate and I have had no issues over several years now . ( washing them ) .
I recently saw one of your older videos where you had a small squirt bottle that you intermittently added (water?) to a diamond stone. This is why I searched this video out. Thanks for updating your maintenance protocol
Great video as usual! I love my Snarpal 325X1200! The 325 is perfect for profiling new knives and flattening my waterstones. The 1200 side will sharpen an "almost sharp" knife in a few strokes, with a few more on hard leather and diamond paste to finish it off. I've had it 5 years, use it 3-4 times a month, and it's almost like new.
Great stuff. That shirt is giving my wife and I some serious Star Trek vibes though.
Lol spock could make some seriously sharp knives 🖖
Gotta say......i made the mistakes of pull through sharpeners, the cheap shitty amazon blue/white whetstone, then i found this channel!!
Bought the sharpal and couldn't be happier! So glad i bought it and found the channel!!
Much love from the uk!!!
Same here - Such an nice, compact solution.
Just used water with it, but will change this habit now too.
Send him a kiss.
💋💋💋
@@matandcat2506 Hahaha.
I bought the sharpal too. It’s great and all I need for a while.
I feel like you are the “project farm” of the knife community
Exactly! We need a collab!
Friend, that is an excellent idea. @@nazgu1
I'd buy that
Hi, i used a pull through almost exclusively for almost ten years. You got me hand-sharpening again, on a piece of brick 🤣
Good upgrade
@@mikejake6360 for real, I'm getting better by the day. 😉
Lol. I like to strop on cardboard or the frosted top of my car window
@@zacharysherry2910 Not kidding, I was thinking of carboard with campfire ashes for strop + compound. You think we got a goldmine selling those ? 😁
Wow, I think that's every question answered that Ive ever had. Truly timeless my friend. Hope you have a great time at blade show and a speedy recovery 💪
Awesome, thanks friend 🙏👍
I took your advice and bought the S SATC diamond stone and the sharpal angle guide you showed a while back. Delivered at the end of May, and now only a week and a half later, I've been able to bring my dull pocket knife back to life. I'm not really into collecting knives, just own a chef knife and a couple of pocket knives. I do like to maintain what I have. The S SATC stone is cheaper than a new knife. Thanks for saving me a ton of money in the future!
When you get up to really high grits they do kinda plug up sometimes. Bar Keepers friend with a magic erase pad or scrub pad works great
You forgot to mention in this video that an added value for the sharpal is it comes w a base/storage box and an angle "guide".
Same as many other no-name brands on eBay. I just picked up a 400/1000 diamond STONE with a base on ebay for $20AUD.
@@intensecutn thank you but that was not the stone I wanted and bought. the sharpal stone I bought came w a base/case that he didn't mention.
I'm glad you're happy w your purchase.
The rubber eraser works as well as a poly eraser and for finer Stones I would use a Gum Eraser and just roll it piece of dough across the stone I don't understand who started this Windex craze including any type of oil totally not necessary glad you brought this out well done Alex
you've been on fire lately with all these new videos. I feel so blessed!
Great video answered so many of my extra beginner questions. Someone probably already commented this but I don't read through all the comments, compressed air sounds like a solution for a lot of the corrosion and cleaning issues... Maybe
I use 2” pencil erasers. They do really a good job.
They do a good job on Spyderco ceramics as well.
Diamond Abrasives I like are ATOMA # 140, 400, 600, 1200; DMT in F, XF, XXF
They last a long time.
I also really like the Shapton DGLP for Waterstones; it’s expensive, sure, but it’s great for flattening. It will last many many years and maybe even a couple of decades as I don’t use it on stones under JIS 1000. For that I use ATOMA 140
I want to thank you a lot for teaching people how to sharpen properly. I used to watch a lot of videos with fancy setups and really expensive sharpening material, I even bought a Work Sharp precision adjust but it felt like a chore to use. After your recomendations I bought the Sharpal stone and a strop and 4 micron diamond paste and was able to get hair popping sharp edges without even using angle guides.
I have used water to lift grindings with my diamond stone for years sharpening multiple kitchen cutlery a couple of times a week. I have never seen any rust. I always wash the stone with hot tap water, towel dry it and let it finish drying on its own because it is hot. It is nickel based. I wonder if the rust others are seeing is actually rusted particles from the knives.... ?
Great video! After watching the review video of the Sharpal I caved and bought one. So far I've only done a few knives with it but I'm favorably impressed. My feeling based on a few uses is that the Sharpal's 325 side is slower/less aggressive than the Atoma 400 or even the S SATC coarse but this may change as I get more time on it. What I wasn't prepared for was just how great the case would be! OD55 kind of undersold it IMO. It's fairly substantial and well made. The bottom is very nicely rubberized and doesn't budge a bit, and the case is thick enough that there's plenty of knuckle clearance to use the stone. It's really shocking that this combo stone is still $70!
Agree that the case is a real selling point. It provides an excellent working surface. Its sturdy. It does not move around. And it stores the stone. And the cardboard box it came in has room for a strop, the bottle of compound. Its all good.
yet the case is badly designed, I see that OD55 actually removed the lid on his, probably by cutting it. I found a way to make it removable by removing the hinge pin and bending it at one end (under heat), and now the lid is removable, but I shouldn't be the one having to fix it.
I am totally hooked on..Now I need to break down all this info. Still not clear on which stone, how many stones needed to sharpen and stropping. Here we go…
I've got bleeding thumbs after having just got the 400#/1000# SATC stone. Keeping the knife angle consistent is evading me. Once I figure this out, I'll upgrade to a DMT or Sharpal. Thank you Alex.
Rather Sharpal, DMT cuts slow and has crazy grit contamination.
Really looking forward to the chefs knife arc of the diamond stone series!
Help, I’ve got a problem. I started watching Alex’s channel so I could sharpen all of my pocket knives. But they’re sharp now. So I went through all my kitchen knives and now they’re all sharp, too. I’ve started buying knives on eBay and I realized my primary reason for buying them is to sharpen them. Where does it stop?!? I’m sure my wife would like to know, too.
You need a brick 🧱 😉
Start selling the knives you've sharpened so you can recoup a bit of money.
@@OUTDOORS55😂😂😂😂😂
Sounds like you found a sidejob...
My wife also wants to know the answer to that question for me.
Thank you for the video. I bought the Sharpal diamond stone thanks to your review. The manufacturer claims that we can use honing oil so since honing oil is basically mineral oil, thats what im using to prevent rust mainly. I like to use mineral oil because i dont get that metal dust everywhere and i think the stone is easier to clean. To clean better a diamond stone simply use mineral spirits ODORLESS which is more refined than the regular one and stronger smell. Just use mineral spirits with a toothbrush and it will be super clean. For the most stubborn dirt, when the stone is dry the best option is a simple eraser.
Thanks for your reply/comment. I go the Sharpal as well and was wondering the same thing about using oil. Makes sense to me. THX.
A kneadable eraser may work well to clean stones, I use it for erasing when im drawing they get into the grooves of the paper quite well and don't leave residue
On fine dia stones a film builds up soap and water works well
I really love my DMT workshop plates. Done a lot of knives with them so far and I guess I won't need a new one for years to come
I use and clean my diamond stones same as spyderco ceramics. They are in perfect condition. 👌
I used water on my sharpal before i knew better and put it in the ultrasonic cleaner with simple green and it seemed to get some of the staining off of it. Now I just keep my shop vac with brush attachment to clean off the stone when using it dry since I've got a HEPA filter in it
Thanks!
Thanks so much my friend 🙏🙏
This guy is the best value for your dollar on the internet!
Cazy question of the week. Does the diamond grit fall out of a lap over time if used upsidedown?
Getting good information on selecting such equipment is great.
What I would like, actually, is some info on what to do with it after you buy one, the actual process of sharpening...
He has a start to finish tutorial on that already, uploaded about 6 months ago. The method is the same no matter what stone you use.
@@no.no.4680 Which one is that? "How To Sharpen A Knife In About 5 Minutes With ONE Stone"? Any chance you can link it, please?
@@PavelKostromitinov Yes that’s the one.
Live long and prosper.
Thanks! Been waiting to hear about cleaning diamond stones. Much appreciated.
I very recently got into knife sharpening and your videos definitely helped, and I quickly got to sharpening to a shaving edge. I don't have a strop yet but I will get one soon. That said, money was a bit of an issue for me, so I ended up going with a locally available cheaper option than the sharpal ("sharpi" 600/1000, about half the price) - so far it does work but it almost certainly isn't nearly as good as the sharpal. It definitely seems to wear out around the edges pretty much during break in, so no recurve sharpening. If/when this one wears out, the next thing I get will definitely be sharpal though. Unfortunately, the S SATC stone isn't available locally and shipping costs kill it as an option (this is the one thing I hate about product recommendations on youtube - almost none of it applies to my country because shipping from amazon is often more than the cost of the item being shipped, and a lot of it just isn't available in my country)
Fantastic video, Alex! Very useful information. Thanks for putting it out
Just got my new stone ordered thanks for the advice
I definitely gotta get one and try it out
Not using water raises a question: what about stone cleaning?
I clean my stones using water and soap for dirty hands (auto mechanic soap) with citric acid and pumice. For harder soiling, vaseline oil (liquid paraffin) can provide additional help (it is also used to treat kitchen cutting boards). I let the stones soak for a while, repeat cleaning, and then rinse and dry the stones well. I faced rusting only on a couple old low-quality stones. However, I don't have much experience. Anyway, any advice would be very useful.
I also tried a rubber cleaning stick. It is not at all bad on abrasives for wood, but it doesn't affect those diamond stones much.
What do you think? Thank you!
Have you tried using minera oil? It should reduce friction on the diamonds and the plates will last longer and prevent rusting. Maybe not worth it because of the mess.
I like oil for high grit natural stones but have no experience with diamond plates.
I always learn something new with your videos. I'm going to stop using water with my diamond stones. Thanks
Great video, I really enjoyed it and learnt a lot!
I'd like to contribute a content idea: Try to turn a really cheap and coarse diamond "stoney/plate into a flattening stone by fixing it to a flat surface. I'd love to see that!
Keep up the good work and stay healthy!
Hey, watched a few of your videos after it popped up on my feed, really informative stuff I never knew what a burr is before I saw one of your videos and I did hear about people using strops but I always thought it wasn't really necessary and it was only for people who wanted their knives to look shinier or something. I've been using a whetstone (1000 grit) for a couple years now after trying a honing steel and a pull through knife sharpener and basically seeing no results with either on actually getting a better edge (maybe a tiny bit with the pull through knife sharpener but nothing compared to the whetstone).
With the whetstone I was able to get really sharp edges but they would only last a couple of weeks before getting dull, this makes so much more sense after I saw your videos about stropping and removing the burr, I ordered one on amazon for $30 I know that's not exactly what you recommend but I saw it get some good reviews and I'm looking forward to trying it out. I didn't really feel like spending north of $50 on a belt + compound + contact cement and most of the stuff you link doesn't even ship to my country lol.
thanks for the informative videos.
One question I do have (I'm sure you probably covered it in one of your videos, sorry) is does it matter which side you push/pull your knife with on the stone? I always use a backwards direction (edge trailing as you put in one of your videos) with my whetstone, should I use a forwards direction for better results? I see that's how you do it in your videos.
Great explanation and video Alex
I find that diamond stones do a much better job using fluid. It's much easier to not loose my angle when the chisel or handplane blade travels smoothly. I like using automotive window cleaning fluid because it has anti-corrosion agents. So far I have no issues with rust on my diamond plates.
I used tro clean my stones with oleic acid. Works wonders.
interesting, Re the water. I have diamond plates to sharpen my woodworking tools, and I have been using water /glass cleaner on them, and not run into issues so far. I'll keep my eyes open, though!
(and I have one of them diamond stones you like for the kitchen, which I have been using dry, as per your recommendation)
Great video. Your information is invalueable. You deliver the information required clearly. Best knife sharpening channel on youtube.
You better not be ceasing or desisting! Great work on all things diamond here, Alex. Feel better, and good luck with the legal wrangling. 👍
Just talked to my attorney, things are VERY much in our favor if they move forward 👍
Just found your channel, very informative and fun to watch, I’d like to see your thoughts and comparisons of some of the newer blade steels like s35vn ,s90 ,magna cut.
I just bought one of those $20 Amazon stones as a set with the holder for $40 and a new Beaver Craft strop made in Ukraine and got all three for $56. Love all three, especially for the price...thanks for another great vid and answering both the questions I had Before I had a chance to ask them....lol
I just bought the same setup. 600/1200 stone with holder and the beaver strop. It's a bit cheaper now about $45 for the whole package
Can you do a video on victorinox. Maybe the steel they use for their knives or just your opinion on swiss army knives in general. Also leatherman's and other multi tools. 😊
Hey, I don’t know if you noticed, but SHARPAL just dropped a new diamond plate 167H. It looks exactly like the one you mentioned, but without the plastic box. At $45 it might be even better offer 😁
thanx for the content bro. never miss an episode.
Thus far, I use fluid when sharpening. I think it makes it a bit simpler to remove the swarf. Most of the time I will use an automotive glass cleaner which does not have ammonia in it. Ammonia can bother the nickel plating material. Using water is not a problem, IF you dry them off. I will leave mine on their side and propped up on one end so all of the water drains off and there are only 2 tiny surfaces that are in contact with the wood I have mine on. I have CBN grinding wheels for all of my lathe tools. Under 'production' work, they are good for 5 or so years. I would expect diamond to last longer since it is a bit harder than the CBN.
I like your channel because you talk about stuff from knowledge and experience. There’s no bull💩which is great.
Listening to your videos has improved my sharpening skills and prevented me for wasteing some money. Keep bringing it Sir!
Excellent as always! Learn something every video. Thank you for doing these.
Agree. I don't use water at all to prevent rust. I sharpen swords and they can get rusty. I clean stone with baby oil to prevent rust too.
Hi Alex, I would love to know your views on scalpels as to what mskes them so sharp and if they are sharper than the knives you've sharpened. Also, please provide your views on blade sharpness testers. Much love from Canada ❤
Thank you so much from Costa Rica!! Really appreciate your work.
I purchased and learned to use the Sharpal stone and a strop following your instructions with great results. For the first time in my life, I can hand sharpen knives pretty well. Would a finer diamond stone be worth purchasing to obtain the "mirror finish" razor blade type edges, i.e., 3000 grit, etc.? If so, what do you recommend? Keep up the great videos. It has become one of my favorite channels. Thank you.
I would very much appreciate if you could make a video on sharpening "gentelmans knives" like CRKT CEO, Boker Kaizen/Nori/Kwaiken Air etc. I find them challenging due to the height of the blade being very minimalistic. I'm qurious if you have any tips specific to this type of knife.
Have you ever heard of or tried the MPOWER Tools diamond stone sets? They have different sets and I see Stumpy Nubs likes those a lot, and they seem practical,so if they're good, it might be a good deal.
Hi, can you explain in detail how to sharpen kitchen knife? I don't talk about those staight 1 dolar kitchen knife you show, I'm talking about curved kitchen knife. I know that "keeping angle" is most important but if you keep angle on straight part of knife and move your body, then, at least for me, on curved part knife just doesn't touch sharpening stone. I saw some short that said you need to move your elbow up and it helped a bit, but I would like to see your guide.
Use the search feature!?
I have a very old video on this, but plan on also making a new one👍
Love the channel. Just put together diy sharpener that I've seen on YT. Was wondering if you could recommend a 1" x (4" or 6") diamond stone(s) to use in the sharpener. Maybe some of you other sharpening junkies could tell what small diamond stones have worked for you. These will be use on my diy sharpener, router bits, ....thanks
Thanks for all your instruction!
Is it then a false economy to start a sharpening session with too fine a grit? For the benefit of the knife and the stone, what are guidelines for starting and finishing grit? Yes I'm sure it depends on many variables, beginning with how bad the edge is in the first place...
Krud Kutter is the best option for use on diamond stones. They will not work as well if you don't use a lapping fluid. Never seen a quality stone have any sort of rust. Though I use Ultra Sharp stones and they are basically the best you can get. If you are using cheap junk from Amazon, you get what you pay for. Also if you dry the stones with a rag after using the stones. Another thing is you can contaminate the diamond stones simply by going from a 300 to a 600 without wiping your knife off first.
Since you said that some diamond plates are embedded with nickel on carbon steel that prone to rust thus fasten their degradation, what's your opinion about diamond sharpening stones as tool used for lapping, dressing, and/or flattening water stones ?
On the same matter, is it better to use aluminum oxide/corondum based sand paper on a relatively flat medium such as glass? Since from economic aspect its far cheaper to replace sand paper that has little to none chance to rust.
Also from hardness aspect, aluminum oxide/corondum falls only 1 point behind diamond on mohs scale.
Thank you
Awesome vid
Thank you. That was very informative.
As always, the best stone is the one you have 😉 I have different diamond stones, both the nickel plated ones and resin bound ones. The resin bound ones, I save for specialty knifes and carbide tools. The other ones I use on all other knifes but as a rule of thumb I save the expensive nickel plated stones for the harder steels only. Those real cheap diamond stones with the oval holes in the plates are the only ones I don't use anymore since I ruined the tip of more than one knife and chisel on those.
Very informative video. Could you please do a video of the Japanese King Stone 1000/6000 grit stones please. And a video of how to sharpen a long blade fish fillet knife thanks when you get the time 😊
Hey, Alex. Can you do a video about knife edge maintenance? Are there any do’s and don’ts of cleaning a knife? I heard some people don’t wash their knives and just wipe them with a rag. Thanks!
*Can you do an updated video on sharpening Karambits/curved blades?*
Atoma ftw.
Never failed me, and I’ve been using a set of them for over a decade before having to replace my 400 & 600 plates.
Have you tried the 1200?
@@OUTDOORS55 I’ve been using it for years.
It’s a great plate to progress into, from the 600.
Gives you a nice refined finish, without taking any of the toothy feel away. A must have, IMO.
Another great video with some funny moments. :)
Excellent ideas, thank you!
Have you had the chance to try a Dianova stone?
It's a small Swedish make, so might be hard to find in the US.
I have a small hand-style sharpener (300/600 grit) from them that I've been quite happy with, it's nice and flat, and the grit seems even.
But I was looking for a bench stone that isn't the ultra-cheap oval-holed plate on plastic (I have one of those from Lidl, which is pretty good for what it is, but not quite as flat as I'd like).
Then I remembered the Dianova, and found out they make decent sized 300/600 grit lap stone called "Önne", for under $50(!), so I figured it's worth a shot. Seems to be plastic core, but as long as the plates aren't super thin, it'll hopefully be quite flat. (They also make a 1200/strop version, but I wanted it mainly for shaping chisels and plane blades.)
It's currently in the mail, so haven't been able to test it yet.
(Their site is currently "under construction" which is slightly unnerving since I haven't got the delivery yet, but I figure it's just a website update hopefully. They've been around quite a while, so I don't think they're going away.)
No affiliation, apart from being a Swede :)
i use 3m 675l finishingfilm, tape on a g10 plate, it works great
Have you ever tried the Fallkniven DC521? It's a 25 micron diamond stone bonded to a 5 micron ceramic stone. ~8"x2". Sells for less than $60.
Thanks for the video. Lots of great information!
I got to use a lubricant with my diamonds. usually water and dish soap. Friction at the apex is a thing with dry abrasives (less than micron thicc, thermal dynamics is the law) . Also metal and diamond dust gets into your lungs, since your nose is right above the grind stone. Just spray some dw40 after, its formulated to displace water and protect against rust. You are going to get contradicting views while giving sharpening advice, dont let your ego take over, its how we learn. I bugged cliff stamp as well (rip). Nylon brush can also clean the diamonds and they last forever. Rubber also releases dust, that you inhale, since your nose is at the grind stone
Dying for you to do a full test under the microscope of water vs honing fluid vs windex vs whatever else people say to use. I believe you, but there are a bunch of people that don’t and I’d like to see you show us what it takes to convince them.
I bought the Sharpal diamond stone and the manufacturer doesnt recommend using water to sharpen, just honing oil as the unique option.
@@vaguincolombia It’s on my wishlist, but haven’t bought one yet. Can you confirm if they say honing oil or honing fluid? I think there’s a difference but am not really sure, which is why I want him to do a deep microscopic dive.
For ski edging (which uses very similar diamond stones) I have always heard to use something like a 50/50 alcohol and water mix. Either ethanol or isopropyl alcohol.
@@PetesGuide The box says clearly "Honing oil". Honing oil is basically mineral oil USP grade which is for human usage and it is easy to clean with water and soap or if you want, you can use ODORLESS mineral spirits which is a more refined mineral spirits than the regular one with strong smell. Use the odorless mineral spirits with a toothbrush.
You can add water with a little dish washing liquid, sewing machine oil? To the list 👍
Thanks, this was a lot of information on diamond stones I wasn't aware of. Just because most kitchen knife sharpeners don't use this type of stones (some do use diamond stones that are more like powder on a typical ceramic stone) so they aren't very informed or don't see it worthwhile to talk about them a lot in depth. For example I've noticed you don't use water at all and wondered about it. Does one of those "eraser" stones (sabitoru I've seen some brand call it or maybe that was the brand name, Japanese package) used for cleaning kitchen utensils from rust help with rust on a diamond stone like that or is it just a lost cause to try? People sometimes clean their ceramic whetstones with those.
I wish you would review The Smiths 400 - 1,000 Grit, because it's supposed to be two stones bonded in plastic to keep grit contamination from happening. Also, is not having the diamond paste for the strop keeping me from getting hair splitting results?
If the knife has the newer harder steel, the diamond is the way to go
I wonder if the Atoma 400 isn’t to fine to start the sharpening. I want to buy diamond stones to go faster, now I start on a 300 King stone.
Thanks for the video 💪
Brake cleaner works great for cleaning diamond plates for me
What about toothbrush and isopropyl ?
Excellent video as usual!!! :-)
I do have a question that is not that common with the subject of sharpening of the apex, but as chef we do have a problem with our fine cuttings especially vegetables that sticks on the side of the knife and the question is, is it a hollow edge going to help by moving those fine small pieces away from the side of the blade because of the curve of the apex or is it a way we can make the side of the blade hydrophobic so they don't stick whatever the geometry of the apex is?
I found a paper about using Lazer to cut microscopic cuts on the surface so it become hydrophobic so since I don't have a Lazer that powerful in hand, I am wondering if we could make it hydrophobic by using the right size grain sandpaper.
Just a thought that could change the way professionals use their knives.
The problem is not only how sharp the apex is but also what the drag of the rest of the surface of the blade create, especially by applying force to move all those fine cuts upwards as we cut and finally they are released at the top of the knife.
My respect and love, brothers and sisters!!! :-)
What about diamond bonded resin?
Just a video suggestion
Love the content Alex!
I just did a video on them👍
those rubber things also work well for cleaning the grip tape on a skateboard.
Really surprised you didn't even mention bonded diamond stones, a very different beast from the plated. I pretty much use bonded stones and I prefer them to the plated, but they need to be lapped before use and have different characteristics from plated stones.
This was specific to plated stones. I have another video on resin bonded
What can the contaminated 1000 grit side of the S SATC diamond stone be used for? Is it just a slow 400 grit? Or completely useless?