A Melbourne Murder: The Case Of Maulin Rathod
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 сер 2024
- On July 23rd, 2018, a 000 call was made from a house in Sunbury in Melbourne, Australia. The caller bluntly and calmly said they thought they had killed someone. When officers arrived at the home, they were met with a face they knew all too well…and this would all be the tip of the iceberg as they started looking into this frightening case.
Our email is for business enquiries only.
linktr.ee/trul...
Sources 📝
pastebin.com/F...
Patreon 🖤
/ trulycriminal1
Buy Me A Coffee ☕️
www.buymeacoff...
Thank you to Jupiter Productions for making all of our original music 🎵
open.spotify.c...
/ jupiter-productions
Many thanks to 369 Film Studio In Leicester for the use of their sets and space to film some of the stock footage that has been shown in this video.
Further Resources ⬇️
www.mhm.org.uk...
www.mind.org.uk
mentalhealth-u...
suicideprevent...
www.samaritans...
www.papyrus-uk...
www.crisisserv...
www.suicidepre...
Gosh. I live in Melbourne and didn’t know this one.
I feel like there’s so many prejudices here. She’s a young white female with mental health issues. He was an Indian student here on a visa. If the roles were reversed there would ABSOLUTELY be a very different outcome. I’m absolutely disgusted and fear for my own children at the way our system works here.
Roles reversed? You mean like Rajwinder Singh?
Your desperate hunt for Racism™️ is cringe lol.
@@mjanny6330 you know exactly what he meant: an Indian student on visa in Australia, killing a white Australian woman.
Absolutely. The color of the skin had a big role to play.
@@marrmalade no ur country's justice system is just shit
I remember this case. I live 20 minutes from where it happened and people were and still are angry about her light sentence. How the jury came to the conclusion that she didn't premeditate this murder is beyond understanding.
You are right
Sunbury is called scumbury for a reason
The defence did too good a job unfortunately
If I ever have to go through a trial I will request a bench trial. Juries have proven time and time again that they are idiots. If you think about the collective intelligence of the population it's not that surprising.
Were you at the trial? If not, then you don't know everything that took place.
It feels as though more value was placed on her life than Mr. Rathod's. My heart goes out to his mother and father.
I am a hindu Indian too. To be fair, she gave him ample warning about her tendencies and it was clearly written in her dating bio. He said "he wanted to learn"?. I am sorry but he literally f*cked around and found out. Feel bad for the parents, but this is why you dont give in to your son's whims. Plenty of good educational institutes in India to study in.
If course it was.
Least racist Australian jury .
@@small_joys2022kinks are different than getting killed man. A lot of people have them. He told her he was okay but not with her hurting him. Everyone needs to be wary when meeting strangers online, doesn’t mean he deserved to be killed. It’s not something maybe you or I would do, but that doesn’t justify her actions or diminish the injustice he faced.
so frustrating!
@@small_joys2022 victim blaming, nice. -eyeroll-
The jury should be ashamed. How is it not premeditated???
And I thought juries here in the U.S. were empaneled with idiots. They have NOTHING on juries Down Under.
Because Australia is a racist country.
Yup really she knew days before she was gonna kill someone and hey your childhood dont determine whether you become a killer I was sexually, emotionally, verbually, and physically abused by my own mother and her father and I am not a killer its a choice shame on you ppl for not holding her accountable and letting her fool and manipulate you shit your letting her manipulate you like charles manson did to his followers
Exactly, she searched for ways to kill, she admitted it, she planned it
No they shouldn't. Play stupid games win stupid prize.
What the hell? This was clearly premeditated. How the jury acquitted of murder is incomprehensible.
No it's not. She was and always will be supervised by the state. She needs a medical model not a punishment model.
Just going to throw this out here. Although this story is researched and well done, none of us were present in the court room. And none of us know what was presented to the jury. Which means we can only wonder at her sentence.
I see so many comments about "bad" juries. Doesn't seem fair, when we weren't privy to the trial or its nuances. There are things we don't know in the legal proceedings of this case and most others. ❤
Outrageous. She will do it again .
Murder is not really punished in Australia. Australian juries are notorious for downgrading or acquitting murderers. That's why prosecutors there hate to take cases to trial and will accept almost any plea bargain they can get to avoid it. Murderers spend on average about five years in prison there.
@@BrenMurphy1 Could you please elaborate what Medical model means?
I'm certain her story is not over and will continue after she's released. She's made statements that guarantee she'll do it again. And while we're talking about her own words... how often do you hear of a murderer giving THIS many warnings on SM, to carers, on the dating app, and even to the victim? When someone tells you who they are, BELIEVE THEM.
I 100% agree with your comment. We have not heard the last of her. I'm positive she will be in the news again, accused of murder...again.
Ditto 😢 very sad.
Maybe she'll take the life of someone the jury actually cares about next time. SMH
so true. when people tell you who they are (and they always do-even if indirectly) Believe them! i learned that the hard way myself.
@@boop7313 Well said.
I don't think she should EVER be let out. She should be put in a mental health facility until she is too old to do harm and even then put into a place that she can be watched.
Her victim and his family shouldn't have to think about her again b/c she shouldn't be locked up and not get out but I guess here we are. Ugh
I dont think this woman will ever be too old to do harm.
Ever ? Really long time I take it you don't believe in rehabilitation?!
@@dianeshannon7988 good point lets rehabilitate a person that wanted to kill someone and had no remorse what are you on about murder should mean life in prison without parole you take a life you lose your own
@ryandougall7052 So you don't believe in the concept of rehabilitation then one has to rise above even if the crime is heinous
@@dianeshannon7988 question for you then can a serial killer be rehabilitated and does he deserve that chance
I think the real investigation should be done into the sanity of the jury members.
Lol...totally agree. Seems anyone can be picked for jury duty.
Lol a fine case of white privilege right there. How could this poor white woman murder a coloured fella
I wish some of us from this channel could have been on the jury.
Make all the people take a quick iq test before they are allowed on a jury 😂
@@dianeg7580 Do you not know how the jury system works? Every person over the age of 18 who is enrolled to vote, from all sections of the community, has an equal chance of being called upon to undertake jury service. The jury does not set the sentence.
I’m sorry but this boy got murdered in Australia by an Australian and it was the Australian government’s responsibility to at least send his body back to his parents knowing the fact the family was struggling financially!
They should have covered the cost for his family to be there for the trial too..
Well said. I totally agree. And yes, I am Australian.
I'm sad to hear there wasn't a crowd funding in the very least to get his parents out for the trial, I would've donated
It's Australia, so that was very on-brand for them. They couldn't care less about that young man and his family.
We have to keep in mind who was in govt at that time, the Lnp were disgraceful in more ways than one. Thank god we booted them out.
She should not be allowed back in society. She needs to be in prison or a mental facility for the rest of her life. If they're going to release her, which it unfortunately looks like, she needs to be heavily monitored. Otherwise she will re-offend.
People like her manage to reoffend even whilst under heavy surveillance I’m sad to say
People with that kind of mental illness who have committed violent crimes and who are released back into society need to be treated like convicted sex offenders: put on a watch list, be under regular police surveillance, with the community in which they live being made aware of their presence; and being restricted in who they are allowed to associate with. The safety of the public comes first!
I'm so sorry for his parents. As the parent of an only child, I'm not sure if I would be able to recover.
There is no pain like losing your only child.
Dude should have known better. She blurted our her red flags on her profile. Front page!
And he didn't see the warning signs? Was clearly blinded by his desires.
Prey willingly walked into a prowling predator's claws(thighs?)
Atleast should have thought of his family's sacrifices before engaging in cheap thrills. Only feel sorry for his family.
She should never be released. She is very dangerous. I can't believe she only basically got five years. Surely they should have lifetime follow-up after she's released. RIP Maulin! Thank you Truly Criminal ⭐
Yes she had trauma from her childhood but she knew what she was doing. She even searched on-line on how to murder and get away with it. Unbelievable! Shame on the jury! May the victim Rest In Peace.
May the jury NOT
Guilty of only manslaughter and not murder? Why ?? And she will be out in a few years. That is scary as hell.
Why??
She has an impairment I don't agree BUT that's the fact in law the leniency is something else though
She clearly had intent to kill him because she looked up how to murder someone on google. She pretty much said it, looked up how to do it and said it made her feel good. Disorder or no disorder she understood right from wrong and definitely premeditated it. It's terrifying thinking about her getting out. She will do it again, 100%.
Agree whether she will rekill is an unknown she was too unsupervised carers pros whin were scared of her should also not be in that role if they can't manage her and avoid their remit to be fair
Did they use this evidence for the trial?
Yeah doesn't really make sense
What an appalling outcome! What is the matter with judges and juries that they can't see how dangerous people like this are? She will kill again as soon as she is freed and will probably get away with again and again. Horrible!
Our justice system in Australia is an absolute joke. And the police are too busy chasing revenue to worry about a teenager threatening that she might do something one day.....sad but true
@@dannii2323 It is not the police's fault, they do not sentence people. And are restricted by laws as to who and why they can arrest and hold people.
@janetpendlebury6808 very true, their hands are tied hey
I was sitting here watching it in the early stages saying I bet she gets two years, if that. I can see I wasn't far off.
Australia really does hold to its history of being a land of convicts allowed to roam free.
@SoWhatIDC couldn't agree more. They give everyone a slap on the wrist over here....free to roam and continue to commit escalating crimes
I live in Melbourne and have lived in Sunbury and I have never heard of this case! Great job!
I’m a western suburbs girl and I’ve also never heard of this!
same here i heard nada
Same here! This is crazy!
I live in Queensland and can safely say it didn't make national news because we've heard nothing about it either.
Same here guys. Melbourne Australia girl here and I hadn’t heard of this case before. 😮
As an Aussie living in Victoria I can confirm the continuing failure of mental health care. My son was temporarily a danger to himself and others yet we could not access care for him until he acted upon it. Relying on an overloaded and broken system often results in a "too little too late" senario for some people.
This woman has made it clear she should not be trusted. My heart breaks for his parents.
😞😞😞😞
The problem is global. I'm in UK and agencies here will only act after someone's been hurt.
Her bio on the dating app was just disturbing. How can anyone even want to have a conversation with her after reading that? This girl has deeper issues. This poor man was just naive but he definately didn't deserve this.. 😟
Hectic
He was a pervert….remember india is the rape capital of India
He saw she had all sorts of sexual fetishes and rrpe fantasies and he immediately thought he's gonna score...
Guy is a idiot he should have arranged a escort .
A Single lapse in judgement and suspension of intellect was all it took for him to get murdered. I sympathise with his family. He should have thought about their sacrifices. People often divulge their darkest secrets or escapades to their closest friends. And assuming he did tell about the
" adventures" he was going to have, I wonder why they didn't stop him.
I'm curious what the jury and judge would have done had the roles been reversed. I doubt he would have received five years and nine months had he searched the internet for how to kill before her arrival and then proceeded to strangle her to death, and immediately confessed his guilt and planning of the crime. I don't think it would have been a manslaughter conviction or any concern given to him feeling as remorseful as he was capable of.
The obvious truth that most Australians in the comments don't want to admit to. To the jury she's the one who's like their own daughter, he is just some foreigner.
If the murder of Grace Millane is anything to go by: Kempson was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum non-parole period of 17 years (he had a history of hurting women).
@@JoliNatural The Grace Millane case immediately came to my mind also, there are definite similarities between the two but, interestingly, very different outcomes in the trial and very different terminology in these comments when discussing the victim.
@@DinoCism Im not Australian but she must be condemned for murder and after paying her years being put in a mental health center surveilled 24/7. Anybody deserve being killed by any mental sick damaged person. We wouldn´t travel or seek a better future abroad if we had for certain such horrendous crime would happen to us.
In much countries for murder the aggressor must serve 20/30 YEARS of his/her life. In US even can end up in the Death Row depend the country. Im sorry for the guy parents for losing his child in such manner.
When I was working as a nurse in mental health in Melbourne, I cared for a few women in community care units who also had extreme borderline personality disorders. I agree with the assessments made of this woman even though I never knew her. However, going by the extreme behaviours of my patients/clients it's a wonder this sort of thing doesn't happen more often.
The things these women did to themselves, to others including staff were shocking and the stuff of nightmares. I was always hypervigilant and like the other staff frequently phoning the emergency services. Driving to the CCU one night, I was confronted by an ambulance, a fire truck and a police car all with sirens wailing. I nearly drove off. There had been three separate incidents, requiring all three services!
There would be knife threats (rehab units must have knives to prepare food!), other physical and verbal threats towards themselves other patients and staff, fake allegations of rape, fake suicide attempts, a couple patients had pets they neglected so I had to call the RSPCA, most of the staff had their cars vandalized, though mine wasn't for reasons unknown.
I received a phone call one evening from a police officer who said to me (paraphrasing) we at the police station don't know how you guys do the job that you do. Wow, I was shocked and thanked him for his recognition.
Yep, mental health staff don't carry tasers or guns. Our only protection are our emergency button and our wits. De-escalation only works if you know what's coming.
The judge got it wrong BIG time. It's impossible for some judges to accept the views of other professionals.
I'm deeply sorry for the loss of this young man's life. She should've been locked up a long time ago. The world is not safe with these kinds of individuals roaming free. Counselling and medication have their limits, obviously.
My deepest condolences to the family.
Not all these kind of people should be locked yp what in cages like animals and you work in mh??
Community mental health care is not enough for people with such severe mental illness.
@@dianeshannon7988 No need for cages; simply enough to protect the public.
Totally agree with you. These people are broken beyond repair. They need to be locked up, and society kept safe from them. Too many are roaming around killing, and the victims should have been safe. We had a senior police officer who warned everyone his son would kill his wife, and no one did a think. He was let out after 72 hours, went straight home, and stabbed his mother to death. Over a hundred stab wounds.
@@sheribrougham4863 So you are saying all people with BPD should be locked up?
Cases like this are especially frustrating because the signs are all there of a person who has a mental illness. This murder could have been prevented.
Yes, if only he had of listened to her!!
😏
Like all who also have mental illness and murders too, there is no stopping anyone from hurting someone. Mental health care is shoddy, and if patients refuse treatment, even family can’t force them. Can they really be helped and treated to not hurt? I don’t know… Unless admitted to an institution that costs money or admitted after a crime.
Seriously though-the testimony of the caregivers about how frightening she was and there really needs to be an option for involuntary institutionalization for some folks. Before they kill someone.
@@justkiddin84absolutely for everyone's sake
She's disgusting in many ways. Such a monster that karma will catch up with. She murdered that man with premeditation.
If karma/God was real we wouldn't have justice systems. Can't rely on that shit.
How awful it must have been for the guys family. After all they did to try and give him a ‘better’ life. Sad, man.
Should have taught him not to be a pervert tho
@@haqq1234and that deserves death?!
Common sense and ethics should go hand in hand with education.
I only sympathise with his family who trusted him.
Play stupid games win stupid prizes.
@@brandonpinto5290 Seek help
I am an Aussie, and I’m disgusted with her sentence. 🤬 That poor guy and his family. She will surely kill again.
I think all these jurors should be evaluated by mental health professionals too!!
I'm thinking they came from mental health ward!!!
When you said acquitted, I literally gasped. There's people in prison for nonviolent crimes & doing a decent amount of time. She's (unfortunately) going to have to kill someone to get life like she Should've. I'm in awe.😮😢
Rip angel 🕊🌈🩵
Thank you TC, you guy's are great.
God bless 👑🙏🕊🌈❤️🩹
She need to be in a 24/7 Psychiatry institute once released from jail
I dont know whats more shocking; the fact that total strangers meet up for such dangerous sex even though theres zero trust built, the fact that such a crazy monster can go about unchecked and is able to kill someone despite it being obvious to many, or the fact that the jury unanimously thought what she did wasnt premeditated. WTF!
It is absolute madness.
She was honest in her profile so he should’ve known he’d be in trouble. How sick was he to be attracted to THAT?
@nancymesek yeah that's what was crazy, she was honest but he went ahead anyway :/
@@nancymesekExactly,educated,came from respectable family who sacrificed so much for him and he was into this sort of disgusting stuff,it's weird that some people look and act normal and yet harbour such nauseating mentality deep inside of themselves, couldn't he find a decent girl and date her.
Uh, definitely the second two.
Good God, were her Google searches and what she had told the detectives not admitted into evidence??? I have no idea how the jury could have acquitted her of the more serious charge of murder; and not only that, but how the judge could have sentenced her to such a light sentence, especially after what he had to say and put in writing about the matter. These people will be sorry once this freak is a free woman and does something else along the same lines. If exorcisms worked, I would say Jamie definitely needs one. She should be locked up in a psych ward for life. Hate to wish harm to anyone, but hope she in fact takes out another inmate or at least attempts to so she can be charged with that, tried, and get plenty more time added on to her sentence.
Poor Maulin, as well as his parents.
Thanks for sharing the story, sisters, and hope you're enjoying the weekend!
Because she is white
I think that’s discrimination against Indians at its best but well the country will have to deal with her again soon. Sad but karma for the jury
@@tkkumarr terrible accusation ... If you want to go there ??? look at Puneet Puneet... Where is the justice for his victim ???
@@moocher9935 truth hurts yea
@@tkkumarr 🙄🤦♀️
They knew she was a danger. Carers were terrified of her. But when she turned 18 everyone stepped back from her and left her to it! Shes most definitely guilty, but so are the authorities who just left her to it! Its so tragic, that this poor man was murdered
I disagree only to the extent that all of Australia's laws are fashioned to an unrealistic view that all can be rehabilitated. No they can't. These examples are evil. When she gets out she will do this again. It is part of who she is. Wonder how the jurors will feel when she murders someone they personally love and care for. Also is Australia so poor a country that they couldn't afford plane tickets for his parents? Yet they paid to keep this evil woman in the community. Housed and staffed. Put their own fellow Australians in danger first living with her then only visiting her. How stupid and shortsighted.
Yep!
NO. •• you don't get to blame other people for what she chose to do. Plenty of mentally ill people don't harm other people.
@@real_MacrocosM👏
@@real_MacrocosM Not many mentally ill people are as ill as this person was, she needed help from a young age, she told authorities she was feeling this way, she was crying out for help and the people in charge of her did nothing. There are hundreds of different mental illness's out there, I am sure if she was given the correct medication early on, and kept under supervision this would not have happened.
Wow . Just wow. What kind of justice is this!!?
None at all 😞 it’s infuriating
This girl looks up how to murder on the web before meeting the victim… like she obviously wanted to kill him that combined with her confession of premeditation it’s completely unacceptable she is going to be out in the public in just a couple years. Jurors should be ashamed of themselves.
Some of the dumbest jurors I've ever heard of.
these jurors are psycho to just like her they to need to be locked up letting a killer by her own admission go free basically what is 3 years for murder ridiculous
Jurors are racist psychopaths
On the contrary I have zero doubt the jurors hi fiver each other over a job well done. Least racist Australian jury.
That poor man. It seems like he worked so hard in life, worked hard to please everyone. That one night he wanted to let go of control, stress, & effort in his daily life, & he ends up with that evil insane woman. Just my op. Rip!
😂 Let go of stress you clown he was a right sick muppet!!
The red flags were there for all to see. He should have known better than to do stuff with total strangers. He chose to listen to what his other head said. I only feel sorry for his family whose trust he broke and left them further in debt.
RIP Maulin. Sincere condolences to the family and friends. This is not the last we've heard of this case as many have predicted, there'll be a repeat unfortunately.
I can’t believe she’s gotten such a light sentence. I had to go back cause I thought I heard it wrong. She should be in a mental institution then prison for taking this gentleman’s life. It’s just astonishing. She’s going to do it again if she gets out guaranteed! Sad. Thanks for covering this case. I watch a good amount of true crime & haven’t heard of this one before. Much ♥️& all the best all.
Oh yes, she will. She _said_ "You won't believe me, you never believe me" so she's playing out the destruction of her trust in someone.
& she will do so again. & again. & again.
She should be in a mental institution "or" prison, not both. If a person is unwell when they committed the crime, you can't send them to prison after mental health treatment, as it isn't the same mind state who commited the crime originally. Sending them to both is like having your cake and eating it too. Just wrong. That's what they'd do in the US, and we all know how messed up their justice system is.
Her urges won't stop
I knew from the start that she wouldn't get anything. I was thinking two years.
@@LadyAstarionAncunin sad to think that’s all his life was worth in the courts eyes. All the best to you & yours.
What kind of jury were they? 🤬 With that amount of evidence against her how did they come to that decision?
I wonder if they'd feel the same if after her SHORT sentence she moved into a house next-door to one of them 🤔
The jury do not determine how long a sentence someone gets, and the jury were made up of people over the age of 18.
The jury new exactly what it was doing. Least racist Australian jury.
What a sad story all around. Sad that she had such a disturbing profile up on a dating site AND SHE GOT A HIT?! Sad this man died! Sad that this woman had a horrific upbringing. And sad that her sentence was not longer. Australia has pretty light sentences considering the crimes, its really frustrating. She SHOULD be put in hospital for the remainder of her life, even she kept telling people she's not well.
This makes me sick. Her Google searches, admission was clear. What the hell is wrong with this jury. Unbelievable
It’s interesting how I live in Melbourne n never heard of the story. Oh my true crime channels r just incredible. Great work ❤️
You would've heard about it loud and clear if the roles were reversed.
This is madness, although I have never understood Australian and Canada’s justice system. She should have been put in a psychiatric prison for life. She will do this again… RIP to the victim 🙏🏿
27th😂
The first thing you hear when something like this happens "if only we'd know. We could have done something." It's actually quite often we know about a lot of these people and do nothing. She is for sure guilty of first degree murder. But she's crazy as they come. She should never be released.
Wow the jury got it wrong on that one!!! I live in Melbourne and have not heard of this case. Sometimes the legal system does not execute justice. Thanks as always for a great video and for regularly including Australian content 💜💜💜💜💜💜
I live in Sunbury & did hear about it at the time... She should not be released obviously... She is not mentally stable but our judicial system is a joke
@@moocher9935I'm curious about something... Do you know if the Australian public tried to blame the court's decision on white privilege in favor of the girl? or accusations of racism toward the jury? I know here in America if this same thing happened the media and many of the American people would be raging mad about what they perceive to be racism and white privilege. Is that sort of mentality prevalent in Australia too?
I'm another person from Melbourne and haven't heard of this case. It's terrifying to think she will be out so soon and got such an inappropriate sentence. My heart breaks for his family, I cannot imagine putting everything into helping your child live their dream for something this horrific to happen and then to be so woefully let down by the system that it took so long to get him home, that they were unable to attend the trial and then to have the final insult to injury of that sentence. While I understand how much a horrifically abusive childhood can effect you, she had a choice and she chose violence because it made her feel good.
Oh my God i live in Sunbury, and I've got to admit, I'd hate to see her back in the community any time soon... if ever. I can't believe her sentence was 3 years. How is that justice for the family?
Do we address the elephant in the room, or do we continue wondering aimlessly why the sentence was so light?
There's 2 elephants as far as I can see
Gender and race 😅.
I often feel that sentences here in the U.S. are far too harsh, but less than six years for deliberately taking a life is ridiculous. The fact that there doesn't seem to be any plan for treatment or supervision after she is released is terrifying.
What an absolute farce of the justice system. God Bless Maulins family. And heaven help when she’s released again.
I'm an Indian and is truly shocked, disgusted and bewildered,if the roles were reversed I can visualise without doubt how the judgement would have been passed. Its disgusting,at the very least his parents should be compensated by the Australian authorities for their loss though no amount can weigh the precious life of their beloved son....
Lol what a load of crap! How many people dying in India, you gonna compensate them all for their suffering or youse all just gonna come over here . Lol.
Also, no, if the roles were reversed it would make ZERO DIFFERENCE, do you have any idea how many men have murdered their exes over the last decade and have gotten away with it, actually!! So many that there's a whole friggin DV laws revolution going on here atm bcoz it keeps happening, so shut the fuk up with your whiny gender crap it's total bull.
she should have been sent into a psychiatric hospital for an indeterminate amount of time before the crime even happened
As a melbournian I am disgusted, sad, horrified and scared after watching this. I understand the defence planting the seed for manslaughter but I can’t understand the judge giving the lower end sentence. Very scary to think of her on the streets, ever
Thanks for reminding me why I don't do dating apps.
Wow. Just wow. When she gets out she should be made to go live with those bonehead jurors. Pretty sure even a child could deduce that someone looking up 10 ways to commit murder then killing someone is actually a murderer.
But she isn't. She is a damaged person who tried and tried to get people to listen to her. Hope she manages to find some stability when she gets out.
@@Erebus.666.🙄
@@Erebus.666. - She's a murderer. It's not difficult to see that she knew what she was doing and it would end in his death.
I'd like to know a lot more about what she did to get help - did she sincerely seek out medical help, or did she make herself a perpetual pain in the arse to all who came across her?
Yes her past is no doubt tragic but just because it results in a narcissistic psychopathic personality it shouldn't absolve you of murder if intent is there, or there wouldn't be murder convictions for 95% of serial killers. Nor should the public at large be put at danger just because the roots of her problems are in a childhood of abuse that she's not responsible for.
@@simonw1313 She was in state care from the age of 10 and everyone agreed they were scared of her and she was not 'normal', yet they did nothing for her! She told them over and over about how she was feeling and the authorities ignored her, they washed their hands of her as soon as they legally could. Making herself 'a pain in the arse' as you call it, was her crying out for help when she was a child, instead of perpetually punishing her they should have sought help for her. The state has a lot to answer for. She should have been sent to a secure mental health facility not prison, she is not going to get much help for her mental condition there.
@@janetpendlebury6808 - I'd like to know how she went about asking for help - neither you or the film details that. Nor is there much on what went wrong with her care or the nature of the abuse she suffered - both of which presumably were aired in court.
It was implied she was committing offences to ask for help. She apparently didn't go to a doctor.
That jury are the ones that need to be psychologically evaluated-- insane - she’ll get and do it again - blood is on their hands - you don’t need to know the past to see what she did period.
💜💛💜💛💜🕊
Rest in peace young man
My heart goes out to all of his family and friends 💕
As an Indian, I truly believe racism and discrimination had a role in the verdict. She is a white Australian woman, while he was just another Indian living on a student's visa. This case is evidence for Indians studying abroad to be extra careful because the authorities of those countries will just see you as an outsider. Truly shocked and sad for the parents. May they find peace.
Tru dat
you have forgotten about paneet paneet the soft cock that ran away
The most handsome Indian in Australia:
ua-cam.com/video/g4n5q-Ttbcc/v-deo.html
But if he didn't message her he be alive. Any one could have message her but he choose to. It don't matter why the poor man is dead by a sick evil individual.
I'm indian but your wrong
I’m Australian and the legal system here is so lenient. It’s actually disturbing to most.
We see time after time that no justice is given to victims and their families. It’s pathetic and truly unjust.
It's infuriating
I don’t wanna point any fingers tho but don’t u think it was tad racially driven judgement? Id like to hear some thoughts
@@uglybetty8747 no, I don’t believe race had anything to do with it. Judges in Australia are impartial and objective. The laws around minimum sentences for certain crimes are the issue.
Australian here too. Race had nothing to do with it. The justice system here is not objective or unbiased at all. I have first hand experience in this area and I can say without any hesitation men and women are treated very differently. I can give many examples of this if interested
I hadn't heard of this case, and I live in the state of Victoria in Australia. I had a look at her socials, and wow. The signs are there. I hope, if she does get parole, which I hope she doesn't, she goes straight from jail to a psychiatric facility. She should not be left to her own devices, to roam around in the world and do this again!
You would've heard about it loud and clear if the roles were reversed. Unfortunately this a murder you can't politically exploit, so.
@@shawnredmond8402 it shouldn't matter which way the genders go, should it? Just sad.
As always, great work on a video. Narration, transition, especially the soundtracks are done really well. My favorite crime stories channel.
I work with people like this girl... long term residential care 24/7 watch in group homes..... this video shows you... this is 1% of what they think, feel and act like.... residents like her, unbelievably dangerous... go from happy to trying to bite your face in a split second.... smearing body fluids, self harm... alot of sexual behaviors.. I'm so stunned they let her out into the world once 18 smh our heath care system is broken
She has been failed since day one.. then that poor boy paid for it.. then she (and public safety) was failed yet again because she should never be allowed out of a psychiatric hospital. Ever. His poor parents 💔
Also worth mentioning, at least in passing, that she is a psychopathic scumbag.
Idc how bad of a childhood you had, it’s no excuse to kill . None excuse is good for murder . Period
Do you know the difference between an excuse and a cause?
Right? I had a horrible childhood, but that did not diminish my ability to know right from wrong.
@@cw9007 Well said. This girl was definitely suffering.
@@cw9007 I do I meant what I said .
@@Erebus.666. she played y’all for a fool and it worked on you too … no one “unstable “ would google what she did or do what she did period
How would the Jury feel if something like that happens to their own relative or child? Will they still give such a verdict? Seriously this woman is openly admitting to her twisted worldview and still she was given 3 and a half year punishment? Wow just wow
Former British colony it is. What more can you expect..?
If victim is brown then forget about justice 💀
@@Women-hate-short-men exactly!!
Disgusting sentencing. House her near the jury foreman. Feel so sad for his family. Shit childhood is no excuse for sadistic murder.
I definitely believe she new she was going to kill him she needs help not let out on her own she needs help
How does someone stop needing 24 hour care the second they turn 18?
I can’t decide if she’s just using her mental illness as an accuse or if she’s a plain evil psychopath! RIP Maulin you did not deserve this ❤
Both, I suspect.
Her problems are undoubtedly tied back into her childhood abuse. Yet here she is a full sized narcissitic psychopathic adult who clearly premeditated this murder - and largely got away with it. Things are unlikely to improve when she's released in her mid twenties. God help anyone who gets involved with her post release.
@@simonw1313 I agree and so people like her need to be institutionalised because rehabilitation is highly unlikely.
Her mental illness is that she's a plain evil psychopath. The thing that makes her irredeemable has been twisted around by the perverse Australian legal system to make her into the victim while victimizing the actual victim's family a second time.
Love your channel, I’m from Melbourne Australia 🇦🇺 take care & be safe in this crazy world ❤❤
Most people with MI can live on their own or with others - but - some clearly need to be in long term hospitalisation. This is an example of the latter.
I agree with you. It can be managed.
This is an extreme case of neglect to all concerned.
She will clearly reoffend… 😮
This is so sad…the world needs to wake up and realize that mental illness is at an all time high!!!
Cannot tell what you are trying to say.
@@eadweard. …I’m saying that there are no residential programs anymore for people who need help. Unless you are a millionaire, genuine mental health care is not available to you.
@@minini5571it's just endless waiting lists and medication changes.
Christ, people selling drugs get more than that. That is an insult to the victim. Was his life worth so little.
Mental Illness always seems to trump Justice. This Channel is excellent, one of the best presentations of Crime Drama. Thank you for another great narrative. RIP Maulin
I’m always surprised when people think the jury decision is a real justice. The jury are a bunch of people who more than often are not capable of making the best choices and decisions in their own lives and yet they’re expected to decide about a justice and other people’s lives. It’s ridiculous and the jury on this case proved their incompetence 💯
Why exactly would he go with her at all after seeing her on line profile? Shocked that he would do that. He seemed a nice guy. She was so very sick.
That was a detail that I noticed, too. Not that much of a ‘nice guy’ if he was attracted to that profile… 🤔
It's like he drank a bottle of poison despite the label.
Sometimes, I seriously, without humor, think it must be so difficult living with an organ that is so set on coitus that it will betray a man to his death. Even men who know of this case would likely still meet a woman online to "bang" if she offers it freely. There's something so stupid about it. And, no, I don't mean it in a man-hating way. Love men, but I don't love how greedy and stupid their "little friend" makes them.
He was probably looking for someone easy to get laid.
@@toagoodhome46Indeed
As an Indian, and a former international student, I cannot tell you how much my friends fantasised of having non-Indian (read: white girls) dates and girlfriends. In their mind, having a white gf would be considered an achievement.
Unfortunately, this kid ignored all the red flags for a little "one-night action", and had to lose his life. My heart goes out to the family, such a horrible loss.
I live in Melbourne and have never heard of this case! Thank you
I too live in Melbourne. I can't recall hearing about this one either.
Have you heard of Colin Campbell Ross? Thre are videos on his case, known as the Gun Alley murder. If you haven't, you should look it up. It's madness.
You truly are my favorite!! I always switch right on immediately. Thank you 😊
Way to make my weekend ladies!! 🙏🖤✌️
I live in Melbourne I don't remember this case...she planned to kill that young man she said that in her statement to the police...she will kill again when she's released I wonder is she receiving any mental health care in prison ?...thankyou for covering this one does the sentence shock me...sadly it doesn't our justice system is dreadful in Australia 😢
I don’t think any amount of mental health care could help this psycho. The only way to protect the world from her is life confined to a solitary mental ward. She will most definitely kill again as soon as she’s released imo. I wonder how the judge and jurors would feel if she moves into their neighborhoods once released. Unbelievable that she could be released so soon. 😳😬
@@ruthlody7300 I agree 💯!
Psychopaths can not be rehabilitated, unfortunately.
@@ruthlody7300 I concur!
Oh I definitely agree rehabilitation will not work on her but she will be out of prison unless she kills a fellow inmate of course...the court's in Australia are a joke honestly how could they come up with such a pitiful sentence for this crime...
"How to commit a murder and get away with it" looks like she got away with it. Truly shocking, especially for Parents whoes son will never come back, only because someone was depressed, and faced abuse in their life and felt like killing someone..... what rubbish.
She didn’t get away with it, her karma will come and it will be extremely bad.
Seems a fairly clear case of murder to me. She pre-planned it and clearly had intent. Cluster B type personalities (Borderline personality disorder, narcissism and psychopathy) shouldn't be mitigating factors let alone a get out of responsibility for murder card. For sure her care was a mess, and her childhood was a mess, but that should have been *possible* mitigation factors in a sentence for murder.
Agree totally. I have BPD and the responsibility is on me to maintain my health. If anyone is unable to do that for themselves, they need mandatory, consistent care to ensure they don't harm themselves or others.
Time after time factors which should ensure you are kept from harming people are actually used to victimize those who are harmed a second time by being twisted into some sob backstory for the murderer as if the world isn't full of people with trauma/mental illness who have never hurt anyone.
I’m sorry but that sentence is a ridiculous insult 😡 I feel so awful for Maulin and his family not getting the justice they deserved. I hope I’m wrong but I have a feeling we’ll be hearing her name again once she is released
definitely will
the joyous words she used to admit to police that she killed him she will definitely find the next victim with another excuse of her past childhood
Yes, she should be institutionalized for life-maybe not prison, but not on the dang street.
@@justkiddin84 I agree but Australia did away with institutions a long time ago. Has it helped? , no, far from it. The mental health system is broken, people struggle to get psych appointments, there just isn't adequate help available to meet the ever growing demand. I believe some people such as her need to be institutionalised for life. For her own good and for the good of the general public who should not have to live in fear.
People are scary
This sounds more like psychopathy than BPD. To have no remorse, to not feel empathy and to have to do extreme acts or kill another person just to feel anything at all? Sounds like the beginnings of an unorganised serial killer. Scary stuff.
Are you a psychiatrist?
@@cw9007 Hi, gosh no. Just an interest in criminal psychology.
@@cw9007 - Going by the information in the film it's clear she has narcissitic and psychopathic traits. Obviously that information is limited and she could be border line personality disorder. So what? Whichever it is she's an absolute menace who could premeditate murder and very likely to spread fear and misery and possibly death when she's released in her mid to late twenties.
Yeah I'm in tendency to agree. People with BPD tend to hurt themselves not others
Thank you, for covering a case where the murder victim is male. It is all too common (~80%!) and needs to be highlighted worldwide.
I just never understand why people just meet strangers of dating websites 😢 😞 so scary and so sad..
I just never understand why people want to kill strangers they meet on dating sites 😢😞
@@AreniapixieAs failures of understanding go, yours seems the more relatable.
feeling for the parents who gave their all for a better & brighter future!!
Lots of love for the breaved couple from Pakistan
Honest to God- What the hell?? I have never, ever heard of a more deranged person being let down by every single aspect of society- Parents, social workers, Dr's, prosecution, police, detective work-ending with the most abhorrent conviction from the Jury to the light sentence given by the Judge- WTF does this woman need to do or say that would make those people understand what an unstable dangerous. person she is and what she is capable of. She's the only one thinking realistically!
I live in Melbourne and I've never heard of this case. After responding to her disturbing Plenty of Fish ad what did he expect... any female who says she likes being gang raped against her will clearly has some issues.
Justice was not served for Maulin's death... in fact the light given sentence was an insult to Maulin's family, a proof that for the Judge and the Jury his life had very little importance!!
RIP Maulin & Courage to his parents, friends and loved ones
OMG, 9yrs, r u joking? Australia judicial system really let the victim down. The sentence is a slap in the face to his family.
please nobody cross her path if you see her run like you never ran before once shes out she’s definitely going to kill again
Disgusting. She's obviously very dangerous. My heart is with his family. How let down they must feel after sending him somewhere they thought he would be safe and happy. 😢
The jury will regret their decision to acquit this despicable monster. 💞🇿🇦
I'm totally a feminist but dude, if she was a man, she would have gotten life. This is so scary, she should never be released. Poor guy. Poor family.
I don’t know if that’s true unfortunately, with all the mental health issues, the profile and how he’d agreed to be strangled plus the rest.
@@felbicky6333 - he'd agreed to be choked and both agreed to a safe sign - she ignored the safe sign and strangled him to death for fun. Fun that was premeditated.
She literally knew what she was doing. The whole "I wish he'd stopped me" schtick is just about deflecting responsibility.
I've no problem with mental health defences when it's psychosis (the person has literally left reality) or some other issue that's directly related to the offence. But in this case it was psychopathic, and if psychopathy allows you to escape from responsibility you'd need to let out 95% of serial killers from jail.
Oh my God, I can’t imagine what his Mom and Dad are going through 😭😭😭
"She wanted the victim to stop her" ..... what in the freaking hairy hornballs did i just hear?! If she doesn't think the police would've believed her about her issues then she should've admitted herself to a psych ward. This is a travesty. She hasn't gotten any help. He's dead. Other people are at risk.....Imma go cuddle my kitty cat now. Fur therapy is awesome.
You heard a narcissistic psychopathic personality attracting more attention to herself and trying to pass off responsibility for those who didn't "help" her. She is clearly irredeemable, she clearly premeditated and should have been found guilty of murder.
This is absolute madness. I cannot believe this outcome!
And the Australian government should be bloody ashamed of themselves for the entirety.
Not sending his body home, not helping his parents - I’m literally disgusted to the point of nausea and goosebumps. Vile. And the jury - they all need an assessment because I’m mortified at their decision too! RIP sweet man
The jury got this so wrong! This POS is evil to the core. Regardless of her crappy upbringing, she was still capable of making good choices for herself (as we all are - damaged or not) but, she chose to take this young mans life, a life she had no right to take and his poor family are left heartbroken. It saddens me that they were not even able to afford to get to Australia for the trial. This sucks big time. A gofundme should have been set up for his family to be here. She is a monster!! I hope she never gets out. I hope her life sucks for ever. She deserves nothing less than that.
This is so shocking and disturbing !
The jury has future blood on their hands how incompetent
I feel like she knew what she was doing and that the murder was premeditated.
There is no justice in this case. I feel sorry for the victim, the victims family, and for her. I’m talking about her mental health issues. Everyone loses here. 😢