He was innocent. But a facial recognition 'match' got this Black man arrested
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 кві 2021
- Nijeer Parks couldn't have committed the crime. That didn't stop police from arresting him based off of a false facial recognition match. Here's why the technology can often misidentify Black people, with serious consequences.
Produced by John General & Jon Sarlin
Supervising Producer: Bronte Lord
Production Assistant: Sofia Barrett - Наука та технологія
He could prove he was 30 miles away at the time, and they didn't care.That's insane!
Yet Tim Scott thinks there's no institutional racism in America
That is insane.
@@Angel-tw3ko unbelievable!! Just a sad state of affairs.
@@Angel-tw3ko This completely proves institutional racism, there must be a kkk guy programming the algorithm to that software to prosecute black people, or maybe cameras need lighting and black people don't reflect light very well,but thats not racist enough.... let's go back to blaming the camera for racism because that makes sense.... remember folks we must find racism in all things or it's not worth reporting.
@@Angel-tw3ko Anthony Ray Hinton did too and they sent him to death town for almost 30 years.
“ i shouldn’t have to prove that i am innocent , you should prove that i am guilty” well said bro
Only if u Black ⚫
He didn’t need to say that ... it’s OBVIOUS and FAMOUS slogan in the justice system ... it’s like when trump supporters was saying the democrats should prove massive voter fraud didn’t happen ... smh ... the mother is lying when she saying the picture don’t look like the guy . It looks like him ... but it’s not looking exactly like him
100%
@@dannychong7842 djal is nit allah. Allah is not one eyed.
Amerkkkan judicial business at its best. People trying to call it a justice system. Smdh
"I shouldn't have to prove that I'm innocent. You should have to prove that I'm guilty". I felt that as a Black male in the US.
I felt that as a white male in the US.
Shit gives me chills man
@dejialaran
Until they choose to acknowledge the truth about black people history in America, they will forever minimize and detach themselves of what black people faces daily with WS.
@dejialaran
Because, I acknowledge WS is wrong, I am prejudice? Therefore, I will look within myself, so that I can change any ways that are not pleasing to God!
Romans 2:11
For God does not show favoritism.
Matthew 22:36-40
36 “Teacher, which is the greatest commandment in the Law?” 37 Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ 38 This is the first and greatest commandment. 39 And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ 40 All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.”
@@coronahotel4967 Do you have to make everything about yourself...??
What they didn't say is that if he couldn't afford to bail out of jail, he would have been sitting in jail for a year waiting for trial.
Oh yeah. Who can't afford to take a year away from their life while they defend themselves in court, to friend/family and their employer.
Possibly more! Kalief Browder spent almost 3 years in jail and 700 days in solitary confinement for an accusation of stealing a backpack, a misdemeanor, that he did not steal.
This type of horror is why advocates have been fighting to ban facial recognition for years.
Are you joking? Its not a perfect science by any means. People can change their face, features and more. Do you know how rare it is for this to happen? Do you know how many terrorists, criminals, killers and worse are found and tracked by this? One in a trillion being false flagged does not mean this science that does so much good should be banned by any means. Just because he got arrested does not mean he got charged nor even convicted. Being arrested is simply being taken in. Arrests are not on your record nor charges. A charge is the government formally accusing you of a crime but you are innocent until proven guilty. Once you are proven guilty or plead guilty, only then have you been convicted of a crime. Only then will it show on a record. This happens far more than you know and there's never any outrage. Why? People today play victim for everything. Let's call up all the past people false flagged by this imperfect but extremely useful and necessary science. Let's get them some outrage too. Nothing happened. They get a false flag, take the person in and quickly realize its not the person they are after. Simple as that. Theres no victim hood about it. Its an accident with no repercussions.
@@TheMilkMan8008 you’re extremely ignorant if you can watch this video and come to this conclusion. The software is biased because biased people designed it! Ask yourself who works in tech? Primarily white men. Which is why the accuracy rate for this tech for white men is near 100% and the accuracy rate for darker skinned men and women is under 50%. That’s the literal definition of racism. Please do some research. This is a real problem for everyone.
@@rationallyruby why does America have primarily whites working in ANY job? Because of its 73% white population. Its like saying "Africa is so bias in its work forces. Its almost all Africans and no white people" why? Cause Africans population is get this... majority Africans. Yes, different ethnic and racial groups have different features. Asians for example end up being super similar to computers. Africans less so bit still similar. Germanic whites similar to eachother but different to European Caucasian originally from Canada. It depends on your locality, history, and ancestry. But its not the 80s. Science has advanced and so has picture and facial match technology. They pick up better on nose shapes, jaw shapes, forehead and eye shapes. Far less false flags and even the few that happen here and there. Know what happens to them? Not a damn thing. Because its not who they are looking for.
@@rationallyruby
"He's" trolling.
Guessing having an ignorant opinion gets responses.🌼
@@rationallyruby do tell me if you can identify every single difference between a group of 10 asians, a group of 10 Africans, and a group of 10 Caucasians from Poland and Russia. You can for some but some will be harder than others even for our human eyes. We don't live that culture. We don't easily know 1 from 2 like they would. Asians can tell asians apart better than whites. Whites can tell whites apart better than asians can. Africans can tell Africans apart better than asians. Are we all "racist" for not having the cultural ability to recognize different ethnic and racial features the way they can? We must be.
The judges should be held accountable for their lack of duty as well
Yeah but will he be held accountable NO!!
I agree with you. But the system is not about getting it right. It’s rigged against ppl of color.
Some judges are above any law!
Judges, prosecutors, all members of a gang.
No judges have very cushy permanent jobs and can't be sued.
If cops had to pay these lawsuits out of their pockets or from the cop retirement fund they'd definitely tread more carefully
AMEN!
So true
Actually that doesn't sound like a bad idea.
Fact
@@tanyalove1661 It does to police
He said I now know they have the ability to pick me up, put me in jail, and take my life away, even if I am innocent, the greatest fear ever.
😔😔By far
Ban facial recognition software.
Are you joking? Its not a perfect science by any means. People can change their face, features and more. Do you know how rare it is for this to happen? Do you know how many terrorists, criminals, killers and worse are found and tracked by this? One in a trillion being false flagged does not mean this science that does so much good should be banned by any means. Just because he got arrested does not mean he got charged nor even convicted. Being arrested is simply being taken in. Arrests are not on your record nor charges. A charge is the government formally accusing you of a crime but you are innocent until proven guilty. Once you are proven guilty or plead guilty, only then have you been convicted of a crime. Only then will it show on a record.
@@TheMilkMan8008 and do you know how many millions of people are being persecuted using facial recognition cameras? In china they can tell if you are uyghur or even part uyghur based on facial recognition and they have expanded it to remember the way people move,walk sit, posture to identify people. China uses millions of cctv cameras that constantly watch their citizens and they are given a rating which if you did things that the governments considers good like buying groceries ,but if you bought alcohol your rating goes down. It's being used to control the population in abusive manner. When your rating goes low enough you lose freedoms like using public transportation and losing services that are available to regular scored citizens.
@@blackprop9393 ohhh! I forgot we are in China. I didn't realize this wasn't the US. Pardon my mistake. Are you stupid? Yes China has corrupt government practices. So does Russia and both Koreas. You can't even use the internet some places without being imprisoned with no trial, no defence and never being seen again. This is America. You get a trial. You get defence. You are seen by multiple people during a trial and there's visits and retrials. Facial recognition in America has never been used for bad. Show me im wrong. Provide me proof. Because any time. False flag is brought in its pretty damn obvious to everyone its not their person. Places like China don't care about that. Dont compare the US to a place that is completely different. A place that human rights has been after for years. Compleatly non comparable. US has put terrorists away and China puts people away for looking at the wrong websites.
@@TheMilkMan8008 you obviously don’t understand facial recognition. Facial recognition is horrible. It doesn’t work. It’s totally useless. Look at the stats. Accuracy is high for white men. But horrible for black men and women. Did you not watch the video?! You shouldn’t use a technology that doesn’t work on half the population as a tool to take peoples liberties. Also when you look at the pictures, sure they look similar but you can tell they aren’t the same person!!!!
Are you still crying over Rudy, Styx?
Just being arrested can ruin a person's life, even when found completely innocent of the charges.
Especially if it’s something like rape and crimes dealing with children.
I have had to fill our forms that ask have you ever been arrested. Not felony, convicted just arrested.
He can write the prosecutor and request to have the record expunged. Not a big deal.
When you have a channel like this that will convict you before you even go through the process. Then there's people that people listen and believe anything they say even though the info is false.
@@MrTodayistheday unless in those 10 days you were supposed to show up to work and so you got fired or the prosecutor decides to drag his feet while you're looking for a new job. Only two of the many possibilities that would screw this guy's life up for quite a while... But "no big deal".
Even the naked eye can see those two men look nothing alike....🤔
yeah they do
But they never showed the actual picture in question. They blurred it out
they look similar, but at most they would be cousins.
To be fair, the vast majority of black Americans have ancestors in West Africa...and they are distinguishable from people living on other parts of that continent. Much like how Scandinavians are distinguishable from people from France.
Why don't you apply for a job there, if you can see better than a computer I'm sure you will be making millions of dollars
This system is sick, when they can get an id off the ground, and that override the video at a store, that is telling you it's all about putting black people in jail at all costs, and they wonder why, we don't trust anything coming from the system
He should be extremely well compensated for his time both in jail, his court time and fee's. Plus the damage to his reputation.
Absolutely 💯 agree and anyone that says otherwise, well hopefully you get arrested facing years in prison for something you didn't do.
You see a lot of people commenting, oh oh that person's just looking for a payday. And in this case they should be! It's not just a simple case of unlawful arrest, 10 days in jail. Trust me and I think we all know it's true there are some jurisdictions, not all but some jurisdictions in America where 10 days in county lockup for a white man is just a bummer but for a black man it could be his life. This is enough anxiety to give anyone lifelong PTSD
@@Frenchblue8 I agree 100%
People don't understand that for 1 it will be on his record, charges dropped or not, its there. The humiliation, all of it plays a role and you probably will see people say it's not a big deal. But like I said in 1 comment, if you feel some type of way about it, then when it happens to yourself and facing that time, lmk how it works out.
He should be gifted enough money that that judge, those cops and the prosecutor never ever think of using facial recognition software ever again as evidence against anyone. Like perhaps around 100 million dollars, with additional 100 million dollars to groups trying to advocate against facial recognition software.
Hit em in tha pocket my guy
I thought they got the pic from a security camera or something. An actual pic of the criminal in action. Picking a fake licence off the ground and then getting a warrant off that is pure bullshlt
AGREED.
I mean how do they even know its his face
It's a Black Face, and that's all that matters to White Officers. PERIOD..
Welcome to the United States of America bullshit like this is more common than you think
Lazy law enforcement has been happening for years .....swore the badge stood for integrity
This technology of facial recognition is obviously very dangerous. Some people look almost identical to another person who they might not be related to at all. I walked into a Walmart and this man looked like a carbon copy of me. It made the hairs on the back of my neck stand up. It was a weird, chilling experience.
This same thing happened to a guy years ago he was 50 miles away from the crime...the justice system is a mess
We tried to contact the Woodridge, police director, prosecutor and judge, but it was Wash your Hoods Wednesday and they were unavailable.
😂🤣👍
Funny af but sad at the same because its true.
How about the white robes??? Don’t they wash those too??? Maybe when they’re not burning crosses on lawns, they use the robes to lay on while inbreeding. Just a thought 😏🤷🏾♀️
Hahaha
Cleaning white clothes is hard,you know how much these reds hate any stain on those white ropes and hoods,it will take them hours to get a stain off.
"You've proven to me that you can lock me up for anything and there's nothing I can do about it"
Damn! That's deep, and so true being black.
fricking government gotta stop sentencing us to death
they probably got facial recognition set on bias
@@richardraymond9108 Dave Chappell had a skit mentioning that. When the victim was describing the black perp to the cop drawing the sketch he replied let me grab my stencil.
Are you joking? Thats not deep at all. He wasn't charged. Its not a perfect science by any means. People can change their face, features and more. Do you know how rare it is for this to happen? Do you know how many terrorists, criminals, killers and worse are found and tracked by this? One in a trillion being false flagged does not mean this science that does so much good should be stopped or not used by any means. Just because he got arrested on a false flag does not mean he got charged nor even convicted. Being arrested is simply being taken in. Arrests are not on your record nor charges. A charge is the government formally accusing you of a crime but you are innocent until proven guilty. Once you are proven guilty or plead guilty, only then have you been convicted of a crime. Only then will it show on a record. This has happened before. And it will happen again. They take someone in on the very rare chance this happens to ANYONE black white green yellow or purple and realize its not the person they're after and bam. Let go. This is unnecessary outrage just because of the times. There has never been any outrage by anyone in the past this has happened to because nothing came of it. Its an understandable mistake for an imperfect science.
@@TheMilkMan8008 the justice system that we have was originally designed to make sure even if the guilty get free no innocence should be sentenced that's why we have things called hung juries whereas if even one juror says no there is no conviction. Doesn't matter if you get it right nine times out of 10 even one innocence is wrong. Would you go to jail just so real guilty people go with you?
@@TheMilkMan8008 You don’t understand facial recognition software then or what stage it’s at. It has the highest rate of failure with dark skinned people. Has nothing to do with people changing their faces. It has to do with the technology simply not being able to distinguish black people that well due to its limitations. Yet they still rely solely on it as in this case.
Like I said, the police will never learn from these so-called “Mistakes” they made since the death of George Floyd.
Damaged reputation & relationships, time lost from work, dealing with confinement being incarcerated, having to be strip searched (spread and cough) The mental stress and feeling of being in a system that hates you because of the hue and tone of your skin. It seems like it would be a simple thing to fix to prevent these mistake from happening again. Evil.
I'm from Tennessee and the dude on that driver's license looks like 20 other guys. This is sad man...
I got the same haircut and beard. Its scary.
@Shibata Katsuyori you do realize in this country everyone is Innocent until proven guilty. A pending charge is not proof of guilt.
@@silentdragon9151 thank you Captain Obvious!
@@flyinhawaiian49 Ty man. Glad to see you have some understanding when many dont.
You guys love being scared, after covid next on the schedule is climate crisis. Wait and see. Then you can be scared all over again but this time it's gonna be about global warming.
This is outrageous! Look up doppelgangers & you'll see that everyone has multiple other people that look like them. Facial recognition is severely flawed!!
They don't even look alike besides both being black.
Supposedly we all have a minimum of 7 people that look like us or could pass for our siblings!
I work in residential construction and once a month I get “don’t I know you from somewhere?” Makes me feel like I hope none of these handsome mofos go on a crime spree.
My brother , who lives in a different state spotted my doppelganger. He was so freaked out he called me to make sure it wasn't me.
From what I have read the companies that make these softwares have told the police that the systems are flawed in general but especially when it comes to non white people.
He could prove he was 30 miles away, the picture on the ID doesn't even look like him and the popo went ahead anyway....
He should be compensated for all the pain and suffering they ( law enforcement put him through .)
He will they all get compensated but not nearly as good as George Floyd or Breanna Taylor. He might get 500k for every year he spent in prison at the most
@@ermac6466 Good point 🧐
People should also Sue all those face recognition Camera's companies as well. And arrest that judge who signed it, for not doing his job.
That's never happened and probably will not even in 200 years.
@@alyciaparks4292 make it make sense
Oowww.. the guy was arrested in Tennessee, then the facial recognition said to the guy he is the only ten it sees. Lol😂
Actually from what I've read, many if not most of the companies that provide this software warn the police that facial recognition should only be used as a tool, not as proof. And that was before the racial bias became public knowledge. The cops should have known better and conducted an actual investigation.
@@alyciaparks4292 If we don't do anything and look for solutions together and together I mean all the good people from every race religion & gender, it will not. Yes good people are always few, But all the good people together can achieve everything anything they want. But giving up , is never an option and is exactly those do support wrong evil Corruption want you to be in. They will continue doing so to try make you give up.
Imagine if he didn't have a alibi
It's funny how we always fit the description no matter what.
Strength is when you have been severely broken, but still have the tenacious courage to be gentle to others.
Facial recognition vs. A video tape(s) of a murder by a police officer. The killer officer got a 4 wee trial even though we all watched the video.
Wats your point?
@@thetruthhurtsdunit8493 the point is that when it comes to black people our police system will arrest them quick but when it comes to white people it’ll take it’s sweet time.
@@americancommunist7633 I am white and they always arrested me real quick.
@@thetruthhurtsdunit8493 ...I see you're not paid for thinking.
@@bmojo7118 your personal experience does not negate statistical facts and evidence based research.
This is why that woman(a black womanon the AI team) at Google spoke up and was fired for pointing out this bullshit
I need to look into that.
@@TheDesciple30 me too. Scary stuff
@@joyis4ever Agreed
@Liberalist D Thank you 🙏🏿
Seriously that messed up post the link👇🏽
Same thing happened in the city I live in. This guy got in trouble for robbing a barbershop with a gun and it was all caught on camera, the cops arrested a guy that looked like the man on camera, the barbershop owner and all the witnesses said it wasn't him but the cops didn't care, he had to hire a lawyer,lost his job because they thought he was a armed robber and had to go to court to prove it wasn't him
Facial recognition is not foolproof. Anything that man makes is imperfect.
Well if it’s not 100% correct then they shouldn’t use the technology because this is peoples lives on the line
I identified a minimum of FIVE DIFFERENT FEATURES, the minute they posted the pics.
How did they NOT see them?!?! Bless this poor man. He BETTER get paid PAID!!!
They should just throw out their facial recognition software and hire you since your catching things the computer can't.
@@blackprop9393 lol!
@@blackprop9393 I'm a retired Make-up Artist, and studying faces for a living was required. I wasn't actually being a smart ass, it's my thing. =)
@@blackprop9393 no they should just throw the whole thing out as even the computer scientists admit they don’t even know how their algorithm works.
Or at least the police should know the tool is not very reliable for certain groups of people. Maybe it can be used as a lead on a suspect but not as evidence to go much further than that.
Damn,Facial recognition should not be use by law enforcement because facial recognition gets it's wrong too
Lawsuit is coming soon
@dakota haro Yeah I saw that it's sad how they almost ruin this guy's life
Not only is facial recognition not accurate with certain “demographs” but also eyewitness testimony is notoriously inaccurate which is hard to believe but true.
So..facial recognition software is literally just a cop holding up a complexion board to Peter Griffin's face. Awesome. Way to go people. We're done here.
In this case, his cell phone location data and the CCTV at the financial institution will be very credible alibis. He should sue them for damages! Open and shut case if he gets a good lawyer.
These are very EVIL people that are in charge of this society.
Wow, that statement is telling. When you believe the very people trying to help you are evil, that means that you live in a very dark place. I am sorry.
I wish someone was in charge. The reality, we are all trying to live within individual constraints and make an individual choice. . . . and this is the result.
If you can tell me who is in charge, I will spend my life trying to meet him or her. :)
"He fits the description" How many times I've heard that statement? This is truly sad times.
@@MrTodayistheday Wow....what you are saying is telling....You don't see the hand behind the hand....
Yep, and thats why this american society is on its way to hell!!
@@MrTodayistheday problem is they're not trying hard enough. The very ppl being targeted by this draconian technology are largely descendants of the very ppl that were here before any so-called "settlers". The majority of the so called Natives you see today are hybrid off-spring of "$5 Indians," and Chinese rail workers. The total disregard your statement says, and what your ppl usually do with others they come in contact with is almost laughable, if it weren't so tragic. Yet you want somebody to look at how difficult it is to master this technology? If it were affecting Caucasians in a negative manner, you wouldn't be on your soapbox, now would you?
Facial recognition software is only as good as the people who program and configures it.
It should definitely not be used to find criminals, it's a freaking Computer program that's inaccurate
and definitely the people that use it.
solution of a crime should never ever rely only in one source of evidence.
Exactly...💯💯👋👋👋🥺🥺😲😲😪😪
@S Lin facs
it's only as good as the people who use it. Despite inevitable inaccuracies, it can still generate leads and narrow the suspects down to save time and money, but it will never provide stand alone evidence for convicting someone and misusing it in that way should be illegal.
This is so scary, as if we need anything else to worry about!😩
They didn’t respond because they knew they are lying nothing more, this guy is not the only innocent person they have done that to, there’s so many innocent people in jail now
"Cutting Edge"... I've literally met 4 strangers in my life that look nearly Identical to me, heaven forbid if any of them commits a crime where facial recognition is "Evidence"...
Or heaven forbid, they are flagged as a false positive and don't have a solid alibi for the time period in which the crime was committed.
The problem was not the system. The problem is he looks like many other people. The system only makes suggestions. In the end, people make the final decision.
You're right,people look alike.
That’s not understanding how the tech work. A system could look at two similar people and judge them different or it could judge two different people similar.
That is precisely why these are used as screening tool and not as a positive identification tool. Faces are not unique in the same way that fingerprints are unique. The CNN article is flat out wrong when they blame this error on the technology. It is a mistake made by a likely overworked and improperly trained judicial system. If anything, this is an example of why the judicial system should be better funded.
I thought this was supposed to be a tool to help, I didn't know this was evidence that can convict you with nothing else is insane
Sounds like they are pretty satisfied with the results...
Omg the facial recognition made 1 mistake after millions of recognitions let's find a way to make it racist.
@@blackprop9393 are you serious? Did you not listen to this video? Have you not looked at the studies? Darker skinned women have an accuracy rate of under 50%. UNDER 50%! Are you serious? Darker skinned men have similar stats. Yet light skinned people have an accuracy rate of 80-100%. Tell me please how this tool isn’t racist. It’s literally discriminating against people with darker skin. The literal definition of racism.
that is insane.
@@blackprop9393 it's not one mistake out of millions. it's countless mistakes out of millions. and they were using it as the only source to convict people of color with no other evidence. that is institutional racism cause it's the institution that is ruining the lives of a certain ethnic group when they did NOTHING WRONG.
I would rather a thousand guilty men go free than for one innocent man be sent to prison.
It sickens me on how they're quick to make unjustified arrest, but slow or never available for comment addressing their screw ups!.💯👎
He now has to get his arrest and imprisonment expunged from his record by going to court. Also, he has to sue the background information companies to remove that information from their files. They are all shady and there’s no national law mandating them to keep their information current and correct.
WTF?! This looks nothing like him at all. Even the jaw line is way different. The skin tone is different. Even the cops should’ve pick this up right alway. Police these days do not pay attention to details at all
Facial recognition tech and software was modeled using white American and white European faces during development and beta testing. Therefore, it does horribly in matching likeness of minorities, particularly African, American Black, Native American, and East and Southeast Asian faces.
He was black, that's all that mattered to them
It very racist. I remember when the saying was they all look alike and thats a crock of shit.
The nose was different as well
BECAUSE THE POLICE DEPARTMENT ONLY HIRES THE MOST STUPID PEOPLE OR RACIST PEOPLE TO BE COPS. SMART PEOPLE WHO APPLIED ARE TURNED DOWN.
Really got to start wearing gps monitor all the time to prove you where not there at crime scene.
The law doesn't care who you are, if you are picked up by the law, you are guilty period. I've been fighting to get my innocent name off the sex offender registry. My problem is I've never been charged for said crime. So I can't even clear my name due to the law stating I have to have a case to get an expungement, five years ago I cleared my name with the courts but a District attorney change the ruling of the judge to keep my name on the registry and he had no right to do so. It's been 15 years of fighting and I have no more fight left. Every single lawyer in the state of Michigan has declined my need to clear my name. So how can I clear my name when the justice system keeps me on this list. Again no victim no charges just my name and that's it
When he was taken into the Court for his arrangement he was in Chain's and Shackles , giving the Appearance that he was Dangerous and Guilty .
It was unfortunate that he looked like the real culprit.
Exactly! That's how they do us.🤬
He did not look like the real culprit.
The people who built the software think black people look alike, and you just proved that by saying they look alike.
It’s what you put into the software that it recognises.
My friend went to get her drivers license, and the facial registration software could not input her face and “not a human figure” popped up.
She is a black girl with very thick nose and lips + braids.
More diversity in the tech industry
@@kole1ful Asians are a minority. They study hard, develop the skills and complete difficult degrees in computer science and mathematics. Even with entrance requirements a full GPA lower for blacks, I have seen less than 10 blacks in these programs. This is a parenting issue. They are not encouraging their kids to succeed in these programs.
@@kole1ful As I said earlier, the algorithms are color blind, and the technology should be used as a screening tool. Another piece of biometric identification needs to be used for positive identification. If they had the time, they would have cross checked his story sooner. This illustrates why the police should be better funded.
So at the beginning of all this the police found an ID at the scene with a name on it...so instead of looking for the guy that is actually on the ID they arrest some other guy because a computer told them to? Did they even try to look for the guy on the ID at first? And this guy's alibi (proof) didn't even matter? WTF?
Some people lack common sense. An arrest means more than a potential mistake.
They tried to say that the ID was fake so they could excuse arresting any black man, as they did
This is every day for a Black Male in America. 70 years ago any Black man would do. Now it's just that he looks close enough.
Minority report, in reality theaters soon!
Its funny to me that people think that AI is infallible when it was made by imperfect humans
You mean to tell me that he can’t even sue?
They must be crazy.
Omg 6 yrs for a crime he never committed !!! Our cops are disgusting!!!!
It's a rough Life when someone blames you for something that you didn't do when it when it comes down to your race and your skin color that's a whole different story🤔
It's awesome being a victim isn't it?
@@motherofthree8884 Is it? You tell us.
And your bank balance
@@niciolamyelwee6646 so true
Lol @ democrats low iq responses
I saw another case like this, thankfully the guy they tried to accuse was at work that day. Very scary...
That's sad but I'm glad that brother was still alive to see another day and to fight...... They don't even look the same you don't even need a face recognition to see that.
I think the 'facial recognition' technology company should be sued. The argument that "they all look alike to me" won't wash in Court.
Your saying the facial recognition algorithm is racist? Lol
@@blackprop9393 yes. Yes it is. It’s racist because the people who designed it are biased. When you code a computer through purely showing it primarily white peoples photos and categorizing them, in order to “teach” the computer, it’s racist.
@@rationallyruby There are around 80 different things facial recognition software looks at, race isn't one of those things.
@@crackiechan4432 no they don’t look at race. But they do look at facial features. And if the software has been taught to look at predominantly white photos by predominantly white male programers, the result is extremely inaccurate results for people of color. Do you know how they program these types of tech? Statically men with lighter colored skin have an accuracy rate of near 100% yet the accuracy rate of women with darker skin is under 50%. Regardless of the intent of the programers or the tech itself, the result is racist and sexist.
@@rationallyruby I bet you pulled those stats out of your ass, didn't you.
It took me 2 seconds to realize the driver license pictures completely different than the other person
Me took
I worked in Woodbridge for 8 years and my dad once had a traffic ticket in the area. A majority of people from townsfolk to my bosses to the cops and to the judges are racist. I got called all sorts of names. Lots of Italians in Woodbridge who are nice but many imply you are beneath them
THIS IS SO UPSETTING! I'M SO SAD ABOUT THIS ALL! THESE ACTIONS ARE WRONG!
Bruh, they don’t even look alike
EXACTLY! it makes you feel like the police can just roll up on you and do whatever they want and there is nothing you can do about it SO it makes you feel scared every time you see them!!! and that will stay with him the rest of his life!
AND THAT"S WRONG!
What gets me is it was a fake id and they still were like "ThIs MuSt Be tHe GuY"
I fit the description ever since I was about 17 years old and last I checked they still aint found this dude
That's so scary. Omg I can't even imagine going thru something like that.
Hope he wins his lawsuit, and hope he wins big!
Vinny - I AM going thru something like this and the hardest part is the removal of my voice. THEY DO NOT CARE WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY. Cops need to have guilty people, whether they are guilty or not.
when all’s said and done, this young man and his grandkids should be set for life!
The goal for law enforcement is a conviction, they could care less if they convict the person who actually did it.
They can’t solve a single crime without a snitch.
Good god, imagine the amount of people behind bars for something they haven't committed.
I already knew about this worrisome shit. Like damn this is concerning as hell
its not just that its mobile phone and actual cameras that were found to have that racist flaw built in. this is the reason why they prevent us , even with degrees from coding the tools that make a difference.
when i said this years ago i had to demonstrated that something as simple as HTML coding , use coding number to create hue and color values . when the color white is *FFFFF F nad black is *00000 we are actually designated with the value ZERO in the coding world . let that sink in for a minute. anything greyscale has black people with the digits zero
bcoz you are black man afraid to get arrested ?
@@gion1988 afraid of being misidentified and wrongly accused to be later wrongly convicted.
When I was in the army, my friends saw another soldier in the AFTRS television station that looked just like me and while on leave, I saw another soldier that looked just like me. This software wouldn’t have been able to tell us apart.
Didn’t the movie “Enemy of The State” teach us how these things can be detrimental to the citizen and society. They using this technology to go after people without doing the actually investigation
I worked with a guy that spent a long time in jail for bank robbery mistaken identification. Terrible.
Any PERSON could see those are 2 different people.
Javi, its the fact that even with evidences and the guy's alibi Gringos did not care they just wanted to feed his body to El Diablo gringo.
I seriously doubt ANY person can tell the difference, you don't speak for anyone let alone all people. if a computer algorithm can't figure it out, maybe... just maybe they look alike and there's not some crazy racist facial recognition software on a mission to put black guys in jail.
@@blackprop9393 they do look alike.
Facial recognition has been something that independent "techies" have been talking about for awhile. The feds should start to regulate this industry before it gets out of hand.
It's the feds that are abusing the technology aren't you paying attention
@@niceyh.2529 he's obviously stupid. The government is the ones who don't need this technology.
Wait, don't those Cash Checking M/O places have cameras. And the Stuhhh'pid Prosecutor could have matched it with the time the crime happened 10 miles away?
Please fire the Incompetent Prosecutor.
I did not even know that software was in effect. The pics did look similar, but other parts of this story are missing.
We were warned about this but we never listen. I remembered a song by pearl jam called grievance it say for every tool they lend us a lost of independence and privacy
👏👏🏆👏👏
Yes sir.🌼
Jeezus. I could look at those two photos and see they're not the same person. That's scary.
It is widely recognised that facial recognition systems have issues with Black faces. Don’t believe me? Ask users of apple’s face recognition system for unlocking iPhones.
good piece!
Wow 😳 why did they do that to him, it seemed so clear that he was innocent
Those two pictures didn't look anything alike, the only they had in common was they are both black. Wth
Charmaine its about the fact that the software only flags our distinctive symmetry but selects features for caucasians instead. i decided to come in coding world specifically because of this racial bias. but with proprietary devices and no commission to screen and vet the material ethiclaly. caucasians will fight tooth and nails to be scrutinized.
They must have programmed it to be racist.
I'm really glad that ppl are standing up too this Because this happens alot .So wake America To much false arrest are being made.💪☠️🙏
A lot of cowards as Woodridge public employees.
It prob had to to trial before they finally dropped the charges. Who's going to pay him back for the lawyer? Who's gonna pay him back for his time missed? This was covered on the daily show over a year ago. Js
Police should pay for all those sh** for wrongly doing him that
The evil of the old is in a defined mode, there is nothing else.
"Lock Me Up for anything and you can't do anything about it" That is so wrong!
When you hear “non of them responded to our request”, you know they messed up real bad.
This craziness will never stop!
I hope he is successful in his lawsuit and everyone involved is fired or at some point wrongly accused of crimes because of face recognition aka Miss Karma.
Sue the pants off for the highest amount awarded.... but that won't give you back your 10+ days and the trauma endured. Sounds like investigation 101. Somebody didn't pass the test or too lazy to investigate. I'm glad you are here and with us to speak about it. No telling what Great Lengths they would have gone through to cover this up
I experienced something like this OVER A DECADE AGO, when I was homeless, in New York City. It's was regarding a traffic ticket, from a cop I never met, involving a vehicle I never had, and a non-existent baby car seat and said unidentified baby I never had, much less met or drove around. I didn't even have a place to live at the time.
But they did not even use facial recognition technology, just the word of this disgusting, female officer and her buddy, buddy judge and court clerk in a room, just the four of us. No due process! No lawyer! No trial! No witnesses! No evidence! I NEVER GOT JUSTICE!! BUT I'm still homeless!!
GOTTA LOVE THIS COUNTRY!! That's why I served it.
Ask the Stargates and snow bunnies stop their men from doing this.
Right. I thought white women were loyal to them
Wow...now computers think all African Americans look alike.😟
Omg computers are racist reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
They want to get you by any means necessary! 😒
Everyone has a “ twin” “doppelgänger”
Based on that - Facial Recognition Should not be legally used for any type of law enforcement.
I’ve come across several people throughout my life that appears to be my identical twin. It’s weird! Clones of me..lol
Me too
Weirdly enough I’ve never seen anyone that looks like me
Of course none of them wanted to respond! The stress you caused this young man and his family is disgusting to say the least!
Facial recognition software was introduced in this side of the hemisphere for one set of people as seen in a documentary. Look it up sorry for this young man trials. Be safe and be bless
So is the WHOLE AMERICAN JUDICIAL SYSTEM made EXCLUSIVELY for AMERICAN BLACK CITIZENS
@@georgiasweetpotato7170 What do you mean? Your question does not have a focus. Exclusively normally means to benefit but I assume that you mean against.
It wasn’t even a facial match of someone from the scene. 😳 it was a match of a photo found at the scene that anyone could have left there. He could have left it there the day before. A veritable alibi, and this evidence? All involved should be sanctioned. 😞
Who could have left it there the day before ????? So he is going to intentionally incriminate himself????? A veritable alibi???
Is that what you would do????
@@clarkclarke I think you missed the point of my statement. The person who was a facial “match” wasn’t taken in a video or anything at the scene, it was a photo on a document left at the scene. My point was that that document could have been left there any time prior to the time of the crime by anyone at all and the person that left it there may not have had anything at all to do with what they were investigating. My point was that they took that item at the scene and presumed that it was left by the person committing the crime when there was no evidence of that in any case. And that that evidence that wasn’t really, they presented as more important than a verified alibi that he was 30 miles away at the time of the crime. That on its face is absurd.
And they say systemic racism doesn't exist
Good Lord...even the computers think we all look alike 🤦🏽♀️
I feel ya, man.... Sometimes I hate that I get so many warnings. Haven't been to court since 2003 😒