State v Hannah Gutierrez Rust Armorer Trial Day 1 - Opening Statements & Testimony
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 лип 2024
- #HannahGutierrez #Rust #NewMexico
Afternoon Coverage: ua-cam.com/users/liveyGBJtZb9cBM
THE DOCKET
0:00 Welcome
2:06 Road So Far
9:10 Juror Selection Information
9:42 Q&A
23:15 Court is in Session
28:30 Opening Jury Instructions
43:25 Opening Statements - Prosecution
1:25:42 Court Break
1:45:05 Opening Statements - Defense
Prosecution Law Enforcement Witness
2:13:50 Detective Nicholas Lefleur Testimony
2:35:00 Lunch Break
2:37:29 Summary
2:40:15 Q&A
STAY IN THE LOOP WITH EMILY D. BAKER
Download Our FREE App: lawnerdapp.com
Get the Email Alert for Free: www.LawNerdAlert.com
WHAT I USE TO STREAM - STREAMYARD: streamyard.com/emily
Proud Streamyard Partner!
Join the community for exclusive content: www.LawNerdsUnite.com
Mailing Address: Emily D. Baker 2000 Mallory Ln. St. 130-185, Franklin Tn 37067
Business Inquiries: emilydbaker@cesddigital.com
WHAT I USE TO STREAM - STREAMYARD: streamyard.com/emily
LAW NERD MERCH!
www.LawNerdShop.com
Help with the shop: help@emilydbaker.com
LONG-FORM CONTENT / @theemilydbaker
The Emily Show Podcast on UA-cam: emilydbaker.com/TheEmilyShowP...
Apple Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/AppleTheEmily...
Spotify Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/SpofityTheEmi...
On your favorite podcast player Wednesdays
QUICK CONTENT?
Quick Bits Podcast: emilydbaker.com/quickbitsplay...
Apple Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/AppleQuickBits
Spotify Podcasts: emilydbaker.com/SpotifyQuickBits
Quick Bits Channel : / @emilydbakerquickbits
EMILY ON SOCIAL
Instagram: / theemilydbaker
Twitter: / theemilydbaker
Facebook: / theemilydbaker
MY UA-cam ANALYTICS TOOL
**My Favorite UA-cam TOOL VidIQ vidiq.com/LawNerd
Follow My Cats on Instagram:
/ fredandgeorge_cat
Emily’s glasses lenses are Irlen tint www.irlen.com
This video is not legal advice; it is commentary for educational and entertainment purposes. Some links shared are affiliate links, all sponsorships are stated in video. Videos are based on publicly available information unless otherwise stated. Sharing a resource is not an endorsement; it is a resource. Copyright 2020-2023 Baker Media, LLC - Розваги
Emily!!! THANK YOU for colour coding morning and afternoon and labelling "Morning Day 1". "Afternoon day 1" etc. Always on the replay crew due to time zones. Often used to get lost and would eventually give up watching. With the new colour coding and labelling of which day and which session, I will DEFINITELY be able to follow better and therefore watch the entire case from beginning to end! THANK YOU 👍🏻❤️🌟‼️🙏🏻🙌🏼👊🏻🫶🏻🧋🥤🥂❤🎇🥇🏆🎀💪🏻1️⃣✅✔️✴️❤
Best part of replay crew… bumping up the playback speed during Prosecution Opening Statement!
😂💯
Came here to say the same thing 😂
So true!
I agree but unfortunately it speeds up Emily as well and I wanted to hear her
Omg thank you for the reminder on playback speed! His “ umms” are driving me nuts.
It’s so wild to me that upon hearing the opening arguments from the state, it felt so administrative of Ms Guitierez. Like, oh boy!this will be a no brainer. Then moments later, hearing the defense….it switches so fast…this is way more complicated! This is why watching these trials with Emily and the law nerds is so informative!
Many trials streamed on UA-cam are no-brainers; Darrell Brooks is an example. This case is intriguing.
I had the same thoughts. It was like welp, yeah looks like those are live bullets and if it can be shown it didn't come from the prop house then it's on her. Then like oh no, here is another thing to consider. Defense is so far doing a good job. As armorer, yes, she should be checking, but if she's trying and ppl grabbing guns from her and not letting her check and not doing their safety meetings and demanding safety that puts her in a tough spot. And even if there is evidence of her doing drugs or drinking in free time, I'd need some good proof that she was affected by that on set or while loading weapons. I really put so much blame on production and Dave Halls. Only wish Hannah had said nope, not doing this cuz she was worried about killing someone then she wouldn't be here, but Helena would probably still be dead cuz Dave would have grabbed guns anyway. Her age and pressures put on her and her representing her step father's name and all that was probably a huge huge huge component. Heck, she might not have even realized she could say, nope, taking all these guns with me unless ya'll are gonna do safety checks and meetings and listen to me. She probably had no experience to even know that was possible
Exactly! This is why it's so important to always hear both sides, ESPECIALLY when it's MSM giving it out. It's so easy for an unqualified person to look at an event and state, "well it MAKES sense" with no actual investigation. It seems a lot more people are at fault than just her
omg props and armourer are two very full time jobs, it's insane to give both roles to one person, let alone one so experienced
Diversity hire.
@@aruglaempire2518nope - it’s well known the producers went with the cheapest option. If that had been a 16 year old white boy they would have gone for that one.
I came here to say this too. I have a background in theater and I saw how intense props is. It's basically EVERYTHING that isn't a wall- props sources, designs, fabricates, shops for EVERYTHING an actor touches or set dressing. It's intense.
I agree and disagree... Production was absolutely cutting cost by doubling up on jobs; it is quite common in independent film making.
But I don't like it as an argument for the defendant's negligence. While it's never a good idea to split focus between two jobs it sounds like she went in knowing that information. The dates/timeline of production, the job titles, the pay rate would all be in her start work (or at least a deal memo). She may have gotten overwhelmed later but she chose to take on both roles.
Also only paying her for 9 days as an armorer & definitely pushing her past what was capable.....but also, how tf are there live rounds on set & how tf didn't she realize that when she loaded the gun
For what it’s worth, I’m new to the details of this case. I appreciated the Prosector taking it slow - educating me, then telling me what went wrong.
I'm not new, but I also liked the prosecutor's approach.
Yep I know literally nothing except a ton of headlines back when it happened. So it was very useful
I also appreciated it... as I have insomnia even narcotic sleep medications can't cure, but bro is definitely doing a better job, 😂😂😂😂.
He has to explain it to a jury that might not know anything guns or filmmaking. Though the lack of emphasys and sense of importance of certain elements is quite infuriating. Somebody DIED that day!
Yes. The other lady makes me extremely anxious. She's great, but sometimes it's too much
Listening to Emily while watching this makes me realize that ADHD can be a great asset for lawyers. I know that it makes a lot of things harder, especially while studying, but I hope that those who want to become lawyers remember that they have strengths that others lack.
This is called the Swiss cheese scenario in Australia's health and safety industry. When all the random odd holes line up perfectly. And if only one 1 slice is out of place, it would never have happened .
Very clever analogy.
Giving Dave Hall a plea deal while charging Hannah is insane
She could’ve taken a plea deal. Thr first one who accepts a deal gets the best deal. That has always been the case.
@@ravenzyblackthey’re not offered to everyone. I’m not sure that she had that option.
@@kateashby3066 confirmed later she was offered it but I don’t know what the plea deal is. I do know part of plea deal for her is to reveal where the live rounds come from and she said no. This may indicate her team believes if that evidence comes to light her punishment may be worse. Usually it’s true the person taking the first plea deal gets the best package.
Ironically, the mention of only loading five bullets is an Old West cowboy load. When holstered, the hammer rested on the empty cylinder to prevent it going off half-cocked. Hence the adage : Going off half-cocked.
Thank you! I appreciate the nugget of knowledge!!
It's a flint lock reference, not a cowboy one. Nothing to do with keeping an empty chamber under the uncocked hammer. As soon as you cock the hammer, it has rotated to a live cylinder.
@@ED-es2qv How does a flint lock have a half cock rest? I thought it was always once action.
As a Property Master that has worked as both as On-Set Property Master (aka Assistant Property Master) and as an Armorer, I Am significantly enjoying your coverage of this. I've tried a couple and found yours to be the least judgmental, most informative, and lacks the snarky hearsay style comments other youtubers fill their videos with. You are fun, no-nonsense, informative, and leave your discussions bullshit free. Thanks for all you do. Liked and Subscribed.
catching this on replay crew......YES on sweatpants! With pockets, please!
Me too! Yes!
It blows my mind knowing there were misfires on set and still they continued.
I don’t think they specified if negligent discharges were blanks or live rounds (lead leaves barrel). The sound is very similar
Well normally on a set they have only blanks, so Id assume misfires are not nearly as concerning.
Thank you for explaining all the legal things!
David Halls should be made to testify in this case, he's partly responsible for touching the weapon without her presence.
If he refuses to testify his plea deal will be revoked. It's literally stipulated in the deal he needs to testify against them both.
I think he already took a plea deal didn't he. Isn't he the only one who accepted respinsibility?
@@lindafarnes486Yes. But it also means taking the lesser charge. So, it's kind of iffy
@@lindafarnes486I wouldn’t call what has been said about his deal to be “taking responsibility” as much as cover ass and throw the inexperienced young subordinate under the bus.
Even based on this opening statement - as the superior and first AD who the armorer is supposed to do the full check in front of, I have to ask why he allowed her to do a shitty check.
His deal is a load of crap... and how quickly he was given one. They wanted at Alec Baldwin, it's why the deal was given so fast & in my opinion, loose, Miss Guteiriz(sry if spelled incorrectly) has, IMO, been collateral damage and thrown under the bus in the process. I feel like Emily going into this, we will see if my opinion changes as things go.
The odds of all these factors coming into place to take a life is wild.
I'm working on movie sets in Europe, where admittedly, the departments and responsibilities are structured differently. So I can only speak from that perspective.
She is GUILTY. For the simple fact that the armorer has the final responsibility for the weapons.
Her age can not matter at all. If she's too young to do her job responsibly, she can't be the armorer. There obviously just is no margin for error. Same with experience: if she's too inexperienced to do her job properly, she can't be the armorer. Maybe the second armorer, or the assistant, but not the first/main armorer.
In the question if she's guilty or not, it also doesn't matter who brought the live rounds on set. Same is true for the actor pointing the gun and pulling the trigger. If she had done her job correctly, she would have found the live rounds and only put dummies in the gun. Period. That's her job. She has to check every single bullet she puts in.
So imho she's guilty no matter what.
Now that does NOT mean that others aren't responsible as well. If someone else brought live rounds on set: responsible. Prop master not giving Hanna time to do her armorer job: responsible. Alec Baldwin: definitely responsible. In my eyes not necessarily responsible for pulling the trigger as an actor, but very responsible as the producer. Hiring a very inexperienced person as sole armorer. Hiring a part time armorer - in a Western movie: ABSURD. Not caring enough about safety on set.
But these people being guilty as well, doesn't take away the fact, that checking the bullets and making absolutely sure all guns on set are safe to handle by the actors, is the armorer's job. If she had done her job, it wouldn't really have mattered if someone brought live rounds on set. It wouldn't really have mattered if Alec Baldwin pulled the trigger. If Hanna had done her job properly, this would not have happened.
And if she wasn't able to do her job properly, due to budget/time issues, she had to walk away.
Ya know what..your comment has made more sense to me than any..even after my now thought about quite misunderstood comment..your's actually really makes sense!..Continue to educate with these very important nuggets of information!!..ty..tyvm..
P.s..imean..I did think many of the points you made anyhow but the way you worded things?..spot on!..
Edit: spelling
@fionamcfadden5772 that's very kind of you to say, thank you!
It's not really about her being guilty or not. She absolutely made mistakes she needs to be held accountable for and should never be allowed to work with guns again...but she isn't the MOST culpable. She is a scapegoat for the actions of multiple people on that set. Hall should have gotten years of prison.
@outwardbound2241
you are absolutely correct! Age should never be an excuse. As you said, if she is "tto young", she should not have the job
Hannah had her part in this but the more I’m hearing this the more I believe that production is using her as a fall guy for all this. A mess.
they are all on trial thought so not really
Yes bsummers, they certainly tried, that they did.
A scapegoat. One person for all the blame to fall upon.
She was the one hired. It was her responsibility. So it is her problem.
@@eileenmcdonald1599 Idunno, when someone is hired to lose, I am sympathetic.
No, BRANDON LEE was killed by a tip of a bullet that got lodged in the firearm during a previous scene. When the gun was fired next, the powder created a strong enough thrust to eject the bullet tip. Hit in lower abdomen. It was a .45 ACP that killed BL, a very large bullet. Far from a blank. JON-ERIK HEXUM is the actor on the set of 'Cover Up' that died from wading from a blank. It was an accidental self-inflicted shot to the head due to the wading ejection from the blank.
I live in NM. South of Santa Fe. Moved here from Ohio 10 years ago. Most beautiful sunsets you will ever see!
EBD Her lawyer’s opening is far more convincing than the State’s. Gotta say my youngest is her age and I can completely see her being bulldozed by others on set
are women incapable of taking accountability?
@@Cobbido how is her being a woman relevant? Any one young in this position would feel bulldozed. This set was well documented as toxic. There is often an imbalance of power on sets which is dangerous and ends up causing exactly whats happened here. Sit down!
Then you are a garbage parent. She took the job. Most likely because of who her daddy is. She is the one that screwed up
@@eileenmcdonald1599we don’t know how much she screwed up and how much she was screwed over yet. That is what this trial is about. If they purposely chose her because they were going to over work her and push her into unnecessary and unsafe situations that could end her career as it started that definitely needs to be taken into account. We think about all the movie producers that harmed young actors/actresses. Everyone of the producers knew they didn’t need a gun for the staging seen. Many people failed here.
@@Cobbidodid you miss the part where her MALE BOSS told her to skip checking the gun? meanwhile the other MALE who happened to be a producer and the most powerful man on set insisted on using a real gun to REHEARSE- something they’re not supposed to do. So by “taking responsibility”, I think you are confusing the woman with the two men in charge. But thanks for sharing your misogynistic view.
The defense needs to quit claiming she was "only" 24 years old while also saying she was very well trained from the time she was little. That is 6 years past being an adult. If she couldn't handle the job, she should not have taken it or should have quit.
Maybe she was trained her whole life, but her being 24, a young adult, on a filmset with heaps of older people (men), might have meant they didn't take her seriously or listened to her. Wouldn't be the first time a woman was ignored with detrimental results. And now she is the fall guy.
Agreed! 18 year olds in the military handle all kinds of deadly weapons after training…she had a lifetime of training with her father!
@@margjeweijdt1510- She IS an adult. She was paid to do the job she should know how to do the job. Trying to make this about sexism is just stupid.
@@ravenzyblackyou sound like you're on your period. Calm down. Go find some emergency chocolate.
Defense will never quit using everything at their disposal. Age really does play a part. Because it was an accident, the jury will take nuance into consideration (or choose not to) when deciding her fate. This was her second job so she WAS inexperienced in terms of actually doing it under pressure for work. She may never have worked on a set that modeled for her how it should be done- so when her supervisor orders her to cut corners… she may not have felt confident enough to tell him to shove it (and thus never work in Hollywood again). Im not saying I feel this way, but a juror could.
Thank you for making these trials easier to follow!! Your Chanel is the only one I’ll watch live 😁
Emily, your speech speed is perfect. When I listen to slower speech, I just can't and I must speed it up.
opposite for me, unfortunately
I have ADHD and I don’t know if this is because of that but I’m with you- GET TO THE POINT is my philosophy lol.
@@DaibhidhBhoAlbawhen she speeds it up he sounds normal. When she doesn’t it sounds slow motion 😵💫
Let's see! Can't wait to see this judge in action. She was such a no nonsense lady and confident. Good to see her switch when talking to jurors.
Emily!! 👏🏽👏🏽I am SOOOO excited and happy you are covering this!!! Yay!!!👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽I adore you!!👏🏽👏🏽
I live for your fast talking bottom line scoops. I so relate and have been told not to talk so fast my entire life. Thank you Em❤❤❤
Catching this on replay crew. Kinda thankful for that lol... He speaks at IRL 0.5 speed.
New Mexican cadence in spoken english is influenced by Native American languages, which is why the meter is slower.
Interesting! Thank you!
i think its fine to talk slow the problem is that hes too monotone
@@wearmeout1he’s also saying “umm” a lot and that kills flow.
To say she in a lot of trouble would be a understatement
"You don't have time for a weapons check." Excuse me? Did that really happen?
Honestly, there were failures all down the line here. I would be inclined to go the probation route.
I love Hannahs Lawyer❤so precise, compelling and calm.
If your boss does not give you the oppertunety to do your job and does not care when you tell them, then the fault is on the boss.
and is bringing live bullets into set the boss’ fault too?
Not quite. He’s def responsible but she is an adult and supposedly a certified armorer sand that comes with obligations to do the job properly. If a cop is ordered by their chief to beat a citizen for no apparent reason other than they’re being snarky, that cop is still liable if they follow the command. They DO have the option to disregard their boss and do the right thing.
This happened in my state. If she's been around guns her whole life as she says then she knows the first rule is to always assume the gun is loaded with a live round. You don't hand it to someone before checking it. And of course you don't aim a gun at anyone loaded or not. If that is part of a scene then you check the gun.
In her interrogation video, she claims to have checked to see if one was in the chamber. And that she didn’t see one. so she’s claiming the blank that they put in was actually a live they didn’t see it.
And you check every damn round on set.
EXACTLY!!!! The mistakes of having live rounds among blanks BAFFLES me! Even if someone manipulated her inventory, she STILL should have checked before giving him the gun. I do not get it at all. But let’s not put the bullets before the gun now… 😏😂
And to not do anything with them when impaired!!!
So is Alec Baldwin. He’s been around guns his whole life. His father taught a gun course in a high school for years. He also bragged in his police interrogation hours he knew ALL at guns safety on full sets. He’s had over three decades of experience.
I thought they was using her as a scapegoat, after the defence opening its 100% solidified it in my mind x
She screwed up. She didn't do her job. She needs to be the one held responsible
@@eileenmcdonald1599 I understand that, but I still think the powerful bosses above her are pushing her under the bus to save their own skins and jobs x
Greetings from Scotland. Great to be back with you all. X
I feel for this HG. I can’t help feeling she’s a scapegoat.
There should be no live ammunition on a movie set. The armorer is in charge of all weapons and all accessories to those weapons, which includes ammunition. This person should have and could have minded all weapons and all accessories for the weapons. I’m not sorry for her. She shirked her job.
@@Pond_Maven agreed. She was also on a set riddled with production and safety issues; safety officers who bypassed safety trainings and actors who refused gun training…and that’s really just the tip of the iceberg.
@@Pond_Mavenyhh'ess..exactly!..i see just what you mean..in the long run?..it was down to her to check!..I feel for her though if Halyna had of been one my relatives?..I would not be happy at aaalll!..Would you be?..who would you point the last finger at?..I'm sorry to say but mine,no matter how bad I feel for her would be at her,H.G!..
@@AgathaMistyDefense did a good job of making me feel she is scapegoat, because many people are to blame. In the end, she didn't do her job correctly that they all rely on for their safety. However, she being very young and at the bottom of the totem pole, it's already obvious that she DID NOT receive the respect she deserved, in that she tried to do the right thing and was very frustrating that other people, like Baldwin, did not do what she asked and I bet they even argued with her about her concerns. Like not being able to train Baldwin. On the other hand, as a juror, I would be swayed by the fact that she was doing drugs, and from what I know about people who do these types of drugs, she was most likely under the influence since she had it at her hotel room.
I think she will not escape, but the sentence should be light because it seems that other people are ALSO to blame. So sad.
Agreed. She messed up but she isn't even close to the most culpable. Hall and Baldwin should have gotten/should get prison time. I can't believe Hall got a deal...
this is the first trial in a while that i'm looking forward to cross-examination/defense's case.
Part of the replay crew, thank you so much for covering this!! I love your insight, it's so educational ❤
I agree she screwed up but so many people screwed up not just her
blame everything on Hannah & Dave does have merit. But.... Baldwin was never "shown" a cold weapon. As the film's producer, Baldwin skipped safety protocols, and carelessly engaged an unchecked firearm.
I agree. He just went for it. Like no common sense but I understand the responsibilities of the others to keep people safe too. It’s complicated
Holy cow, EDB. I have you at 1.5x and you have the prosecutor sped up? He sounds like he’s speaking normally. Like a typical cadence. I cannot imagine him at 1x.
I have missed live trial coverage from Emily so much 💕💕 cheers to the next few weeks! 🥂
Replay crew - sped up at 1.25x and enjoying the commentary EDB 💜
Omg Emily is cracking me up😂 I'm screaming in my head the same that she is. So glad I decided to watch this trial on this channel ❤
I’m at 1.75 speed. I can’t imagine watching this at normal speed!!!
Are u from Cali or the north east?
It's so sloooow...
I grew up in Florida and live in Seattle, and this is too slow for me. There are more places than just Cali and the east coast that speak quickly.
@@nowasiwassaying...1699 the Midwest- Chicago metro
I’m Australian and it’s even too slow for me !!! 1.75x is fine.
Replay crew: I’m also watching the gone mom trial during the week. I am catching up on this trial during the weekend. Thank you so much Emily! You give this Stay at home mom some much entertainment ❤
Almost started on the afternoon stream! Playing catch-up 👩⚖️
The second bird in NM Seal is from the ancient Legend of how the Mexican capital and origins of the Republic of Mexico was founded according to the native lore. The prophesy was that the place to settle as birthplace of Tenochtitlan would be decided by a sighting of an Eagle holding a snake perched on a cactus in the middle of a dry lake. This is where the current City of Mexico is located. It’s Mexico’s present day National Symbol.
SHE should have checked..FULL STOP....
She was getting paid exactly just to do so!..
Let's be honest, she was getting paid to [nudge nudge] _not_ check.
The Defense opening was GREAT !
1:02:01 most interesting thing about this guys opening statements is watching the attorney?? Behind him with the butterfly lashes
Johnny v Amber was the best body doubling I've received at work in a long time! Glad to have a few more weeks of it!
Replay crew! I love how you time stamp everything Emily! 💜
She could have called OSHBA. She could have quit. She is one of the guilty parties, based on info so far.
2:42:00 Great comment! So true! I've seen upper management (in essential technical positions) quit over unethical choices by the big boss. It gave me the courage to also quit.
I’m gonna call it - Hannah is the scapegoat
Eff no way
High and reckless
.
What if she’s guilty AND also the scapegoat? Because 3 ppl are involved here. She def played a part.
A woman died and for that i am so very sorry. Recognizing that - this is going to be a fascinating trial. EDB thank you.
People seem to forget that the Director was also hit. He was standing right behind the Cinematographer. There were two people hit by one bullet.
@@ravenzyblack thank you for the reminder.
Can’t wait for Sarah Zachary testimony!
She wanted HG fired. She could have set her up as she had access to the guns.
EDB, you are always spot on !!
I've been pissed about AD Halls sweetheart deal for months. I'm so glad you brought it up multiple times. As one of the safety links in the chain and as the safety officer on set he really should have shouldered more of the responsibility for what happened.
It appears that in cases like these they’re gunna give the least guilty person the best deal because they need him to testify to get the other two. Just like we saw in Adam Montgomery’s trial- his wife Kayla got off practically Scott free and yet she practically aided in a murder of a child and helped cover it up for years. But it got her to flip and give up all the details in her husband and thus got him convicted. Without her they wouldn’t have been able to get either for murder.
Replay crew. Long week in Nashville. I'm sitting at BNA enjoying the coverage as I await my flight home. ❤
What I took away from this opening is that the prosecutor knows nothing about guns or filmmaking.
And neither do I.. I thought his inexperience spoke to the jury... that handling guns is a skill..some people do not have the attention for detail required for some tasks...every bullet should have been checked, regardless of color..shake shake.. 1:56:49 what....
@@DrunkComments And I suppose that's a fine takeaway. Perhaps my own preference is a prosecutor who's able to explain important concepts to a jury and therefore seem knowledgeable enough on the topic to be able to confidently and competently say "she did it wrong."
In fact, I would argue that handling firearms in this situation is NOT that complicated and that she was SO reckless because the concepts are actually quite simple.
@Grey_Duck both the pros and Def had intriguing opening statements... I'm starting to think that whoever hired her is culpable, however she did accept the position. She loaded the gun...I love reading comments on this channel...phenomenal input (not from me, I'm just trying to keep up😅)
@@DrunkComments- Don’t forget her stepfather is a famous armorer in Hollywood. He has decades of experience doing exactly what Hannah did on this set.
@@ravenzyblack nepo-hire, I agree!
She got this opportunity before she was qualified (emotionally and technically) because of her dad
Replay crew - playing catch up. Thanks Emily for the coverage.
love Emily’s response to heRing jurors get to ask questions!!!
This defense came in hot and swinging. They seem like they are ready for a fight. I need more of their information
Emily, you make it a lot of fun to watch!
Watching all the way from Brazil 🇧🇷
Replay crew…if I’m a juror, the defense has already presented some very compelling reasonable doubt that the prosecution is going to have to overcome to get a guilty vote.
bummed that i just missed this live but on the bright side I can watch this guy at 1.25x
Big fan watch you all the time. ❤
Oooh! New sweatshirt!!! Agree with motion for sweatpants ❤
I feel called out, talking about the rate of speech and I am watching this at 1.5 and prefer it fast paced with talking 😂
The brown hair on Hannah is doing wonders for her.
I think there has been a conserved effort on behalf of media to use the most unflattering photos possible.
@@angeliccow also it can be a strategy by her council to make her look as normal as possible. All the photos I see of her are ones of her posing with guns lol
@@bsummers1386- Oh absolutely that was her lawyers doing. They were probably telling her to color her hair one shade instead of multicolored, remove all her paraphernalia, and remove the nose ring etc etc.
@@bsummers1386this was NOT Hannah’s doing. I guarantee you she will go back to funky colored hair, piercings, and Misfits shirts after the trial.
Replay crew coming back to day 1! I didn’t have interest in this case but day 4 and 5 were so wild that I have to see gavel to gavel!! Emily, one day can you share your notes and what you write down during these cases?
How ge hell did I miss this! I have a lot of catching up to do.
Sounds like scene of the crime was a mess, with everyone doing CYA
I like this judge.
I love your goat so much that I bought one for my husband so he can use it at work. He gets frustrated with his job very often and I thought it would give him a good laugh to be able to have his goat scream at them. I lived in NM for 5 years. Their jury process is much different than any other I've encountered or at least it was in the area of NM where I lived. I was on jury duty for 3 months and had to call in each week to see if I needed to report. Even after being on a case you're still "on" jury duty for the full 3 months and can be called to serve on multiple cases. I hated that. Just having to remember to call each week. Most of the people in NM do have a VERY laid-back demeanor. I'm from the South and it was laid back even for me. They're like "I'll get to it, today, tomorrow, maybe next week" kind of style.j
“You’re a book made better with pictures.” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Emily I’m dying
That’s too funny. I just came back from Svalbard by the North Pole on Wednesday! Best place ever. 🇮🇪
I like how the witness looks at the jury when he answers questions
All witnesses are told to do that. Some are better at it than others.
Prosecution's opening statement delivered with the aplomb of an elementary school student asked to read out loud in front of the class.
And this is also why I since becoming more senior in my profession I have started to avoid too hierarchical companies and being much more harsh with colleagues especially higher in rank than myself when I spot issues
If your interested Jensen’s full interview with the police is on Crime Circus.
Thank you!
What people hardly talk about in this case is the fact that the assistant director who handed the gun to Alec told him that it was a 'cold gun', meaning there was no live ammunition in it! This is further proof that Baldwin is not guilty: Baldwin trusted the words of the person he worked with and who was in the production department and oversaw all these things. So if I have been in this business for several decades, like Baldwin and the director's expert/assistant tells me that it is a 'cold gun', then I trust him, just like Baldwin did, because I have no reason not to trust him, because words indicate that the person giving you this weapon has checked it. So why would Baldwin further check this gun if the people who handled it told him it was a 'cold gun'? This is the whole point: the production people whose job it was to prepare this gun told Alec that they had done it!! So they lied because they didn't actually check it! This fact alone exonerates Baldwin, period.
Sorry but he pointed the gun to a person and pulled the trigger. That along makes him guilty. A gun should never be pointed at a person whether it is cold or hot. That is for safety.
I am waayy behind. Because Time Zones. Solely based on opening statements, I'm more inclined to pay attention to the defense side.
Emily, I love you platonically, and you really are my go to legal analyst. Having said that: The dude from the opening statements really wasn't that boring, nor do I think he needed to skip parts of what he was saying.
This is coming from someone who has not closely followed this trial, and who has only heard some news through social media and whatever. I had no clue what exactly was going on, nor do I know about blanks and dummy rounds. I imagine that at least some of the jurors, if not the majority, were somewhere close to the same boat as me.
I agree he sounded a lot better when he got sped up, but the contents of his statements were not boring or unnecessary, in my opinion. Your treatment of him, however, was a little unnecessary and possibly a little disrespectful to his character.
Either way I do appreciate you endlessly, and I thank you for taking the time and giving your energy to cover these trials to teach us about the American legal system, and to entertain us while we go through the motions.
I can't believe how slow the prosecutor spoke 😂 I was trying SOOOO hard to listen because I wanted to know the sequence of events but it was painful 🥲
Man, I bet she replays every moment of that day on a loop.
It also makes so much sense it's a cadence to speak slower in that area because even the defence spoke slower than I thought
i won’t lie the defense attorneys sowed a lot of doubt in my mind why was SZ not charged with tampering, but hiding a bag that could be coke is tampering? HG 100% feels like a scapegoat.
It was a very smart of her to dye her hair one color instead of having that blonde flash in the front
Love yal emily!❤❤
Whenever emily sighs i know the lawyer speaking isnt performing on her level😅
If i was lawyer, one of my greatest fears would probably be hearing emily sigh at me
The sign of disappointment - the ultimate failure 😂
@@nzingahendricks4128 ahahahaha..yes, well I can handle a verbal confrontation.. however, a well placed sigh from someone I respect could cripple me for days lol...and emily has a power sigh🤣
A PROP GUN is just a regular gun.... the only difference is what rounds you place in it. There should have been no LIVE ammo allowed onset. Period. NO exceptions. A replica has no working parts so you can't even shoot the blanks, so that is why a replica was not used in production, I'm pretty positive that is why.
I miss being able to watch EDB live.
Scapegoat. Young girl that was NOT given respect in her role on the set. She didn't do the important safety ✔️ so she is responsible for that, but at least two other people should ALSO be prosecuted, especially the lady who threw 'things' away.
🎉
Great defense attorney
as a nurospicy new mexican I have a hard time with the DAs slow delievery
Court Tv- ‘They can get up to 60 years..’ Em- “the furk they can!” 🤣🤣🤣