Always love the "free" bonsai videos. The more information you give on this subject the easier it becomes for your viewing public to collect trees and develop their hobby for minimal cash outlay. Thanks, Peter. Just goes to show that bonsai doesn't need to be prohibitively expensive.
Maybe it's just me, but I was itching to separate the rogue sucker and let the lower branch grow 😁. Glad to see hawthorne and thx for sharing Peter and team 👍. Cheers
Another great video and an awesome tree. Peter I had never heard of root cuttings until watching your video. This year I have had about a dozen root cuttings take off that I made during repotting season. Wisteria, elm, and maple. It really is a valuable piece of knowledge thanks so much.
I've grown bonsai for twenty years, certainly not by the book, simply my own way, but watching this incredibly knowledgeable gentleman, I've learned so much about the monumental errors I've been making for so long now, Thank you sir, I bow in respect of a master!
Don't ask me why, but I'm in a children's storybook sort of mood these days, and I'm imagining the tree getting really flattered when it's her turn to be assessed and you praise her shape to high heavens.
I love it when you go at the plant with chisels and axes and then say you don't want to stress it too much. 😊 I really like the end result though! Wonderful!
That turned out really nice. Of all the field bonsai I've seen you work on this is by far my favorite, indeed it's probably my favorite of all the many I've seen you work on regardless of origin. If I lived in the UK I'd be writing you to ask about purchasing it.
Thank you and I am impressed by the number of trees you managed to get out of this tree. I cannot help wondering if the process would have been easier if you used a water jet to get rid of most of the soil first. my reasoning being, a water jet would have removed all the soil with little or no damage to the roots allowing you to separate the roots and the plants by cutting them under direct vision.
Good morning Peter. I had never changed my mind so much until I started watching Magic Chan videos. When I see one I tell myself this is undoubtedly my favorite Peter video, but that doesn't last long, until the surprise of the next job. At first I thought there was plenty of the second branch, but then I understood that what makes it special is the repetition of the movement pattern.
I've taken a few air-layerings of hawthorn recently. As thick as my arm and covered in flaky bark. They'll obviously need to grow out over a tile in the ground for a few years but hopefully I'll get a similar, instant-ish result.
Those little natural hollows in the tree, give such character! IThey spoke to me. ❤️ they said “HAPPY HOLLOWEEN’ ! Perhaps I could request a video on how to create Hollows. Or a story of there process of creation please? 🙏
Learned so much from you today. Have a question about all the sawing and hammering away at the roots. Do you ever use a water hose and separate roots that way? I have done it myself, since I am not so strong and have no associates to help me. Have not noticed any ill effects so far. Thank you for providing so much information.🙋♀️
Mr. Peter Chan, thank you for your sphagnum moss trick! It works like a miracle on the stressed trees and my collected yamadori trees. But what do you do with the sphagnum moss when the tree has recovered and the sphagnum is full of new roots? Do you remove it and replace with bonsai soil or just leave the sphagnum until it degrades?
Hi I've been watching you for sometime I have a couple of good specimens I want to know when to transplant them from pot to training pot what's a good time
No, the video is a couple of months old already as Peter Chan already said in a comment a few above yours. And take a look at one of his latest videos where he rightfully said that it is a bad idea to repot a tree in the summer or every year. Bonsais can grow for quite a while in the same pot without any problems. Only trees with a lot of root growth or younger trees need to be repotted more often than old and mature trees. Some can even grow for 5-10 years or longer in the same pot.
It seems like a rather wet mix with both the peat substitute (is that coir?) and the sphagnum. In Surrey's humid climate how often do you water this tree?
Without a pot, it's not living up to its name which translates directly as tree in pot or plant in container. But yes, potted it looks great as a Bonsai!
I just have to ask: that huge clump bursting the plastic pot and trying it tease the thing out ... wouldn't it be easier to soak the whole thing and then pull it apart?
Most of the Roseacea genus (Roses, Apple, Cotoneaster, Quince, Hawthorn etc) are prone to Rust, Blackspot and mildew. You have just got to spray it with the appropriate chemical to control these diseases.
I have a hawthorn in my yard that at put out seedling at an incredible rate. I can't stand to toss waste them either. I have no idea what I'm going to do with so many. Bonsai away I guess- 😄
May i ask why did you repot this hawthorn in the middle of summer (July?)? I guess you did it just a few days ago? Usually i repot hawthorns in march/april or late august/early september and now i am a bit confused about the best timing ...
He said in another comment that it has been a few months since he filmed this video, and both trees are doing well, so I think you must be repotting hawthorns at the correct time 😊
@@Jasper_Tree But i can see well developed leaves already on the tree, so ... it must be at least and of may or early june since he repotted this hawthorn. I would really like to hear a reason behind his decision.
My guess is that this video was filmed between mid-April and May, but it was done so with a mixture of common sense and judgement from past experience. The maples in the background of the potting bench all appear to be green. In the insect pest spraying video (6th April), the maples were on the cusp of turning completely green. So, the earliest it could be when the hawthorn video was filmed is around mid-April. But, the weather conditions in the UK have been quite odd this year. Many gardeners have reported that spring was set back a month (meaning that it was colder for a longer spell than normal). I have noticed this myself from harvesting my plum trees - in previous years plum picking would take place around the third week of June but this year they need about 2-3 weeks more before they are ready to be picked.
The hawthorns that grow here in California have nasty thorns, and if one tried to manhandle them bare-handed as in the video one would be sorry! Are English hawthorns different in that regard?
I love how even the little sucker at the bottom had grown itself into a nice literati style. It must have known whose field it was growing in!
Yes The trees Know Peter and want to be picked next so The trees allmost grow to bonsai
3 cuts in the last 10 years = almost an instant bonsai. I like your attitude to time, Peter )
Instant bonsai in 10 years and 30 minutes :)
That is the sad part. You have to start young to become a Bonsai Master.
@@jotaroslegs2345 you are not to Old to START just start!
lot of old trees out there that are just growing in the ground. Get permission and grab some!
Just run through a forest and collect mature saplings.
@@7rocedural6en71 😂 California has some very tuff tree laws you don’t want to fuck with someone else’s trees unless they hang over your property.
You again showed us how to never fixate on a style for a tree. Consider “everything” and anything. And be BOLD. Thank you Mr. Chan.
you are a guru. the entertainment value of your work grows at the same rate that i understand what you are doing.
Always love the "free" bonsai videos. The more information you give on this subject the easier it becomes for your viewing public to collect trees and develop their hobby for minimal cash outlay. Thanks, Peter. Just goes to show that bonsai doesn't need to be prohibitively expensive.
Nice progress! Also, I like the fact that Peter always try to recycle everything. 👍👍👍
The person holding the camera is Cool!
Josh. He's doing a good job.
Absolutely stunning. Peter has the eye of a true artist
-"I'm not going to show you the boring cutting up of the pot". Then proceeds with showing the cutting of the pot, haha. I love it.
Fair do's that pot put up a good fight! 🙂
The helper did a good job. I would personally use a heavy duty box cutter with a new blade. It would be must faster.
@@nightcoder5k Josh.
can't wait to see the other three trees in pots!
Great analysis Josh.
I really like the 2 little shoots growing near the base
Credits to the camera operator! Wonderful job sir!
Woke up having a bad day, and Peter is making it better.
Love a bonsai made with hatchet and cold chisel 😄
Maybe it's just me, but I was itching to separate the rogue sucker and let the lower branch grow 😁. Glad to see hawthorne and thx for sharing Peter and team 👍. Cheers
Another great video and an awesome tree. Peter I had never heard of root cuttings until watching your video. This year I have had about a dozen root cuttings take off that I made during repotting season. Wisteria, elm, and maple. It really is a valuable piece of knowledge thanks so much.
I always get excited when you put out a new videos.
I've grown bonsai for twenty years, certainly not by the book, simply my own way, but watching this incredibly knowledgeable gentleman, I've learned so much about the monumental errors I've been making for so long now, Thank you sir, I bow in respect of a master!
Don't ask me why, but I'm in a children's storybook sort of mood these days, and I'm imagining the tree getting really flattered when it's her turn to be assessed and you praise her shape to high heavens.
I love Peters attitude, no messing around. Great work
Watching this while waiting on my Herons delivery!
Beautiful work , enjoy your videos
🌲 creating on the hoof, going with the flow! Nice one! 🌳👍
Thank you for sharing your experience, the video was very helpful.
Nice to meet you and friends who are passionate about bonsai 🙆♂️
I love it when you go at the plant with chisels and axes and then say you don't want to stress it too much. 😊 I really like the end result though! Wonderful!
That turned out really nice. Of all the field bonsai I've seen you work on this is by far my favorite, indeed it's probably my favorite of all the many I've seen you work on regardless of origin.
If I lived in the UK I'd be writing you to ask about purchasing it.
Email our office for a price
Excellent timing. I've been wanting to see what Pater does with Hawthorne.
you 2 make a good team
Loved the pools used... jeje
As always, another great video!
Thats a really nice tree
You are superb explainer
Thank you and I am impressed by the number of trees you managed to get out of this tree. I cannot help wondering if the process would have been easier if you used a water jet to get rid of most of the soil first. my reasoning being, a water jet would have removed all the soil with little or no damage to the roots allowing you to separate the roots and the plants by cutting them under direct vision.
Instant bonsai in only 10 years.
that tree looks great
What a treat! Thank you for this and all your videos.
Amazing work and video as always.
Beautifully interesting trunk on the main tree.
Good morning Peter. I had never changed my mind so much until I started watching Magic Chan videos. When I see one I tell myself this is undoubtedly my favorite Peter video, but that doesn't last long, until the surprise of the next job. At first I thought there was plenty of the second branch, but then I understood that what makes it special is the repetition of the movement pattern.
Loved this video. Thanks!
Instant bonsai… just 10 years in the making :D I love him lmao
I've taken a few air-layerings of hawthorn recently. As thick as my arm and covered in flaky bark. They'll obviously need to grow out over a tile in the ground for a few years but hopefully I'll get a similar, instant-ish result.
Very interesting 👏👏
I'm growing a cascade hawthorn.. they are cool trees
Beauty well done 👍👍👍
Dear Mr Chan, could you perhaps do a video on olive bonsai trees? Interested to see your take on them :)
Regards.
I have done a video on two very big ones we have on the nursery - look it up
The second tree would make a very interesting root over rock tree
This is a lot like yamadori work . Great video
Agree with you on the character. Nice work
Muy lindo trabajo!!!!! Felicitaciones Peter
Think I might have got the pressure washer on that rootball!
whenever the hatchet comes out...you know it's gonna be a bonsai fo free! jah bless!
Those black nursery pots are damn hard, all ready had to cut open a few myself.
I used a box cutter
Those little natural hollows in the tree, give such character! IThey spoke to me. ❤️ they said “HAPPY HOLLOWEEN’ ! Perhaps I could request a video on how to create Hollows. Or a story of there process of creation please? 🙏
I really enjoyed this video and found it very informative and useful as I am trying to save an old hawthorn atm
Learned so much from you today. Have a question about all the sawing and hammering away at the roots. Do you ever use a water hose and separate roots that way? I have done it myself, since I am not so strong and have no associates to help me. Have not noticed any ill effects so far. Thank you for providing so much information.🙋♀️
That also works but using water is very messy and not good for videoing
Love this tree
Mr. Peter Chan, thank you for your sphagnum moss trick! It works like a miracle on the stressed trees and my collected yamadori trees.
But what do you do with the sphagnum moss when the tree has recovered and the sphagnum is full of new roots? Do you remove it and replace with bonsai soil or just leave the sphagnum until it degrades?
Leave the moss in place - it is good for the tree
@@peterchan3100 thank you very much!
Hi I've been watching you for sometime I have a couple of good specimens I want to know when to transplant them from pot to training pot what's a good time
It's beautiful .
Hey Peter , it would be very nice to see a bonsai video dedicated for india specific trees.
I dont have that material as I am in the UK - so this is not possible
Beautiful!! You can cut roots this way in the Summer months??
No, the video is a couple of months old already as Peter Chan already said in a comment a few above yours. And take a look at one of his latest videos where he rightfully said that it is a bad idea to repot a tree in the summer or every year.
Bonsais can grow for quite a while in the same pot without any problems. Only trees with a lot of root growth or younger trees need to be repotted more often than old and mature trees. Some can even grow for 5-10 years or longer in the same pot.
@@h.b.1421 OK, yes, I saw that recent video too. Spring is the best time.
It seems like a rather wet mix with both the peat substitute (is that coir?) and the sphagnum. In Surrey's humid climate how often do you water this tree?
nice tree many thanks' for video
Wow... thanks master.
why soil is dry? this is safe?
I really liked the look of the tree at 16:10 . Would it still be classed as a bonsai if work stopped at that point?
Without a pot, it's not living up to its name which translates directly as tree in pot or plant in container. But yes, potted it looks great as a Bonsai!
@@digitaIgorilla what about bonsai that have been grown and put into an ornamental garden? Still a bonsai
Love Hawthorns my favourite tree 😅❤ really want a big one to develop
I just have to ask: that huge clump bursting the plastic pot and trying it tease the thing out ... wouldn't it be easier to soak the whole thing and then pull it apart?
Brilliant 👏 ❤
excellent
🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹 thanks Peter
where do you get your tabletop potting soil trays from
Hey 🙂Im so interested in if that "literati-root" Has survived. Pls keep us updated 🙏
for sure the smaller part would die if i had tried to save it with so few roots!😁
Its been a couple of months now since I separated them and both are growing strongly.
I really like how that turned out. @Peter do you ever use "superthrive"?
I used to 40 years ago when I could get it from the USA but not now.
@@peterchan3100 Any reason why you dont use it now? I know one can get it uk side
It works wonders here in South Africa
Couldn't try and get the soil off with a water hose? Would that damage the roots in any way? I think it might be easier to remove the soil with water
Too messy with water
Me sitting here thinking dont cut anymore i want to buy it as it is and then me when he is done oh Nevermind i Will never be able to pay for that tree
My Hawthorne gets bad Cedar Quince rust every year, is there a recommended chemical to remove the rust, or protect the tree from getting it?
There is only one solution
It´s called love ;)
Most of the Roseacea genus (Roses, Apple, Cotoneaster, Quince, Hawthorn etc) are prone to Rust, Blackspot and mildew. You have just got to spray it with the appropriate chemical to control these diseases.
I have a hawthorn in my yard that at put out seedling at an incredible rate. I can't stand to toss waste them either. I have no idea what I'm going to do with so many. Bonsai away I guess- 😄
"In the field for 10 years" - "Instant Bonsai".... make your mind up! ;)
Peat bark lavastuff and what ? Clay ?? peter said ??
Thanks.you for the comment ♥️
That last you cut off at 13 mins, I'd have cut horizontal and used the remnant to create part of the nebari.
Is it always necessary to wire the bonsai to the pot? And why does it have to be wired to the pot?
They wires them in to stop the tree from falling out in bad weather ect so the tree doesn't get damaged until it roots its self in the pot
They wire them to stop the tree falling out in bad weather ect to protect the tree until it roots itself in the pot so yes it is nessary
Hello my personal opinion, i like 25:45 as the front side better.
May i ask why did you repot this hawthorn in the middle of summer (July?)? I guess you did it just a few days ago? Usually i repot hawthorns in march/april or late august/early september and now i am a bit confused about the best timing ...
He said in another comment that it has been a few months since he filmed this video, and both trees are doing well, so I think you must be repotting hawthorns at the correct time 😊
This was filmed earlier, sometimes they will tell you when it was filmed.
@@Jasper_Tree But i can see well developed leaves already on the tree, so ... it must be at least and of may or early june since he repotted this hawthorn. I would really like to hear a reason behind his decision.
My guess is that this video was filmed between mid-April and May, but it was done so with a mixture of common sense and judgement from past experience.
The maples in the background of the potting bench all appear to be green. In the insect pest spraying video (6th April), the maples were on the cusp of turning completely green. So, the earliest it could be when the hawthorn video was filmed is around mid-April.
But, the weather conditions in the UK have been quite odd this year. Many gardeners have reported that spring was set back a month (meaning that it was colder for a longer spell than normal). I have noticed this myself from harvesting my plum trees - in previous years plum picking would take place around the third week of June but this year they need about 2-3 weeks more before they are ready to be picked.
How much?
🔥😍👍
TOP 👍👍👍
I want to power wash that root ball
for the next video, please add an Indonesian translation
How can I - not possible
👍🏼🌲🌳👍🏼🌟
I use a carpet knife
👌👍🍎
🥰🤩👍🏼❤️
Bare root it with a hose pipe would have been better
What I saw on this channel only cutting/pruning 🙏🙏
The hawthorns that grow here in California have nasty thorns, and if one tried to manhandle them bare-handed as in the video one would be sorry! Are English hawthorns different in that regard?
cut the thorns off
Think you should spend some money and get sharp tools
Damn the bonsai is cool but the guy with the camera is hot :D