This may sound controversial, but few Left Channels are focusing on such high quality content. Congrats for your ability to constantly produce such high quality discussion. P.S- Too much belling ! One at the beginning, one at the middle, one at the end may suffice?
Many economist and politician in India say India should lern from china in terms of economics. Bu there are U.S.A lobby in India.iead about it on 11 Feb 2024. IT PEOPLe have to work 24 hour a day.please comment on this
hunger-free world. A hunger free India? A hunger free basti ? This lady could visit GovindPuri New Delhi once - Approx 15 lac undocumented peoples live there. To see the Hunger bound reality. Point being, the global north cannot be blamed for deep inequalities within the Indian caste and economic structure. The Indian imperialism or say Baniya-Brahman apartheid. Terms like Mahamari and Bhukmari, are frequent use in India through the 50s 60s into the 2000s. Also India which spends so much money on weapons military tech (wow) - it also contains 1/3rd of the total malnutrition children on earth. This cannot be blamed on any global north or outside imperialism. Incoming future will contain more food shortage, be it the global north or south. The Indian subcontinent itself could be a region of mass exodus, the experts say.
Oh absolutely. Caste based exclusion is a big problem for all schemes of general welfare. But i think the deeper point is even if there were not to be such persistent castism, the food imperialism will still be a problem. That is the common problem of all the poor of the global south. In india, the fight against food imperialism will require the dismantling of caste. In fact the must be part of the same movement.
@@arjunravichandran7578 Agreed that even if we can imagine or manage a caste-free India, the food problem will remain or even be worse. The thing to consider, which this channel generally disregards, is science. There is a biophysical limit to the number of people can be in steady state. Within a country, a region, a continent and the whole earth. India is way over that biophysical limit. India is in overshoot stage. What follows usually is a collapse stage. Now in that situation, called Mahamari in Hindi, caste will again come back to feed the elite and starve the mass.
Don't be so sure of anything. I am not a leftist, but there are grains of truth. The world functions as an organic whole as well as separate organs. All fates are intertwined.
It's people like the Patnaik family that taught me real economics. Not the garbage we learn from the Western textbooks....cheers from South Africa
This may sound controversial, but few Left Channels are focusing on such high quality content. Congrats for your ability to constantly produce such high quality discussion.
P.S- Too much belling ! One at the beginning, one at the middle, one at the end may suffice?
No I think you're right.
Excellent!! What an informative discussion. Please have more sessions with Utsa Patnaik.
Please turn off that horrid bell! Thanks so much for the content.
yes, turn off the bell! is it a temple or the chime of monetisation???
or is the bell some kind of assessment or applause for making the points youtube thinks are correct??
My favourite scholar
Great job, very educated guest and sensible questions. The bell helps people not to fall asleep haha
Yes, please turn off the bell. It interrupts the presentation/discussion. Thanks.
Keep up the good work. 🌻
Great show
i believe its something we can achieve as long as dumping crapitalism takes place first.
Many economist and politician in India say India should lern from china in terms of economics. Bu there are U.S.A lobby in India.iead about it on 11 Feb 2024. IT PEOPLe have to work 24 hour a day.please comment on this
the clicking and bell are very annoying to have interrupting this conversation
Malthus is action....................Population decline of the south being masterminded.........
It is furiously annoying to have such an interesting guest be interrupted by that ridiculous bell sound. 😡😡😡
Trade unions in india depand on poltical parties which makes weak.y cant it be changed
hunger-free world. A hunger free India? A hunger free basti ? This lady could visit GovindPuri New Delhi once - Approx 15 lac undocumented peoples live there. To see the Hunger bound reality.
Point being, the global north cannot be blamed for deep inequalities within the Indian caste and economic structure. The Indian imperialism or say Baniya-Brahman apartheid.
Terms like Mahamari and Bhukmari, are frequent use in India through the 50s 60s into the 2000s. Also India which spends so much money on weapons military tech (wow) - it also contains 1/3rd of the total malnutrition children on earth. This cannot be blamed on any global north or outside imperialism. Incoming future will contain more food shortage, be it the global north or south. The Indian subcontinent itself could be a region of mass exodus, the experts say.
Oh absolutely. Caste based exclusion is a big problem for all schemes of general welfare. But i think the deeper point is even if there were not to be such persistent castism, the food imperialism will still be a problem. That is the common problem of all the poor of the global south.
In india, the fight against food imperialism will require the dismantling of caste. In fact the must be part of the same movement.
@@arjunravichandran7578 Agreed that even if we can imagine or manage a caste-free India, the food problem will remain or even be worse.
The thing to consider, which this channel generally disregards, is science. There is a biophysical limit to the number of people can be in steady state. Within a country, a region, a continent and the whole earth. India is way over that biophysical limit. India is in overshoot stage. What follows usually is a collapse stage. Now in that situation, called Mahamari in Hindi, caste will again come back to feed the elite and starve the mass.
Don't be so sure of anything. I am not a leftist, but there are grains of truth. The world functions as an organic whole as well as separate organs. All fates are intertwined.