I live in Us and masjid is 20 min away it is very hard to pray all 5 namaz at mosque. I actually started praying reg. May Allah forgive me and accept my namaz
May Allah make it easy for you Ameen Try to go to the masjid or if you are with other muslim men ask them to pray with jamat with you . Masjid can be anywhere clean
I visit mosque every Juma prayer but not all five daily prayer ...and I do pray daily in my house or relatives house if I am visiting or in a masjid if I am traveling...but I am regularly pray.
Good answer. SALAT is required. Preference is for congregational prayer in Mosque. Will start doing that in sha ALLAH. Two opinions---Farze kafaya or Farze Ain.
I don't go to mosque. None of my family members know that I pray. That's because when I pray (except jummah) my mom goes like "Oh! Are you okay? Since when?". So I just pray in my room secretly or in mosque alone.
Thats not a valid reason brother to leave salah .. even if ur parent stop you from praying islam gave u a right to not listen to them and pray …but in your case its not forcing so this reason is not valid may allah bless u brother🫀
@@PrachinGyanSutra why it will hurt anyone?, but islam itself is a toxic ideology, responsible for genocide and ethnic cleansing of Hindus in indian subcontinent..kashmir- 5 to 0%, Afg- 2 to 0. Pakistan -14 to 2%, Bangladesh 28 % to 7% now and in few decades ,will be near 0 ,there as well. ..
It is very hard in the US. The closest Majid is about a 20 minute drive. I would have to do nothing all day but stay there if I do not want to keep driving back and forth 5 times daily so it is very hard to do all 5.
But there is also a hadith which says that dont make your homes as graveyard and pray there as well. Does it mean the compulsory prayer or just the sunnah one?
@@zoraizkhan6230 According to Dar Al-Ifta, the majority of scholars agree that congregational prayers, except for Friday prayers, are not an individual obligation."it is an emphasized sunnah or recommended action. This was the position of Imam Malik, Abu Hanifah, and many Shafi’i scholars.
Hello Zakir Uncle lets say there is only one Muslim man in an Isolated state of United States then should he ask other non-Muslims to participate with him to fulfill his fardh? Look the purpose of praying salah in congregation mentioned in surah nisa was in the context of a battle ground.
No there is no need for that, how will the prayers of a non believer even be accepted when they dont even believe in Allah and the prophet pbuh? Who will they be praying to? Just fulfill your duties and pray Salah, preferably in congregation or if not possible, privately.
I suffer from Dysplasia which means when hearing prays on loudspeaker I get Dysplasia attack. When this happens I cannot or hearing what is being said on loudspeaker therefore I have been praying at home. I just want to know if that is allowed in islam.
Dr Zakir Praying salaah congregational is not compulsory because prophet (pbuh) says praying salaah congregational has 27 times more sawaab than praying individually (sahih bukhari) so hadith clearly shows praying salaah individually is correct but has less sawaab than congregational.
A blind swahab asking prophet (pbuh) is it compulsory for me to come to the masjid because im bling Our beloved prophet (pbuh) said tie a rope from your home to the masjid and then hold and follow the rope and come to the masjid
I have extreme nyctophobia! I can't even stand outside my house after evening and before morning! So i chose to pray Fajr and Isha at home! Is it permissible or not??
I think you have a pretty valid reason and even if it isn't Allah (S.W.T) is the most forgiving So don't worry just pray at the mosque with congregation as much as you can and leave the rest for Allah to decide. Have a great day buddy ❤
My prayers are still valid. Scholars are just giving their opinions , it's not a sin in the Quran nor is there any prescribed punishment for it. Yes , it is good to pray in congregation but it isn't sinful nor my years of prayer to Allah (SWT) are invalid
there's a difference between prayer in mosque being fard and prayer outside of mosque being invalid. it's agreed that prayer outside of the mosque is still valid
If the mosque is situated within the distance of a stone s throw from your home, you should attend the mosque to pray in congregation. You may pray at home for a valid reason
@@Dosxxinfinity look, even though Allah highly recommend us that we should all pray together, but He never said that praying alone is bad, it's also good. If you can go to the masjid and pray, that's good, if cannot, don't feel bad. We're in this world only to serve Allah, whether it be praying with people or praying alone. Just pray, do good, fast in Ramadan, give zakat & thank Allah. That's it.
But sir in ur first lacture u have earlier told in question answer session that it is near to compulsory congregational prayer ..sir plz gave explanation..
That’s true , on another video he explained it as “Mustahab” but now his answer is most likely its “Compulsory” I have included the video link ua-cam.com/video/piTrNP9o2Vc/v-deo.html
@@Monjursworld Yes, I agree with you. In the old video he agreed with the “Mustahab” rule and on this video he is agreeing with the “Compulsory” rule, it's kind of self conflicting. He also said in the old video that, majority of the scholar agree with the “Mustahab” rule.
All the time it is mentioned in the Quran by Allah that, "Pray your Salah and give Zakah." Allah never mentioned absolute clearly that,"Pray your Salah in Congregation and give Zakah." So, there is always a room for debate on this topic.
@@abdullahmustafa6301 Quran doesn't even tells you how many times and how to pray. The way we pray is the way our beloved prophet Mohammed (SAW) used to pray so the way today we pray is Sunnah. Quran was revealed upon our prophet and he (saw) reflected upon Quran upon his own life as a guidance of his (saw) Ummah. Remember what you wear and weather you keep beard or not that's not important the most important Sunnah is the behavior of our prophet (SAW).
@Riz Hawk, quran mentioned all 5 salah, the time when to perform it. In different surahs and verses. Praying at mosque for men is better. 27 is better than 1
The Quran mentions in Surah Baqarah "Establish prayers and give charity and bow down with those who bow down".(2:43)here it's very clear cut that we have to bow down with those who bow down referring to congregational prayer.
There is a lot of interpretation in these evidences. First of all, he is comparing the times of the prophet to our current evil times. The prophet did say to his companions that the times in the future will become exceedingly more difficult in the future for the ummah. So I 100% agree with the hadiths the doctor mentioned in that the people who didn't come out to pray ought to have their houses burned down. How could you not pray in congregation when the prophet himself is alive during your time after seeing and knowing the man as well as witnessing all the miracles? You would be paying to go to the mosque if he was alive with us now. Are we in such blessed times? NO. Do we all live in a country where Islam rules? NO. The doctor said himself IF you heard the Athan. I do not hear it in the country I live and doing the 5 prayers by yourself today (which I do) is difficult enough let alone going to the mosque. Perspective seems to always be lost in these discussions. One such example is the infamous Quran verse "and kill the disbelievers where you find them". People use this without context wherein this verse applied to a specific situation at the time of the prophet where a treaty was broken by the pagans in which unarmed Muslims were slaughtered. Peace be upon our prophet and Allah knows best.
Al-Haakim reported in al-Mustadrak (4/359) that Anas ibn Maalik (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: There will come a time when people will sit in circles in the mosques and they will have no concern except this world. Allaah has no need of them so do not sit with them. This is a saheeh hadeeth even though al-Bukhaari and Muslim did not narrate it. Al-Dhahabi said in al-Talkhees that it is saheeh.
You are 100% correct about times now. In my local mosque a man was beaten up by several other worshippers over a petty Wudhu related argument. Other fights regularly break out. That has put me off going there to pray.
Assalamulaikum . I live in Paris, France there are very few mosques, My nearest mosque us 25 to 30 minutes away from my house. That's why I pray in my home. What can I do now ? Please inform me.
I wake up about 40-45 minutes before Fajr, so i can offer some tahajjud. After I am done, Fajr's time is about to begin, so i pray at home and go to sleep as the prayer take place 30 minutes after the time starts. Am i sinful?
If the imam do minor bidah then its fine, but if the imam does bidah which lead to shirk then its not permissible. The best option is to find a mosque where imam is free drom bidah.
But it can be said that the prohpet saw only said that fajr and Isha is only hard fir them because the people could not see them due to the lack of light.
I have social anxiety and hate being around others. I've only been in a Mosque 3 times. I think I stick with staying at home. A person shouldn't need to be around a whole bunch of other to pray.
Abu Huraira reported: There came to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) a blind man and said: Messenger of Allah, I have no one to guide me to the mosque. He, therefore, asked. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) permission to say prayer in his house. He (tee Holy Prophet) granted him permission. Then when the man turned away he called him and said: Do you hear the call to prayer? He said: Yes. He (the Prophet then) said: Respond to it. Reference : Sahih Muslim 653 In-book reference: Book 5, Hadith 319 USC-MSA web (English) reference: Book 4, Hadith 1374 (deprecated numbering scheme)
If my prayer won't accpt if i pray at home so there's no point of praying. I have a social phobia. I didn't go outside about 1 year+.. Its psychological problem. I don't like strangers.
If you have a severe phobia then it’s okay. Allah is understanding and the most merciful. Why would Allah invalidate your prayers when you can’t leave the house. Anyways, hope Allah can cure you and hopefully you can gradually push yourself to go to the mosque. Honestly noone cares about anyone else, its pretty peaceful at the mosque
There is no problem in it brother, only by praying in congregation,u will get 27 times more reward, it doesn't mean if u pray at home ur prayer is invalid,u are infinite Times better than those who don't even pray any namaz except Juma namaz, and mashallah u go to masjid for Juma namaz,so it's completely fine,there is no problem,u r not sinful according to me
If this demotivate you then pray to allah for hedayat. Because, you can felt that praying farz salah at mosque and home is never be same. I tried, when I pray farz salah at home after few days doing these it makes me lazy and concentration is also not great when I pray salah in congestion
I wish my brothers listen to you most of them grow up in new mosque when the mosque build now they're brown they're bussy with their family not big family only few kids one & two & none
It seems there r many foundational hadeeth evidences that aligns with prayering at mosque while less Quran verses(which is words of Allah swt) to a compulsory of such act. & It is ash'hadu alla ilaha illa allah, Muhammed wa rasoolullah. Muhammed is his messanger. So Mhd(PBUH) words ofcourse counts as well.
Not sure if my reasoning is valid but I am well known in my area and so whenever i exit the house i must look well dressed otherwise People talk. I really would like to go to the masjid and pray there regularly if i wasnt seen as a recognised person.
I work 7 days a week. How am i suppose to pray at the mosque? Do i just drop work and go to a mosque, that's just not possible at all. See how difficult this all becomes? I try to do my best and still its not good enough. We are not rich people that have nothing but free time on our hands to go to the mosque 5 times a day. Unfair
Do what is possible! Allah swt doesn't expect you to do what you cannot but I doubt you are at work 24 hrs a day 7 days a week, so ask for guidance and do what you can. Just make sure you pray 5 times a day. Allah swt knows best. Ask Allah to make it easy for you. Ameen
@@thequantum-plator I know what kind of "valid excuse" today's generation has.... You don't need to spoil them! Of course I'm not saying them to go to masjid when they have high fever or illness or they have a big pain on part of body which are valid excuses but no, this brother is asking question just like that "valid excuse" will not make him pray in masjid till his death...Valid excuse is always temporary, not permanent! Today's generation likes to go outside from home for school/buying something/playing with their friends but yet they have so-called "valid excuses" for not going in Masjids!
@@thequantum-plator seems like u r also one of them therefore getting offended....but that's truth...nice to meet u...I'm also from this generation therefore I know u guys better :-) Btw thanks for honoring me with beautiful and brain-touching words...
The prophet also said the best deed is when it is secret, and the quran also said we made the entire earth a place of worship.. My opinion is it is recommended but it cant be consider haram not to pray in the Masjid for some reason some places did not have even a Masjid, my view is the congregation is what recommended but not necessary at the Masjid because you can also do Jamaa at home..during the prophets time they dont have a loud speaker for the adhan, in our time a masjid 2 - 3kms away the adhan can be heard, second nowadays there are a lot of differences in our religion, that masjid maybe a shia, or any other that are not the same to what you are following, It doesnt make sense to me it becomes Haram to him just because he dont pray at the Masjid, Islam is not that hard..
Praying at mosque isn't hard bro. Would u feel same if they gave you 1 million $ daily if u went mosque? U wouldn't. But prayer is more important than money. I am struggling too but with imaan In Sha Allah it will get easier. I am not being mean to u I am just saying :) hope u took something good from it. Ameen.
@@ZincZXzinx ok it may not be hard for you, but my point is you cannot limit the prayer within the masjid only..it doesnt make sense.. If it is fard that means prayer is only at the masjid, why there is a rules of making up the delayed prayer? That alone prove that fard prayers are not limited at the masjid..
@@nashi.t3965 bro/sis, you are taking things lightly by giving your own understanding over people of knowledge who studied these stuff. Please consult a scholar on these matters. Also it's not about it being easy or hard for me. You don't know me bro. I am by no means someone really pious. I am striving just like you and other person. We should not just disregard mosque prayer saying its not fard... please try to understand what I mean.
@@ZincZXzinx i am saying base on my understanding, and i give you my ayah as well, you dont know me too, pretty much i know you dont even know yourself as well.. To say fard you are saying you will commit a sin, praying in the masjid is recommended not fard, the prophet gave the advantage of praying in the masjid, but to say its fard? You mean if we missed it we are no longer allow to pray after the prayer in the masjid? How does it make sense? How do you limit the prayer in the masjid? Thats why we are still allowed to pray if we have delayed it, it prove that we can pray anywhere, understand it, it is recommended not Fard..
Asallamu alaikum, if anyone can guide us are we allowed to offer prayer at home instead of going to the masjid although masjid is nearby.. Can we form a jamat of all of us residing in a joint family consisiting of mother, father and their three childrens and their spouses.. please guide if this is allowed..
@@ummarfarooqpk You can pray behind him if he only does biddahs... but if he is extreme Sufi or Barelvi who has shirky beliefs u can't pray behind him... You will have to find another masjid and btw where do u then pray Jumma Namaz lol.... If u can pray Jumma Namaz prayer there what's wrong in other prayers? If Imam has shirky beliefs you should completely abandon such masjids and pray Jumma Namaz elsewhere even if it is far away... And for other cases, if the masjid is under 1km u should pray there regularly every namaz otherwise I don't think it is mandated upon you... Allah knows best
Assalamu elaykum! Mujhe Aisa lagta hi ke Jung ladte huye namaaz padna aur Jung hosakne ke haalaat me namaaz padna do alag baatein hi. jung ladte huye koi namaaz Kaise Ada karsakta hi. Agar jung hone ke haalaat hi to koi kaise apne aap ku aise hi halaak karva lega. Mujhe aisa lagta hi ke Allah swt jung ke haalaat kaise rehna hi hame apne nabi ke zariye bataa rahe hi. Aap apni namaaz kam karlo, aap apne dushman se chaukanna raho ye waqt dekh kar ( namaaz ka waqt ) Aap par hamlawar hosakta hi. Isliye aap log nammaz me ek dusre ki nigraani Karo ,kaha hi. Agar army ke soldiers alag alag rehke namaaz padhenge to jyaada chances hi ke wo dushman ke haat marejayenge. To isi liye Allah SWT ne yaha Pe namaaz jamaat ke saat adaa karna farz kardiya. Aisa mujhe lagta hi. Kyu ke mujhe aisa lagta hi ke mustahab ya Muba Kaam nazook halaat me farz hosakte hi. Allah swt Sabkuch Janne wale hi. Me sirf ek talib e ilm hun. Kuch galti hoto maafkardo aur sudhaaro.
Praying namaz at other places except home is permissible only and only if there is a valid excuse....But in the era of so much convenience and technology, do you think u have any such excuse? So pray in masjid!
@@hasnain9654 if someone don't want to follow a sunnah which is not even a mustahab , just to rebel with Allah Swt and his prophet muhammad pbuh then he or she is doing a major sin. And Quran and Sunnah are not depend on technology and other things. Allah knows best
@@imrozeroshan2312 Why r u talking like Shias? Shias keep such beliefs, Sunnis respect and adhere Sunnah along with Quran... And obeying PROPHET PBUH is the part of your faith....You can't obey Allah unless you know how to do obligatory things which are explained in Hadiths... And if Hadith makes something haram it becomes haram no matter what.... But if you are Shia then do WHATEVER YOU WANNA DO!!
@@tam6493 thats right they are making Islam hard, how could they say that praying in the masjid is fard? Thats why we are allowed to make up the delayed prayer at home or anywhere if we missed the concregation prayer at the masjid it proves that praying in the masjid is just recommended but not fard..
@@tam6493 thats right they are making Islam hard, how could they say that praying in the masjid is fard? Thats why we are allowed to make up the delayed prayer at home or anywhere if we missed the concregation prayer at the masjid it proves that praying in the masjid is just recommended but not fard..
lol you think praying in Masjid is a compulsion for you?.. wow...Playing and hanging up with friends 24/7 doesn't feel compulsion to you but this feels compulsion to you? wow man so impressed by your thoughts
Zakir bhai assalamualekum .I am ashfaque .m.p. india . Bhai merey town ki masjid me kuch paise baale log ghar me juma know namaaz padh rahey hai aur kuch log unko khush karney ke leye unkey saath namaaz padh rahey hai jabki masjid open hai .wajeh imam sahab quran hadeth ki baat kartey hai. Is par ek bayaan zaroor karey hindi me please sir
I don't think these imams should make such statements as the prophet is not between us now and I don't think there is anyone has connection with Allah to talk on behalf the public and determine what they should do in our era. We have the Quran, we can read and comply with to the best of our capabilities, but these imams don't understand the poor as they all don't work like you and I. They all get paid by the governments to preach. If I am working in a place and I go to my boss and tell him that I will have to leave work 4-5 times every shift to go to the mosque to pray, I will be fired on the spot because who wants to hire someone that does that. I know some of you will be okay well Quran says that God created the human and gin to worship only. Fine, then pay me so I can feed myself and my family and then I will do what you ask. The answer from these imams will be oh well we all have to work. These imams should be ashamed of themselves by trying to force kids who are trying to be close to Allah to leave the religion as they want them to pray 5 times day one, wear your burka, fast the month of Ramadan, read Quran, and if you don't, then the prophet said you are Kafar. Wallah there is no Kafar in this world outside them for spreading fear in the heart of muslims. Read the Quran and comply to the best of your Capabilities. Allah will judge us by his mercy otherwise we all going to hell because we all forced to do jobs that we don't want to do to be able to feed our families and live in countries we don't want to live in.
Assalamualekom. Some years ago you said that Praying in congregation is mustahab and majority of the scholars are with this view but now you are saying that Praying in congregation is obligatory. Which opinion of yours is correct? And you also said in past that majority of the scholars are of the view that congregation is obligatory? Which statement of yours is correct?
@@antisocial333 we should 5 times prayer only for allah dr zakir naik don't know anything even the female can 5 times prayer at masjid and home says Quran not Hadith because Hadith makes the Islam destroyed that is why our prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi vasallam forbidden not to write Hadith of prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi vasallam.
Qur'an allha bani itna agaar masjid jana joruri hota toh allha Qur'an pe bata deta hadith pe mujhe believe nahi hain q ki oo prophet ne bhi nahi likha a collection ki gyi bate Hain jis me glti a ho Sakta hain
Ye to akhri jamana ka sign ha. (People will claim to follow the Qur'an but will reject hadith & sunnah (Abu Dawood) Rasul sm ne formaya keyamat ka ek nishan ye ha ki kuch log quran manneka bat karega aur wo same log Hadith aur sunnah ko reject karega. Ap bhi keyamat ka us nishan se ho. Hadith kese logoka bana hua ho saktehe? Ye sahabi ka bate ha jo wo rasul sm se sikha aur rasul sm ne hadith ki bareme bola islie rasul sm ki janeki bad sahaba ne wo sab hadith likhna suru kia. Lekin iska matlab ye to nehi ki bad me likha to jhut ho geya. Agar apki kisi honest friend ne apki maut ki bad apki bareme kuch likha to wo galat hoga? Apki mammi ki bareme ap jo likhoge to kia wo jhut honge? Kew ki apko to apki ammi ki bareme pata ha. Par agar ma kuch likhunga to galat hoga. Wese hi sahaba ne rasul sm ki sat apni jindegi guzare aur Rasul sm ki hadith ki bareme une hi pata tha.
I live in Us and masjid is 20 min away it is very hard to pray all 5 namaz at mosque. I actually started praying reg. May Allah forgive me and accept my namaz
You can go to work but not masjid
May Allah make it easy for you Ameen
Try to go to the masjid or if you are with other muslim men ask them to pray with jamat with you . Masjid can be anywhere clean
@@LeftHanded-kt5hzcause we have to go to masjid 5 times that means 20minx5💀 so stfu child
See 9:10
@@LeftHanded-kt5hzyou seems praying 5 time in mosque.
May Allah Almighty Bless Him & All Of Us. Ameen!
La ilaha illallah.
Muhammadur rasoolullah (s.a.w.s).
I was looking for that answer
very helpful
MashaAllah BarakAllah.
JazakAllahu khairun kaseera for sharing it
Astagfirullah Ya Rabb forgive us and guide us all to the right path n keep us all away frm all sins Ameeen🤲🏽♥️
I visit mosque every Juma prayer but not all five daily prayer ...and I do pray daily in my house or relatives house if I am visiting or in a masjid if I am traveling...but I am regularly pray.
I prefer reading at home. Except Friday jumah prayers
Me too
Good answer. SALAT is required. Preference is for congregational prayer in Mosque. Will start doing that in sha ALLAH. Two opinions---Farze kafaya or Farze Ain.
Jazakallah hu Khairan, Alhamdulillah....
i do congregation salat in prayers room with other staff at hospital. i work at hospital.
Sir the hadith you quoted for burning of houses was for Jumma prayers
Any reference brother?
I don't go to mosque.
None of my family members know that I pray. That's because when I pray (except jummah) my mom goes like "Oh! Are you okay? Since when?".
So I just pray in my room secretly or in mosque alone.
Thats not a valid reason brother to leave salah .. even if ur parent stop you from praying islam gave u a right to not listen to them and pray …but in your case its not forcing so this reason is not valid may allah bless u brother🫀
Watch zafar heretic ex Muslim sshil
@@inam535Oh really, 😅😅 According To Majority Scholars Opinion Going to Masjid This Was Recommended Not Manditory...🤐
@@mrsandeepreddyjtn why is it hurting you that hes praying
@@PrachinGyanSutra why it will hurt anyone?, but islam itself is a toxic ideology, responsible for genocide and ethnic cleansing of Hindus in indian subcontinent..kashmir- 5 to 0%, Afg- 2 to 0. Pakistan -14 to 2%, Bangladesh 28 % to 7% now and in few decades ,will be near 0 ,there as well. ..
As per Wakf instructions , 60+aged people are not going mosques due to covid19 situation
Masha Allah
Allah bless you nd your family
Can we pray ishrak after praying fagr in masjid at home
It is very hard in the US. The closest Majid is about a 20 minute drive. I would have to do nothing all day but stay there if I do not want to keep driving back and forth 5 times daily so it is very hard to do all 5.
But there is also a hadith which says that dont make your homes as graveyard and pray there as well. Does it mean the compulsory prayer or just the sunnah one?
Our prophet (pbuh) said to pray the compulsory prayers in mosque and the rest at home. So sunnah prayers should be prayed at home.
Don't Worry Brother According to Majority Scholars opinion praying masjid Not Compulsory 🎉
@@yasin_Ko you sure? Can you give any reference (like name)?
@@zoraizkhan6230 According to Dar Al-Ifta, the majority of scholars agree that congregational prayers, except for Friday prayers, are not an individual obligation."it is an emphasized sunnah or recommended action. This was the position of Imam Malik, Abu Hanifah, and many Shafi’i scholars.
@@yasin_Ko can you tell who is Dar Al-Ifta? I am hearing the name for the first time.
Hello Zakir Uncle lets say there is only one Muslim man in an Isolated state of United States then should he ask other non-Muslims to participate with him to fulfill his fardh? Look the purpose of praying salah in congregation mentioned in surah nisa was in the context of a battle ground.
No there is no need for that, how will the prayers of a non believer even be accepted when they dont even believe in Allah and the prophet pbuh? Who will they be praying to? Just fulfill your duties and pray Salah, preferably in congregation or if not possible, privately.
I suffer from Dysplasia which means when hearing prays on loudspeaker I get Dysplasia attack.
When this happens I cannot or hearing what is being said on loudspeaker therefore I have been praying at home.
I just want to know if that is allowed in islam.
Dr Zakir Praying salaah congregational is not compulsory because prophet (pbuh) says praying salaah congregational has 27 times more sawaab than praying individually (sahih bukhari) so hadith clearly shows praying salaah individually is correct but has less sawaab than congregational.
Hadith no. 645 and 646 in Bukhari 🥰
A blind swahab asking prophet (pbuh) is it compulsory for me to come to the masjid because im bling
Our beloved prophet (pbuh) said tie a rope from your home to the masjid and then hold and follow the rope and come to the masjid
Do you have a youtube channel scholar?
@@fare1181 why,do you have any questions??
@@linoshaji4669 please give reference
I have extreme nyctophobia! I can't even stand outside my house after evening and before morning! So i chose to pray Fajr and Isha at home! Is it permissible or not??
I think you have a pretty valid reason and even if it isn't Allah (S.W.T) is the most forgiving
So don't worry just pray at the mosque with congregation as much as you can and leave the rest for Allah to decide.
Have a great day buddy ❤
How about the hadith where our Prophet (S.A.W) says that the entire Earth is made a masjid except for the washroom and graveyard?
My prayers are still valid. Scholars are just giving their opinions , it's not a sin in the Quran nor is there any prescribed punishment for it. Yes , it is good to pray in congregation but it isn't sinful nor my years of prayer to Allah (SWT) are invalid
Be careful, You're thinking as if you know more than Scholars. May allah accept all of our prayers.
there's a difference between prayer in mosque being fard and prayer outside of mosque being invalid. it's agreed that prayer outside of the mosque is still valid
don’t follow your desires astaghfirullah. how do you know more than the scholars?
We live here the temperature is very high, plus I'm sensitive to sun, i head headaches for being out even for few minutes
So i pray at home mostly
I LOVE YOU SO MUCH MY DEAR DOCTOR ❤️❤️❤️
Doctor 🤣😂Become a gay like ur profit Mo Mo - the rapist
Yes a Muslim can do ebadat or prayer at home, if he is not associated with any sect (firqa) of Muslims.
If the mosque is situated within the distance of a stone s throw from your home, you should attend the mosque to pray in congregation. You may pray at home for a valid reason
5:57 9:30 12:27
Please quote context of the hadees of blind sahabi RA
Sunan abi dawud 552
Im 19 going to be 20 within 1 month
Im praying every prayer at my room execpt Jummah.. Even masjid is near to my house 😔
@Dar Suhaib٢٣٢ u r from??
Same
Here masjid is 950metre (almost 1km) away from my house.... What can I do? 😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫😫
You are not Muslims in your mind you must change your religion for happy life
@@uniquepawan3911 I can't understand your words
I have Spinal cord issues and it hurts alot sometimes.....so can i offer salah at home when my spine pains
Yes
I don't go to the mosque much anymore just pray at home. I'm just not connected to the mosque anymore. But llhamdulilah for all.
According to Majority Scholars opinion Not Compulsory in praying masjid
How I can send my query to Dr. Zakir naik sir ?
Will it be as equal to pray in congregation at home with Muslim brothers as it is at Mosque?
If the person leading a prayer at mosque is a musrik. Can a good muslim pray at is back also?
😔 we are in so much trouble 😭😭
What do you mean?
@@rohail-saqib I mean how many of us goes to the mescid and prays?
@@Dosxxinfinity look, even though Allah highly recommend us that we should all pray together, but He never said that praying alone is bad, it's also good.
If you can go to the masjid and pray, that's good, if cannot, don't feel bad. We're in this world only to serve Allah, whether it be praying with people or praying alone.
Just pray, do good, fast in Ramadan, give zakat & thank Allah.
That's it.
@@rohail-saqib I agree! Although we are all going to a place where we all will wish we did more.
@@Dosxxinfinity yup.
But sir in ur first lacture u have earlier told in question answer session that it is near to compulsory congregational prayer ..sir plz gave explanation..
Brother, he did explain about this in this video MashaAllah.
That’s true , on another video he explained it as “Mustahab” but now his answer is most likely its “Compulsory” I have included the video link ua-cam.com/video/piTrNP9o2Vc/v-deo.html
@@Monjursworld Yes, I agree with you. In the old video he agreed with the “Mustahab” rule and on this video he is agreeing with the “Compulsory” rule, it's kind of self conflicting. He also said in the old video that, majority of the scholar agree with the “Mustahab” rule.
Can we shorten the prayers at our own place( in another city) when we intends to stay there for four days?
No you can't shorten it only when u r traveling on the way u can shorten it
How lazy can u be to shorten your prayer just because you are not in your city 🤦♀️ sad. Seriously
Please write the name of Allah in capital letter's video editor's and public :)
All the time it is mentioned in the Quran by Allah that, "Pray your Salah and give Zakah." Allah never mentioned absolute clearly that,"Pray your Salah in Congregation and give Zakah."
So, there is always a room for debate on this topic.
In quran there is "establish namaz"
@@abdullahmustafa6301 Quran doesn't even tells you how many times and how to pray. The way we pray is the way our beloved prophet Mohammed (SAW) used to pray so the way today we pray is Sunnah. Quran was revealed upon our prophet and he (saw) reflected upon Quran upon his own life as a guidance of his (saw) Ummah. Remember what you wear and weather you keep beard or not that's not important the most important Sunnah is the behavior of our prophet (SAW).
@Riz Hawk, quran mentioned all 5 salah, the time when to perform it. In different surahs and verses.
Praying at mosque for men is better. 27 is better than 1
@@sea120305 Do you go to the Mosque everyday and pray 5 times Salah daily in the Mosque?
The Quran mentions in Surah Baqarah "Establish prayers and give charity and bow down with those who bow down".(2:43)here it's very clear cut that we have to bow down with those who bow down referring to congregational prayer.
Jazzak Allahu khair
There is a lot of interpretation in these evidences.
First of all, he is comparing the times of the prophet to our current evil times. The prophet did say to his companions that the times in the future will become exceedingly more difficult in the future for the ummah.
So I 100% agree with the hadiths the doctor mentioned in that the people who didn't come out to pray ought to have their houses burned down. How could you not pray in congregation when the prophet himself is alive during your time after seeing and knowing the man as well as witnessing all the miracles? You would be paying to go to the mosque if he was alive with us now.
Are we in such blessed times? NO.
Do we all live in a country where Islam rules? NO. The doctor said himself IF you heard the Athan. I do not hear it in the country I live and doing the 5 prayers by yourself today (which I do) is difficult enough let alone going to the mosque.
Perspective seems to always be lost in these discussions. One such example is the infamous Quran verse "and kill the disbelievers where you find them". People use this without context wherein this verse applied to a specific situation at the time of the prophet where a treaty was broken by the pagans in which unarmed Muslims were slaughtered. Peace be upon our prophet and Allah knows best.
To be on the safer side,
do you think your opinion, or the ijtihad of scholars, experts, and people who studied Islam for decades, is more valid?
Al-Haakim reported in al-Mustadrak (4/359) that Anas ibn Maalik (may Allaah be pleased with him) said: The Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: There will come a time when people will sit in circles in the mosques and they will have no concern except this world. Allaah has no need of them so do not sit with them. This is a saheeh hadeeth even though al-Bukhaari and Muslim did not narrate it. Al-Dhahabi said in al-Talkhees that it is saheeh.
If u don't wanna follow, then it's fine,,,,
Don't spread 'fitnah' among the people...
You are 100% correct about times now. In my local mosque a man was beaten up by several other worshippers over a petty Wudhu related argument. Other fights regularly break out. That has put me off going there to pray.
@@AH-hz5xc May I ask what nation you are in? I will be careful to pray only in my hotel if I ever visit.
Please someone help me this full lecture English writing here please 😢😢
Assalamulaikum .
I live in Paris, France there are very few mosques,
My nearest mosque us 25 to 30 minutes away from my house.
That's why I pray in my home.
What can I do now ?
Please inform me.
You can pray in your home
I wake up about 40-45 minutes before Fajr, so i can offer some tahajjud. After I am done, Fajr's time is about to begin, so i pray at home and go to sleep as the prayer take place 30 minutes after the time starts. Am i sinful?
Yes.
If the imam does bidah and follows peer, should I pray behind him or pray alone?
Search in google
You shouldn't. It is rightly mentioned in the Qur'an, I had the same question until I happened to fall upon an aayat in the Qur'an.
If the imam do minor bidah then its fine, but if the imam does bidah which lead to shirk then its not permissible.
The best option is to find a mosque where imam is free drom bidah.
Find another masjid
Then pray alone, we should all stay away from shirk
Im Towfeeq,Can we wish long life for our parents and Ourselves...
Is it Permissible/halal
i don't know about that but you can make dua for there good health
But it can be said that the prohpet saw only said that fajr and Isha is only hard fir them because the people could not see them due to the lack of light.
I have social anxiety and hate being around others. I've only been in a Mosque 3 times. I think I stick with staying at home. A person shouldn't need to be around a whole bunch of other to pray.
Nobody will judge in a mosque bro don’t Mather how you look etc but I understand i also have problems
Abu Huraira reported:
There came to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) a blind man and said: Messenger of Allah, I have no one to guide me to the mosque. He, therefore, asked. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) permission to say prayer in his house. He (tee Holy Prophet) granted him permission. Then when the man turned away he called him and said: Do you hear the call to prayer? He said: Yes. He (the Prophet then) said: Respond to it.
Reference : Sahih Muslim 653
In-book reference: Book 5, Hadith 319
USC-MSA web (English) reference: Book 4, Hadith 1374 (deprecated numbering scheme)
If my prayer won't accpt if i pray at home so there's no point of praying. I have a social phobia. I didn't go outside about 1 year+.. Its psychological problem. I don't like strangers.
"So there's no point of praying" You need to learn about Allah, His names, the Day if Judgement, Heaven and Hell, etc.
Watch videos about the importance of prayer.
May Allah forgive you for even saying such a statement.
But bro something is better then nothing ryt ! ( you have to change ur self bro )
If you have a severe phobia then it’s okay. Allah is understanding and the most merciful. Why would Allah invalidate your prayers when you can’t leave the house. Anyways, hope Allah can cure you and hopefully you can gradually push yourself to go to the mosque. Honestly noone cares about anyone else, its pretty peaceful at the mosque
I don’t know why but this topic always demotivates me to pray.
There is no problem in it brother, only by
praying in congregation,u will get 27 times
more reward, it doesn't mean if u pray at
home ur prayer is invalid,u are infinite Times
better than those who don't even pray any
namaz except Juma namaz, and mashallah
u go to masjid for Juma namaz,so it's
completely fine,there is no problem,u r not
sinful according to me
@@Nadeem_NDYes ,This was majority Scholars opinion ❤
Same
@@Nadeem_NDthank you I just read your comment now. You encouraged me to keep praying with your words. May Allah bless you
If this demotivate you then pray to allah for hedayat. Because, you can felt that praying farz salah at mosque and home is never be same. I tried, when I pray farz salah at home after few days doing these it makes me lazy and concentration is also not great when I pray salah in congestion
I think men should have no excuse unless they are sick not to pray at the masjid
Asalamalikum Ii live in a place where no masjid. Nearest is 21mile can't even go to jummah because of transportation issues please suggest
According to Majority Scholars opinion Praying in Masjid recommend Not Manditory ✍️
Hello any one full lecturer give me English writing?
I want to read salah in masjid but my brother don’t want to take me
Jazakallah
I want to ask a question with dr.zakir naik pls guide me
Masha allah
Is it also compulsory for adult women to pray her 5 daily farz namaz in congregation ????
No
I need this bangla language or any one translation full English writing
It is mandatory to pray in masjid...
tell me how could The REHMAT ul LIL Alameen burn a muslim's house if he is offering prayer at home?
I wish my brothers listen to you most of them grow up in new mosque when the mosque build now they're brown they're bussy with their family not big family only few kids one & two & none
thats why we should make a mosque in our own house❤
😂
Let’s make it count everyday in 🕋 🚶🏻♂️with 500,000 + 1,200,000 vs 135 + 324 other mosques. Inshaallah.
I didn't listen to lectur but every man pray at home without mosque not many man ho mosque pray & why man pray for some reason 🧐😳
Can we pray at home during covid time?
If your masjids are closed then you don't have a choice but to pray at home :)
@@AmerDipps bro if masjid is open i don't think you should go bcz it's like doing suicide bcz your going madjid in a pandemic
You guys are making islam complicated.....people should pray by any means at mosque or in home....
It seems there r many foundational hadeeth evidences that aligns with prayering at mosque while less Quran verses(which is words of Allah swt) to a compulsory of such act.
& It is ash'hadu alla ilaha illa allah, Muhammed wa rasoolullah. Muhammed is his messanger. So Mhd(PBUH) words ofcourse counts as well.
Not sure if my reasoning is valid but I am well known in my area and so whenever i exit the house i must look well dressed otherwise People talk. I really would like to go to the masjid and pray there regularly if i wasnt seen as a recognised person.
Sir can I offer salah at Shrine Of Sheikh Abdul Qadir jeelani RA please respond
Where in the sunnah do you find this ? Nowhere so it’s bid’ah
I work 7 days a week. How am i suppose to pray at the mosque? Do i just drop work and go to a mosque, that's just not possible at all. See how difficult this all becomes? I try to do my best and still its not good enough. We are not rich people that have nothing but free time on our hands to go to the mosque 5 times a day. Unfair
Do what is possible! Allah swt doesn't expect you to do what you cannot but I doubt you are at work 24 hrs a day 7 days a week, so ask for guidance and do what you can. Just make sure you pray 5 times a day. Allah swt knows best. Ask Allah to make it easy for you. Ameen
Prophet used pray alone in cave for many days.
That was case of compulsion and a valid excuse....what excuse do you have?
@@hasnain9654 They might have a valid excuse, either give a suggestion or just watch the video, don't be haram police by replying harshly to every one
@@thequantum-plator I know what kind of "valid excuse" today's generation has.... You don't need to spoil them! Of course I'm not saying them to go to masjid when they have high fever or illness or they have a big pain on part of body which are valid excuses but no, this brother is asking question just like that "valid excuse" will not make him pray in masjid till his death...Valid excuse is always temporary, not permanent! Today's generation likes to go outside from home for school/buying something/playing with their friends but yet they have so-called "valid excuses" for not going in Masjids!
@@hasnain9654 wow 'today's generation' , judgemental and rude. Two great qualities to be a bad Muslim. Keep it up.
@@thequantum-plator seems like u r also one of them therefore getting offended....but that's truth...nice to meet u...I'm also from this generation therefore I know u guys better :-) Btw thanks for honoring me with beautiful and brain-touching words...
To brothers and sisters in the UK please pray at home because the situation on the streets is becoming dangerous may Allah keep you all safe.
The prophet also said the best deed is when it is secret, and the quran also said we made the entire earth a place of worship.. My opinion is it is recommended but it cant be consider haram not to pray in the Masjid for some reason some places did not have even a Masjid, my view is the congregation is what recommended but not necessary at the Masjid because you can also do Jamaa at home..during the prophets time they dont have a loud speaker for the adhan, in our time a masjid 2 - 3kms away the adhan can be heard, second nowadays there are a lot of differences in our religion, that masjid maybe a shia, or any other that are not the same to what you are following, It doesnt make sense to me it becomes Haram to him just because he dont pray at the Masjid, Islam is not that hard..
Praying at mosque isn't hard bro. Would u feel same if they gave you 1 million $ daily if u went mosque? U wouldn't. But prayer is more important than money. I am struggling too but with imaan In Sha Allah it will get easier. I am not being mean to u I am just saying :) hope u took something good from it. Ameen.
@@ZincZXzinx ok it may not be hard for you, but my point is you cannot limit the prayer within the masjid only..it doesnt make sense.. If it is fard that means prayer is only at the masjid, why there is a rules of making up the delayed prayer? That alone prove that fard prayers are not limited at the masjid..
@@nashi.t3965 bro/sis, you are taking things lightly by giving your own understanding over people of knowledge who studied these stuff. Please consult a scholar on these matters. Also it's not about it being easy or hard for me. You don't know me bro. I am by no means someone really pious. I am striving just like you and other person. We should not just disregard mosque prayer saying its not fard... please try to understand what I mean.
@@ZincZXzinx i am saying base on my understanding, and i give you my ayah as well, you dont know me too, pretty much i know you dont even know yourself as well.. To say fard you are saying you will commit a sin, praying in the masjid is recommended not fard, the prophet gave the advantage of praying in the masjid, but to say its fard? You mean if we missed it we are no longer allow to pray after the prayer in the masjid? How does it make sense? How do you limit the prayer in the masjid? Thats why we are still allowed to pray if we have delayed it, it prove that we can pray anywhere, understand it, it is recommended not Fard..
@@ZincZXzinx unless the prophet said it is fard to pray in the masjid then it is fard, otherwise no..
😂 iam so lazy 😭 so i prayer at home 🏡😅
কারণ ছাড়া মানুষ ঘরে একা নামাজ পড়তে পারবে কি
Asallamu alaikum, if anyone can guide us are we allowed to offer prayer at home instead of going to the masjid although masjid is nearby.. Can we form a jamat of all of us residing in a joint family consisiting of mother, father and their three childrens and their spouses.. please guide if this is allowed..
its allowed
Asslmualikum bhai
In my city are only mosques with bidah .Should i Go there?
Bidah? Could you please expand?
Same doubt anyone give answer
@@user-cm5ts6in9w yes...
@@ummarfarooqpk You can pray behind him if he only does biddahs... but if he is extreme Sufi or Barelvi who has shirky beliefs u can't pray behind him... You will have to find another masjid and btw where do u then pray Jumma Namaz lol.... If u can pray Jumma Namaz prayer there what's wrong in other prayers? If Imam has shirky beliefs you should completely abandon such masjids and pray Jumma Namaz elsewhere even if it is far away... And for other cases, if the masjid is under 1km u should pray there regularly every namaz otherwise I don't think it is mandated upon you... Allah knows best
NO I STARTED PRAY AT HOME😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
He enforces the word, adult male. So what about teens like the students of schools and colleges??
An Adult in islam is when the person, Male or female has hit puberty . Allah Knows best!
@@sameerstephens4016 exactly
if you are 18+ u r adult
@@learner9917 who has reached the age of puberty i guess
Exactly @@Abid_Ibn_Ashraf
JazaakAllahih
MashaAllah tabarak Allah
Assalamu elaykum!
Mujhe Aisa lagta hi ke Jung ladte huye namaaz padna aur Jung hosakne ke haalaat me namaaz padna do alag baatein hi.
jung ladte huye koi namaaz Kaise Ada karsakta hi.
Agar jung hone ke haalaat hi to koi kaise apne aap ku aise hi halaak karva lega.
Mujhe aisa lagta hi ke Allah swt jung ke haalaat kaise rehna hi hame apne nabi ke zariye bataa rahe hi.
Aap apni namaaz kam karlo, aap apne dushman se chaukanna raho ye waqt dekh kar ( namaaz ka waqt ) Aap par hamlawar hosakta hi. Isliye aap log nammaz me ek dusre ki nigraani Karo ,kaha hi.
Agar army ke soldiers alag alag rehke namaaz padhenge to jyaada chances hi ke wo dushman ke haat marejayenge.
To isi liye Allah SWT ne yaha Pe namaaz jamaat ke saat adaa karna farz kardiya. Aisa mujhe lagta hi.
Kyu ke mujhe aisa lagta hi ke mustahab ya Muba Kaam nazook halaat me farz hosakte hi.
Allah swt Sabkuch Janne wale hi.
Me sirf ek talib e ilm hun. Kuch galti hoto maafkardo aur sudhaaro.
Comment on it🙄
Praying namaz at other places except home is permissible only and only if there is a valid excuse....But in the era of so much convenience and technology, do you think u have any such excuse? So pray in masjid!
@@hasnain9654 if someone don't want to follow a sunnah which is not even a mustahab , just to rebel with Allah Swt and his prophet muhammad pbuh then he or she is doing a major sin.
And Quran and Sunnah are not depend on technology and other things.
Allah knows best
@@imrozeroshan2312 Why r u talking like Shias? Shias keep such beliefs, Sunnis respect and adhere Sunnah along with Quran... And obeying PROPHET PBUH is the part of your faith....You can't obey Allah unless you know how to do obligatory things which are explained in Hadiths... And if Hadith makes something haram it becomes haram no matter what.... But if you are Shia then do WHATEVER YOU WANNA DO!!
@@hasnain9654 where is it mentioned that praying salah in mosque is compulsory , send me the reference from quran and sahih hadiths
Does this mean praying at home is invalid?
ua-cam.com/video/kXdNf5bW3vo/v-deo.html
Grow up, for Allah sake
No, praying at home is completely Valid. Remember that it is only the people that makes Islam a hard religion.
@@tam6493 thats right they are making Islam hard, how could they say that praying in the masjid is fard? Thats why we are allowed to make up the delayed prayer at home or anywhere if we missed the concregation prayer at the masjid it proves that praying in the masjid is just recommended but not fard..
@@tam6493 thats right they are making Islam hard, how could they say that praying in the masjid is fard? Thats why we are allowed to make up the delayed prayer at home or anywhere if we missed the concregation prayer at the masjid it proves that praying in the masjid is just recommended but not fard..
Hadees is 553 sir i love you
Quran says.."there shall be no compulsion in the religion." are you arguing with Allah?
Do you know what is referring by this ayah?you should read the tafsir(explanation) of this ayah, to know what is meant by this ayah.
@Fredo Cuomo May Allahu subhanahu wa ta'la guide you and set your affairs in order, dear brother.
lol you think praying in Masjid is a compulsion for you?.. wow...Playing and hanging up with friends 24/7 doesn't feel compulsion to you but this feels compulsion to you? wow man so impressed by your thoughts
Why Dr zakir naik is not drinking water as per sunnah?
Allah knows better, you kindly don't leave sunnah . Keep following 👍
Plise hind/bangla ma tanslat kro
Zakir bhai assalamualekum .I am ashfaque .m.p. india . Bhai merey town ki masjid me kuch paise baale log ghar me juma know namaaz padh rahey hai aur kuch log unko khush karney ke leye unkey saath namaaz padh rahey hai jabki masjid open hai .wajeh imam sahab quran hadeth ki baat kartey hai. Is par ek bayaan zaroor karey hindi me please sir
Spread the Goodness. Subscribe & Share.
May Allah Bless You!
bit.ly/HudaTv
I don't think these imams should make such statements as the prophet is not between us now and I don't think there is anyone has connection with Allah to talk on behalf the public and determine what they should do in our era. We have the Quran, we can read and comply with to the best of our capabilities, but these imams don't understand the poor as they all don't work like you and I. They all get paid by the governments to preach. If I am working in a place and I go to my boss and tell him that I will have to leave work 4-5 times every shift to go to the mosque to pray, I will be fired on the spot because who wants to hire someone that does that. I know some of you will be okay well Quran says that God created the human and gin to worship only. Fine, then pay me so I can feed myself and my family and then I will do what you ask. The answer from these imams will be oh well we all have to work. These imams should be ashamed of themselves by trying to force kids who are trying to be close to Allah to leave the religion as they want them to pray 5 times day one, wear your burka, fast the month of Ramadan, read Quran, and if you don't, then the prophet said you are Kafar. Wallah there is no Kafar in this world outside them for spreading fear in the heart of muslims. Read the Quran and comply to the best of your Capabilities. Allah will judge us by his mercy otherwise we all going to hell because we all forced to do jobs that we don't want to do to be able to feed our families and live in countries we don't want to live in.
i understand your statement but once a person reaches mature age shouldnt they follow what is wajib? according to quran, not hadith.
Aslm yess my shekh way not is oky now problem Bismillah ramanurahim tawakatul
What about teenagers
u mean who don't own houses? they may practice as well ig
@@MiloKai-18 wdym
@@chees4407 praying at mosque
@@MiloKai-18 Not Compulsary According to Majority Scholars opinion
Assalamualekom.
Some years ago you said that Praying in congregation is mustahab and majority of the scholars are with this view but now you are saying that Praying in congregation is obligatory. Which opinion of yours is correct?
And you also said in past that majority of the scholars are of the view that congregation is obligatory? Which statement of yours is correct?
Is it really... Can you share me the previous video link, where zakir naik said its not obligatory.
Im xenophobic, what should I do?
According to your God bukhari and God Muslim and many others.
❤❤❤❤
A human can pray 5 times a day with congregation yet he may be doing shirk you never know.
Only if he lacks knowledge
@@antisocial333 we should 5 times prayer only for allah dr zakir naik don't know anything even the female can 5 times prayer at masjid and home says Quran not Hadith because Hadith makes the Islam destroyed that is why our prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi vasallam forbidden not to write Hadith of prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi vasallam.
Allah mujhe maf kare hadith pe mujhe jada Biswas nahi hain
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Qur'an allha bani itna agaar masjid jana joruri hota toh allha Qur'an pe bata deta hadith pe mujhe believe nahi hain q ki oo prophet ne bhi nahi likha a collection ki gyi bate Hain jis me glti a ho Sakta hain
Ye to akhri jamana ka sign ha.
(People will claim to follow the Qur'an but will reject hadith & sunnah (Abu Dawood)
Rasul sm ne formaya keyamat ka ek nishan ye ha ki kuch log quran manneka bat karega aur wo same log Hadith aur sunnah ko reject karega.
Ap bhi keyamat ka us nishan se ho.
Hadith kese logoka bana hua ho saktehe? Ye sahabi ka bate ha jo wo rasul sm se sikha aur rasul sm ne hadith ki bareme bola islie rasul sm ki janeki bad sahaba ne wo sab hadith likhna suru kia. Lekin iska matlab ye to nehi ki bad me likha to jhut ho geya.
Agar apki kisi honest friend ne apki maut ki bad apki bareme kuch likha to wo galat hoga?
Apki mammi ki bareme ap jo likhoge to kia wo jhut honge? Kew ki apko to apki ammi ki bareme pata ha. Par agar ma kuch likhunga to galat hoga.
Wese hi sahaba ne rasul sm ki sat apni jindegi guzare aur Rasul sm ki hadith ki bareme une hi pata tha.
I don't believe philosophical logic anyway thank you you are truely hard worker