is it permissible to eat chicken at mac or kfc in a non muslim country Dr Zakir Naik

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 610

  • @Robbieaiz
    @Robbieaiz Рік тому +61

    Air Pacific ( now renamed Fiji Airways) has been serving Halal Food since the 1980s. Muslim community in Fiji give great importance to the availability of Halal food. Fiji Muslim League is the authorizing body in Fiji ensuring that.

    • @Morestuff1
      @Morestuff1 8 днів тому

      There is a very distinct difference between Halal and Zabiha (slaughtered the muslim way). Halal just means permissible. Goat, lamb beef etc. all permissible meat whether sold in a U.S.., European or Arab store. No difference in permissibility or being not halal. (you see "halal" on rice, daal and spices also, does not mean the rice has been slughtered) But all Halal is not zabiha. Halal meat means this is the meat of an animal that is permissible to be consumed irrespective of it's method of slaughter. Muslims go a step further in that they consume only that halal meat which is Zabiha.

  • @fatehabegum3353
    @fatehabegum3353 6 місяців тому +8

    Mate Dr Zakir Naik, in the West there's hardly any Ah le kitab these days, majority are atheist, the countries in the West are no longer Christian's. However, your explanation is very clear.

  • @zayedzihan6594
    @zayedzihan6594 9 місяців тому +7

    If this generation is so tempted to eat at these non halal restaurants, where has our Iman reached? We cant even avoid eating these places even though we have halal options. We, as muslims should be proud of our customs and encourage these big chains to bring halal options

  • @xoomwireless6997
    @xoomwireless6997 11 місяців тому +10

    Alhumdulillah, You have said it so logically and I agree with you 100%. I hope all other scholar follow the same logic.

  • @tariqpakistan
    @tariqpakistan Рік тому +18

    For my understanding can anyone share a verse from Quran that says that “ any animal slaughtered without taking Allah’s name is haram”
    In my opinion its the other way round which is , a meat is haram if “it is slaughtered on the name of anyone but Allah”
    The above two statements are totally different.
    Looking for guidance please
    Thanks

    • @bienemaja6663
      @bienemaja6663 8 місяців тому

      there is a long video from assim al hakeem about the same subject but a diffrent answer and it includes your question.

    • @SunLight-r3x
      @SunLight-r3x 5 місяців тому +1

      Sora Anam verses 118-121 Allah completly warned us of not eating non halal meat n those who misguiding us to function opposite is considered 😈by Allah .

    • @agarrikr2996
      @agarrikr2996 Місяць тому

      @@SunLight-r3xAnd you threatening people and being close minded will also put you with the 😈

  • @cookwithme7550
    @cookwithme7550 Рік тому +43

    Whoever reads this please pray for health of Rasheed, Sabiha. Jazakallahu

  • @jamescrowi6472
    @jamescrowi6472 Рік тому +24

    How a Muslim can ask such a question? A Muslim must boycott all these brands even if the meat is 1000000% halal.

    • @XploreKnowledge-i8u
      @XploreKnowledge-i8u Рік тому

      It is HARAM to breathe in the air that contains air🎉 breathed out by non-muslims and where there are pigs that are bred in the country as these air contain haram microscopic pork particles that are breathed out into the air by non-muslims' mouths and pigs, and muslims must not breathe haram particles into their body. Anyway some muslims were turned into pigs according sahih hadiths. Sunan Ibn Majah 4020.Prophet:"Muslims who play music & singing girls,Allah will cause earth to swallow them up & turn them into monkeys & pigs.”

    • @SolarErazer
      @SolarErazer 9 місяців тому +2

      No wrong if it's halal it's ok

    • @portshore8552
      @portshore8552 9 місяців тому +1

      How does food become 1000000% halal?

    • @Alth1te
      @Alth1te 4 місяці тому

      Youre so funny bro. We will continue boycotting anyway to bring your restaurants, that support terrorism, down

    • @zeeshan0987
      @zeeshan0987 Місяць тому

      Some of us have fallen in habit of pleasure. Some can't leave the pleasure of the tongue, if it is tasty, they'll drink their brother's blood.

  • @imexcruciate
    @imexcruciate Рік тому +13

    JazakAllah for the elaborate answer. May Allah help and keep you healthy, Ameen

  • @RFK_71
    @RFK_71 Рік тому +6

    I follow the notion being discussed here. That is, the food at these establishments are not halal nor intended to be halal. They don’t run their restaurants with the intention of providing halal foods. And the Christians don’t follow the kosher laws of Moses. So that should give you a message that you are not eating in the way of the verses of the Quran. On the other hand, those meats, etc., from Orthodox Jews, is a different story. We may eat from their restaurants or whatever circumstances. Pretty straightforward. Logic in the concept prevails here. We can eat somewhere else. We are not going to lose something if we don’t eat at those establishments. However, if nothing is available (starving), Allah knows best. Thank you Dr. Naik…

    • @Nova5s
      @Nova5s Місяць тому

      So you can only eat fish and egg? Very few places has halal food nearby in western country

  • @creativity2598
    @creativity2598 22 дні тому +4

    I think this question should be addressed with following points.
    1. Is the meat halal to eat if its slaughtered by machine? Because realistically its impossible to slaughter billions of chickens through a human by paying them and keeping costs low.
    2. People of west don't follow Christianity in its original form because bible, torah, zabur is corrupted.
    3. Are they really people of the book when majority of them are athiests. When they have stopped practicing their religion and abandoning their churches and muslims are the ones buying their churches to convert to Masjids.
    5. What if those chains have some kafirs and athiests who slaighter animal by stun shock or one single swing shot.
    4. All those brands in a way fund the oppression in Palestine. Does this fall under the category of stopping opression with hand, tongue and feeling bad for it?

  • @demdox
    @demdox Рік тому +47

    We have Halal KFC and Mcdonalds in Sydney, not all but some. They use halal certified ingredients and don’t sell bacon.

    • @JellyBean-vk3sn
      @JellyBean-vk3sn Рік тому

      Lol bacon is part of their menu and yes there is a cross contamination

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 Рік тому +1

      It's still fast food! It's bad for your health, whether it's been sacrificed to your false god or not.

    • @TruthShallSetYouFree2023
      @TruthShallSetYouFree2023 Рік тому +2

      NO you don’t have Halal, all those you mentioned serve Haram. And I can prove it.

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 Рік тому

      @@TruthShallSetYouFree2023 How do you know if it’s halal or not? You were not there when those animals were slaughtered?🤷🏻‍♂️ That includes the ones you believe are halal. Unless you are physically there and witness the slaughtering, there’s no way of telling.🤷🏻‍♂️ That’s why back in 2013 or so muslims ate pork thinking it’s lamb, all because someone swapped the stickers.🤷🏻‍♂️ Just like they have sugar almost in everything, they can easily add pork by products to the so called halal foods and you wouldn’t even know it. This haram nonsense in food needs to stop!! Because it’s manipulative and gaslighting you into believing that you can be perfect human beings who can keep a micro-drop of urine off your garments, that you can’t even see with a naked eye. The true God will NEVER demand such perfection from imperfect beings who reside in an imperfect world! That’s narcissistic and only satan can demand such!

    • @muhammaduddin9268
      @muhammaduddin9268 Рік тому +3

      Wow! Halal McDonald’s in Sydney.

  • @polashquadhi2330
    @polashquadhi2330 Рік тому +13

    His opinion on this is completely contadictory to Quran and sunnah, doesn't matter what Asian Ulama says. 2:46 The fact is the People of book never slaghtered their meat according to Islamic Zabiha sunnah. Yet, Rasul pbuh ate their meat. Not only this, in many occassion we have seen asian Muslim Ulama treat Western Christians as if they are worse than Athiests and Pagan Hindus which is also against Sunnah of Rasul pbuh. They do it becasue of the hatred of Colonisation and have nothing to do with Islam. The idea itself was really wierd that people of Book would do anything Islamically cause they are not Muslim or followers of Islam. They do it in their way and that was accepted by the Rasul pbuh.

    • @AlexOjideagu2
      @AlexOjideagu2 Рік тому

      EXACTLY! So many Muslims don't seem to understand this. Christians have NEVER slaughtered in the Kosher or Islamic way. Yet the Quran clearly says Christian meat is allowed.

    • @maverickkhan2718
      @maverickkhan2718 Рік тому +5

      You have got it completely wrong and you need to see it with more care and understanding. First of all eating halal is necessary. If you talk about people of book they are christians and jews. Jews still do there slaughter based on the religious decree and there meat is called kosher which every scholar will agree to be halal. There is nothing like that in christian world. They have abondened the religious slaughter. There meat is not Zabihah which requires animal to be killed in silence before cutting the throat. The blood is not drained. So please get yourself educated before making any comment on scholars.

    • @polashquadhi2330
      @polashquadhi2330 Рік тому

      @@maverickkhan2718 so where did you find that Christian used to slaughter their animal during the time of Rasul pbuh following the jews way or Muslims way? You don't have any knowledge yet you are asking people to get educated. That shows how ignorant you are. It's a waste of time talking to you cause you think Christians are not the book of people cause they don't follow certain Islamic rules which Jew follow. Well, Jews also don't follow many rules. Scuh as they believe in a deity named Uzair. It's mentioned in Quran, After believeing such thing, doesn't matter they slaughter or not that meat should be as Haram as a Pagan's slaughtered meat. And this is according to Islam moreimportant than how the animal was slaughtered as it's been mentioned in Quran not to eat any animal that was slaughtered with the name of anything but Allah. Yet Rasul pbuh aproved that Koshar meat. You are trying to be smarter than Rasul pbuh. I don't need to understandanything more than my Rasul pbuh understood. That's a waswasa of Shaitan.

  • @rashidtemuri3419
    @rashidtemuri3419 Рік тому +12

    How about the argument of machine slaughter or hand slaughter?

    • @eleghari
      @eleghari 29 днів тому

      And what about hunting dog kill that is allowed (even though it was NOT slaughtered)?

  • @bk-yd3xw
    @bk-yd3xw 9 місяців тому +8

    Thank you, may Allah bless you and your family.

  • @khabirulislam999
    @khabirulislam999 Рік тому +37

    Mash Allah! May Allah increase our Islamic knowledge. Every Muslim should spread Dr Zakir Naik's videos on various social media platforms

    • @XploreKnowledge-i8u
      @XploreKnowledge-i8u Рік тому

      It is HARAM to breathe in the air that contains air🎉 breathed out by non-muslims and where there are pigs that are bred in the country as these air contain haram microscopic particles that are breathed out into the air by non-muslims and pigs, and muslims must not breathe haram particles into their body. Anyway some muslims were turned into pigs according sahih hadiths. Sunan Ibn Majah 4020.Prophet:"Muslims who play music & singing girls,Allah will cause earth to swallow them up & turn them into monkeys & pigs.”

    • @GlobalQuest88
      @GlobalQuest88 Рік тому +6

      to hate non believers who are not believing your cult leader?.to become a terr'ristt?

    • @himanshusaraswat8171
      @himanshusaraswat8171 Рік тому

      Mujhe kuch nhi samjh aaya isse pahle to kuran hafiz meet kha jate h bad mai aayenge dr. Zakir naik

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 Рік тому

      Of course Allah will crank up the deception. We are in the end times now, and he knows his time is short!!!

  • @Wyhhd
    @Wyhhd Рік тому +25

    also there's always the possibility of cross-contamination. they use the same utensils and oil to prepare all food. whether it's has pork or not

    • @amaanzia007
      @amaanzia007 Місяць тому +1

      Don’t complicate please !!! Quran doesn’t say any thing for cross contamination.
      Also Ahadees of Bukhari doesn’t mention. So who is that non Allah that you are obeying???

    • @Quiyum
      @Quiyum 25 днів тому +1

      Cry about it. Cross contamination is not something said by Allah or the prophet

    • @Quiyum
      @Quiyum 25 днів тому

      Don’t make your own religion

  • @user-gt4cr2jd6f
    @user-gt4cr2jd6f Рік тому +39

    I really appreciate this question. So many adults and kids eating meat that is not slaughtered in the Islamic method. The adults have to learn so the kids can learn as well.

    • @AlexOjideagu2
      @AlexOjideagu2 Рік тому

      Christians have never slaughtered in the Kosher or Islamic way. yet the Quran clearly says Christian meat is allowed.

    • @XploreKnowledge-i8u
      @XploreKnowledge-i8u Рік тому

      It is HARAM to breathe in the air that contains air🎉 breathed out by non-muslims and where there are pigs that are bred in the country as these air contain haram microscopic particles that are breathed out into the air by non-muslims and pigs, and muslims must not breathe haram particles into their body. Anyway some muslims were turned into pigs according sahih hadiths. Sunan Ibn Majah 4020.Prophet:"Muslims who play music & singing girls,Allah will cause earth to swallow them up & turn them into monkeys & pigs.”

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 Рік тому

      I regret eating Halaal food. I shall NEVER again eat meats sacrificed to an idol.

    • @a.demifemiflapo5795
      @a.demifemiflapo5795 Рік тому

      ​@@Turtleback8024Shut up troll

    • @creativeaarts4023
      @creativeaarts4023 10 місяців тому +3

      ​@@Turtleback8024 Islam doesn't do idol worship

  • @moinshaikh89
    @moinshaikh89 Місяць тому +4

    I am impressed by the priorities of Muslims in 21st century

    • @adams6688
      @adams6688 18 днів тому

      You are right. There is greater problems to solve. But this affects daily life of muslims. We cant blame people for that. Besides, the spectrum of questions is wide enough for all to find those that are of interest and priority to them.

  • @user-wv9bo6nm8k
    @user-wv9bo6nm8k Рік тому +2

    The majority practicing Muslims, regardless of origin, in US, UK and Canada eat Halal. The non Halal restaurants are not exactly Jewish or Christan, one should also note that pork based ingredients are freely used and food could have exposure to pork products.

  • @houarik8492
    @houarik8492 28 днів тому +3

    There is possibilities to eat halal even in European countries! No need to go to KFC or macdo !!!!

  • @themotivationmafia6091
    @themotivationmafia6091 Рік тому +3

    I don't know about america and canada but in London there's no excuse there is plenty halaal eating outlets so why take a chance eating from non Muslims?

    • @casilasgoaler
      @casilasgoaler 7 місяців тому

      No need excuse. If something is Halal, who are you to say no?

  • @go2go376
    @go2go376 21 день тому +1

    Muslims are more worried about meat being halal or not but they are least bothered about their earnings and day to day acts are halal or haraam.

  • @mansooralikc
    @mansooralikc Рік тому +1

    The argument that we should check weather food is lawful before eating is the case of Ahlul kitab, then if the food is found to be lawful even if served by Hindus, we can eat it, why to segregate Ahlul kitab then? In kerala, many Hindu wedding parties serves Halal meat and we eat them. Halal meat can be eaten even if served by anyone. But food served by ahlul kitab can be eaten saying bismillah not having to look deeper into it is the relaxation. Please don't make deen complicated when Allah has grabbed a relaxation as per his will

  • @Know_Allaah_The_All-Mighty
    @Know_Allaah_The_All-Mighty Рік тому +5

    Jazak Allaahu Khayran

  • @JackWong2-i1p
    @JackWong2-i1p Рік тому +12

    Make it simple, Make sure it is 100% halal before eat, dont be ignorance.

    • @XploreKnowledge-i8u
      @XploreKnowledge-i8u Рік тому

      It is HARAM to breathe in the air that contains air🎉 breathed out by non-muslims and where there are pigs that are bred in the country as these air contain haram microscopic particles that are breathed out into the air by non-muslims and pigs, and muslims must not breathe haram particles into their body. Anyway some muslims were turned into pigs according sahih hadiths. Sunan Ibn Majah 4020.Prophet:"Muslims who play music & singing girls,Allah will cause earth to swallow them up & turn them into monkeys & pigs.”

    • @amaanzia007
      @amaanzia007 Місяць тому

      Quran say AhleKitab and Quran didn’t mention that it will apply only that time of AhleKitab, so please don’t misquote Quran.
      Today Christians or Jews are same as before.
      Today also they believe in diluted Bible and Taurah and at the time of Muhammad saw they belive the same dialute ones.
      So your daleel against Quran is fasik.
      As far as zabiha halal is concerned there is nothing mentioned in Quran period.
      Also Zakir Naik mis interpretation the Quran aayat 5:3 where he totally incorrectly and intentionally translated the word لِغَيۡرِ ٱللَّهِ ب.
      He translated “Other then Allah”
      But anyone clearly says “Ghair Allah” not an Allah.
      Its a big difference this Aaya 5:3 is totally mentioning the things that are not permissible/halal.
      True translation is “Forbidden are those dedicated to “Ghair Allah”.
      Where does this aayat said “Other the Allah” ????
      In Arabic its called مِن دُونِ ٱللَّهِ ل aayat (29:17).
      So even if nothing mentioned its halal. Like seafood all halal.
      Quran is not complicated people like these mullahs make it complicated.

    • @amaanzia007
      @amaanzia007 Місяць тому

      @@XploreKnowledge-i8u
      Quran doesn’t mention not to eat or breathe contaminated air or food.
      Other than Quran. Nothing is perfect, so why don’t believe in this ahadees

    • @MAJESTicMOMENTS7
      @MAJESTicMOMENTS7 Місяць тому

      ​@@XploreKnowledge-i8ui can quote you a one line that you are illiterate, if you think food particles can be in air 😂

    • @mohammadparvez5618
      @mohammadparvez5618 27 днів тому +1

      What if you ask non muslim and they say its halal

  • @tentimesful
    @tentimesful Рік тому +1

    I thought as long as an anmial is not slaughtered in another name than allah al hamd then its ok to eat it even if no name was called when slaughtering as long as you say bismillah rahmani rahim before eating...

  • @ghanirehman9930
    @ghanirehman9930 Рік тому +9

    The Home cooked food is the best food . A balanced food with lot of veggies and fruits saves the medical bills. Excess meat eating is an addiction at the cost of health.

  • @kman5768
    @kman5768 8 місяців тому

    A very important feature of Halal meat is not only how the animal is slaughtered, BUT, it is how the animal was raised. Most people forget that fact! And l am not a fully practising Muslim.

  • @saltahir533
    @saltahir533 Рік тому +4

    Jazak’Allah Shaikh. I am a little bit confused on the taking of Allahs name part. Isn’t the actual verbiage that the food is prohibited if anyone name besides Allah’s was taken ? So if no name was taken at time of slaughter then that should be fine right? I know I’m getting into nitty gritty but if the intention was that we are allowed then I just want to be sure.

    • @Mani-kg5sg
      @Mani-kg5sg Рік тому +1

      Taking name is basically from the belief of a muslim that Allah is the all mighty and with HIS name i take the life of this animal. This belief is not there in non-muslims

    • @Vs91912
      @Vs91912 Місяць тому

      No read 6:121

  • @aekpani
    @aekpani 2 місяці тому

    Problem is in the item used in those fast food chains and cross contamination.
    For example oil, sometimes high temperature oil contents pork fat.

  • @golamali2149
    @golamali2149 Рік тому +1

    Why does Hadis override the saying of the Koran?. If you follow the four imams you will constantly fight between yourselves. So following the Koranic directives is the best way to avoid confusions and frictions amongst muslims.

  • @MuhammadWaqas-zv6qz
    @MuhammadWaqas-zv6qz 9 місяців тому +2

    I've heard both arguments and I agree with the other view. I feel like it's atleast logically consistent. It takes Quran as the starting point and brings an authentic Hadith to clarify the confusion . I mean how many Muslims go and ask butcher houses in Turkey to check whether the butcher is not an Athiest as the probability of him not being considering himself as a Muslim is quite high. Is that really more Halal than having a meat from a pre-dominantly Catholic country such as Mexico?

  • @TheoNèyCSU
    @TheoNèyCSU Рік тому +25

    I love this Sheikhs explanation; He does not cut corners!!

    • @AbdalMalik-ye1df
      @AbdalMalik-ye1df Рік тому +1

      he is intelligent and a proper sheikh without giving himself such titles

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 Рік тому

      🤣 deception is real I see!!! He kept saying the fast food restaurants are owned by Christians without providing any proof thereto. Looks like he's still got a lot to learn.

    • @exoo7968
      @exoo7968 8 місяців тому

      @@Turtleback8024 Vanguard CEO is jewish, vanguard owns a lot of the food companies. While not official, blackrock has Christian views. Lastly he is speaking mainly about america and the UK in that example which both identified as a christen countries and are christen by law.

    • @Turtleback8024
      @Turtleback8024 8 місяців тому

      @exoo7968 Christian anything means nothing. Anyone can claim to be anything.🤷‍♂️ All I'm asking for is proof to his claim, whether he's referring to the UK, America or Haiti. Just because some dude is Jewish doesn't make him Christian.🤷‍♂️

  • @unitedummah100
    @unitedummah100 4 місяці тому

    As Salam Alaikum, please clarify this for me, In the Quran, verse 6:121 of chapter 6, Sūrat l-anʿām (The Cattle), Allah says, "And do not eat of that upon which the name of Allah has not been mentioned, for indeed, it is grave disobedience". Other translations of this verse include:
    "Eat not of (meats) on which Allah's name hath not been pronounced: That would be impiety"
    "And do not eat of that on which Allah's name has not been mentioned, and that is most surely a transgression" Jazak Allah Khairen.

  • @AB-fe1dn
    @AB-fe1dn 9 місяців тому

    Please note the hadith where the prophet said, you say tasmiyah and eat was meat from recent reverts to Islam NOT ahlu kitab. And if a Muslim serves you meat you don’t need to ask but Sahabah were concerned if the new Muslims were doing tasmiyah or not.

  • @hotbird3
    @hotbird3 9 місяців тому

    Dr Zakir is the wisest scholar you can rely on.. Logical scientific answers.. as for the meat ,, why not have fish and eggs for as long as you want ,, healthy and cheaper...Im a regular meat eater but I was surprised in a recent trip to Europe that Halal and Kosher was prohibited by law ,, so what , even without knowing a clear answer I just ate sardines and eggs and fish ,, lost 5 kg , energy went up , skin better and above all felt a sense of peace and achievement .. Don't run around in circles people , there's always a way if you want to look.

  • @huma3053
    @huma3053 10 місяців тому

    Sir plz reply talaq e hassan deny sy talaq ho jati hai k nhi q k quran me 3 mah k bad wali talaq hai mtlb ahsan to kiya talqe hassan jaiz hai ho jati hai or paper har month ghr gy hain or ak bar gawah majood thy dusri bar nhi or pury 3 paper gy hain 3no month
    Or aurat ny paper recive bi nhi kiye kiya yeh talq ho hai k nhi

  • @citycentregreen
    @citycentregreen Рік тому +3

    well said sir

  • @rouilliew
    @rouilliew 7 місяців тому

    MashAllah, TabarakAllah, Doctor. But that wonderful fountain...so relaxing! MashAllah.

  • @skamal8330
    @skamal8330 Рік тому

    I cant believe why a Muslim ask this question. I stay in foreign country most Mcs Kfc etc are not halal. I educate my kids not to consume haram so as they grew they know as where they can eat halal food. I heard some actress ate pork. If you live in Pakistan India or and Middle East please investigate before eating. They probably eat in their country so they assume that they can eat in foreign country too. ALLAH KNOWS THE BEST ❤

  • @maliknawaz5120
    @maliknawaz5120 Рік тому

    Salaam Zakir Sahib, my question is that to which prophet of God was Vedas was revealed ?

  • @azammohiuddin1827
    @azammohiuddin1827 2 місяці тому

    Very nice explanation of the halal in the light of the Quran, bible and Jewish holy scriptures.
    God bless Dr Zakir Naik

  • @Foundonetruth
    @Foundonetruth 25 днів тому

    A deeper question is let’s say a Christian’s slaughters the way a Muslim does and also uses the name god however in his mind he is thinking about Jesus, is it still permissible

  • @HawkEyeBlue
    @HawkEyeBlue Рік тому

    If the animal is slaughtered in an "Islamic" way then what is an issue in the first place its not it is halal and even if Hindus serve you food you can eat?

  • @abudujana13
    @abudujana13 Рік тому +3

    Well said!!
    JazakAllah khair

  • @muhammadabdullahi8033
    @muhammadabdullahi8033 Рік тому

    Please can someone tell me where to ask Dr. Zakir Question, I mean his question and answer channel

  • @abdulmalikcollins4985
    @abdulmalikcollins4985 9 місяців тому

    Actually in McDonald's they do not cross contaminate. They have different preparation areas for different products. You do not know anything about their food prep. You think everything is deep fried ? Only fries are again cooked separately. But if they don't say halal it ain't. I have halal kfc wand subway in my town

  • @aitezazkhan3839
    @aitezazkhan3839 6 місяців тому

    AoA
    Kindlr clarify, that weather the stem cells in legs of cow or bull etc, could be eaten uncooked, which is slaughtered in Eid Ul Azha??

  • @johnfirth9791
    @johnfirth9791 11 місяців тому

    Pork is not allowed in Christianity. The rationale for eating pork is exactly how you have explained the rationale of the Arabs version of eating non halal meat

  • @ChromeMan04
    @ChromeMan04 Рік тому +1

    Besides the fish, all the other meat at McDonalds is haram. Period.

  • @ArshadAli-yi2vh
    @ArshadAli-yi2vh Рік тому

    I would like to ask from India's perceptive, in India McDonald's states they have halal certificate, if asked upon they openly share it. Based on the certification , can we consume it or not?

    • @saifurrahman7094
      @saifurrahman7094 Рік тому

      McDonald's replied recently after halal crackdown by government that they are not using halal meat

  • @fullehmosa6251
    @fullehmosa6251 11 місяців тому +1

    Of course it is what kind of question is that just don’t eat pork

  • @simplicity6302
    @simplicity6302 7 місяців тому

    One think is halal meat the other issue is cross cantamination which no one pays attention. Eating vegi food where haram food is made/ sold is also Haram.

  • @naimulsattar7686
    @naimulsattar7686 22 дні тому

    But in kosher meat, Allahs name is not mentioned but it is slaughtered as per Islamic method so how is it halal?

  • @GulamSaiyed-m6z
    @GulamSaiyed-m6z Рік тому

    Food from KFC McDonald Etc cannot be permitted because the serve pork and cross contamination is possible. Therefore it not would not be halal even if i is in a non Muslim country. In uk halal food is now readily available. It out question to go these non halal food companies

  • @AHMEDAhmed-bg9wp
    @AHMEDAhmed-bg9wp Рік тому +5

    MashaAllah!

  • @mohammadpervez272
    @mohammadpervez272 Рік тому

    Of the Quraan is the final book of Revolution and it's clearly says that in surah maida that Muslim can eat with the book of the because there food is permitted for Muslim to be Halal. Then why the other sources rejected that?that?

  • @zaibers17
    @zaibers17 2 місяці тому

    What if the animal is slaughtered by reciting the name of Allah in any other language than Arabic, will it be halal ?

    • @pcfan2625
      @pcfan2625 2 місяці тому

      Yes , Halah . Arabic is just Language . Don’t be meticulous

  • @RavinTaksing-m4s
    @RavinTaksing-m4s 24 дні тому

    Answer is yes because rasulallah allowed Muslims to eat pork if nothing else is available 😊

  • @curlyomar
    @curlyomar 6 днів тому

    most people cant afford Halal meat or chicken, the prices are outrageous.

  • @ferozemir1318
    @ferozemir1318 Місяць тому

    Your explanation makes better sense .

  • @salamafarooqui4272
    @salamafarooqui4272 Рік тому +1

    All these big corporations are neither Christian nor Jew... their religion is money and profit so why even such a long debate and speech??

  • @amjadrana-nu8zn
    @amjadrana-nu8zn 18 днів тому

    Drinking and gambling is specifically banned in the Quran so using this is a nonsensical argument in this case.
    Sheikh Assim and other scholars disagree with this view.
    So, there is a genuine scholarly difference in views. Arabic scholars vs Asian scholars.
    Where there is a difference in views with scholars, then clearly we do not have a black and white consensus. Who can we believe and who should we trust?
    In cases like this, it should be left to the individual to follow his/her own heart and they should not be persecuted for their beliefs.
    Personally, in cases like these, where even scholars do not have a unified opinion, I always think the best view is the more liberal view.
    Peace

  • @ahsanahmedi1372
    @ahsanahmedi1372 Рік тому +3

    Dr Zakir Naik is not interpreting the Quranic verse of the Holy Quran of surah Maida correctly.
    Allah says, " Forbidden is...and on which the name of other than Allah is invoked", NOT as he translated "on which name of Allah is not invoked"
    It changes the meaning completely.
    Also it is narrated in authentic books of hadith that "Hz Aysha(ra) asked the Holy Prophet(sw) that many people visit us and offer meat as gifts. We dont know if they have invoked Allah when slaugtering. Should we eat it?" He replied, say Bislillah and eat it wholeheartedly"

    • @mudeshassan6503
      @mudeshassan6503 Рік тому

      Absolutely brother

    • @SaifAli-cv7jm
      @SaifAli-cv7jm 11 місяців тому

      I see what your saying brother but it is a well known fact that most of the meat is stunned which makes it dead meat and haram

  • @creativesheju
    @creativesheju Рік тому

    I have a question so Koshar means jews says Nismallah Allah o Akbar when cutting an animal?

    • @BotiestGuy
      @BotiestGuy 9 місяців тому

      They don’t say Bismillah or Allah o Akbar but kosher means they cut animal same way like muslims does..
      They cut half neck like us…
      In western countries back in time when there was no halal meat being served on that time muslims use to eat kosher meat…

  • @Northern777
    @Northern777 Рік тому +1

    جزاك الله خيرا

  • @warrior7466
    @warrior7466 Місяць тому

    We're not starving like the palestinians. Allah has given us so many blessings in the west.

  • @arsalanmirza3411
    @arsalanmirza3411 5 місяців тому +1

    The Muslims and the Jews should COLLABORATE to compel MacDonald and others to serve KOSHER burgers 🍔

    • @TRayan-tq4jy
      @TRayan-tq4jy 3 місяці тому

      why Kosher? Halal!

    • @arsalanmirza3411
      @arsalanmirza3411 3 місяці тому

      @@TRayan-tq4jy Because Kosher and Halal is the same and based on same principles of animal slaughtering for food ! Btw, Judaism ✡️ and Islam ☪️ are the only 100% truly Monotheistic Religions today.

  • @Morestuff1
    @Morestuff1 8 днів тому

    Quran at no place says that the name of Allah has to be taken when slaughtering. It just says everything on which (note that here it does not mention meat) Allah name has not been taken is not allowed. This is not just meat but everything that you eat so it has nothing to do with slaughtering. sura Inaam does not mention meat. It is wrong interpretation. Tell me which Arabic word translates into "meat" . It says "Do not eat out of that on which Allah's name has not been recited" also translated as "Do not eat out of that on which Allah's name has not been recited." On previous references in other Ayah where the Hukm is about meat, it specifically mentions meat or animal or slaughtering of animal. Surah Inaam Hukm (order) does not mention meat or animal but "everything that you eat" (by inference "that is permissible"). Now you could not be slaughtering Wheat or vegetables which are part of everything you eat that goes to show that the order does not relate to taking the name of Allah at the time off slaughtering but at the time of eating. So you start eating with Allah name by reciting Bismillah it is similar to the blessing of food by Christians and Jews before they start eating. Where Allah intended to mean Meat it very clearly mentions meat or slaughtering or animal. In Sura Inaam it does not mention meat, slaughtering, animal or offering unless you can tell me the word in Sura Inam verse that means meat, animal or slaughter.

  • @AlamKhan-xc4fh
    @AlamKhan-xc4fh Рік тому

    Method of slaughtering has to be islamic. Most non-muslims kill poultry by guillotine. When there's no option only then it can be consumed by saying Bismillah to save life

  • @69sec
    @69sec Рік тому

    there is one question after living in the western country and in this field I came to know even the Jews who are slaughtering the animal (kosher) they don't take the name of Allah or their Lord, it is just the method they follow. Like for them it is mandatory to have very sharp knife (chalef) single cut throat.. but no where they mentioned about taking name of the Lord. so in this case is it still permissible to have such meat?

  • @mohamedhameed1237
    @mohamedhameed1237 Рік тому +1

    Thank you sir

  • @BasheerAhmed-je1qi
    @BasheerAhmed-je1qi 9 місяців тому

    In Canada I hope some serving Halal food. But in India even you cannot put Halal in packed foods.

  • @muhammedalimi
    @muhammedalimi Рік тому +3

    Allahu Akbar ❤️ ❤️ ❤️ ❤️

  • @furkhankhader8875
    @furkhankhader8875 Рік тому +6

    Right.
    If you do not know ...and you hungry...
    Then have it 👍
    But
    If you know ...and you hungry...then dont have it ✋
    But
    For me,personally
    Even if i do not know...and i am very hungry...i would rather go for any vegeterian/ or any fish.🐟 dish😘

  • @muhammedfijinkassim7871
    @muhammedfijinkassim7871 Рік тому

    Recommending to avoid MC D as they serve pork as well.

  • @tahakhan88
    @tahakhan88 9 місяців тому

    Living in a Muslim country I can never know for a fact if the animal slaughtered by a Muslim was Halal either. How come I should doubt non-Muslim but not a Muslim? I agree with the Arab School of thought in this regard. If you know that the person who prepared meat was Ehl-e-kitab you should say Bismillah and eat it rather than Interrogating how the food was prepared.

    • @TRayan-tq4jy
      @TRayan-tq4jy 3 місяці тому

      lazy way of thought. Follow the Quran and eat halal its very simple.

  • @sampk9229
    @sampk9229 Рік тому +1

    i have seen muslim brothers who want only halal meat when drinking alcohol.

  • @Saa42808
    @Saa42808 22 дні тому

    Every single scholar got this question wrong, except one. Sorry it’s a fact. BTW I am very curious in knowing the name of any Jewish or Christian scholar who takes the name of Allah before any act.

  • @kamrankhan-zz6dh
    @kamrankhan-zz6dh Рік тому +3

    He knows even all firqa and explained clearly not like other so called alim who only talk about his taught and forced his thinking to you welldone dr zakar naik.

  • @SmartMoneyRyan
    @SmartMoneyRyan 8 місяців тому

    Im curious, is halal certification an innovation? The prophet never verrified if it was salughtered in a specific way. It was just assumed it was if it was from a jew or christian.

  • @cvikastube
    @cvikastube Рік тому

    There are elements that could be perceived as hypocrisy, particularly in the divergent opinions and practices regarding the permissibility of consuming non-Muslim-slaughtered meat in Western countries.
    The varying opinions among scholars, with some suggesting that it is permissible to consume meat from non-Muslim establishments, while others emphasize the necessity of Islamic slaughtering methods. The existence of contradictory views on the same issue within the Muslim community can be seen as inconsistent.
    The speaker refers to a Quranic verse in Surah Al-Ma'idah (5:5) and a Hadith to support the permissibility of consuming non-Muslim-slaughtered meat. However, there appears to be a selective application of these sources, as other verses and Hadith emphasizing the importance of Islamic slaughtering methods are not given equal weight.
    An argument based on comparative religion, stating that Christians should adhere to their biblical dietary laws, yet it doesn't address the Islamic perspective that insists on specific slaughtering methods. This selective application of religious principles can be seen as contradictory.
    While the speaker acknowledges that certain scholars from the Indian subcontinent, particularly those of the Hanafi school of thought, insist on Islamic slaughtering methods, the speaker expresses a personal belief aligned with this view. However, the acknowledgment of differing practices and the subsequent personal adherence to a specific view may be perceived as inconsistent.

  • @tahakhan88
    @tahakhan88 9 місяців тому

    Your priority for righteousness should be Quran > Hadith > Other Scholars and not the other way around. I respect Bin Baaz but I will follow Hadith and Quran over him.

  • @DHUL_QRNAIN
    @DHUL_QRNAIN 8 місяців тому

    Forget non Muslims even most Muslims living in the west don’t follow the Quran and sunnah in this.

  • @SmitTheAdventurer
    @SmitTheAdventurer Рік тому +2

    Quran alone is taking over, Damn.

  • @sharoonamin9893
    @sharoonamin9893 Рік тому +7

    My question is why to visit in first place

  • @xs2me223
    @xs2me223 Рік тому

    Imam, the question is: Is the food you mentioned, halal for Islam, yes or no?! Islam is ONE. Islam is not all of these: Hanafi, Safi, Maliki or Hanbeli. Things in Hanafi that are haram are halal in Safi or visa versa, so that can not be in ISLAM!

  • @Tiger-cy3fv
    @Tiger-cy3fv Рік тому +2

    one scholar ( i thin his name Yasir Qagdi,,) said now at sloter house Hindu, Sikh, Athetis ,,,ect ppl work who are not ppl of book so how do you consider??

  • @abdursyed4111
    @abdursyed4111 3 дні тому

    As per the verses in Quran if the animal slaughtered without the name of Allah(SWT), isn’t Halal. Why are we having arguments?

  • @daleafaghani340
    @daleafaghani340 Рік тому

    We live in a country where the Muslim population is about 10%,but the permissible meat is about 90 % halal.

  • @basimsafdar
    @basimsafdar Рік тому

    JizakaAllah May Allah bless u. You are right. In the West muslims eat haram meat.

  • @noorthelight7037
    @noorthelight7037 Рік тому +1

    Now Halal outlets are opened in USA not too many but very few. We only eat only Zabiha Halal meat.

    • @Heropakistani2011
      @Heropakistani2011 Рік тому

      For it to be halal, it needs to be cut and cooked by a muslim or a practicing christian (not a man worshiper). The point is there are no true christians in the world now, there are only man worshiper christians.

  • @Mercnix101
    @Mercnix101 2 місяці тому

    Most Christians today cannot be considered Ahlil kitab because they reject the Old Testament. Most "christians" today follow Paul's version of Christianity. Ahlil Kitab means "People of The Book" in referencing to the Christians and Jews of the time where they believed in their scriptures and practice the rules and laws of their religion (before things were added, changed, and removed, and secularism was introduced). Ask the "Ahlil Kitab" people today about their religion and scriptures and most of them know next to nothing about their own religion. So let's not kid ourselves. Being willfully ignorant is choice. A choice that you will have to answer for in the akhirah. Remember Allah knows.

  • @RifaiAL
    @RifaiAL Рік тому +9

    Zakir Naik first of all need to understand that the "people of the book" as mentioned in the Quran is not existing today. The mentioning of the people of the book in the Quran is referenced to those people during the time of the Final Messenger of Allah who believed in the genuine and uncuncocted teaching of Jesus PBUH. The Christians of today who changed belief with disbelief by believing that Allah betook Himself a son, can in no way slaughter animals to make it "halal".

    • @Zayanahmedyt
      @Zayanahmedyt Рік тому +5

      Well do you believe the halal meat you eating was slaughtered by a practicing Muslim who prays 5 times a day??? What if meat you are eating was slaughtered by a Shia or no Sunni Muslim or a person who commits shirk and grave worshipping?

    • @omarmasohood
      @omarmasohood Рік тому +1

      U didnt watch the whole video

    • @messaoudmehafdi8982
      @messaoudmehafdi8982 Рік тому

      Plus a lot of the so called halal meat and chicken in the U.K., even it comes from properly slaughtered animals, it is not healthy because it is not organic.

    • @Spastic110
      @Spastic110 Рік тому +2

      That doesn’t even make any sense, Christians live with prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in Medina, the Quran refers to the Christians who believe in Jesus as the Som of god, the original Christians came and went long before islam

    • @masoodkhan581
      @masoodkhan581 5 місяців тому

      Let's not over complicate things. Let's stick to the Qur'an and Hadith

  • @tameemjamal5505
    @tameemjamal5505 Рік тому

    McDonald's, KFC are American, just based on this fact all humans supporting free Palestine should not have anything to do with American products.

  • @muhammaduddin9268
    @muhammaduddin9268 Рік тому +1

    Is it permissible to live in western countries?

    • @BotiestGuy
      @BotiestGuy 9 місяців тому

      Yes but your mission should be spreading Islam.. not for money

    • @muhammaduddin9268
      @muhammaduddin9268 9 місяців тому +1

      But everyone loves money and that is a fact.

  • @sreebeechannel
    @sreebeechannel 11 місяців тому +2

    Every religion has rules… just take what you feel is best and reject whatever seems nonsense.. you have only one life, just live it to the fullest.. then you won’t need any zakkir Naik

  • @pashapa11
    @pashapa11 Рік тому

    Why would any one want to? It’s bad for you. Tastes bad, costs too much

  • @nz3762
    @nz3762 Місяць тому

    McD, KFC ++ are Jewish Owned… are the meat n chicken products Kosher? And would they not cater for the Jewish community? Can anybody check into this?

  • @M_D_13
    @M_D_13 8 місяців тому

    So what does it mean that you can have the food of alhe kitab? They certainly don't slaughter the Islamic way. How can you go against the Quran?