CARLY SIMON YOU'RE SO VAIN REACTION | True life and pure work of art meet.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 160

  • @terri8988
    @terri8988 3 роки тому +3

    Warren Beatty and was always leaving the women that he’s so-called love.

  • @shanenolan8252
    @shanenolan8252 3 роки тому +39

    In the studio version mick Jagger is singing backinf vocals

    • @ycoyle2803
      @ycoyle2803 5 місяців тому

      This is dubbed over the live performance.

  • @markamos1911
    @markamos1911 3 роки тому +20

    "Son of a gun," was a reaction to her hearing the bass line Klaus Voormann had come up with on the studio version. Klaus was an early friend of The Beatles, playing on solo albums by John, George and Ringo, and also designed the cover for the "Revolver" album.
    Yes, that is Jagger on backing vocals, and he's another of the people the song is rumoured to be about.

  • @trespatines8698
    @trespatines8698 3 роки тому +29

    That’s The Way I’ve Always Heard it Should Be is one of Carly’s great songs.

    • @dunismith3045
      @dunismith3045 3 роки тому +2

      LOVE that one!

    • @jannaromine5908
      @jannaromine5908 3 роки тому +2

      Absolutely! It's awesome live❤️

    • @-belue-6697
      @-belue-6697 3 роки тому +1

      There is a live version where she is wearing a beautiful red dress (I think it was red) but she looks stunning and that live version is awesome. The story in that song is quite gripping as well. Love it! 😎😍😎

  • @cpmf2112
    @cpmf2112 3 роки тому +34

    Mick jagger did sing backing vocals on the studio track, they must be dubbing it in for the live performance

    • @SWLinPHX
      @SWLinPHX 2 роки тому +1

      Yes, that's what I figured. They use pre-recorded tracks many times in a live performance.

  • @gesundheit602
    @gesundheit602 Рік тому +1

    True, a person can’t know if someone really loves them for sure. But if the other party tells them that they do, when in actuality they do not, then I think the person that lied loses the right to complain if a song gets written about them! Fair play, player! 🙂

  • @woodiicycad
    @woodiicycad 2 роки тому +1

    She said several years ago that David Geffen is who she was speaking of in the lyrics of this song.

  • @sherryheim5504
    @sherryheim5504 3 роки тому +13

    I love Carly Simon you should consider looking into her catalog deeper, she had so many great songs and that voice! She is amazing as a singer, songwriter and poet. She did date Warren for a time and was married to James Taylor for years. She and James had a couple of kids together. Mick and Carly dated for a time and yes, Mick did sing on the studio recording of this song.

  • @timtabor6893
    @timtabor6893 Рік тому +1

    I am from Nova Scotia I remember that total eclipse 😊

  • @walterpanovs
    @walterpanovs 3 роки тому +18

    The Beatles' old, artistic friend from their early days in Germany, Klaus Voormann, who went on to become a fine bass player and in-demand session man played on this #1 hit track and he's the one who came up with that ominous bass lick that opens the song (and over which she says "son of a gun"). Voormann also played on many of the solo Beatles' recordings.

  • @carolinagallegos3926
    @carolinagallegos3926 Рік тому +3

    You hearing her whisper son of a gun proves you have a great ear for music, many reactor's who listen to her singing this live don't pick it up!! Great reaction Harri!!

  • @timwhitnell7145
    @timwhitnell7145 3 роки тому +23

    She must have used the studio version's backing vocals as it is indeed Jagger singing in the background. It's a very biting song. No doubt what she thought about Beatty and likely a few other men.

    • @-belue-6697
      @-belue-6697 3 роки тому

      Sadly, all the ones I dated! 🙄🤣😐...Well, there were a couple people that are the kind boys you can't let in cause the rudE boys mess with your head. 🤷 🤷‍♀️...Almost everyone has that one person that was a sweet soul but the timing wasn't right...Not that you pine for them, Oh no, but you remember that one sweetie, even if you knew allot of sh*T people...But when you are young you are still learning and growing and learning and growing in life is important. 😎

  • @ricelaker
    @ricelaker 3 роки тому +2

    Bought this on the first cassette I ever bought in 1972.while serving on a remote air force base in Alaska

  • @bethcrumpton476
    @bethcrumpton476 3 роки тому +31

    On the studio version, she whispers "you son of a gun" in reaction to the bass player's into, which he came up with on the spot.
    Some of the top contenders for who this song is about are Mick Jagger (who is singing backup, you were right,) Warren Beatty, and James Taylor, who was Carly's husband at the time.

    • @frankiebowie6174
      @frankiebowie6174 3 роки тому +4

      I’m sure it applied to all three of them. Probably an amalgamation.

    • @vincentschmitt7597
      @vincentschmitt7597 3 роки тому +4

      She has said each verse is about a different man. Your guesses are probably right on. Mick has to be one. Lol

    • @obbor4
      @obbor4 3 роки тому +2

      The bass player was Klaus Voormann, of Manfred Mann and Beatles in Hamburg fame.

    • @vincentschmitt7597
      @vincentschmitt7597 3 роки тому +4

      @@obbor4 if I recall it was him that came up with the opening hook. It was a finger exercise with the strings to loosen up. The producer said what's that and wanted it in the song. Its the first thing you hear as the song starts.

    • @obbor4
      @obbor4 3 роки тому +3

      @@vincentschmitt7597 That's the story I heard, from Klaus, in an interview. Pretty cool how some things just turn out like that.

  • @jskit92380
    @jskit92380 2 роки тому +1

    Harri, for years and years, Carly would not reveal who the song was about. ☮🖤🤘

  • @happymethehappyone8300
    @happymethehappyone8300 3 роки тому +3

    CARLY SIMON "THAT'S THE WAY I'VE ALWAYS HEARD IT SHOULD BE"..AN ABSOLUTE MUST HEAR CLASSIC.

  • @ChuckHackney
    @ChuckHackney Рік тому +1

    This is their one hour concert on Martha's Vineyard as I recall. If I am wrong, someone correct me. Love this song. Love Carly. I always heard this was about Jagger, some even said Don McClane. Came to find out I think it was about Warren Beatty. And a solar eclipse in Nova Scotia!

  • @bemused9522
    @bemused9522 3 роки тому +17

    She does a great song called "Coming around again/itsy bitsy spider" also, I love her version of " You belong to me"

    • @ThePittsburghToddy
      @ThePittsburghToddy 3 роки тому +2

      Yes! That’s a great version and, I believe Carly Simon wrote “You Belong to Me”✌🏻

  • @kens32052
    @kens32052 3 роки тому +3

    This is from her Martha's Vineyard concert.

  • @robertsaul234
    @robertsaul234 3 роки тому +10

    For a charity, she auctioned off a walk on the beach where she would reveal the identity of the song's subject. Unfortunately, James Taylor made the winning bid.

  • @rranger1014
    @rranger1014 3 роки тому +2

    I remember riding in the back of my folks' station wagon with my brothers and sister on the way to the community pool when this song came on the radio in the early 70s. Thanks for posting!

  • @vegaswillie
    @vegaswillie 3 роки тому +2

    Good job, Harri.
    Enjoy your reactions tremendously.

  • @johnianknox1629
    @johnianknox1629 3 роки тому +5

    Harri, great reaction to Carly, you have to hear her duet with then husband JAMES TAYLOR with MOCKINGBIRD, and while I'm here, you must get into James himself, still one of the best singer/songwriters on this planet, start with SWEET BABY JAMES, there is great footage of him in the early 70's live at the B.B.C.

    • @MagicGoblinPrincess
      @MagicGoblinPrincess 3 роки тому

      I used to love James Taylor, until the Rolling Stone issue with Carly on the cover, where he said in the article that she "was the best piece of ass in the business". What a terrible, demeaning thing to say about your wife. Or ex-wife. He's clearly a jerk.

  • @famat161
    @famat161 3 роки тому +1

    Yes. Son of a Gun

  • @vincentschmitt7597
    @vincentschmitt7597 3 роки тому +6

    There is a MUST see on the making of this tune on UA-cam. The producer MADE this into the classic it is. It addresses the "son of a gun" line. Carly had ad-libbed several words and short phrases in the beginning of the song. Son of a gun was the one used.

  • @patrickdoolan9527
    @patrickdoolan9527 Місяць тому

    You made a brilliant point about 'how can someone speak for another'.

  • @smartin807
    @smartin807 3 роки тому +4

    Yes, Mick Jagger sang back-up on the Studio version.

  • @stevewalsh4850
    @stevewalsh4850 3 роки тому +6

    It was over dubbed into this version. It was Jagger, again, very astute and keen ear 😎

  • @rebeccawyse5562
    @rebeccawyse5562 3 роки тому +4

    They mark our moments in time dont they

  • @Veritas2112
    @Veritas2112 Рік тому +1

    You can say someone loved you if they treated you with great sex, love and kindness. Whether or not they appreciate you or to the degree they respect you and are honest, is something else.

  • @59elgreco
    @59elgreco 3 роки тому +2

    Carley Simon...."That's The Way I Always Heard It Should Be" live 1971 a must listen/watch !!!! (George Harrison and Art Garfunkle watch from the wings)

  • @SebGeddy
    @SebGeddy 3 роки тому +1

    Right, Harri, "Son of a Gun" 👏

  • @anthonymunn8633
    @anthonymunn8633 3 роки тому +1

    Jagger actually sang the backup on the studio recording.Maybe they used the recording as a backing track.
    As for Beatty,he was a notorious cocksman in the 70s.

  • @ralphvillanueva8724
    @ralphvillanueva8724 3 роки тому +1

    Great live performance at Martha's Vineyard.

  • @debbiechang5781
    @debbiechang5781 3 роки тому +4

    I like this song and have always thought part of its success was its mixed messages and confusing lyrics. The word “gavotte” puzzled me for years. I tried to find another definition other than a French dance. It still intrigues me to this day! Mission accomplished Carly! 😂

    • @lauramclaine504
      @lauramclaine504 3 роки тому +2

      It’s his walk his swagger my ex had a swagger walk and you could see it a block away every body knew it was him. People would comment about it.

  • @jewls9697
    @jewls9697 3 роки тому +1

    She said.... you said that we made such a pretty pair & that you'd never leave. Maybe she can't speak for him, but when ppl say things to u that make you believe something, than they can speak what was said to them & they believed it. If that made any sense! lol

  • @JuandeFucaU
    @JuandeFucaU 3 роки тому +2

    I've been called vain too.... but that's probably because I stand on top of people's barns and spin around in the same direction the weather blows.

    • @Russ_Keith
      @Russ_Keith 3 роки тому

      So you're vain when you're around a blowhard.

  • @garyarnett1220
    @garyarnett1220 3 роки тому +3

    She has never publically verified who it was about, Beatty was just one of the top contenders.

    • @cpmf2112
      @cpmf2112 3 роки тому +1

      Incorrect.... people.com/books/carly-simon-says-youre-so-vain-second-verse-is-about-warren-beatty/

  • @gpxo11
    @gpxo11 3 роки тому

    This was a huge song back in 1971-check out the studio version-Mick jagger DOES sing backup!

  • @KarenCatMom2
    @KarenCatMom2 3 роки тому +3

    More Carly please! Let the River Run, Anticipation, Coming Around Again, Give Me All Night
    Yes she can say you gave away the things you loved and one of them was me IF the man ever said I love you to her. Then she's just repeating his words back to him. 😊
    And I love the double entendre of the title of the song. Of course he thinks it's about him but he thinks it's about him because he's so suave, so desirable etc. And she's ripping him to pieces.

  • @comersbbq
    @comersbbq 3 роки тому

    One of my favorites by her!

  • @porflepopnecker4376
    @porflepopnecker4376 3 роки тому +1

    According to some music industry myths and legends, the subject of this song was none other than actor Don Knotts, who played Deputy Barney Fife on "The Andy Griffith Show."

  • @DLee1923
    @DLee1923 2 роки тому

    🥀 Enjoyed this reaction ! Nice job ! By the way, in earlier days it was said this song was about Mick Jagger ! HaHa I've never even heard the Warren Beatty discussion.
    Thanks for the video ! 😉🥀🙋🏻‍♀️

  • @michaeltveten8458
    @michaeltveten8458 3 роки тому +11

    Everyone knows who this song is about…….Carly, can’t say it, cuz it would be crass…..But, we know…

    • @88wildcat
      @88wildcat 3 роки тому +1

      Let's face it, even if it is not about Warren Beatty it should be.

  • @douglasbrown970
    @douglasbrown970 2 роки тому

    Hey Harry love seeing you feel music as I feel about it though we're of different ethnic backgrounds music transcends every difference and see use as music lovers

  • @StevesFunhouse
    @StevesFunhouse 3 роки тому +1

    Well, "son of a gun" ... you were right !!! I never noticed her saying that before but it's the 1st 3 words in the song's lyrics. And thought many don't know it, the entire song is about several men, but, and it's a BIG one, the main part of the song IS about Warren Beatty.
    Update: I forgot to mention, Warren contacted her and thanked her for the publicity ... really !!!

  • @kierstenridgway4634
    @kierstenridgway4634 3 роки тому

    I was 10 in my Uncle Smitty's " man cave" before they called it that. Black light with posters. Listening to this, Jimi Hendrix etc.. I love this album. The whole album is gold.

  • @willblood7082
    @willblood7082 3 роки тому

    She had quite a few high profile lovers back in the day but, most assume it’s about Warren of James Taylor.

  • @ALong-fo5so
    @ALong-fo5so 3 роки тому

    Mick Jaeger sang back up. He called up on a whim and invited himself into the studio one day and she happened to be recording the song.

  • @stevewalsh4850
    @stevewalsh4850 3 роки тому +1

    Very astute, Jagger is on the studio version singing backup

  • @fredneecher1746
    @fredneecher1746 3 роки тому

    Carly Simon did some great stuff back in the 70s. Well worth looking at. She wasn't so bad to look at either.

  • @SebGeddy
    @SebGeddy 3 роки тому +1

    Brilliant lyrics, bitter but/and subtle

  • @StevesFunhouse
    @StevesFunhouse 3 роки тому +3

    I can't seem to hear Mick's voice at all, but I see others who've said he sang on the studio version. This seems like it was done live, and he's definitely not there but, if you hear him, they must've synced in some of the studio sound. I've seen artists of the time (like James Taylor), who needed a previously recorded piece in their live performances but, due to the cost, small percentage of need for live performances, or a multitude of other factors, they just SHOW you the tape mechanism being used. I thought it was not only nice, but hilarious (James Taylor made a joke out of it).

  • @vincentschmitt7597
    @vincentschmitt7597 3 роки тому +2

    Supposedly each verse is about a different man. She said she would not reveal them as one of 'em is still clueless that "the song is about you" lol. Oh and once you know Mic Jagger is on the record you cannot unhear him. "Yower sooo vaiuun".

  • @vidge123
    @vidge123 3 роки тому

    iconic hit...thanks for the reaction! mick jagger did back her up on the original recording.

  • @igor1069
    @igor1069 3 роки тому

    I requested you did this song a few days ago. I mentioned then that on the Studio/album version of this MICK JAGGER is the back up singer. Listen to that on your own sometime and you'll definitely hear him then.

  • @SWLinPHX
    @SWLinPHX 2 роки тому

    If it is about you and you think it is then that means you recognize yourself so you ARE indeed vain. And if it isn't about you and you think it is then you really ARE vain.

  • @michaelplotino7046
    @michaelplotino7046 3 роки тому +1

    Hi Harri, First of all, great reaction as usual. I'm not sure why most reactors do this live version, but in my opinion, the studio recording is the way to go on this one. - Brooklyn Mike

    • @samsowden
      @samsowden 3 роки тому

      This is the easiest one to find on UA-cam

  • @marymarin3277
    @marymarin3277 3 роки тому +1

    Hey..she wrote a hit song from that broken heart! 😁💃

  • @oldschoolfink3212
    @oldschoolfink3212 3 роки тому

    Interesting you said this reminded you of Mick Jagger. . Mick He just happened to be at the same studio the day she recorded this and sang backup vocals on this track.

  • @maureenwilliford4380
    @maureenwilliford4380 3 роки тому

    The line is 'you gave away the things you loved and one of them was me'. I take that to mean love in the past tense and once he was through with her, he gave her away. Maybe I'm wrong but this is how I hear it.

  • @SebGeddy
    @SebGeddy 3 роки тому

    1. Son a of a gun, OK. 2. Mick Jagger did backing vocals on the studio version. But I don't hear these 2 in this live version. You really have a tremendous ear, Harri!

  • @frankiebowie6174
    @frankiebowie6174 3 роки тому +1

    Vanity is just one of the venial sins so it’s okay, I admit to my own vanity. 😊
    To me, looking as good as you can is an act of kindness to those who have to see you every day.

  • @suzymckinney9678
    @suzymckinney9678 3 роки тому +2

    That is Mick Jagger singing back up !

  • @marilynmontgomery4579
    @marilynmontgomery4579 Рік тому

    Carly Simon, for many years, would never say who this song was about. The one thing she said was that it had alot of vowels in it. Only recently did she finally said it was indeed about Warren Beatty.

  • @cathyhetzel5944
    @cathyhetzel5944 2 роки тому

    Poor Carly had panic attacks before going on stage. The crowd knew so they helped here with kind word and understanding. No one knew for years who she was talking about. HE WAS VAIN! He was a HUGH play boy.

  • @evanleehome2178
    @evanleehome2178 3 роки тому

    Mick Jagger did sing on the studio version. I believe that her line, "You gave away the THINGS of love ... and one of them was me" admits the she was in love but he wasn't in love with her.

  • @raenellefisher8514
    @raenellefisher8514 3 роки тому

    This song is something of a female anthem.

  • @robertkolb228
    @robertkolb228 18 днів тому

    It was Mick Jagger, great catch!

  • @bruceeven9942
    @bruceeven9942 Рік тому

    Yes, she said son of a gun. Regarding who the song is about, she denies it is Warren Beaty. She said it's about a mix of various boyfriends.

  • @stephenduffett8340
    @stephenduffett8340 2 місяці тому

    Many people have said the song is about David Geffin. Carly came from a publishing family , Simon and Shuster. Apparently she dated a few arrogant males.

  • @theJellyjoker
    @theJellyjoker 3 роки тому +1

    I know what I want. And I want it now. I want you, cause I'm Mr. Vain.

    • @G-y_m
      @G-y_m 2 роки тому +1

      Hilarious

  • @trixmenmarvelhp
    @trixmenmarvelhp 2 місяці тому

    “and others girls dreamed that they’d be Ben’s partner they’d be Ben’s partner” 😂😂❤

  • @patrickdoolan9527
    @patrickdoolan9527 Місяць тому

    I always thought it was about Tony Knowles!

  • @joejoesguitarinventions
    @joejoesguitarinventions 3 роки тому

    this song is about relationships.... someone is always get a little mote.. 👍

  • @marjolewis9405
    @marjolewis9405 2 роки тому

    There's been so much speculation about the identity of the subject matter. I've even heard this song could be about the lead guitarist of Cheap Trick.

  • @lethasatterfield9615
    @lethasatterfield9615 Рік тому

    I think that was filmed at Martha's Vineyard, where she lives. She's well known for having terrible stage fright and doing an outdoor concert in her own town would be less stressful. The song is supposed to be about Mic Jagger AND Warren Beatty (from what I've heard). She's always done that song with humor...so I doubt it's a song about heartbreak. I believe it truly is about the absurd behavior of extremely vain, narcissistic people. Poking fun. In any case, she is FILTHY rich (heiress) and got to be married to the AWESOME James Taylor for more than a decade, so I doubt she had much trouble moving on.

  • @annejohnston2193
    @annejohnston2193 3 роки тому

    Hiii Harri , you are great

  • @nicholasramos2982
    @nicholasramos2982 2 роки тому

    I heard Simon recorded You're So Vain in England. Guess who was invited and present at the recording of this song? Yes, Mick Jagger, one of her many famous, eligible bachelor boyfriends was present and participated in its recording. You are proven right, Harri. Realize Simon was a sex symbol of rock and roll. MANY high profile, eligible bachelor, celebrities were Simon's lovers. She said the song was more than JUST about 2 lovers. Opening up the MYSTERY who else was she singing about? Her ex husband, James Taylor? Early lover, Cat Stevens, who she admitted to an affair with early in her career. She was his opening act when she started her career. I believe, Warren Beatty and Mick Jagger were definitely two that "influenced" her in writing this song. But she admitted her other lovers ALSO influenced her when composing this famous, iconic song.

  • @SebGeddy
    @SebGeddy 3 роки тому

    To be a narcissist asshole is bad but to treat women like damaged goods or shit is one of the worst things ever. Kick-ass song by the great Carly Simon

  • @dhamma58
    @dhamma58 3 роки тому +4

    Avoid being too literal with these metaphors littered through the song. And I remember when the song came out the allegations, denials, non-statements, etc. Carly was one of the defining voices of the period, along with so many other great singers...

  • @bronsongetseven7326
    @bronsongetseven7326 3 роки тому

    It was written about James Taylor.

  • @louisdiblasi5441
    @louisdiblasi5441 Рік тому

    Baby playing by the stove.

  • @pattymckitrick7436
    @pattymckitrick7436 4 місяці тому

    ❤❤❤❤

  • @John_Chu
    @John_Chu 3 роки тому

    She also had a transatlantic fling with Cat Stevens. He actually proposed to her. She’s always had very nice things to say about him though. Shortly thereafter she met and married James Taylor.

    • @CharCanuck14
      @CharCanuck14 3 роки тому

      Carly wrote the song "Anticipation" about waiting to see Cat Stevens.

  • @cathyhetzel5944
    @cathyhetzel5944 2 роки тому

    Mick Jaggers did do vocals on the song.

  • @mulatacatachufla
    @mulatacatachufla 2 роки тому

    As a matter of fact this son is about Carly's ex-husband, the singer James Taylor, and the song was written after they broke up. Simons was also jealous of his professional relation with Carol King at the time.

  • @muriel2267
    @muriel2267 3 роки тому

    Mick Jagger does sing backup on the studio version

  • @eileenegger1466
    @eileenegger1466 2 роки тому

    Carly didn’t admit for years who the song was about. Both Warren & Carly each dated the beautiful people of their time,
    including each other.

  • @donaldmoon
    @donaldmoon 3 роки тому

    That was Mick Jaggers! --don

  • @DawnSuttonfabfour
    @DawnSuttonfabfour 3 роки тому

    It MAY be about Warren but the vote tends to come down to it being Mick Jagger; the irony is that on the single Mick is doing backing vocal! Love this song, good memories. How you doing this Sunny Sunday harri? xx

  • @Dee-JayW
    @Dee-JayW 3 роки тому

    She and James Taylor do a great rendition of Mockingbird…please react!!

  • @neilmartin99
    @neilmartin99 3 роки тому

    Well you're where you should be all the time
    And when you're not, you're with some underworld spy
    Or the wife of a close friend wife of a close friend
    "Ouch!"

  • @darleendionne6403
    @darleendionne6403 3 роки тому

    The song is actually about her.

  • @johnravert2377
    @johnravert2377 3 роки тому

    Funny...Mick was the number 2 choice for the subject matter...

  • @timothykelley3635
    @timothykelley3635 Рік тому

    Jesse is a great song by her also

  • @shanenolan8252
    @shanenolan8252 3 роки тому

    Yes son of a gun

  • @karinwolf3645
    @karinwolf3645 3 роки тому

    In recent interviews she has said that this song was not about Warren Beaty or Mick Jagged or Donald Trump whom she had some dates with... But she refused to say who it was!

  • @lorislotsky
    @lorislotsky 2 роки тому

    There is actually a fantastic cover of this song by an 80's "hair metal" band called Faster Pussycat. They did a rock version of the song which I actually like better than Carly Simon's version. Please do a reaction to it. The video is a must see.

  • @ralphandleosmom9075
    @ralphandleosmom9075 3 роки тому

    Mick Jagger did sing back up on this song.