@@serdargokkaya5840 serdar adam dw yi kendi sahasında tuş etti gitti sen de diyorsun ki kendinde değil. yönlendirici sorulara ters gitmeden ters gitmek bu kadar olur. bence adam gayet kendinde ve gayet makul istekleri var kolay değil ama makul.
he is parked in a stall under a lux apartment complex in Russia managed by Steven Seagal's valet company. And yes, Assad, Seagal, Gérard Depardieu, and Snowden are tenants there too
Mouaz Moustafa says it's frustrating that SDF has not reached to Damascus to make a deal. Surely he can't be this uninformed. SDF has been calling for negotiations and peace for weeks. But they get rejected, because Turkey is pushing against having the kurds be part of ANY negotiation for a future Syria. They have been sending delegation to Damascus for a long time. But Turkey is pressuring HTS to not engage. This has been the case for years. Turkey has done everything to deny them any access to negotiations.
Hts is literally a turkish proxy at this point. His suggestion that sdf should go make a deal with hts is foolish. Its all rhetoric and talk right now, hts has yet to prove that they can rule impartially.
Negotiations for what? The request is clear: disarm completely and hand the Syrian national oil and gas fields back to Damascus. But we all know that KCK's Syrian military wing YPG dominates the SDF and their main objective is to keep their weapons and gain autonomy with imperialist US backing them so they can continue to steal Syrian oil or use it to blackmail the central government.
The bottom line is don't expect the media to answer all of the questions that come to mind. You have to be willing to do some of your own research then to expect a video that is barely 5 minutes long to answer all your questions!?
Being a Canadian, I don’t see why Syria can’t have a Kurdish province within the State and allow it its own language, guaranteed number of seats in Syrian government, etc. Look it up, we have done it with dominant French Speaking Quebec, with their own language rights, legal system, etc., all under the umbrella of Canada. In fact, the rest of us Canadians gave, in 2023, to Quebec $13,316 million in equalization payments and $3,719 million in Canada Social Transfer payments. So, if a country like Canada can do it … absolutely no reason why Syria can’t show some maturity and follow that model. Or the alternative… more war
Because it will be used for a pretext to establish a Kurdish state in the region in the future besides they were not majority in many places in the north pre-war
Because the SDF are committed to a revolutionary and even anarchist ideology that doesn't coordinate well with the sort of government Damascus wants to establish
Well if you lived in Middle-East you would have a totally different state of mind. Some questions: did US provide weapons to Canadians to potentially fight against each other this whole process? Were there proxy wars and terrorist groups supported by world super powers? I doubt it.
Bro i guess local Quebec people does not bomb the other region with terrorist attacks for 30+ years and kills around 40000 people. I guess they are also not in the official Terror list of almost all United Nation countries. Oh also probably there are no huge oil reserves in that area. Thats why. I geniounly dont get how foreigh people dont get the PKK element.
They can live in their territory under the flag of a united Syria. Don't forget that they only make up to 10% of the population. Easy for you to say but how would Europe look like if all ethnic groups had their own country?
Kurds deserve their own autonomy,turkey should not say no to kurds because kurds are an part and parcel of syria turkey cant veto kurds and say no to kurds ...if Syria ignores kurds and abandoned kurds than new syria would remain an unstable region because you can't erase the syrian kurds identity
ok give them a land in your own country. Syria for Syrians. Kurds are not even 10% of the Syrian population. Europe is weak and sinking, America is busy with Trump. Russia fled from Syria, who are you to give land?
Kurdish civil society is the most Democratic women are free and equal they even serve in the military. Not dependent on fathers brothers or husbands. Kurds hace a tradition of live and let live. Don't let Erdogan destroy a civilized society !!!!!!!
@@syedibtisamhaider9257it’s joke for people who are against justice and democracy. There are 22 arab, 7 Turkish, and 3 Persian countries why not one Israelis and one independent Kurdistan in the middle east.this will resolve lots of problems in the region. We Kurds deserve to have our independence Kurdistan. We are going to be democratic and respect all minorities even we will die for their rights because this is whatI should be
But the kurs are behaving do badly. They dont unite with the revolutionary in damaskus and continue to fight and take land under their control although these cities and villages are mostly Arab population . They control oil and third of syria etc every other minority syria are so patriot and want one united syria except the kurds . They are really making so much troubles
Are you delusional?😂 -There has never been a Kurdish state in human history -“Kurdish regions” are also inhabited by other ethnic groups that don’t want to be part of a Kurdish state -The territories that they claim span over 5 sovereign countries
And what do you suggest doing with the Kurds? You can't erase their identity overnight and expect them to forget their language and traditions. If they were to be involved in a Syrian project, it would have to be with a federalist approach in which they are given a certain level of autonomy.
@@IsabellaCastile-y8y erdogan is literally supporting that. Americans are the ones that want to divide syria by 2 parts SDF and legitimate syrian government
@@AndresNostos who said we're erasing their identity?? he simply said Syria is for syrians and that's the absolute fact. it's not for russia, iran, sdf or any group that wants to divide my country and btw syrians for us mean = arabs, Turkmen, kurds, armenians, assyrians, circassians and greeks.....the list is long but whoever considers "syria" as his homeland, we don't have a problem with him. they're also my people. we just want our lands back
If Turkey is interested in peace with the Kurdish people throughout the region it will support their interests in integration into a new government with representation and self determination. If however this is just another opportunity for Erdogan to scapegoat all of them as he labels them with no opportunities for change given to the rest of Syria and continue violence against them for political purposes, then the region will remain unstable and it may spread. I am not saying all the Kurds are innocent at all but look at the rest of the groups fighting for Syria. I mean come on, if you will give them a chance then you should give the same to the Kurds. Unless this is simply an ethnic cleansing by the Turks. In which case the international community should get involved .
Negotiations for what? The request is clear: disarm completely and hand the Syrian national oil and gas fields back to Damascus. But we all know that KCK's Syrian military wing YPG dominates the SDF and their main objective is to keep their weapons and gain autonomy with imperialist US backing them so they can continue to steal Syrian oil or use it to blackmail the central government.
Th rea h to say we want to keep out independence under one flage, basically we keep the states quo but we rise another flag. That is not something we can agree to ever
your country was born 100 years a go by the british empire and they denied the Kurds their own state , Kurds do not want their land to be occupied by you , they are independent people and want to be
Syria is the oldest country in the world that was born way before 100 years ago, the Kurds were minority that was living in the Middle East but they never ever had their own official land. Mark my words, the Kurds population will grow and prosper under the new Syrian government. A united Syria 😊
dear friend.. wtf? Syrian civilization is one of the most ancient on earth. thousands of years before the birth of the term "Kurd", its basic history you can check it up on google very quickly. and those people you're speaking for without knowing anything about the matter, they themselves want to be a part of the new syrian government, bc they're also Syrians themselves. the singular problem thats happening right now is the factions that has control over that are which is also being supported by the US, is trying to resist the reality, and shooting their own kurdish civilians in the streets who was requesting the union with the Syrian government. you need to understand the difference between a civilization and an ethnic group. Syria contains many ethnicities and religions and they're all united under the name Syrians (including syrian kurds) and all of them love it.
Yes really they dont belong to Syria. They came from central Asia fifty years ago..they were given syrian citizenship in the last ten years and now they want their own state on syrian land 😂
Turkey needs to give the Kurd territories inside Turkey and Syria and northern Iraq and help Kurds combine territories into a consolidated Kurd territory. Help them create a Kurd territory in totality and even help them build their own country. It is better to build relationships, allegiances with them as allies. Turn the tide from conflict to strong alliances with new neighbors. To be honest and let's be clear. Historically neither the Arabs nor the Turks have any legitimate claim to Kurd territories. Because the Kurds are an Iranian nation. Even the Iranians should combine their Kurd territories with the other Kurd Territories, and Iran, Turkey and the new Kurd nation should build together a strong allegiance together. The rest of Syria needs to be combined, and Syria should demand the Golan back from Israel for the illegal annexation based on UN resolution. Of course, for that Syria should sign an Ironclad treaty with Israel, to never attack Israel and Israel to never attack or invade Syria. There is so much more that could be achieved by building for peace with actual Justice. But I guess a lot of people are just blind with misplaced vengeance rather than really looking for Justice and then establishing peace.
If US had stepped in and told Turkey to back off attacking Kurds, none of the fighting that is happening in north of Syria now. Trump praised Edugon instead 🤦♂️.
Rump sees men like Erdogan and Putin as strong men, he likes authoritarian leaders. Rump also gave the greenlight for Erdogan to attack the SDF back in 2019, he pulled US troops out of Rojava, so the Turkish Armed Forces and SNA could proceed with Operation Peace Spring. I believe Rump doesn't care about the Kurd Syrians, he's friends with Erdogan I would say.
Don't worry, the world's most stable genius that know everything in the entire world will end all wars within 24 hours ./S unless the Kurds pay Trump in gold they are going to get screwed.
Honestly, as long as the U.S. remains involved in Syria, the prospect of peace seems distant. The primary objective of the U.S. and Israel appears to be weakening any efforts toward peace and stability in Syria, as they perceive the country as a threat to Israel. However, if the Syrian people can come together in unity, it would be a positive step forward and great news for the nation.
I think that is a presumptuous statement because from what we seen at least in the case of the US their main goal is to eliminate isis from regaining a foot hold in the country. I have seen nothing to alter that perspective. This spokesperson Mustafa also did not say otherwise. As for Israel, I haven't seen any source that has enough evidence to say what their intentions are. The IDF has been busy destroying weapons in Syria that used to be under control of Assad's regime because they don't want it falling into the hands of a party that might threaten Israel. It's too early to draw conclusions of how any of this will play out.
Iranian imperialism resulted in the deaths of their people for over a decade. Israel took some abandoned territory in the Golan Heights and destroyed a bunch of missile launchers and planes that the new Syrian government couldnt even use. Israel is not the main enemy of the new Syria. It is still Iran and Russia
Didn't you know that Israel helped the rebels by bombing Hezbollah and Iranian forces in Syria that helped Assad? Turkey is also an ally of the rebels but they let Turkey invade 1.6 square miles of territory.
Turkey wants Palestinian state but not Kurdish state They want to eliminate Kurdish forces because they don't want terrorists around it's borders but they criticize Israel for doing the same to hamas 😂
Ahmed al-Sharaa was not elected, and his interim government does not control all of Syria. Even ISIS still controls some regions. Calling him the “Leader of Syria” is premature. The civil war is not over yet.
Not yet. al Sharaa is still not the leader of Syria. It will be decided by all the people of Syria from all Syrian factions in March 2025 through elections.
03:01 - Insanely dishonest of the man being interviewed to claim that Kurdish-led SDF has not reached out to Damascus to negotiate. They've reached out to Damascus over and over again, but Damascus, and Ex-Al-Qaeda led HTS has been ignoring them, hoping for Turkish backed ISIS terrorists to win or severely weaken the Kurds.
I'm so hopeful for Syria! Stay strong and don't mess up this opportunity. Hopefully the lessons learned in the past two decades is that Syria is for Syrians, if you let your divisions guide you, the predators like Russia or Iran will exploit it to their advantage.
The Kurds will only settle for either a high level of autonomy or independence, so if Damascus wants to buy them into a new Syria they will need to keep that in mind.
civil war risk 2,5K km southeast of Berlin. DW: lets ask some expert from the US about it. expert says: the new government of syria, which used to be ISIS, needs to be asked by the kurds for a deal.
I think you're sorely mistaken. A united Syria by, from and for the people might bring peace and prosperity to their nation. I think most Syrians aren't ready to start another war.
Who ever be the new govt in syria by 2025 must respect the laws of democracy to bring back syria in its old glory unite all citizen what ever their beliefs the govt should be mix of all these tribes.
DW doing what DW always do again. As much as you want to impose a rhetoric, there is no conflict between Turks and Kurds. Türkiye, as a state, fighting against terrorist organization PKK and you know this very well. Calling them the "Kurds" doesn't change the fact that they don't represent or given authority by them. I want to hear your honest opinion about Israel's one sided war in Palestine though. How do you call Israel's enemies? Hamas, jihadists or Palestinians?
Türkiye is against Kurdish identity, their language, their culture, their names, town names, street names, mountain names, river names...and their peaceful representatives are in jails. Stop playing terrorist cards, it may convince you because you are brain washed.
These kurds are not a part of Syria (except kurds that Syria origin). The demographic map suppose to be like 2011. The best place for kurdistan is Central of Germany, Bavyera, Munih, Frankurt. We support Kurds who want to establish a state in Germany.
@@IsabellaCastile-y8y There are nearly 20 million Kurds in Turkiye, and more than half of them are born of Turkish-Kurdish marriages. They see themselves as Turks of Kurdish origin.The other half are assimilated and are loyal to Turkiye.
once upon the time his now cheering counterpart put a bounty of ten of thousands of dollars $$$$$ on his head... that said all about his counterpart and him...
@Samayil_2024 if all factions of Syria unite under Damascus then who's stopping Turkey and Damascus to jointly take action against them? It's the SDF who needs to compromise
We can make a deal, whole northern Mesopotamia is autochthonous Indo-European peoples lands. Always was. Afro Semitic Syrian people can unite with Afro Semitic Lebanon-> then they can call their lands Arab republic ASia(N) is the ancient Indo-European Hellenic term for autochthonous Indo-European West Asian IraniC word & people. As well as Asian Minor (-> Anatolia) /Northern Mesopotamia and CavcAsia (-> Zagros/Pontus ). CavcAsia literally means in Indo-European mountainous Asia(n)Kurd (KurManc Khord/ Sorani Khord) are Northwest IraniC Indo-European people and always live in West Asia. It’s written in “Greek”(Roman name), in Roman and any other ancient mythology. It’s very easy to prove. PIE originates in the Indo-European West Asian Near Eastern part of Indo-European West Asia, not the Indo-European West Asian European part. Indio-European Europe is not a continent of its own- but it’s instead geographically, genetically, linguistically and culturally the most western part of Indo-European West Asia. The other part of Indo-European West Asia is the Indo-European Near East (Anatolia/Northern Mesopotamia and Caucasia (Zagros/Pontus up to Afghanistan/Iran borders). The Middle East = North Africa + Horn of Africa + Southern part of Southwest Asian peninsula = Afro (Southwest) Asiatic people/areas started from the oldest one in North African, spreading to the Horn of Africa but also to the southern part of the Southwest Asian peninsula up to Southern Mesopotamia where the Afro Semitic live.
> guy sitting in his car
must be calling from syria
> guy is in washingron dc
Bruh
can't tell the difference a lot of the time lmfao
Hé is dillusional nothing is true what hé say
@@serdargokkaya5840 serdar adam dw yi kendi sahasında tuş etti gitti sen de diyorsun ki kendinde değil. yönlendirici sorulara ters gitmeden ters gitmek bu kadar olur. bence adam gayet kendinde ve gayet makul istekleri var kolay değil ama makul.
You don't know what he did beforehand, go for the subject matter.
he is parked in a stall under a lux apartment complex in Russia managed by Steven Seagal's valet company. And yes, Assad, Seagal, Gérard Depardieu, and Snowden are tenants there too
It may not be easy to call off the Kurds. They have a long-standing legit beef with Turkey.
as in Turkey claiming a quarter of their territory
@@OilHutJones most of sdf territory is arab majority
@@letsplaywithmegacyborg3098
Arab lands is Southern Mesopotamia , not Indo-European Northern Mesopotamia
@@barand.4950 i mean, that's where arabs live rn
Bruh if it wasn’t for UN or sanctions Turkey would disintegrate them in a non
Mouaz Moustafa says it's frustrating that SDF has not reached to Damascus to make a deal. Surely he can't be this uninformed. SDF has been calling for negotiations and peace for weeks. But they get rejected, because Turkey is pushing against having the kurds be part of ANY negotiation for a future Syria. They have been sending delegation to Damascus for a long time. But Turkey is pressuring HTS to not engage.
This has been the case for years. Turkey has done everything to deny them any access to negotiations.
Hts is literally a turkish proxy at this point. His suggestion that sdf should go make a deal with hts is foolish. Its all rhetoric and talk right now, hts has yet to prove that they can rule impartially.
SDF needs to disarm ASAP. SDF fighters should be a part of Syrian Army
Negotiations for what? The request is clear: disarm completely and hand the Syrian national oil and gas fields back to Damascus.
But we all know that KCK's Syrian military wing YPG dominates the SDF and their main objective is to keep their weapons and gain autonomy with imperialist US backing them so they can continue to steal Syrian oil or use it to blackmail the central government.
Why would damascus make a deal with terrorists?
SDF wants autonomy for the eastern Euphrates area to be ruled by Kurds, who are no more than 20% of the population, this is never going to happen.
I always wondered why these news channels don't provide a map when speaking about any area? 🤔
Because if they do, they won't be able to manage perception.
@@ozkanaydin34 or assume people can't read maps
Maybe because most of Syria is under uncertain territory or changed rapidly the past month?
The bottom line is don't expect the media to answer all of the questions that come to mind. You have to be willing to do some of your own research then to expect a video that is barely 5 minutes long to answer all your questions!?
@@michaeldeierhoi4096 If a country's politics can be discussed in a 5-minute video, a map can certainly be included. This is perception management.
Being a Canadian, I don’t see why Syria can’t have a Kurdish province within the State and allow it its own language, guaranteed number of seats in Syrian government, etc. Look it up, we have done it with dominant French Speaking Quebec, with their own language rights, legal system, etc., all under the umbrella of Canada. In fact, the rest of us Canadians gave, in 2023, to Quebec $13,316 million in equalization payments and $3,719 million in Canada Social Transfer payments.
So, if a country like Canada can do it … absolutely no reason why Syria can’t show some maturity and follow that model.
Or the alternative… more war
Because it will be used for a pretext to establish a Kurdish state in the region in the future besides they were not majority in many places in the north pre-war
There are more domestic Turkish people than kurds in Syria. It must be Turkish othonom region in there.
Because the SDF are committed to a revolutionary and even anarchist ideology that doesn't coordinate well with the sort of government Damascus wants to establish
Well if you lived in Middle-East you would have a totally different state of mind. Some questions: did US provide weapons to Canadians to potentially fight against each other this whole process? Were there proxy wars and terrorist groups supported by world super powers? I doubt it.
Bro i guess local Quebec people does not bomb the other region with terrorist attacks for 30+ years and kills around 40000 people. I guess they are also not in the official Terror list of almost all United Nation countries. Oh also probably there are no huge oil reserves in that area. Thats why. I geniounly dont get how foreigh people dont get the PKK element.
Turkey needs to leave the Kurds alone let them just live in their ethnic territory
So US can steal oil.
Don’t talk about matters you know nothing about
The Turks don’t know how to do that. Unfortunately!!
@@TurquazCannabizSo tell us. I am kurdish. Teach me.
They can live in their territory under the flag of a united Syria. Don't forget that they only make up to 10% of the population. Easy for you to say but how would Europe look like if all ethnic groups had their own country?
Kurds should protect themselves
Mind your business! some people can’t handle how everything is going good with the new Syria
You mean “communists”?
Prayers to Syria. A lot of great people with good hearts that just want a better life 🙏🏾
Why can't they divide their region so they can live peacefully each one of each fraction??.. Too much pride, they don't know how to swallow.. 😎😎😎
“Boundaries shift, allegiances change”
Ah, the Middle East.
Either you are naive or you pretend to not know the real issue in the Middle East
Kurds deserve their own autonomy,turkey should not say no to kurds because kurds are an part and parcel of syria turkey cant veto kurds and say no to kurds ...if Syria ignores kurds and abandoned kurds than new syria would remain an unstable region because you can't erase the syrian kurds identity
Give Kurds their land back…
what land.. Did they have a place that belonged to them before?
Can you give me a year or any date when the Kurds were an indepandant state?
They have never had land throughout history
So?
@@sengon344Ayyubid Sultanate, Zand dynasty, Banū Rawwād, Republic of Mahabad etc...
The Kurds deserve their own state.
if they do, give them land of your country.
ok give them a land in your own country. Syria for Syrians. Kurds are not even 10% of the Syrian population. Europe is weak and sinking, America is busy with Trump. Russia fled from Syria, who are you to give land?
The kurds rly thing israel or amerika let a strong powe like thyrkie be side just for her land they rly have to be not in this earth
Kurds always were in this region.
@@ragesmirk like virus ?
Kurdish civil society is the most Democratic women are free and equal they even serve in the military. Not dependent on fathers brothers or husbands. Kurds hace a tradition of live and let live. Don't let Erdogan destroy a civilized society !!!!!!!
Hahaha, nice joke
@@syedibtisamhaider9257it’s joke for people who are against justice and democracy. There are 22 arab, 7 Turkish, and 3 Persian countries why not one Israelis and one independent Kurdistan in the middle east.this will resolve lots of problems in the region. We Kurds deserve to have our independence Kurdistan.
We are going to be democratic and respect all minorities even we will die for their rights because this is whatI should be
Kurdish people have right to defend themselves
Yes they do, but they can't and should not divide Syria. The country ought to be one just like before the war.
@@Wqghfxz Your opinion is irrelevant here. Better mind your own business in Ukraine.
Freedom to Kurdistan!!
Lmao no
Fallacy
In Germany
@@cyclomb🦃what is this animal?
@@dyakokurdish Ⓛⓞⓞⓚⓢ ⓛⓘⓚⓔ ⓨⓞⓤⓡ ⓂⓄⓂ
the Kurds are my concern - as soon as i heard the terks were involved i know this would be an issue. a kurdistan proper needs to be established
But the kurs are behaving do badly. They dont unite with the revolutionary in damaskus and continue to fight and take land under their control although these cities and villages are mostly Arab population . They control oil and third of syria etc every other minority syria are so patriot and want one united syria except the kurds . They are really making so much troubles
Are you delusional?😂
-There has never been a Kurdish state in human history
-“Kurdish regions” are also inhabited by other ethnic groups that don’t want to be part of a Kurdish state
-The territories that they claim span over 5 sovereign countries
Give them your land since you do care about them
Wby dhould any of the legit states there gave arguebly potentially lucrative land (oil) to a bunch of people that clearly dosent care abt law n order.
It is high time for the Kurdish to have their own country.
hahaha, lol
They have. It's in Disneyland, Florida.
Syria is for the Syrians
@@angelito4872 absolutely. The Western world should correct this injustice.
Any time western world “corrects” something, it gets broken worse than before. Let the people fight for their fate.
God Bless Kurdistan !!!
Turdistan ? What kind of place is that ?
Yes show us on the map. Where is it.?
@@Börü78 Southeastern Turkey, northeastern Syria, northern Iraq, and northwestern Iran.
@@otisdylan9532 that is your dream. You cant show on map. Impossible isn’t it.
@@Börü78 Yes, it is impossible to draw map of any kind in the UA-cam comments section.
Syria for Syrians, one and united.
Sorry but Erdogan won't agree with you!
And what do you suggest doing with the Kurds? You can't erase their identity overnight and expect them to forget their language and traditions. If they were to be involved in a Syrian project, it would have to be with a federalist approach in which they are given a certain level of autonomy.
@@IsabellaCastile-y8y erdogan is literally supporting that. Americans are the ones that want to divide syria by 2 parts SDF and legitimate syrian government
@@AndresNostos who said we're erasing their identity?? he simply said Syria is for syrians and that's the absolute fact. it's not for russia, iran, sdf or any group that wants to divide my country and btw syrians for us mean = arabs, Turkmen, kurds, armenians, assyrians, circassians and greeks.....the list is long but whoever considers "syria" as his homeland, we don't have a problem with him. they're also my people. we just want our lands back
@@BushraYaser-l6v This conflict will continue for another 1, 400 years! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
If Turkey is interested in peace with the Kurdish people throughout the region it will support their interests in integration into a new government with representation and self determination. If however this is just another opportunity for Erdogan to scapegoat all of them as he labels them with no opportunities for change given to the rest of Syria and continue violence against them for political purposes, then the region will remain unstable and it may spread. I am not saying all the Kurds are innocent at all but look at the rest of the groups fighting for Syria. I mean come on, if you will give them a chance then you should give the same to the Kurds. Unless this is simply an ethnic cleansing by the Turks. In which case the international community should get involved .
People didnt lost any citizen from terrorism should give their land to Kurds so they can live.Easy to talk from miles away.
Nope the UN already decided where Kurdistan goes
He keeps talking as SDF is not reaching out to make deals. They are the groups that seeks a deal the most.
Negotiations for what? The request is clear: disarm completely and hand the Syrian national oil and gas fields back to Damascus.
But we all know that KCK's Syrian military wing YPG dominates the SDF and their main objective is to keep their weapons and gain autonomy with imperialist US backing them so they can continue to steal Syrian oil or use it to blackmail the central government.
No. SDF/PKK wants to divide Syria. That's enough reason to be against them. Period.
they have no legal basis to divide syria aside from US support. Of course they will want to make deal because right now legally they have nothing
Th rea h to say we want to keep out independence under one flage, basically we keep the states quo but we rise another flag. That is not something we can agree to ever
Do what…????
your country was born 100 years a go by the british empire and they denied the Kurds their own state , Kurds do not want their land to be occupied by you , they are independent people and want to be
Syria is the oldest country in the world that was born way before 100 years ago, the Kurds were minority that was living in the Middle East but they never ever had their own official land. Mark my words, the Kurds population will grow and prosper under the new Syrian government. A united Syria 😊
@@alterzz2121 Israel and Syria are modern interpretations of old ideas. 😂
@ wrong , syria was born at the same time when turkey and iraq and jordan and most of the meddle-astern countries was born , google it
dear friend.. wtf?
Syrian civilization is one of the most ancient on earth. thousands of years before the birth of the term "Kurd", its basic history you can check it up on google very quickly.
and those people you're speaking for without knowing anything about the matter, they themselves want to be a part of the new syrian government, bc they're also Syrians themselves. the singular problem thats happening right now is the factions that has control over that are which is also being supported by the US, is trying to resist the reality, and shooting their own kurdish civilians in the streets who was requesting the union with the Syrian government. you need to understand the difference between a civilization and an ethnic group. Syria contains many ethnicities and religions and they're all united under the name Syrians (including syrian kurds) and all of them love it.
@@alterzz2121 They're millions , don't you think that they deserve their own official
land ?
Turkish people are more worried about Syrians and Kurds than syrians themselves....worry about your country 1st
a purely colonising mentality that colonises people's lands under the guise of aiding them
maybe its because they are host to a third of the entire syrian population.
Democracy for Syria Autonomy for SDF....NEER NEVER give up weapons
Her biji ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Kurd/karda
U❤❤❤❤❤❤ Kurdistanê ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
no
Kurdistine will be free?
No
yes
Yes. America announced that Kurdistan will be established on Mars in 2050.
FREE FREE KURDISTAN
FROM THE MOUNTAINS TO THE SEA
Kurdistan SHALL BE FREE
FREE FREE KURDISTAN
That makes a Kurds State or country or nation...
Syria and Kurds don't mix.
Yes really they dont belong to Syria. They came from central Asia fifty years ago..they were given syrian citizenship in the last ten years and now they want their own state on syrian land 😂
@@al.be.8679so like Palestinians then.
@@al.be.8679 Bro go read History. 50 years ago 🤣😂🤣😂
@@JohnJones-k9dyou mean like the European ‘Israelis’?
Syrian isn't an ethnicity it's just a nationality, Kurds are syrians too, majority are Arabs but there are druze, ammonites etc .
Turkey needs to give the Kurd territories inside Turkey and Syria and northern Iraq and help Kurds combine territories into a consolidated Kurd territory. Help them
create a Kurd territory in totality and even help them build their own country. It is better to build relationships, allegiances with them as allies. Turn the tide from conflict
to strong alliances with new neighbors. To be honest and let's be clear. Historically neither the Arabs nor the Turks have any legitimate claim to Kurd territories. Because
the Kurds are an Iranian nation. Even the Iranians should combine their Kurd territories with the other Kurd Territories, and Iran, Turkey and the new Kurd nation should build together
a strong allegiance together. The rest of Syria needs to be combined, and Syria should demand the Golan back from Israel for the illegal annexation based on UN resolution. Of course,
for that Syria should sign an Ironclad treaty with Israel, to never attack Israel and Israel to never attack or invade Syria. There is so much more that could be achieved by building for peace
with actual Justice. But I guess a lot of people are just blind with misplaced vengeance rather than really looking for Justice and then establishing peace.
When Assad was in power, the Kurds came close to cutting a deal to confront the "rebels".
If US had stepped in and told Turkey to back off attacking Kurds, none of the fighting that is happening in north of Syria now. Trump praised Edugon instead 🤦♂️.
Rump sees men like Erdogan and Putin as strong men, he likes authoritarian leaders. Rump also gave the greenlight for Erdogan to attack the SDF back in 2019, he pulled US troops out of Rojava, so the Turkish Armed Forces and SNA could proceed with Operation Peace Spring.
I believe Rump doesn't care about the Kurd Syrians, he's friends with Erdogan I would say.
Don't worry, the world's most stable genius that know everything in the entire world will end all wars within 24 hours ./S
unless the Kurds pay Trump in gold they are going to get screwed.
There is no power in the world that can make Turkey do something it does not want.
stop calling him a leader
He led a number of people/freedom fighters to achieve a common goal. Is that not the definition of a leader?
Why america can’t simply give some land in unite states so kurds can finally be free.
Honestly, as long as the U.S. remains involved in Syria, the prospect of peace seems distant. The primary objective of the U.S. and Israel appears to be weakening any efforts toward peace and stability in Syria, as they perceive the country as a threat to Israel. However, if the Syrian people can come together in unity, it would be a positive step forward and great news for the nation.
I think that is a presumptuous statement because from what we seen at least in the case of the US their main goal is to eliminate isis from regaining a foot hold in the country. I have seen nothing to alter that perspective. This spokesperson Mustafa also did not say otherwise.
As for Israel, I haven't seen any source that has enough evidence to say what their intentions are. The IDF has been busy destroying weapons in Syria that used to be under control of Assad's regime because they don't want it falling into the hands of a party that might threaten Israel.
It's too early to draw conclusions of how any of this will play out.
It's all about money. These guys have not jobs
Israel invades your country and all you end up talking about is Iranian imperialism. What a shame this man must be for his kin and kind, and for what?
Sounds like they were welcomed in
Iranian imperialism resulted in the deaths of their people for over a decade. Israel took some abandoned territory in the Golan Heights and destroyed a bunch of missile launchers and planes that the new Syrian government couldnt even use.
Israel is not the main enemy of the new Syria. It is still Iran and Russia
Didn't you know that Israel helped the rebels by bombing Hezbollah and Iranian forces in Syria that helped Assad? Turkey is also an ally of the rebels but they let Turkey invade 1.6 square miles of territory.
Let's hope there will be peace in Syria and everywhere in the world!
Q: Which factions exactly have united?
A: Various ones have united, liberal and conservative.
Not useful...
🌈Kurdish INDEPENDENT HOMELAND as self determination is essential for any nation
The Western world seems united in best wishes for Syrian people.
This war will continue for ever!
*Lets hope not.*
Simply he is bulshiting.
SDF must ally with the ruling HTS to survive. less autonomy but with chance to survive.
Hows Christmas celebration going in Syria?
Turkey wants Palestinian state but not Kurdish state
They want to eliminate Kurdish forces because they don't want terrorists around it's borders but they criticize Israel for doing the same to hamas 😂
Damascus it turkey lead the government and what's your talking about it same fight to turkey
when this puppet knotted his tie, Zelensky died
[2:36] "with the sole role to defeat ISIS" my a$$ 😂😂😂
Ahmed al Sharaa is the leader of Syria not a rebel leader. Please correct ur narrative
Ahmed al-Sharaa was not elected, and his interim government does not control all of Syria. Even ISIS still controls some regions. Calling him the “Leader of Syria” is premature.
The civil war is not over yet.
Not yet. al Sharaa is still not the leader of Syria. It will be decided by all the people of Syria from all Syrian factions in March 2025 through elections.
Why they make elections in Syria?
@@thejohannreinshow2497 Turkey is the Leader of Syria.
rebel lader who was not voted in by the people.......best called a rebel dictatorship, with isis laws
Never give up your weapon
Someone is going to cry...Based on the script from time immemorial.
Ummah! Ummah will be so disappointed!!!
Why DW news speaking someone in Washington . Can they not find anyone in the Syria
Kurds need Iraqi type autonomy or independence but Turkey needs to get the heck out. Israel and the Kurds need to work together.
Keep dreaming 😂
03:01 - Insanely dishonest of the man being interviewed to claim that Kurdish-led SDF has not reached out to Damascus to negotiate.
They've reached out to Damascus over and over again, but Damascus, and Ex-Al-Qaeda led HTS has been ignoring them, hoping for Turkish backed ISIS terrorists to win or severely weaken the Kurds.
These factions will come together. Its the west thats creating devisions.
Hoping for the best for Syria! 🙏
Stop calling legitimate leader Ahmad Sharaa as rebel leader.
Have some respect DW😊
As if the Sunnis were going to be willing to submit to Kurdish rule if the Kurds took Damascus
Divide Syria according to its belief.
The whole point is to establish a greater Israel, but this seems impossible with Türkiye.
1 Syria 1 nation
I'm so hopeful for Syria! Stay strong and don't mess up this opportunity. Hopefully the lessons learned in the past two decades is that Syria is for Syrians, if you let your divisions guide you, the predators like Russia or Iran will exploit it to their advantage.
Turkey is the major predator right now
There'll definitely loose.
Kurds will I agree!
The Kurds will only settle for either a high level of autonomy or independence, so if Damascus wants to buy them into a new Syria they will need to keep that in mind.
No room for pkk and pyd in the future of Syria..
They will always be there! Kurds are over 30 million in population!
yes@@IsabellaCastile-y8y
so Turk don't have right talk and make decision for other nation
Pyd can have a kurdish province in canada
Why he mentioned germany?
Because DW News is German
This isn't going to go as as this dude thinks.
civil war risk 2,5K km southeast of Berlin. DW: lets ask some expert from the US about it. expert says: the new government of syria, which used to be ISIS, needs to be asked by the kurds for a deal.
God bless Syria and Peace to its people 🙏🙏
Not a rebel leader, the real leader of Syria, get over it already!!!!!!!
No tolerance for Commies apparently, Kurds or otherwise.
They should give up on Kurdistan and join the new Syrian government. Even if they deserve autonomy, it's not worth dying for some far-fetched dream.
From battle gear to a suit&tie looks official
Rojava will be established as an autonomous region of Kurdistan, governed by Kurds.
A united Syria is not good to Israel 😪
There is a reason why Israel is so loved. Globally and historically.
I think you're sorely mistaken. A united Syria by, from and for the people might bring peace and prosperity to their nation. I think most Syrians aren't ready to start another war.
Free Kurdistan ❤🎉
Reality is back after the party
Let the Syrian live peacefully. US & Turki shold leave Syria.
Absolutely not... Jesus... if turkey leaves, Israel will 100% invade Syria.
The cause and foundation of the problem is italy and France Paris,Rome,Napolitano,Napoli,America, Rome,Taranto,Torino,Sardegna?,??
The 100M Kurds in Turkey, Syria, Iraq and Iran should unite have their own country!
It’s Turkiye, not turkey
nope we can call it whatever we want. Its our language.
İt's turkey🦃 you understand?
For all those who are worried about them to have their own country, Montana is I nice place for them to build Kurdistan!
Over 30 million Kurds live in the region. They will have their land eventually!
Turkey is powerless!
They steal the syrian oil
Турция ❤🇹🇷💪
Who ever be the new govt in syria by 2025 must respect the laws of democracy to bring back syria in its old glory unite all citizen what ever their beliefs the govt should be mix of all these tribes.
Great guy. I’d like to see a little trim of the beard.
DW doing what DW always do again. As much as you want to impose a rhetoric, there is no conflict between Turks and Kurds. Türkiye, as a state, fighting against terrorist organization PKK and you know this very well. Calling them the "Kurds" doesn't change the fact that they don't represent or given authority by them. I want to hear your honest opinion about Israel's one sided war in Palestine though. How do you call Israel's enemies? Hamas, jihadists or Palestinians?
@@Runo1923 What a clownish take
@element4element4 yeah, my guy keep consuming DW all day. Reality hits differently.
Türkiye is against Kurdish identity, their language, their culture, their names, town names, street names, mountain names, river names...and their peaceful representatives are in jails. Stop playing terrorist cards, it may convince you because you are brain washed.
Free Palestine
🤣🤣🤣
Better leave Kurdish alone don't forget iran can easy be friends with kurds
Are Syrians going to have free elections?
These kurds are not a part of Syria (except kurds that Syria origin). The demographic map suppose to be like 2011. The best place for kurdistan is Central of Germany, Bavyera, Munih, Frankurt. We support Kurds who want to establish a state in Germany.
😂😂😂
The Kurds will have their land in southern Turkey eventually. Nothing will stop 30 million Kurds.
@@IsabellaCastile-y8y There are nearly 20 million Kurds in Turkiye, and more than half of them are born of Turkish-Kurdish marriages. They see themselves as Turks of Kurdish origin.The other half are assimilated and are loyal to Turkiye.
They have a bigger right to Kurdistan than the Palestinians to a Palestine.
Ok, "Jeff"....terko
What promises were made
Syria finna be like Sudan
once upon the time his now cheering counterpart put a bounty of ten of thousands of dollars $$$$$ on his head... that said all about his counterpart and him...
Ottoman Empire 2 loading...
Partiality: Not Kurdish-backed vs turkish backed. It is US backed vs Turkey backed.
Well first SDF should retreat from the areas that are not Kurdish, and then make a deal with Damascus
First Turkey must retreat... Only then any negotiations will bear fruit....
@Samayil_2024 if all factions of Syria unite under Damascus then who's stopping Turkey and Damascus to jointly take action against them? It's the SDF who needs to compromise
We can make a deal, whole northern Mesopotamia is autochthonous Indo-European peoples lands. Always was.
Afro Semitic Syrian people can unite with Afro Semitic Lebanon-> then they can call their lands Arab republic
ASia(N) is the ancient Indo-European Hellenic term for autochthonous Indo-European West Asian IraniC word & people.
As well as Asian Minor (-> Anatolia) /Northern Mesopotamia and CavcAsia (-> Zagros/Pontus ). CavcAsia literally means in Indo-European mountainous Asia(n)Kurd (KurManc Khord/ Sorani Khord) are Northwest IraniC Indo-European people and always live in West Asia. It’s written in “Greek”(Roman name), in Roman and any other ancient mythology. It’s very easy to prove.
PIE originates in the Indo-European West Asian Near Eastern part of Indo-European West Asia, not the Indo-European West Asian European part.
Indio-European Europe is not a continent of its own- but it’s instead geographically, genetically, linguistically and culturally the most western part of Indo-European West Asia. The other part of Indo-European West Asia is the Indo-European Near East (Anatolia/Northern Mesopotamia and Caucasia (Zagros/Pontus up to Afghanistan/Iran borders).
The Middle East = North Africa + Horn of Africa + Southern part of Southwest Asian peninsula = Afro (Southwest) Asiatic people/areas started from the oldest one in North African, spreading to the Horn of Africa but also to the southern part of the Southwest Asian peninsula up to Southern Mesopotamia where the Afro Semitic live.
@@barand.4950 talk about out of touch from reality 😑
@@komododragon410
You think so.
These are all based on FACTS
SDF has no right to be in Rakka. Rakka is an Arabic town. They are trying to occupy Arab majority region.
So in your logic Turks have nothing to do in Kurdistan (east-Turkey) Kurds are in Majority there!
@@kyaxar3609❤