Okay I was coloring a picture I drew while listening to this(it was on auto play) and all the sudden I heard "stay inside the lines Hailey" and I jumped thinking someone was talk to me(I have the same name)! 😂
SHOPAH0LIC and that's why I don't buy pen liners! I just don't get the point.. they don't last.. if you get maybelline or Nyx gel liners, they last you about 2-3 months with DAILY USE!!
Not for me lol Whenever is starts to dry i just let it sit upside down for a rew minutes and it's like new but I still prefer gel/liquid liners over pens
SHOPAH0LIC I've got the Kat Von D liner, it's really good. But I do store all on my pen liners in a pen upside down, because they were drying out a lot quicker when laid on their side.
I use my Kat Von D tattoo liner basically everyday, and I do huge wings! And it lasts so long! I don't even understand how that's possible but I only had to change my last one after 4/5 months!
Oh Lord, I saw the title, thought it was the eyebrow product, and started praying. Then I realized it was the pen liner and started praying harder 😅 Also, lmao to the number of people who are like "OMG Why you guys don't do a more internationally accessible product?" Number one, Japan month. Number two, now Americans can feel part of the pain of being not American and watching most US gurus. Get over yourselves. Thanks for confirming one of my long held suspicions about Japanese liners, girls! Great vid as always.
Can you do a different style makeup breakup where you leave an eyeliner uncapped to see how long it takes to dry out and how much of the contents evaporate? (by weight), as i think thats how they usually 'run out'
Sits back and waits for some moaning old fart to state that this is inconsistent as not all swatches are the same... Well done ladies! The dedication to your videos is superb.
Maybe the drying up in 3 weeks is more a function of them being open that long? Like maybe there's lots of product that dries up in felt tip liners before you can get it out?
This is my HG liner and I did not expect it to have that many swatches. The only reason I had to buy a new one was because I forgot to properly close the cap and it dried out
Sometime in the future you should definitely compare it with another brand with similar tip and ml's (or grams whatever this one was marked as) that's easily purchased worldwide so there's something to compare it to since this one has set the bar high. I'd be interested to see if anything stands up to it since most I've tried dry up so fast. Another commenter suggested KvD and I'd second that as a contender since it's so popular 👍
Life hack for eyeliner lovers: If the tip of your eyeliner pen loses it's fine tip, you can pull it out with tweezers and most eyeliner pens have another tip on the other end, just pull it out flip it around and put it back in lol, good as new.
Great video guys! I feel for your arms though haha. If you were to say that 1 swatch = 1 eye application (depending on eye size etc) you could potentially get 750+ days out of this eyeliner if you're not fussy about expiration dates/ if it doesn't dry out or go off over that time. Seems like a really good buy!
That's still a decent amount of days that you could potentially get out of it. Do you think you'll try seeing how many swatches you can get out of a gel liner pot at some point?
I'm new to the Beauty News family and I love watching your videos because of your friendship. It reminds me of my own with my best friend. It's so fun to watch!
Does anyone else love the songs ??? Lol I love the third song they play in this one it gets stuck in my head all the time ❤️ I watch way too many of these videos 🙊🙈
Your swatch videos are just sheer awe inspiring dedication. Like, it seems painful. Good on you for putting in the work for actual helpful content! (With beauty news too, obviously. ❤️)
I would love to know if a regular drug store felt tip liner has nearly that much product! (but don't want to ask for your poor arms haha) I am wondering if they have the same amount of product but they just dry out in a few weeks so you can't use it all
vilhelmiina I think they put a tick mark in a note book for every 10 swatches, so at the the end if they had like 64 tick marks they would have 640 swatches, but if they do they would of put 1 tick mark for every 25 swatches in this video. I'm not sure if it's what they do though.
Love these videos, feel like they are so satisfying to watch but also make me think shit it takes forever to get through makeup lol! Also lucky it's winter and you guys can cover your arms after this!!!
hi lady's when you were in japan i hope you bought a couple of backups of that eyeliner it seems to give you so much more i would say it's the eyeliner that keeps on giving well done great video
Ba Be it was an eyeliner not an eyebrow tint. I'm saying that in a helpful hey just letting you know kinda way and not in a bitchy way. I just wanted to clarify as I know tone is hard to decipher in comments sections sometimes, I'm not trying to be a smartass 😊
You had to explain yourself so much in that comment, sad to think that the world has come to a time where everything is "offensive" or someone is "starting trouble".
Mikaela Watson I dont have an "issue" I'm just saying that social media has filled society with more negativity than positivity, in my opinion. I understand your point completely however, they had no need to explain their point in such depth.
Sophie A I explained myself in my original message to clarify what my intention was and avoid unnecessary confrontation or questions. I wanted to make myself clear incase what I said was misinterpreted as mean or bitchy which often happens online where it's hard to tell sometimes whether someone is being helpful and sincere or just being an asshole.
You guys are funny! This is my go to eyeliner pen and it does last a long time plus it dries out fast and doesn't smear. Thanks for doing this! Enjoyed it very much...well, like I do enjoy all your Makeup Breakup videos! Haha
You've changed your method because people were complaining about swatch sizes, now I bet people will go 'Oh you put more pressure on the 46th swatch than the 88th swatch.' IF YOU DO NOT LIKE THE CONTENT DO NOT WATCH THE VIDEO! ishouldstopscreaming
The new Laura Mercier highlighters (I just saw them on Laura Lee's snapchat) have a very interesting texture/pattern pressed onto them and I'm very curious to see if the glow is just an overspray or if they're fully pigmented all the way through. I'd love to see a video on those if you guys are able to get your hands on one
Could you do a how many swatches for a sample sized liquid eyeliner like the Kat Von D or the Stila one. I feel like it would be interesting to compare to a full sized product.
I love it that you got the fuck its toward the end. Wash it off nice? Meh, fuck it. lol... But, I'm buying this now. I usually get a month, two tops out a felt tip liner.
I'm not sure if this was mentioned as I did skip through some of the swatches (to keep my own sanity intact, don't know how you did it, Hailey), my thoughts are that fair enough, you get 1500 odd swatches of liner when its new, but surely it would dry out and die waaaay before someone gets that kind of usage, that or it would go out of date. So although you get tonnes of swatches new, you would never get that usage out of the product, as in my experience, these liners dry out after a few months, so unless you're applying the liner 16 odd times a day, you really wouldn't see that majority of that product. That was very long winded, but hopefully sense was made.
I had this for 2 years and its still black and intense! Only use it for drawing a small tail at the end of my eyes so I don't use much product. Might have to part with it due to hygiene reasons though xD
I have an idea, but it's a lot of work. Lol what if you did a video where you swatch it all at once like this, then used another new one and only did so many swatches a day over time (to simulate how much you'd use on your eyes) and compare to see if the number of swatches changes drastically with time compared to how many swatches you can get with it brand new in one day. And do it for different brands to see which brands dry up faster. 🤔 it'd be awesome in theory to know what brands dry out the fastest, but again, a lot of work. Lmao.
It actually seemed to get blacker as you went on!
Karie Reilly and more blotchy
Okay I was coloring a picture I drew while listening to this(it was on auto play) and all the sudden I heard "stay inside the lines Hailey" and I jumped thinking someone was talk to me(I have the same name)! 😂
😂😂😂
Hailey Riddle lmao that's great
LOL
You should do that with the Kat Von D liner. I swear it runs out after 10 uses.
SHOPAH0LIC and that's why I don't buy pen liners! I just don't get the point.. they don't last.. if you get maybelline or Nyx gel liners, they last you about 2-3 months with DAILY USE!!
Not for me lol Whenever is starts to dry i just let it sit upside down for a rew minutes and it's like new but I still prefer gel/liquid liners over pens
SHOPAH0LIC I've got the Kat Von D liner, it's really good. But I do store all on my pen liners in a pen upside down, because they were drying out a lot quicker when laid on their side.
Just store it upside down! (:
I use my Kat Von D tattoo liner basically everyday, and I do huge wings! And it lasts so long! I don't even understand how that's possible but I only had to change my last one after 4/5 months!
When you got to 400 and there was still over half the video left I started praying for your arm
Shauna Dawson lmao
Oh Lord, I saw the title, thought it was the eyebrow product, and started praying. Then I realized it was the pen liner and started praying harder 😅
Also, lmao to the number of people who are like "OMG Why you guys don't do a more internationally accessible product?" Number one, Japan month. Number two, now Americans can feel part of the pain of being not American and watching most US gurus. Get over yourselves.
Thanks for confirming one of my long held suspicions about Japanese liners, girls! Great vid as always.
Junlan Li 🙌🏻
🙌🏻
Can you do a different style makeup breakup where you leave an eyeliner uncapped to see how long it takes to dry out and how much of the contents evaporate? (by weight), as i think thats how they usually 'run out'
Favorite quote "If you ever feel it is drying up, shake it and regret it the rest of your life"😂
I've only been watching since the flower lipstick video but already, I admire your dedication...
Dream Discovery me 2
Sits back and waits for some moaning old fart to state that this is inconsistent as not all swatches are the same...
Well done ladies! The dedication to your videos is superb.
Bryony Wilson LOL! I thought the same thing!
do the kim k contour sticks please!!!
Lizzie Bone it would be one of their shortest videos 😂
😂 damn the shade!!! Dem sticks are stingy though
yess!!!
It has 12 uses in it. 12.
Lizzie Bone they got one so a video will be coming soon ? Woohoo 🙌
Maybe the drying up in 3 weeks is more a function of them being open that long? Like maybe there's lots of product that dries up in felt tip liners before you can get it out?
This is my HG liner and I did not expect it to have that many swatches. The only reason I had to buy a new one was because I forgot to properly close the cap and it dried out
I just love how dedicated you ladies are!! You rock!! 🤘❤
Btw, I miss seeing ur gorgeous faces in the intro/outro. 🙄
SAME!!!
Sometime in the future you should definitely compare it with another brand with similar tip and ml's (or grams whatever this one was marked as) that's easily purchased worldwide so there's something to compare it to since this one has set the bar high. I'd be interested to see if anything stands up to it since most I've tried dry up so fast. Another commenter suggested KvD and I'd second that as a contender since it's so popular 👍
Yall are seriously gonna fuck up your arms lol. Love the vid tho
well... makeup packages say to test it on skin first hahaha
Life hack for eyeliner lovers: If the tip of your eyeliner pen loses it's fine tip, you can pull it out with tweezers and most eyeliner pens have another tip on the other end, just pull it out flip it around and put it back in lol, good as new.
Kat Von D tattoo liner please!
Great video guys! I feel for your arms though haha. If you were to say that 1 swatch = 1 eye application (depending on eye size etc) you could potentially get 750+ days out of this eyeliner if you're not fussy about expiration dates/ if it doesn't dry out or go off over that time. Seems like a really good buy!
As a winged liner wearer you would probably need closer to 3-4 swatches per eye
That's still a decent amount of days that you could potentially get out of it. Do you think you'll try seeing how many swatches you can get out of a gel liner pot at some point?
you should do a how many swatches in a nyx soft matte! I always feel like they come empty
This is what I call dedication to your craft! I would have given up so quickly, props to you lovely ladies! xx
I'm new to the Beauty News family and I love watching your videos because of your friendship. It reminds me of my own with my best friend. It's so fun to watch!
You guys have so much patience & dedication to do these videos, I couldn't do it!
You should try the Stila "putty" highlighter. I feel like this product would mostly be made of corn starch?
Girls you were brave :). I wonder how long did it take to film this video
+julia kleczkowska about an hour and forty five minutes ☺️
Does anyone else love the songs ??? Lol I love the third song they play in this one it gets stuck in my head all the time ❤️ I watch way too many of these videos 🙊🙈
Your swatch videos are just sheer awe inspiring dedication. Like, it seems painful. Good on you for putting in the work for actual helpful content! (With beauty news too, obviously. ❤️)
I would love to know if a regular drug store felt tip liner has nearly that much product! (but don't want to ask for your poor arms haha) I am wondering if they have the same amount of product but they just dry out in a few weeks so you can't use it all
We will do a maybelline one in a few months time to compare
you can also just swatch on paper!
Amanda Patterson maybelline master precise works like a charm and it lasts a looong time.
Laura roman mine's kinda running out and I barely use it.
how do you not lose count while doing this??😅
vilhelmiina I think they put a tick mark in a note book for every 10 swatches, so at the the end if they had like 64 tick marks they would have 640 swatches, but if they do they would of put 1 tick mark for every 25 swatches in this video. I'm not sure if it's what they do though.
“It’s fatter than I expected!” I have used that line before to honey 🤣❤️
Your dedication is amazing! But your poor arms! 😱💪🏻
Love these videos, feel like they are so satisfying to watch but also make me think shit it takes forever to get through makeup lol!
Also lucky it's winter and you guys can cover your arms after this!!!
Obsessed w you guys. Listen to you in the car every morning💞
I love love love this eyeliner! My HG for sure
This channel is the reason I'm into makeup :)
hi lady's when you were in japan i hope you bought a couple of backups of that eyeliner it seems to give you so much more i would say it's the eyeliner that keeps on giving well done great video
There is so much in it. Wow 😳 I have to say it looked more like you were swatching a black marker rather than a eyebrow tint
Ba Be it was an eyeliner not an eyebrow tint. I'm saying that in a helpful hey just letting you know kinda way and not in a bitchy way. I just wanted to clarify as I know tone is hard to decipher in comments sections sometimes, I'm not trying to be a smartass 😊
You had to explain yourself so much in that comment, sad to think that the world has come to a time where everything is "offensive" or someone is "starting trouble".
Sophie A ??? It's sad that the world has come to a place where people are trying to be nicer to eachother?? I don't understand what your issue is?
Mikaela Watson I dont have an "issue" I'm just saying that social media has filled society with more negativity than positivity, in my opinion. I understand your point completely however, they had no need to explain their point in such depth.
Sophie A I explained myself in my original message to clarify what my intention was and avoid unnecessary confrontation or questions. I wanted to make myself clear incase what I said was misinterpreted as mean or bitchy which often happens online where it's hard to tell sometimes whether someone is being helpful and sincere or just being an asshole.
i love waking up to beauty news!!
Does anyone else try to guess how many swatches they'll get out of a product before the video starts? Or am I just sad and needing a life? 😂
Georgina P I do. 😂 I never get it right either.
JoAnn Wilson I'm always wayyyy out lol 😂😂
You guys are funny! This is my go to eyeliner pen and it does last a long time plus it dries out fast and doesn't smear. Thanks for doing this! Enjoyed it very much...well, like I do enjoy all your Makeup Breakup videos! Haha
I love those videos! They're so relaxing and almost like meditation ♥
Is there any way to find out which song(s) you use in the sped up parts?
That saw!!! 😂 Yet another beaut video ladies! ♡ keep em coming!
kkw contour sticks!
Adrianna Delacruz I predict 5 swatches
Evelin Delgadillo me too friend
After the eyeshadow one this one took it to another level holy shit lmao I need this eyeliner 😩 you guys are insane
We didn't expect to last this long haha
You've changed your method because people were complaining about swatch sizes, now I bet people will go 'Oh you put more pressure on the 46th swatch than the 88th swatch.' IF YOU DO NOT LIKE THE CONTENT DO NOT WATCH THE VIDEO! ishouldstopscreaming
I tried doing swatches with a cheap eyeliner pen and I gave up when I reached around 100. You girls are heroes for doing this lmao
The new Laura Mercier highlighters (I just saw them on Laura Lee's snapchat) have a very interesting texture/pattern pressed onto them and I'm very curious to see if the glow is just an overspray or if they're fully pigmented all the way through. I'd love to see a video on those if you guys are able to get your hands on one
You guys deserve some kind of special award!!! 👑💲🔱
Also why was Haley the only one doing swatches at first? Did she lose a bet or something? LOL!
Orleidis Lozada I think it was because on one of the swatching videos Kat's arm had a reaction to the product the were swatching.
+Orleidis Lozada I just started swatching and we swapped when my arm started to hurt
You can literally wear this eyeliner every day for two years straight
I have one like that though its an Avon product... once it started drying out I began using it to do my eyebrows... works nicely though like that
How long did it end up taking to get the eyeliner off your arm?
Also just wanted to say I love your videos!
Love from Canada!
+EmilyCwen used a proper oil cleanser when I got home and that took the rest off ☺️
Could you please please do how many swatches in the kkw contour sticks
OOOOOOOOO PLEASE test how much is in those big Marc Jacobs bronzers!
I want to try one but Im curious to see how deep the pan actually is!
I COULD'VE EATEN THAT EYELINER!
Then buy one and eat it
BEAUTY NEWS I will.
Could you do a how many swatches for a sample sized liquid eyeliner like the Kat Von D or the Stila one. I feel like it would be interesting to compare to a full sized product.
Why did it get darker as time went on
I think because it was upside down that more product came to the tip
Holy c- u got a saw out. 😳 dedication. Hats off ladies.
I love it that you got the fuck its toward the end. Wash it off nice? Meh, fuck it. lol... But, I'm buying this now. I usually get a month, two tops out a felt tip liner.
Can't tell if you love us or you just really hate yourselves, this seems awful lmao. Great video
Can you do the maybelline studio gel liner??
Well, guess what I got on my business trip to Japan last week... 😊 This video was literally my buying guide.
AHHH IM SO EXCITED
That's one heck of an eyeliner! 😊👍
Can you do the Maybelline Master Precise or just any drugstore eyeliner
We have one set aside but we will probably do that one in a couple of months. It's boring doing the same thing too close together
Kkw contour stick, pls??
Millie Moo it won't even make it to 10 lol
I'm still dying for how much usable product is in the new Morphe setting spray!
I love you beauty news
The fact that your arm is bright red at the end shows amazing dedication 😱😂
I for one appreciate your sacrifices for us! 💜💜💜TFS💜💜💜
I need to buy one, I'm pretty sure I would die before using it up! LOL
I'm not sure if this was mentioned as I did skip through some of the swatches (to keep my own sanity intact, don't know how you did it, Hailey), my thoughts are that fair enough, you get 1500 odd swatches of liner when its new, but surely it would dry out and die waaaay before someone gets that kind of usage, that or it would go out of date. So although you get tonnes of swatches new, you would never get that usage out of the product, as in my experience, these liners dry out after a few months, so unless you're applying the liner 16 odd times a day, you really wouldn't see that majority of that product.
That was very long winded, but hopefully sense was made.
Does it have a matte or shiny finish?
I love you guys! Love all you videos! Your personalities are great! Would love to meet you 💜💜🦄🦄
I got to 1200 and saw how long left to go... I NEVER would have guessed that! Thank you Hailey for sacrificing your poor arm. Also your shower hahah
this is my go-to eyeliner for 8 years
You should do the Maybelline instant age rewind eraser dark circles. It seems like the product gets wasted in the sponge
Lol did anyone else think "Stay in your line!" When she said stay in the lines?
Pls do this with the fenty flyliner xx
Haleys arm will have stripes on it forever. I loved Kats hope that it was running out. Can you do a makeup breakup on mascara?
I had this for 2 years and its still black and intense! Only use it for drawing a small tail at the end of my eyes so I don't use much product. Might have to part with it due to hygiene reasons though xD
how swatches does a blush have .. plz do that video
If I were to do this after about 10 I would be bored and want to give up
EVERYTHING YOU DO IS GENIUS!!!! Gold!! Really tho love you guys! Sorry I got a "little out of fucking control there" :D
I swear after so long it got darker and more pigmented😂*cue manny*
This is dedication
Do the Kim k contour stick !!!
You guys are troopers holy shit
Thanks for the amazing content!!!!
Was that an unintentional eyeliner pun at 2:39 😂😏❤️
Do the new Mac roll on liner thing
How many mls were in there?
Can you tell me how much the eyeliner cost and where I can get it?
Link in description
BEAUTY NEWS thank you
Hell, I need to invest in some of these. I'll be flying high the rest of my life at that rate.
I have an idea, but it's a lot of work. Lol what if you did a video where you swatch it all at once like this, then used another new one and only did so many swatches a day over time (to simulate how much you'd use on your eyes) and compare to see if the number of swatches changes drastically with time compared to how many swatches you can get with it brand new in one day. And do it for different brands to see which brands dry up faster. 🤔 it'd be awesome in theory to know what brands dry out the fastest, but again, a lot of work. Lmao.
Amber George It's not very practical. It may takes months or even a year to make one vid.
Tina.xyxiao I reiterated twice it was a lot of work. I acknowledge that. I just think it'd be pretty interesting, so I threw it out there.
lol claim that fart as if it was your own lmao that was the highlight of this video
I thought this was the tattoo eyebrow tint until about halfway through the video when I actually read the whole title lol
You should do Kim k contour stick🙏🏻
bet this is literally hell to do these!!
So much product !!
That little saw! What is that actually for?
sawing wood
I love how you say EYELINER!!!!!!!!!!
yeah we say it like eyeliner
it's a lovely accent LOL!
Oh my! The more you swatched the blacker it went 😫
Could you please do this with a Maybelline liner so we can compare? 😊
We do have one set aside and we will do it in a couple of months x
Yay!