RUSSIAN CARRIER SUNK - HARPOON MISSILES SCORE DIRECT HITS | Cold Waters Mission Gameplay

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 544

  • @studinthemaking
    @studinthemaking 7 років тому +516

    I still can't believe that USSR actually built that. It's some thing from a sci-if. Movie.

    • @Livd8-y8d
      @Livd8-y8d 7 років тому +100

      It's still smaller than a Nimitz though

    • @Livd8-y8d
      @Livd8-y8d 7 років тому +91

      And less advanced

    • @cranedigiangaming6113
      @cranedigiangaming6113 7 років тому +7

      studinthemaking really was I the only one who saw sci-if

    • @workingonanames
      @workingonanames 7 років тому +13

      Topsideneptune117 because reasons

    • @toomuchforanything3274
      @toomuchforanything3274 7 років тому

      studinthemaking well nothing is impossible as I say it XD

  • @arkamun1659
    @arkamun1659 6 років тому +179

    *Contact faded*
    Raptor:You gotta be kidding me that would be so loud the sonar operator would be throwing his headset off
    Me: Thats why the contact faded

    • @LukeRen-rl4yv
      @LukeRen-rl4yv 5 років тому +6

      *a s u d d e n l a c k o f e a r s*

  • @Hunpecked
    @Hunpecked 7 років тому +261

    Either Raptor's playing on "easy" level, or the Soviet ships are captained by The Three Stooges. :-)

    • @henkrearden4282
      @henkrearden4282 6 років тому +23

      Hunpecked or Soviet captains have been drinking too much vodka

    • @JakeAikens
      @JakeAikens 5 років тому +4

      Yeah, three blind mice.

    • @benkemper4606
      @benkemper4606 4 роки тому +3

      Hunpecked or the stupidest people in the world

    • @communismisgreat1482
      @communismisgreat1482 4 роки тому +3

      Nah they are just too hungry

    • @TonySpike
      @TonySpike 3 роки тому +4

      Actually its because raptor has "purposfully" hidden his submarine within the noise of each ships engines, they know he is their, but are not certain where and dont wanna guess

  • @Raptoria
    @Raptoria  7 років тому +129

    This was CRAZY and hilarious. Bunch o' laughs and a successful attack on a massive carrier. Awesome! Thanks for watching and suggest some more scenarios.

    • @atlantis2933
      @atlantis2933 7 років тому +3

      i live in Riga

    • @yaboipalps8616
      @yaboipalps8616 7 років тому +2

      Atlantis well you just got wrecked

    • @vpsniper995
      @vpsniper995 7 років тому

      great vid
      ! continue the great work! but plz do moe men of war!

    • @JakeTheTankmaster
      @JakeTheTankmaster 7 років тому

      almost a 200k sub's!

    • @killman369547
      @killman369547 7 років тому +1

      +Raptor. helpful tip for missiles, if a ship is running away from you ignore the aiming dot and set the missile's enable point (blue box you move around) behind the ship, the seeker will do the rest

  • @ZzDeathImpactzZ
    @ZzDeathImpactzZ 7 років тому +122

    Raptor, when are you going to realise that firing at the blue dot is a freaking bad idea? you gotta fire at that blue dot but closer so your damn weapon can activate and search before it get on top of your target and start searching.

  • @jeffburnham6611
    @jeffburnham6611 6 років тому +19

    Cheese whiz lol. Never heard it called that before. The CIWS (Close In Weapon System) is usually called a Sea Whiz.

  • @Augur21
    @Augur21 7 років тому +79

    Did...Did you play the tutorial?

  • @thatstatefarmguy480
    @thatstatefarmguy480 7 років тому +173

    Good god, this gameplay is so hard to watch hahaha "let's surface with an enemy ship 100 yards from us". Sub warfare at its best.

    • @Raptoria
      @Raptoria  7 років тому +18

      +Jacob Marshall Its a fun game, highly recommended.

    • @thatstatefarmguy480
      @thatstatefarmguy480 7 років тому +20

      Raptor it looks like it! Naval warfare is one of my favorite subjects. Im liking the gameplay, keep up the good stuff!

    • @steedm1093
      @steedm1093 6 років тому +6

      LOL it made me cringe, especially since Im formerly trained in ASW during my tenure aboard the USS Roosevelt DDG80.

    • @JurzGarz
      @JurzGarz 6 років тому +8

      In my experience playing the game, this is a suicidal move.

    • @JurzGarz
      @JurzGarz 6 років тому +1

      In my experience playing the game, this is a suicidal move.

  • @t10god
    @t10god 7 років тому +8

    _"Okay so it's morning time, just complete some repairs..."_ Oh okay, it seemed like you were straight up sinking last night but I guess what doesn't kill you makes you stronger ;P

  • @OddDreams101
    @OddDreams101 7 років тому +59

    Raptor. The blue dot is for UNGUIDED TORPEDOES. Not HARPOONS.

    • @xxtrousasnakexx5362
      @xxtrousasnakexx5362 5 років тому +4

      OddDreams101 That blue dot is me , any unrecognized contacts will show up as white dots

  • @Wanderer628
    @Wanderer628 7 років тому +174

    Fun fact, HMS Conqueror is the only nuclear sub to kill an enemy ship.

    • @Raptoria
      @Raptoria  7 років тому +43

      +Wanderer628 oh in the falklands?

    • @Rimasta1
      @Rimasta1 7 років тому +45

      Raptor Yup. The Conqueror sank the ARA General Belgrano, a former US Navy light cruiser of the Brooklyn-class that was then the USS Phoenix. The Phoenix saw action from the Japanese raid in Pearl Harbor on December 7th, to various battles around the Pacific including the Battle of Leyte Gulf in which she fired a spread of torpedoes and is credited with helping sink the Japanese battleship Yamashiro.

    • @Hairysteed
      @Hairysteed 6 років тому +17

      ...with WW2 unguided torpedoes no less!

    • @taylor7772
      @taylor7772 6 років тому +23

      I know some Argentinian friends that are still pissed from that

    • @LucioFercho
      @LucioFercho 6 років тому +17

      Yeah, but those argentinian were quite incompetent, the ASW escorts were pretty much useless and the CL wasnt even buttoned up while cruising through a combat zone, the SSN got time to call home, ask for permission, wait for them to make up their mind and then sink her... a sitting duck.
      I am pretty sure that crew had had tougher sinkex...

  • @testuser1337
    @testuser1337 7 років тому +3

    The massive amount of incompetence broke the ai lol. Nice.

  • @呂其樂
    @呂其樂 6 років тому +4

    The most hilarious submarine warfare I've ever seen lol

  • @frogsshadow4189
    @frogsshadow4189 7 років тому +22

    The harpoons are really fast. You need to fire them so that they go active behind the ship or it won't hit. The blue circle is where you need to target for unguided torps.

  • @shawhavy
    @shawhavy 7 років тому +38

    when firing the harpoon the blue box is when it goes active you shot passed them

  • @joshrasmussen4002
    @joshrasmussen4002 4 роки тому +1

    Raptor : he took 2 torpedo's , wow!
    Bismarck: am I a joke to you

  • @legendaryletsplays1355
    @legendaryletsplays1355 7 років тому +13

    You have to aim before the contact on the map so the missiles have time to lock on, and when firing torpedoes you have to aim a bit before the blue box, for the same reason.

  • @rugerdern1554
    @rugerdern1554 7 років тому +1

    Your commentary is hilarious!!!!

  • @martytheanimator6426
    @martytheanimator6426 7 років тому +79

    Iron Armenian is crying elsewhere as one of his many carriers for landing various planes on has been sunk by Raptor.

  • @whostolemypassport9478
    @whostolemypassport9478 7 років тому +8

    21:27 Riga is my home City

  • @nicholasogburn7746
    @nicholasogburn7746 6 років тому

    Thumbs up for Dead Dawn joke. That made me smile, man!

  • @lostcanadian1240
    @lostcanadian1240 5 років тому +4

    The aircraft is actually a TU-142 Bear F

  • @bp_cherryblossomtree723
    @bp_cherryblossomtree723 7 років тому +125

    The ship is sinking!
    every even likes are survivor
    odd likes died

  • @OneJazzKid
    @OneJazzKid 6 років тому +4

    I guess these Soviets really are fans. They should...sub.

  • @RinCat
    @RinCat 7 років тому +16

    It seems a bug... 2 ships stopped on you top.

    • @snp117
      @snp117 6 років тому

      i think it's not a bug, those two ships switch to passive sonar to ear the subs, i guess because the active sonar "ping" in front... so they stop to ear the sub... (those ships haven't got towed aray so stop is the best solution...)

    • @uteriel282
      @uteriel282 5 років тому +1

      @@snp117
      the active sonar of those ships should have gotten him a long time ago.
      they also wouldnt come close.
      the moment they think a sub is at a certain lokation they fire torps or send helis to drop more sonars or torps.
      thats at least as far as my experience with this game goes.

  • @macanix8072
    @macanix8072 7 років тому +67

    LMAO... Reality Level - Zero

    • @kathylessard604
      @kathylessard604 6 років тому

      Shut up

    • @hanfei6871
      @hanfei6871 6 років тому +1

      @@kathylessard604it's a bad sim, own it

    • @codenamehalo9847
      @codenamehalo9847 6 років тому +3

      HanFei have you ever seen a simulator ever be realistic?

    • @robertharris6092
      @robertharris6092 5 років тому +1

      @@codenamehalo9847 its called rising storm red orchestra 2.

    • @thesauc33
      @thesauc33 5 років тому +1

      @@robertharris6092 lmao Rising Storm? Realistic? hahahaha right buddy. Only thing realistic about it is ttk. Really fun game, though.

  • @metanumia
    @metanumia 5 років тому

    @Raptor you fired your harpoons at the estimated bearing point of the Kiev carrier, meaning they only enabled their sensors after they flew past the Kiev, that's why they flew off to the right and then crashed into the water. With harpoons, you need significant distance (at least 5-10 kilometers) between your sub and the target vessel, and have your weapon enable its sensors *before* it reaches the enemy target vessel by stretching the targeting line of the weapon far enough from your sub that it turns from red to green and then click on the map on a point located between your sub and the target's position.
    Same thing goes for torpedoes, if the targeted enemy vessel is sailing *away* from you and you click the target mark past the enemy ship then torpedo will *overshoot* the target and *then* activate its sonar past the target vessel. If the targeted enemy vessel is coming at your sub, then clicking the torpedo target marker on the enemy vessel's estimated bearing point on the map (blue circle with blue square inside it) will make the torpedo enable sensors right under the targeted vessel. So, it's best to have all sub-launched weapons (harpoons and torpedoes) enable their sensors *before* they reach the intended target, so click the target marker with the left mouse button at a position on the map behind the enemy vessel you're targeting so the weapon's sensors will enable before it reaches the enemy ship.

  • @Shinno.-.
    @Shinno.-. 7 років тому +53

    You calling the CIWS "cheese wiz" makes me cringe. Every. Time. Lol

  • @Free_Tha_Willy
    @Free_Tha_Willy 3 роки тому

    Straight beast man!! Love your videos and the way you narrate. Keep up the good work 👍🏾

  • @ShadowRhapsody81
    @ShadowRhapsody81 6 років тому

    at the 13:19 part the "Contact evaded? oh man that'd be so loud the sonar operator would be throwing off his headphones" ...
    that might be 'why' it evaded >.<
    Sonar Operator: "F-this noise!!!!!" *rips headset off*
    Captain: "Where is it?!?"
    Sonar Operator: "strait up, but beyond that hell if im going to know!"

  • @ghost_ship_supreme
    @ghost_ship_supreme 6 років тому +1

    The second their radar hit his con mast, they changed course straight for him. (The blue lines). But if they somehow didn't, the second he fired his torpedoes, his stealth was gone. Staying hidden in this game is very hard.
    And for those curious, yellow = sonar, blue = radar, and purple = ESM

    • @nathandamaren2093
      @nathandamaren2093 5 років тому +1

      Russian sailors had to remain home due to being sent to gulag and the Kremlin tasked numerous fishing vessel crew to take over the navy ships with 1 hour of non sober training.

  • @guardianmaster2142
    @guardianmaster2142 7 років тому

    good startegy raptor!

  • @hike3
    @hike3 7 років тому

    Raptor finds the best games lol

  • @ness4705
    @ness4705 7 років тому

    14:10 yes my comrades are HUGE fans of you!

    • @ness4705
      @ness4705 7 років тому

      LOYAL TO COMRADE TILL THE END!!!!

  • @Pat_Scratchers
    @Pat_Scratchers 5 років тому +1

    the blue square is where the weapons go active, so when you place missile squares past the target they dont go active till they pass the target. you need top place the blue squares in a direction where they go active and see the ship then turn into the target. you might want to watch jivturkey and his coldwaters cast.

  • @joshuacrim3041
    @joshuacrim3041 7 років тому +12

    Awesome video man, keep it up. just a few suggestions: using harpoons you need to ignore the lead PIP and basically just aim towards the ship but not too close because the missile needs time to pick up the ship once it hits search mode. also I never see you use regular ballast (C and E keys), might help you surface and dive faster?

  • @robertlaube574
    @robertlaube574 2 роки тому

    I love the fire burning invisible ships, such realism. Psh.

  • @AugustGreen_
    @AugustGreen_ 5 років тому

    "I don't know how how to pronounce em but I do know how to sink 'em."
    -Every Submarine Captain, Ever.

  • @TriggerLRSSG
    @TriggerLRSSG 7 років тому +6

    It will be nice if you can sink Admiral Kuznetsov in this game. I tried that in Falcon BMS and it's not easy.

  • @ibizenco
    @ibizenco 7 років тому +14

    Putin's not gonna be happy about this.

    • @pineli6752
      @pineli6752 4 роки тому +1

      More like Leonid Brezhnev.

  • @s.jwilliams5741
    @s.jwilliams5741 6 років тому

    Aviation cruiser. Great vid

  • @jasonferguson4247
    @jasonferguson4247 7 років тому

    Got yourself a new subscriber. Great video.

  • @bungeezombie6189
    @bungeezombie6189 4 роки тому

    Yay. Destroyer has a bunch of subscribers on it

  • @evolgenius1150
    @evolgenius1150 3 роки тому

    Do u still have to "make" your target by identifying it's audio signature in order to get a firing solution like in Red Storm Rising?

  • @stewartjmurray
    @stewartjmurray 7 років тому +10

    That was a bug or a glitch those ships would have detected you.

    • @snp117
      @snp117 6 років тому +4

      not a bug bro... active sonar ping in front, plus, the sub is between those 2 ships so they are confuse.... they switch to passive sonar but the sub stop moving... they ear the other ship, not the sub because he are less noisy...

    • @57thorns
      @57thorns 6 років тому +3

      @@snp117 That is a possible explanation. I would love to hear Jive Turkey explain his in a whiteboard video....
      But it is possible to hide in the wake of a surface ship, the problem here is that the Russian escorts just sits there.... too close to use weapons.

    • @Hutcho72
      @Hutcho72 5 років тому +1

      @@57thorns Yep I used to hide in the wake of the ships in Red Storm Rising where possible, or I would have my Torpedoes approach from the rear of surface ships, and indeed Submarines and hit them from behind.
      Nothing like hitting a sub or ship from behind, and blowing the prop shaft seals.

    • @TonySpike
      @TonySpike 3 роки тому

      Actually it was a classic case of raptor "accidentally" hiding in the prop noise (baffles) of the two ships, they needed the confirmation of him firing harpoons to find him hence why they waited till then to start attacking, they knew he was their, just didnt know where

  • @starbugmechanic5236
    @starbugmechanic5236 6 років тому

    The water looks great

  • @daividcandido339
    @daividcandido339 4 роки тому

    Muy bueno
    Saludos desde 🇺🇾 Uruguay

  • @johnstockdale6881
    @johnstockdale6881 6 років тому

    hey this game is great and yes i am a us navy veteren myself first claas petty officer and this game is great and i cant wait for more from you

  • @masondavidfromtheusblackop6092
    @masondavidfromtheusblackop6092 7 років тому +7

    WAIT THE USSTR BUILT A SHIP.....THAT FLOATS!!!

  • @JosephBrown-hk3sp
    @JosephBrown-hk3sp 7 років тому

    o7 to good job on that carrier and the other two ships!

  • @Karinrinkashi
    @Karinrinkashi 5 років тому

    How much compressed air do these torpedoes have?

  • @Kadaj616
    @Kadaj616 7 років тому

    "What are they going to do ? Get out a hand gun and shoot at it ? - Those words I will remember for the rest of my life !!!

  • @horsebecrazy2928
    @horsebecrazy2928 7 років тому

    Raptor high subbed and turned notifications on

  • @capnye6580
    @capnye6580 7 років тому

    Kiev got me like 3 times until I have figured out how to take her and her escort down without getting hit. This skip got her as if it's nothing. Good job! Maybe I should try the technique of sailing right beneath the enemy fleet and surprise attack them front their 6!

  • @airplanemaniacgaming7877
    @airplanemaniacgaming7877 7 років тому

    those tupolev TU-95 bears are a dangerous long ranger bomber. also able to be used as scout planes due to the range capability they have. the USSR made some beautiful weapons in the cold war. beautiful.

  • @pjscudder7124
    @pjscudder7124 7 років тому

    This is the first video I have seen of yours and I think you great and tell people the game

    • @Raptoria
      @Raptoria  7 років тому

      +M.I.O_and_PJ Scudder Thanks!

  • @Lord_Shadowz
    @Lord_Shadowz 6 років тому

    Lol. I’m dying. Raptor kept his mast up for a full minute. I don’t understand how 20 torpedos weren’t incoming. I can’t imagine how they didn’t pinpoint him?? What’s the general rule for keeping the mast up? I think it’s less than 15 seconds?

  • @chuckdeg5267
    @chuckdeg5267 3 роки тому

    Those Russian ships are using tactics against you. The plane dropped that torpedo to scare you into maneuvers that would reveal your location and the ship was " sprint and drifting" you. Ship charges at your perceived location then cuts engines and drifts listening to sonar hoping you will bolt and evade. That's good EI

  • @karagothshlomidabush3727
    @karagothshlomidabush3727 5 років тому

    AWESOME ! THOSE ARE LIKE CHEAT MODE TORPEDOES LOL

  • @skakpedersen
    @skakpedersen 6 років тому

    Good show!

  • @gunksmtn
    @gunksmtn 3 роки тому

    so if theyre like 1km away like that dd and they active ping you, that doesnt mean they know you're there? Trying to understand what to do when the yellow lines pop

  • @ChucktownNights
    @ChucktownNights 7 років тому +4

    The sonar ID lines have to be exact.

  • @laurelworth720
    @laurelworth720 4 роки тому +1

    Wonder what year this takes place IN the cold war

  • @tb87670
    @tb87670 5 років тому +1

    How did sailors on those ships not see your periscope so close to their ships? And then missiles come out of the water right next to their boat! I bet a few of those guys on the decks of those boats wish they wore their brown pants. I have been watching these vids and thought about buying the game for a while but this is the vid that sold it, I gotta do this now.

  • @nonerdshere
    @nonerdshere 7 років тому +1

    The reason your harpoons doesn't work is because you need to put them right on the ship that way they have time to track the target if you have the ship moving left to right or right to left then you need to lead the target. hope you read this!

  • @Marcus51090
    @Marcus51090 6 років тому +1

    In reality the U.K. ministry of defence describe this class as the floating hulk it’s old under powered, under armed with primitive weapons and is literally rusting to death etc and is not considered a major threat.

    • @boiboiboi1419
      @boiboiboi1419 5 років тому

      ciws and s300 on board is not primitive, kiev class carrier can go toe to toe with a destroyer without escorts

  • @ebenitez2011
    @ebenitez2011 6 років тому

    You should’ve put some more distance between yourself and the escort vessels… When you launched the harpoon missiles that close, You essentially notified them of your position

  • @EscapeTheCloudsOfficial
    @EscapeTheCloudsOfficial 6 років тому

    "It's not going to be Red Dawn. It's going to be a Dead Dawn." LMAO.

  • @sandcobra
    @sandcobra 7 років тому +6

    be cool if you could play as the other ships also
    been looking for modern

    • @MovingTargetOne
      @MovingTargetOne 3 роки тому

      Sea Power: Naval combat in the missile age, coming soon

  • @thefrenchtransit3236
    @thefrenchtransit3236 6 років тому

    What is the key to speed up the time?

  • @dragonalpha9894
    @dragonalpha9894 5 років тому

    Where to you get this game?

  • @antonibratasz6777
    @antonibratasz6777 7 років тому

    which mission is it

  • @cmdrpanorpa8631
    @cmdrpanorpa8631 7 років тому

    Don't forget to like and subscribe! Great fun watching you play this game. A multiplayer game mode of this would be epic so you could sink some friends, that would be such a laugh.

  • @SmartassX1
    @SmartassX1 5 років тому

    That 1 ship stopping next to you, seemingly "as a fan" is actually pretty realistic. The "Soviet Union" was actually just Russia occupying a bunch of nations, so it's reasonable to assume that some ships (and many army units) would defect to fight the russians.

  • @juddandrada8093
    @juddandrada8093 7 років тому

    I wondered when he would post another video of Cold Waters. I love this game!

  • @neuromotorspecificsinterna4618
    @neuromotorspecificsinterna4618 6 років тому

    Which part of campaign u encounter carrier?

    • @snp117
      @snp117 6 років тому

      it's random moments bru but there is a career on mission, not in the campaign

  • @bugs9284
    @bugs9284 6 років тому

    how do you get to fight that

  • @neom472
    @neom472 7 років тому

    Great content

  • @skyserf
    @skyserf 6 років тому

    Which mission is this?

  • @williammartin9384
    @williammartin9384 7 років тому

    Yo falter just wanted to say keep up the good work And didn't know there was aircraft carriers in this game

  • @cmdrpanorpa8631
    @cmdrpanorpa8631 7 років тому

    Shouldn't you fire your torpedos before the blue dots because that is where the ship is going to be? Or are they a lead sight that tells you where to fire to have best chance of hitting the target?

  • @handersolo4573
    @handersolo4573 7 років тому +2

    the circle in front of the enemy is where you aim with none tracking torpedo not with missiles and tracking torpederes

  • @alphawolffestudios1169
    @alphawolffestudios1169 6 років тому

    15:50 WAIT COMRADE RAPTOR DO NOT KILL US!!

  • @michaelbarnwell1065
    @michaelbarnwell1065 7 років тому

    What type of sub did he use

  • @donniemontoya9300
    @donniemontoya9300 7 років тому

    When you're looking at a ship through the periscope, press "i" to identify the ship. It's a 100% accurate identification and boosts the solution to 95%. Also stop firing weapons at the blue prediction circle. Aim them just before so the weapon activate and start it's search pattern.

  • @stum99
    @stum99 7 років тому +9

    Lets 'get ready' to stop saying 'get ready' every five seconds!

    • @Raptoria
      @Raptoria  7 років тому +3

      +E ntertheQ getting ready to get ready on that

  • @KYLE1630
    @KYLE1630 7 років тому

    What's this mission called?

  • @JoaoVictor-zx8zf
    @JoaoVictor-zx8zf 7 років тому

    hey man, what is button of ''FastTime'' ? > 18:38

    • @JoaoVictor-zx8zf
      @JoaoVictor-zx8zf 7 років тому

      Aditya Shrawat Thx, I found... "Time depression" 😀😉

  • @franklyndrossevelt3012
    @franklyndrossevelt3012 4 роки тому

    Is there some tutorials in this game?

  • @ebenitez2011
    @ebenitez2011 6 років тому

    I think The escort vessels were trying to do a protective screening tactic kind a like a sacrifice maneuver in case they detect more torpedoes in the water heading towards their carrier

  • @ikrarbarca3520
    @ikrarbarca3520 6 років тому

    raptor,i wanna ask. how you download this game?

  • @blastdude89
    @blastdude89 7 років тому

    Really entertaining !
    Subbed

  • @bigbonede6201
    @bigbonede6201 6 років тому

    what game?

  • @willynthepoorboys2
    @willynthepoorboys2 4 роки тому

    The carrier alone had a compliment of 1200-1600 naval personal ( including air wing ), A huge loss of life on that day.

  • @Eurodance_Groove
    @Eurodance_Groove 5 років тому

    What game is this one ? Is it a mod for U-Boot ?

  • @cuddiejulian
    @cuddiejulian 7 років тому

    I don't even know what this is but it was pretty cool

  • @Viper555
    @Viper555 5 років тому

    This man never learned what a ballast is

  • @gamestp6586
    @gamestp6586 7 років тому

    Is this online?

  • @leekeyser1968
    @leekeyser1968 3 роки тому

    The Russian Escorts would be using active sonar at this point. They would know your there, and be launching torpedoes, among other anti sub weapons....

  • @geoffbraid1607
    @geoffbraid1607 6 років тому

    Are you playing againts other people or bots?