Which Action Camera Is the BEST ONE for YOU? An In-Depth Discussion
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 тра 2024
- In this video I do an in-depth look at the GoPro Hero 12, DJI Osmo Action 4, Insta360 Ace Pro, and DJI Osmo Pocket 3. I explore numerous features and characteristics and provide a summary of these as well as my perspective of which cameras shine in which areas.
Buy the GoPro Hero 12 here: amzn.to/48hHWc4
Buy the DJI Osmo Action 4 here: amzn.to/3P2nlQU
Buy the Insta360 Ace Pro here: amzn.to/49TuDOT
Buy the DJI Osmo Pocket 3 here: amzn.to/3T1vfvj
Table of Contents
0:00 - The cameras
1:01 - Cost
2:11 - Weight
3:09 - Battery life
5:01 - Battery cost
6:09 - Battery charging time
7:58 - Mounting
9:35 - Lens cover
11:04 - Durability for action
12:19 - Pocket 3 unique strengths
15:14 - Maximum resolution and FPS
16:19 - Bitrate
17:18 - Sensor size & low light
19:49 - Stabilization
20:34 - Bit depth
21:59 - Sharpness & Noise settings
24:03 - Digital lens and POV
26:34 - Color grading
29:23 - Gyro data
31:33 - Time lapses
37:23 - Night lapses
40:41 - Photos
42:51 - Apps
44:59 - Which camera do you like best?
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Some of the following links are affiliate links. If you click on an affiliate link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission. This does not result in any additional cost to you, and the affiliate commission I earn helps contribute toward the costs to keep this channel up and running. Thank you for your support!
MUSIC TRACKS FOR MY VIDEOS:
🎶 Track Club is a great source for high-quality music for UA-cam videos. I get all of my music from Track Club. Get a FREE, FULL-ACCESS 1 Month Trial of Track Club using my link: bit.ly/3t28y0I
CAMERA GEAR I USE:
- GoPro Hero 12 Black: amzn.to/48hHWc4
- GoPro Hero 11 Black: amzn.to/3SuQipa
- Sony a7S III Full-Frame Mirrorless Camera: amzn.to/41jTrw2
- DJI Osmo Action 4: amzn.to/3sYRusk
- Insta360 One RS 4K Edition: bit.ly/3HCo0UJ
- Insta360 X3: bit.ly/3e9Uhbd
- DJI Wireless Mic: amzn.to/3rqymmt
- Freewell ND filters. I get all of my ND filters from Freewell: amzn.to/3Zok7eo
- SanDisk 256GB Extreme MicroSDXC UHS-I Memory Card with Adapter: amzn.to/2Cu9dhc
- ANKER USB-C Charger I USE: amzn.to/3O6ce7u
MY FAVORITE GOPRO ACCESSORIES:
- Media Mod (Hero 9, 10, 11): amzn.to/3qaBjEx
- Dual Battery Charger + Battery (Hero 9 and 10): amzn.to/3jmy5c6
- Dual Battery Charger + Battery (Hero 5,6,7,8 Black): amzn.to/3jcpBV6
- Protective Housing (Hero 9 and 10): amzn.to/3jlCgoG
- Protective Housing (Hero 8 Black): amzn.to/3xgwwla
- Shorty Mini Extension Tripod: amzn.to/34EYPhe
- Suction Cup Mount: amzn.to/2WSOei7
- USB Pass-Through Door (Hero 9 and 10): amzn.to/3nn5fLN
- Anker External Power Bank: amzn.to/3s3ODKh
- Anker USB-C Wall Charger: amzn.to/37fCnN9
HIKING GEAR WE USE:
- Black Diamond Trail Ergo Cork Trek Poles: amzn.to/2OCkA9r
- Osprey Poco Plus Child Carrier: amzn.to/32vU8Gy
- Salomon Men's X Ultra Mid 3 Aero Hiking Shoes: amzn.to/2Ch9u7p
- Salomon Women's X Ultra Mid 3 Aero Hiking Shoes: amzn.to/3ji2iIK
Not looking for any of this sweet gear right now, but still want to support my channel? If you use this link to start your Amazon search it will benefit my channel with a small commission from some of your purchases on Amazon: amzn.to/2WAgbbt Thank you for your support! - Навчання та стиль
very informative and appreciate the honest opinion. I am a fan of the pocket 3 and the ace pro, but I will be mainly using the ace pro since I can take it anywhere even underwater, but the pocket 3 just can't do in extreme enviroment
Thank you and I appreciate your feedback. Yes, both are great cameras and have different areas where they excel. The Ace Pro is great for that take anywhere use case.
Great video! Thanks for taking the time to make and post
Excellent ..... thank you for taking the time to produce this detailed comparison ..
You’re welcome and I appreciate your feedback.
Thank you for your time to explain all this! it was very solid and honest. Greetings from cancun
You’re welcome and thank you for your feedback!
A very nice video, with lot of information. I just suscribed to your channel. Thanks a lot for the hard work.
Excellent detail description on the action/vlog camera. We can prioritize on our own which to choose for our own needs. Thanks
Appreciate it. Yes, my goal with this video was to provide the needed information to make the decision easier for anyone in the market for one of these.
Very thorough and concise comparison of these cameras. Thank you 👍
Thank you. I appreciate your feedback.
I start to follow your channel when I was waiting for my ace pro to be delivered. I found your videos are very informative with details very organized👍🏾
Thank you for your support and feedback! Hope you enjoy your Ace Pro.
The best comparison video I have seen - thank you!
I appreciate your feedback. Thanks!
Quite a detailed comparison, very well done!
Thanks!
Good stuff! Thank you for this in-depth comparison.
You’re welcome!
Great video, exactly what I was looking for!
Thanks!
Very helpful and thorough 💚
Thank you!
Fantastic and thorough comparison. Probably the best comparison I’ve seen. Thanks.
Thank you!
Very thorough! I have 3 of the 4 cameras (No Action 4), and agree with your findings. GoPro best in good light, Ace Pro best in low light and Osmo best for cinematic (travel, vlog, low light) but, as you said, limited for "action." Having these three in my quiver allows me to make the best of any scenario.
Absolutely. They each have their strengths and weaknesses that make them beneficial in different situations and use cases.
So helpful, thank you!!
You’re welcome!
Beautiful comparison, thenks.
Thanks!
Thanks for that information!!
You’re welcome!
I currently have the DJI Action 3, which I love, but you are right, it's limited for night time stuff. I'm hoping the 5 will address that problem! I found it great when I went snorkeling and caving last year though, it's very tough and easy to replace a lens if you break one
Great info, thanks
You're welcome and thanks for your feedback!
great content sir, thank you
Thank you. Appreciate it.
Excellent! Thank you.
You’re welcome!
I look to UA-camrs to be a UA-camr your content has helped me allot with learning the dos and don'ts of action cameras. Good in depth review. bought an action 4 and it hasn't let me down .great camera
Thank you. The Action 4 has been a great camera to own and use.
Danke für das informative Video, das hätte ich vor 3 Monaten sehen sollen! Liebe Grüße aus Tirol
You’re welcome and glad you found this useful.
Hello! Question regarding power supply for timelapse shooting on the GoPro Hero 12 -- what's the best way to ensure the camera stays charged for a multiple hour-long shot in which the camera must remain still (e.g. sunset, stargazing, etc.)? Should it just be connected to an external power source, as opposed to replacing the battery with a fully charged new one? Seems like replacing the battery would jostle the camera and mess up the shot.
Also, if it's connected to an external power source, does that make it more susceptible to damage from weather elements (e.g. condensation, dust, etc.)? If so, how can I prevent that damage?
Thanks so much for the help!
Very well done. I have the GoPro Hero10 and the new Ace Pro. I will use them both for motovlogging... the Ace Pro for night rides.
Thank you. Both good choices and the Ace Pro is a great choice for night rides.
Thanks for this excellent comparison video. I think i’ll go with dji pocket 3.
You’re welcome. The Pocket 3 is an incredible camera.
I was hesitant about acepro and pocket3 but finally decided on acepro. Pocket 3 is not waterproof and kinda fragile in my outdoor use case, and acepro has very good vlogging features, also low light performance better than DJI and gopro...
All valid points and pros with the Ace Pro for sure.
just as a heads up to people reading this thread, the only downside for ace pro for vlogging is it *by far* has the longest minimum focus distance of the 4 cameras and at normal arms length with the ace pro facing you, a face will be slightly out of focus because of this, IMHO this makes ace pro a bit less of an ideal vlogging platform.
@canyonblue737-8 Thank you for emphasizing this here as it is useful info.
Just began following you, enjoy your comparison here.
I’ve been playing with how to best night lapse with an Action 4. I am a novice but looks like I’ve been fighting an uphill battle
Thank you. Yes, definitely not anything you did wrong with the Action 4.
Most comprehensive comparison available, super helpful, at the end it seems that the pocket 3 wins but to be perfect it would be with the action 4 for all the more unsafe videos, it's also a lot more discreet, keep up with the great vlogs
Thank you. I’m glad you found this helpful and I appreciate your feedback.
Fantastic in depth review... the only thing that would have added more to it would have been a few more comparison videos. Thanks!
Thank you for your feedback. I will keep this in mind when doing more videos like this!
Amazing video, just subscribed. I think the DJI Action 4 is the best camera for my use case.
Thank you and I appreciate your support. The Action 4 is a great choice and great price.
Great review. I have been using ace pro for 3 months, it remains my top pick for capturing life's adventures. I'm thrilled with the innovative features it provides, which help me save a lot more time in shooting and editing process. Overall, ace pro is a great choice.
Thank you. Glad you've been enjoying the Ace Pro. It is a fun camera that is capable of a lot.
which particular Camera is being used during the short vid images throughout during hike w/children?
My first but definitely not my last watch of one of your videos. Please don’t burn out though, want your channel to last, great video, thanks. I found it so useful. 👏
Really appreciate your feedback and support! Yes, I have focused on finding a good balance with my content plan for this year in order to combat the risk of burn out.
love this your guides for the action camera. I’m a beginner interesting for my vacation camera. Since beginning i like action 4. Mostly i will use this as is meaning just choose from the menu and i will use the video as is but if i have time to update i will. So do you think my choice is good enough for that?
Yes, the Action 4 is a solid vlogging camera. Check out this video here for more specific vlogging settings I recommend for this camera: ua-cam.com/video/TgI5ihg9jRI/v-deo.htmlsi=EX2cBR0bbV7s7nss
My man you just added the mic extension on the ace pro and ofc it will weight more lol
Great review, we go GoPro, as we have been using them for years without issues and have a lot of legacy mounts etc. and like the new features on the 12. Why no mention of the add-on wide lens for the GP12? BTW a "one inch class" sensor is not that much bigger than a 1/1.9", it's actually about 13x10mm or about 1/1.5" if it's the same size as the Sony and Canon "inch class".
Good point about the Max Lens Mod 2.0.
As far as specific sensor sizes if you look at the mm measurements of the 1/1.9” vs the 1” CMOS the percentage difference is quite significant; however, sensor size is not everything and a lot of other factors matter as well. I, too, like my GoPro cameras. I have owned every single one since the Hero 4 Silver and use my Hero 12 often. Just used it this past weekend in fact.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
I've got a DJI Mini 3 Pro, Action 4, and Pocket 3 combo with their wireless mic (which also pairs with the Action 4 - which is a great firmware update). That alone is a fantastic benefit. DJI quality has always been excellent, so let's hope that remains so. I also have an Insta 360 X3 which is great for action (sailing in my case) as it allows for framing the action in post when you are too busy to film and sail at the same time.
That’s a great collection of DJI gear you have. The Insta360 X3 is a great camera. I’ve really enjoyed adventures with that camera.
Excellent thorough video mate, I’ve got a GoPro Hero 11 and Osmo Pocket 3. They’re both good, but always worried I’m going to break the Pocket on a hike. GoPro would be so much better if they ironed out all the glitches that plague their new cameras every year.
Absolutely agree. The Pocket 3 is great but it doesn’t replace having action cameras for me. I do bring the Pocket 3 on some hikes while keeping in mind if I drop it, impact it, or fall on it that it’s probably going to need some serious repairs after that (I did buy the DJI warranty). My GoPro and other action cameras I’ve dropped or hit plenty of times and they get a scratch or two but keep on going. Also, I’m hoping for big things from GoPro with the Hero 13 this fall.
Which camera is best for filming football/soccer games?
which one is bang for bug for overall rating?
Forgot to mention Ace pro have low light stabilization. Game changing. I even tried in a go-kart at night and you don't see any jiggle
From iran, thank you for great review
But im still confused im a motor rider and this is first time to buy a action camera but i wanted a cinematic videos on camera and and also in night, can you say what should i chose?
For your use cases I believe the Action 4 or the Ace Pro would be best. Both are good for action and both do great in low light with the right settings. I made this video with the low light settings I recommend for the Action 4: ua-cam.com/video/d36laQxaRHA/v-deo.htmlsi=Kw3tv5gZGH-zKMsy
Thank you for the review, I have all these cameras with the accessories, I can tell the best camera for best results and easy to use:
DJI Osmo pocket 3
Insta360 Ace Pro
DJI action 4
Gopro 12
Thank you for your feedback and perspective. Glad you've been able to own and test all of these out as well.
I'm a GoPro enthusiast. I prefer the Action 4 over the 10-12.
I hear GoPro overheats a lot. Do the other three do that as well?
Brilliant - nice details.
I really don't like the way DJI forces you in the arms of their app for registering - so they're out. AFAIK Gopro doesn't do that shite, you can even update the firmware via the SDcard. I have no idea how Insta360 have done this, so actually the Gopro is my favorite.
Thanks for your feedback.
I'm not sure if the DJI Osmo Pocket 3 can be considered an action camera... It's not waterproof, dustproof, or shockproof and has a lot of exposed moving parts. I consider it as different type of beast altogether: a vlogging camera.
This is a fair point and something I considered before creating this video. I included it because of the size, specs, and the fact that many people use action cameras for vlogging too, but you’re right, the Pocket 3 is designed with one main use case in mind: vlogging. The Pocket 3 is definitely not an action camera for action sports.
@@GreatDayForAHike Great video, by the way (forgot to write it down in the first comment as I was half-asleep while typing)! Full of insight on all cameras! I've got the GPH12 and Pocket 3 and tomorrow I'll get the AcePro. Since I've already got the Action 3, I'll skip Action 4 and go straight for the Action 5, which, judjing from Pocket 3, willl probably be larger in size (similar to AcePro) and feature a 1" sensor, so it'll definitely be worth the upgrade!
@TravellerChris Thanks. Sounds like you have a nice variety of great cameras. Yes, I am hoping for great things from the Action 5 as well.
@@GreatDayForAHike Thank you. 🤩 Yes, I'm also expecting Action 5 to be an amazing camera. As for my camera "collection", I've invested a lot of money in an attempt to continue improving the quality of my videos and offer a little bit more varied content. I'm using each camera for different types of content, as each of them excels on certain fields and none of them is the best on everything, with GPH12 being used mostly for short distance day driving (with MaxLens 2.0)/nightlapse/vehicle lights/star trails, Action 3 also for long distance day driving/hyperlapse, Pocket 3 for walking tours/timelapse and the AcePro for night driving videos. Hopefully, all of my efforts won't go unnoticed from the UA-cam algorithm for much longer. 😅
I agree however i truly appreciate the comparison as i am looking at that and one of the other cameras as well at the moment plus the details sharing great
Does it mean the ace pro has the better image quality among the 3 action cameras since the bitrate is higher? I personally prefer the look of the red rim design, also the flip screen
Great question. Part of the reason the max bitrate is higher is because of the 8K24 resolution that is possible on this camera. The bitrate appears to be lower when filming in 4K. However, when I look at the footage filmed with the Ace Pro next to footage from the other action cameras the quality from the Ace Pro looks great and the clarity and detail are solid. I find the Ace Pro and GoPro Hero 12 to have the best clarity and detail in their footage out of the three action cameras.
I also like the red rim design and flip screen. It's an aesthetically pleasing camera and the flip screen is useful in many situations.
Is there any way to set GoPro 4k60 1/50? DJI has no problem, but I need uniform footage from the S24U.
If you’re using 30fps, you’d be limited to shutter speed options of 1/30 and 1/60 on either side of 1/50. In other words, 1/50 isn’t going to show as a shutter speed option for 30fps footage.
@@GreatDayForAHike My mistake, I have already corrected it, I meant 4k60 1/50 - my S23U does not record in 50FPS so it remains 60FPS 1/50 to avoid flickering in the PAL system. Unfortunately, GP 11 does not allow 60FPS 1/50, so there is a problem with combining materials from S23U and GP11. Action allows 60p 1/50.
@Marek_Holland Yes I don’t think there is a way to set it to 1/50 in 60fps but this could be possible if you look into GoPro Labs firmware. There may be a QR code that will enable you to do this.
wish you've added more visual explanation
Thanks for your feedback and noted.
Actually the difference between 1/1.9 senosor next to 1/1.3 is great. About 2x or bigger and similar to the difference between APS-C and fullframe camera. That's pretty noticeable in the practice in my opinion. The main negatives I see about Insta Ace Pro is the lack of 10 bit video and the agressive hdr artefacts. In many cases that looks cheap and definitely not professional.
All good points. Thanks!
I got my GoPro 12 for $200 can beat that, also I’m happy with it, not saying that others are not better, but I’m good with the Gp12 for that price
That is a great price. For $200 that’s hard to beat.
May be one day I’ll be able to get the Ace Pro. Great video as always brother. 👍🏼
@OutdoorGentleman Thank you.
Had the DJI Action 4 but returned when the camera required activation to continue using. It is an infringement of my privacy in my view.
The activation requirements for some of these cameras is unfortunate.
talking about Pocket 3
Understood.
Possibly price wrong on gp12
Right after I filmed this video it looks like GoPro went and did a $50 sale on the camera 😂 Yes, the price was $399 when released but now a $50 sale at $349 and still the subscriber discount.
@GreatDayForAHike OK.. but im a subscriber so went on site after your video & saw no discount..Great video as always..maybe a glitch my side
I have GoPro 11. It sucks. I also have Go 3, Pocket 2, ZV-1 ii, and Sony X3000. Guess which one never gets used? Ding ding ding. GoPro 11. I'm selling it today and will put the money towards Pocket 3. Go 3 isn't the best image quality, but it's fun to use. The others are all fine cameras too.
Pocket 3 is a great choice.
Ace pro is the only one without 10bit color 😢
Yes, and while this doesn’t allow for much editing flexibility, most action camera users do not necessarily want to grade the footage. I find the footage from the Ace Pro to look great overall considering it is 8-bit. The Ace Pro can hold its own in many areas and I find is a fun camera to use.
GOPRO Hands down, also if you want to re sell it as a used item, the GOPRO will hold the value much more than any of these
You're right. The GoPro cameras do seem to have good resale value.
Opening question: the one where you don't have to put Chinese software on your pc or phone.
Video over. :)
That is certainly a win for GoPro with that criteria.
your talking American dollars because sphere not duble but just an idea I paid 1068.12. or 929 plus tax Canadian
Correct this is in USD.
Action 4 big problem is ugly flare.
I have found the flare to be an issues at times with action cameras over the years. I hadn’t noticed it as being particularly worse on the Action 4 vs other cameras. Although that may be in part that I rarely point my action camera toward the sun except when time lapsing a sunset or eclipse. For most other use cases I typically have the sun at my back.
@@GreatDayForAHike I compared all DJI Actions and version 4 has the worst - they appear most often and have the shape of a trumpet or a baseball bat.
@Marek_Holland Interesting. I haven’t seen that with mine.
@@GreatDayForAHike Take a look, they are a terrible shape and tend to show up a lot compared to the GoPro.