He was highly Rational.. he wanted the work to be done on the ground level and not just in worlds of politicians... The frustrating part of his life was that no one was catching up to his levelnof thought process and ideas.. at that time.
In May 1950 Ambedkar went to Ceylon with his wife to attend an inaugural conference of world fellowship of Buddhists. They were invited by young men Buddhist association, all of them are Sinhalese. This conference held in Dalada Maligawa ( holy temple of sacred tooth relic ) in Kandy where Maha nayaka theras of Malwatta and Asgiriya welcomed them and other delegates. Ambedkar was not a delegate but present with his wife as an observer, yet he was treated as a delegate by the conference organisers. These two divisions of Malwatta and asgiriya belongs to Siyam Nikaya ( Buddhist order ) which grants higher ordination only to those who belong to two high castes, Radala and Govigama. lower castes created their own nikayas in view of the caste discrimination. Nearly thirty caste divisions exist among Sinhala Buddhists. Being a jurist, a well respected social activist and reformer, I wonder how could Ambedkar have agreed to present himself with his wife at a temple premises that maintain caste discrimination, even now. There are five other divisions within these two major Malwatta and asgiriya sectors, all on caste status, though they belong to high caste. Government recognise only Siam Nikaya as the premier Buddhist sect and give all its support. Ambedkar gave a short speech at the conference but failed to condemn Siyam Nikaya’s caste discrimination. His acceptance of YMBA’s invitation and participation contradicts his principles and life long agitation. He might have felt inside that by mere becoming a Buddhist, caste discrimination cannot be abolished. He failed to acknowledge it for reasons known to him. I don’t know whether he knew at that time that no other heads of nikayas belonging to lower castes are invited to the Kandy conference. After a few years it has come to light that US govt has funded this conference through their agencies as a part of their fighting communism through Buddhism.
While your historical facts remain correct, one thing you missed out is that caste system in Sinhala Buddhism is in fact a legacy of Hinduism. Buddha was one of the first to rise up against caste system in Hinduism (he was born a Hindu - remember...?) There is no discrimination what so ever in the Buddhist scriptures (practice is a different thing) In fact caste system amongst Hindu Tamils in Sri Lanka is much more benign mainly due to Buddhist influence.....
Indian constitution framed under the chairmanship of Dr. Ambedkar reflects western ideas/ethos/values since he studied and spent significant amount of time in the west which influenced him greatly looking at the western society and their governance. Influenced by the wester society set-up he wanted to build Indian society on the western way in order to get rid of the caste system for which his community suffered the most. As a result, the Indian constitution contains very little Indian civilizational ethos, values and traditions that made India great in terms of her social system developed, but later on it degenerated and caste system got enshrined in the society. His hate for "Sanatana Dharma" has also influenced him.
Shashi Tharoor is a most prolific book writer with close to 25 books to his credit and perhaps many more to follow. Arguably the most articulate and definitely among the top Indian intellectuals dead or alive. Nevermind his party doesn't think so. Cong has reputation for aquiring talents and trashing them. As a professional author, speaker and a politician, Tharoor doesn't stand by his own arguments. Having spoken against colonial mindset and atrocities of the British Raj etc he was among the first and the strongest to oppose the banning of BBC Files. Eventually the govt of India raided BBC office and found incriminating evidences. Today BBC is shaken up and is in bad shape as a consequence of multiple misdeeds of similar nature worldwide. So much for the scholarship and intellectual proficiency of Tharoor which fail his own countrymen frequently when they need him the most to defend the voices and honour of the country. Worthless junk.👎 Satyamev Jayate! 🪷 Jai Hind!!
Ambedkar has been proved right, in every way. Ambedkar was simply not a hypocrite. And he spoke out of knowledge....he read 10 times than everybody...he saw ahead..what we SEE today, the "hindutva" ism around, WE know what he was and IS . These two are.pygmies relative to Ambedkar.
Further to my previous comment: On the following day of the Kandy conference, Ambedkar addressed in a meeting held at Colombo Town Hall” appealing to the untouchables to embrace Buddhism without having a separate organisation”. This is unbelievable when entire Buddhist chapters and worshiping places in Ceylon are observing caste discrimination, how could Ambedkar, a well educated person, make such an appeal. Hasn’t he studied the history of Buddhism and Buddhists in Ceylon , before he accepted the invitation? Can Sashi or someone explain please.
Now after Mr. Gandhi , Mr. Shashi Tharoor opens his fang what he think of dr. Ambedkar . Baba saheb chosen Buddhism not because someone gave him a book but because he studied all the religion then he decided to chose Buddhism and now current research also verified it that all India were Buddhists.baba saheb declare that Hinduism is the worst religion of the world , a religion that makes his own people untouchables, how can we call it a religion ?. Surely because it is not a religion but collection of caste . Baba saheb told the BBC exactly the correct sentence not the unnecessary thing that Gandhi opens his fang. Mr Shashi if Gandhi was right then why did not he accept the seperate electorate?. In this interview you criticize Dr ambedkar ,and you didn't spoke a single word against Gandhi how can you do that . Baba saheb did all the hard work for his country ,now you all blaming baba saheb that he didn't do anything about adhivasi .He did far more than what he can do ,now ask yourself having these privileges what work you have done ?.
Dr BR Ambedkar is Dalit no one allow him or call him respectfully to join free india movement On the contrary he has his own caste decent Carry himself every day bcz Gujarati got Gujarat state , shikh got Punjab, but he would not get dalit state for his community Therefore always fight against Mahatma Gandhi on this issue Bcz Muslim got Pakisthan No one forget his education and his knowledge and wast experienced through international studies. He has lots of knowledge about Sanskrit and Mahabharata. What's hindu always ask himself . By the way thanks to Shashi ji for his acknowledgement about Dr Ambedkar.
My watchman talk better English than shashi Tharoor but Indians think this(Shashi Tharoor) mere Language knowing donkey had invented electricity for mankind.😂
My understanding of Dr. Ambedkar became multifold with this 50min video. Thank you Dr. Tharoor.
Very good discussion….this is how conversations are conducted.., thanks to both on the stage
Have read the book and it is most revealing about his brilliance and even being voted as World number one Scholar in 1915 by Columbia university
The book gives an insight in his fight from his childhood as a Dalit against other Hindus.He as an economist and a brilliant jurist.
Shashi sir donned Ambedkar's soul while writing😊
Dr. Ambedkar is my inspiration
Another superb speech from the speaker who continues to inspire many youngmen and women around the world ! Continue your good work Sir.❤😊🎉
I do not know much about Dr.Ambedkar but Dr. Shashi , yes; my inspiration ....a living legend, a paragon of excellence.
Brilliant book. More importantly this brings to fore the importance of abolishing caste systems in India.
Looking forward to reading this book.
Stupendous task❤
Wow 🎉can’t wait to get my copy. Hi South Africa 🇿🇦 😊
Looking forward to reading the book
He was highly Rational.. he wanted the work to be done on the ground level and not just in worlds of politicians...
The frustrating part of his life was that no one was catching up to his levelnof thought process and ideas.. at that time.
Fist comment you are the best speaker sir
Ambedkar ❤
Shasi tharur sir has written very good book on Dr ambedkar
Great 👍🏻👍🏻
Amazing...
Love from Karnataka
Chitradurga ✌
I have been read that book. He has been described about ambedkar very well. He is saying. Who was ambedkar.
Great 1🎉
👌👍from kollam, kerala
Such a Knowledgeable
Jai Bheem
Appealing to the untouchables to embrace Buddhism without having a separate way good enough.
Share the link to buy this new book
Great 👍👍👍 sir
Great
Worth reading
❤❤❤❤
In May 1950 Ambedkar went to Ceylon with his wife to attend an inaugural conference of world fellowship of Buddhists. They were invited by young men Buddhist association, all of them are Sinhalese. This conference held in Dalada Maligawa ( holy temple of sacred tooth relic ) in Kandy where Maha nayaka theras of Malwatta and Asgiriya welcomed them and other delegates. Ambedkar was not a delegate but present with his wife as an observer, yet he was treated as a delegate by the conference organisers. These two divisions of Malwatta and asgiriya belongs to Siyam Nikaya ( Buddhist order ) which grants higher ordination only to those who belong to two high castes, Radala and Govigama. lower castes created their own nikayas in view of the caste discrimination. Nearly thirty caste divisions exist among Sinhala Buddhists. Being a jurist, a well respected social activist and reformer, I wonder how could Ambedkar have agreed to present himself with his wife at a temple premises that maintain caste discrimination, even now. There are five other divisions within these two major Malwatta and asgiriya sectors, all on caste status, though they belong to high caste. Government recognise only Siam Nikaya as the premier Buddhist sect and give all its support. Ambedkar gave a short speech at the conference but failed to condemn Siyam Nikaya’s caste discrimination. His acceptance of YMBA’s invitation and participation contradicts his principles and life long agitation. He might have felt inside that by mere becoming a Buddhist, caste discrimination cannot be abolished. He failed to acknowledge it for reasons known to him.
I don’t know whether he knew at that time that no other heads of nikayas belonging to lower castes are invited to the Kandy conference.
After a few years it has come to light that US govt has funded this conference through their agencies as a part of their fighting communism through Buddhism.
While your historical facts remain correct, one thing you missed out is that caste system in Sinhala Buddhism is in fact a legacy of Hinduism. Buddha was one of the first to rise up against caste system in Hinduism (he was born a Hindu - remember...?) There is no discrimination what so ever in the Buddhist scriptures (practice is a different thing) In fact caste system amongst Hindu Tamils in Sri Lanka is much more benign mainly due to Buddhist influence.....
Ambedkar also pointed out that Muslim brotherhood is not universal brotherhood.
👏👏 🌷 🌹
Indian constitution framed under the chairmanship of Dr. Ambedkar reflects western ideas/ethos/values since he studied and spent significant amount of time in the west which influenced him greatly looking at the western society and their governance. Influenced by the wester society set-up he wanted to build Indian society on the western way in order to get rid of the caste system for which his community suffered the most. As a result, the Indian constitution contains very little Indian civilizational ethos, values and traditions that made India great in terms of her social system developed, but later on it degenerated and caste system got enshrined in the society. His hate for "Sanatana Dharma" has also influenced him.
Lol
Sir hindi ma book published Kab hogi
🐮🤣
Dhananjay keer ke book padhlo wo authentic hai kese bhi or writters se.
Should Be PM. ❤
Completely agree
My goodness...tharoor's knowledge is so superb...Oceanic depth.
We INDIAN DONE SOMETHING BAD IN FUTURE SO THAT WE GOT EX FOREIGN MINISTER OR OPPOSITION MINISTER LIKE SHASHI THARROR😞😞😞😣😣
Shashi Tharoor is a most prolific book writer with close to 25 books to his credit and perhaps many more to follow. Arguably the most articulate and definitely among the top Indian intellectuals dead or alive. Nevermind his party doesn't think so. Cong has reputation for aquiring talents and trashing them.
As a professional author, speaker and a politician, Tharoor doesn't stand by his own arguments. Having spoken against colonial mindset and atrocities of the British Raj etc he was among the first and the strongest to oppose the banning of BBC Files.
Eventually the govt of India raided BBC office and found incriminating evidences. Today BBC is shaken up and is in bad shape as a consequence of multiple misdeeds of similar nature worldwide.
So much for the scholarship and intellectual proficiency of Tharoor which fail his own countrymen frequently when they need him the most to defend the voices and honour of the country. Worthless junk.👎
Satyamev Jayate! 🪷
Jai Hind!!
Apni party ka saath do sir.....
The interviewer seems to be short of Ambedkarite knowledge. Dr. Shashi Tharoor also needs to read Changdeo Khairmode's volumes on Dr. Ambedkar.
34:00 to 37
Before criticizing Dr. Ambedkar please check your degrees compared to Dr. Ambedkar in totality your own intellectual level ❤
Ambedkar has been proved right, in every way. Ambedkar was simply not a hypocrite. And he spoke out of knowledge....he read 10 times than everybody...he saw ahead..what we SEE today, the "hindutva" ism around, WE know what he was and IS .
These two are.pygmies relative to Ambedkar.
Further to my previous comment: On the following day of the Kandy conference, Ambedkar addressed in a meeting held at Colombo Town Hall” appealing to the untouchables to embrace Buddhism without having a separate organisation”. This is unbelievable when entire Buddhist chapters and worshiping places in Ceylon are observing caste discrimination, how could Ambedkar, a well educated person, make such an appeal. Hasn’t he studied the history of Buddhism and Buddhists in Ceylon , before he accepted the invitation? Can Sashi or someone explain please.
Hope it is not a Macaulay Putra point of view of one and only Ambedkarji! If it is, it will be crass!
Hope shashi tharoor ji must have understood dr ambedkars understanding of india and his philosophy and avoid the stand of soft hindutva.
Now after Mr. Gandhi , Mr. Shashi Tharoor opens his fang what he think of dr. Ambedkar . Baba saheb chosen Buddhism not because someone gave him a book but because he studied all the religion then he decided to chose Buddhism and now current research also verified it that all India were Buddhists.baba saheb declare that Hinduism is the worst religion of the world , a religion that makes his own people untouchables, how can we call it a religion ?. Surely because it is not a religion but collection of caste . Baba saheb told the BBC exactly the correct sentence not the unnecessary thing that Gandhi opens his fang. Mr Shashi if Gandhi was right then why did not he accept the seperate electorate?. In this interview you criticize Dr ambedkar ,and you didn't spoke a single word against Gandhi how can you do that . Baba saheb did all the hard work for his country ,now you all blaming baba saheb that he didn't do anything about adhivasi .He did far more than what he can do ,now ask yourself having these privileges what work you have done ?.
I agree with u my friend, great knowledge u have about Dr br ambedkar. Just bcuz he was a dalit people will always criticize him!!
Though we live in Hindu major country,I must say that these belief is not so good,a bit weird,Fundamental right should not be basing Hinduism.
Wife killer?
Why do not you ask her son?
@@rakhimukerji7937 poor chap doesn't know...he said he was busy with u on that date.
Dr BR Ambedkar is Dalit no one allow him or call him respectfully to join free india movement
On the contrary he has his own caste decent Carry himself every day bcz Gujarati got Gujarat state , shikh got Punjab, but he would not get dalit state for his community
Therefore always fight against Mahatma Gandhi on this issue
Bcz Muslim got Pakisthan
No one forget his education and his knowledge and wast experienced through international studies.
He has lots of knowledge about Sanskrit and Mahabharata. What's hindu always ask himself .
By the way thanks to Shashi ji for his acknowledgement about Dr Ambedkar.
Read the book before you comment.
My watchman talk better English than shashi Tharoor but Indians think this(Shashi Tharoor) mere Language knowing donkey had invented electricity for mankind.😂
It's means your Watchmen is better then you 😂
You should be ashamed to make such a degrading comment on Shashi Tharoor.