Probably. Similar to up2u. I doubt it lasts any longer than 2-4 months and that’s stretching it. Maybe a song, a week of promo, and then a disbandment song.
I feel like Lea wasted her time on this show because you're telling me that the older sister of two successful idols decided to join a lackluster budgeted survival show?? Unbelievable.....💀
I hate global voting for the whole show because most ppl look for visual, age, and/or nationality. One thing I like about I-Land is that they wait for voting at the end of the show, which is how I think all survivle shows should be like
@@annanowak9620 That’s the show that made their contestants dances until they were exhausted/had to be hospitalized right? (At least, I think a few contestants were hospitalized?)
Kelly being #1 while clearly not being even close to ready frustrated me and it continues to the more I see clips of her pretending to “forget” choreography and doing overly-forced aegyo instead. Lea at the very least has experience although her group didn’t work out. There’s always room for improvement but I don’t think Kelly has any business being in the k-pop industry without being trained for it first. She’s pretty, but that’s about it for now.
lol, true. I dont really understand why out of other skits, she chose the "I forget the choreo", exacerbating her already tainted reputation of not being able to properly dance.
idk much about the industry, I’m just a passive music liker. What kinda pissed me off on insta is people glazing the 1st place saying “GUYS SEE SHES IMPROVING” “I TOLD YALL SHE HAD POTENTIAL”. imo, being an idol isn’t about improving WHEN you debut- it’s about having the talent beforehand, in fact, you should have experience WAYYY before you even train to be one. About the voting (the tiktok sticker stuff), it’s rlly sad. It’s not abt talent anymore, it’s about who has the most amount of people willing to spend money on them. People who cant afford don’t have a say in it, kpop culture shouldn’t exist to only those who can afford it :(
i think its okay for idols to improve in certain aspects that their lacking in, but most if not all are good if not amazing in other categories that makes up for what they lack and sadly kelly doesn't have any of that. it's like they just put a survival show together to get money from people and didn't bother training the girls. the company who made it is also like a tiktok company so yeah.. 😭 it definitely felt like a scam but people were for some reason willing to spend money.
Its not about talent. About visual unfortunately. But thats how kpop started lets say. Why was Yoona added to snsd? Rmshe created rhe visual thing. The one who was catching The eye of everyone. And then every company started doing The same. Visual has alwaya been important. Talented or not. So Idk why these kpop stans think visual is not important. But ai have never seen such case as The nr 1 girl that won. She really cant sing. But at least she is attracting others... 😅😅
Not necessarily cuz in some jpop groups fans actually like to see how their idol grow hence you see the skill gap with the AKB48 girls and the kpop trainees in produce 48, however the show just lacks content for viewers to even justify it by personality or being a stan attractor which happens quite often. Plus everyone looked like they aren’t even trying to put effort in which makes the whole thing worse, the main point of being an idol is to at least be entertaining in some form that is not limited to singing, dancing or rapping but the show fails to even do that
I don't think it's ever been solely about talent and skill. How you look will always be a factor for how "popular" you become. And unfortunately, become a pop idol is about getting as many fans as possible. You don't need money to watch a person's music video or fancam to get them views and ad revenue. BUT for some reason, the visuals generally get the most views.
I have been a kpop fan for a while. I thought I already heard the worst the industry had to offer when it came to vocals. I was wrong. This show exists. How the hell did this happen?
I know that debut is gonna have the budget of 3 pennies, they Will have Maybe 2 single albums and we Will see some of the members on gp999 season 2 lol
One of the contestants told her fans not to vote for her as she didn't realised that the votes were based on gifts that required money. This shows that the whole show is rubbish and the entertainments only want money.
from the few videos i watched of the program, it doesnt even look like a REAL survival show, it looks like as me and friends we are playing as if we are in a survival show
The worst thing for me about this survival show was.. how long it was. Omg I skippee almoet everything. The MC were talking too much and evey girl had like 10 minutes for themselves to talk. Omg I didnt like that
I’ll say second worse solely for the fact that it was all adults. Up2u was produced by a company known for adult streamers yet in the first season, an 11 year old won and in the second, two 12 year olds and a 9 year old won. Thankfully they were only a group for like 3 weeks and had one done each but still. It was also heavily funded by fans I think it was paid voting
This show is a total disaster, participants debut not bc of their talent but their visuals. The fact that kelly kim debut is a pure joke, this girl didn’t even have a single talent and she sing like trash..This show is literally an insult to every REAL kpop idol, i’m desperate..
Ok but girl in 1:27 is pretty good She definitely can sing, i guess it wasn't her best day, considering the sh1tty nonexistent training and technical difficulties, she probably couldn't even hear herself
i’m not a fearnot but i never want to hear anything about le sserafim not being able to sing ever again if this group debuts (because, if they’re running a survival show via tiktok, they can’t afford a debut). i can’t carry a tune to save my life but this is embarrassing. actually, beyond embarrassing. we need to invent a new word stronger than embarrassing to describe this.
I am not a fearnot But I dont like when kpop stans talk badlt abnour them because every kpop groups lip sync (only few like mammoo or nmixx ewtc can be an exception) but the others? Omg The whole industry lip sync or they have altered mics to sound better. So I dont wanr kpop stans to complain about orher kpop groups. Especially sm stan since they idols lip sync a lot.
i wanted to! but i have my finals this week! i'll try to edit it for next week but i can't promise anything cause its a lot of info and maybe i can't make it!
Ok honestly I didn't care tm that Kelly was cringe and everything and I thought she was like 17, when I found out she was like 26 I was flabbergasteddd 😭😭
MAKESTAR IS not an tiktok artist company; it's a KPOP merchandise company, which has many connections! they made an Svs of boy group with KBS (NouerA); they debut line-up best a banacle group with talented members
@@hannisjeanzUsually I wouldn't be mad when the survival show debuts member that can dance but can't sing but if they can't dance OR even sing,heck not even rapping then I would be so pissed.
Uh, have you hard of starlight boys with actual abuse/ Time Turner was just a fun show for tiktok girls, there was never a plan to make a kpop group, no need to be serious about it
The show was terrible. At least, it was really live, so mistakes were obvious. Shows on TV are not live and get a lot of edition, even their voices are edited to sound better. I won’t boycott the group because of that. I will pay attention to the group and I’m looking foward to their better version. I think it’s possible that the members improve their skill. Don’t forget that Bahiyyih was less talented than 90% of the trainees in Girls Planet and she made it anyway. She improved a lot nowadays, so I believe it’s possible for Kelly Kim.
I was excited to see timeturner since one of my fav idols (Eungi) was on it! But it was definitely not fair at all! I wish they had judges 😒 Ps Eungi is a soloist and member of lura Lucy rn and was previously in hi cutie! Check her out if you would like ❤
Thank you so much for this, but this is not I needed! :( I needed a intro video for my channel, not the video! But this is saur good, I'll probably use it
WHAT IS THAT UGLY CAPCUT ICON, I PAY THE PRO VERSION, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
The struggle is real
BAHAHHAAA
Capcut is such scam for money honestly (i use it too)
It’s so annoying
Capcut better count their days. They’ve been trying me lately.
I cant belive sis has 2 SIBLINGS WHO ARE IDOLS and she thought this was a good idea. She had so much potential without this already
like surely she could use some nepotism to get into an actual group
It looks like thia nepotism dildnt work.. she is not in sm, yg, jyp, cube, starship etc
So maybe the nepotism wasnt there in the First place.
Nepotism doesnt work this way ??? I m crying 😭 they dont have that much power for that
she could've find some other way, really companies would've love to have her 😭
@@annanowak9620 lea debuted before her siblings so she's not a nepo baby 💀
This survival show is a fever dream 💀
frr 😭😭
Even a fever dream make more sense
@@Itzstar446Frr😭😭
I have no words
@ YOU'RE EVERYWHERE WITH ME
i feel like this was a scam fr like they will debut for like a day and disband
I honestly hope so, i dont think i could handle them being a real grp
that's what I think will happen, or dungeon
Probably. Similar to up2u. I doubt it lasts any longer than 2-4 months and that’s stretching it. Maybe a song, a week of promo, and then a disbandment song.
@@hyuncuteyou have to have money for a dungeon though…
I feel like Lea wasted her time on this show because you're telling me that the older sister of two successful idols decided to join a lackluster budgeted survival show?? Unbelievable.....💀
?? Bahiyyi is known as a joke among both Korean and i fans. Only her white svpremac!st stans tolerate her.
I thought this survival show was a joke by tiktokers, it was painful to watch
frr 😭
like I’m sorry how is this a group? honestly if THEY can debut I am 10000% I can debut
@@wonyunaz fr bro, our dreams can be true and we don't even need talent
@yunawonyism
If they debut I'm Heeseung 😊
The woo woo s during kelly kim’s singing are the ultimate bad faith
watching the kelly part rlly gives me the urge to smash my laptop 💀😭at this point even i can sing better
frr 😪😪
Sameee😭😭
Even with Itzy blurred in the background, the stark difference in talent with Kelly Kim is still very apparent.
HELP😭🙏
I hate global voting for the whole show because most ppl look for visual, age, and/or nationality. One thing I like about I-Land is that they wait for voting at the end of the show, which is how I think all survivle shows should be like
This why judges and judges scores are needed
Wsit until you hear about statlight boys...... terrible idea
@annanowak9620 ik about it 😭😭😭😭
@@annanowak9620 That’s the show that made their contestants dances until they were exhausted/had to be hospitalized right? (At least, I think a few contestants were hospitalized?)
@@parkchimmin7913 yea it is
girl i was litro laughing all the way watching the survival show-
at least you could watch it, it was impossible for me 😭
@hyuncute the way i was about to smash my phone and cry was so funny
Kelly being #1 while clearly not being even close to ready frustrated me and it continues to the more I see clips of her pretending to “forget” choreography and doing overly-forced aegyo instead. Lea at the very least has experience although her group didn’t work out. There’s always room for improvement but I don’t think Kelly has any business being in the k-pop industry without being trained for it first. She’s pretty, but that’s about it for now.
lol, true. I dont really understand why out of other skits, she chose the "I forget the choreo", exacerbating her already tainted reputation of not being able to properly dance.
Not google forms🤦♀️
ngl I'm glad the talented ones got eliminated, they deserve better promotion in better companies
Why is it even considered as a survival show? 😭
frr
because you need to survive hearing these contestants
@@scxrletslove Lmfao real.
idk much about the industry, I’m just a passive music liker. What kinda pissed me off on insta is people glazing the 1st place saying “GUYS SEE SHES IMPROVING” “I TOLD YALL SHE HAD POTENTIAL”. imo, being an idol isn’t about improving WHEN you debut- it’s about having the talent beforehand, in fact, you should have experience WAYYY before you even train to be one. About the voting (the tiktok sticker stuff), it’s rlly sad. It’s not abt talent anymore, it’s about who has the most amount of people willing to spend money on them. People who cant afford don’t have a say in it, kpop culture shouldn’t exist to only those who can afford it :(
i think its okay for idols to improve in certain aspects that their lacking in, but most if not all are good if not amazing in other categories that makes up for what they lack and sadly kelly doesn't have any of that. it's like they just put a survival show together to get money from people and didn't bother training the girls. the company who made it is also like a tiktok company so yeah.. 😭 it definitely felt like a scam but people were for some reason willing to spend money.
Its not about talent. About visual unfortunately.
But thats how kpop started lets say. Why was Yoona added to snsd? Rmshe created rhe visual thing. The one who was catching The eye of everyone. And then every company started doing The same.
Visual has alwaya been important. Talented or not. So Idk why these kpop stans think visual is not important.
But ai have never seen such case as The nr 1 girl that won. She really cant sing. But at least she is attracting others... 😅😅
Not necessarily cuz in some jpop groups fans actually like to see how their idol grow hence you see the skill gap with the AKB48 girls and the kpop trainees in produce 48, however the show just lacks content for viewers to even justify it by personality or being a stan attractor which happens quite often. Plus everyone looked like they aren’t even trying to put effort in which makes the whole thing worse, the main point of being an idol is to at least be entertaining in some form that is not limited to singing, dancing or rapping but the show fails to even do that
I don't think it's ever been solely about talent and skill. How you look will always be a factor for how "popular" you become. And unfortunately, become a pop idol is about getting as many fans as possible. You don't need money to watch a person's music video or fancam to get them views and ad revenue. BUT for some reason, the visuals generally get the most views.
I have been a kpop fan for a while. I thought I already heard the worst the industry had to offer when it came to vocals.
I was wrong. This show exists. How the hell did this happen?
I know that debut is gonna have the budget of 3 pennies, they Will have Maybe 2 single albums and we Will see some of the members on gp999 season 2 lol
I fear that's what will happen 😭
I want to see them on gp999. The mentors gonna have field day😂
This was a survival show to see how long their viewers can last watching this cringe.
sis has 2 IDOL SIBLINGS and thinks this is a good idea?? bbygirl ur face is already a foot in the door, why are u doing thiss😭😭😭
I sent understand 🤷🏻♀️🤷🏻♀️ she could've debuted in a proper way... with a good company
One of the contestants told her fans not to vote for her as she didn't realised that the votes were based on gifts that required money. This shows that the whole show is rubbish and the entertainments only want money.
from the few videos i watched of the program, it doesnt even look like a REAL survival show, it looks like as me and friends we are playing as if we are in a survival show
The show has to be definitely a scam
The worst thing for me about this survival show was.. how long it was. Omg I skippee almoet everything.
The MC were talking too much and evey girl had like 10 minutes for themselves to talk. Omg I didnt like that
Let me add that Eungi was singing without an ear-monitor like omg what the heck with this showw
never heard anything like this. omg what a mess😭
frr 😪😪
Hiii btw this is the WORST survival show oml
heelloo! it was! 😭
@ ikr
I’ll say second worse solely for the fact that it was all adults. Up2u was produced by a company known for adult streamers yet in the first season, an 11 year old won and in the second, two 12 year olds and a 9 year old won. Thankfully they were only a group for like 3 weeks and had one done each but still. It was also heavily funded by fans I think it was paid voting
@@SweetforS Yeah Up2u was something else, it's really disturbing.
@ yeah. I’ll rank it up2u, starlight boys (for the physical torture) and then this show for the mental torture they put the viewers though 😭
This show is a total disaster, participants debut not bc of their talent but their visuals. The fact that kelly kim debut is a pure joke, this girl didn’t even have a single talent and she sing like trash..This show is literally an insult to every REAL kpop idol, i’m desperate..
Whoever hyped them up are wrong 😭
fr 😪
Dalia wasnt ready to be an idol yet she really needs to practice but she deserved to debut over kelly fr fr
Who is that guy hyping them with the bad vocals 😂😂😂😂😂
the mc!! I think it was a former jbj member 😭😭
Ok but girl in 1:27 is pretty good
She definitely can sing, i guess it wasn't her best day, considering the sh1tty nonexistent training and technical difficulties, she probably couldn't even hear herself
This show is like the one annoying dream that you dontt wanna see the next time yet it came back
I love (G)i-dle but why- 5:04
Are they even debuting ? 😅
apparently 😬
@brunettebrbie16 yeah they have a whole kprofiles profile and I'm just like 😮
that's what they say 🤷🏻♀️
Apparently predebut this month and debut early 2025. Im gunna guess March. I’ll bet their budget is like $1000 💀
@@SweetforS they probably will use money from the TikTok gifts
El show entero era como una broma, no puedo esperar a ver con qué debutan y de qué manera... 😂
no le tendría mucha fe, ni siquiera pudieron hacer un programa en condiciones, el debut tendrá un presupuesto de 3 céntimos y un sueño
@hyuncute literal jajaja
tiktok live and voting on google forms….yeah this wasn’t serious 😶
This obviously can’t be real there’s gotta be for some TikTok gifts or something
Even the fake kpop agency I'm part of forces me to make more
i’m not a fearnot but i never want to hear anything about le sserafim not being able to sing ever again if this group debuts (because, if they’re running a survival show via tiktok, they can’t afford a debut). i can’t carry a tune to save my life but this is embarrassing. actually, beyond embarrassing. we need to invent a new word stronger than embarrassing to describe this.
your comparing oranges to apples lesserafim has more exeperience
I am not a fearnot But I dont like when kpop stans talk badlt abnour them because every kpop groups lip sync (only few like mammoo or nmixx ewtc can be an exception) but the others? Omg The whole industry lip sync or they have altered mics to sound better. So I dont wanr kpop stans to complain about orher kpop groups.
Especially sm stan since they idols lip sync a lot.
Hey girlie, I was just wondering if you were making a video on the Vcha scandal? No pressure Ofc!
i wanted to! but i have my finals this week! i'll try to edit it for next week but i can't promise anything cause its a lot of info and maybe i can't make it!
@ ofc ofc girl❤️
I already posted it 💗💗 thx for the idea
@@hyuncute Thank you for posting it despite ur school work girl💗
I thought i sound like a goat and untalented until i saw the lineup song
Ok honestly I didn't care tm that Kelly was cringe and everything and I thought she was like 17, when I found out she was like 26 I was flabbergasteddd 😭😭
MAKESTAR IS not an tiktok artist company; it's a KPOP merchandise company, which has many connections! they made an Svs of boy group with KBS (NouerA); they debut line-up best a banacle group with talented members
if kelly kim debuts im auditioning on yg
Sorry pooks but you gotta audition
Tiktok Survival Show,wow.What a show.(I'm even more disappointed)
42 seconds ago- also real
@@hannisjeanzI was even more disappointed when I heard Kelly Kim debuting because she doesn't have one of the talent like singing or dancing.
@@Rainbow-Bicake REALL SHE DIDNT DESERVE LATATA
@@hannisjeanzUsually I wouldn't be mad when the survival show debuts member that can dance but can't sing but if they can't dance OR even sing,heck not even rapping then I would be so pissed.
I have a question: will these girls receive proper training before the debut?!
On what and where will the winners win?
they are supposedly debuting in a group together
Uh, have you hard of starlight boys with actual abuse/ Time Turner was just a fun show for tiktok girls, there was never a plan to make a kpop group, no need to be serious about it
that's what they are selling
Surviving is a human desire.
Is that same Makestar that helped funding nugu groups back then
Klly kim looks a LIL scary
The show was terrible. At least, it was really live, so mistakes were obvious. Shows on TV are not live and get a lot of edition, even their voices are edited to sound better. I won’t boycott the group because of that. I will pay attention to the group and I’m looking foward to their better version. I think it’s possible that the members improve their skill. Don’t forget that Bahiyyih was less talented than 90% of the trainees in Girls Planet and she made it anyway. She improved a lot nowadays, so I believe it’s possible for Kelly Kim.
I know timeturner was a mess, it’s crazy.
not that i wanted to watch it but still, tiktok is banned in my conutry to begin with😂
🥹
at least we got sim yerin 😣 wish it was in a better, higher budget group but
5:43 this can not be a real competition
3:56 who the f is saying wow
I was excited to see timeturner since one of my fav idols (Eungi) was on it! But it was definitely not fair at all! I wish they had judges 😒
Ps Eungi is a soloist and member of lura Lucy rn and was previously in hi cutie! Check her out if you would like ❤
kelly 🦆
It's just SOOOOOOOOOOO BAD.... 😭😭😭
this will be the most tone deaf k-pop group in history
Kelly’s actually debuting?
Thank you so much for this, but this is not I needed! :(
I needed a intro video for my channel, not the video!
But this is saur good, I'll probably use it
5:01 The hell why latata tho- latata is too good of a song for her
it's so difficult to singg
I wish lisa and soyeon was there😭
Only Cleo is the best one
Exactly 😭
Just watched the show and it sucks
5:10. STOPPPP LIA LOOKS SO DONE WITH THEIR SHITT 😂😂😂😂😂
It’s so funny I’m dead
I am sad for the girls tho, that « survival show » is so unserious.Also plz stop bullying that one girl that’s not her fault being picked 😭😭😭😭😭