Why was the Saturn V Black and White?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 гру 2014
  • For a little more on why the German-based Apollo-era rockets look the way they do, check out the latest on Vintage Space over at Popular Science: www.popsci.com/why-was-saturn-...
    Title image via NASA/Wikipedia user Reubenbarton. Music "The Coup" by AudioQuattro from Music Loops.
    For more Vintage Space, add me on Facebook, Google+, and Twitter as @astVintageSpace. And subscribe to Vintage Space on Popular Science for regular blog updates: www.popsci.com/blog-network/vi...
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,2 тис.

  • @frankroberts9320
    @frankroberts9320 8 років тому +679

    As a video engineer for PBS, I'm going to take an educated guess that the paint scheme was intended to aid the hundreds of tracking cameras in maintaining focus and tracking during the flight. Having attempted to manually maintain focus and tracking on the Columbia and Challenger shuttle launches of 1981-1983, I can tell you firsthand that once those electric fly machines get up a good head of steam, its damned hard to keep them in the viewfinder, much less keep them in focus.
    Without going into a lot of dreadful technical detail, the analog video system in use then (NTSC) did useful things when it was pointed at objects containing bold, high contrast patterns such as the paint schemes shown here. Video signals of black and white patterns contain a lot of high frequency information. The sharper the transition between the black and white areas in the image, the stronger the high frequency signals in the video will be. This means that electronic systems can monitor the high frequencies and automatically adjust camera focus and tracking to maximize the high frequency video components. We call it auto focus,

    • @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793
      @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793 8 років тому +2

      The h-bombs in Dr. Strangelove had a small black+white checkerboard pattern too.
      It's not for the camera, it's for the mind of the viewers.

    • @frankroberts9320
      @frankroberts9320 8 років тому +37

      +John Jingleheimer-Schmidt The H bombs in Dr. Strangelove were movie props. Any similarity between them and reality is purely coincidental.

    • @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793
      @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793 8 років тому +5

      Frank Roberts
      Movie props are designed to appear realistic on-screen, so its absurd to dismiss actual similarities as 'coincidence'.

    • @godfreypoon5148
      @godfreypoon5148 8 років тому +54

      +John Jingleheimer-Schmidt Well, as a matter of fact, I have personally ridden atop an H bomb dropped from a B-52 whilst wearing a cowboy hat, and I can tell you it looked NOTHING like in the movie.

    • @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793
      @johnjingleheimer-schmidt2793 8 років тому +2

      Godfrey Poon
      I think the checkerboard pattern is more symbolic of the object being a part of their 'great work'.

  • @AgentJayZ
    @AgentJayZ 7 років тому +58

    Werner von Braun has said publicly that the B&W paint scheme used on the V2, and all subsequent rockets was inspired by the rocket ship in the film "Woman in the Moon", released by German director Fritz Lang in 1929.
    This movie is thought by many to be the first use of a countdown prior to launching a rocket.

    • @sumbeech1484
      @sumbeech1484 3 роки тому

      @@61Ldf Russian Moon Rocket: Zero-Lift off- , Then either, Get the fire extinguisher, or run for it !!!

    • @Bellabong
      @Bellabong 3 роки тому

      @@61Ldf You say this, but the RS-25's/SSME's started at -6.6 seconds and the F1's of the Saturn were ignited at almost -9 seconds. The RS-68's of the DeltaV stagger their ignites around -3 seconds. Where did you even get the impression that US = 0 = igniton?

    • @61Ldf
      @61Ldf 3 роки тому +2

      @@Bellabong You are right. It’s the other way around. Russian Zero means ignition. The western zero means lift-off.

    • @donaldhoot7741
      @donaldhoot7741 2 роки тому +1

      Wrong! The pattern WAS used for video recording and to see if the rocket was rolling. It's NOT from some old mold y movie!

  • @LonesomeTroubadour
    @LonesomeTroubadour 9 років тому +206

    You might say the Apollo rockets had a checkered past, ahem.

    • @fishstuff
      @fishstuff 6 років тому

      Robert Clary Yuma wang

    • @jimdoucas6006
      @jimdoucas6006 5 років тому +1

      A PUNY PUN !!!

    • @indridcold8433
      @indridcold8433 5 років тому +1

      They were designed by an evil Nazi. "Checkered," past indeed. But the final result was spectacular!

    • @GumballAstronaut7206
      @GumballAstronaut7206 4 роки тому +1

      Go to your room

    • @lwjones55
      @lwjones55 4 роки тому

      Do you have any info on why parts of the service module are white and other parts are silver?

  • @user-lw8jk6nv7l
    @user-lw8jk6nv7l 7 років тому +21

    I live in Mississippi and I get to see the booster rocket almost everyday when i pass the Stennis Space Center

  • @Guitarfollower22
    @Guitarfollower22 7 років тому +219

    I wish I was alive to see Saturn V launch

    • @pbcanal1
      @pbcanal1 7 років тому +18

      Guitarfollower22 It was quite a time. Everyone would gather around the TV to watch. You got the updates from space and it seemed that time slowed as they went around the backside of the moon. Then the moon landings, wow. But by the time 15 to 17 came around, it was all old hat. It's a shame we can't do this anymore. Kennedy made the promise and although he was killed, the Country cared enough about him and science to make it happen.

    • @Guitarfollower22
      @Guitarfollower22 7 років тому +6

      I saw Apollo 13 for the first time just a week ago. In the movie the national news didn't want to cover even the Moon landings because sitcoms were more appealing, such a shame.
      And ya unfortunately NASA has turned to SpaceX, and other companies, for space flight. I never got to see even a manned shuttle take off from Cape Canaveral :(
      I hope that this country keeps investing the Federal Budget in NASA because within the next two centuries humans may have to colonize another planet such as Keplar-22b

    • @filipfarag676
      @filipfarag676 7 років тому +22

      Mate, just wait for SpaceX's ITS to launch in 2020s. It will be even more epic than Saturn V launch was.

    • @twirlygirly
      @twirlygirly 7 років тому +3

      Go to the Air and Space Museum in Huntsville, Alabama... you can see the first stage out back lying on its side.. frigging huge. Also there's a V2 out there.

    • @bengarcia9612
      @bengarcia9612 7 років тому +1

      PC5032 i love that place its well worth a full days exploration

  • @kevinharrington9148
    @kevinharrington9148 8 років тому +88

    You are amazing. As a little kid I got to watch Armstrong step onto the moon. So I love the early NASA missions!

    • @911gpd
      @911gpd 7 років тому +11

      man, I envy you.
      I consider it as one of the greatest endeavour of the Human kind

    • @jrogertrudel6356
      @jrogertrudel6356 7 років тому +2

      Kevin Harrington - so why is it today so much questioned as a hoax?

    • @cjeppinga
      @cjeppinga 6 років тому +7

      J Roger Trudel we are the lost generation... its too bad our generation can't comprehend the possibility of leaving earth...

    • @Bjowolf2
      @Bjowolf2 5 років тому +5

      @@jrogertrudel6356
      Only by ignorant fools and crazy conspiracy theorists, whose every single claim of hoaxes has long since been debunked big time 😎

    • @kevrob1784
      @kevrob1784 5 років тому

      unfortunately you were.fooled like millions

  • @dstar1958
    @dstar1958 7 років тому +78

    If I'm correct the original space shuttle had the huge fuel tank painted white but it was later left orange to save weight.

    • @AmyShiraTeitel
      @AmyShiraTeitel  7 років тому +38

      Yup. The paint was needless mass to lift off the ground!

    • @dstar1958
      @dstar1958 7 років тому +1

      Thank you.

    • @mikearthut781
      @mikearthut781 7 років тому +2

      ORANGE =33 33 DEGREE, FREEMASON. Dstar 1958

    • @ironcito1101
      @ironcito1101 7 років тому

      So why weren't the orbiter and the SRBs also left unpainted?

    • @ironcito1101
      @ironcito1101 7 років тому

      How does reusability make paint necessary?

  • @williamm374
    @williamm374 2 роки тому +1

    I saw these rockets and the aesthetics, though not intentional, were simply awesome. The Saturn-Apollo spacecraft was just off the charts beautiful.

  • @jeffcivjeep7
    @jeffcivjeep7 8 років тому +9

    One of my favorite road trips was down to the US Space and Rocket Center and taking a tour of Redstone Arsenal. Walking under the Saturn V and seeing the F1 engines, the lander, etc. But it was a bit depressing as well to see the facilities and how they seemed so dead and dated. For a while it really made me think that I screwed up by not perusing a career in aerospace engineering. Love the videos, wish I had found them sooner!

  • @NecroBones
    @NecroBones 9 років тому +23

    You know, I googled this very question a few months ago. It was your web content that answered the question for me (confirmed what I had thought), which is what prompted me to subscribe to your youtube channel. So seeing it as the topic today just brought it full circle. Awesome!

  • @curtw7747
    @curtw7747 8 років тому +11

    love the saturns and yes, i love this entire series. great job amy!

  • @markweippert6323
    @markweippert6323 Рік тому

    I lived near Stennis Space Center in Mississippi when my dad was an electronics technician for Douglas Aircraft on the 2nd stage of every Saturn V that went up. He taught me all about the program and I still remember going to Stennis with my mom to pick him up from work and how unbelievably loud the engines were when they were on the test stands.

  • @nuke314159
    @nuke314159 9 років тому +6

    Honestly I'm just astonished at the stuff I have recently come to learn having just found your page in the last few weeks. Thank you for all your in sight and keep up the good work!

    • @AmyShiraTeitel
      @AmyShiraTeitel  9 років тому +8

      Thanks so much! I'm just glad I get to share my nerdy passions with like-minded people!

  • @JeffGR4
    @JeffGR4 9 років тому +6

    I recall asking Deke Slayton the purpose of those black markings on the Saturn rockets ---- he said it was for tracking. Amy's explanation is more thorough and I agree with her on how fantastic the Saturn V looks. Great channel, Amy ---- I'm glad to be a subscriber!

  • @Drone256
    @Drone256 5 років тому +2

    My grandfather was one of the 104 engineers/scientists of Operation Paperclip. He worked on the V2. Many years ago he told my father, also an engineer, that the black and white paintings were to help with expansion/contraction problems while the rocket sat on the pad in the sun. The answers you find online today about the paintings all refer to making the rocket more easily seen during flight, but I do not believe that was true for the V2, at least during their early test flights.

    • @MrSvenovitch
      @MrSvenovitch 5 років тому

      My grandfathers were nobodies. So am I and I won't lose a second of sleep over it, because I am a bona fide insomniac under achiever.

  • @Ricovandijk
    @Ricovandijk 3 роки тому

    If I didn’t know any better I’d say you’re an Air Traffic Controller. Clear voice, great articulation, speed of a rockets upper stage. Thanks for not wasting any time! :-)

  • @terpcj
    @terpcj 8 років тому +3

    I'm always drawn to the Saturn 4. The S-IC (first stage) was already painted when they noted the heating problem, so they painted white paint over the troublesome black areas. You can see the black showing through the white, which amuses me every time.
    I also like that the pattern on the S-II (second), S-IVB (third) interstage is in binary (white-white, white-black, black-white, black-black).

  • @mikec573
    @mikec573 5 років тому +14

    Totally off topic, and I apologize but my God shes so beautiful.

    • @N75911_
      @N75911_ 5 років тому +22

      Absolutely, gorgeous, 363ft tall, fitted with 5 of the most powerful engines ever built.

    • @davidwuertzer4907
      @davidwuertzer4907 3 роки тому

      @N75911 I know this reply is a year old but it’s so funny

  • @yourmusicguru
    @yourmusicguru 2 роки тому

    Saturn V is my favorite rocket. My uncle was a welder on the project. I love going through Huntsville and seeing the Space & Rocket Center.

  • @komradking
    @komradking 9 років тому +1

    I love these vintage space videos! Thank you so much for sharing these delightful tidbits!

  • @SeanHollingsworth
    @SeanHollingsworth 8 років тому +4

    Very interesting trivia bits. Love it! :-)

  • @CharlieTechie
    @CharlieTechie 7 років тому +3

    Your channel is amazing! Lots of interesting info on paint and I did know why it was there, but not all the changes. Yes, the Saturn 5 was truly a rocketer's rocket, the size and majesty will mostly never be duplicated.
    BTW, the Space Shuttle's orange vs white main fuel tank is also interesting. I understand the first few were painted white, but engineers decided it wasn't needed for cooling and to cut down on weight, it was no longer painted so it stayed the natural insulation orange color.

  • @lifeofbrian5092
    @lifeofbrian5092 7 років тому +1

    I just happened upon your channel (recommended), but so glad that I did! I grew up loving all this stuff, so thank you, sincerely, for all effort and great job!

  • @guitarz667
    @guitarz667 8 років тому

    You are by far one of the most interpretive youtubers when it comes to everyday questions we peons love to learn about. Thank you so much for being "down to earth", figuratively speaking. Myself and my six year old, that's dead set on being an astronaut when he grows up, are extremely enjoying all of your phenomenal videos. Just a fan that can't say thank you enough for bringing an awesome mixture of information and enjoyment to the two guys in this family from Nashville TN. Keep up the good fight ma'am!

  • @stanpatterson5033
    @stanpatterson5033 8 років тому +18

    02:25 is that a cat wandering into the shot? bottom right (her left) just about where her elbow is.

    • @orangejoe204
      @orangejoe204 8 років тому +12

      That is Pete. He's her CAPCOM.

    • @foxdmulder
      @foxdmulder 7 років тому +1

      Alex Tocqueville or catcom

    • @scotthilliard7177
      @scotthilliard7177 3 роки тому

      Bahahaha!!!! I'm surprised one of those little curious bastards didn't wind up on the rocket!!! 🐈

  • @johnallardyce4164
    @johnallardyce4164 7 років тому +6

    Thanks Amy, I now know from your channel that it is a Saturn 1 because of the fins!

  • @Nesmorbutt
    @Nesmorbutt 9 років тому

    you present these videos really well mate, good work!

  • @AmericanBusinessman422
    @AmericanBusinessman422 6 років тому

    I love how your videos answer to questions I didn't even know existed! Amazing

  • @theblukatlife
    @theblukatlife 7 років тому +8

    Ok, I want to build my own spaceship so this is giving me some knowledge. Thank you human

    • @CriticoolHit
      @CriticoolHit 7 років тому +12

      We await the arrival of our new overlords with great anticipation.

    • @mike74em
      @mike74em 7 років тому +3

      Do you have an estimated time of arrival? Just curious, no pressure.

    • @sparkplug1018
      @sparkplug1018 7 років тому +3

      Have a rough ETA for us? Possible landing sites? No pressure or anything, just want to make sure I'm there to great you.

  • @ILSRWY4
    @ILSRWY4 8 років тому +8

    In addition to seeing if the rocket would "spin" in flight you will notice that all stages and stage adapters had a different pattern. That was so if the rocket broke apart in flight, and the pieces were recovered, the parts of the rocket would be quickly identified, by the pattern, as to what stage was what part of the rocket... Furthermore the command and service modules were not a tiny speck of sliver. They were intended to be in space and be exposed to heat and radiation.. that silver you see on the service module is chrome mylar. Under the white removable shroud the command module was also chrome mylar. Since the service module was lost in space, only the command came back and the Chrome Mylar burned off in reentry. Ref. U.S. Space and Rocket Center.

  • @threglanzaldor7763
    @threglanzaldor7763 4 роки тому

    Great video! Thanks for providing so much rich detail about these missions.

  • @olivergarsideconeron
    @olivergarsideconeron 9 років тому +1

    Such a great channel. Thanks Amy!

  • @stevefowler1787
    @stevefowler1787 8 років тому +8

    Here's a tidbit of local info on the Saturn V...I grew up in Cocoa Beach and then later Titusville in the space race years (My Dad was a Radar Guidance Engineer for GE out at the Cape)...anyway, in downtown Titusville on U.S. 1 right on the Indian River pretty much due west of the Saturn V launch pads 39A and 39B we had a Burger King and being the late 60's the attached screened in outside eating area had recently become air conditioned so the screens were replaced with big sliding glass doors...the first time they lit the Saturn V it shattered the glass and also shattered the showroom window glass at the Ford Dealer next door...I don't know what the distance was from the launch pad to the Burger King, but I would swag it at about 12 to 15 miles. BTW, thereafter whenever a Saturn V was on the launch pad both the BK and the Ford dealer would have tape on their windows, which fixed the problem. EDIT: my swag was pretty damn accurate, I just googled it and the drive from 39B to U.S. 1 in Titusville (which would be only feet from the BK) is 12.1 miles.

    • @stevesimms9622
      @stevesimms9622 8 років тому +4

      +steve Fowler hahaha. Great story man. I have a similar one. My dad was an engineer for NASA here at Redstone Arsenal in Huntsville, Alabama. They were working on the F1 engines, for the 1st stage of the Saturn 5. The tests, where it was just ONE engine were breaking windows several miles away in downtown Huntsville & the stores were starting to get a bit pissed about it. They didnt want to lose the peoples support , so they did something to control the sound. I cant remember exactly what it was though. I got to see one of the tests when I was a kid & man, it was loudest thing I've heard even to this day. And thats from a guitar player that has spent years in front of Marshall stacks (Amps) on stage. But the thing I really remember was a test where my dad told my mom & me to go outside at the exact time one day that they were going to test one of the engines & see if we could hear it. We were at a Minimum of 30 miles, but at that exact time , we heard what sounded like thunder on the horizon. Was so cool that I will Never forget it.

    • @stevefowler1787
      @stevefowler1787 8 років тому +3

      STEVE SIMMS
      Cool story dude...btw I was born in Hunstville...my Dad was stationed at Red Stone arsenal when he was drafted in the 50's...I was born there in '57, then we moved to Cocoa Beach and later Titusville...those were great days.

    • @stevesimms9622
      @stevesimms9622 8 років тому +2

      steve Fowler
      Yes indeed! Was really a special time. Thats what gets me pissed about the conspiracy nuts. But, I was born near Huntsville in '58. And btw Redstone is still there & going about as good as ever. Still know people that work there.
      My dad was at Redstone before I was born, so its very possible, him & your dad crossed paths at some point.

    • @stevefowler1787
      @stevefowler1787 8 років тому +3

      STEVE SIMMS
      It's a small world...my dad told me about going to the Friday night audiences that Von Braun would hold for technical discussions so yeah I bet they did cross paths...thanks for your stories...and yes the conspiracy peeps are batshit crazy. Btw I'm retiring from Lockheed Martin here in Orlando on Feb 1st with 30 years...software engineer. Take care dude.

    • @stevesimms9622
      @stevesimms9622 8 років тому +1

      steve Fowler
      Hell, that is Very Cool! 30 years. I've been married 32 yrs in Jan. I worked in engineering for a while after college. Math major engineering minor 4 yr degree. But I always wanted to get back into music & we opened a music store & I quit my job & the store took off & did well. Mainly a guitar store. But I got in a band that started going places & we made it to opening act status but never headliner. We were opener for Joan Jett, that was our most fun job, & Edgar Winter, Foghat, Atlanta Rhythm Section & several others. Some of the live stuff of my band Witcher is on my YT cha. But go to all videos to get to my actual cha. But yep, I bet the dads did cross paths at one time, just about certain. I remember my dad had a friend named Sloan that lived in Huntsville, we were about 30 mi out in nowhere, but on Fri nights he did go unto Huntsville with that friend.Thats probably where they were going! We had a German neighbor that was one of Von Brauns team that came over with him after WW2 & he rode to work with my dad. He used to come to our house 2 or 3 nights a week to help my dad with the calculus & physics for a last test he had to pass to get qualified for Von brauns personnel team. I Loved the German accent! haha. But they were working 100 hr weeks & my dad dropped dead of a heart attack & fell within a foot of where I was playing in the floor. It was the week before JFK was shot. I was a kid but I'll never forget it. I still have some of the rocket models he used to bring home to me. But these days, I'm still playing just part time, & now I have a shop at my house & I do guitar repair, setup , customizing, etc. Have several Grammy winners as customers being here in Muscle Shoals. Load of hits recorded here & I know all the Swamper guys Lynyrd Skynyrd mentions in Sweet Home Alabama. haha. But I stay busy most of the time & it's something I enjoy, but hell man, keep in touch. My email is marshallsteve1234@yahoo.com

  • @SGFrySG
    @SGFrySG 9 років тому +5

    I think i'm in love

  • @redastrachan8978
    @redastrachan8978 6 років тому

    Your usual great work!

  • @dennisstilwell8116
    @dennisstilwell8116 4 роки тому +1

    I had the joy and privilege of being at the cape during the last launch of the Saturn 5. It took our 1st space station into orbit. What surprised and amazed me was how loud the engines were. The entire earth shook for what seemed like at least 5 minutes. Oh how I treasure that memory.

    • @jlevesque5907
      @jlevesque5907 3 роки тому

      I loved the Apollo and the shuttle missions. I was 13 when Skylab launched inside the last Saturn V. I never did get to see an actual launch, not even the Space Shuttle missions. Hopefully I'll get to see/experience a future launch.

  • @Teeebs
    @Teeebs 8 років тому +4

    The Saturn V is such a beautiful piece of engineering. Space nerd porn...

  • @ronaldtartaglia4459
    @ronaldtartaglia4459 8 років тому +16

    you love rockets! so dreamy♡♡♡

  • @ptonpc
    @ptonpc 8 років тому

    I've watched the Saturn launches many times and it never occurred to me this would be the reason why that paint scheme was used. Thanks

  • @WhirligigGirl
    @WhirligigGirl 9 років тому

    I am so happy now. I'm not the only one who realized that the Saturn rockets had different paint than the one model kits have you paint.

  • @pforce9
    @pforce9 8 років тому +7

    When I see the Saturn Rocket, I get really pissed that they never got to the next step which was the "Nova Rocket".

    • @jamallabarge2665
      @jamallabarge2665 5 років тому

      Been neat to see one. When the Nova concept came out Orbital Rendezvous was not considered possible. Figured that they'd need a giant spaceship to land on the moon then launch itself back to Earth. Someone got orbital rendezvous to work, you could have a separate lunar lander. This slashed weight required to be lifted into orbit.
      The Nova wasn't really necessary. I agree - would have been cool for them to at least build one.
      I'd suspect that the next moon mission will use conventional rockets, to lift various parts and pieces into orbit. They'll arrange to string them all together. Send them on their way.

  • @overbank56
    @overbank56 7 років тому +14

    the greatest rocket EVER MADE!

    • @pauljones3017
      @pauljones3017 7 років тому +2

      For now.

    • @fiveoneecho
      @fiveoneecho 7 років тому +2

      Falcon 9 FT is pretty awesome because it auto lands, but yes, the Saturn V is an amazing contraption in its careful yet haphazard design!

    • @overbank56
      @overbank56 7 років тому

      Cole Smith : why do you say, "haphazard" design?

    • @JFrazer4303
      @JFrazer4303 6 років тому

      Energia was the best. It only flew a few times, but the way it was made and was conducive to different uses was a big part.

    • @cjeppinga
      @cjeppinga 6 років тому

      I dont know that lOKI might be my fav... Jk jk lol

  • @MrAndy9572ac
    @MrAndy9572ac 7 років тому

    Soooo awesome. Thanks for doing these videos 😄😄😄

  • @jpsned
    @jpsned 4 роки тому

    The first Saturn V model I ever bought had the 500-F paint scheme--it was as late as 1969. So, as a kid, I was really confused by the images of Apollo 11 rocket with the newer scheme. I was then happy to get a newer version of the model with the updated paint patterns soon after--made me feel grown up!

  • @CatspitProductions
    @CatspitProductions 8 років тому +12

    It's a beautiful machine and to me is a man made wonder of the world along with the Shuttle program, Hubble and ISS. How could none of these make the 7 modern man made wonders of the world list? Hubble alone has made more discoveries than any other telescope in mans history. profound discoveries too ;) Come get some Catspit~!

    • @frankroberts9320
      @frankroberts9320 8 років тому +3

      Unfortunately they just barely got edged out by perforated toilet paper.

    • @cjeppinga
      @cjeppinga 6 років тому +1

      Its too bad we pretty much screwed our space program with the shuttle program...

  • @flameout12345
    @flameout12345 9 років тому +5

    Need Hello Kitty on those rocket

  • @richardlewis7471
    @richardlewis7471 4 роки тому +1

    Best paint scheme ever. And thanks to you even more interesting.

  • @kevindean294
    @kevindean294 6 років тому

    Another great vid Amy thanks

  • @911gpd
    @911gpd 7 років тому +15

    Let's build a 110m high dummy rocket for fun guys :D

  • @leokimvideo
    @leokimvideo 8 років тому +340

    A girl talking rocket science, feel right to me

    • @DDG2023
      @DDG2023 7 років тому +68

      Shew, Thank God. You have no idea how long we've been waiting for your approval.
      Quick, someone call the OP with permission to go ahead. This guy said it's OK.

    • @Graphicstodiefor
      @Graphicstodiefor 7 років тому +1

      lol

    • @Graphicstodiefor
      @Graphicstodiefor 7 років тому +5

      condescending much ?

    • @gavbag1234
      @gavbag1234 7 років тому +28

      @DDG, I don't think you mean it as such, but that was an extremely unhelpful and unproductive way to communicate and promote your values to strangers.
      The guy made a comment about how good it is to see a girl discussing rocket science, and you mock that as a statement of his "approval". That is sexist, divisive bullshit. You are deliberately twisting his words ostensibly on the basis of his gender, but certainly not on anything he actually said.
      What you did was bad for equality, and bad for all involved. I hope you understand this isn't me saying you're a bad person, just that I believe what your approach here is contrary to even your own interests, and I suggest you reconsider it.

    • @Bob3D2000
      @Bob3D2000 7 років тому +13

      Whilst the reaction to the comment was somewhat over the top, it remains that the fact of the presenter being female shouldn't be worthy of note.

  • @alitlweird
    @alitlweird 7 років тому

    You're awesome! I love your passion for this stuff!! 😀

  • @CHAS1422
    @CHAS1422 3 роки тому

    Great channel, love your reporting. Thanks

  • @jmcenanly1
    @jmcenanly1 9 років тому +3

    Why do the paintings and CGI of the SLS have the same black and white paint scheme as the Saturn V? Is it some practical reason, or just to evoke the old Apollo era?

    • @AmyShiraTeitel
      @AmyShiraTeitel  9 років тому +1

      I am not actually sure about that, but I'm going to look it up now! I assume it's a similar heat-related issue. But then again since it's still CGI concept art it might be more aesthetic for the moment. I think we'll have to see what the flight article comes out looking like.

    • @BlakeHelms
      @BlakeHelms 9 років тому

      I really hope they keep it, it's so iconic. The first two shuttle flights had white external tanks which meant the entire stack was either black or white as well. This changed later due to weight savings from by not painting them.

    • @donaldbrown1100
      @donaldbrown1100 9 років тому +1

      Amy Shira Teitel The flight article will have an orange tank like the shuttle. NASA has already confirmed.

    • @WarriorOfHonor16
      @WarriorOfHonor16 9 років тому

      Blake Helms definitely agree - with the Apollo missions drifting further and further away from us as years go by I think the reverence of that paint scheme is all the more appropriate.

    • @MrxFivexAlive
      @MrxFivexAlive 9 років тому

      James Mcenanly It`s probably so that they can tell whether the rocket is rotating or not.

  • @callanhutchison1871
    @callanhutchison1871 7 років тому +4

    She's sooooooo...smart

    • @skyeplaysgames6734
      @skyeplaysgames6734 6 років тому

      Nissim Levy you wouldn't say that if she was male would you

  • @ihavetopis9514
    @ihavetopis9514 8 років тому +1

    I can bear these types of high-pitched panic voices for about 1 minute max.

  • @teenagerinsac
    @teenagerinsac 8 років тому +4

    Too bad she wasn't around to see one fly live :)

  • @alexabadi7458
    @alexabadi7458 8 років тому +3

    I now feel much smarter...

  • @oscarnarvaez6108
    @oscarnarvaez6108 8 років тому +1

    First time I watch a video like this, and hope I have enough time to
    watch all your videos and find out some space stuff I want to know
    Bravo!

  • @captainbc52
    @captainbc52 9 років тому +2

    that little side smile at 2:43 tho....made me smile :)

  • @jgbusquets
    @jgbusquets 5 років тому +4

    Damn, she speaks fast XDD I can follow her listening at 0,75x speed XDD

    • @CFO404
      @CFO404 3 роки тому +2

      Did she said something? 🤤

  • @richardmyhan8755
    @richardmyhan8755 7 років тому +3

    Because the V2 was black & white.

  • @redspider2005
    @redspider2005 9 років тому +2

    Fritz Lang's silent science fiction German film "Flau im Mond" showed audience in 1929 about the white and black rocket. It gave Wernher Von Braun and German rocketeers an idea to paint white and black experimental V-2 rockets in Germany and then America. Soviet Union wanted to paint green on the ballistic missiles and experimental rockets. Wernher von Braun and NASA had painted white and black rockets since 1958. They added the red letter marks "United States" or "USA" and the American flags. Black and white paint on the rockets became famous and popular. They are still used in years or decades.

  • @Mesabi193
    @Mesabi193 7 років тому

    I have always wondered about this! Since building a model when I was a kid... I remember painting over that middle ring, even though the directions said to have the black ring there. Lol. Now all these years later, I know why! Thanks again.

  • @ArmyJames
    @ArmyJames 5 років тому +46

    We got to the moon before the Soviets mainly because our Germans were better than their Germans.

    • @theworkshopmechanicchannel3296
      @theworkshopmechanicchannel3296 5 років тому

      Иван Кузнецов
      Some of these people had a German background

    • @donaldculp3759
      @donaldculp3759 5 років тому

      Hey Hank.....if Trump has his way, there will be only 1 candidate in 2020. He’s Putin’s puppet and N Korea’s court jester. But sorry, this is about Apollo rockets. True that Von Braun was instrumental in the early first 15 years but then American engineers took it from there

    • @donaldculp3759
      @donaldculp3759 5 років тому +1

      Oh Hank. Comon.....you’re talking to a guy who’s Dad entire career was at NASA right before Mercury and he retired right before Challenger. Later, I worked there too. We went to the moon. Deal with it. 100,000 peo0le cannot keep a lie secret for 50 years! And then there’s the chemistry of the moon rocks that don’t match Earth rocks....hmmmm.....please

    • @Cynthia_Cantrell
      @Cynthia_Cantrell 5 років тому

      The Moon Nazis got there first. ;)

    • @kevrob1784
      @kevrob1784 5 років тому

      we cant leave low earth orbit ask any modern NASA astronaut, gone to the moon 😂

  • @fitty77
    @fitty77 8 років тому +21

    How sexy it is, to see a girl talking about rockets and saying she loves them... :) Respectfully

    • @zoidburg2975
      @zoidburg2975 5 років тому

      Don't really get why some guys like it when girls like masculine stuff...

    • @commentatron
      @commentatron 5 років тому +1

      @@zoidburg2975 You mean you don't like it when a girl likes your 'masculine stuff.'

    • @Thenotfunnyperson
      @Thenotfunnyperson 5 років тому +1

      She know how to get the blood boiling.

  • @mnicholson66
    @mnicholson66 7 років тому

    I just wanted to point out something about the Saturn V. In this video you mentioned that it was the largest Saturn rocket ever made. Not only that, but the Saturn V has the distinction of being the most powerful machine ever built by mankind. That is an awesome quality.

  • @ajmittendorf
    @ajmittendorf 8 років тому

    Sharp. Clear. Professional. Additionally, this is an unexpected, unique and surprisingly educational commentary. Bravissima!

  • @vector6977
    @vector6977 8 років тому +10

    Would it be because most of the cameras were black and white at the time?

  • @jaridkeen123
    @jaridkeen123 6 років тому +44

    She is really cute

    • @bigsid54
      @bigsid54 6 років тому

      Adorable pushing fake NASA!

    • @Victor-wy7yc
      @Victor-wy7yc 6 років тому +13

      bigsid54 You are fake

    • @bipbong2906
      @bipbong2906 6 років тому +5

      Jarid Gaming please don’t start this shit

    • @starshot5172
      @starshot5172 6 років тому +1

      Jarid Gaming creep

    • @commentatron
      @commentatron 5 років тому +1

      As well as lovely, attractive, fetching and comely.

  • @thomasdiefenbach2624
    @thomasdiefenbach2624 7 років тому

    First time seeing you, you did a great job! Thanks for an interesting discussion of what would seem to be a simple question but has an interesting history.

  • @robertgriggs8636
    @robertgriggs8636 3 роки тому

    I just love these videos.

  • @PedroIvoGaldinodaCostabrasil
    @PedroIvoGaldinodaCostabrasil 9 років тому +3

    I am in love for you Amy Shira S2

  • @youreale
    @youreale 8 років тому +3

    I love your posts and I love all Apollo stuff, but i am afraid that I can just follow 40% of your talk. My processor is not fast enough.

  • @IanKemp1960
    @IanKemp1960 8 років тому

    Thank you I loved this video... just the right amount of detail and a no-nonsense explanation :-)

  • @TheTimpan01
    @TheTimpan01 7 років тому

    Straight to the point and interesting. Liked.

  • @joesmith9330
    @joesmith9330 7 років тому +4

    THE SATURN WAS BLACK AND WHITE CAUSE IT WAS A FORMAL OCCASION AND THEY FORGOT THE PINK PAINT

  • @sbentjies
    @sbentjies 9 років тому +53

    Smart and pretty-killer combination ;)

    • @stuffanthings
      @stuffanthings 7 років тому +2

      Yep que cards are pretty

    • @macstrong1284
      @macstrong1284 6 років тому +13

      +stuffanthings She has a Master's degree in Arts and a minor degree in Science and Technology Studies, which I imagine far outranks whatever "expertise" you think you possess. God, I love that in 2018, women still can't be taken seriously at face-value when discussing STEM subjects and are written off as "pretty faces reading *CUE* cards", as opposed to their male counterparts becoming infallible national celebrities.

    • @NihongoGuy
      @NihongoGuy 6 років тому +2

      Well stated, mac.

  • @jimsvideos7201
    @jimsvideos7201 5 років тому

    Good on you for putting this together; your presentation of it is compelling also.

  • @jameswaugh8339
    @jameswaugh8339 8 років тому

    Excellent research work and articulate, detailed report, young lady.

  • @Barzins1
    @Barzins1 9 років тому +76

    Slow down. It's hard to follow you as you rapid-fire information. But, also, thanks for the information.

    • @SMGJohn
      @SMGJohn 7 років тому +3

      LOL fucking Americans, tiny attention span.

    • @Barzins1
      @Barzins1 7 років тому +17

      ***** that may be true, but I don't think I'm proof of that. I was born in Iran.

    • @3seven5seven1nine9
      @3seven5seven1nine9 7 років тому +14

      I like how people think Americans are xenophobic but it's always people like SMGJohn proving stereotypes opposite

    • @no1DdC
      @no1DdC 7 років тому +1

      Non native speaker here. Most people are talking too slowly. She's just doing it right. Why bother wasting time?

    • @Barzins1
      @Barzins1 7 років тому +10

      no1DdC if most people speak too slow, by definition, slow is the normal rate of speech. Even if it were not, if the presenter wants most people to understand what he is saying, he has to slow down.

  • @mollyfilms
    @mollyfilms 8 років тому +100

    Crikey woman! Breath!!!!

    • @jacklav1
      @jacklav1 8 років тому +5

      +Lee Curran e

    • @SiskinOnUTube
      @SiskinOnUTube 8 років тому +1

      +Lee Curran It does seem that everybody on UA-cam wants me to have a headache when I leave their video. Non-stop.

    • @SiskinOnUTube
      @SiskinOnUTube 8 років тому

      +Jack Lavender I think when you are driven to hyperventilate, missing an e, is no big deal.

    • @Wildstar40
      @Wildstar40 8 років тому +2

      +Lee Curran
      Wow you can smell her breath from there with your dog nose ?
      Or were you really saying she should breathe ?

    • @orangejoe204
      @orangejoe204 8 років тому +8

      I find her flawless and breathless delivery highly impressive. I presume, based on the production values, she's reading off a Teleprompter.

  • @zaguar3153
    @zaguar3153 7 років тому

    That's a nifty bit of trivia - thank you, Vintage Space!

  • @johnnystek6900
    @johnnystek6900 7 років тому

    just came across this channel today, love it...............

  • @whome6878
    @whome6878 5 років тому +4

    To believe we went to the moon 50 years ago but can't go now, isn't just gullable and irresponsible, it's vintage stupid!

    • @bxdanny
      @bxdanny 5 років тому +2

      It took time to build the rockets and the spacecraft they carried, as well as build the infrastructure on the ground for "mission control", and get trained people in place to run it. With several years lead time, we could do it again. But right now, we can't. And why would we do all that again?

    • @ArmyJames
      @ArmyJames 5 років тому +2

      We CAN go - but it costs money which nobody wants to spend.

    • @SteverRob
      @SteverRob 5 років тому

      Who says we "can't go now"? Where do you guys get this? Has anyone been paying any attention at all to NASA's Space Launch System/Artemis 1 and 2?

    • @neilbishop1686
      @neilbishop1686 4 роки тому

      @@SteverRob Its not that we couldn't or can't go now..but so far we don't have a ready to launch and go system at present...

  • @milanap3547
    @milanap3547 7 років тому +74

    Why this woman talk so fast? This like the end of commercial for medications.

    • @AmyShiraTeitel
      @AmyShiraTeitel  7 років тому +50

      "This woman" gets excited when she's passionate about sharing something cool!

    • @marklandgraf7667
      @marklandgraf7667 7 років тому +6

      Yes, but hardly any creaky voice. Big plus there!

    • @fattmouth7715
      @fattmouth7715 7 років тому +5

      Because she is a professional.

    • @BarbikaPahor
      @BarbikaPahor 7 років тому +2

      especially phallic objects like rockets that penetrated to space.

    • @danahan01
      @danahan01 7 років тому +1

      BarbikaPahor
      You said "penetrated". You must be smart or something................................

  • @squatch545
    @squatch545 5 років тому

    I've always wondered about this, especially when I was building Saturn V models as a kid in the 1960s. Thanks!

  • @TheStockwell
    @TheStockwell 7 років тому

    I've just discovered this channel and need to say what a relief it is to find a fact-filled channel where the host is the actual smarty-pants behind the writing. UA-cam has too many channels where a team of researchers turn their script over to a hot-looking face-for-hire who has no idea what it all means - but reads script really well.
    You, on the other hand, are your very own hot-looking and brilliant writer/presenter. How convenient and reassuring is THAT?
    No - thank YOU!

  • @furnaletto
    @furnaletto 8 років тому +17

    to fast speaking......slow a little....bit :)

    • @Wildstar40
      @Wildstar40 8 років тому +10

      +Silvio S
      Click settings,click speed and slow her down yourself ! LOL !

    • @samsignorelli
      @samsignorelli 6 років тому

      She's still slower than I am on MY UA-cam channel....

  • @kdfox2007
    @kdfox2007 8 років тому

    Wow, first time viewing your VLOG and despite a life time following NASA, I learned so much from just this short 3 min. video. Great job!.

  • @BlakeHelms
    @BlakeHelms 9 років тому

    The 500D also has the black ring. It was used for vibration tests at the Marshall Space Flight Center. It's now displayed here in my home state of Alabama at the US Space and Rocket Center. We love our Saturn V!

  • @K6III450MHZ
    @K6III450MHZ 8 років тому

    Amy I was 9 when they stepped on the moon. Like millions perhaps billions I saw it live with our entire family around the console color TV in my grandmothers front room. You cannot be more than 20 if that. It is so cool to see a person 3 generations past me still interested in what was the most important science and technology marvel of that day. I subscribed, oh and I didn't know why the rockets were painted that way, so you learn something new every day. Peace and get your butt through school.

  • @harrytodhunter5078
    @harrytodhunter5078 6 років тому

    Great video!

  • @kevinsullwold2388
    @kevinsullwold2388 7 років тому

    You are a wealth of interesting knowledge!

  • @MrMarinaca
    @MrMarinaca 7 років тому

    Great explanation. Thanks!

  • @TheFretwalker8
    @TheFretwalker8 3 роки тому

    I am fortunate enough to see every NASA space launch beginning with the Mercury program. Back then it was spectacular.

  • @korky5214
    @korky5214 7 років тому

    Love to know what job you do, thank you love the information.

  • @MichaelRandazzophotoguy
    @MichaelRandazzophotoguy 7 років тому

    Love that young people are continuing the history of our Space program. I have a 5 foot Saturn 5 in my living room. I'm 62. LOL Keep up the great work.

  • @BCBtrucks64
    @BCBtrucks64 2 роки тому

    just finished watching the doco on the Apollo space program and in amazement once again at the launch and stage separation of Apollo 10 and 11 to watch them rockets powering up through our atmosphere is just all inspiring

  • @javierperales4432
    @javierperales4432 6 років тому

    I love your videos! You're so cool.

  • @meme5546
    @meme5546 7 років тому

    As an electronic engineer, I would guess in addition to the roll of the rocket, checked and striped lines are good indicators for the orientation of the craft but also in failure analysis. any deformation prior to catastrophic failure would be identified and the origin of the problem can easily be pinpointed. However it can also be used to measure the oscillation frequency of the modules to determine changes is resonance during flight. Right after the launch, all video material is sent to the engineering department and all data that can be abstracted are analyzed from that material. They can indicate resonance, orientation, deformation, separation and catastrophic failure.
    One thing I learned over the years, one thing more important than the success of the mission is the data you can gather from that mission. Regardless if that mission is a success or not, to ensure future missions are safer and better planned with less risk and uncertainties is critical. For that we need data and tons of it.