Why Score Matters. What Hollywood Forgot

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 тра 2024
  • Saw this really cool Bollywood movie and really wanted to talk about it. Copyright went crazy with this one had to do some real degenerate stuff.
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 285

  • @DJ-lk6xy
    @DJ-lk6xy Місяць тому +244

    Finally he didn’t pronounced Punjab as “POONJAAB”

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +52

      I still do it sometime but my girlfriend threatens to hit me every time I mispronounce it so I'm starting to get better 😂

    • @NikhileshSurve
      @NikhileshSurve 21 день тому +2

      Probably coz he has heard the correct pronunciation & not simply relying on the spelling.

  • @SRJ7798
    @SRJ7798 29 днів тому +107

    The best Indian movie that I ever saw was "Tumbaad". The score and cinematography was outstanding.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому +15

      I'll add to list! Thank you!

    • @vinaykumarkharwar177
      @vinaykumarkharwar177 28 днів тому +15

      The score for Tumbbad was by Jesper Kyd, the musician for Assassin's Creed games. Possibly the most ominous sounds I gave heard in Indian Cinema.

    • @parinikasharma317
      @parinikasharma317 28 днів тому +4

      Tumbbad is freaking awesome

    • @IraserH
      @IraserH 24 дні тому

      @@vinaykumarkharwar177holy that makes so much sense!

    • @AnupBhatt
      @AnupBhatt 23 дні тому +1

      @@QVanGhoul Watch the movie "Rangeela" from 1996. It has scores by Indian musical maestro A R Rehman. The west would recognize him from his Oscar for scoring the background of Slumdog Millionaire.
      It is a "coming of age" movie for India as much as it is for the characters.

  • @spilltea4241
    @spilltea4241 29 днів тому +145

    Some Indian films with great OST
    Bombay (1995)
    Dil Se (1998)
    Barfi (2012)
    Life in a metro (2007)
    Veer-Zaara (2004)
    Swades (2004)
    Jalshagar (1958)
    Pyaasa (1957)
    arvind desai ki ajeeb dastaan (1978)
    Death in the Gunj (2016)
    Kal Ho na Ho (2003)
    Taal (1999)
    Mughal-e-azam (1960)
    Pakeezah (1972)
    Lagaan (2001)
    Rang De Basanti (2005)
    Guru (2007)
    Devdas (2002)
    DevD (2009)
    Choker Bali (2003)
    Sairat (2016)
    Jodha Akbar (2008)
    Sathiya (2002)
    Zindagi na milegi dobara (2011)
    Sagara Sangamam (1983)

    • @rahulvinalnarayan9743
      @rahulvinalnarayan9743 29 днів тому +7

      Brilliant list of films. I might also add Mohobatein and Zubeida to this list

    • @ArvindKumar-me6sw
      @ArvindKumar-me6sw 29 днів тому +4

      +Sita ramam

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому +15

      Thank you! This feels like a very complete list. I see their are a few examples from the 50's. Which is very exciting, in Western cinema I find that to be a most interesting era for film, so very excited to see Indian films from that time period.

    • @IAmAthulKishor
      @IAmAthulKishor 28 днів тому +10

      *proceeds to tell only Bollywood films in the name of Indian films* 💀

    • @vigneshsubramanian2511
      @vigneshsubramanian2511 28 днів тому +2

      Add Sadma Ilayaraja the goat

  • @mbanerjee5889
    @mbanerjee5889 28 днів тому +36

    To say DDLJ changed Bollywood cinema would be a huge understatement. The 90s rom-com era had incredible music, not just songs, MUSIC. It used to be that every movie had songs and medeolies that would interweave into each other and throughout the movie itself (DTPH, KKHH, K3G, Mohabbatein, etc.) Sadly a lot of these leitmotifs are also starting to disappear from newer Bollywood movies.
    I think the only recent Hollywood movie that did this well is Encanto, and even that was 3 years ago.

  • @Akash_Xavier_Rai
    @Akash_Xavier_Rai 24 дні тому +44

    You should also watch the Shakespearean bollywood interpretations.
    Maqbool (2003): Macbeth
    Haider (2014): Hamlet
    Ram-leela (2013): Romeo and Juliet
    Omkara (2006): Othello
    These are amazing Shakespear interpretations that the world needs to watch.

    • @TheRishijoesanu
      @TheRishijoesanu 23 дні тому +3

      Joji (2021) is the best Shakespearen adaptation in Indian cinema

    • @Akash_Xavier_Rai
      @Akash_Xavier_Rai 22 дні тому +1

      @@TheRishijoesanu Thanks for the recommendation. I will check it out

  • @deogiriyadav8399
    @deogiriyadav8399 Місяць тому +59

    Although we have so many amazing movies.... But in 2021 ... Bollywood gave us the best historical movie ever.... Sardar udham... 2021 ... Check out this movie.... N i m sure... Its impossible to forget about this movie.... This movie shows the real meaning of colonialism.... The brutality by english in India.....

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +14

      That sounds very interesting. Definitely going on my watch list. Thank you

    • @deogiriyadav8399
      @deogiriyadav8399 Місяць тому +2

      @@QVanGhoul hmm... It's a slowburn... So this movie need some patience... Believe me... This movie will completely change ur perception about India... Indians... Indian movies.... And british.....
      N some scenes are really heart wrenching.... So strictly prohibited for under 18....n thank me later....
      Good luck...

    • @spilltea4241
      @spilltea4241 29 днів тому

      @@QVanGhoul its a great movie

    • @arnavranka4510
      @arnavranka4510 29 днів тому

      ​@@QVanGhoulTrue. An amazing film. Awesome cinematography. No melodrama.

    • @arjundev8797
      @arjundev8797 28 днів тому

      The problem with Indians ,us if we like a movie..we would tag it as best ever..whereas one should always be sure..there is nothing like the best..it's a good movie or a bad movie.. sardaar udham is a good movie..but if u compare with laggan or swadesh...they are also good movies..just because u watched one movie...that's the best movie..no one can beat that..that attitude is wrong..

  • @NikTh181
    @NikTh181 25 днів тому +10

    2:12 this monologue is my favorite too. It carries a sense of alienation, isolation , seclusion and being isolated fro from your motherland. It definitely not for homesickness like me

  • @abyheek7037
    @abyheek7037 Місяць тому +36

    The placement of songs has changed nowadays in Bollywood movies, you will rarely see the running around trees, lip syncing and dance number always, in some movies they are part of the narrative and stay as a background score and a background song

    • @perseusvlasov367
      @perseusvlasov367 28 днів тому +2

      Rarely?? Lol stop covering up

    • @mamamooscake281
      @mamamooscake281 26 днів тому +3

      LoL what ? Did u not see those SRK films lmao. Item songs or songs in general in films are still relevant and will be.

    • @Kitty786kat
      @Kitty786kat 22 дні тому

      ​@@perseusvlasov367what do you mean cover up? Do you think it's bad ? I feel it's better that way but it's true nowadays you see that rarely

    • @gabbar51ngh
      @gabbar51ngh 20 днів тому

      Bollywood is Hollywoodizing.
      Only difference is that star power remains in Bollywood. Instead of IP and franchises, we're having Massy movies.

  • @RespiroOfficial
    @RespiroOfficial 19 днів тому +12

    The one thing you need to remember is that "Bollywood" is not the same as "Indian movies". Regional cinema is as good as the stuff made in Mumbai/North India. For eg. My home of Kerala is famous for its low-budget, well-written and acted films rhat actually manage to recieve National Film Awards from the Central Government ever so often. Some Malayalam films I recommend are:
    - Kireedam (1989): The score alone is up there with stuff like Scorsese's Taxi Driver and other character study films like American Psycho. This is a must watch.
    - Big B (2007): If you like Ryan Gosling's Drive, this is for you.
    - Devasuram (1993)
    - The Great Indian Kitchen
    - Virus
    - Anjaam Paathira
    - Bramayugam (2024)
    - New Delhi (1987)
    - Nadodikaatu
    - Manichitrathazhu (1993)
    Feel free to comment down if you want a more definitive list ☺️

    • @laabh9949
      @laabh9949 12 днів тому +1

      Bro Mollywood has barely started being recognised in Indian media culture thanks to aavesham, there's no way one can expect Americans of all people to realise a Nation can have a film industry in multiple languages

    • @FlauFly
      @FlauFly 4 дні тому +1

      Oh, I absolutely love malayalam cinema. I watch a lot of Indian movies, but the most I watched are malayalam. I explain to people all the time that Bollywood =/= Indian movies.

    • @RespiroOfficial
      @RespiroOfficial День тому +1

      @@FlauFly which are your fav films from Malayalam?

  • @mimbulusmimbletonia9737
    @mimbulusmimbletonia9737 Місяць тому +49

    You definitely should check out Lagaan! I know the people here are giving you loads of recommendations, but I would like to stick with Lagaan simply because this video is about scores, and Lagaan is one extraordinary piece of musical artistry. The composer, AR Rahman, is also the one who won two Oscars and a Grammy for "Jai Ho" from Slumdog Millionaire. Lagaan was also in fact India's official submission to the Oscars that year. Have high hopes, you will definitely not be disappointed :)

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +7

      I really want to. Lagaan came up a few times in comments, and after watching the trailer I can definitely say that I am into it!

  • @kanak4198
    @kanak4198 Місяць тому +19

    My top recommendations: gangs of wasseypur, dev d, andaaz apna apna, masaan, manto, pyaasa, kaagaz ke phool.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      Thanks I'll add those to my watch!

    • @sanjeevsethi6330
      @sanjeevsethi6330 24 дні тому +2

      @@QVanGhoul these are just underrated shit. better start with movies which are very popular. later you can get to the underrated ones, if you really want critical acclaim watch Swades, dangal, bajrangi bhaijaan, top movies by aamir khan and SRK

  • @prachuryyabaruah7
    @prachuryyabaruah7 27 днів тому +11

    Indian youtubers are busy with mocking DDLJ where on the other hand Westerns are appreciating DDLJ. Not a fan of SRK or DDLJ but it seems that we Indians somehow love to mock our own mileatones. No doubt DDLJ has some issues. But every movie had its own.

    • @mankindinc6131
      @mankindinc6131 21 день тому +2

      Like which UA-camr mocked DDLJ?? Please elaborate.

    • @gabbar51ngh
      @gabbar51ngh 20 днів тому +5

      Probably because to indian audience it's not a novelty. To a Western audience it is.
      I find DDLJ product of it's time. A lot of hype and praise is due to nostalgia rather than genuine praise.

    • @prachuryyabaruah7
      @prachuryyabaruah7 7 днів тому

      @@mankindinc6131 Yogi Baba, YBP Filmy, Bnftv ( not specific video but time to time mocks it), And there are many who have done it. Currently no one is coming into mind.

    • @mankindinc6131
      @mankindinc6131 7 днів тому

      @@prachuryyabaruah7 oook

  • @KnightOfNewColu
    @KnightOfNewColu 20 днів тому +2

    No Smoking (2005) has the classiest jazz soundtrack for such a weird, lynchian story

  • @raunee100
    @raunee100 28 днів тому +3

    We've got a new lover of DDLJ here!
    Just so you know:- this is not just a movie but a pure emotion!!! My entire childhood and my happy memories!!! ❣️

  • @Sp00kys0uL_77
    @Sp00kys0uL_77 26 днів тому +5

    If you loved this, you would definitely love Veer Zara.

  • @Ep347
    @Ep347 Місяць тому +20

    Loved the video! You should definitely check out more classic Indian films and give them a try! Nearly every Indian movie uses leitmotifs to the MAX like this. What you found profoundly outstanding about 'DDLJ' is something extremely common. Nothing wrong with that, it's just your first time seeing it! In fact, if you watch many of the other classic films starring Shah Rukh Khan (who plays Raj in 'DDLJ,' you'll see this exact same thing). "Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham," "Kuch Kuch Hota Hai," "Kal Ho Naa Ho," "Dilwale." and more recently "Jawan" just to name a few. These movies all have incredibly iconic scores that any Indian can recognize within just a few notes. Most genres in India do this, from an action flick like "RRR," to even a horror movie like 2024's "Shaitaan." Music is a huge part of Indian movies in every way!

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      Great insight thank you! I definitely plan on checking out classics. I don't know what part of brain does but there just a certain quality to film pre-2000 that I just love! Thank you for the suggestions!

    • @jiminies
      @jiminies 28 днів тому +2

      Dilwale??? I agree with the rest to a certain extent but Dilwale is a total no.

    • @hmmm713
      @hmmm713 27 днів тому +1

      Music really is a huge part of Indian cinema! It's sad to see that nowadays people see it as annoying or outdated. Sure, overused random dance numbers every 10 minutes is distracting, but even just being played as a background score adds so much to the experience of many movies.

  • @diosnelfrica590
    @diosnelfrica590 28 днів тому +3

    Om Shanti Om is a gem. My second favorite SRK movie.

  • @119arshiyaislam8
    @119arshiyaislam8 Місяць тому +8

    You can try Lootera , it's based on the last leaf, a short story by O Henry. Loved the movie, you'd love the score too.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому

      Thank you for the suggestion! Super appreciated

    • @aaditsingh3632
      @aaditsingh3632 28 днів тому

      Ooh my favorite Bollywood movie ever. It wasn’t so meanstream but more artsy, and yet it hit every checkmark that defines a Bollywood movie. Definitely a must watch.

  • @aleenaprasannan2146
    @aleenaprasannan2146 5 днів тому

    Maybe you noticed this in DDLJ, because the theme was more digestable for you. But music and background score having massive importance in just the identity of the movies itself has been a given in all Indian movies forever. We remember movies by iconic music numbers. And movies capitalize on that a heck lot. So much so that, music served the purpose of what movie trailers do now; trailers are fairly a new convention in Indian film industry. They maybe have a even larger purpose because music release of movies were also an important promotional event as well.
    The Malayalam movie industry is currently in limelight in India and Sushin Shyam is the music composer in vogue in the malayalam industry rn. There were 3 back to back malayalam movies, that got pan Indian attention and he scored 2 of them- 'Manjummal Boys' and 'Aavesham'.
    There is 2019 movie 'Kumbalangi Nights' which is becoming like a cult classic if it hasn't already, and Sushin Shyam won a State award for his work in that movie.
    One other big budget movie among the current craze is Aadujeevitham and its scores are done by the Academy award winner A R Rahman, who is like a living legend here and most of the suggestions you've got are movies made iconic with his music

  • @sanzi8
    @sanzi8 20 днів тому

    You're right...the main theme song of ddlj is a feeling...it's nostalgia, it gives that feeling of love and stirrs up your emotions

  • @kirtigupta9753
    @kirtigupta9753 6 днів тому

    The problem with Hollywood is, it doesn't have 7k years of civilization to draw the inspiration from.
    Do remember, the first book on performing arts called "Natya Shastra" was written in India 2500 years ago.
    Also India has the oldest classical music form called Dhrupad. The oldest proof of dance is inscribed in Bhimbetka cave paintings in India.
    So, India has a rich plethora of cultural history to draw inspiration from. India may not be rich in money now but is certainly blessed with a very rich culture.

  • @crasherdgrate
    @crasherdgrate 21 день тому +1

    4:12
    I don’t under why Avengers is always neglected in this regard.
    The theme/BGM was played throughout the promotional stuff, and it’s sort of iconic now

  • @IAmAthulKishor
    @IAmAthulKishor 28 днів тому

    One of the most recent rom com film from down south side on India got real appreciation is "Premalu". The one you should definitely check it out as at this time most of Indian rom coms don't work.

  • @teddyfurstman1997
    @teddyfurstman1997 12 днів тому

    Scores do matter in Movies. Great Video. ❤

  • @arafatkhan5782
    @arafatkhan5782 29 днів тому +4

    Saw Shah Rukh khan in thumnail..had to check out

  • @strawberrylime33
    @strawberrylime33 11 днів тому

    I'm sitting here trying to think of a recent American movie with a killer score that I remember long after the end credits roll. I did really like the score for The Imitation Game.

  • @siddhantshekhar
    @siddhantshekhar 23 дні тому +1

    Sholay (1975). Lot of the suggestions here are not differentiating between score and playback songs. However, Sholay's theme, almost entirely whistled, is as iconic as the DDLJ mandolin theme.

  • @devvvved
    @devvvved 24 дні тому +1

    I wonder how much time it took non-Indians to realise that the guy delivering the monologue starting from 1:51 is the one who also played Mola Ram in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom...

  • @the-right-toe
    @the-right-toe Місяць тому +18

    Some recommendations - 3 idiots, , Andhadhun, Kal Ho Naa Ho, Fan, Dangal.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +3

      Thank you! I think among friends and co-workers 3 idiots is the recommendation I get the most, 100% will check it out

    • @tenemus9624
      @tenemus9624 Місяць тому +1

      @@QVanGhoul You might also check out these ones, they are really good 'like stars on earth' or Taare Zamin Par, 'Talaash'.

    • @user-en8wp8cg6w
      @user-en8wp8cg6w 29 днів тому

      All of them are wack! Go to South watch kgf, bahubali

    • @the-right-toe
      @the-right-toe 29 днів тому

      @@user-en8wp8cg6w Super Deluxe, Aavesham, Sita Ramam, Vikram bola hota toh samajh aata. Par kgf 😂🤣🫵. But Bahubali is good tho

    • @neshwhat702
      @neshwhat702 21 день тому

      I would recommend 12th Fail

  • @carbonic9115
    @carbonic9115 26 днів тому

    Great video!
    Here are some recommendations from me, which i can say go head to head with hollywood movies :)
    Andhadhun (best Indian suspense thriller)
    Swades (gives the best perspective on patriotism)
    Dil se (The best OST of any indian movie imo)
    Dil Chahta Hai (best indian slice of life movie)
    Zindagi na milegi dobara (My comfort movie :D)
    Karwaan (also my comfort movie :D)
    Jab we met (DDLJ but made for the 2000s)
    3 Idiots ( absolutely essential to get into bollywood)
    Gangs of Wasseypur (its like goodfellas or godfather but set in a small town in india)
    Pyaasa (Cult classic from the 1950s, that is still talked about today)

  • @shanAnim8terSeige
    @shanAnim8terSeige 15 днів тому

    The movie "Kisna" also re-uses its score/main theme in various ways to represent the mood of scenes and interactions between the main leads, however I would say it's not done the same way compared to DDLG. Its not a bad thing though! If anything, you can identify "Kisna" because of the main theme due to how relevant it is to the movie's plot. I do recommend giving it a watch (if you haven't already)! Overall...great video❤❤❤

  • @Sirrajj
    @Sirrajj Місяць тому +15

    Some Bollywood classics that are must for any newcomer (all are 2000s films)
    Kuch Kuch hota hai
    Lagaan
    Tere Naam
    Swades
    Hera Pheri 1-2
    3 Idiots
    Jab we met

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +5

      Yes! I've seen Kuch Kuch hota hai what a good movie! On your recommendation just watched the trailer for Lagaan, looks so good! Thank you for the suggestions!

    • @hrishikeshbandgar2162
      @hrishikeshbandgar2162 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@QVanGhoulHere are few other classics:
      1. Life in a Metro
      2. Chhoti si baat
      3. Tadka
      4. Paa
      5. Raid

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +1

      Thank you for the suggestions!

    • @raja-jl9os
      @raja-jl9os Місяць тому

      ​@@hrishikeshbandgar2162 mother India,sholay,mr India, dhoom series

    • @Filmyzaada
      @Filmyzaada Місяць тому +1

      @@QVanGhoulwatch andhadhun

  • @AADIBAWA
    @AADIBAWA 19 днів тому +3

    DDLJ IS EMOTION,,,,,,,,,

  • @DimaRakesah
    @DimaRakesah 11 днів тому

    So glad to see fellow Americans finally appreciating Indian cinema! 🥰

  • @arpitapatil9290
    @arpitapatil9290 29 днів тому +1

    Explanation
    Description of the story
    Best
    Why people are interested in India I don't know from ancient age till now?❤

  • @vednigavekar5270
    @vednigavekar5270 Місяць тому +7

    I'm a little curious. Which movies did your girlfriend show you as your first introduction to Bollywood? Before DDLJ?

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +4

      I think I was a little harsh in the video if I were to re-watch some of them I'm sure I'd give them a better review then hot garbage.
      First she showed me Ajab prem ki gazab kahani, yeh jawaani hai diwaani, Gangubai(I actually really liked this one) and Kabhi Khushi Kabhi Gham.
      I've seen about a dozen since DDLJ, but it is still by far the favourite. A real 10/10 for me

    • @SuhaniPal-pz1ev
      @SuhaniPal-pz1ev Місяць тому +7

      @@QVanGhoul if you liked gangubai, i would recommend you movies like, Dangal, Highway(has same lead actress from gangubai) and Queen you would get how bollywood feminism is different from hollywood.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +1

      Thanks for the recommendations! Sounds like something my girlfriend would like too, we'll probably try and watch this weekend.

    • @1S9N7
      @1S9N7 Місяць тому +1

      I was wondering the same thing. Azab Prem Ki gazab kahani is straight trash ngl. There are some like that & you can just tell from the acting. Once you watch the films especially the older ones with an open mind you will most likely enjoy them. & of course always keep in mind these films are made for Indians not necessarily for westerners so whenever you don’t get something it’s bc you have no exposure/connection or just not as much in-depth experiential understanding of it. I feel thats the best way for a non-Indian to enjoy these films is to just keep an open mind. & most of these films are meant to just make you laugh & forget about life or just feel something & you can always tell from beginning of the film if it’s going to succeed or not by the director, acting & the music.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      I'm glad to hear someone else say that movie is trash 😂. But yes super well said. Whenever interacting with a cultural different than yours an open mind is so important. In the instance of Bollywood once I just accepted that every movie is going to have musical numbers I started having way more fun with it. I digress super important to be said, thank you!

  • @nehayadav772
    @nehayadav772 21 день тому

    You must be a huge music lover to notice all of these deep things about music's role in Indian movies.

  • @Namitesh1
    @Namitesh1 Місяць тому +8

    This was perfectly done! Great video man! Finally some video where they talk about bollywood music and their soundtrack.
    I guess, you have to make a video on Mohobatein, it has many songs and also a great violin theme, also the Raj in DDLJ is also there as Raj only.
    P.S.- Seek your gfs help to translate the song, they are fun but have meaning too.
    I will be waiting.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      Thank you for the support! I've seen Amitabh Bachchan in a few other movies now and I think he is a fantastic actor! Will absolutely check out Mohobatein!

    • @Namitesh1
      @Namitesh1 Місяць тому +2

      @@QVanGhoul Oh that’s great, Amitabh bacchan is undoubtedly one of the best actors. His acting is getting better as he is getting older, try his movies after 2000s. One suggestion would be Sarkar, Indian version of Godfather(just the plot). But very well done. And my man, if you are coming to the party, then Gangs of Wasseypur both the parts will make you go berserk(just see the reviews of IMDB) 🤌
      Hope you will make more video essays, maybe some nerdwriter shit on bollywood movies. 🤌

  • @Fantasty-mn1dc
    @Fantasty-mn1dc Місяць тому +4

    i recommend u to listen to the albums of the bollywood movies DevD and Haider
    they have one of the best albums ive heard

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      Thank you I will! I'll put it one while I'm working this week!

    • @shivangijha3150
      @shivangijha3150 28 днів тому +1

      ​@@QVanGhoul the first thing you should do is to watch these movies..it's honestly good

  • @rolosilver3256
    @rolosilver3256 6 днів тому

    You should check out K3G, the Bahubali duology, and the YRF Spy Universe

  • @WorldandSumeet
    @WorldandSumeet 27 днів тому

    A good project for you would be analysing the bg score of another SRK movie Swades.

  • @subhankarsaha3638
    @subhankarsaha3638 Місяць тому +10

    Great analysis❤
    Here is some other recommendations
    Ega(makhi) & Bahubali 😊

  • @AmitSunar3092
    @AmitSunar3092 19 днів тому +1

    But Sadly Since 2015 Music Now in Bollywood is just CRAP only Remixes of old song . I would Say only The South Indian Movie Industries are Doing great JOB and keeping the Indian Music alive.

  • @nujuheh
    @nujuheh 11 днів тому

    if you are looking more 'palatable' bollywood movies for a beginner (i get its not that you're calling it unbearable, more like its too foreign to get the essence at one catch) then i suggest some indie style movies within bollywood. Dangal, Barfi!, Queen are some good picks, each with their own signature tune to be remembered as 'that movie'.
    Its also interesting that you found having an dedicated score a strong plus for indian cinema but i would also argue (as an avid watcher myself lol) that they sometimes overuse or depend SOLELY on the score alone to get popular. FYI the modern music industry in india is heavily intertwined with movies to the fact that artists releasing an album/song that ISNT featured in a movie is unheard of. Ofc the internet and spotify is helping to give artists a new route, but it still rarely broke any of the known bollywood singers level of popularity. My point is that, good movies have good scores, bad movies can still have good scores and ppl will eat it up for the score alone. it may or may not lead to an abusive system at the hands of bollywood.

  • @areeedan2889
    @areeedan2889 11 днів тому

    I am Indian, so I have to come. Stayed for Ui-mama. And subscribed for the logic.

  • @vypa-bk1iy
    @vypa-bk1iy 21 день тому

    Im your 200th subscriber

  • @NikhileshSurve
    @NikhileshSurve 21 день тому

    Growing I only watched Indian films on TV & whenever a song started I'd change the channel coz I always hated & still hate being interrupted in the middle of film watching by some songs where they change the location out of nowhere or start dancing. My parents scolded me but I never liked listening to filmy songs, of course there are some exceptions. But after I started watching hollywood films I found out a film doesn't need to interrupt the story with songs which made me like hollywood films although now due to less interesting stories I've lost interest in them a bit.
    Also it's important to note that USA has a vibrant independent music industry & India doesn't in any language. I think the reason is all Indian music industries are dependant on their respective film industries which prevents them from growing. That's why we don't have music superstars outside the film industry who could sell albums & sell big concert tickets on their own coz only the albums of films get sold. Punjabi music industry may be an exception & probably coz Punjabi film industry itself isn't that big to make Punjabi music industry dependant on it.

  • @ak12gamer
    @ak12gamer Місяць тому +11

    This movie is a master peice! U should checkout more bollywood or indian films. One i would recomend is "RRR" it is a action period musical ( every indian film has music so its not technicaly a musical ) u are underrated keep up the good work :)

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +7

      Thank you so much! I'm really trying to watch more Bollywood. My girlfriend is trying to teach me some basic Hindi, so the end goal is to be able to watch without subtitles 😂

    • @vednigavekar5270
      @vednigavekar5270 Місяць тому +1

      I agree, RRR is a great recommendation

    • @Shokunin_Spirit
      @Shokunin_Spirit Місяць тому

      I respect the emotional connection, and I'm not trying to invalidate that. But we've really gotta learn how to appreciate art and playing fast and loose with the word "masterpiece". India has produced world-class filmmakers like Satyajit Ray, Shyam Benegal, Mrinal Sen, Deepa Mehta and many more, and it's a huge disservice to Indian cinema to push regressive films like DDLJ as the best India has to offer.

    • @arnavranka4510
      @arnavranka4510 29 днів тому +1

      ​@@QVanGhoulRRR isn't actually Bollywood though. It was produced by the Telugu film industry, called Tollywood.

    • @ak12gamer
      @ak12gamer 28 днів тому

      @@arnavranka4510 thats why I said bollywood/ ***indian cenima***

  • @bisnu548
    @bisnu548 Місяць тому +4

    *Man watches movie with low as hell imdb score*
    *Man is surprised by the badness*
    *man watches movie with high as hell imdb score*
    *man likes it*
    In other news, water wet 😀
    Not that this is always the case but you get my point.
    Also human emotions go beyond cultures so you didn't like some of em probably not because of the culture but because of something more fundamental.
    But good video.

  • @vigneshsubramanian2511
    @vigneshsubramanian2511 28 днів тому +1

    Im utterly disappointed and also not surprised that no one mentioned Ilayaraja who is the GOAT composer of India. I highly recommend you watch Nayagan (1987), Moondram Pirai/Sadma (1983), Sagara Sangamam (1982 or 83), Hey Ram (2000), Mouna Ragam (1986), Mullum Malarum (1978), and Thalapathi (1991). Kamal Hassans films trump any of the Three Khans films, tho Bollywood films from 70s and earlier give good competition to his films.

  • @sanvan5245
    @sanvan5245 28 днів тому

    The xmen animated 1994 has really good score,i still remember

  • @KanishQQuotes
    @KanishQQuotes 21 день тому

    2:48
    This song even begins to haunt the girl

  • @D_ki_kitab
    @D_ki_kitab 10 днів тому

    I have two movie suggestions 1st secret super star and 2nd Taare zameen par.. they are just too good but only few people talk about them even here

  • @Ursfrndlyneena
    @Ursfrndlyneena Місяць тому +2

    Watch Brahmayugam, it has amazing bgms.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому

      Thank you for the suggestion! I'll check it out

  • @Isotonicdev
    @Isotonicdev 11 днів тому

    one movie i'll like to suggest to watch will be 'karz' which is pretty good

  • @RespiroOfficial
    @RespiroOfficial 19 днів тому

    4:07 I definitely can hum the Avengers theme bro....

  • @painmisery4301
    @painmisery4301 19 днів тому

    Try Tumbbad bro , thats a peak horror movie with amazing cinematography

  • @NadeemShekh-uy9zn
    @NadeemShekh-uy9zn 20 днів тому

    Great video

  • @hayat3428
    @hayat3428 16 днів тому

    I'm not Indian but i can relate to that dialogue about homesickness. But i didn't like this movie as much as i liked other old romantic movies like Chandni and Mr.India. I also loved Drishyam, Andhadhun, Badla, and Kahani, but especially Drishyam. India makes great crime thrillers. Their romance movies can be quite melodramatic, eg K3G. I only liked half of this film, the first half. On the other hand, Jab We Met was great.

  • @g0dsp3ed13
    @g0dsp3ed13 27 днів тому +1

    watch Joji, who’s story is inspired by Shakespeare’s Macbeth.

  • @JuneKafaltiya
    @JuneKafaltiya 16 днів тому

    There is a lot of good stuff that indians themselves do not know beacuse its hella underrated
    1) tumbad
    2) My clients wife
    3) Family man
    4) Ratsasan
    5) Patallok
    And many more pls do check them out
    Also no weired music we have progressed in that department

  • @Whatreally123
    @Whatreally123 Місяць тому

    Top Gun, Terminator, Titanic, Rocky, Predator, Indiana Jones, and some great movies woth great osts.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому

      I didn't mean to discredit Western movies and if it seemed that way I apologize. In the video I even specifically mentioned how great and emotional the Indiana Jones theme is, and more vaguely praised how more classic cinema handled their scores. I was more criticizing a recent industry trend from directors like J.J. Abrams, Joss Whedon, the Russo brothers, etc. To deemphasize the scores which can make a product that feels a little lifeless and hasn't really been able to make many new iconic scores. Not that these directors are bad per se I find it more likely these decisions come from studio interference.
      TLDR yes you are absolutely right and I agree with you. And given all your examples are from pre-2000 I'd wager you probably agree with me too.

  • @ArvindKumar-me6sw
    @ArvindKumar-me6sw 29 днів тому

    And you know what the worst part is ,that even after so many good soundtrack you can't find single one on Spotify,its this with every indian film,like why..when there are soundtracks uploaded for every Hollywood film thenwhy not indiann😭

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому

      REALLY? Is that true? I thought the industry around that was huge in India. That is so surprising. Is their an alternate platform that's being used?

    • @ArvindKumar-me6sw
      @ArvindKumar-me6sw 28 днів тому

      ​@@QVanGhoulnot that I know of,the songs are all out there on utube and Spotify reaching the top list every now and then,but the soundtracks of the same movie,are nowhereee it's like only when there are lyrics the song will be posted on Spotify when there is only music nobody appreciates it this is the problem not with the directors and everybody in the industry but also with the audience,the PPL watching the movies only focus on the songs nobody cares about the background music,so that's also one of the reasons why soundtracks get neglected

  • @snigdhaghosh5865
    @snigdhaghosh5865 28 днів тому +4

    Very well put. Bollywood and most of Indian cinema has always used music as a seamless part of their narration.
    People now days think they are distracting, but back in the day, it was very very important for the music album to be a big hit for the movie to make it mainstream.
    ddlj broke a lot of barriers when it came out. It’s a classic and a masterpiece for a reason.
    Don’t pay heed to the people who intellectualise cinema more than it should be. India has mainly derived entertainment from cinema and that is our Kung fu :)

  • @ragas93
    @ragas93 29 днів тому

    These kind of movies of tradition and modernity are there in most of the Indian movie industries (bollywood being one among them and a big one). For ex, our movie industry (Telugu film industry) made a movie Padamati Sandhya Raagam (The song of the western dusk) in 1987. It's also a romantic comedy that focus on love angle between a traditional indian girl and an american. We still remember "Thomas Jane" ( very underrated actor who later went on to act as the Punisher) from this movie who played the American. The story takes place in US. The movie is available on youtube, but unfortunately there are no subtitles.
    One of the latest to focus on same sex relation is AWE (2018). People liked it!
    The argument between modernity and tradition swings like a pendulum. Not all tradition is bad, but all groups should have self-criticism and reformation.
    And coming to the music aspect of it, Indian movies started as an extension of stage dramas which had poetry sections in them. These are used for more impactful parts of the dramas. This later in the movies transformed into songs which are different from our classical songs and dances. And then came the background scores. Our music for most part in very on the nose and plays the part of a wing man in flattering the audience. This is more so in the southern movie industries whose expression style is highly characterised by intensity. Music tells a story all by itself. For ex: Aditya 369 (1991) is a time travel movie whose title section is very impressive. The music was provided by Ilayaraja (my favourite). It goes from asynchronous clock ticks to grand orchestration matching the visuals that show the montage of time machine development. The hartbreaking theme of the movie Nireekshana (1982) durring the titles is very impressive too. All these are used as leitmotifs through out the respective movies, just like how you mentioned Raj's theme here. These are very important for emotional resonance in the audience. The latest work that I can talk is the RRR (2022) where both the leads got their own themes.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому

      Oo I imagine that one would really hit home with me. definitely going to check out.

    • @deogiriyadav8399
      @deogiriyadav8399 27 днів тому

      Gazab ka nalla h be Tu. 😀😀🤣😀

  • @salahaldin447
    @salahaldin447 29 днів тому

    Watch no smoking and super deluxe if you wanna see real gold.

  • @2301WAYNE
    @2301WAYNE 25 днів тому +1

    Christopher Nolan - And I took that personally and let the score ruined the entire movie!

  • @TSB004
    @TSB004 28 днів тому +3

    Loved the video and I completely agree with your take. India has so many different industries that excel at different things. I would recommend checking out the Malayalam film industry(very underrated) if you like more art house style films. They are usually visually stunning, realistic films with great storytelling and ofc great scores. I would recommend checking out kumbalangi nights, ennu ninte moideen, drishyam, manichithrathazhu, manjummel boys, premam, Charlie, ustad hotel, romancham, maheshinte prathikaram, ayyapanum Kohiyum, urumi, bhramayugam, home, 2018, thallumaala and aavesham. This doesn’t even scratch the surface and I wish I could recommend more but my comment is already so long.

  • @aoibhealfae
    @aoibhealfae 19 днів тому

    John Wick 2's Plastic Heart is great tho

  • @user-qx9bt9tr6t
    @user-qx9bt9tr6t 21 день тому

    Bollywood only produces a small fraction of those 1500-2000 films. And yes, nearly all of the industries (catering to different language-speaking ethnogroups) generally put good effort in the backing tracks always. I am surprised you even heard of the industries as generally, only industries and specific films with good marketing and distribution are known outside their native circles. I wonder where you watched this old film.

  • @abhisp7162
    @abhisp7162 27 днів тому

    If you're looking for good movies which arent boolywood but Indian, I can suggest a few:
    Kanthara, Kirik party, Kasturi Nivasa
    Jai bhim, Badshah, Annamalai, Arunachalam,
    Premam, Bangalore days and many Malayalam movies are good.

  • @rahulray9983
    @rahulray9983 Місяць тому

    Animal released last year has the best BGMs

    • @Yvess44
      @Yvess44 29 днів тому

      Yess bgm is great but not the movie.

  • @loveutube04
    @loveutube04 28 днів тому +2

    He started the video by addressing whities, but no whity is watching the video though

  • @SagarPatil-py9qq
    @SagarPatil-py9qq 28 днів тому

    Love from India 🇮🇳❤️

  • @KanishQQuotes
    @KanishQQuotes 21 день тому

    There's lot of commercial fluff
    But there are always a few jems

  • @pra9391
    @pra9391 11 днів тому

    Hi , you should try this small industry in india called mollywood . Start with this movie called 2018 .

  • @sippymanher3811
    @sippymanher3811 29 днів тому

    how come not a single comment about -
    Rang De Basanti, black, Bhool Bhulaiya,
    Andhadhun, Badhai Do, Thappad, 12th Fail, pink, Tamasha, Masaan, Piku, Queen (these are the latest ones)
    i guess i carried out.... ps sorry for the long list.
    😅😁

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому

      No need to apologize 😂 I am loving how passionate everyone in the comments is about Indian cinema. I am absolutely taking all suggestions to heart. Thank you!

  • @drwriddhimanchattopadhyay2701
    @drwriddhimanchattopadhyay2701 25 днів тому

    Please watch “ 3 idiots “
    “ ZNMD” “ tumbad” “ tare zameen par” etc .

  • @oneriskylife
    @oneriskylife 29 днів тому

    Latest is Animal for good BGM.

  • @Rupalroy-ft9wp
    @Rupalroy-ft9wp 28 днів тому

    I think you should explore more about indian movies because indian movie is not bollywood it has so many languages such as bengali, Marathi, gujrati,Tamil, telugu,kannada, Malayalam, assamese .....these are the indian movies.......you should explore more you will love this industry

  • @EpixGaminginc
    @EpixGaminginc Місяць тому +1

    I yearn for Punjab

  • @thevindicator1220
    @thevindicator1220 26 днів тому

    Bro said the Avengers theme is not iconic or memorable. Bruh, that is the theme that defines this generation

  • @jackowacko007
    @jackowacko007 Місяць тому +10

    Deshdrohi is always amazing.

    • @ak12gamer
      @ak12gamer Місяць тому +12

      Bro what kind of suggestions are u giving him 💀 "deshdrohi and adhipurush will always be disaster movies which torture u till the end" -me

    • @jackowacko007
      @jackowacko007 Місяць тому +2

      @@ak12gamer Mano ya Na Mano, it's a Bollywood cult movie.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +4

      Thank you I'll try and check them both out 😂

    • @subhankarsaha3638
      @subhankarsaha3638 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@QVanGhoul they are joking 😂😂 dont watch those shit or you will surely die

    • @fnmidas7936
      @fnmidas7936 29 днів тому +2

      ​@@QVanGhoulyou'll need a therapy after you done watching that movie

  • @aktab9
    @aktab9 11 днів тому

    Brother my trinity of Bollywood are Gang of wasepur 1 and 2 , Three Idiots and Awara. My favorite 3 Bollywood movies well yes 4. But you get what I say.

  • @rammckee6319
    @rammckee6319 Місяць тому +3

    I'd like to contradict with your opinion. I'm an Indian and I grew up watching Indian cinema. But after watching several Hollywood movies during lockdown, I actually feel otherwise. Now I feel the music in Indian movies (score not the songs) are quite distracting, even though they're good. I feel often in Indian movies, music overshadows the scene and affects my investment in the scene by becoming an element of it's own. It's quite evident in recent movies of S.S. Rajamouli like Baahubali 1 & 2, RRR etc. which have great scores but can be quite overwhelming.
    After watching many movies of auteurs like Spielberg, Scorsese and Nolan, I tend to like more the Hollywood's way of doing it. Where the scenes are accompanied by just the right amount of score to keep us hooked. But still some musical pieces made me pause the movie and immediately look up on Spotify to listen later, like Indiana Jones Main Theme, John Wick theme, Driving with the top down from Ironman, Like a dog chasing cars from Dark Knight, to name a few. I hope Indian movies too tone down the scores.
    PS: This is just my personal opinion and I've never come across another Indian who shared my views.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +3

      I think this is a super valid take! I'm pretty sure the reason I bounced off of Indian movies at first was because the first handful I watched did a particularly poor job with balancing this aspect of the films, with some music numbers I might call frivolous. I think for me I just really connected with it because films from auteurs like the directors you mentioned just aren't always in the cultural mainstream like they used to be (Oppenheimer being an obvious exception). So movies that came out recently feel almost emotionally neutered (might be too harsh). A different approach to scoring like what's present in Indian films was novel to a western like me and was exactly what I needed to wake me up from my apathy for film that I've been feeling recently.
      This is a super interesting and fun discussion point for me! Thank you for leaving your opinion I love hearing different perspectives from people. Most people I talk to don't think about film too deeply like this, so this was really fun for me thank you.

    • @erabhikdasgupta
      @erabhikdasgupta 29 днів тому +2

      The movies you named has music directors for background score who are Oscar worthy. Nolan or Spielberg movie emphasize on background scores beibg prominent. You can listen to them even without the movie. The OSTs are art in itself.
      Imagine the snyder movie Justice League where Flash runs. The reason why its elevated scene is because of the unique score that has been created for it. A lot of Indian movies will have big names in background scores and you will feel the difference in when a background score music director does the backgrrather than the generic music director.
      One Hollywood Music art similar to DDLJ is Titanic. You know the Titanic Theme and you know the emotion everytime it is played. The score is slowed or sped or or played with different instruments to show different emotions. Its played at the saddest scene and the happiest scene and yet you feel different emotions.

    • @rammckee6319
      @rammckee6319 29 днів тому

      @@QVanGhoul The pleasure is mine brother. Keep exploring Indian cinema, not just Hindi cinema but other regional cinemas as well. Regional film industries like Tamil & Malayalam have their own variations in the style of storytelling. Until you watch at least 50 Indian movies, don't expect to end up liking a movie. You may be disappointed. Instead aim to fully experience this style of storytelling. If you're comfortable with it, then keep going. Wishing you a joyful journey 👍

  • @TheRishijoesanu
    @TheRishijoesanu 23 дні тому

    You should check out Malayalam movies. It's the best film industry in India.

  • @ADITYA-qt8zd
    @ADITYA-qt8zd 11 днів тому

    i don't know bro you are on to something

  • @AdityaWaghmare
    @AdityaWaghmare 27 днів тому

    9:55
    Disney/Marvel just became progressively lazy and playing it safe with music and stories where even the origin story of new characters (like Dr Strange) was simple rehash of first Iron Man (young arrogant rich guy goes through crisis and turns into hero).
    The more monopolization Hollywood goes through, the more such issues will plague.

  • @sarathmanoj04mytube
    @sarathmanoj04mytube Місяць тому +3

    Wait till you have seen malyalam movies.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      I think I saw another comment suggesting Ratsasan. Do you have any other recommendations for Malyalam movies?

    • @Fantasty-mn1dc
      @Fantasty-mn1dc Місяць тому

      @@QVanGhoul watch majjumenal boys this movie was relased this year

    • @torilovato9500
      @torilovato9500 29 днів тому

      @@QVanGhoulRatsasan is telgu not malyalam

    • @cobaltpterodactyl
      @cobaltpterodactyl 19 днів тому

      Aavesham! It's got great music!

    • @sarathmanoj04mytube
      @sarathmanoj04mytube 19 днів тому

      @@torilovato9500 tamil bro

  • @prithwin
    @prithwin 20 днів тому

    Dilu ale dhoola niya le jungay

  • @arpitapatil9290
    @arpitapatil9290 29 днів тому

    I never see film this way as u narrating

  • @magnisky
    @magnisky 28 днів тому

    Please thank your girlfriend. She has done you a service. Haha. And thank you for appreciating this movie the way it was intended. 😊 It is an indeed classic for a reason. For all the reasons you have said you were fascinated by this movie, I will recommend the following Bollywood movies:
    1. Kuch Kuch Hota Hai
    2. Kabhi Khushi Khabhi Gham
    3. Kal Ho Na Ho
    4. Jab We Met
    5. Veer-Zara
    6. Fanaa
    7. Devdas
    From 1-4, watch it in that order. From oldest release to newest. 5, 6, 7 are more drama than comedy but again just like the rest the musical scores are something else.
    (I am not gonna suggest shitty cgi movies, those are not the type of Indian movies I go for either).
    Enjoy.

  • @hdl2084
    @hdl2084 Місяць тому +17

    As an Indian I've always had this complaint with Indian movies, that they are very esoteric and not something someone living outside of India and neighboring countries is going to understand particularly well. A lot of them are about cultural phenomenon in India or about some societal ill or something along those lines which won't particularly resonate with a worldwide audience unlike let's say a sci-fi movie. The Indian movie makers also like to play it very safe, so they don't tackle topics which aren't tried and tested in the Indian market and aren't a guaranteed box office success. That being said, it's only natural that out of the 2000 or some odd movies being made each year, a couple of them end up being genuine masterpieces which could be enjoyed by an audience worldwide. Now for some movie recommendations, Veer-Zaara also starring Shahrukh Khan has in my opinion the best soundtrack in a bollywood movie and the best romantic film I've ever seen, it is silly and corny and very much an Indian film of the 2000s but has a charm which any film in India since hasn't been able to replicate. As for a real tear-jerker, Taare Zameer Par is one of the best movies to come out of India imo. Guzaarish from 2010 on the other hand is a lesser-known movie which tells the sad story of a quadriplegic, it has brilliant acting and cinematography. There are many more movies but this is getting too long already.

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  Місяць тому +2

      Thank you! Very well put! I feel we probably have similar tastes; those three are absolutely going to the top of my to' watch list'.

    • @Namitesh1
      @Namitesh1 Місяць тому +6

      Taare zameen par is a legend level movie. I don’t think much about its music and songs because I might start crying.
      Not a spoiler-
      Also, the dream is to get a painting like in the end for myself!

    • @sarathmanoj04mytube
      @sarathmanoj04mytube Місяць тому +3

      Bollywood is not the entire Indian movie industry. If you consider Malayalam movies, they have always been of very high quality sans the budget.

    • @Namitesh1
      @Namitesh1 Місяць тому +1

      @@sarathmanoj04mytube I agree, one movie which does great with OST will be Ratsasan for me. Eerie music.

    • @nehayadav772
      @nehayadav772 21 день тому

      @@QVanGhoul Yes I too second Veer-Zaara. as a romantic film, this movie has unique charm to it, be it cinematography, musical scores, acting, characters, costumes.

  • @Mr_-Heisenberg
    @Mr_-Heisenberg 29 днів тому +2

    Indian audience has been summoned 😂

    • @QVanGhoul
      @QVanGhoul  29 днів тому +1

      They really turned up for this one 😂

  • @sagarsahil8728
    @sagarsahil8728 28 днів тому

    Nice channel Need thumbnail deisgner or video editor

  • @groupups11
    @groupups11 21 день тому

    SUSBCRIBED!!!!!

  • @comicnerd1186
    @comicnerd1186 24 дні тому

    Looks like bro has never heard of Hans Zimmer and John Williams 😂😂😂

  • @Isotonicdev
    @Isotonicdev 11 днів тому

    why are the pronunciations so messed up 😭

  • @fromthebackroom
    @fromthebackroom 20 днів тому

    ANKHON DEKHI

  • @jeongbun2386
    @jeongbun2386 14 днів тому

    TUJHE DELHA TOH YEH JAANA SANAM