Kashmir: China vs India vs Pakistan
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- Discover the complex history of Kashmir, a region caught between India, Pakistan, and China. We dive into the centuries of conflict, diverse cultures, and the power struggles shaping its modern-day fate.
Love content? Check out Simon's other UA-cam Channels:
MegaProjects: / @megaprojects9649
SideProjects: / @sideprojects
Casual Criminalist: / @thecasualcriminalist
Today I Found Out: / todayifoundout
Brain Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
Places: / @places302
Astrographics: / @astrographics-ve4yq
Simon's Social Media:
Twitter: / simonwhistler
Instagram: / simonwhistler
Restore the Mongolian Empire, Genghis Khan would know how to handle this.
Their foreign policy was straight forward and effective
No he wouldn’t the man stayed far away from the Himalayas
He tried but failed !
Led Zeppelin has been bringing attention to Kashmir since 1975
Hiding pedophilia since way before then
So have sweaters
Except they confused it with the Sahara
@@chrisballard7250do you mean sweat as in stanky?
I am sure the comment section will be full of people discussing this topic with civility and decorum.
The Indians, Chinese, and Pakistanis are mostly asleep right now. We have a good 6 hours of civility before they wake up.
The comment section might get more entertaining than the video tbh. Time to get some popcorn for the shit of show polarized views.
I have 🍿 rdy.
🍿
😮🍿
Last time I was this early, India and Pakistan were still part of the British Empire.
Last time I was this early, UK was a based conquering empire, not a woke DEI hole with a two tier policing.
@@Tonius126 Last time I was this early the UK wasn't populated with Indians and Pakistanis everywhere I look.
last time i was early, it was still called hindustan
@@Tonius126 The USA neutered your country and you still do whatever we tell you to do. At least the French have enough backbone to try and resist. Even if it is while asking us for help lol.
@@cwj2733Last time I was this early "Hindustan" was ruled by Muslim for over a 1000 years
bro assembled entire south asia
and China apparently.
Did he just say China liberated Tibet?
Deadpan humour is dead
@@ibrahimsalman5504 If that was an attempt at humor, it was horrendous.
And I say this as someone that loves deadpan humor.
@@thearpox7873it was a joke, you can laugh.
@@wassupyeah28 No, I can't. The delivery was crap.
HE HAS BECOME a mouthpiece like BBC , good old Simon is gone
Never let the british draw a map 😅
Never let the british do anything besides pubs, fish and chips, and prog rock.
Talking only about Kashmir and leaving out PoK and GB was so convenient 😂
It's crazy for me to think that just because your a nuclear powered Nation does not mean you're a superpower, also becoming a nuclear powered Nation paints you a Target and usually forces you into some sort of treaty or alliance.
Simply having nuclear weapons has never made a country a superpower.
@@CedarHunt yes and no
I like the "neutrality". Being an Indian citizen, it's not easy to see Kashmir discussed by other nations as if it were a territory our government has colonized. But also not being a Kashmiri, I have learned that the people of Kashmir may well want to be independent.
It’s hard to find good sources of info on such a politicized topic. :(
realistically india can't leave Kashmir, i know humanity and thing but as a nation its in Indian interest to control kashmir.
Also, very soft material for sweaters.
and socks
and a nightmare to properly wash.
And a great song by led zeppelin
I remember the news of the iron rod fights being a quick blur in the news.
Basically no mention of any Pakistani human rights abuses but like half the video to India's 🤔
Because he cannot mention American blunders for supplying terrorists with weapons, which they still do with back channels.
Totally unbiased video🙃
Let's be honest 90% of human rights violations are done by India, I am a kashmiri myself and have never heard about any major problems that kashmirs have faced in the other part of Kashmir. Now I am not saying that pakis don't do any human rights violations, I am sure they do 10x more than India does but they do none of them because of the Kashmir issue so the admin doesn't have to report them in a video related to Kashmir issue.
Because there are a thousand times more human rights abuses in Indian Occupied Kashmir than in Pakistan's Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan. Maybe eat less faeces and you will be able to think logically.
Pakistan does not oppress the Kashmiris it rules.
India oppresses the Kashmiris it rules
Case closed.
How do so many people not understand that Simons "liberated Tibet" at 09:22 was sarcasm ? 😆
Make a better informed vid bruh really poor . No mention of princely states no mention of violencw of Pok by pak govt i mean its all shambles showing jammu as kashmir aksai chin is with china doesn't mean it has a lot of say in kashmir
@@rutvijdoctor2957 bro got all his info from Indian state media and is now hurt by reality
@@rutvijdoctor2957 instead of feeding on the brainrot your govt gives you,how about you do some actual research.
@@ibrahimsalman5504 he's right
jammu isn't kashmir
and china doesn't have a say in kashmir
Nobody cares what some prince from 100 years ago thought, I care about what the people who live there NOW want and need, nothing else.
Probably one of the most extraordinary and beautiful regions of the planet. I had the pleasure and displeasure to work there for four years as a humanitarian during the noughties. A forgotten war despite the oldest and longest UN presence (purely symbolic) since this organisation's foundation. A region of unlimited prestige since Alexander the Great that all surrounding powers refuse to let go. A terrible tragedy for an independence aspiring and proud population, without any whatsoever solution in sight. When you ponder that India keeps almost a million soldiers there.
What a shame...
Oh god, another addition to the Simon Whistler Cinematic Universe.
Fun fact: it's also a belter of a curry house near Bradford University.
Just one thing. India (and Pakistan) has got ballistic missiles but only medium range with 5,000km range, which cannot reach China's more populated eastern parts, whilst China has got ICBM:s.
The religion of peace and tolerance not getting along there either...
Read up on the Partition of India sometime - the tensions are definitely not one-sided. Reality is very rarely as simple as "it's always Islam's fault."
@@Talisguy you're explaining it to a hindutva guy. Speaking against a wall really
@@Talisguy and if you wanna go further back, it was the west "fault", Islam was reforming in the 19thcentury but then the west occupied or controlled indirectly large parts.
Thats resulted in more conversitism and xenophobia in Islam.
But remember India has more grievious towards Islam than the Brits, due to col..
Do they ever get along with anyone?
@@sschaubal No they don't.
Seriously? LiBeRaTeD Tibet... -.-
gotta get those ccp propaganda funds😊
@@devanshsharma5757 It's a joke. The pause is for air quotes.
@@devanshsharma5757 have you even watched his other channels where he's made videos criticizing China
I am sure the comment section will be full of people making rhetorical comments about this topic.
I hope the Kashmir situation is resolved peacefully.
Kashmir: "We want independence!"
Pakistan: "See India, Kashmir wants independence from you! They want to be a part of Pakistan!"
India: "See Pakistan, Kashmir wants independence from you! They want to be a part of India!"
That's not true at all. Gross oversimplification of facts including genocide of the original habits of Kashmir which by the way were not Muslim. Do better.
@@JohnAdams-vd5dc 🎶 smallest 🎻
@@JohnAdams-vd5dc "Do better?" Did you really end with "do better?" Good Lord, Poe's law personified.
They'd ideally like complete autonomy but they claim if they were under one of them that Pakistan would be better for them, and IMO besides religious tolerance (for Muslims), don't really know why.
@@free_at_last8141 well, he is correct about the first part regardless of the end. But yeah, it was taken a bit too seriously
When talking about war in the Himalayas it's not like how yall think. Huge magnetic anomalies normally malfunction electronics, Radars, very low oxygen, military aircraft cant carry full load due to low oxygen, steep cliffs hence normal artillery unavailable in targeting over the horizon strikes, here logistics mearly matter coz mountains often fall off every other day.
In short China wants India to keep its focus on the mountains rather than the indo-pacific. How that plays out is something we all are yet to find out.
Damn, With the amount of Videos coming out across all your channels on a daily basis
The writers and editors gotta be working overtime in the basement
Just choose your side and stick to it.
India or dictatorship?
as if amnesty international has any credibility these days😂
Hi Zionist
@@muhammadalimalik337Hi radical islamist
@@muhammadalimalik337 hello terrorist supporter
They do? lol
It was an informative episode about the kashmir region and kashmir political issues amongst Pakistan 🇵🇰, India 🇮🇳, and China 🇨🇳...kashmir is a large highest plateau container of fresh water 💧 reservoir for Pakistan, China, and India
8:58 Crouching China
Hidden Baton 😂
Felt like another chapter in Black Myth Wukong
I need to make a correction here: "The strong do as they will, the weak suffer what they must" is paraphrasing the greek historian Thucydides, not Machiavelli from several centuries later. While Machiavelli might well have been familiar with the quote, and its sentiment or the equivalent doubtlessly included in his thinking on matters of statecraft, The Prince (his more infamous work) does not reference the quote, and would find statecraft unduly based on the maxim to be bad statecraft.
Quite balanced !
Guess you changed the name because you didn’t use enough graphics.
Love a vidio on the Malaysian emergency.
Do they even let you sleep Simon?
There is no Simon. It's a highly advanced AI used by the shadow government via the deep state to disseminate information in a variety of topics.
Either that or dude barely sleeps like ever. 🤷
Why did the name of the channel change?
Jimmy page and Robert Plant should be appointed the kings of Kashmir
really, liberated tibet? u must be joking......?
He clearly is
@@aggressivenipples8391 🤡
He was being sarcastic..
i remember asking for this! time to see if this was written before or after the most recent Indian elections….
22:25 Not Macchiavelli, but Thucydides' Melian Dialogue
I'm sorry to say. 9.25.. u said liberated Tibet.. but from whom!? From the people who want to see Tibet in their final breath.. we are not very violent. As compared to others ..
But we are still here on this earth and listening to ur thoughts.. we are Tibetan .. who were forced to take refuge in foreign land..
Bhod gyalo.. free Tibet
@@tenzinnyima2792 it was a joke. He has made videos on his other channels about the horrible things China has done you're a dummy if you think he's pro-china at all
The Western media's selective coverage of the Kashmir conflict often perpetuates a biased narrative, disproportionately focusing on India while overlooking the human rights abuses committed by Pakistan in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) and Aksai Chin. The Kashmiri people living under Pakistani rule face severe restrictions, including limited freedom of expression, arbitrary arrests, and extrajudicial killings. Despite these grave violations, the international community has been largely silent, allowing Pakistan to evade accountability for its actions. Such double standards undermine the principles of justice and equality, and it is imperative that the global community demand a more balanced and comprehensive approach to addressing the Kashmir issue.
More like China vs India vs Pakistan vs the Kashmiris who want their own independent state
Not the sweaters the place
Regardless of who gets what, i feel sorry for people in kashmir who are getting trampled by these circumstances.
The people of Kashmir have a right to choose for themselves, and a referendum should be made in the land.
If you want to see who is the occupier in Kashmir look at who has sent 800000 troops to occupy a land and who has given autonomous rule to the natives there’s your answer
This is like a dramatic reinterpretation of everything happened. It feels like its entirely based on BBC kind of coverage of and it doesn't surprise me tbh
Dont they have treaty that says they cant carry firearms in area? They beat each other with barb wire wrapped clubs.
half-arse information present with terrible infographics
Choose your side, free country or oppressed
China liberating Tibet is crazy to say. But this reminds me of the Kurdish people split between 3 countries. I wish they had a Kurdistan.
I tought northern Kashmir, where they grow the silk, was at peace. & it was just the poor south where all the violence was at.
Sooner as well as later india will realise how big of a blunder 2019 abrogation was, it lost whatever it had gained in kashmir for 7 decades.
I like the name change but I gotta be honest the new logo looks like a mobile game, not the serious channel this is
I swear to god I've seen you in like 7 different channels
Idk if the creators of this video will see this but just in case you do....... Does the state of the world worry you?
China LIBERATED Tibet?
You have lost all credibility.
Ig someone doesn't get deadpan humour
@@ibrahimsalman5504That wasn't humor. It was a bow to the censors. Dead pan humor would have been "China liberated Tibet bringing new freedoms and liberties."
@@whiskey_tango_foxtrot__ ah yes how about you censor his content for him karen
it was a joke, you can laugh.
@@ibrahimsalman5504 See. Your statement is not funny on any level and you obviously don't get deadpan humor. Maybe you should stick with appeasement.
Its clear neither India or Pakistan will let go of Kashmir. But it is also pretty clear that India has the upper hand in everything from ammunation to manpower to geopolitical influence over pakistan. And with Pakistan crippling economy, political instability, I don't know how much longer they can hold onto Kashmir. They just have to hope that India somehow goes through the same thing they are so they can gain some upper ground against India, but that does not seem the case atleast in the next half a century.
Let Jimmy page and Robert Plant, Govern Cashmere
Bruh got the 7:53 entire timeline wrong lmfao
Changes name to Warfronts releases content of historical wars and nothing about Iran vs Israel
Can you we just make Kashmir an independent country
kashmir produced tantra Philosphy, trika philosophy. there's no kashmir without kashmir shaivism. kashmir's greatest man/saint is abhinavgupta who was one of the greatest hindu polymath buddha. kashmir's greatest king is Laliltadtiya who slayed muslims and defeated calipahtes. kashmir's essence is hindu and will remain hindu.
if given a choice kashmir would definitely not going to choose pakistan. they have seen the condition of pok. budget of kashmir is higher than pakistan's entire aukat.
no kashmiri want to go to Middle Ages.
sooner or later kashmiri will denounce islam and embrace their aborginal superior faith of shaivism. it has already begun.
@@Advaitamanta cowpiss has got to bros brains frfr
lol
Such delusion is truly comical.
@@shayan.a why do you people name your missile after the people of Afgan, Turk, Iran and India.
A country that celebrates foreign invader Quasim instead of their own Raja Dahir.
Pakistan is an abomination on the brink of a collapse.
Kbhi America ka kutta bn k Iran pr attack, kbhi China ka kutta bn kr India pr.
@@shayan.a
ua-cam.com/video/IVVppmOq0k0/v-deo.htmlsi=LoPArSrjB_yjIRb-
Lol
I could rule the region if you guys need my help so much, but mostly because i like you people.
Reminds me of my kashmiri girlfriend, those were the days
Only Kashmiris can decide their fate and India doesn’t let them have a referendum as per UN resolutions because he knows the outcome, Free Free Kashmir
We are freeing Kashmir of the peacefuls.
Pakistan was supposed to demilitarize first as per UN resolution 2. They never did, so India refused to in return. And that is why there is no plebiscite. You also conveniently left out the genocide of Kashmiri Hindus perpetrated by Pakistan.
Kasmir is necessary for water safety
Last time I was this late keshmir already turned to Bactria
Last time I was this early, India and Pakistan were still below the equator
😂😂🤣🤣
A place to monetize!
uh ew
Plz talk about Kashmir hindu genocide please 🙏
Bruh you got all the timeline soo wrong... Not even biased just borderline false. No context definitely not balanced.
Only here for Poojeet vs Pakjeet comment wars
I think we all unalived in 2012 and now we're living in hell...
I don’t know about everyone else but I’m personally fed up with the whole situation in the Middle East and these Asian countries.
Not to be crude or disrespectful but why can’t the outside east and west countries just walk away altogether and if needed pass laws forbidding the sale of arms from said countries to these nations.
Just let it all play out til there’s a peace amongst them. Then the outside world can negotiate with the clear leader of that whole region instead of all these different factions
I know I’m probably a very small minority on this but it has to be thought about at least.
Oh and of course I don’t mean with nuclear weapons obviously
so now only middle east topics get the views?
Worrying
12:58 BRUH
Nobody cares
Except the people who live thre
stupidly shameless biased video
Hmm
Kashmir legally acceded to India & a legitimate territory whether world accepts it or not. Those who have problem please ask Pakistan & China to vacate parts of JnK under their occupation.
Acceded by an illegitimate genocidal monster who killed over 200,000 kashmiris in an attempt to change the region's demographics.
Kashmiris want either independence or to join Pakistan.
Your hindutva ideology is an affront to humanity.
Bro feeling are hurt from reality lol ,which is why you'll never make it out of the slums
but had a muslim majority population should have been acceded to Pakistan. A plebiscite should have taken place like in Junadhgar
legally acceded but if it was put up to a vote back then it would of been voted either as independent or join pakistan.
who are you to decide the succession, we want a free nation, and we will have it, not india, not pakistan,,, a free kashmir
Free OJ
Was this channel named something else before? He makes so many channels, I lose track of what I'm subscribed to. I thought it was Warographics or is that different? No hate, btw, the man's a capitalist plying his trade of content creation. I consume content---so we have an arrangement where I subscribe to a dozen channels and he continues to make money as it rains down from the ether...
They rebranded from warographics a couple days ago
@@notaguineapig3136 awesome, thanks. It's weirdly hard to Google that
Shjt vs Shjt vs Shjt
9:25 liberated tibet?? Holy f what tf is this guy😭
Deadpan is ded
Notice he said it with a pause. Youre meant to read it as "liberated" meaning he's mocking the use of the word liberated that china uses.
I think sioman is be sarcastic
he's clearly being sarcastic, see 19:41
Did you not notice the sarcasm in his voice and the pause before he said it?
Poorly researched video once again ofc Brits are highly biased towards India.
Which bits are wrong?
@@wizzyno1566 He skipped over a major event that lead to a drastic decline in Hindu population in Kashmir. This in turn favored Pakistan as we know its a Muslim country. Indian government has provided overwhelming evidence about the involvement of ISI in Operation Tupac. To this day we see how minorities are treated in Muslim most* majority countries.
Also to add for some reason you Brits are still biased towards India & favour Pakistan. You didn’t even mention the fact that Hindu minority of Kashmir had face exodus from their own homeland which is Kashmir during early 90s under Pakistan backed Operation Topaz. If London cares about Kashmiri’s so much please ask Israel to vacate Palestine & give the territory back to the Palestinians.
Hmmm maybe because Pakis regularly demonstrate and call for the destruction of the west while India doesn't.
Tell me you don’t do your research without telling me you don’t do your research
@@YuNotSteppin Denying the exodus doesn't mean it didn't happen. Denial is as an age old tactic of Pakistan. There has been overwhelming evidence to prove the involvement of ISI in operation Tupac. Want me to point you to it ? Not backing his Israel and Palestine claim though.
bro getting that china points
Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India, as much as Montana or Virginia is part of US.
Hindu nationalist bots on their way to the comments 😂😂😂😂😂
They here already 😂
So what?
Says the Muslim .
Atleast hindu nationalist dont do any terror attack around the world they dont have isis,al quade,hezbolla,hamas,taliban the names go on.
@@shradheyagaikwad289the Muslim Kashmiri genocide was done by aliens then ig,I guess those arent considered terror attacks in a shudras book
The unfortunate fact is that most Indians want Kashmir but have no wish to respect the wishes of Kashmiri people.
From a Pragmatist perspective, Kashmir region is the origin point for most of the river systems in north India. India losing kashmir will put 250 million people at the mercy of their geopolitical rivals. Is Kashmiri freedom really worth putting a quarter of a billion people at risk?
@@Red_Neckyes
@@ibrahimsalman5504
No. Imo
@@Red_Neck Yes. You don't get to trade the freedom of one for the freedom of another. If India doesn't want water conflicts with Kashmir, they could try being nice and using diplomacy.
What is the wishes of Kashmiri people? Get security from Indian tax, get jobs in India other states but not allow other people to have home in Kashmir just be tourist, why?
You like Pakistan occupied kashmir? Is that place haven anymore ?
Save Europe
From Islam .
bruh.
...From itself.
From indian immigrants
Kashmir was named after a hindu saint named " Rishi Kashyap " before Muslim invadere fircefully conveted most kashmiris to islam .
Also any word on Kashmiri Hindu pandit genocide ?
Pakistan also intervened after the Hindu raja of Kashmir started massacring the local Muslim population
Also if they were forcefully converted it wouldn't be a Muslim majority province
Ain't noone wanna be a shudra in yalls backwards and religon
Bro you are gonna get targeted by muslims if you write the truth
Hindu nationalist bot spotted 😂😂😂😂
Yall forgot the most important news. That its Warfronts now??
They put a video out 4 days ago addressing that
Before reaching to any conclusion just google where the name Kashmir came from and all your questions will be answered 😅
Names don't matter.
@@Red_Neck Good... It matters to us and we are keeping it. 🤣🤣🤣 Meanwhile Try searching for Lahore and Karachi
@@shivamagarwal2460 stuck on names still,we sacrificed 1 billion $ worth of cows this Eid ,lil shudra
@@shivamagarwal2460 just search how many years Muslims ruled Hindus and then how many years Hindus ruled Muslims and all your questions will be answered.We ruled your degen asses for a 1000 years.Personally I'd be ashamed before talking
@@ibrahimsalman5504 seriously that's what you guys do with the loan amount provided by world bank. 🙄🙄 Next time try milking them.
KASHMIR BELONG TO INDIA. it's the cradle of indic greatness. islam is to kashmir what Zionism is to Palestine.
even tibet historically had more indic influence than chinese
Bros crying
A Muslim majority Kashmir has no relation to india
In fact they are not even the same race ,colour ,religion,language or literature
Kashmiri people are mongol/Aryan just like northern Punjab and NwFp which bothe lie in pakistan while most of Indians are dravidians, characteristically black and short height and smaller body frames
@@ibrahimsalman5504 kashmir pandit and upper caste muslims are genetically closer to upper caste hindus of himachal, punjab and jammu than pak muslims. majority of settlers aka low caste muslims aka ajlafs have higher asi than even the upper caste hindus of the said religion.
kashmir produced tantra Philosphy, trika philosophy. there's no kashmir without kashmir shaivism. kashmir's greatest saint is abhinavgupta who was one of the greatest hindu polymath buddha. kashmir's greatest king is Laliltadtiya who slayed muslims and defeated calipahtes. kashmir's essence is hindu and will remain hindu.
if given a choice kashmir would definitely not going to choose pakistan. they have seen the condition of pok. budget of kashmir is higher than pakistan's entire aukat.
no kashmir want to go to Middle Ages.
sooner or later kashmiri will denounce islam and embrace their aborginal superior faith of shaivism. it has already begun.
India has no right to claim Kashmir. They should let the Kashmiri people decide their fate, rather than occupying the region due to historical support for a dictator.
that would be nice, but sadly we life in a bad world.
the problem is pakistan never goes behind the kashmir border so that a free and fair referendum can be done
@@Lmao-truth-5670 India has consistently resisted international intervention in Kashmir, despite initially agreeing to a UN-backed plebiscite in 1948. India later argued that Pakistan's presence in parts of Kashmir prevented the conditions necessary for a fair vote. Since then, India has insisted that the issue be resolved bilaterally without external involvement. The 2019 abrogation of Article 370, which revoked Kashmir's special status, further reinforced India's stance against any form of external mediation or self-determination in the region.
@@abukarabukar5193 well 370 was within India's constitutional area and India had every right to govern the way it wants until the issue resolves
obviously i dont support the current govt's actions after removal of 370
but overall they haave done what wwas within their right
also for a free and fair election oto occur both sides need to vacate
but pakistani army has always took advantage of India's helpfulness
which in turn has complicated the issue
further i accept that Indian politicians have made Kasmiris suffer due to some very bad decisions which inturn led to 1992 genocide of Hindus by the same kasmiris funded by Pakistan.
🎶I am a traveler of both time and space...🎶
Me waiting to see if Indian and Pakistani ultranationalist keyboard warriors (and possibly paid CCP shills) are gonna start arguing in the comments:
+
Which are you, none right? But good work setting it up to dismiss anyone that disagrees with you. 👍
I wanna would you rather be with a right wing hindu or a right wing muslim extrimist?
@@shradheyagaikwad289how about neither? is that an option? can we just get rid of nationalism as a whole.
@@cwj2733why i love my nation