Fake vs Real Flow Hives - I Wasn't Expecting This Result!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 116

  • @BlackMountainHoney
    @BlackMountainHoney  2 місяці тому +1

    Interested in having your own personal, expert online beekeeping mentor with access to exclusive advert free videos and priority replies to comments? Join the BMH bee mentoring programme HERE - www.blackmountainhoney.co.uk/beementoring

  • @ulaB
    @ulaB 10 місяців тому +11

    I like the "roof" on mine, because I can keep tools in that small space for each hive, so there is no chance of cross-contamination. And I like the higher feet, because I don't have to set it on pallets that way.

  • @mrspot234
    @mrspot234 Рік тому +16

    We have two flow hives at our home and several standard hives nearby in the hills. The convenience of the flow hives cannot be overstated. You really can turn on the tap and watch the honey come out. It is great fun. But the bee keeping itself is just the same. Hive inspections, do I super yet or not, have I gone queen-less and please don't swarm on me again, etc.

  • @nicoleslavec9849
    @nicoleslavec9849 Рік тому +12

    It all depends on your situation, in Australia it’s so hot in summer and we have small hive beetle to contend with so a screen base board is a must at my place. I agree the cost is quite prohibitive but I get my hubby to modify my Lang boxes and put in the original flow frames as a compromise.

  • @SER8TED
    @SER8TED 5 місяців тому +8

    So many people are so quick to bash the flow hive, we have one, and it seems like really good quality. I think some people are just so caught up in tradition sometimes that no matter what you have to show, even if its a great thing, they'll still have a preference for what they already know. Kind regards.

  • @VictorFursov
    @VictorFursov Рік тому +5

    Thank you for interesting comparison and details. Best greetings from beekeepers in Ukraine!!!😮😮😊😊😅😅

  • @bluedogron
    @bluedogron 11 місяців тому +3

    @BlackMountainHoney They now show that the plastic is BPA free and made from "food safe" materials. "🌻🌻Material🌻🌻: Bee hive boxes are built using high quality fir wood. Honey frames are made by food-grade, BPA-free plastic, designed to be used for a lifetime."

    • @andrewadam9544
      @andrewadam9544 8 місяців тому +1

      yeah but how do you know without sending a frame for testing ?

  • @psyched1231
    @psyched1231 7 місяців тому +5

    I've been using both the Australian and the Chinese flow frames for years and have taken over 600lbs of honey from them. I agree that the Chinese version is not only so much cheaper, but works just as well. As far as worrying about the plastic in the Chinese not being safe, the world is literally awash with food safe plastic. Look at all the plastic water bottles! It would be beyond crazy to think that a manufacturer would spend all that money on molds and production and then use an unsafe plastic that could bankrupt him. Also, the bees coat the entire cell in beeswax before putting in nectar. So, the honey never touches plastic anyway. Save your hard-earned money and buy the Chinese verson!

  • @martinlunsford1077
    @martinlunsford1077 7 місяців тому +11

    I've got a genuine Flow hive and a couple of knockoffs. I am absolutely certain that the knockoff flow frames are made in the exact same factory as the "genuine" flow frames. The ONLY difference is the logo on the little wrench cap. I even weighed the frames. I have 8 Flow brand and 16 knockoffs. They all weigh within a few grams of each other. If you trust the Flow brand frames, then you can trust the fake ones because they are made on the exact same assembly line.
    By the way... I need to add that this is only my opinion. I don't want Flow to sue me. It's my OPINION!

    • @AmbivertsGrow
      @AmbivertsGrow 6 місяців тому +4

      I wouldn't be surprised if that was the case. My dad is an electrical engineer. He works in a lot of factories fixing and putting new machine in. A lot of 'knock off food products are made in the same factory as the 'branded foods and there is only slight differences I the ingredients like a little less butter etc

  • @avandyke143
    @avandyke143 9 місяців тому +2

    Many of the Amazon versions for the US do say they are food grade/BPA free.

  • @Dogtagnan
    @Dogtagnan Рік тому +7

    The description on Amazon declares that the plastic used is food grade and BPA and HDEA free.

    • @bettinaclark5843
      @bettinaclark5843 Рік тому +9

      There is no requirement for truth in what's advertised on Amazon.

    • @what_Love_Drew_forth
      @what_Love_Drew_forth 9 місяців тому

      @@bettinaclark5843show us the policy. No expectations of honesty on UA-cam it seems. So proof up and I’m on your side.

    • @bettinaclark5843
      @bettinaclark5843 9 місяців тому

      Proof of what exactly @@what_Love_Drew_forth ?

    • @what_Love_Drew_forth
      @what_Love_Drew_forth 9 місяців тому +1

      @@bettinaclark5843 my first comment was pretty clear I thought. I’m talking proof of your claims about Amazon having no requirements about advertising accuracy on products listed on their platform. Your exact words were “There is no requirement for truth in what’s advertised on Amazon.” Please provide proof to back this up. Otherwise there is no merit to your statement and makes it misleading. What you’re saying seems unlikely. The best thing about proof is that it’s pretty easy to get (if it exists).

    • @bettinaclark5843
      @bettinaclark5843 9 місяців тому

      @@what_Love_Drew_forth Amazon do not enforce statements or claims made about a product that are made on their platform to be verified, verifiable or supported by Certification. It's as simple as that. In theory they should comply with the laws of the country they are selling into, and this would include truth in advertising & truth in product claims, however counterfeit product sellers have no reason to as they sell more with false claims & then they just disappear & re-list under a new seller name if there are complaints made about them.

  • @ailzamurray1959
    @ailzamurray1959 Рік тому +4

    Fantastic video. Thank you for your honest review.

  • @thehomochefual
    @thehomochefual 2 місяці тому +1

    If we’re now being told how much microplastic microscopically flake off into our drinks in plastic bottles, how much microplastic end up in honey?! Does it warp from multiple hot/cold seasonal changes?

  • @Larry-ur4xc
    @Larry-ur4xc 8 місяців тому +1

    Do you offer any instruction/guidance on getting started with an auto flow hive? I'm looking at some knockoffs and the primary thing I'd get if I bought a flowhive is access to plenty of support. Thoughts on that?

  • @radekfanta9451
    @radekfanta9451 7 місяців тому +2

    Hello, I have purchased both types and my experience so far is that the original was much easier to assemble and overall, it's better crafted with most things better resolved. The instructions were also great, understandable, and well-processed, and they even have videos on UA-cam on how to assemble the individual parts. As for the fakes, the instructions are terrible, an incomprehensible guide on how to assemble the frames was not at all, and some things seem unresolved to me. As for the quality of the wood, the original also leads with beautiful solid wood whereas the imitation is just ordinary, fragile, soft wood, which I think won't last very long. I don't have the hives in operation yet so I can't judge this, these are just my observations from the build so far.

  • @lucianodipietro7933
    @lucianodipietro7933 5 місяців тому +1

    Good morning, those who cannot buy the original new from the manufacturer must buy the fakes.
    Buy used and judge the new.......madness

  • @timan2039
    @timan2039 Рік тому +38

    I’ll skip all Chinese knockoff products for reasons from health and safety to respect for patents and people.

    • @avandyke143
      @avandyke143 9 місяців тому +1

      There’s another similar video that debunks all of that. I’ll try to find that.

    • @armstrongthegod761
      @armstrongthegod761 9 місяців тому +2

      It was stolen, but it was by Australia. George M. Macdonald patented and invented this method in the USA in 1916. As a US citizen I will choose to buy the technology created by my countrymen from whoever I want. That will not include an Insanely priced product from a country claiming to have created it, among other claims of helping the planet. Meanwhile they received Millions of dollars on their startup surpassing their goal by over 100 fold. They even have the audacity to still sell the hives at an insanely marked up value for 100 dollars of material while trying to claim they came up with the method all on their own through “15 years of research”. I’d much rather buy the Chinese made as they do not claim to have created the technology.

    • @sauce6534
      @sauce6534 7 місяців тому

      @@avandyke143I will bet 1 million the CCP made that video

    • @wmdjohnson
      @wmdjohnson 7 місяців тому +4

      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Sure buddy, go right ahead and pay triple to quadruple for the SAME EXACT PRODUCT. My CN auto flow supplier makes their frames from food grade PETG. I have had the plastics tested by a lab and confirmed results of PETG .

    • @sahasgunasekara4962
      @sahasgunasekara4962 6 місяців тому +2

      @@wmdjohnson hey do you have a name for this particular auto flow?

  • @georgemeadows3683
    @georgemeadows3683 5 місяців тому +1

    Flows national size super is great, don’t bother with the hive and just try one on your existing hives

  • @N1ghtR1der666
    @N1ghtR1der666 7 місяців тому +1

    If someone is absolutely sure about something they have no experience with and cant provide you with clear reasoned and tested evidence, then you can immediately file their opinion in the garbage pile

  • @annalisetlbll8581
    @annalisetlbll8581 5 місяців тому

    Thank you for sharing your experiences, really valuable! I would personally really dislike to buy honey which had been kept in a non-certified plastic. But as a consumer we really cannot know that...

  • @PadiTetteh
    @PadiTetteh Рік тому +2

    You missed a component of the roof of the fake flow hive. There is supposed to be a mesh between between the fake flow super box and the roof.

  • @albigensian4655
    @albigensian4655 Рік тому +1

    i have 5 flow hives now, all 10 frame brood box which are the correct size, no problem with the gap you have on yours, agree about the roof, i bought multipurpose crowns for mine and ditched the gabled roof, i wouldn't bother with the chinese knock offs if anyone plans on selling any honey, But what i'd really like to see is a review on the paradise honey smart box you got, been waiting for it before i decide to expand my new out aipary , they're looking good certainly alot cheaper than the flow hive and they're poly hives to boot.

    • @dickymint4109
      @dickymint4109 Рік тому +1

      Like you I was keen to see one in use but not likely to happen anytime soon! I think they have patent or copyright issues. Laurance did hint at this a couple of months ago and he doesn't have one.

  • @richnunes5683
    @richnunes5683 4 дні тому

    Your roof will sit properly if you have the top hive inner cover lid on and just not the roof.

  • @LukeTelff
    @LukeTelff Рік тому

    Very great Video. Enjoy hearing the professional opinions of the flow hive along with its counter part/copy cat. I never thought about the roof until you mention it, so true. Great research and practical information for sure. Keep up the good work. From Northern Canada :)

  • @sunflowerslily
    @sunflowerslily 10 місяців тому +1

    I’d like to know what happens the 2nd year and after? Can you just keep them or is there work to clean them? Thanks

    • @wmdjohnson
      @wmdjohnson 7 місяців тому +1

      You can clean and reuse, and they can be disassembled for easier cleaning.

  • @shesinthegarden4490
    @shesinthegarden4490 8 місяців тому

    I am glad that you’ve done that thank you

  • @emmawood2784
    @emmawood2784 Рік тому +1

    Hi, so how long does it take to fill a jar and how much of a pain was it to stand there waiting to change jars, also what’s it like in colder weather please

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  Рік тому

      Take a good few mins to fill a jar. Definitely a pain. Next year I am going to do all 7 supers into a single bucket. I wouldnt use in the cold

  • @markcameron6717
    @markcameron6717 2 місяці тому +1

    I have 2. Garbage! Last only 2 years.

    • @richnunes5683
      @richnunes5683 4 дні тому

      I have had 3 genuine flow hives for 4 years and they are perfect.

    • @yakivpopavich
      @yakivpopavich 3 дні тому

      I have one of the fake ones, had it since like 2020. It still is holding up, seen a lot of rain and some snow.

  • @amelieviennot5570
    @amelieviennot5570 8 місяців тому +4

    China became a super power real quick because they dont spend billions on research (of course they do) but what I mean, a lot of technologies that costed billions they just reverse engineered them, and at reverse engineering like it or not, china is number 1 by far..

    • @pdfico
      @pdfico 7 місяців тому

      I’ve never purchased a Chinese knock off that didn’t 100% disappoint me

    • @skival
      @skival Місяць тому

      They steal other people's idea and make them with a step above slave labor...That is why their knock offs are cheap.

  • @BadaBingBadaBoomYT
    @BadaBingBadaBoomYT Рік тому +1

    Thank you! Was waiting for this one. Bought one for my girlfriend and she insisted on the copy...(price) Came from a Dutch beekeeping website though. Didn't think about the plastic used. Ah well, that's then the honey we don't give away :)

  • @ryanmiller6146
    @ryanmiller6146 7 місяців тому

    Great video thanks but please give this guy a life sentence in jail for painting his hives like that 🤮

  • @baggyobeast
    @baggyobeast 4 місяці тому

    Great video, very informative

  • @prizonfrost123
    @prizonfrost123 Рік тому +3

    Actually, I talked to the manufacturers of the fake flow hive, they also do it bpa free plastic polypropylene ( Medical grade Plastic). I am using one I got it for$130. working great. We can just order supers for $56. Thats a better deal than australian one i gues

    • @sarahmojazza7660
      @sarahmojazza7660 3 місяці тому +1

      Which one did you get?

    • @prizonfrost123
      @prizonfrost123 3 місяці тому

      @@sarahmojazza7660 chinese version and they are good...
      Roof is useless of either ones, so nerd to change to telescopic ones.

  • @JaimeBird-n8m
    @JaimeBird-n8m 2 місяці тому

    Is the roof to help with high heat in Australia?

  • @LoneWolf0568
    @LoneWolf0568 7 місяців тому +2

    I picked up a fake one off of Amazon too but after 3 years of trying it, I have yet to get any honey out of it because my bees simply won't draw it out and fill it with honey. No matter what I have tried, melting former honey comb and painting it on the frames, leaving the Queen excluder off so she can roam it and leave her pheromones, nothing seems to entice them to seal it off and start storing honey in it?

    • @RTSquad138
      @RTSquad138 5 місяців тому

      Did you try a Demaree Split in the spring? I did and it made all the difference in coaxing the bee to use the flow frames. Keep the queen excluder on over the single brood box and move a bunch of capped brood frames and a second deep box above the flow super. Worked like a charm for me. 100+ lbs of honey and counting.

    • @LoneWolf0568
      @LoneWolf0568 5 місяців тому +1

      @@RTSquad138 I painted it with nearly 2 pounds of wax from cappings of normal supers from last year. I'll try the Demaree spilt and under supering next year. Thanks for the advice!

    • @dano1234v
      @dano1234v 4 місяці тому

      I put my flowhive on in May it has Queen excluder installed, every once in a while I would see a few bees in it checking it out , the second last week in July they started going in and waxing the cells together, now they are going full tilt with the honey , I put a little wax on them in May when I installed it, so once the bees had all the brood frames done they went to the flow frames
      ua-cam.com/video/XoW2jjOcEiA/v-deo.htmlfeature=shared

  • @mrblue2715
    @mrblue2715 6 місяців тому

    Good video. I watch the original video you made about fake flow hive versus real flow hive and then in that video you did not like the floor the fake one.

  • @carlfrederick7780
    @carlfrederick7780 11 місяців тому

    You say its good for a couple in the garden, how would it compare on a productional scale, like 100-300 hives, compared to conventional beekeeping?
    Also, did you ever contact the manufacturer for info about the plastics?
    Thanks!

    • @BlackMountainHoney
      @BlackMountainHoney  11 місяців тому

      I don't think it will ever compare on a commercial basis as its too time consuming to get the honey from the frames. Manufacturer seems to think they are BPA free but couldn't provide assurance documentation

    • @carlfrederick7780
      @carlfrederick7780 11 місяців тому +1

      Isn't the point that its less time consuming to get the honey from the frame, with less workload on the overall? A little confused here. Reason I ask is up here in Norway, a "commercial" beekeeper is usually 200-500 hives for a full time job. That would include going into the woods gathering the honey, back and forth to the car to get to the equipment etc. You know the deal. Is that your "commercial" keeping, or do you think about those large scale beekeeping "plants". Im setting up a small farm, considering this as lower effort cash flow while regenerating soil, as we have state supported sales channels. @@BlackMountainHoney

  • @rickwarner516
    @rickwarner516 Рік тому

    Good job thanks good thoughts

  • @shaneashley5463
    @shaneashley5463 5 місяців тому

    Would it be worth it to get a genuine top and a knockoff bottom

  • @-RobHunter-
    @-RobHunter- 9 днів тому

    All flow hives, "fake or real" are made in China. They just add onto the cost in Australia.

  • @DavidFrat123
    @DavidFrat123 Рік тому +1

    I always wonder how Flow Hive doesn't sue the copycats. I would assume Flow Hive patented their design.

    • @sinisterhipp0
      @sinisterhipp0 Рік тому

      It’s impossible to combat China copycat companies. It’s like hydra heads.

    • @PixieParamedic
      @PixieParamedic Рік тому

      I do believe most are built in China...not sure they can sue internationally?

    • @timan2039
      @timan2039 Рік тому

      The knock-offs come out of China which has no qualms about theft of…well anything.

    • @Fellowtellurian
      @Fellowtellurian Рік тому +2

      Flow bought at 1938 patent, they didn't create the frame design. What they did bring to the table is excellent marketing. But even that is taken from Apple design aesthetic.

    • @bettinaclark5843
      @bettinaclark5843 Рік тому +6

      Actually Flow invented the Flow Frame and has it patented internationally. The patent you are referring to is quite different. @@Fellowtellurian

  • @GaroSargsyan-db9sn
    @GaroSargsyan-db9sn 6 місяців тому

    🇺🇸 💫 GC 👍 FLY 🕊🕊🕊

  • @susanagallo7334
    @susanagallo7334 Рік тому +1

    Amazon have a few flow hive which one you have thanks

  • @jrys23
    @jrys23 10 місяців тому

    Do you have a flow hive referral link? In Canada…

  • @natemissin3893
    @natemissin3893 5 місяців тому

    Flow hive against knockoff flow hive is like iPhone against android,
    Android can do all the stuff a iPhone can but for some reason android is just shit.
    Real flow hive any day 👍🏼💪🏼

  • @richnunes5683
    @richnunes5683 4 дні тому

    That top box in the beginning of your video is upside down.

  • @aprilminthant1234567
    @aprilminthant1234567 11 днів тому

    ngl, i think flow is not a very reliable company. cause it seems like all the fake ones work better and are better design. and flow just seems like a really irresponsible company in general.

  • @billrodiger7697
    @billrodiger7697 8 місяців тому +1

    Oh my goodness, you really have a downer on genuine flow hives. Your comments appear so biased it is hard to take you seriously.

  • @The_Angry_BeEconomist
    @The_Angry_BeEconomist 8 місяців тому

    will you sell the honey from the fake flow hive?

  • @DC-lu9pc
    @DC-lu9pc 6 місяців тому

    Good luck keeping the Bee's out of your honey flow! I get more bee's in the jar than honey, had to fabricate a lid to fit the tube into so not to drown the bee's. Save your money!

  • @BlackMountainHoney
    @BlackMountainHoney  9 місяців тому +1

    BUY HERE - amzn.to/3v8pOm6

    • @AdityaMajumdar-vi1kt
      @AdityaMajumdar-vi1kt 5 місяців тому +2

      bruh it litrally sais on the website that it is made from "7pcs honey frames are made by food grade and BPA free polypropylene"

  • @andrewadam9544
    @andrewadam9544 8 місяців тому

    what about buying the fake flow hive and replacing the frames with flow originals

    • @andrewadam9544
      @andrewadam9544 8 місяців тому

      ignore this as i have just seen the price of replacement flow frames......seems a major expense, they will have to drop prices sooner or later or they wont stay in business

  • @wallingtonfilming
    @wallingtonfilming Рік тому

    Just watch your video mate, noticed how you have problems with the roof section. I’m pretty sure the reason the roof hits those handles is because you haven’t got the wooden frame with the mesh in it, to lift the roof up slightly. i’m surprised you don’t realise that.
    Also, are you trying to tell me you don’t have trouble extracting the honey from the plastic flow hive frames when you crank the handle because of the bees ceiling the plastic frames ?

    • @Darren_Nicola
      @Darren_Nicola Рік тому +1

      No issues here extracting honey from flow frames , it’s only the fakes where the roof hits the handles the inner mesh inner cover should be binned straight out the box for a solid inner cover , you don’t want air flowing out the top like that as you don’t need upper venting in hives just insulated roofs

    • @PadiTetteh
      @PadiTetteh Рік тому +1

      I simply sealed the top vents@@Darren_Nicola

    • @Darren_Nicola
      @Darren_Nicola Рік тому +2

      @@PadiTetteh best idea keep it tops vent free, bees don’t have top vents inside trees and only one entrance 😀

  • @chrisoliver6690
    @chrisoliver6690 7 місяців тому

    'kind of' & 'like' great filler words.

  • @roblowe7252
    @roblowe7252 9 місяців тому +1

    unfortunately I found about the "fake" hive issues after i bought it, i'll take the loss, definitely a lesson learned. still lots to learn. AU

  • @ktjamlex
    @ktjamlex 10 місяців тому +2

    To support a knock off goes against everything we should believe in.

  • @markjames2828
    @markjames2828 Рік тому +1

    Can you use real flow hive frames in the fake?

  • @markpannewig2460
    @markpannewig2460 10 місяців тому +3

    The Chinese take pride in mass production of others' tech. That in turn undermines the process of research and development. I am happy to pay premiums to avoid any Chinese products. So flat no from me.

  • @jodi4029
    @jodi4029 11 місяців тому

    my 5 years son built it... how dare you lol ;lol

  • @Fellowtellurian
    @Fellowtellurian Рік тому +1

    Flow bought at 1938 patent. They did not develop it. Lol.

  • @scooterreinhart3163
    @scooterreinhart3163 4 місяці тому

    Why do i have to watch a 2 minute ad?