At last, someone explained why the face vise is on the left. As a lefty, I had a suspicion I should design mine the other way round, but now I know why. One of the best videos I've seen in researching this subject.
I totally agree! This was a great, and very instructional video. I just recently had major back surgery and am now designing a small workbench for here at my house so I can start doing some tinkering. With the exception of church and physical therapy, I'm not getting out of the house much and am really getting stir-crazy.
Not quite sure if I should laugh at your antics or rather feel sorry for you. You apparently didn't understand one bit he was saying, yet you feel the need to complain - based on what exactly? Let's see YOUR video about benches, then. Let's hear YOUR thoughts, let's see YOUR shop.
As I suspected - you are just a poser who didn't even watch the video and who didn't even listen. Go and annoy someone else with your nonsense, will you? I don't want any of it and if Stumpy Nubs had not said this was a "family channel", I would have used much more drastic words. I take his advice over your substanceless outpourings any day, but that might be a familiar feeling to you.
Simon, I think you missed the whole idea behind the video. This was not about how to do woodworking but about suggestions about how you can customize your workbench to meet your needs. It is about not buying something just because you can. It is about spending money wisely on good tools that help you produce fine work. I think his tips were excellent. I benefited from a couple of them and suspect to could have, as well. Example, I did not make the front of my bench flat across the whole front. That was a mistake and now I realize why I should correct my work.
@@SimonWoodburyForget I disagree. I'm an individual who makes forward decisions based upon data presented by others. Learning the opinions and methods of others assists me in finding what works best for me. I prefer to avoid making the same mistakes already made by others. You seem to be an individual whom sees no benefit in informational videos as this. I certainly am my own individual and make my own path and certainly do not interpret Mr. Hamilton's words as woodworking hard-line gospel that if not followed means I'm wrong and am an idiot. Perhaps your experience teaches you to move on and avoid seeking videos like this. I must say, however, no matter your real experience, your posted comments provides me with evidence that you would not be an individual I would trust taking advice or counsel from. With 36 years of solid engineering experience in my background, I certainly do appreciate the credibility Mr. Hamilton shows forth and am able to find little nuggets that are certainly better than the way I've been doing things. I shudder that any serious amateur woodworker looking to improve their skill set could be sent down a road of torturous filled effort by accepting as practical truth no need for a solid, well architected & designed work bench and is not needed in a smallish amateurs wood shop. I am so sorry you have wasted your time here. I wish you much success following your perceived superior ways.
i have to admit for wood work you have become a trust seal for me. none of you video/info given has ever let me down. thanks for all the hard work and passing on information that you would have spent life time gaining. God bless your heart and all your loved ones.
This guy, even now is my go to on all subjects involving wood. All the you tubers now and even some of the veteran wood working you tubers have nothing on the nubs.
I built my workbench from a Readers Digest plan back in the 70's. Built it on an open carport with a few tools I managed to scrounge up to fit in a 10 x10 metal shed. Though far from the professional versions, it's been through a lot over the years and still solid; more than I can say for myself.
Have watched several videos about building a workbench for my garage and this is by far the best one I’ve seen. Thank you for helping me figure out all the ways to build a work bench properly with maximum functionality. 👍🏻
James, you are a master of clear, succinct explanations that are full of helpful information. This video is an excellent example of verbal commentary, visual demo, and pacing. I have watched a few of your Stumpy Nubs videos and plan to work my way through most of the others. Thank you for the time and effort you and your crew obviously put into your duel crafts or wood working and video production! I, and apparently many others, appreciate you all!
Im a Jamaican and our work bench is just a plywood top and it get work done. We dnt have any of those fancy clamps at the shop i work. You explaining a proper work bench put things on a next level. Im planning on building my work bench at home and you give me an idea. Awesome video always. I subscribe few days ago. Keep up the great work.
I’ve been a cabinet maker 16(?) years, and I always find myself nodding to your videos. A lot of it I know, and checks out with my experience, but I always learn a couple of things I did not already know. Thanks for the prolific video-making.
Just came across this video while considering how to build my next workbench. I must say I loved how you told us what to consider but also thoroughly supported it with why it is important. Great job on this video and thank you for the great advice!
Your review was excellent. I built my work bench 10 years ago and it is pretty simple: face vise, tail vice, dog holes. Very flat maple top, 4x4 SYP base with mortise and tenon joints, no nails, screws, or bolts and no tool tray. I figured a woodworker worth his salt should build his own. My vises have that quick release feature. I agree with you, they're more trouble than benefit.
As I am planning my workbench build, I watched 10+ videos on workbenches. This video was the most informative. The information was clearly communicated and important. Thanks a lot.
I am in the process of building my workbench and your information is as always spot on. It's small compared to most as it must fit into my 1 car garage shop. All wood is free, including a cherry butcher block slab top with a bottom slab of 2 1/4 in pine from old growth trees that had to have been 7 ft in diameter. (Salvaged from wife's grandfather's shop) Legs are free highly figured rock maple useless to my cabinet shop owner friend and paid for with ripe tomatoes. Life is good! The only thing that could make this build easier is to have a good workbench to work from in the first place! Ken
I have an old bench that was in the house when we moved in over 20 years ago. It's a heavy, stout old bugger but has a 2x6 top so it's far from smooth and has decades of pounding abuse so it's also all dinged up. I am getting ready to add a 3/4" plywood top that I'll seal so it doesn't soak up oils and stains and then drill bench dog holes in it. You gave me a few good ideas for how to make that better. One of the things that was already on my list was a tool shelf about 6-8" down from the top but with an additional one 3 or 4" down to catch sawdust that goes through the dog holes so it's not falling on the tool shelf. You made me realize that the "catch shelf" needs to be at least far enough down to allow the dogs or hold fast to drop in far enough to work properly. Keep up the great videos James, I certainly appreciate them.
I've built several benches over the years, and each time I learn something new (sometimes about the bench, and sometimes about myself). My current bench is FWW's New-Fangled Workbench. I love the "crochet" (planing hook) and adjustable platform that supports the wood from underneath when hand planing. I'm not so fond of the pipe clamps used as face and tail vises. Like you, I loathe tool trays on benches. They attract clutter and a cluttered workbench is sub-optimal. Instead of a tool tray, I used some scrap plywood and 2x4s and created a rolling tool cart. The top is shorter than the bench, so even with tools on it I can have it next to me and it won't interfere with anything on the bench that might be overhanging the bench. It was an impulse decision to make it, and it's the best accessory for any bench. My next bench is going to be a combination of an English workbench and a Roubo workbench, with a split-top. Still in the design phase but should start working on it soon.
Getting information from an experienced person is greatly appreciated. I’m an union Ironworker by trade and have just started to work with wood as a hobby. I’ve been drawing up ideas to build a bench that integrates my old 70’s jointer with my new planer as well as be a work bench and hearing your POV is priceless thank you. I’ve went with 3/16 x 2x2 angle iron as the framework already and have a lot of maple I am now going to use for the top instead of the 1” mdf I was going to use. I find myself wanting to Swiss army the bench and have my table saw and band saw part of it to. If anyone has any links to where I can find ideas for a integrated work station I’ll just make a bench then the station for all the equipment . I daydream about having the bandsaw and jointer running on the same motor
I loved your video. I debated on the tool tray and finally built my bench with one. After 3 years of use, 51% of the time, I like the tray. I have 2 vises on my bench and use both vises. There have been many times where it has been very useful to keep a piece in the vice that I am working on and then use the other vise to quickly perform a task to fashion something to be used on the other piece. Because of this I am a fan of having a face and end vise.
I added a tool well also and grew tired of it constantly being filled with sawdust. So I added a hinged plexiglass top and it has been a game changer. Absolutely love it now.
@@brett328 my plan is to have removable side-pieces to make an easy clean out...pull the big stuff out, remove the end pieces, rake the sawdust and chips on the floor, get yelled at by my better half, and....done! ;-)
Most times, when I build a new bench (after someone's decided to want the old one more than me...lolz) I add a few "dog-holes" around the sides at regular intervals... These are two-ways very very useful... 1. Depending on your own preferences (obviously) they allow certain utilities (like various sizes of trays) to be simply added to the side of the bench WHEN AND ONLY WHEN NECESSARY OR APPROPRIATE... 2. Being "dog-holes" exactly like the rest of them on the bench, they're a precision SIZE allowing for "odd clamping" techniques to be employed with only a bit of "predictable improvisation"... Basically, using the same "hold-down" as on the top of the bench, you can "hold-sideways" on the side... a useful (even rarely) utility when certain joints and prospects over-hang at an angle otherwise unusually difficult to work with... That dependable size, the same as the dogs, allows you to manufacture just about any "side-rig" or "out-rigger" you could possibly want for the face territory around the bench. Granted, with properly productive and predictable projects about, you shouldn't need it often if you need it at all... but man, it can make life SOOOooo much easier to have it and not need it than to need it and wonder why the hell you don't have it. ;o)
I love the big, expensive benches...I myself have an inexpensive but capable one that matches my level of involvement - but - I am always amazed at how Japanese craftsmen can sit on the floor with what amounts to a plank on their knees and still produce exquisite works out of wood. Their joinery and tool mastery are, in my eyes, unequaled.
What a great video. Never knew benches could be that involved, but it just makes me more excited to get into woodworking now. Thanks so much for this upload.
Goodness...I got into casual weekend woodworking ~2 years ago when I bought my first house. I wish I would've found your channel 3 years ago. Fine work, good sir!
These videos are so good. I'm just getting into woodworking and figuring out my setup and tools is hard. I've been doing things sort of halfway in the DIY-save-money sense of building things. So a bunch of 2x4 projects. My current workbench is built from a pallet. Not even kidding - I found a pallet that was square, plumb, and level and turned that into my bench top, and did 2x4s for the underside. It's sturdy enough for light assembly of small projects, but it's really just a workbench shaped object. Looking forward to building a solid workbench this winter!
Dang, you just saved me a TON of regrets! I was about to totally screw up my face and end vises when I start my bench in the morning. I was going to use a 10" quick-clamp style vise for a face vise and spend big bucks for the end vise. Your video makes so much sense. I am going to flush mount the 10" for an end vise and get a high quality face vise. Honestly, I expect to be building a second bench within a year or two with all the things I learn from this first one which is going to be 2x6 Southern Yellow Pine and probably too short and too soft, and full of regrets. Lol! 🙂 Thank you!
This video is the best explaining what I need to know about workbenches. Now I know so much more about this matter, specifically because I started to build one for myself. Thank you for this video.
Thanks for the video Stumpy some sound advice. Mine is a complete mongrel and I love it. It’s a work bench not a piece of furniture. It’s an English style or Nicholson bench with a flat solid softwood top over a frame of 5x2s on 5x5 legs. On one side there’s an old Record bench vise and on the other side my home-made moxon vise. I drilled a few dog holes but if I need another hole I just drill one or if I need a temporary hold then I just pop in a screw or a nail. For hammering or chopping, just go over a leg or the apron and nothing even flexes however hard you hit. When it gets too scruffy I put a sander over it and some Danish oil and it’s as good as new. If I ever have to change the top I’m going with a plank top to make it even simpler. For anyone thinking of building their own bench but feeling a bit intimidated I recommend checking out the EnglishWoodworker for some equally sound advice. Cheers from UK
I will be moving soon and am abandoning my old bench and will be building a new one for my new shop that is customized for me and my type of work. These vids are valuable, thanks again for your channel.
Thanks Stumpy! This is one of those subjects where I said to myself, "what could I really learn [new] from this video?!" Since it was you, I watched, and I'm damned glad I did before considering my own build. I learned more than I imagined- one of those, "you don't know what you don't know..." ignorant of my own ignorance on the topic... so to speak. Thanks again!!!!
I screwed an old door for the top onto my Mom's old dresser and put some wheels on it for my workbench.........I expect NASA to call with a job offer any day now.
Hi James I also have the Sjobergs Elite 2000 with storage module and accessories got about 5yrs ago. Holdfast clamp does work well but can be a pain twisting the handle as opposed to wacking the other style with a mallet. I installed work bench casters makes it more convenient especially with a small shop. Really like your videos keep up the good work.
Just built a bench with vertical vises. And the one vise on the long edge is situated perfectly for a lefty…. Good thing I’m right-handed! Wish I had watched this video sooner!
We are about to rebuild our woodworking bench at the makerspace and this brings up a lot of good points (and reinforces many of the complaints) about the old bench we made. Thanks for sharing this information this way. It is now easier for me grok the "why" in the comments I get from people who don't build things the same way that I do.
So glad I came across this randomly. This is the best explanation why workbenches are made the way they are and why each thing is used. I pretty much just want that work bench.
I built my own bench back in 1997 when I didn't know a lot. luckily, I read a few books on workbenches and followed suggestions for things that I only later understood the reason for. I have a quick-release front vise, that only is a slight problem because I got the guides slightly out of parallel, so I have to keep them well waxed for it to slide easily. I have a Veritas Twin-screw End vise that I've never had any problem with, but you are right, I use it less often. I got a pre=made laminated maple top, the legs, drawers, cabinet I did myself. I think the only thing I've sometimes wanted was the dog holes in the right front leg ( or one of those removable legs you see) but I can still add that, and probably should. I started with a Veritas adjustable holdfast, and it has always worked well. I only recently got a pair of traditional holdfasts and Man, I really prefer them. you can use them so quickly, holding or releasing that I now work more safely holding something that I used to try to get by without clamping well. You can buy shorter traditional style holdfasts.
I gave your video a thumbs up because it was so brutally honest. I say that because of the space and financial requirements that are not so easily met by some wood workers. For example, I rent and my shop has a standard door. It's like 35 or 36 inches and that kinda limits me unless I make the bench so I can take the top off and that the frame will fit through the door when I can't pay my rent. LOL!
So many features that I've never seen before on any of the workbenches I've used, now I have some more things to look for when I get/make my own workbench someday!
This was very helpful. I ended up following the Mike Siemsen template for a Nicholson workbench. I'm under the impression that I will find all kinds of problems down the road, and once I know exactly what I want I'll build another that fits my specific, known needs, especially since I currently only have about 100 dollars of wood into the whole build.
Follow up comment: GREAT video. Clear, concise, and conscientious. Aware of what works and what doesn’t. Really appreciate the nod to building mass for stability. It’s OK to have storage below.
Outstanding intro and run-down. Wish I had a shop like that... one day! One part at a time. Agree on the tool tray. I build a rolling tray, nothing fancy just a three-shelf cart on soft smooth-rolling (but lockable) casters from Home Depot. That way I can have all the tools I'll need for a job on that tray, within arm's reach. When I'm done, they all get cleaned and put back into storage locations. It definitely cuts down on having to move all about the shop for clamps, bits, chisels, whatever.
I agree with your statement to not get caught up in whatever workbench is trending at the moment. There's been a lot of that in the past few years with glowing testimonies of Roubo style workbenches.
🙏🏽🙏🏻I want to say a big thanks for your education and shared experience.🙏🏻🙏🏽 Your amazingly unexcited way to teach & explain is an refreshing change in the chaotic UA-cam world. Finally managed to subscribe on your website. Thank you
I accidentally did that on my design for a diy bench and now after using it for months i would never ever go back to an overhanging tapletop =) Especially since my budget has not allowed me yet to get a vise. This. Is. Worth. Gold. =)
Spot on! Love the explanation of each feature and what you need to think of if you attempt to make one. The two things that I didn't incorporate into my bench are the face vice and dog holes on the legs. If I were to do it again, I would add them. Great video Stumpy.
James Hamilton, for real I thought Stumpy Nubs was a nickname you go by, until your greeting at the start of this video. Thanks for all your exceptionally good information!
I am building the Samurai Carpenter Workbench now (for the last few months - yes, I am slow, but I am also learning a lot as I go and practicing most things on scrap stuff first). The point is, your video kept me from making a big mistake with my Face Vice - I was thinking of adding (not in the plans) a rear face vs using the Apron- now I can see that would have been a major mistake! Thanks and keep these videos coming.
I had my first look at this video when it initially came out. Now I’m about to build my first bench since my workshop is finally finished. I’ve watched many videos on workbenches since this one, but I’m pleased to see how much of this one has stuck with me for these two years. James is a great teacher, woodworker, father, visionary, humorist, thinker, etc. Sharing the knowledge between his ears will bless woodworkers and their craft for decades, or even centuries, to come. This channel is truly a treasure.
Made my holdfast is of a carefully chosen branch of Rhodedendron. Grows wild here and can cut it to a not annoying length, for those who don’t have the four inch bench tops. I love using this bit of scrap wood and giving it a bash with a mallet and seeing people’s faces.
Thanks, I have a great base on my bench, but just an old solid core door for a top, I’ve been thinking of making a better top and you gave some good advice.
That workbench looks almost exactly like the one my dad had, only much nicer. He actually built two. He built the first one from scraps so he had a base to build the second. He incorporated the table saw into his bench, and made it wide enough to secure a 4' x 8' sheet of plywood. We were always in construction mode, so the 4' x 8' standard was, well, standard. The pickup had to have a bed that could accommodate a sheet flat, the workbench had fit one, the sheet goods truck had to fit them too. Good video!
Mr Hamilton...I love your videos, and I really, really appreciate that I can play them anytime, even with my children are in the room....Butter sticks, indeed, sir! Thanks for keeping the bar raised. (And proving that humor need not always hit below the belt....)
Thank you so much for this video. I just started learning about woodworking benches and have been overwhelmed by all the terminology, what with moxon vises and wagon vises and tail vises and round dogs vs square dogs and tool wells, etc. You really covered everything quite succinctly and I now have a much better understanding of the workbench and the features to keep in mind. Thanks again!
other than having my kids i tihnk one of the best ideas i ever had was making my own workbench.I did the Paul Sellers type build for the top. only complaint i have is i used 2x10's and yeah its more than likely stronger than the entirety of the McMansion i bought that its sitting in but holy crap was it a pricey project. i have it set up to use the modern hold downs i also have a smaller pattern of holes thta are only half inch and i have made a bunch of custom stuff in my metal shop to go in them. i hope i never move house because this thing has to weigh at least 1000lbs at 8ft long and 4ft deep its a honking monster.
Wonderful video. Excellent presentation style. Crystal clear articulation. Everyday language that most people can easily understand which actually inspires me to go down to my humble work area and make 'stuff'. Congratulations!! Greetings from Brisbane, Australia.
yeah i like the vid, I have two work benches in my shop that i bought from old or dead woodworkers. They are both different, and you are right, there are pros and cons with each model, and when you start working on them, you realize what you dont have, rarely are we thankful for what we do have because we just assume its always there or common to all work benches. I am ready to sell both of mine and build a bench that works well in more ways. If only I had more time.
Great overview of the workbench, I’m a little surprised you didn’t talk a little about the difference between this workbench and the other one you have a build video fore Thank you for sharing 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
The one I built has all these features (storage cabinet was added later). After a while I did wish I had mounted the vise on the left and used a wider chop. And I wish it was hardwood, but that couldn't be helped. But that same bench can be built from those plans to meet all the criteria in this video. www.stumpynubs.com/2x6-roubo-workbench.html
I think Rex made some really good points for why a vice which racks is not only acceptable, but even desirable: 1. Without big guide bars, you have more room for holding large parts. 2. If your vice can rack, it can be used to hold tapered parts very securely. the vice will conform to the angle you need on its own, just by tightening, without the need for extra shims. As you mentioned, you can compensate for racking when you need to hold a piece in one side of the vice by adding a spacer. While this isn’t necessarily desirable, it’s easier than finding spacers for tapered parts as I mentioned before. 4. High-quality screws are inexpensive and easy to find, so you could reasonably make your own vice on a budget if you’re willing to accept racking.
as a woodworker begginer myself I'm loving this video, it really makes me want to buy\build my proper work bench! Thanks for the info Stumpy! U deserve a cold one!
I love how you explain the WHY of your decisions. EG: For me, as I need to set up and tear down my bench every time I work, being an apartment dweller who works in the yard in the complex, from your own description, I realized a tool well will probably be great to me, as I can't have a wall of tools nearby, and it's guaranteed to get cleared out between work sessions when I stow my bench. Thank you. Do you talk anywhere about your thoughts on twin-screw vices?
I had an odd workbench that was 4” thick in the center, mounted on barrels, but only 1” thick out at the last 18” at the ends where it hung over. I had a very heavy duty Wilton vise and the only place I could really mount it to get the stability it needed was in the center, where it’s very secure. I can work around it OK, but the biggest limitation of having it center mounted is that I can’t trim the ends of long boards with a hand saw, but that’s what table saws and miter saws are for. It has a quick release mechanism that works very well. In hindsight I should have just made shims for it at the left end, but it’s mounted with long recessed bolts that are countersunk and the holes filled with epoxy, so it would be a bear to move now. Because I have four 55 gallon drums under the bench, I’m able to use those long bench hold downs in a few key areas with no problem, but those modern ones are a lot more convenient for sure. I believe all the bench dog holes I drilled in the bench are for 3/4” diameter dogs and hold downs. Thanks for the great tips! This is the only video I’ve ever seen having the details about vise placement. 👍
A man after my own heart. I built my bench with a face and end vice, and I virtually never use the end vice. I'd have to say the end vice was a waste of money and effort. The face vice is a Jorgenson quick-release-and it always works. I too have never understood the value of tool trays. Quite enough junk gathers on the benchtop without adding a too-shallow place to collect objects that poke above the surface and prevent me from laying anything flat on the surface, aside from turning a good portion of your bench surface into a dustbin. Drawers are convenient enough for oft-used tools, and they add mass and keep the tools form gathering sawdust and swarf.
I didn't add an end vise to my bench, mainly through lack of funds than planning, but I don't miss it. I use the right hand end for sawing and an end vise would get in the way. I will probably add a fixed (but easily removed) bench hook instead as it will be used much more. My big mistake was a single low shelf underneath (junk and dust collection area), so I will most likely build a cabinet and drawers to replace that next spring.
I've just today put up another MDF board and hung up my files and chisels. The only thing I do want on the side (or in) the bench is my 2 most-used saws. I'm thinking about cutting a slot for them on the side. Or adding a single small beam that will hold them. They take too much space on the wall and I've plenty below the bench (no tools there)
I recently added a tool well/tray that mounts along one side of my bench. At first I really liked it, then the constant filling up with dust started to wear on me. So I added a hinged top lid to the tool well and it really won me over all over again. It keeps the dust out, forces me not to overload it with too tall or too many things and became a real bonus for keeping all different size brads and screws at hand at all times. You can check it out on my channel if your interested, not why I commented, just really like the tool well now that it has been modded to perform better.
Oh boy. Seriously, OH! BOY!!! It seems you covered almost everything, and being a "newbie," you told us about what really MAKES a good bench; I thought it was "simple," but it seems that's just "my newbie brain talkin'." And it came at a good time for me. I figured I'd start small by building a "table-top bench," and I'm still going to but I'm gonna use (read that "steal") several ideas now that you described here. So, thanks! It was a very comprehensive posting, and I really gotta hand it to you. Thanks again.
I am in the process of designing a workbench for my shop and these are excellent points that you have made and I will incorporate them into my design. Thank you, much appreciated.
Love the collection of planes on the top shelf! Height is something to consider, most of what I do is fine detail work so I prefer a bench that's about elbow height when standing, which is much higher than most people like. If I go for something as low as knuckle height (what a lot of recommendations say to go for) I'd have a horrible kink in my back....
I'm totally with you. My understanding is the lower bench height comes from when all cutting and surfacing was done with hand saws and hand planes, and the height suited the body mechanics needed for doing this all day long. My bench is 34" high and I also made a "bench" another 10" high that clamps on top to get even closer to the work.
I feel like you hit on a lot of great points! And I agree. It’s way better to over build a bench. Also I store my tools in tool boxes underneath the bench on a shelf. So if I need to I can quickly move a whole bunch simply by sliding the tool box over
Hey no need to let those leg vices go to waste in your shed. You can always give them to me. 😀 lol. Great video my friend. Thanks for sharing! Thanks again for all the quality content. I've learned so much from your channel. I can't thank you enough! Let me know if you have any other tools going to waste... I would be more than happy to help you get rid of all the clutter! Haha. Thanks again!
I always put a spacer the same size of what I'm working on at the other end of my LN chain vice - just to keep the pressure even. Learned that from the legend Chris Becksvoort!
At last, someone explained why the face vise is on the left. As a lefty, I had a suspicion I should design mine the other way round, but now I know why. One of the best videos I've seen in researching this subject.
I agree
Unpretentious, straight to the point, not too biased in terms of brands. No BS indeed, videos like this one are far too rare on YT. Thank you, sir!
I totally agree! This was a great, and very instructional video. I just recently had major back surgery and am now designing a small workbench for here at my house so I can start doing some tinkering. With the exception of church and physical therapy, I'm not getting out of the house much and am really getting stir-crazy.
Not quite sure if I should laugh at your antics or rather feel sorry for you. You apparently didn't understand one bit he was saying, yet you feel the need to complain - based on what exactly? Let's see YOUR video about benches, then. Let's hear YOUR thoughts, let's see YOUR shop.
As I suspected - you are just a poser who didn't even watch the video and who didn't even listen. Go and annoy someone else with your nonsense, will you? I don't want any of it and if Stumpy Nubs had not said this was a "family channel", I would have used much more drastic words. I take his advice over your substanceless outpourings any day, but that might be a familiar feeling to you.
Simon, I think you missed the whole idea behind the video. This was not about how to do woodworking but about suggestions about how you can customize your workbench to meet your needs. It is about not buying something just because you can. It is about spending money wisely on good tools that help you produce fine work.
I think his tips were excellent. I benefited from a couple of them and suspect to could have, as well. Example, I did not make the front of my bench flat across the whole front. That was a mistake and now I realize why I should correct my work.
@@SimonWoodburyForget I disagree. I'm an individual who makes forward decisions based upon data presented by others. Learning the opinions and methods of others assists me in finding what works best for me. I prefer to avoid making the same mistakes already made by others. You seem to be an individual whom sees no benefit in informational videos as this. I certainly am my own individual and make my own path and certainly do not interpret Mr. Hamilton's words as woodworking hard-line gospel that if not followed means I'm wrong and am an idiot. Perhaps your experience teaches you to move on and avoid seeking videos like this. I must say, however, no matter your real experience, your posted comments provides me with evidence that you would not be an individual I would trust taking advice or counsel from. With 36 years of solid engineering experience in my background, I certainly do appreciate the credibility Mr. Hamilton shows forth and am able to find little nuggets that are certainly better than the way I've been doing things. I shudder that any serious amateur woodworker looking to improve their skill set could be sent down a road of torturous filled effort by accepting as practical truth no need for a solid, well architected & designed work bench and is not needed in a smallish amateurs wood shop. I am so sorry you have wasted your time here. I wish you much success following your perceived superior ways.
i have to admit for wood work you have become a trust seal for me. none of you video/info given has ever let me down. thanks for all the hard work and passing on information that you would have spent life time gaining. God bless your heart and all your loved ones.
This guy, even now is my go to on all subjects involving wood. All the you tubers now and even some of the veteran wood working you tubers have nothing on the nubs.
James, you pronounce all your words so clearly. It is a pleasure just listening to you talk. ☺
I built my workbench from a Readers Digest plan back in the 70's. Built it on an open carport with a few tools I managed to scrounge up to fit in a 10 x10 metal shed. Though far from the professional versions, it's been through a lot over the years and still solid; more than I can say for myself.
Have watched several videos about building a workbench for my garage and this is by far the best one I’ve seen. Thank you for helping me figure out all the ways to build a work bench properly with maximum functionality. 👍🏻
James, you are a master of clear, succinct explanations that are full of helpful information. This video is an excellent example of verbal commentary, visual demo, and pacing. I have watched a few of your Stumpy Nubs videos and plan to work my way through most of the others.
Thank you for the time and effort you and your crew obviously put into your duel crafts or wood working and video production!
I, and apparently many others, appreciate you all!
Im a Jamaican and our work bench is just a plywood top and it get work done. We dnt have any of those fancy clamps at the shop i work. You explaining a proper work bench put things on a next level. Im planning on building my work bench at home and you give me an idea. Awesome video always. I subscribe few days ago. Keep up the great work.
I’ve been a cabinet maker 16(?) years, and I always find myself nodding to your videos. A lot of it I know, and checks out with my experience, but I always learn a couple of things I did not already know. Thanks for the prolific video-making.
Also, you should probably get to sleep. It’s almost 9:30 in Michigan! What are you, in your 20’s?
I have revisited this video numerous times when considering workbench adjustments. Consider this a belated thank you for making it.
As a newbie looking to build his first workbench, I thought this was an excellent summary. By far the most informative I have found on UA-cam
Just came across this video while considering how to build my next workbench. I must say I loved how you told us what to consider but also thoroughly supported it with why it is important. Great job on this video and thank you for the great advice!
I've watched this a couple of times and I really appreciate how you treat a bench as more than just a table, but as a sophisticated tool in itself.
Your review was excellent. I built my work bench 10 years ago and it is pretty simple: face vise, tail vice, dog holes. Very flat maple top, 4x4 SYP base with mortise and tenon joints, no nails, screws, or bolts and no tool tray.
I figured a woodworker worth his salt should build his own.
My vises have that quick release feature. I agree with you, they're more trouble than benefit.
End Vise , Face Vise ?? In Austria we use an Edelwiess !
I'll see myself out...
Love it!😂😂😂
As I am planning my workbench build, I watched 10+ videos on workbenches. This video was the most informative. The information was clearly communicated and important. Thanks a lot.
So happy I found this video before getting started on finally building a proper workbench. Thanks for sharing!
I am in the process of building my workbench and your information is as always spot on. It's small compared to most as it must fit into my 1 car garage shop. All wood is free, including a cherry butcher block slab top with a bottom slab of 2 1/4 in pine from old growth trees that had to have been 7 ft in diameter. (Salvaged from wife's grandfather's shop) Legs are free highly figured rock maple useless to my cabinet shop owner friend and paid for with ripe tomatoes. Life is good! The only thing that could make this build easier is to have a good workbench to work from in the first place! Ken
I have an old bench that was in the house when we moved in over 20 years ago. It's a heavy, stout old bugger but has a 2x6 top so it's far from smooth and has decades of pounding abuse so it's also all dinged up. I am getting ready to add a 3/4" plywood top that I'll seal so it doesn't soak up oils and stains and then drill bench dog holes in it. You gave me a few good ideas for how to make that better. One of the things that was already on my list was a tool shelf about 6-8" down from the top but with an additional one 3 or 4" down to catch sawdust that goes through the dog holes so it's not falling on the tool shelf. You made me realize that the "catch shelf" needs to be at least far enough down to allow the dogs or hold fast to drop in far enough to work properly.
Keep up the great videos James, I certainly appreciate them.
I've built several benches over the years, and each time I learn something new (sometimes about the bench, and sometimes about myself). My current bench is FWW's New-Fangled Workbench. I love the "crochet" (planing hook) and adjustable platform that supports the wood from underneath when hand planing. I'm not so fond of the pipe clamps used as face and tail vises. Like you, I loathe tool trays on benches. They attract clutter and a cluttered workbench is sub-optimal. Instead of a tool tray, I used some scrap plywood and 2x4s and created a rolling tool cart. The top is shorter than the bench, so even with tools on it I can have it next to me and it won't interfere with anything on the bench that might be overhanging the bench. It was an impulse decision to make it, and it's the best accessory for any bench. My next bench is going to be a combination of an English workbench and a Roubo workbench, with a split-top. Still in the design phase but should start working on it soon.
Thank you so much for your excellent videos. I watch and rewatch them all the time. I hope that we cross paths one day so I can shake your hand.
Getting information from an experienced person is greatly appreciated. I’m an union Ironworker by trade and have just started to work with wood as a hobby. I’ve been drawing up ideas to build a bench that integrates my old 70’s jointer with my new planer as well as be a work bench and hearing your POV is priceless thank you. I’ve went with 3/16 x 2x2 angle iron as the framework already and have a lot of maple I am now going to use for the top instead of the 1” mdf I was going to use. I find myself wanting to Swiss army the bench and have my table saw and band saw part of it to. If anyone has any links to where I can find ideas for a integrated work station I’ll just make a bench then the station for all the equipment . I daydream about having the bandsaw and jointer running on the same motor
I loved your video. I debated on the tool tray and finally built my bench with one. After 3 years of use, 51% of the time, I like the tray. I have 2 vises on my bench and use both vises. There have been many times where it has been very useful to keep a piece in the vice that I am working on and then use the other vise to quickly perform a task to fashion something to be used on the other piece. Because of this I am a fan of having a face and end vise.
I added a tool well also and grew tired of it constantly being filled with sawdust. So I added a hinged plexiglass top and it has been a game changer. Absolutely love it now.
@@brett328 I love this idea.
@@brett328 my plan is to have removable side-pieces to make an easy clean out...pull the big stuff out, remove the end pieces, rake the sawdust and chips on the floor, get yelled at by my better half, and....done! ;-)
Most times, when I build a new bench (after someone's decided to want the old one more than me...lolz) I add a few "dog-holes" around the sides at regular intervals... These are two-ways very very useful...
1. Depending on your own preferences (obviously) they allow certain utilities (like various sizes of trays) to be simply added to the side of the bench WHEN AND ONLY WHEN NECESSARY OR APPROPRIATE...
2. Being "dog-holes" exactly like the rest of them on the bench, they're a precision SIZE allowing for "odd clamping" techniques to be employed with only a bit of "predictable improvisation"...
Basically, using the same "hold-down" as on the top of the bench, you can "hold-sideways" on the side... a useful (even rarely) utility when certain joints and prospects over-hang at an angle otherwise unusually difficult to work with...
That dependable size, the same as the dogs, allows you to manufacture just about any "side-rig" or "out-rigger" you could possibly want for the face territory around the bench. Granted, with properly productive and predictable projects about, you shouldn't need it often if you need it at all... but man, it can make life SOOOooo much easier to have it and not need it than to need it and wonder why the hell you don't have it. ;o)
I love the big, expensive benches...I myself have an inexpensive but capable one that matches my level of involvement - but - I am always amazed at how Japanese craftsmen can sit on the floor with what amounts to a plank on their knees and still produce exquisite works out of wood. Their joinery and tool mastery are, in my eyes, unequaled.
James I fully agree with all your points. I’m currently designing a workbench for my shop. Your video helped me stick to my plan. Thanks.
What a great video. Never knew benches could be that involved, but it just makes me more excited to get into woodworking now. Thanks so much for this upload.
Your intro is Genius. Best one I've ever seen. And that's no BS.
Love your channel. I come here whenever I want a no butter sticks explanation of things. Thanks
Goodness...I got into casual weekend woodworking ~2 years ago when I bought my first house. I wish I would've found your channel 3 years ago. Fine work, good sir!
Dave Wisnosky I’m you 2 years from the time you wrote this.
Probably your best video. Straight, direct to the point, factual, and informative. Amazing job.
These videos are so good. I'm just getting into woodworking and figuring out my setup and tools is hard. I've been doing things sort of halfway in the DIY-save-money sense of building things. So a bunch of 2x4 projects. My current workbench is built from a pallet. Not even kidding - I found a pallet that was square, plumb, and level and turned that into my bench top, and did 2x4s for the underside. It's sturdy enough for light assembly of small projects, but it's really just a workbench shaped object. Looking forward to building a solid workbench this winter!
Simple, clear and precise information for any woodworker. Thks for sharing those valuable information ☺️.
Dang, you just saved me a TON of regrets! I was about to totally screw up my face and end vises when I start my bench in the morning. I was going to use a 10" quick-clamp style vise for a face vise and spend big bucks for the end vise. Your video makes so much sense. I am going to flush mount the 10" for an end vise and get a high quality face vise. Honestly, I expect to be building a second bench within a year or two with all the things I learn from this first one which is going to be 2x6 Southern Yellow Pine and probably too short and too soft, and full of regrets. Lol! 🙂 Thank you!
This video is the best explaining what I need to know about workbenches. Now I know so much more about this matter, specifically because I started to build one for myself. Thank you for this video.
Absolutely a vise on any kind of work bench is essential. Dude has his shit together with his shop for sure
Thanks for the video Stumpy some sound advice. Mine is a complete mongrel and I love it. It’s a work bench not a piece of furniture. It’s an English style or Nicholson bench with a flat solid softwood top over a frame of 5x2s on 5x5 legs. On one side there’s an old Record bench vise and on the other side my home-made moxon vise. I drilled a few dog holes but if I need another hole I just drill one or if I need a temporary hold then I just pop in a screw or a nail. For hammering or chopping, just go over a leg or the apron and nothing even flexes however hard you hit. When it gets too scruffy I put a sander over it and some Danish oil and it’s as good as new. If I ever have to change the top I’m going with a plank top to make it even simpler. For anyone thinking of building their own bench but feeling a bit intimidated I recommend checking out the EnglishWoodworker for some equally sound advice. Cheers from UK
I will be moving soon and am abandoning my old bench and will be building a new one for my new shop that is customized for me and my type of work. These vids are valuable, thanks again for your channel.
Thanks Stumpy! This is one of those subjects where I said to myself, "what could I really learn [new] from this video?!" Since it was you, I watched, and I'm damned glad I did before considering my own build. I learned more than I imagined- one of those, "you don't know what you don't know..." ignorant of my own ignorance on the topic... so to speak. Thanks again!!!!
Excellent tour of the woodworking bench. Exactly what I was looking for! Thanks.
I screwed an old door for the top onto my Mom's old dresser and put some wheels on it for my workbench.........I expect NASA to call with a job offer any day now.
Hahaha😃😃😃😃!
Your comment made my day.
@@Canosa612 Cool 😎!
Son, have you ever considered the possibility of life on other planets ?
Scaffolding boards and glue 👌👌
Hi James I also have the Sjobergs Elite 2000 with storage module and accessories got about 5yrs ago. Holdfast clamp does work well but can be a pain twisting the handle as opposed to wacking the other style with a mallet. I installed work bench casters makes it more convenient especially with a small shop. Really like your videos keep up the good work.
Just built a bench with vertical vises. And the one vise on the long edge is situated perfectly for a lefty…. Good thing I’m right-handed! Wish I had watched this video sooner!
We are about to rebuild our woodworking bench at the makerspace and this brings up a lot of good points (and reinforces many of the complaints) about the old bench we made. Thanks for sharing this information this way. It is now easier for me grok the "why" in the comments I get from people who don't build things the same way that I do.
So glad I came across this randomly. This is the best explanation why workbenches are made the way they are and why each thing is used. I pretty much just want that work bench.
I built my own bench back in 1997 when I didn't know a lot. luckily, I read a few books on workbenches and followed suggestions for things that I only later understood the reason for.
I have a quick-release front vise, that only is a slight problem because I got the guides slightly out of parallel, so I have to keep them well waxed for it to slide easily. I have a Veritas Twin-screw End vise that I've never had any problem with, but you are right, I use it less often. I got a pre=made laminated maple top, the legs, drawers, cabinet I did myself. I think the only thing I've sometimes wanted was the dog holes in the right front leg ( or one of those removable legs you see) but I can still add that, and probably should. I started with a Veritas adjustable holdfast, and it has always worked well. I only recently got a pair of traditional holdfasts and Man, I really prefer them. you can use them so quickly, holding or releasing that I now work more safely holding something that I used to try to get by without clamping well. You can buy shorter traditional style holdfasts.
I gave your video a thumbs up because it was so brutally honest. I say that because of the space and financial requirements that are not so easily met by some wood workers. For example, I rent and my shop has a standard door. It's like 35 or 36 inches and that kinda limits me unless I make the bench so I can take the top off and that the frame will fit through the door when I can't pay my rent. LOL!
So many features that I've never seen before on any of the workbenches I've used, now I have some more things to look for when I get/make my own workbench someday!
This was very helpful.
I ended up following the Mike Siemsen template for a Nicholson workbench.
I'm under the impression that I will find all kinds of problems down the road, and once I know exactly what I want I'll build another that fits my specific, known needs, especially since I currently only have about 100 dollars of wood into the whole build.
Follow up comment: GREAT video. Clear, concise, and conscientious. Aware of what works and what doesn’t. Really appreciate the nod to building mass for stability. It’s OK to have storage below.
Outstanding intro and run-down. Wish I had a shop like that... one day! One part at a time.
Agree on the tool tray. I build a rolling tray, nothing fancy just a three-shelf cart on soft smooth-rolling (but lockable) casters from Home Depot. That way I can have all the tools I'll need for a job on that tray, within arm's reach. When I'm done, they all get cleaned and put back into storage locations. It definitely cuts down on having to move all about the shop for clamps, bits, chisels, whatever.
I agree with your statement to not get caught up in whatever workbench is trending at the moment. There's been a lot of that in the past few years with glowing testimonies of Roubo style workbenches.
Your videos are invaluable to me, thank you so much. Quality and delivery are always excellent. Thanks again
🙏🏽🙏🏻I want to say a big thanks for your education and shared experience.🙏🏻🙏🏽
Your amazingly unexcited way to teach & explain is an refreshing change in the chaotic UA-cam world.
Finally managed to subscribe on your website.
Thank you
Thanks James. Good tip about keeping the legs flat with the face; I hadn't heard that one pointed out before but it could come in extremely handy.
I accidentally did that on my design for a diy bench and now after using it for months i would never ever go back to an overhanging tapletop =) Especially since my budget has not allowed me yet to get a vise. This. Is. Worth. Gold. =)
Spot on! Love the explanation of each feature and what you need to think of if you attempt to make one. The two things that I didn't incorporate into my bench are the face vice and dog holes on the legs. If I were to do it again, I would add them. Great video Stumpy.
James Hamilton, for real I thought Stumpy Nubs was a nickname you go by, until your greeting at the start of this video. Thanks for all your exceptionally good information!
Another jewel in the crown, James. Top video, to the point and with a lot of very useful info.
I have been racking my brain for months trying to decide what bench to build or buy. Nice educational tutorial, Thanks
¡Eres brujo! 😮🧙🏻♂️, es la tercera vez que tus videos corresponden a la labor que realizo.
Muchas, muchas gracias por compartir
I am building the Samurai Carpenter Workbench now (for the last few months - yes, I am slow, but I am also learning a lot as I go and practicing most things on scrap stuff first). The point is, your video kept me from making a big mistake with my Face Vice - I was thinking of adding (not in the plans) a rear face vs using the Apron- now I can see that would have been a major mistake! Thanks and keep these videos coming.
I had my first look at this video when it initially came out. Now I’m about to build my first bench since my workshop is finally finished. I’ve watched many videos on workbenches since this one, but I’m pleased to see how much of this one has stuck with me for these two years. James is a great teacher, woodworker, father, visionary, humorist, thinker, etc. Sharing the knowledge between his ears will bless woodworkers and their craft for decades, or even centuries, to come. This channel is truly a treasure.
Made my holdfast is of a carefully chosen branch of Rhodedendron. Grows wild here and can cut it to a not annoying length, for those who don’t have the four inch bench tops. I love using this bit of scrap wood and giving it a bash with a mallet and seeing people’s faces.
Thanks, I have a great base on my bench, but just an old solid core door for a top, I’ve been thinking of making a better top and you gave some good advice.
I love these longer videos...
That workbench looks almost exactly like the one my dad had, only much nicer. He actually built two. He built the first one from scraps so he had a base to build the second. He incorporated the table saw into his bench, and made it wide enough to secure a 4' x 8' sheet of plywood. We were always in construction mode, so the 4' x 8' standard was, well, standard. The pickup had to have a bed that could accommodate a sheet flat, the workbench had fit one, the sheet goods truck had to fit them too. Good video!
One of he best produced and informative videos I've seen.
Mr Hamilton...I love your videos, and I really, really appreciate that I can play them anytime, even with my children are in the room....Butter sticks, indeed, sir! Thanks for keeping the bar raised. (And proving that humor need not always hit below the belt....)
Thank you so much for this video. I just started learning about woodworking benches and have been overwhelmed by all the terminology, what with moxon vises and wagon vises and tail vises and round dogs vs square dogs and tool wells, etc. You really covered everything quite succinctly and I now have a much better understanding of the workbench and the features to keep in mind. Thanks again!
Just paid $10 for a Sheldon quick release a few weeks back, now No excuses now. Thanks James
other than having my kids i tihnk one of the best ideas i ever had was making my own workbench.I did the Paul Sellers type build for the top. only complaint i have is i used 2x10's and yeah its more than likely stronger than the entirety of the McMansion i bought that its sitting in but holy crap was it a pricey project. i have it set up to use the modern hold downs i also have a smaller pattern of holes thta are only half inch and i have made a bunch of custom stuff in my metal shop to go in them. i hope i never move house because this thing has to weigh at least 1000lbs at 8ft long and 4ft deep its a honking monster.
I wanna see a photo of this monster
Wow ! Wonderful set of information. I am so glad I have seen this video before building my solid workbench. Thank you. watching from Haiti
Wonderful video. Excellent presentation style. Crystal clear articulation. Everyday language that most people can easily understand which actually inspires me to go down to my humble work area and make 'stuff'. Congratulations!!
Greetings from Brisbane, Australia.
Well researched, prepared, executed and edited. Thanks
Great food for thought. Mine’s legs are set back…I’ll be facing them out with 2x4 on the front. Great vice advice too.
yeah i like the vid, I have two work benches in my shop that i bought from old or dead woodworkers. They are both different, and you are right, there are pros and cons with each model, and when you start working on them, you realize what you dont have, rarely are we thankful for what we do have because we just assume its always there or common to all work benches. I am ready to sell both of mine and build a bench that works well in more ways. If only I had more time.
Another quality video with tons of great info and no fluff. I get excited every time I see a new Stumpy Nubs video. Thank you!!!
Great overview of the workbench,
I’m a little surprised you didn’t talk a little about the difference between this workbench and the other one you have a build video fore
Thank you for sharing 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
The one I built has all these features (storage cabinet was added later). After a while I did wish I had mounted the vise on the left and used a wider chop. And I wish it was hardwood, but that couldn't be helped. But that same bench can be built from those plans to meet all the criteria in this video. www.stumpynubs.com/2x6-roubo-workbench.html
James, you really know your shit. Seriously, you are a wealth of knowledge. Keep up the good work, I love your channel.
I think Rex made some really good points for why a vice which racks is not only acceptable, but even desirable:
1. Without big guide bars, you have more room for holding large parts.
2. If your vice can rack, it can be used to hold tapered parts very securely. the vice will conform to the angle you need on its own, just by tightening, without the need for extra shims.
As you mentioned, you can compensate for racking when you need to hold a piece in one side of the vice by adding a spacer. While this isn’t necessarily desirable, it’s easier than finding spacers for tapered parts as I mentioned before.
4. High-quality screws are inexpensive and easy to find, so you could reasonably make your own vice on a budget if you’re willing to accept racking.
Awesome video. I am in the middle of building a laminated 2x4 bench. I will redesign my legs before I chop out the mortises for the legs.
Brilliant content for a beginner. THANK YOU!
I learned so so much from this video. Now I have reasons to love my benches and know what I can improve on. Awesome!!! Thanks.
as a woodworker begginer myself I'm loving this video, it really makes me want to buy\build my proper work bench! Thanks for the info Stumpy! U deserve a cold one!
I love how you explain the WHY of your decisions. EG: For me, as I need to set up and tear down my bench every time I work, being an apartment dweller who works in the yard in the complex, from your own description, I realized a tool well will probably be great to me, as I can't have a wall of tools nearby, and it's guaranteed to get cleared out between work sessions when I stow my bench. Thank you.
Do you talk anywhere about your thoughts on twin-screw vices?
I had an odd workbench that was 4” thick in the center, mounted on barrels, but only 1” thick out at the last 18” at the ends where it hung over. I had a very heavy duty Wilton vise and the only place I could really mount it to get the stability it needed was in the center, where it’s very secure. I can work around it OK, but the biggest limitation of having it center mounted is that I can’t trim the ends of long boards with a hand saw, but that’s what table saws and miter saws are for. It has a quick release mechanism that works very well. In hindsight I should have just made shims for it at the left end, but it’s mounted with long recessed bolts that are countersunk and the holes filled with epoxy, so it would be a bear to move now.
Because I have four 55 gallon drums under the bench, I’m able to use those long bench hold downs in a few key areas with no problem, but those modern ones are a lot more convenient for sure. I believe all the bench dog holes I drilled in the bench are for 3/4” diameter dogs and hold downs. Thanks for the great tips! This is the only video I’ve ever seen having the details about vise placement. 👍
A man after my own heart.
I built my bench with a face and end vice, and I virtually never use the end vice. I'd have to say the end vice was a waste of money and effort. The face vice is a Jorgenson quick-release-and it always works.
I too have never understood the value of tool trays. Quite enough junk gathers on the benchtop without adding a too-shallow place to collect objects that poke above the surface and prevent me from laying anything flat on the surface, aside from turning a good portion of your bench surface into a dustbin. Drawers are convenient enough for oft-used tools, and they add mass and keep the tools form gathering sawdust and swarf.
I didn't add an end vise to my bench, mainly through lack of funds than planning, but I don't miss it. I use the right hand end for sawing and an end vise would get in the way. I will probably add a fixed (but easily removed) bench hook instead as it will be used much more.
My big mistake was a single low shelf underneath (junk and dust collection area), so I will most likely build a cabinet and drawers to replace that next spring.
You need a good bench hook :) ua-cam.com/video/9mMdZD8OdyA/v-deo.html
I've just today put up another MDF board and hung up my files and chisels. The only thing I do want on the side (or in) the bench is my 2 most-used saws. I'm thinking about cutting a slot for them on the side. Or adding a single small beam that will hold them. They take too much space on the wall and I've plenty below the bench (no tools there)
I recently added a tool well/tray that mounts along one side of my bench. At first I really liked it, then the constant filling up with dust started to wear on me. So I added a hinged top lid to the tool well and it really won me over all over again. It keeps the dust out, forces me not to overload it with too tall or too many things and became a real bonus for keeping all different size brads and screws at hand at all times. You can check it out on my channel if your interested, not why I commented, just really like the tool well now that it has been modded to perform better.
This video is pure gold.
Oh boy. Seriously, OH! BOY!!! It seems you covered almost everything, and being a "newbie," you told us about what really MAKES a good bench; I thought it was "simple," but it seems that's just "my newbie brain talkin'."
And it came at a good time for me. I figured I'd start small by building a "table-top bench," and I'm still going to but I'm gonna use (read that "steal") several ideas now that you described here. So, thanks!
It was a very comprehensive posting, and I really gotta hand it to you. Thanks again.
Thank you. Can confirm this and all your other videos are no bs with so much great info to an amateur woodworker.
i buy used solid core flush doors and use those as a surface. Even mounted one into a work cabinet. Worked great.
I am in the process of designing a workbench for my shop and these are excellent points that you have made and I will incorporate them into my design. Thank you, much appreciated.
Love the collection of planes on the top shelf! Height is something to consider, most of what I do is fine detail work so I prefer a bench that's about elbow height when standing, which is much higher than most people like. If I go for something as low as knuckle height (what a lot of recommendations say to go for) I'd have a horrible kink in my back....
I'm totally with you. My understanding is the lower bench height comes from when all cutting and surfacing was done with hand saws and hand planes, and the height suited the body mechanics needed for doing this all day long. My bench is 34" high and I also made a "bench" another 10" high that clamps on top to get even closer to the work.
im nearly 7' tall so my shop is the kind of place most people cant work in with out a step ladder at every table lol
Your show has improved 1000%
I feel like you hit on a lot of great points! And I agree. It’s way better to over build a bench. Also I store my tools in tool boxes underneath the bench on a shelf. So if I need to I can quickly move a whole bunch simply by sliding the tool box over
_Excellent_ guide. This will help me design my home-built upgrade work bench. 👍🙂
I find myself liking your videos more and more with each one I watch!!!!!!!
Hey no need to let those leg vices go to waste in your shed. You can always give them to me. 😀 lol. Great video my friend. Thanks for sharing! Thanks again for all the quality content. I've learned so much from your channel. I can't thank you enough! Let me know if you have any other tools going to waste... I would be more than happy to help you get rid of all the clutter! Haha. Thanks again!
You beat me to it. I was going to say the same thing.
A most excellent and concise video, contains all the points to consider.
Don
Thanks Don!
I always put a spacer the same size of what I'm working on at the other end of my LN chain vice - just to keep the pressure even. Learned that from the legend Chris Becksvoort!