SpaceX Starship 28 Re-entry Animation

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 бер 2024
  • Used the footage from the live stream to approximate Starship's orientation.
    Music is Shenzhou from Gravity
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 241

  • @Proxicentia
    @Proxicentia  Місяць тому +3

    Hello new and returning viewers, checkout this much better visualisation by TheSpaceEngineer: m.ua-cam.com/video/99FZxaqFT7I/v-deo.html

  • @captain_commenter8796
    @captain_commenter8796 Місяць тому +191

    The fact it didn’t immediately break up despite a majority of its reentry being UPSIDE DOWN is the biggest flex for those starship engineers. Rip Ship 28

    • @Fickil1i
      @Fickil1i Місяць тому +16

      The stainless steel body had higher melting point considering it's also why they ditched the carbon composites for big falcon rocket

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому +1

      steel

    • @bosshog8844
      @bosshog8844 Місяць тому +5

      I heard it said that the total thrust demonstrated by S28 is roughly equal to what is required for a direct to earth return from the surface of Mars.

    • @WyoSavage1976
      @WyoSavage1976 Місяць тому +4

      Not to mention it looked like it also lost a bunch of heat tiles.

    • @Jadefox32
      @Jadefox32 Місяць тому +1

      ​@WyoSavage1976 it was actually ice

  • @ianmastin
    @ianmastin Місяць тому +50

    Watching the development of Starship has been the Apollo Program of our generation... these are the moments that we remembr years from now as having inspired a nation to dream just a little bit bigger. Thank you to EVERYONE who has made this possible, you are literally putting the future of humanity in space!

    • @Tim4706
      @Tim4706 Місяць тому +1

      My generation grew up with the Space Shuttle I remember watching as a kid in elementary school the landing tests with Enterprise and the first launch like you said Apollo of your generation I like that.🇺🇲

    • @ianmastin
      @ianmastin Місяць тому +1

      @Tim4706 Sadly, I'm just old enough that I'll likely live to see it all be possible but not quite long enough for it to be practical... my greatest contributions won't be made in space, but in sharing my passion with the next generation, in hope they might take up the torch and carry it out into the stars.

    • @tomrichter9079
      @tomrichter9079 Місяць тому

      I saw the Apollo night launch in person. I know what you guys feel🚀🚀🚀

  • @stevengaming3689
    @stevengaming3689 Місяць тому +87

    S28 - First Starship that Reentered upside down. Chad.

    • @lyft4238
      @lyft4238 Місяць тому +6

      And Starlink. What a beastly connection it had

    • @user-mf4sx3so7v
      @user-mf4sx3so7v Місяць тому +1

      Chad's dead on mars lol

    • @BlueAerospace236
      @BlueAerospace236 Місяць тому

      bro forgot ryan hensens

    • @stevengaming3689
      @stevengaming3689 10 днів тому +1

      ​@@BlueAerospace236bro forgot that ryan hansen's starship broke up while entering sideways

  • @Opusss
    @Opusss Місяць тому +44

    Elon is going to have to have a chat with Starship about its attitude.

  • @OfentseMwaseFilms
    @OfentseMwaseFilms Місяць тому +24

    Thank you for this great visualization

  • @MrVolodus
    @MrVolodus Місяць тому +25

    They had signal for almost all time! That is absolutely crazy! First live video of reentry.

  • @aadvaitture
    @aadvaitture Місяць тому +36

    oh my god the music and the visuals!
    this feels like those epic ending to a story which leads to a even more exiting future
    you just made my hype for IFT-4 10x

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому +3

      Gravity, landing scene, burning.

    • @aadvaitture
      @aadvaitture Місяць тому

      @@mareksarvas1102 yeah, but i have not watched gravity nor did my breath stopped while i watched that scene.

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      @@aadvaitture
      By all means, enjoy the ride down the hill... Pleasant experience
      ua-cam.com/video/2EMOVUZPJSM/v-deo.html

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      @@aadvaitture ua-cam.com/video/2EMOVUZPJSM/v-deo.html

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому +1

      @@aadvaitture ???

  • @DudsMotorShop
    @DudsMotorShop Місяць тому +22

    You could see it tumbling in the live video. It has impeccable structural integrity to withstand those loads in a reverse, inverted orientation.

    • @Cleptro
      @Cleptro Місяць тому +1

      To be fair, we knew Starship was robust after IFT-1 flipped and rolled out of control, and then the FTS *failed to terminate the rocket.*
      That said, seeing that plasma build up against Starship's hull as it tumbled wildly through the upper atmosphere was incredible. Seeing this thing work on a successful flight is going to be a sight to behold. What a spectacle of modern engineering.

    • @DudsMotorShop
      @DudsMotorShop Місяць тому

      @@Cleptro The question is what happened at stage separation for it to tumble. It looked initially like the fuel was sloshing end to end as if there were no baffles in the fuel tanks, and then it went inverted following the fuel transfer to the nose tank... #JustAnObservation

    • @dsdy1205
      @dsdy1205 Місяць тому

      My two cents is that a vent or thruster was stuck open, rolling the Starship constantly during its coast phase. It used other thrusters to counter, but those obviously exhausted themselves in due course. So come the moment of entry interface, Starship was left rolling with no way to stabilise into reentry attitude. The flaps did their best but it was never going to be enough, not to mention with the fuel tanks completely drained, the trim was probably way outside the control limits the flaps were designed for.​@DudsMotorShop

  • @Slacker_eepy
    @Slacker_eepy Місяць тому +119

    Bro I’m still trying to get used to the fact that STARSHIP HAS BEEN IN ORBIT NOW. WE ARE SO CLOSE.

    • @v-q-np15
      @v-q-np15 Місяць тому

      It was in space in IFT-2

    • @Slacker_eepy
      @Slacker_eepy Місяць тому +4

      @@v-q-np15 alright fine, *orbit

    • @AeonExploration
      @AeonExploration Місяць тому +3

      it has not been in orbit

    • @samuelalves391
      @samuelalves391 Місяць тому +3

      Orbital speed, not in orbit

    • @Slacker_eepy
      @Slacker_eepy Місяць тому +20

      God dammit guys, let me be happy for one goddamn second! You’re killing the mood!

  • @cabanford
    @cabanford Місяць тому +4

    Amazing how quickly the whole project is moving forward. Fascinating.

  • @Astronetics
    @Astronetics Місяць тому +15

    This is really well done. Helps visualize what was happening orientation-wise during the "reentry"

  • @benni1951
    @benni1951 2 місяці тому +17

    That was pretty epic ngl, and also probably quite accurate. Thank you!

  • @paulgrove1407
    @paulgrove1407 Місяць тому +14

    The amount of data generated by this flight is incredible. Not even a shuttle re-entry was this closely monitored.

    • @jebes909090
      @jebes909090 Місяць тому +2

      thats because the shuttle actually worked

    • @gordonslippy1073
      @gordonslippy1073 Місяць тому

      Actually, we know a lot about the breakup of STS-107 (Columbia), which occurred at roughly the same altitude.

    • @Jadefox32
      @Jadefox32 Місяць тому

      ​@jebes909090 Challenger and Columbia, also they had to replace tiles and look for any and all microcracks and repair them which is why the shuttle hardly launched more than once or twice a year.

    • @paulgrove1407
      @paulgrove1407 Місяць тому +3

      @gordonslippy1073 what I meant was telemetry. Thanks to Starlink there was even video feeds.

    • @gordonslippy1073
      @gordonslippy1073 Місяць тому

      @@paulgrove1407 yes, agreed, the video feed was amazing.

  • @clintatk
    @clintatk Місяць тому +5

    Excellent work! It helps me understand how its integrity held up for so long. SpaceX has done an amazing job building such a robust vehicle.

  • @merky6004
    @merky6004 Місяць тому +9

    You just had to put the music from Gravity there…
    Now I’m all emotional about Ship 28.

  • @dimastandayu9576
    @dimastandayu9576 Місяць тому +6

    Thank you for the beautiful animation

  • @LG-ct8tw
    @LG-ct8tw Місяць тому +8

    Pay load door had failed open, TLS tiles where flying off in chunks, ship was in "rotisserie" mode. would have been nice to see that from another POV than the SpaceX flap mounted camera.

  • @creedyboy124
    @creedyboy124 Місяць тому +3

    In Memory of S28
    2022-2024 🕊🙏
    Thank you, S28... You may rest in peace 😢
    BRING OUT S29!!!!!!

  • @chaspfrank
    @chaspfrank Місяць тому +10

    So it effectively was not stabilized prior to entering the atmosphere, and was never able to maintain constant contact between the atmosphere and the heat tiles, causing structural damage and subsequent vehicle failure?

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      Yes

    • @mertc8050
      @mertc8050 Місяць тому

      Nope lack of stabilization caused it to dive down instead of gliding in atmosphere so when it hit thick 65km atmosphere at that speed it got destroyed thx to the speed

    • @chaspfrank
      @chaspfrank Місяць тому

      @@mertc8050Got it. Makes sense.

  • @Hi-ke_Lc
    @Hi-ke_Lc Місяць тому +17

    Immediately realized Gravity ost. The perfect choice for reentry

  • @brunobastos5533
    @brunobastos5533 Місяць тому +4

    did better than many expected , how many ships could survive so long

  • @nomrom357
    @nomrom357 Місяць тому

    Great music. It really fits perfectly

  • @dalegray934
    @dalegray934 Місяць тому +1

    Well done. This was excellent.

  • @phlebiacbrothers717
    @phlebiacbrothers717 Місяць тому

    Incredible amazing presentation idk how you made this so well but I'm happy you did 😊

  • @Lopez_rc
    @Lopez_rc Місяць тому

    Great animation! Good music choice with those parts burning up

  • @Kabup2
    @Kabup2 Місяць тому +8

    This is the missing video of ift-3, thanks!

  • @Gildas_djdb
    @Gildas_djdb Місяць тому

    Your animation is amazing! Well done!

  • @idimitrov7
    @idimitrov7 Місяць тому

    Very nice video! Bravo for making it!:)

  • @coal_edxts
    @coal_edxts Місяць тому +1

    Insane music selection my guy

  • @christopherjohnson1803
    @christopherjohnson1803 Місяць тому +1

    The massive thrust of those engines on liftoff was something to behold!! Could see some damage to the pad in the 1st few seconds.

  • @zahone001
    @zahone001 Місяць тому

    This is amazing!

  • @Cosmic_Encryption
    @Cosmic_Encryption Місяць тому

    Most suited music for For every reentry video❤

  • @jebes909090
    @jebes909090 Місяць тому +7

    1:01 this is incorrect. starship is side on at this point. only half the heat shield were protecting it, the other half was pure stainless steel. starship was out of control and tumbling.

    • @raiguard
      @raiguard Місяць тому +1

      It started out that way, but you can see shortly before the plasma blocks the view of the Earth that it is turning into the stream. It stabilizes, if only for a few moments!

    • @jebes909090
      @jebes909090 Місяць тому +1

      @@raiguard thats not stabilizing, thats it tumbling into a correct position for a moment. It was suppose to be that way the whole time.

  • @mareksarvas1102
    @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому +10

    Very good choice of music from the right movie and the right scene. Well thank you. 🤔

  • @clevergirl4457
    @clevergirl4457 Місяць тому

    You got me bawling over here.
    RIP S28!
    May you spin your way to Valhalla! 😭

  • @Mike-ff7ib
    @Mike-ff7ib Місяць тому

    Great video. Well done.

  • @clarence3654
    @clarence3654 Місяць тому +5

    Nice animation.

  • @anacletomarcelino243
    @anacletomarcelino243 Місяць тому

    Like IFT1 the integrity of the vehicle is amazing

  • @aussiesheriff7070
    @aussiesheriff7070 Місяць тому

    Brilliant mate

  • @cbuchner1
    @cbuchner1 Місяць тому +2

    I‘ll look forward to the first uninterrupted video feed through reentry and landing. This will be epic.

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      That will never happen. Hot plasma will always break the connection. Always.

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      @@mareksarvas1102 we dont really know starship might be big enough to leave a tiny hole and allow starlink to send data

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      @@gamers-xh3uc Child.. 🤣

  • @jerryarcher1923
    @jerryarcher1923 Місяць тому

    Great animation…it tells a lot…Thanks.

  • @VictorDeVandenesse
    @VictorDeVandenesse 2 місяці тому +2

    Pretty nice!

  • @EuloSounds
    @EuloSounds Місяць тому

    incredible

  • @Pepstine
    @Pepstine Місяць тому +1

    Awesome

  • @isaquehossain1427
    @isaquehossain1427 Місяць тому +2

    Can you do one with a constant wide view so we can see how its rotating the whole time?

    • @bilbo75
      @bilbo75 Місяць тому

      Agree. Showing the close up is dramatic, but doesn’t help when you’re trying to understand how the ship was rotating through the reentry. Still the best representation I have seen so far, so thanks for making this!

  • @Danielspacex
    @Danielspacex Місяць тому +1

    Can you chat about the physics behind the flip? Why did it rotate? Had the correct angle. I just thought it would stay on angle?

  • @SanferantoFer
    @SanferantoFer Місяць тому +1

    Os dados do 3° lançamento irá ser crucial para o sucesso do 4.Aprimorar a cada lançamento para ficarmos cada vez mais perto de dominarmos a Lua e o espaço próximo.Um 'trem de cargas' já possuirmos.

  • @jacquesjacques-yh8hh
    @jacquesjacques-yh8hh Місяць тому +1

    The orientation algorithms and actuators have to be re-designed based on collected datas.....May be 3 to 4 months to implement the modifications for starship IFT4

  • @FrEeWaY7k
    @FrEeWaY7k Місяць тому +1

    i like the soundtrack you picked.

  • @PrinceDamlanil
    @PrinceDamlanil 2 місяці тому +2

    Oh! Very nice

  • @f.w.1318
    @f.w.1318 Місяць тому +1

    While watching the live feed and seen Starship roll to Starboard,( :45 sec mark), she was toast, to bad there wasn't a camera on the other forward flap, that would of been a sight to see, we all saw Columbia disintegrated from the ground, but watching as it happened to starship from starship would of been monumental.

  • @meloon6426
    @meloon6426 Місяць тому +1

    Amazing job! I appreciate the work put in🫀

  • @vmafferreira6466
    @vmafferreira6466 Місяць тому +3

    No RCS actuation to control attitude nor aerodinamic stabilization and not enough or lack of fuel to reduce reentry speed. I think

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      Nope the problem was the spin the heat shield should be powerful enough to stop the plasma but the other side not so much, is impossible to successfully re-enter while the ship is spinning like a bay blade even if it was going slower

  • @jtr549
    @jtr549 Місяць тому

    Boldly going where no starship has gone before

  • @ZOEIRO_TNF
    @ZOEIRO_TNF Місяць тому +1

    O escudo de calor aguentou muito hein? Sem falar que o Starship em certas condições é bem resistente, exemplo disso é que no primeiro teste, que o Starship rodou, rodou e rodou, não se desintegrou mas foi destruído

  • @starfaxmc
    @starfaxmc Місяць тому +1

    My average Starship's reentry on KSP :

  • @edwardson6825
    @edwardson6825 Місяць тому +1

    Looked like my last SSTO reentry in Kerbal. Bit to hot then swapped ends followed by rapid unplanned disassembly.

  • @enkiusz
    @enkiusz Місяць тому

    Nice, you almost made it look like it wasn't a tumbling failure of a launch :).

  • @aspuzling
    @aspuzling Місяць тому +1

    "Do a flip"
    Starship: "Alright then"

    • @ghost307
      @ghost307 Місяць тому +1

      The computer deciding to do a victory roll was probably not the best choice.

  • @WyoSavage1976
    @WyoSavage1976 Місяць тому

    Nice animation👍👍

  • @MrAstonishing47
    @MrAstonishing47 Місяць тому

    Wowsers 🔥🔥

  • @bobjoatmon1993
    @bobjoatmon1993 Місяць тому

    So it didn't naturally assume the reentry position from its aerodynamics and continued to tumble so that lead to heating in unprotected areas and loss of the ship.
    So SpaceX is going to have to put attitude control thrusters in place or maybe reaction control flywheels although they'd be heavy and cause payload reduction.

  • @Vondoodle
    @Vondoodle Місяць тому +1

    Great animation- i wonder why it couldn’t correct the tumble ?

  • @x6ftundx
    @x6ftundx Місяць тому

    I want to know, when did it start spinning? was it as soon as it separated or what caused it to do this?

  • @leonardhopper857
    @leonardhopper857 Місяць тому +1

    Yep, like a turkey over the fence. Upside down and backwards with feathers going everywhere. LOL
    All jokes aside,
    What it does show is that attitude control was lost somewhere shortly after MECO and like any unguided ballistic object, it is heavy end first as atmospheric drag builds up.
    Oh and that is a domestic turkey, not a wild one. Wild turkeys do know how to fly. Domestics on the other hand.... WKRP......

  • @marvinellis1517
    @marvinellis1517 Місяць тому +1

    Remember , this is only a test ! 😮 ❤❤

  • @JeremiahWashington-bd2sr
    @JeremiahWashington-bd2sr Місяць тому +1

    Incredible. It has to have exploded by the plasma in the engine bay. (Starship makes the space shuttle look bad)

    • @JeremiahWashington-bd2sr
      @JeremiahWashington-bd2sr Місяць тому

      Space shuttle: Uh oh, wrong angle for entry *immediate explosion*
      Starship: what’s the issue *as it tumbles for minutes through reentry*

  • @MojaveMark
    @MojaveMark Місяць тому

    What's great is, there's no loss of life as with Apollo and the Space Shuttle

  • @dreadous
    @dreadous Місяць тому

    Nice work! I know the time you put into that. So it was tumbling taking all that heat? So the heat tiles wasn't the issue.

  • @Logoseum
    @Logoseum Місяць тому

    A blaze of glory.

  • @jojolafrite90
    @jojolafrite90 Місяць тому

    Is it accurate? How did you make it? A "normal" fluid simulation, like FLIP, realflow, etc? Open FOAM?
    PS: I wish we could have seen the complete reentry, plus landing. I mean, technically, I don't even know if this thing "landed", I just find the short videos or things that suppose we follow this in detail all the time.

  • @tvguide4khv
    @tvguide4khv Місяць тому

    pls show abnormal external point rotation, post ship engines shutdown

  • @pairoa
    @pairoa Місяць тому

    Starship sacrificed itself in the name of science

  • @HailAnts
    @HailAnts Місяць тому

    They still have a long way to go. Getting up there is the easy part. Getting back down in one piece is tough..

  • @thomasstevenrothmbamd2384
    @thomasstevenrothmbamd2384 Місяць тому +1

    Wow! You just have to love Elon Musk.

  • @Tsopni
    @Tsopni Місяць тому +1

    Somehow it reminds me Columbia STS disaster

  • @renanfeitosa101
    @renanfeitosa101 Місяць тому

    this looks the most of my ksp reentry’s

  • @davidmessersmith786
    @davidmessersmith786 Місяць тому

    Was there any ground observation and video footage?

  • @jonmarquez128
    @jonmarquez128 Місяць тому

    I am sure they will learn to execute the right menuvaurs on the next orbital flight test!

  • @1moredayof
    @1moredayof Місяць тому

    They probably should have used maneuvering rockets to keep the heat shield tiles facing in the right direction until the wing surfaces could take control.

  • @crisromero6564
    @crisromero6564 Місяць тому

    Glad to be alive to witness this historic and groundbreaking event. It takes perseverance to get to somewhere. Elon Musk & Co. just doing that. Keep on doing the research and development. 🙏👍👍

  • @user-vd1vj8ti5b
    @user-vd1vj8ti5b Місяць тому

    Well, at least the music wasn't affected by reentry.

  • @shawns0762
    @shawns0762 Місяць тому

    The best method for re-entry would be to use a massive parachute/s. There is a very narrow window of time at the beginning of re entry when a parachute could be successfully deployed. The ship should flip first then deploy from the nosecone so the ship would come down engines first. Every engine would serve as a maximum efficient, miniature parachute. This would eliminate the need for the flaps and the thermal tiles. It would also eliminate the need for the dreaded flip maneuver before touchdown.

    • @MarvelousLXVII
      @MarvelousLXVII Місяць тому +1

      Um...

    • @shawns0762
      @shawns0762 Місяць тому

      @@MarvelousLXVII There is no reason for there to be a rapid re entry, it should take at least 3 hours

    • @evanmorris1178
      @evanmorris1178 Місяць тому

      You do realize that parachutes don’t work at that altitude, and certainly not at 26,000 kph. Be real.

    • @shawns0762
      @shawns0762 Місяць тому

      @@evanmorris1178 They work wherever there is air pressure. There is almost no air pressure at the beginning of re entry. There is no question that a parachute can be successfully deployed. It would have to be large enough to maintain a steady pressure. Parachutes have been successfully used on heavier vehicles such as the XB-70 and TU-160

    • @evanmorris1178
      @evanmorris1178 Місяць тому

      @@shawns0762 The weight of the vehicle was not the issue. It’s the speed. You cannot deploy a chute at 26,000 kph. You are positing that one could slow down from that velocity, 200 km above earth with a parachute. It just doesn’t work that way. Nothing would be strong enough to take the shock. You are literally dumping all the energy added to the starship getting in to orbit, into the
      chute in a short period of time. There isn’t enough air pressure at that altitude to open it in the first place, but if you could get it open and keep it that way long enough for it to somehow get into enough atmosphere for it to even start slowing the Starship down, it would just tear off, possibly tearing the hull in the process. That’s a lot of force! There is no “narrow window of time” when that would work. Have you never noticed that craft are always decelerated by retro burns first, then parachutes are deployed in the lower atmosphere after speed has been bled down to manageable levels. Apollo’s droug’s we’re deployed below Mach .7. Mains at around 120mph max. With the much heavier Starship, these speeds would need to be reduced. Or the harness made much stronger. Which adds weight.

  • @jefersonsilva1673
    @jefersonsilva1673 Місяць тому

    Bom trabalho

  • @deanstevenson1649
    @deanstevenson1649 Місяць тому

    I would have thought 3s of non-heatshield exposure would be immediate RUD

  • @tamaspeter9700
    @tamaspeter9700 Місяць тому

    Gravity soundtrack. Of course😊

  • @MajinLiveTV
    @MajinLiveTV Місяць тому

    Then Maggie turned, faced the planet that would kill her, and like the good professor of Eastern religions that she used to be, she composed jisei, the death poem, in the haiku form.
    Do not mourn me, friends
    I fall as a shooting star
    Into the next life
    She sent it and the last moments of her life to the rest of us, and then she died, hurtling brightly across the Temperance night sky.
    She was my friend. Briefly, she was my lover. She was braver than I ever would have been in the moment of death. And I bet she was a hell of a shooting star.
    -Old Man's War - John Scalzi

  • @Tim4706
    @Tim4706 Місяць тому +1

    They just need to work on getting the positioning correct for re-entry I think they're going to be successful and recover the vehicle in the next flight

    • @Kabup2
      @Kabup2 Місяць тому

      Yeah, upside down reentry cannot be good to anybody.

    • @xponen
      @xponen Місяць тому

      the engine might not restart and crash.

  • @juliancrooks3031
    @juliancrooks3031 Місяць тому

    If you watch the last 5 minutes of video feed it looks like it lost some heat shield tiles so it just burned up like Columbia

  • @mareksarvas1102
    @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому +1

    I don't understand one thing, the fully fueled carrier and the ship got it to about 200 km high orbit, no more fuel was available. It flew without cargo. Something doesn't feel right.

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      There was more fuel available they cut the engines if not it will make it to orbit, they didn’t relight the engines cause the vehicle was out of control

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      @@gamers-xh3uc 3-5 minuts max

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      @@mareksarvas1102yes they had a few minutes left of fuel thats a lot because the vehicle is almost empty

    • @mareksarvas1102
      @mareksarvas1102 Місяць тому

      @@gamers-xh3uc bullshit

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      @@mareksarvas1102they didn’t want an uncontrolled starship going into orbit nobody wants such a massive object up there also there will be orbital refuelling so it seems fine

  • @LeMotorness
    @LeMotorness Місяць тому

    First B9 getting a bidet, and now S28 is getting... a rather.. firery one..

  • @joliteal1
    @joliteal1 Місяць тому

    Rest in piece(s)
    😄😄😄

  • @rockymorokolo194
    @rockymorokolo194 Місяць тому

    I wished to see how it would look from the surface of the earth

  • @yoshtg
    @yoshtg Місяць тому

    re-entry wont be a difficult problem to solve as there is not a lot of energy required to decelerate it because at this point it put the payload already into orbit and burned up most of its fuel so its not so heavy anymore and not much fuel is needed to slow it down to reduce the heat it will have to endure. fun fact: people sometimes falsely say that the heat is caused by "friction" which is actually not true, the main reason for the heat is the air compression
    EDIT - when i said "wont be difficult problem to solve" i am talking relative to the other problems in rocket science, of course pretty much everything within rocket science is a difficult problem for the human brains to solve

    • @gamers-xh3uc
      @gamers-xh3uc Місяць тому

      Not really, the problem here is that the ship wasnt stable thats why they couldn’t use the engines before

  • @eXtremeFX2010
    @eXtremeFX2010 Місяць тому

    They should have had Anakin Skywalker land it. I saw him do it in a Movie once... ended with Happy little landing 🤔

  • @samcerulean1412
    @samcerulean1412 Місяць тому +2

    I don't understand why they don't just use the engines to slow down the entry velocity then freefall.

    • @Proxicentia
      @Proxicentia  Місяць тому +7

      Ship was tumbling uncontrollably making an engine relight a dangerous operation. Plus trying to slow down at that velocity would take way too much fuel which could be saved by using the atmosphere as a break

    • @junkaccount8302
      @junkaccount8302 Місяць тому +3

      Because you don’t have unlimited delta-v (delta = change, v = velocity). Delta-v is essentially how much a rocket can change its velocity, and you only have so much fuel, and it would take just as much delta-v to slow down as it took to get into orbit, and that’s just not practical. The main problem on this flight is that there reaction control system clearly wasn’t working properly, so the ship didn’t enter in a stable orientation, and the flaps just don’t have enough atmosphere that high up to correct for that.

    • @PaulJR-hp2qm
      @PaulJR-hp2qm Місяць тому +2

      Atmospheric braking is required. Starship doesn’t have enough fuel or power to remove all that hard won orbital velocity.

    • @tomscott1159
      @tomscott1159 Місяць тому

      Yes. Consider how much fuel was consumed to gain the potential energy of orbital altitude and kinetic energy of 27,000 KPH. You would need a good portion of that fuel left over to return to a zero energy state by retrofire. And then you would have required far more fuel on takeoff to lift the retro-fuel into orbit. @@PaulJR-hp2qm

  • @user-hc6qq9rw4l
    @user-hc6qq9rw4l Місяць тому +2

    Молодцы, а про бустер 10 есть?)

    • @Proxicentia
      @Proxicentia  Місяць тому +1

      он упал в море и разбился

  • @peraltarockets
    @peraltarockets 6 днів тому

    Should have used Yakety Sax as the music, tho.

  • @olivierjuillet5746
    @olivierjuillet5746 Місяць тому +1

    and where is booster ?