7°C Cooler? This must be a scam - GoChiller Graphene Coolant Review
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 тра 2024
- New Customers Exclusive - Get a free 240GB SSD from Micro Center: micro.center/8806d3
Check out the Micro Center Custom Builds Showcase: micro.center/dc3e88
Check out the Volta GIGA today at geni.us/r91ag
GoChiller created graphene coolant they claim is 60% more thermally conductive than water... but in our experience these things rarely live up to the hype.
Check out GoChiller: gochiller.com/
Purchases made through some store links may provide some compensation to Linus Media Group.
Discuss on the forum: linustechtips.com/topic/13696...
►GET MERCH: www.LTTStore.com/
►SUPPORT US ON FLOATPLANE: www.floatplane.com/
►LTX EXPO: www.ltxexpo.com/
AFFILIATES & REFERRALS
---------------------------------------------------
►Affiliates, Sponsors & Referrals: lmg.gg/sponsors
►Check out our podcast gear: kit.co/linustechtips/lmg-podc...
►Private Internet Access VPN: lmg.gg/pialinus2
►Our Official Charging Partner Anker: lmg.gg/AnkerLTT
►Secretlabs Gaming Chairs: lmg.gg/SecretlabLTT
►MK Keyboards: lmg.gg/LyLtl
►Nerd or Die Stream Overlays: lmg.gg/avLlO
►Green Man Gaming lmg.gg/GMGLTT
►Amazon Prime: lmg.gg/8KV1v
►Audible Free Trial: lmg.gg/8242J
►Our Gear on Amazon: geni.us/OhmF
FOLLOW US ELSEWHERE
---------------------------------------------------
Twitter: / linustech
Facebook: / linustech
Instagram: / linustech
Twitch: / linustech
FOLLOW OUR OTHER CHANNELS
---------------------------------------------------
Mac Address: lmg.gg/macaddress
Techquickie: lmg.gg/techquickieyt
TechLinked: lmg.gg/techlinkedyt
ShortCircuit: lmg.gg/shortcircuityt
LMG Clips: lmg.gg/lmgclipsyt
Channel Super Fun: lmg.gg/channelsuperfunyt
Carpool Critics: lmg.gg/carpoolcriticsyt
MUSIC CREDIT
---------------------------------------------------
Title: Laszlo - Supernova
Video Link: • [Electro] - Laszlo - S...
iTunes Download Link: itunes.apple.com/us/album/sup...
Artist Link: / laszlomusic
Outro Screen Music Credit: Approaching Nirvana - Sugar High / approachingnirvana
Intro animation by MBarek Abdelwassaa / mbarek_abdel
Monitor And Keyboard by vadimmihalkevich / CC BY 4.0 geni.us/PgGWp
Mechanical RGB Keyboard by BigBrotherECE / CC BY 4.0 geni.us/mj6pHk4
Mouse Gamer free Model By Oscar Creativo / CC BY 4.0 geni.us/Ps3XfE
CHAPTERS
---------------------------------------------------
0:00 - Graphene Coolant?
0:45 - What is Graphene?
3:22 - Draining the system
5:20 - Electrical conductivity
6:45 - Foaming test
8:52 - Filling the system
10:19 - Thermal test #1
11:15 - Thermal test #2
12:45 - Test results
14:10 - Micro Center
14:41 - Outro - Наука та технологія
![[柴犬ASMR]曼玉Manyu&小白Bai 毛发护理Spa asmr](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0TsXQ7z2Dh4/mqdefault.jpg)
It feels like Alex is going to drink that black liquid every second he holds the cup.
Ikr? The thumbnail looked like he was reviewing cold brew or something 🤣🤣🤣
At least he'll be 7°C cooler lol
He was fighting the urge... you can just see the engineer in him wanting to do a taste test...
Fun fact, Alex is actually is a robot. He wants it, in his system.
I bet he drank a bit after the vid.
Really filled with an irrational fear that he's gonna drink the glass of coolant-cola
But what if it's really hot outside?
Dude same
yup yup yup yup yup
Coca coolant
Dude same
3:55 "Draining and filling the system should in theory be pretty.. Oh geeeez, that's not how that was supposed to go." That is the essence of LTT
Atleast he didn't drop anything lol
@@Citizen_of_the_Verse See security footage. RIP drinking glass.
imagine what the sex life be like. LMFAO
"Why did we not do this in the first place"
Roll back:
"It would be easier in the test bench but this is going to look so cool!"
Another pointless LTT Video because why not
@@Chris-hw4mq lol wasn't really pointless but ok
The anti foaming agent might not suck. You haven’t seen it without the agent, the liquid might just be SUPER prone to foam, and the agent knocks it down to just what you saw
Good point. Or maybe the anti-foaming agent works by preventing bubbles from sticking to metal and instead they collect in the reservoir?
Graphine bubble bath
@@marxmaiale9981 say it fast 5x
That's exactly what I was thinking
For a suspension, i think its antifoaming looks fantastic.
Open the fill port before you open the drain port. This way air can replace the water and the drain will flow better.
@UCkQdulQAsBQgduFDCJso84Q actually not a rick roll, slightly dissapointed
It's a bit disappointing that he missed this one
buncha dopes
For real. This is common knowledge too. Literally how shotgunning beer works.
I'm surprised he didn't know it out missed it, they should have been pretty good at that considering the number of times they have to do it.
3:55 Pro-Tip: When draining a closed liquid loop, open an air-intake near the top of the loop before opening the drain port. It'll drain faster, and flow more smoothly.
By "more smoothly", I mean you will avoid the -glug glug glug- type of flow that causes the stream to alternate between gushing and dribbling as it allows air to enter through the same hole the liquid is trying to exit from.
I was very surprised he didn't do that in the video.
Not just a PC tip, any closed liquid system that has more than one possible opening. Great tip when you're changing your car's oil for example, open up the fill cap up top, then the plug on bottom.
You would think this is common sense but 🤷🏻♂️
I literally can't believe I have to point this out. But YOU CAN SEE THE OPEN PORT AT THE TOP OF THE SYSTEM. He literally did this you guys
@@askmeaboutmyscrotum3527 That was only removed after the cut, and at that point the pc was almost dry. We never actually see it drain with that cap off and a sizeable amount of liquid in it. I cant believe I had to point that out.
Der8auer already did thermal testing, about 2K less temperature, so quite within the margin of error. I assume you would need much more graphene particles to get a decent effect, but then you would probably have to change the naming from water cooling to syrup cooling or something like that.
I wonder what the optimal ratio is.
"Physicist's McFlurry cooling"
@@boiledelephant Forbidden brownie batter
The only way to improve on water is with a fluid that has more thermal capacity not thermal conductivity. Thermal conductivity is how air coolers work.
@@Mrx1080 water already has an enormous heat capacity. But it's all meaningless if you don't get rid of it fast enough (unless you have a massive reservoir, then maybe)
I like how they can just yell, "BRING IN THE ENGINEERS," and two guys will come and explain exactly what's happening.
And I thought Alex was supposed to be an engineer
@@andrelascasas3156 Haha, classic Alex.
@@andrelascasas3156 There are many disciplines in engineering. Very much so like in medicine. You wouldn't expect a heart surgeon to have the same understanding of the brain compared to a neurosurgeon.
@@andrelascasas3156 alex is mechanical engineering, perhaps the other two are chemical engineer or majoring in material science.
@Swim Fan Yeah you are right in every sense. Sure they could have done more research and set up more appropriate tests.
But I guess they also have a valid point in representing the general consumer and pc enthusiasts who have no idea and would just use the product as marketed. Whether they intended it or not, this video shows that it would have little or no performance improvements to using the graphene fluid over standard coolants in generic use case scenarios.
The anxiety that I felt from him holding it, is astronomical. Every movement felt like he was going to chug it 😅
It honestly looked like he was about to drink it at any second by the way he was holding it and the fact it look's like cola had me thinking, I hope he doesn't forget it's coolant and not soda was freaking me out lol😅..
i was thinking he was going to drink, and then say "surprise! it's grape juice"
You need help bro if that was anxious for you. Did it look like he was going to drink it? Yup xD
If you had astronomical anxiety from that, get some help bro 💜
@@Maradnus it was a joke- lmao
@@wyattsawyer5063 actually not my stumache started feeling bad from watching it xD So not just a joke
Yeah it turns out that thermal conductivity doesn't matter for a transfer fluid that much. The thermal conductivity mainly comes from the metal waterblock, which can be enlarged or shrunk quite easily to have better heat exchange with water. What is needed is thermal capacity in the water to soak up more heat, or a bigger pump. If you'd want any reasonable increase in performance and have thesame tubing and waterblock setup, you'd need to swap the liquid out to ammonia.
And then your PC would smell GREAT
That's why I use my own piss as coolant
Why ammonia? I mean, yea, if you turn the whole thing into a refrigeration cycle that would do, but as a liquid ammonia has about half of water's heat capacity. Actually, water is just about the best medium for heat transfer between 280 and 400-ish K you can find. Nothing (I know) beats its heat capacity.
You're right in that a larger pump would likely help out more just because it helps with the temperature gradient in the block. However, I suspect the bottleneck in this particular system is the water/air transfer, mostly because it always is. In fact, the higher conductivity liquid would probably show the largest improvement in settings where the pump is severely undersized. Any flowing liquid will form what's referred to as a "boundary layer" on solid surfaces, which is essentially a stationary film that heat must pass through by conduction rather than convection. This boundary layer is thicker when the flow velocity is lower.
@@misterjonas6991 About the heat capcity of water being higher? Depending on the temperature, ammonia has a higher heat capacity per litre. It defenately has higher heat capacity, but it's less dense.
Point is, you don't really have to care about heat transfer that much if you're cooling to such extreme colds.
A 1% graphene addition to cooling fluid increases thermal conductivity by 61% and reduces viscosity by 31%. Note: is really only useful at high flow rates to give benefits over other coolants as it absorbs/dissipates heat quicker, but has identical heat capacity. What we would have needed to see in this test, is a high-flow pump setup, as you don't get the max benefits until you hit around 6L/m flowrate to take advantage of the increased thermal conductivity of the fluid. In addition, you could probably use a single pass high flow radiator for increased performance with this fluid with its higher heat transfer rate, instead of the 2 pass rad installed.
6:12 "bring in the engineers" That is exactly what I expected them to be like honestly, just sitting and observing quietly
What did they say about the resistance across a little distance of coolant ? I would have thought graphene would act as wires if it really changed the water? I think its such a tiny amount added to make it go black,that the electrical conducivy didn't change much. The fluid will just be glycerine or something, which will just boost specific heat a bit... Or its the antifoaming agent only making a change?
"I have my highly technical, little agitator here. Normally Linus is good but he's on vacation unfortunately." 😂 😂 Just want to let you know that that was gold Alex. I let out a hearty chuckle at that one.
Linus *drops liquid container*
It's also nice that he's able to take vacations. That's definitely a you've made it moment for any business owner.
@@arthurmoore9488 Shilling all tha overpriced junk they sell will get you there if people buy it.
That joke went over my head in the video, I just got it 😁
I'd like to see a long term test done with this solution, just to see if there is indeed any build-up over time in blocks.
This is definitely needed
where do i sign for beta testing?
The product has been in development for many years, and have done corrosion / sedimentation testing in a number of environments. We have ongoing testing in our lab (mining of course :-) ) and done / continue advanced development in the Automotive world..
@@michaelholland4317 Do you work for the company? Would love to see a video project that looks at potential buildup after for instance one year. I’d gladly volunteer for my YT channel, us VR guys always could use a degree or two cooler 😎
@@michaelholland4317 That's what everyone says about a year before everyone's loops start solidifying... I can't even count the number of coolants that were supposed to cause no buildup or degrade, and were later found to be horrible.
I regularly work with a variety of chemicals, including anti-foam. And the problem with anti-foam is it leaves behind a residue if you use too much of it, or when it dries, which would insulate the inner surface of your loop, preventing, or at least impeding thermal transfer. Your best bet is to simply design a loop that can be vented, and is properly configured to minimize foaming, which mainly just means there’s as little air as possible in the system.
I think you would find a larger temp change with short burst loads rather than sustained load. As with most water loops once the fluid has reached equilibrium you are limited by how much heat can be removed by the rad/fans.
I’m able to get mine to -40, I just leave it outside during a Canadian winter
Ah yes Let me say something else before this comment Gets so many likes
@@yuukina5357 wtf
😂😂😂
shitty canadian jokes, wow
Laughs in death valley.
"What's the theme for your new PC?"
"The empty void that is the meaning of our lives"
😐
It's how gaming makes us all feel.
taking into consideration for that buyer's remorse during the planning stage even before purchasing any parts
just ad some muso black...since it absorbs like 99%plus of light
Empty void that is the GPU slot for some poor folks.
Why not try this with today's PC build !! Would this be possible today ? ua-cam.com/video/Z_X_hgtlJpA/v-deo.html
That 011 dynamic filled with black fluid...im In love ❤
I love how everyone on this channel is supremely gifted in their knowledge of how computers work, but are some of the clumsiest human being on the planet.
Thats what you get for maxing out only one stat
@@LuxGamer16 are you accusing Linus of minmaxing lmao
Comes with the territory
My kind of people.
@Tyler Perhaps ‘gifted’ wasn’t the most correct term to use. I simply mean that they are very knowledgeable about computers and tech in general. Far beyond that of the average person, at least.
But that wasn’t even really the point of my post. I just find it amusing that people extremely skilled in one area can be lacking in another, seemingly simpler area. It does make for more entertaining videos though.
"Keep on holding it there, I'm gonna blow"
- Alex 2021
"is it working at all?"
Ohh you certainly know how to make a mess of things..
What are the chances I come out of this without stains on my clothes?
@@Liamfr34k "I think a little bit came out"
@@thegettokidZz that's what I tell my fiance when I'm finished
@@mr.e-machine9422 Finish Cooking, I Hope You're Just Saying About Finish Cooking With Your Fiance.
7:35 I love how he just stood there and probably thought „Well why didn’t I expect that?“
Guys next time when ever you try to fill up the coolant, open both ends, attach hose both the sides and hold them at equal vertical level above the system, this way you will never have to worry of air gap as filling up from above will simply push the air out from the lower side and holding them above will prevent your coolant from over flowing too. Good work on the video.
I love when Alex gets to run a video. He's got such a calmness to his delivery.
I was thinking the same thing. Not as intense as Linus.
Э He's got such a calmness to his delivery.Э Everyone who isn't Linus you mean.
Although there's utter chaos all around him.
I agree, I enjoy Linus and other staff too, but Alex has a calm light-hearted demeanor about him that makes his videos feel like a breath of fresh air!
I really like both of them Linus is intense and funny while Alex is so comfortable to listen to.
Energy drink vs coffee which cools better?? 😂 Totally expected you to drink it at any moment
plain water
gatorade
green tea
Still waiting someone use “liquid metal” mercury for cooler… and system strong from almagamated with mercury (copper system)
extra dark roast.
Would have been cool to see with a temperature probe in the loop to measure fluid temperature. My guess is the average fluid temperature in the loop is lower by about 3-4 degrees with the graphine solution for a given setup/loop and might give a better delta for comparison. Also be interesting to measure temp in and out of radiator to see how they compare across that
I wish they would've done a long term test with this, I looove how it looks
The anti-foamer may be doing something, we don't know what their solution did without it, could be much worse. Also, I'd be afraid of the graphine buildup in the block and radiator.
I mean, technically speaking as long as the graphene doesn't completely block the flow it is conductive, so its not like it'd be a problem even if it coated it up since it would still transmit heat through itself.
@@Adierit Im starting to think thats exactly what needs to happen in order for it to work even better. A graphene tunnel where the water pushes the thermal load
also suspended particles will stick to the boundaries between the liquid and gas phase and reinforce the bubble boundary so therefore ensure the bubbles stay around for much longer, but if you overdose the suspended particles it can have opposite effect and just shred bubble formation
@@Adierit Theoretically a very small amount of buildup along the radiators would probably increase performance. Better thermal transfer rate material touching a larger amount of liquid to dissipate heat.
@@ImOnyxRS I don't buy it. Normally your heat flow would go from copper cold plate to water directly. You're saying adding another (imperfect) thermal interface would improve it? So the heat would go from copper to coated graphene particles to water.
There's no way that's better, especially since the coating will be nonmetallic.
"Alex is opening the drain port. Wonder if he also opened the fill port so it doesn't just dribble and get every... nope"
This killed me!!! Even when he was blowing on it.
Tried this stuff in my water cooled laptop build because it looks SICK. Within a week my dry break quick disconnects started to become less and less dry break. They never leaked but they went from next to no fluid coming out to needing to keep a paper towel on hand when moving the laptop because about .5ml would be coming out. Looked great but with how quickly it was gunking up the connectors I flushed it.
Curious if the graphene in this liquid could also offer a potential lubricating effect on the pump or other parts of the system, judging from the lubricating properties of graphene and graphite.
Here's a tech tip for your foaming test:
1) put liquid in a bottle
2) close the lid of the bottle
3) shake the bottle
4) observe the foamage
He also used the same cloth thing for all liquids. So there’s some contamination.
@@salluna1957 not significant contamination, but yes
👏👏👏 you did it.
not really, this isnt the type of foaming they are meant to prevent, i made a post apart, the liquid is meant to prevent cavitation bubbles, these are bubbles that generate due to the drop in pressure in certain parts of the pump, they are an issue because when the pressure rises back up they will implode, and the incoming pressure of the liquid will be like the tiniest pistol shot ever, ohh so slightly eroding the surface in which the cavitation bubble had happened.
@@revdarian That's a good point, but i think those would form from shaking a bottle aswell. Though I'm not sure about that. Maybe for the cavitation bubbles to form you would have to hit the top of the bottle (lightly) with a hammer. Like when you hit a glass bottle on the top and the bottom pops off due to cavitation. Imho still slightly easier than Alex's drill method.
I'm super curius if the distilled water or the other coolant impacts the black liquid. It almost seems to be separating. A nice clean and dry to start with test bench would be cool. Also hope the liquid used in the machines isn't the same in both tests to prevent contamination. Nice video thanks for making it!
As usual great content👍 I think you would get another result if you try the foaming test in a closed system without air.. try to open the fill cap before draining.
Shouldn't graphene be abrasive enough to eat your cooling loop over time?
Graphite also makes a good lubricant so idk if it will be good or bad for your system long term. It's staying in that EK machine so we'll see how it holds up in a couple months. -Alex
@@LinusTechTips follow up vid or pinned comment?
Depends on the concentration of graphene in the solution
@@LinusTechTips Graphite or graphene?
people put it in engines, which have very tight clearances, id guess it has to be a fine enough powder to be a lubricant
"Bring in the engineers!" Two guys show up; one is exactly what you'd expect an engineer to look like, the other looks like he's there to take the first guy's lunch money, girlfriend, and job
I can assure you that at least 1 engineer I personally know looks like he probably only wash his hair once every 2 month. So the representation here isn't that far off.
@@gulengz5643 ugh. Now engineers are trying to take over the IT backroom admin guy look.
@@falxonPSN I can also assure you one IT support guy in the company I used to work in looks like Dennis but dress like Linus and always "patrol" around the female engineer's cubicles.
This made me laugh 😂 Thank you!
Dunno about you, but Tynan is a walking & talking cake.
"We recommend flushing the system of your previous coolant with de-ionised water before adding Go Chiller for maximum performance." Theirs a notice to flush the system, idk if that was done, or would alter the testing, Im bigggg interested in this coolant for 3 loops based off the color profile.
Yeah I saw that too.
It would make sense, if the liquid were ionized I suppose you would expect the nano particles to align in direction, and preventing an optimal randomized directionality in the particles.
You should do a long term (6months or so) of constant use with a heavy load put on for like 3-4 hours a day to see if the heat causes the graphine to solidify to cooling fins in a cpu/gpu water block and since its more viscous and heavier per millilitre than distilled water and see what wear/flow it does on the pump
This really feels like the most positive thing Alex has ever had to say about a vendor product.
Man this nsfw AI sucks lol. Spams messages on just one comment and it’s text generation is like one of those inspirational quotes AI
Alex: "Smells like liquor and permanent markers"
A reminder to never be the first person to pass out at a party.
No memes
Only when you have asshole "friends"
Oof thirsty bots in this thread
A reminder never to pass out in a place where you haven't got concealed security cameras.
@@mrn234 eh it’s just a simple joke I wouldn’t call them assholes if they do
Alex: "This is about as brutal as you can be, with a computer"
Me: *stands with blowtorch*
this one time i mixed two different mouth washes one was green one was purple. it made this very strange reaction where it was iridescent and constantly flowing all throughout it even days later. i've never replicated that but i'd love to see something like that in a coolant. seeing the turbulence in the water looks so sweet
that's the alcohol evaporating causing currents with bouyancy changes or something.
i think idk
It's easy to drain, when you remove the FILL PLUG FIRST to allow the air pressure to equalize.
This bothered me greatly.. like trying to drain the oil in a car without opening the fill cap and complaining that it splashes and gulps air as it comes out
@@MotoCat91 I thought he was an engineer? Did the Canadian engineering degree plan not cover fluid dynamics?
Can't be any worse than draining/filling my itx nightmare
@@KrKrypton THIS... he does a lot of clumsy / noobish stuff in a ton of vids.
@@KrKrypton In cases like this I don't actually think it's a lack of education but just a symptom of doing varied projects without much consistency.
Like, I've been through several years of university learning advanced math and engineering concepts but will still occasionally mess up a simple equation or programming syntax that I haven't used in a while.
I also build custom PCs as a local business here in Aus and still sometimes forget to turn on a PSU when I start testing a finished build.
So the fact he makes silly mistakes imo is fine, but he should have the hindsight to recognise them and explain to the audience what should have been done instead.
The question is, how well does it stay in solution over time. Is it going to be like most other liquids with particles suspended in it that drop out of solution after a while? You guys at LTT should setup a test system that you can run over a long period of time to test out it's long term stability.
Also fill up a few test tubes. Leave one at room temperature, one in the fridge and one in a hotbox or somewhere that's continuously warm and leave them there untouched for a month or twelve. That would show if the graphene stays in suspension or separates from the liquids. Also what about the liquid? How stable is it? What's the evaporation rate and so on.
@@blahorgaslisk7763 Evaporation rate shouldn't be an issue since it's inside a closed fluid system.
Actually, even the suspension questions end up being not an issue since the fluid is constantly flowing and mixing around. Even if any settles, it would likely get resuspended as the fluid washes over the deposits.
Though I suppose you could have a problem with micro deposits getting stuck in the tiny radiator fins. I would like to see them pour that fluid through some cloth filters and see how likely it is to get deposits getting caught in the tiny channels.
Didn't he fill that PC up with just straight premix though? Pretty sure he was supposed to add like distilled water to that no?
@@trapical I'm mostly interested in the evaporation rate because it's a new kind of cooling fluid and we don't really know much about how it reacts or what's in it at the moment. Besides even AIO's have a problem with evaporation, so I wouldn't say it's a none issue even though the reservoir should mean it would take a long time for it to become an issue in an open loop.
As for suspension I don't think just having the fluid circulating is any guarantee that there wont be deposits. Just look at all the opaque liquids available. It seems most of these has a problem with deposits building up over time. Now this is one thing that might be less of a problem with this new fluid as the graphene should be extremely light and the particles very small. That should mean thy will stay suspended for longer, but until it's tested we really don't know for sure.
@@sassiest2053 I think so too
6:57; I had a AiO that built up so much bubbles that it dried itself out; I went from temperatures of 36*c to overheating warnings, screen freezes, and 100+*c. I replaced it a couple weeks ago. Also the Reservoir of that pc is SICK.
Okay, so I've worked with graphene liquids before and the reason why it foams is due to the dispersant and the stuff that keeps it in suspension. I doubt they have an anti foam agent in there as it would probably cause clumping and it to fall out of suspension. When we used it it would foam at even the slightest movement. Also you REALLY don't want this stuff on your skin, it's known to accumulate in the mitochondria of your cells, they don't currently know if that's bad, but everyone who takes an educated guess says it's bad.
I don't know, that sounds like an origin story to me...
Did my master thesis on this and yes depending on the ratio and the material suspend in the nanofluid this is entirely plausible.
How do you think one might get close to 7 degrees with this fluid? (or does the fluid need to be re-engineered for that kind of a result?)
@@christopherjc54 As a Chemist, I'd say you'd have to re-engineer not only the fluid, but also the cooling setup. A more volatile fluid is better at taking heat away, but it comes with a whole lot of problems itself. A denser fluid can also improve thermal conductivity with the same nanoparticles, but I wouldn't be sure if that could make the trick.
As an automotive engineer; I'd say if you re-engineer the cooling system you can get pretty much any cooling power you'd want with regular old tap water. No need for any carbon dirt.
I would think though, that the compounds used to maintain suspension of the particles would be a bigger factor than the particles themselves, eh?
@@Nevir202 And you would be absolutely right about that my good sir. There are several other properties that will impact the overall heat transfer, but the material properties of the particles and fluid impact it the most.
"We have controll of the HVAC"
"But the room is 1° cooler"
Me *WTF*
That was not a good idea imo
this video is actually a bit of a joke
i don't even know what they have used to flush the system and how many times they've flushed it
Air conditioning doesn't run at a constant rate. It runs when the temperature is about 3-5 degrees warmer than the set temp then cools till it hits that temp again.
I think with water. It's the long longevity temp that counts. My watercooling pc always goes up 5-6c after 5-6months.
That is actually interesting, the water must somehow get less conductive (unless its just clogged but im ignoring that)
I cant remember off the top of my head what it could be, but it has to be something
@@defiantgg1831 I think it’s just impurities that it collects overtime. Or having it heat up & cool down over & over. Somehow changes the water, everything is clean. Fans & rad. No dust ect but my water always goes up 5-6c noticeably over time. I just put it down to impurities within the water that’s it’s gathered from the loop. Could just be micro impurities but enough to change the temps. Wouldn’t know without a microscope & comparing. The used water with new liquid.
@@Near2Future might be some of the particles of whatever is in the water, since there is still some even in distilled water that gathers, and blocks/slows down the flow or something
im not at all sure, but its possible
its probably your thermal paste drying up.
9:03 a truly man of culture 👏
Maybe 3 degrees cooler today, but when the particles start settling and jamming up microfins a month later you'll probably find that the performance tanks super hard.
Also that is graphene dust so in the long term gonna mechanically corrode you loop, the pump gonna die in one year if things goes good
The settling that happened in that cup just while they were filming didn't leave me with a lot of confidence.
graphite is technically a lubricant, so I would guess that there shouldn't be any issues with additional mechanical wear... settling is a legitimate concern, but graphite building up in the cooling fins could hypothetically improve thermal transmission, however depending on the size of the microfins blockages might be an issue over time... if instead of graphite, you had nanotubes and older generation fins in the loop, there could be a benefit to nanotubes getting caught in larger fins and increasing their surface area.
If they're feeling insane, a water loop filled with gallium would be a lot of fun to see. especially if some "accidentally" uses an aluminium part...
@@davidpretorius2984 No, obviously graphene settling in microfins wouldn't improve heat conductivity, because you're reducing surface area AND/OR increasing flow resistance, and you're also adding material between the copper and the water, and thus reducing overall conductivity even if the thermal conductivity of the material is pretty good.
Imagine for a moment coating the exterior surface of the fins on a standard air cooler in graphene. Even if that increased surface area, would that help heat conductivity? Obviously not. At the micro-level it's much worse, roughly analogous to filling most of the gaps between the air cooler fins with graphene and choking flow.
@@SovietGrazz the thickness is literally one molecule, however. And the thermal conductivity isn't "pretty good" it's off the charts and better than anything it's coating. IDK, it seems to me that if you look up graphene coolants for other applications (because they are out there) a coating of graphene on the interior surface is the point. In fact, several applications go so far to say that after being internally coated by graphene coolant the performance of the radiator increases and will eventually lead to much more efficient radiator technology in the future.
Getting *_Prometheus_* flashbacks every time he holds up that glass.
E
glad somebody said it
A bit older reference would be to the black oil virus from the X-Files days.
@@Yuna-iw4hn B O N K
I believe further testing is required, have you tried checking the exhaust heat from the radiator to check how much heat (air) has dissipated, compared to traditional coolant?
It would be great to see a test PC setup with this running in it long term then check the cooling fins on cpu and gpu thermal plates along with a radiator being cut in half long wise to see if there is any build up of solids and also if there was any reduction in performance. Thanks for the video.
Or erosion from the particles.
9:03 You can call this build, "The Dwarf in the computer, Homunculus"
FMA was a great manga.
You touched Linus' thermostat while he was on vacation?
Uh oh...
leave
@@MrCrabs101 nope
@@Verlisify leave
@@Verlisify leave
@@IvanTube0 Lot of worthless idiots online today it seems
For the next edition of Sketchy Heatsinks, they should try to make this with graphite powder and water, and see if it does anything. Or, make a heatsink out of graphene sheets
i work at a custom graphite milling shop, I'm so hyped to see graphite being used in new and cool ways lolz
“Graphene has been discovered in 2004 and been theorized to do… everything… well except leaving the lab”
That was gold
Edit: thanks for all of your likes
I didnt expect it🤣
E
actually gold was discovered long before 2004 :^)
@@kinomora-gaming i feel like this joke is going to go over a few peoples heads
No, that was graphene... please, pay attention. Ancient Egypt used gold.
@Prxtec Lettuce not
**Draining with fill port closed**
"This system is really not easy to drain guys"
...
Indeed, made that mistake myself too :D But seriously, i thought about draining and have a seperate drain pipeline in the system (on EK front panels 2nd lowest access point) with a close down ball valve+cap. I can drain everything other than the lower rad in 30 seconds, np. So like maintenance of CPU/GPU block is super easy.
You know when you open the drain before the fill port.
I wonder how it would compare to standard hotrod (power sports) solution like Red Line Water Wetter at $10 a bottle. Those work primarily by reducing the surface tension of the water. I've never seen anyone test stuff like that in a PC, but it definitely works on the race track.
I would love to see go chillier do more testing with this stuff n more improvements to make this stuff cool better. Maybe do a higher concentration of graphene which ofc would result in thicker liquid which I’d like to then see them do their own brand of pump specified for this and maybe even their own blocks specially designed for it. Cause I’d def invest in this stuff to even do a full blown build with specialized blocks n stuff if the liquid actually made a huge difference. Since it’s only a few degrees different I’d rather not gunk up my loop with it.
Alex "Hold it there I'm going to blow."
Alex "I think we just need several people to blow on it."
How's that OnlyFans working out for them?
@@Yuna-iw4hn bot
same tbh
69th 👍
I'd like to see long-term testing for this stuff. Does it build up in the system? Does it stain tubing or acrylic?
Im with this statement
My assumption is this will coagulate as it has particles suspended in the fluid. I expect it to build up on basically everything over time.
@@Skylancer727 I dont know.. i ran mayhams nano fluid for 2½ years and there was no build up in the blocks.. it had a little in the pump but not that bad.. if its anything like PRIMO CHILL VUE then its bad.. How ever Graphite is a lubricant. so it might work out OK
agreed. Would somebody need to build a system designed to keep the fluid agitated by keeping it moving quickly and not having many horizontal lengths of tubing? What happens if it does settle, can it be re emulsified?
@@grosen84thats Like saying: "mine worked so yours should too!" not a single part in this loop was designed with this stuff in mind
Place a small, spirally bent wire into the drain, facing downwards (with a parabolic curve if you have the pipe sideways) and it should do the trick, just make sure the wire is somewhat same size as the drainage pipe. The draining stream should follow it.
This video was amazing. Typical LTT shenanigans, making an absolute mess. Also really appreciate that you got the engineers in, and re-ran the test as you weren't happy. (Glad you did the complex system too though, as it looked sick!)
Also "I have my highly technical, little agitator here. Normally Linus is good but he's on vacation unfortunately." - May be the best LTT joke ever.
"This coolant right here can drop your cpu and gpu -" Well Linus can too. "By seven degrees Celsius." oh
@@yuna2912 maybe find some other bots to hang around with, unless you are real, are you?
Underrated
I love that joke
@@sushimshah2896 Dude, of course it's not a real person.
"Keep holding it there im gonna blow"
"I think a little bit came out, you sure know how to make a mess"
I have that drill. The agitator fell out of the chuck because the brake on the drill stops and the heavy chuck spins itself free after a few hard stops. A fix is don't let the drill come to an immediate stop, or tighten the chuck after every time you do let it hard stop
That foaming is from cavitation. Pumps are generally designed to have a certain amount of head pressure (which is so many inches or feet of column of water) on the inlet to avoid cavitation, thus the reason you want the pump to be on the bottom of your loop.
4:53, that's a nice blowing job Alex
WAIT A MINUTE.
If the previous coolants had that "layer developing" property, it's possible that the protective layers those formed were degrading the potential performance of the suspended graphene particles.
Just a thought.
That wouldnt be the case for the 2nd test, where there was just water in the loop beforehand.
@@joshuaford4460 The second test was the one that showed actual improvement. There might have been something in the first tests other coolant that interfered slightly.
“Layer developing” because a multimeter have voltage across the probes when measuring resistance, essentially electroplating the probes.
💌◦•●◉✿ *Content 18 Years and over* ✿◉●•◦💥
👉 45.32.115.72/278?Make-love💥
(◍•ᴗ•◍)✧*。
UA-cam: This is fine
Someone: Says "heck"
UA-cam: Be gone
#однако #я #люблю #таких #рыбаков #Интересно #забавно #девушка #смешная #垃圾
I would expect a greater effect if smaller radiators were used. The pump speed also plays a role, why didn't you try to test low, medium and high speeds?
the speed of the coolant negligibly effects heat transfer unless you slow it way, way down. you're the first person to make the correct assumption that a smaller radiator would have shown a greater effect though.
I'd be interested to see what that pump looks like after 30 days of continous running. I suspect the graphene, while lubricating, may also score the plastics and degrade the performance (and cause permanent damage).
Id like to see them try the automotive coolant additive called "water wetter", they claim up to 20°F cooler temps when used in a car.
the issue is the temperature delta. In a car the coolant is around 100c (212f), and ambient air is going to be, let's say 25c (or 77f). That's a 75c (165f) difference between the coolant and the air you are trying to dissipate heat into. In a watercooled rig what's the delta between coolant temp and ambient? 10, may 15c (50-59f)? There's just not all that much improvement to be had from the coolant itself. Even differences in the radiator itself are going to be minimal with those kinds of delta numbers.
I'm sure water wetter would help, but the difference it will make is going to be very minimal. If we want to see significantly lower core temps, we need to either improve the thermal conductance of the die itself, or go sub ambient.
Iirc, the water-wetter helps by preventing localized boiling at hot spots in the engine block. If your die never gets near the boiling point of the coolant that's probably not benefit to you.
As the other comments say, I don't it will really do anything or something significant, but, "this is LTT!" (Read as in "this is Sparta!") So yeah! They should do that video Ltt style.
Or Engine Ice
Water wetter will not make you engine run cooler, it raises the boiling point significantly so you can be safe at the high temps you see at the drag strip. IIRC it was meant to be added to engines running straight water. If you have antifreeze/coolant already it will do nothing they aren't already doing.
I'd love to see the long term results with using this for a few months and if any issues come up.
I can't shake the feeling that it'll gunk up components over extended periods of time.
Hopefully I'm wrong. Because it DOES look cool in a custom loop.
Yep will be pleasantly surprised if there isnt a major downside, from the universe's pain in the ass rules n laws.
It does look like the graphine comes out of the suspension pretty easily. Noticed it when he was pouring out of the glass into the fill port.
It may not sand down oxidized material the same way vue does. Depends on graphenes hardness I suppose.
of course!!!!!
Graphene's hardness is pretty low so optimistically it won't grind up components, while graphene is electrically conductive it seems the suspension limits that to something similar to salty water or comparable cooling solutions. My only worry is it clogging up the impeller in the pump or the micro-fins in the cooling element since it seems to only barely be in suspension. A longer-term test would be great to see because it does look amazing even if you ignore the marginal cooling efficiency improvements.
The flow from around @9:58 is amazing...
I absolutely love how they just take over Linus' office while he's on leave. Can't imagine my boss would be happy about that AT ALL. lmao
“Cuts through the ice like butter” *cuts to the sheet folding over ice and not cutting it*
It's only 10 microns thick so it's really hard to control where it goes haha -Alex
Linus Tech Tips
yo
I wonder how the graphene particles affect the inside of the tubes and pump over time... Like does it scratch up/cut the inside of soft, hard plastic or rubber tubing?
Was wondering the same thing.
I imagine it doesn't. Graphite is used as a lubricant and graphene coatings are used for abrasion resistance.
I'd be more interested to see if it gunks up the microfins over time or if it foams up in the pump and kills that prematurely.
@@honeybadger6275 Exactly, 30 minute tests for a new type of liquid are almost useless.
@@honeybadger6275 yeah i don’t even give a damn about its „superior performance“ either. Just call it fancy coolant and people would still buy it all I’m concerned about is that stuff coming out of suspension literally everywhere constantly and forcing me to clean out every single component of my loop regularly cause that’d just be much more of a pain than fancy looking coolant is really worth to me
12:31 Maybe the "anti-foaming agent" is more of a film that traps bubbles on the surface and prevents more air from getting in?
When he said "you don't want bubbles forming on the microfins", well for that, where would the air come from? On the contrary you actually want surfactants (tensides) in your liquid that would break the surface tension and allow it to flow around the microfins better; but tensides are literally dish soap, so at the surface, they can tend to form air bubbles. I also think a small amount of surfactant can help remove the air better wherever it can be in the loop.
Maybe the resulting foaming can be disconcerting, so maybe they added tensides to improve performance, and added anti foaming agents to then make it... not foam over in the reservoir and not look so scary.
I wonder what happens to the fins on the pump after a few years of running what's effectively nano-scale blades of carbon?
Also I would highly recommend against touching this stuff, being 1 atom thick, it could slice through anything from cell walls to DNA.
it isn't really just 1 atom think, it's multiple layers of 1 atom thickness. do you believe you'd be able to hold any sheet of 1 atom thick material in your hand like that without tearing it apart?
@@moos5221 It's a liquid. You can't hold it in your hand at all. Stop pretending the sheet he used for demonstration purposes is the fluid going through the pump.
Electrically conductive doesn't sound optimal for PC cooling. Even if you clean a spill/leak you may leave some electrically conductive residue.
A non conductive fluid will pick up contaminants from the loop and become conductive fairly quickly anyway.
Even without leaks, imagine leaving this liquid in there for couple of months, the cleanup afterward would be a nightmare i imagine.
yeah that and the eventual clogging and gunk that will for sure accumulate no thanks staying with clear liquids
@@rb30e perhaps, but can't be as conductive as the most conductive material discovered so far (graphene) according to the video.
try watching the video
The bigger your radiators are, the less temp-difference you'll see... It is better to invest in a bigger radiator.
This kind of fluid is only useful if you have small radiators en high temps!
I thought it's added some surfactant for wetting the flake graphite, and it will lead foaming which defoamer could not erase. but i am curious that if the graphite settling down fast or not?
I really love the Alex content, he really gives off Anthony tech nerd vibes and is as energetic as Linus
When comparing keep in mind your cryofuel was used. It would have picked up ions over it's life in the loop. Fresh fluid might be less conductive. Same goes with water, after a while of running in a loop it will pick up ions from the loop components.
Holy shit you joined 14 years ago?!
you joined in 2007??????????? dayum
@@treatoplease3479 I know it's shocking but youtubes been around for a couple years
@@treatoplease3479 Not that uncommon. I also joined 14 years ago. I actually created this account a month before Saulverde.
@@treatoplease3479
Not everyone on youtube is 14 years old.
Seems like a very cool fluid!
But im also very interested in a long term test vs. a „normal“ coolant to see if there is more or less abrasion on the coolers and if there is more or less residue from the particles falling out of solution.
Evaporation-rate shouldn’t be significantly changed vs. normal coolant or distilled water
and Evaporation-rate is also dependent on how airtight your loop is.
I would love to know if the graphene effected the pressures in the pump. That would indicate that there was increased, or decreased flow through the micro-fins.
Wouldn't you need a graphene sheet based heat exchanger to properly and efficiently disperse the heat absorbed by the graphene suspension for it to work at highest efficiency?
"slice into it like butter"
>literally folds on itself
._ . yes anyway here's a segue
it wasn't, that is just an optical illusion
To be fair butter doesn’t cut very well. It’s just not sharp enough.
linus wtf does that monitor say at 11:43 please respond quickly
Yoooo
i forgor 💀
i think is says "pulse fire 200kph ground pinch" you're welcome
car
Alex said that Linus is on vacation
I'd combine this with the new Thermal Grizzly Kryosheet Graphene for the CPU block... that looked amazing and I bet would work hand in hand with this liquid.
I didn't watch the vid, but there is a product called Water Wetter, for automobile cooling systems that actually does enhance cooling. A magazine test said 2 bottles, instead of the 1 recommend on the label, actually increased cooling.
So, I bought a couple bottles and tried it. Sure enough my coolant temp dropped about 5C. During the summer, I ran mostly purified water with a couple bottles and it worked with typical coolant or plain water. I'm not sure how compatible it would be with pc liquid cooling parts and you'd have to refigure the rate of 2 bottles to 1 gallon of water for your reservoir, but the product did actually work.
"My little agitator here, since unfortunately Linus is on vacation." 💀
so she was always😐😚😊😂
will get nothing; and when you👧👦🧒👶🙊🙉🙈
a dear little girl who was 😘😍😎😋😊😉😆
It’s like the bots are having arguments with each other
@@theeoddments960 LMAO
i love the channel now being variety in hosts nowadays, ik the boss is on a vacation but seeing this kind of direction of the channel is going is wholesome, being more like a team.
I have a question about longevity. As it ages wouldn't it eventually corrode the pump? The particles will eat away like sandpaper against the plastic pump parts id imagine. Still though looks cool enough that I'm gonna try it.
What did they expect, when in a liquid cooling system you'd care for the coolant specific heat capacity quite more than for the coolant thermal conductivity?
The graphene would have to come in contact with the walls for this to work effectively, the boundary layer of a flowing liquid should prevent most of that from happening.
So in other words the graphene does not do much except add a sort of liquid charcoal look. It IS is amazing looking though, very different from just a black fluid. If I has a water cooled PC I might even buy some, provided it does not clog the system up.
I guess the other stuff creating a coating around the graphene particles (as they guess in the conductivity part) doesn't help either. i guess all it really does is making the liquid look fancy and be wayyy more abrasive at the same time...
Yeah. Hearing how graphene conducts heat, it seems like it would be more useful as a heat pipe than something mixed in with the coolant.
@@bilateralrope8643 I thought so too, like integrate it into a new "heatsink" design
this is not correct at all, please do some research on nanofluids. the heat transfer mechanism is still up for debate but there are very concrete gains in conductivity with nanoparticle suspensions. that being said i would never put them in a pc cooler as suspension stability is the hardest part of the equation - an engineer with research experience in nanofluids.