When it takes 15 minutes to decide on taking Scotland’s powers; and the speaker contradicts himself by allowing the division now and changing his mind which goes against Parliamentary Notions; then yes, the SNP did the right thing by walking out. This government is a disgrace and a shambles.
Everything Cool You don’t. If you’re going to be ignored regardless and can therefore not do your representative duties, then yes, leaving the hall would make no difference except actively show your discontent with what’s happened. It was the right thing to do
Kennith Cox You're*. You couldn't even use the right word when insulting us. You're another pure example of why Scottish people are pissed off all the time. Man, I give most of my wage to increase the luxury of life for simpletons like you and so do most of the Scottish population; SNP and Scotland in general expect to at least be listened to in Westminster, considering we do pretty much everything else for you.
The SNP are as always predictable in their behaviour, Scotland is slowly coming round and realising how poor SNP government is. You will get the NATS on here defending this rabble, but as always they are clueless, thank god for the tories
The way some of mps acted was disgraceful seen kids in playground act better at least snp members are standing up for what they believe in unlike other party's which can't agree on anything. Might not have been best idea but at least point was made.
kymerah I guess it depends really, walking out the chamber vetoes your ability to debate and discuss issues, you may argue that the government doesn’t listen but that isn’t fault of the House itself. It’s like saying by not voting your standing up for what you believe in but surely it’s more effective to be heard and deliberate and discuss issues rather than just walk out and sacrifice your ability to communicate.
They are an embarrassment to the Scottish people and have not shown any respect to the parliament in which they are members! The session was for PMQs and he should have moved his motion afterwards?
They were just about to be granted a debate on the devolution aspects of the EU Withdrawal Bill. Instead they chose a stunt over holding the Government to account.
This whole incident was caused by John Bercow! He's quick to tell everyone else about process and procedures - yet he BROKE procedure. Standing Order 163 clearly states that during ANY sitting of the Chamber or Committee, if a member calls for the House to sit in private - then the question must be asked 'forthwith'. - Any sitting....so that includes PMQs. - FORTHWITH....not at the end of the session, or after lunch - 'FORTHWITH' - And it is clearly a legitimate Parliamentary process, because there is a Standing Order to respond to it. Bercow screwed it up....he says he's not hearing it and isn't obliged to.....then he is (obviously told he did have to)...but later. He then OFFERS Blackford the choice for the time of the vote, and Blackford insists (rightly) on having the vote forthwith....only for Bercow to ignore him and say 'later' So he doubled down by ejecting Blackford - who was in the right to demand SO 163 be upheld as written.... Bercow even said to David Linden MP - "You don't tell me procedure, I tell you." In spite of being in breach of those same procedures! This was all caused by Bercow not doing his job in the first place.... then becoming a jobsworth to follow-up
Twowheelsplusengine clearly you only watched the edited video, he was going to agree to it forthwith but was advised by the people in front that he shouldn’t and so didn’t. He has to go off what they say, if they were biased Then there is a discussion, but he just did as he was told, also even a debate at the end is better than no debate
@@kerkhamo So you would rather labour or tories leading the show for us? The only reason Scotland is even relevant in paliament is because of the SNP. Are you not happy that they are sticking up for the country? I dont want some tory or labour mp droning on about UK wide problems. I want some Scottish legend in there droning on about Scotland.
@@hiddenknowledge2012 Scottish legend?? Hahaha you want the loch ness monster in the commons next?? Oh and btw im Scottish the snp are a bunch of fuckwits, no indyref2, next no snp.
OMG! Scotland the brave. I admire the fight from the SNP but show more balls. As I am of Scottish heritage (proud to be), it's a bloody embarrassment. Man up!
This shower need to grow up. When did walking out of a debate ever achieve anything? If the SNP EVER want to be taken seriously they'll have to grow out of this childish behaviour. With tabled questions on the Speaker's list, they chose to ignore their taxpayers concerns and leave......says it all really.
They need to update the Parliamentary cameras and kit, that's true. They voted in January to spend £5800 Million on the Palace of Westminster renewal and upgrade, so hopefully that will include a few cameras !!
Yet SNP don't want to be part of great Britain. Yet you are quick enough to take the tax money of Britain. I speak to Scottish people every day and none of them want to break away and hate Nicolas Sturgeon.
The ones you speak to are known as House Jocks who believe they are welcome in England , yeah as welcome as the Irish-the blacks and the immigrants , your empire is long gone and the union is well and truly f/kd
Stupid stunt! Thick jock should follow the rules of the House . Let children in to play grown-up games and this is what happens. The poison dwarf Sturgeon only speaks for herself and NOT the whole of Scotland!! This idiot should be reprimanded not praised!!
More than a year has passed since this day in Westminster. There were forecasts made saying that the S.N.P. will be finished , they were criticised for what they did some even said they were an embarrassment to the people of Scotland. However there was a recent poll carried out by Lord Ashcroft on the Conservative's home website and it was revealed that there was a 52% in favour for Scotland's independence. Looks like Ian Blackford was not wrong after all.
Ian Blackford is no Glenda Jackson but he's certainly a right drama queen when it comes to total incompetence and disarray! Furthermore the SNP are an embarrassment and rightly mocked by most for there childish hilarious antics laid out for all to see!🤣
absolutely perfectly done if Westminster wants to play games scotland can play also and we will win this action added 10000 plus new members to the snp roll and people are saying it was excellent even no voters and leave voters agree
TOTAL OPPOSITE - They did EXACTLY what they needed to do to get attention, and it worked! Its the Conservatives that are behaving undemocratically, not allowing a proper debate, and forcing the SNP to employ such tactics.
John Sanders No, the Speaker offered a chance to vote now, then changed his position to after PMQs. The SNP acted as a unit, garnering publicity and support for their cause.
Lots of cybernats in this comment section, proving just how stupid you have to be to support the SNP. Thank God their support is waning. They wouldn't need to pull childish stunts like this if they had a real policy platform.
Oh how original "cybernat" now where did you uncover that little Gem ,Daily Mail maybe ,I didn't know this place was reserved for raving unionists must have missed the sign , Your worst nightmare is about to hit you right in the face SNP membership in the last 24 hours has increased by 5000 , read it and weep sucker .
Independence is further away than ever, thank Christ. The majority of the Scottish people will see through this stunt, it's just a ploy to try to turn Scotlands people against the English, to further their case for independence. I pissed myself laughing when I saw them throwing their toys out the pram! If Scotland ever did get independence, we would be bankrupt within a few years, but what about Queen Nicola, oh don't worry about her, she'd travel the world signing books and giving speeches like all other failed politicians, and we'd have to pick up the pieces.
Toon Holman yeah .. let’s just have a bunch of ordo liberal rational technocrats making the decisions for us. That way we can get rid of these pesky democratic votes altogether.
TEASERS ! Your thumbnail : had woman of - iron & STEEL : *Mhairi Black* - givin' : _Conservative_ *(minority)* : a good old - what *FOUR !* - I mean : FOR ! _North of England_ - *SECEDE* 2 Scotland !!! *_R > G_*
The whole parliament acts without any dignity and disgusts me we need new government without royals, without Lords and a new generation of mps, not stuck in tradition and pomp. The sneering, in the pocket of the rich, scum of our Parliament have and always will look out for themselves.
ha ha you do have a sense of humour , didn't you notice it was about NOT being allowed a voice , are you not following whats going on or just presenting the Daily Mails version of events .
PONM123 in no farage fan I want peace SNP n ukip don't provide that corbyn and Mrs may do. they must not get involved in brexit its not there remit anymore they've shown no capability of resolution whatsoever they want to break the UK up and Westminster then put Scotland to the euro what rot. all for there off shore accounts nahhh sum folk have had enough heard enough n seen enough they can move abroad n spend there money they've stole off Westminster supposably for Scotland for there greedy pockets name ten things the SNP have done for u ... ? 😏 Willi Wallace was no lier or schemer he would be utterly ashamed
Respect is earned. Not just given.
I now love a whole new of genre of politics. This parliament is cool.
When it takes 15 minutes to decide on taking Scotland’s powers; and the speaker contradicts himself by allowing the division now and changing his mind which goes against Parliamentary Notions; then yes, the SNP did the right thing by walking out. This government is a disgrace and a shambles.
Everything Cool You don’t. If you’re going to be ignored regardless and can therefore not do your representative duties, then yes, leaving the hall would make no difference except actively show your discontent with what’s happened. It was the right thing to do
Kenneth Cox “Your” stupidity is hilarious
Kennith Cox You're*. You couldn't even use the right word when insulting us. You're another pure example of why Scottish people are pissed off all the time. Man, I give most of my wage to increase the luxury of life for simpletons like you and so do most of the Scottish population; SNP and Scotland in general expect to at least be listened to in Westminster, considering we do pretty much everything else for you.
The SNP are as always predictable in their behaviour, Scotland is slowly coming round and realising how poor SNP government is.
You will get the NATS on here defending this rabble, but as always they are clueless, thank god for the tories
Scottish Independence; A Politician out of Parliament is like a Fish out of Water.
The 'after-dinner speech' joke wasn't even that funny.
Of course it wasn't. The Tories cackled like demons simply because their cabal demands it.
The way some of mps acted was disgraceful seen kids in playground act better at least snp members are standing up for what they believe in unlike other party's which can't agree on anything. Might not have been best idea but at least point was made.
kymerah I guess it depends really, walking out the chamber vetoes your ability to debate and discuss issues, you may argue that the government doesn’t listen but that isn’t fault of the House itself. It’s like saying by not voting your standing up for what you believe in but surely it’s more effective to be heard and deliberate and discuss issues rather than just walk out and sacrifice your ability to communicate.
rebuild the wall
Ke St higher than ever
it's already started lets hope its big enough to keep the Xenophobic nut jobs in the south out .
Small minded. WE DONT ALL LOVE THEM UP HERE YOU KNOW!!!
Ke St exactly
Poor Dear Parliament. Poor Dear Dear.
The guy at the end saying about people leaving after his end of dinner speeches was so funny! Absolutely brilliant. Cheers
They are an embarrassment to the Scottish people and have not shown any respect to the parliament in which they are members! The session was for PMQs and he should have moved his motion afterwards?
They were just about to be granted a debate on the devolution aspects of the EU Withdrawal Bill. Instead they chose a stunt over holding the Government to account.
What a mess although oddly entertaining.
show the full clip all 7.5 min .
UK politics is such a muppet show. Who can take this seriously?
If I didn’t know any better, I’d be easily convinced that it’s a Monty Python sketch.
Respect your queen and parliament
MP's are just football fans in suits. shouting "BYE, BYE, BYE!" as they are leaving. Pathetic.
It's a traditional thing, they nearly always say it when an MP is 'named'. Checkout Denis Skinner
ha ha got right up yer nose eh byeee
😂😂 about as pathetic as the SNP themselves
Love how juvenile some of these MPs are shouting “bye!” from a sedentary position 😂
A bunch of Neros fiddling away.
This whole incident was caused by John Bercow!
He's quick to tell everyone else about process and procedures - yet he BROKE procedure.
Standing Order 163 clearly states that during ANY sitting of the Chamber or Committee, if a member calls for the House to sit in private - then the question must be asked 'forthwith'.
- Any sitting....so that includes PMQs.
- FORTHWITH....not at the end of the session, or after lunch - 'FORTHWITH'
- And it is clearly a legitimate Parliamentary process, because there is a Standing Order to respond to it.
Bercow screwed it up....he says he's not hearing it and isn't obliged to.....then he is (obviously told he did have to)...but later.
He then OFFERS Blackford the choice for the time of the vote, and Blackford insists (rightly) on having the vote forthwith....only for Bercow to ignore him and say 'later'
So he doubled down by ejecting Blackford - who was in the right to demand SO 163 be upheld as written....
Bercow even said to David Linden MP - "You don't tell me procedure, I tell you." In spite of being in breach of those same procedures!
This was all caused by Bercow not doing his job in the first place.... then becoming a jobsworth to follow-up
Twowheelsplusengine clearly you only watched the edited video, he was going to agree to it forthwith but was advised by the people in front that he shouldn’t and so didn’t. He has to go off what they say, if they were biased Then there is a discussion, but he just did as he was told, also even a debate at the end is better than no debate
When will they get rid of berfow the little dwarf snide
When will the SNP realise they are a minority in the UK!
I,m Scottish and I wish the SNP would do one and get lost
@@kerkhamo So you would rather labour or tories leading the show for us? The only reason Scotland is even relevant in paliament is because of the SNP. Are you not happy that they are sticking up for the country? I dont want some tory or labour mp droning on about UK wide problems. I want some Scottish legend in there droning on about Scotland.
@@hiddenknowledge2012 Scottish legend?? Hahaha you want the loch ness monster in the commons next?? Oh and btw im Scottish the snp are a bunch of fuckwits, no indyref2, next no snp.
Bercow to Blackford : "Resume your seat young man" 😂😂😂
@@hiddenknowledge2012 so whats your oppinion now then? XD
OMG! Scotland the brave. I admire the fight from the SNP but show more balls. As I am of Scottish heritage (proud to be), it's a bloody embarrassment. Man up!
This shower need to grow up. When did walking out of a debate ever achieve anything? If the SNP EVER want to be taken seriously they'll have to grow out of this childish behaviour. With tabled questions on the Speaker's list, they chose to ignore their taxpayers concerns and leave......says it all really.
There needs to be a vote of no confidence
Quite agree vote of no confidence in this government now.
Yes a vote of no confidence in John bercow
Looks like a meeting of my condo board!
That is not HD quality! C'mon professional?
They need to update the Parliamentary cameras and kit, that's true. They voted in January to spend £5800 Million on the Palace of Westminster renewal and upgrade, so hopefully that will include a few cameras !!
Yet SNP don't want to be part of great Britain. Yet you are quick enough to take the tax money of Britain. I speak to Scottish people every day and none of them want to break away and hate Nicolas Sturgeon.
The ones you speak to are known as House Jocks who believe they are welcome in England , yeah as welcome as the Irish-the blacks and the immigrants , your empire is long gone and the union is well and truly f/kd
Does the booster protect you from Russian missiles thats what I want to know and wheres our great leader Boris hiding.
If I was Ian Blackford, I would be so embarrassed frankly, to merely exist. I get contact embarrassment every time he opens his mouth.
A Scottish MP walks out of a European debate on English soil but there's still time to blame Israel (see D below). Genius !
I know it's been 2 years, but what were you on about?
Israel?!
He didnt walk out he was made to leave the others walked out in protest !!
How do Scotts expect to be get anything done when they just walk out in a hissy fit like this
Note to the rest of Britain:
The SNP don’t speak for all Scotland
...Thankfully.
neither do you ya thick inbred hun .... won't be long when the killie boys will be singing to you "the union is over why don't you go home" ftq:)
Are you well? Relax bud. 🏴🇬🇧
Floyd1504 Nationality? I'll say mine, Scottish.
KGB Agent you have our sympathy
Stupid stunt! Thick jock should follow the rules of the House . Let children in to play grown-up games and this is what happens. The poison dwarf Sturgeon only speaks for herself and NOT the whole of Scotland!! This idiot should be reprimanded not praised!!
More than a year has passed since this day in Westminster. There were forecasts made saying that the S.N.P. will be finished , they were criticised for what they did some even said they were an embarrassment to the people of Scotland. However there was a recent poll carried out by Lord Ashcroft on the Conservative's home website and it was revealed that there was a 52% in favour for Scotland's independence. Looks like Ian Blackford was not wrong after all.
Let's hope it happens. The sooner the better.
Fantastic just to see the foaming at the mouth down south.
ian blacksheep mp
Dave Freeman the simple crofter eh
That bunter Blackford would give you the boke
Angus MacNeil walked out because he had a prior engagement in a seedy hotel room with some hotties.
Ian Blackford is no Glenda Jackson but he's certainly a right drama queen when it comes to total incompetence and disarray! Furthermore the SNP are an embarrassment and rightly mocked by most for there childish hilarious antics laid out for all to see!🤣
Graham Shoebridge more like Cromwell off Blackadder.
Lets hope these quislings ( snp) walk out and don't come back...
Don't even laugh at Scotland and if you do once more we'll leave the UK!!!
End London Rule! 🏴
absolutely perfectly done if Westminster wants to play games scotland can play also and we will win this action added 10000 plus new members to the snp roll and people are saying it was excellent even no voters and leave voters agree
Sad thing is, people elected those MP's to represent them in that room... and they walk out, disregarding their duty.
TOTAL OPPOSITE - They did EXACTLY what they needed to do to get attention, and it worked! Its the Conservatives that are behaving undemocratically, not allowing a proper debate, and forcing the SNP to employ such tactics.
John Sanders No, the Speaker offered a chance to vote now, then changed his position to after PMQs. The SNP acted as a unit, garnering publicity and support for their cause.
John Sanders as for democracy, the Tory's are blocking a debate, hence the protest.
Well sitting watching that circus called parliament you would want out as well .
Lots of cybernats in this comment section, proving just how stupid you have to be to support the SNP.
Thank God their support is waning. They wouldn't need to pull childish stunts like this if they had a real policy platform.
Oh how original "cybernat" now where did you uncover that little Gem ,Daily Mail maybe ,I didn't know this place was reserved for raving unionists must have missed the sign , Your worst nightmare is about to hit you right in the face SNP membership in the last 24 hours has increased by 5000 , read it and weep sucker .
bneon calm down and have some haggis.
Thank goodness independence is looming
Independence is further away than ever, thank Christ.
The majority of the Scottish people will see through this stunt,
it's just a ploy to try to turn Scotlands people against the English,
to further their case for independence.
I pissed myself laughing when I saw them throwing their toys out the pram!
If Scotland ever did get independence, we would be bankrupt within a few years,
but what about Queen Nicola, oh don't worry about her, she'd travel the world
signing books and giving speeches like all other failed politicians, and we'd have to pick up the pieces.
Only can wait and c?
Peter Gordon put the craq pipe doon hen!
Edward Gunn ull wait till doomsday
Y'all should see the Dutch parliament. We keep to rules, no shouting. The British parliament is ridiculous.
Toon Holman yeah .. let’s just have a bunch of ordo liberal rational technocrats making the decisions for us. That way we can get rid of these pesky democratic votes altogether.
bercow out
Ian Blackford just smirks to much, I do not trust people who smirk this amount it tells of the underlying character
TEASERS ! Your thumbnail : had woman of - iron & STEEL : *Mhairi Black* - givin' : _Conservative_ *(minority)* : a good old - what *FOUR !* - I mean : FOR ! _North of England_ - *SECEDE* 2 Scotland !!! *_R > G_*
Wow tory trolls at it again
who is the woman in the blue dress @ 0:35 🤤
She could be Sarah Jones a Labour MP for Croydon in South London. Can't be 100% sure though.
Typical of the one-eyed and blinkered SNP
The whole parliament acts without any dignity and disgusts me we need new government without royals, without Lords and a new generation of mps, not stuck in tradition and pomp. The sneering, in the pocket of the rich, scum of our Parliament have and always will look out for themselves.
Bit childish... It seems the SNP want a voice in parliament, when they get the voice they throw their toy out.
ha ha you do have a sense of humour , didn't you notice it was about NOT being allowed a voice , are you not following whats going on or just presenting the Daily Mails version of events .
The Daily Mail's presentation of events just might be a bit more measured than The Recod or The Mirror.
Ian Blackford the GREATEST
PONM123 what a joke.
PONM123 in no farage fan I want peace SNP n ukip don't provide that corbyn and Mrs may do. they must not get involved in brexit its not there remit anymore they've shown no capability of resolution whatsoever they want to break the UK up and Westminster then put Scotland to the euro what rot. all for there off shore accounts nahhh sum folk have had enough heard enough n seen enough they can move abroad n spend there money they've stole off Westminster supposably for Scotland for there greedy pockets name ten things the SNP have done for u ... ? 😏 Willi Wallace was no lier or schemer he would be utterly ashamed
lurking with intent to be offended should be a crime ---Blackford could be locked up then.
Lol
Detest the Tories! Scotland will get its independence!! 🏴⚔️
🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧 union ⚔️⚔️⚔️
Acting like a rude boy
Don't you wish that one of the SNP Muppets had shown some individuality and stayed put.
Alan S Binnie short answer no. not wanted
Joan cherry: is it funny?
Rest of the uk: yeah
Snp getting their weekly tanking lol,,
This comment hasn't aged well