thanks for posting this - it's great to hear the author drop this knowledge and insight,,,been a musician all my life but so much of this knowledge is new to me at age 51. many thanks and the musical journey continues to unfold!✨
He's wrong again. In the Beatles track you can clearly hear the cello notes and rhythm , 3 notes, the chord structure, the 3 voices and the word 'I'. And if you have my ears and brain, the pitches also give it identity.
Yeah he can't say it has no pitch. I heard a physics prof claim something similar about short bursts of some types of noise. What they mean is it has no absolute pitch, no distinguishable pitch that can be agreed upon outside of the relationship to the other pitches. So I guess it has relative pitch but not absolute pitch and yes for him to say that song is without pitch is incorrect
thanks for posting this - it's great to hear the author drop this knowledge and insight,,,been a musician all my life but so much of this knowledge is new to me at age 51. many thanks and the musical journey continues to unfold!✨
Absolutely fascinating.
Amazing! I want more . . .
Excellent talk
What’s up with the skip
THIS IS SO CORRECT
🕊
He's wrong again. In the Beatles track you can clearly hear the cello notes and rhythm , 3 notes, the chord structure, the 3 voices and the word 'I'. And if you have my ears and brain, the pitches also give it identity.
What are you talking about? Of course there's pitch in the Beethoven.
Yeah he can't say it has no pitch. I heard a physics prof claim something similar about short bursts of some types of noise. What they mean is it has no absolute pitch, no distinguishable pitch that can be agreed upon outside of the relationship to the other pitches. So I guess it has relative pitch but not absolute pitch and yes for him to say that song is without pitch is incorrect
Yeah, I thought that was unfair too. And same with the Beatles -- stuff was happening down there in bass clef land.