Jackie and Joo-Hyun said "I am going to have a whole-ass nervous breakdown on this stage" whereas Willemijn and Hannah said "All shall burn at my hands idgaf"
I love that you included all 3 languages Willemijn performed the part in! Edit: I didn’t finish the whole video before commenting, when I realized it also included her West End performance!
I'm seriously in trouble about finding my favourite ones, there are so much talented ladies omg! But i guess the way Shoshana sings and act this song is really incredible for me.
Hannah Corneau is the queen of no good deed. In my opinion she has the healthiest technique, and I just like her sound better overall! (Also her name is spelt wrong in the vid lol)
Oof that Jessica Vost rift on the “whyyy” at 36:37 is delicious!! Where can I find the whole video of just that performance? Wow, that part alone makes her 100% the best of the bunch in this video, there truly is no competition.
May be bias but Laura Pick was the Elphie I saw in London recently (and the first Elphie I’ve seen) so I’m going with her lovely technique which got me obsessed with this song!
I Know and Thank you for think that My version of The Actress who played Elphaba is awsome ( Danna Paola, The Mexican Actress who Played Elphaba in my Country)
@@sorrynotsorry6 fun fact. Ur videos inspired me to do comparison videos of my own!!!!! U have such lovely content and I can’t wait to see what else u do!!!! 😁😁😁😁😁
@@grandeflamesbutera3949 (and yes, Son Seungyeon is currently Elphaba in Wicked in Korea, but unfortunately there are no video/audios of her up yet. I saw your comment in my notifs but it doesn't show up in here for some reason)
@@sorrynotsorry6 Oh yeah cause I took it down because it sounded pretty mean and I didn't want to come off that way but thank u for answering my question
There is a video of her singing no good deed on youtube and it makes some of these performances actually look bad. Like Eden be making most of these chicks look like they must be in a public high school version of wicked 😂 that’s how mind-blowing it is.
OK so Park Hye-Na BLEW ME AWAY WITH HER ACTING, as much as this is a vocally difficult song, the acting SO much more important at this part in the show and her, eden, and Julia are the best in this category (also Willemijin is an amazing actress here AND also sings this so effortlessly ) But i do agree that Jessica Vosk and Jackie are the best vocaly
Yeah, and considering this is in order does that mean she’s the one who started the alternative “Fiyero” part ending with an F5? I’m not good at notes so correct me if I’m wrong.
The Korean Elphies go so HARD on the raw emotion and I'm 1000% here for it - Ock Joohyun, Cha Jiyeon, Park Hyena and the newest Elphie since this run, Son Seungyeon!
Stephaine J. Block performed on the 1NT for 1 year 2005-2006 she then reprised the role on Broadway from 2007-2008 Shoshana also performed on the 1NT for a limited time. She performed during 2006 Idina performed on Broadway from 2003-2005 Saycon was a standby from 2005 to 2007
1. Shoshana Bean 2. Willemijn Verkaik 3. Stephanie J. Block 4. Jessica Vosk 5. Idina Menzel (also if you do another wicked one could you include Laurel Harris? shes my fav elphaba and ik there’s a TON it would just be nice to see her in a comparison video :)
I have to look at my program book but I think Jackie is one of the girls I seen I done went 12-14 times to see this and actually going next month to see it again
Willemjin in german is everything ❤❤❤❤and Willemjin in every language 🎉best Elphaba for me. But I'm also impressed by Kelly Ellis, Jackie Burns, Jennifer DiNoia, Jessica Vosk, Alice Fearn and a what a freaking insane performance by Ock Joo Hyun❤❤❤
Wait, if this is in order does that mean Saycon did that alternative F5 first at the end of Fiyero? Also I love how Saycon says “will I do” I wish more would use that one.
The photo listed of Amanda Harrison is actually Victoria Matlock. The overall best "No Good Deed" is Lisa Brescia - Broadway standby 2007-08 and Chicago 2008 - but she's not listed. Of these, Julia Murney is the best-acted, though several others - Idina, Willemijn, etc. - are certainly no slouches. Also, I've said this elsewhere, but rename the Gershwin Theatre the Gershwin-DiNoia Theatre, or erect a statue to Jennifer DiNoia inside the Gershwin. Either/or.
@@matthewrandell5055 there's a difference between Standby and Understudy. Standby is there in the theatre just as if they were a lead, they're the first person to replace a role if something bad or unplanned were to happen. An understudy is there just in case the standby isn't available.
here's another Two versions of the song from Wicked "No Good Deed" ua-cam.com/video/DA-urdsTOA8/v-deo.html one is with Carrie Hope Fletcher and the other is with Annapantsu ua-cam.com/video/8dHmorpVH0o/v-deo.html and I am sure that this are the Right Links, and they are not Rick roll tricks
Dois homens, vestidos de branco, apareceram. ''Jesus foi para o céu,'' explicaram. ''Ele voltará da mesma forma que foi!'' Assim, os discípulos obedeceram a Jesus e foram para Jerusalém. Atos 1-11.
Time stamps 😊
0:01 Idina Menzel (Broadway)
1:38 Shoshana Bean
3:17 Saycon Sengbloh
4:56 Stephanie J. Block
6:34 Eden Espinosa
8:12 Idina Menzel (West-End)
9:52 Megumi Hamada
11:20 Kerry Ellis
12:54 Willemijn Verkaik (Germany)
14:38 Amanda Harrison
16:17 Julia Murney
17:49 Teal Wicks
19:24 Willemijn Verkaik (Netherlands)
21:04 Jackie Burns
22:42 Ock Joo Hyun
24:22 Park Hye-Na
26:04 Willemijn Verkaik (Broadway)
27:45 Danna Paola
29:25 Lindsay Mendez
31:03 Willemijn Verkaik (West-End)
32:40 Myra Ruiz
34:21 Jennifer DiNoia
36:00 Jessica Vosk
37:40 Alice Fearn
39:15 Hannah Corneau
40:51 Laura Pick
42:25 Lindsay Pearce
Thank you 🤗
27:45 here's the version of "No Good Deed" from Wicked of my country by Danna Paola
Lol, the only thing that's hilarious is a picture of Victoria Matlock for Amanda Harrison.
Jackie burns is crazy good
I'm partial to Shoshana's "Fiyerooooooooo!" even though it's not the prettiest. It's this gut-wrenching cry of anguish.
1. Idina Menzel (my all-time favorite Elphaba)
2. Willemijn Verkaik
3. Jessica Vosk
Can't wait to hear Cynthia Erivo sing this for the movie 😍
I’m going to physically combust I think
I’ll be in tears, I already know. This and For Good😭
Jackie and Joo-Hyun said "I am going to have a whole-ass nervous breakdown on this stage" whereas Willemijn and Hannah said "All shall burn at my hands idgaf"
I saw Laura Pick a week ago on West End. She blew me away. She is amazing. Her vocals are crazy.
IMHO Saycon’s “will I do” at 4:42 is one of the best ever recorded. Absolutely lays me flat.
i just watched 44 minutes of the same song... i need help
Haha I hope you enjoyed it nonetheless!
😂
And 3 seconds
It’s such a good song!!
I literally LOL’d 😂. I did the same thing 😅
I love that you included all 3 languages Willemijn performed the part in!
Edit: I didn’t finish the whole video before commenting, when I realized it also included her West End performance!
Thank you!
The woman letting a guttural "ugh" to the reverb on Kerry Ellis's "Ice Cold Eye" at 11:50 is my soul mate
I'm seriously in trouble about finding my favourite ones, there are so much talented ladies omg! But i guess the way Shoshana sings and act this song is really incredible for me.
Hannah Corneau is the queen of no good deed. In my opinion she has the healthiest technique, and I just like her sound better overall!
(Also her name is spelt wrong in the vid lol)
She is very good! One of the top Elphies for sure!
omg finally someone with taste lol i've been saying that since the beggining, Hannah is just amazing
The floatiness she gives the notes before her belting is really dynamic and really brings so much more interest than just singing all at one volume.
Ock joo hyun ❤❤❤
Oof that Jessica Vost rift on the “whyyy” at 36:37 is delicious!! Where can I find the whole video of just that performance? Wow, that part alone makes her 100% the best of the bunch in this video, there truly is no competition.
7:23 love Eden
Holy shit. The SPIN that Ock Jok Hyun gives that Eden Fiyero riff!!!!
I mean Jessica Vosk wins, but Jackie Burns’ vocal should be heard again with headphones. Her F5 is insane.
Ock Joo Hyun gave me CHILLS her vocals and acting were incredible
She was my fav :)
YEEEEEEES!!!!!! She's amazing, i wish i could see hert perform Wicked! I went to Korea at 2019, but idk if she was performing still.
the "euughh" in the audience at 11:49 when Kerry sings "ice cold eye"
I think it’s a sneeze.
May be bias but Laura Pick was the Elphie I saw in London recently (and the first Elphie I’ve seen) so I’m going with her lovely technique which got me obsessed with this song!
danna paola and myra ruiz are just--🛐🛐🛐🛐
I Know and Thank you for think that My version of The Actress who played Elphaba is awsome ( Danna Paola, The Mexican Actress who Played Elphaba in my Country)
I love this!!!!! 😍😍😍😍. Every Elphaba is amazing on in their own feat. ❤️❤️❤️. Amazing video!!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Thank you for watching!
@@sorrynotsorry6 fun fact. Ur videos inspired me to do comparison videos of my own!!!!! U have such lovely content and I can’t wait to see what else u do!!!! 😁😁😁😁😁
Awww thank you so much!
@@grandeflamesbutera3949 (and yes, Son Seungyeon is currently Elphaba in Wicked in Korea, but unfortunately there are no video/audios of her up yet. I saw your comment in my notifs but it doesn't show up in here for some reason)
@@sorrynotsorry6 Oh yeah cause I took it down because it sounded pretty mean and I didn't want to come off that way but thank u for answering my question
I wish more Elphabas would do Saycon’s “will I do”
EDEN ESPINOSA FOR THE WIN!! My god her talent is otherworldly! I wish I was around to see her😢😢😢
There is a video of her singing no good deed on youtube and it makes some of these performances actually look bad. Like Eden be making most of these chicks look like they must be in a public high school version of wicked 😂 that’s how mind-blowing it is.
ua-cam.com/video/ud-CTXf7aeo/v-deo.htmlsi=KorjdcevXFZRWerm this version is best ever no good deed by eden. The last part, ughhhhhh, chills!
Are we just gonna ignore Saycon Sengbloh? Okay....that's fine. 3:30
Willemijn’s vowel placement shift on the last note gets me every time
Time stamps for my favorote part of the song the last note 😊💞
1:19 Idina Menzel (Broadway)
2:58 Shoshana Bean
4:38 Saycon Sengbloh
6:17 Stephanie J. Block
7:55 Eden Espinosa
9:33 Idina Menzel (West-End)
11:04 Megumi Hamada
12:36 Kerry Ellis
14:19 Willemijn Verkaik (Germany)
15:59 Amanda Harrison
17:32 Julia Murney
19:09 Teal Wicks
20:45 Willemijn Verkaik (Netherlands)
22:23 Jackie Burns
24:05 Ock Joo Hyun
25:45 Park Hye-Na
27:26 Willemijn Verkaik (Broadway)
28:05 Danna Paola
30:46 Lindsay Mendez
32:22 Willemijn Verkaik (West-End)
34:04 Myra Ruiz
35:41 Jennifer DiNoia
37:20 Jessica Vosk
38:59 Alice Fearn
40:34 Hannah Corneau
42:08 Laura Pick
43:45 Lindsay Pearce
Danna Paola 😭❣️
I try to find Rachel Tucker but she's not in this video
OK so Park Hye-Na BLEW ME AWAY WITH HER ACTING, as much as this is a vocally difficult song, the acting SO much more important at this part in the show and her, eden, and Julia are the best in this category (also Willemijin is an amazing actress here AND also sings this so effortlessly ) But i do agree that Jessica Vosk and Jackie are the best vocaly
I saw teal wicks as a kid in San Francisco and let’s just say this show changed the wiring of my mind
Danna Paola is.. as always, absolutely amazing.
These videos are a gift. Thank you! 😊
00:01 Idina Menzel
01:38 Shoshana Bean
Saycon Sengbloh is one of the biggest voices! Easily the best TWAI. Its a travesty she never got a proper run...
I heard once she was offered full-time and turned it down to prioritize the health of her voice. I could def be wrong tho.
Saycon confirmed that this was untrue
Yeah, and considering this is in order does that mean she’s the one who started the alternative “Fiyero” part ending with an F5? I’m not good at notes so correct me if I’m wrong.
Ock Joo Hyun and Park Hye-Na slayedddd!! Hopefully they can perform in broadway!
I love ock joo hyun expression
Lindsay took over from Hannah and you can definitely tell she took a list of inspo from Hannah’s ending especially her last note!
I think Rachel came up that ending actually, but
Damn those Korean Elphies 🔥
Yess! IMO, they are the best!
The Korean Elphies go so HARD on the raw emotion and I'm 1000% here for it - Ock Joohyun, Cha Jiyeon, Park Hyena and the newest Elphie since this run, Son Seungyeon!
@@shruthakeerthi4559 Yes! They deserve more recognition in the fandom!
@@shruthakeerthi4559 they’re amazing!
15:48
21:36 and 22:01 (her shrill wicked-witch voice)
22:21 Her voice blew me away. And I like her dramatic finish.
31:38
-Willemijn is the best! 4 different countries. She plays no Elphaba, she is Elphaba.
At this rate you need to do a "The Wizard And I" compilation aswell 😂 But please with Laurel Harris and Jodie Steele 😥
YESSS FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE REQUESTING LAUREL BHDHDHRJDKKF
@@amb2487 WE STAN MISS HARRIS HERE
@@aaronwilliams2155 SHES TOTALLY MY FAVE :D
Done ;)
ock joo hyun though. HOLY WOW!!!!
Stephaine J. Block performed on the 1NT for 1 year 2005-2006 she then reprised the role on Broadway from 2007-2008
Shoshana also performed on the 1NT for a limited time. She performed during 2006
Idina performed on Broadway from 2003-2005
Saycon was a standby from 2005 to 2007
FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION: KERRY ELLIS AND SAYCON SENGBLOH
24:23
JC can you send a Park Hye-Na ( No Good Deed ) please ???
1:27, the pits timing is perfect with the last note.
willemijn is an absolute queen!!
Yes! She is!!
1. Shoshana Bean
2. Willemijn Verkaik
3. Stephanie J. Block
4. Jessica Vosk
5. Idina Menzel
(also if you do another wicked one could you include Laurel Harris? shes my fav elphaba and ik there’s a TON it would just be nice to see her in a comparison video :)
I have to look at my program book but I think Jackie is one of the girls I seen I done went 12-14 times to see this and actually going next month to see it again
Saycon!!!
Very disappointed that Ana Geyster wasn't mentioned. Saw her in Chicago and she was amazing! For those here, Shoshana hands down.
Willemjin in german is everything ❤❤❤❤and Willemjin in every language 🎉best Elphaba for me.
But I'm also impressed by Kelly Ellis, Jackie Burns, Jennifer DiNoia, Jessica Vosk, Alice Fearn and a what a freaking insane performance by Ock Joo Hyun❤❤❤
Wait, if this is in order does that mean Saycon did that alternative F5 first at the end of Fiyero?
Also I love how Saycon says “will I do” I wish more would use that one.
all of them are amazing but there's something about hannah corneau in this song that I LOVE, her ending riff, her tone everything is just so good
Danna Paola es la mejor tercer Elphaba a nivel mundial nombrada por broadway.
Ella es espectacular. Ella y Ock Joo Hyun son las mejores Elphabas en mi opinión
Shoshanna by miles. Her "Fiyero!" is grief and anger and desperation sung out loud.
Eden is the best of the best
YASSS she is one of the best Elphies for sure
Agreed!!!! Absolutely the best! I get chills every time I watch her final Defying Gravity video with Kendra! Those two are just incredible!!
Who do you think did it best? Feel free to comment!
Danna Paola (Mexican Actress for Elphaba That she is from my Country), Eden Espinosa, Stephanie J. Block and also Idina Menzel
26:04 The attempt at “Doctor” in an American accent is exaggerated and overkill. Her voice is BONKERS, but omg that drives me nuts.
that’s just how she speaks…she practically pronounces every word that way
i think lindsay is really great!
I did miss the Donna Vivino in this video :(
1. Willemijn Verkaik
2. Idina Menzel
3. Julia Murney
No further comparisons required.
Lindsay Mendez is just- so amazing. 🤩
Willemijn 💚
Myra Ruiz is just so 🥰
Where is Donna Vivino?
Who cares about the rest of the video? Saycon is the only Elphaba you need to watch. Why she was never lead is horrifying
Yeah it’s crazy I’m not sure why she never took lead, but I think this was during Shosana’s run so she was prob an understudy.
Alice fearn I think was amazing
Julia Murney....what a queen!
1:50
4:44
20:50
22:46
36:37
28:23 ¡¡ Aquí está Danna Paola!! La actriz de Elphaba para Mi país (México)
I feel like Stephanie J. Block's doesn't get enough love
Where is the Queen DONNA Vivino ?
JESSICA VOSK ABSOLUTELY WON THIS CHALLENGE AND NO ONE CAN CONVINCE ME OTHERWISE
It's just Elsa as Elphaba and Maleficent (descendants) as Glinda lol
Danna Paola
The photo listed of Amanda Harrison is actually Victoria Matlock.
The overall best "No Good Deed" is Lisa Brescia - Broadway standby 2007-08 and Chicago 2008 - but she's not listed.
Of these, Julia Murney is the best-acted, though several others - Idina, Willemijn, etc. - are certainly no slouches.
Also, I've said this elsewhere, but rename the Gershwin Theatre the Gershwin-DiNoia Theatre, or erect a statue to Jennifer DiNoia inside the Gershwin. Either/or.
btw, Jennifer dinoia did more than broadway 2016-17 :)
Thank you for letting me know! 🙂
@@sorrynotsorry6 Broadway:Jennifer DiNoia (August 2016-July 2017) Jennifer DiNoia (December 2009-August 2011; October 2012; August-September 2014; June 2019-Current) - Standby 1NT: Jennifer DiNoia (February-March 2015) Chicago: Jennifer DiNoia (October 2007-January 2009) (also u/s Nessarose) - Standby London: Jennifer DiNoia (October 2014-January 2015) 2NT: Jennifer DiNoia (April 2013-April 2014) Sydney: Jennifer DiNoia (November-December 2009; temporary) - Standby Asian Tour: Jennifer DiNoia (May 2012-October 2012) - Standby
@@IMRYAN871 Wow! She did a lot! Good to know!!
36:38 😲😲😲
What does s/b mean?
Standby
@@sorrynotsorry6 ah thanks
Like understudy?
@@matthewrandell5055 there's a difference between Standby and Understudy. Standby is there in the theatre just as if they were a lead, they're the first person to replace a role if something bad or unplanned were to happen. An understudy is there just in case the standby isn't available.
Curious Fact: did you Know that Also Idina Menzel played Elsa in The Movies of "Frozen "
Yes, she is very famous for the role!
@@sorrynotsorry6 i Know... And she Also played a Role in The movie "Enchanted "
@@raquelDRS5936 I've heard about that movie but I actually haven't seen it...maybe I should check it out!
OckElpha!
We're is Talia?
18:02 👏👏👏😲😲😲
Although she's not my favorite, I find Ana Cecilia Anzaldúa from the Mexico City production is missing.
For me it’s a tie between Jessica and Alice. I mean wow/
alice fearn is sooo good its insane
jessica vosk 100%
Saycon absolutely ate
here's another Two versions of the song from Wicked "No Good Deed"
ua-cam.com/video/DA-urdsTOA8/v-deo.html
one is with Carrie Hope Fletcher
and the other is with Annapantsu
ua-cam.com/video/8dHmorpVH0o/v-deo.html
and I am sure that this are the Right Links, and they are not Rick roll tricks
where is my beautiful donna vivinno?
It's very disappointing that there aren't
few Japanese cast
So I'd like to listen other Japanese Cast singing
Laura Pick ❤❤❤❤❤❤💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚Laura pick, mama elphie, laura Pick is elphie x
You spell Hannah Corneau wrong 😨
It's Hannah Corneau ✔️
Not Hanna Corneau ❌️
You forgot the H on Hannah 😨
Hanna was so good
laura pick is pretty damn good
Eden espinosa is queen
00:01:
Dois homens, vestidos de branco, apareceram. ''Jesus foi para o céu,'' explicaram. ''Ele voltará da mesma forma que foi!'' Assim, os discípulos obedeceram a Jesus e foram para Jerusalém. Atos 1-11.