Farm Law Protests - Who is Right? Farmers or Government? 3 Farm Laws Protests and Debate
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2021
- Hello Everybody, in this Video, I have tried to put explain the major concerns of the farmers and respective government responses. This Video will help you understand the reasons behind bringing the 3 Farm Laws as well as the Reasons behind the ongoing Farm Protest.
Here are some key takeaways:
-The simplest solution against the protest of the farmers with respect to the farm laws can be to include statutory backing to the MSP (Minimum Support Price) and procurement in the new Law to eradicate the fear of the farmers.
- Giving farmers the choice to sell without the help of middlemen will be of great use only if there are roads that link villages to markets, climate-controlled storage facilities, the electricity supply is made reliable and available to power those facilities, and food processing companies who compete to buy their produce.
- Farmers fear that the ordinances will disrupt the mandi system of marketing and also hamper the selling of products at MSP.
- These would serve as an “additional marketing channel” for farmers, even as the APMCs “will continue to function”.
- The freedom of choice to sell outside the regulated mandis should help farmers realize better prices for their produce.
- The ordinance itself does not mention anything, directly or indirectly, to suggest an end or phasing out of MSP-based government procurement.
- No provision enumerated under the new ordinance regarding MSP. Farmers may get a price for their crops below the MSP if selling their produce outside the mandis.
We hope you find this video useful in your various competitive exam preparation! Leave us a comment if you have any doubts or questions. Wishing you ALL THE BEST!
**********************************
Instagram: /
My Courses: learn.finology.in
Open Your Quick Account: upstox.com/open-account/?f=2
Blog: blog.finology.in/recent-updat...
Now this what the national media misses out(unbiased perspective). You are just awesome Priya Mam. Finology is😍😍😊
Start with 3rd bill mam 86 % farmers are marginal could they afford cold storage and it allow stocking of every thing which can only be done by big corporates which later cause price increases of every commodity
2nd contract farming have provisions of quality checking of produce
Mam can farmer have power to control climate or temperature which cause damage to crops
And company even take credit from banks on agreement which further have to pay by the farmer if company denay and solution done by the SDM 😂
Now 1st law other private mandis
Mam you told only 6% procurement done on MSP which is not reality they buy from farmers from low price and registered it on MSP in this Arthiyas or middle man help him in doing this
MSP THA HA OR RAHEGA
It is right but we do not buy on it because there is no law
And farmers are demanding law
By reading comments i came to a conclusion ...हम वही सुनते है जो हमें सुनना अच्छा लगता है.
Damn true yrr.. I feel the same when I go through dhruv rathee's comment section..!!
This is a physchological bias in all humans. check out "Confirmation Bias"
Correct
🤣
@@vinayakverma3444 Sahi h...
Dhruv Rathee k comments section esa hi h....!
Jo accha lgta h vahi sunege
Damn damn.. it gave me a Crystal clear vision over what's going on.. Indian Media, the tweet fests going on and with everything else it all seemed so vague.. thank you for this video. ✨
Thank you Ma'am for always making the topic so simple! 💖
ok
There is a teacher in every class but this teacher has class. Law is simplified by you. I've been watching all your classes. Please take some more classes on commercial laws. Thank you ma'am!
@Priya Mam
Particularly Mercantile Law / Business Law .
Yes mam that's called spitting facts and am trying to write what I understood after hearing yours and Vikash sir videos ,
Clause by clause benefits and harms
1)Farmers produce (Trade and commerce) Act - 1. Freedom of choice of sale and purchase - eg. Outside mandis 2. Barrier free inter and intra state trade 3. No need to pay cess and levies 4. Electronic trading - transparency and tine saving 5. Direct trading at farm gate, cold storage, processing units etc 6. Elimination of middlemen 7. Clarification by Govt - MSP system and Mandis will continue
Issues - 1. Farmers might not get adequate demand for their produce at MSP in local mandi 2. They don't have resources to transport produce over large distances 3. Distress sale of products at lower price at local mandi Farmers
2)(empowerment and protection) agreement on price assistance and farm services act - 1. Enable contract farming - eg. E choupal 2. Price assurance even before sowing 3. If higher MP, entitled to it than one in contract 4. Transfer risk of market unpredictability - due to prior price determination 5. Access to modern technology, better seeds and inputs - due to Investment by private companies 6. Reduced cost of marketing - due to assured sale 7. Effective dispute resolution - with clear time of redressal 8. Impetus to R&D in agri sector 9. Clarification - - farmer will have full power in the contract to fix SP - empowering the farmers - FPOs will help - local DSR and no need to go to court Issues - 1. Farmers not empowered or educated to negotiate with corporate sector 2. Inputs like seeds, fertiliser etc might come under corporate hegemony 3. Corporarisation might bring uniformity - ruining the diversity of agro practices in different parts 4. Exploration of farmers 5. Economy of scale is required - but 85% farmers are S&M
3) Essential commodities amendment act, 2020 - 1. Remove commodities like cereals, pulses, oilseeds, onion, potatoes from list of ECs 2. Liberalising the regulatory env - Remove fears of private investors from excess regulation 3. Drive up investment in supply chain - eg. Investment in cold storage - 35-40% wastage due to lack of storage facilities and cost around 35000 cr to farmers 4. In case of emergencies like war, famine, natural calamity, these commodities can be regulated again - thus safeguarding int of consumers
Issues - 1. Might lead to hoarding and black marketing 2. Issues - 1. Unawareness of farmers about their rights - - eg. Shanta kumar committee says only 6% HH get MSP benefits. 2. This leads to non implementation of schemes - 10281 suicides in 2019 in India despite Various Govt reforms
Farmers given choice to sell directly outside mandis - might harm their interests as they are not educated how to protect their interests 4. Might lead to exploitation by rich businesses and debt trap - as the businesses will be their mai baap 5. Commodificaton of agriculture - might lead to food insecurity 6. Previous steps - APLM Act - more than 15 States adopted it's provisions to give farmers choice of sale outside Mandis but not many farmers reaped it's benefits Swaminathan committee - MSP should be C2 + 50% but not implemented correctly Santha Kumar committee - only 6% farmer HH get benefit of MSP More than 65% paddy and wheat growers don't know about Govt procuring grains 2019 - Maha 3927 suicides - highest in country despite loan waivers and reforms India - 10281 suicides - 28 suicides a day. So, practical implementation is the key.
Reform is the crying need of time with slight changes which govt is also trying to modify but rejecting the bill is going to push farmers in same gutterwhere we will say ki lays to 10 me 2 aloo deta hai aur bechare kisaan 1 kilo ke 5 ka benefit hota hai. Peace ❤️
Mereko feeling aa Rahi hai ki future me CBSE civics me ye chapter aayega aur exactly yehi inska notes hoga
Isi se related questions girega 5 marks ka!!!
Bhai itna batane ke bad b log nhai mante
It looks good on paper only reality is far more different.
@@PremSagar-vm4rp itni badi country hone ki sabse badi problem hai...
Ye comment meko copy karne ki hei bhai
All the farmers who are doing these protests need to see this video.
very well explained ..!
they aren't farmers, they are all service men in the mask of farmer to protect their commission.
@@swadeshicreator9717 service men do not owe these many tra tors trolleys u ullu
Extreeeeeemely Informative! I understood everything about the Farm Laws. Thank you very much Finology Legal!!
All farmers should be understand this law and govt should be ammendment in this laws
ammendment k liye government tyar he. lekin ye jo protest kr rhe he.. wo bill hta ne pe tule he..
Share karo
@@karansinhjadejavlogs3310 kll ko fir se amendment ko amend krke fir wohi purani clause daal lenge jbb mrji fir kya krega kissan ,ye bolo pehle,itna bda andolan baar baar nhi hota
@@karansinhjadejavlogs3310 we need a law on MSP we will back to home .
@@karansinhjadejavlogs3310 htane hi pdenge ye tino bill thats it
One minute silence for those who doesn't read farm bills and make a decision 😂😂😂😂😀😀
everyone is doing this except few percent
None of the protestor has read actually
@@aman___004 even farmers' leaders doesn't
Maine vikas sir ka 2.30 hrs ka lecture dekha wo detail mhe tha
@@_Anshukumar bhai maine bhi dekha tha aur ab tak ka sabse best content h farm bills pr
I stand with the government initiative however only empowerment must be given Farmers to challenge in the court instead to approach SDM. SDM tends to fall under Political pressure after all he/she is a civil servant.
I think if they involve farmers or will listen farmers side at the very begining, these small conflicts will arrive early and there will be no protest and that will be a true justice with democracy (atleast we hv to listen to the stakeholders, ultimately they are going to get benefitted or impacted by it), things will solve easily , it was just a matter of talks
Now I can debate with my friends about the farm bills... Nice analysis.. Thank u mam
Donot debate with freinds bec her knowledge is not sufficient she is wrong commission agent framers se paise charge nhi karte buyer commission dehta hai ..
@@MOHIT64929 Abe gawar delhi ke mandi me ja aur jakr bolna alu King aur tamatar king dekhna commission agent gawar sake
@@abi-wg4jt 😂 yar ye logg kya hogaa
@@roh4n591 chup
आपने तो पूरा concept समझा दिया।वो भी बहुत कम समय में।👌
Thanku Ma'am 🙏
At 10:15, Mukesh Ambani be like pta nhi hamesha har dispute me mai kaise aage aa jata hoon 😂🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hmm hm sb jgha
😂😂
jiomart ke baare main sune ho?
@@rahulbatish8704 Na suna hai aur na sunna hai 😂
Greetings to the team of Finology Legal!
This is to extend my sincere and hearty gratitude for considering my request. Found myself thoroughly engaged and enjoying while being educated by Ms Priya Jain.
Pls keep up with the quality neutral content! As I am preparing for some govt exams, your content genuinely helps rhe most.
Much Regards!
TRUE UNBIASED ANALYSIS .... SAW MANY VIDEOS RELATED TO THIS BUT U R THE ONLY ONE WHO CLEARED WHOLE PICTURE IN MOST GENUINE MANNER... LOVE FROM PUNJAB ❤
Country cannot run without reforms.... JaiHind
@@ajaybawa619 i accept of gradual manner... Before it.. misinformation has been spread like a wildfire... Which is More dangerous.. here we can see government failure of farmer government relation and miscommunication
Fir bi congress bolegi kaale kanun vapas karo😂
@@ajaybawa619 kyu . ? Jitni jaldi utna behtar
Yes, but not rammed down people’s throat without their input. Let’s put your income at risk next year with potential reductions of 100% - will you still want reforms?
Hey dii!! First view and comment
Love you and thank you for your teaching ❤
News media should be explaining like this instead of re-iterating the statements again and again. Speech without content would just assist in fuelling the anti-centre narratives. Well explained Madam. Very informative, clear and on mark.
This is the best video I got to get simplified explanation of farm laws, I have covered this topic a lot of times earlier but this video gave me an extreme clarity on farm laws. Thank You Finology Legal, keep up the good work
Very helpfull lecture ma"am I hope finology legal open the coaching centres !! ❤️🙏 Love from lucknow 🙏❤️
👍
My favorite channel for current updates.
Thanks FINOLOGY LEGAL❤
You Are Right
Dr. B.R Ambedkar Ji
Always welcome!
Right to Protest is a fundamental right.
Democracy is the best form of Government.
But keeping silent,consented all is not practicable and possible.
Appreciated!!...please keep up the good work✌
Unbiased facts always 👏💥
Wah😭😉😁😂😂😂
Thank you di for giving your lecture 😊
It's a totally balanced approach ma'am... 😊👍 Thank you so much for explaining farmers Bill... 😀
You forget the point of unlimited storage of food grains.
Please elaborate this.
very much to her convinience
Not every crops
Get your facts clear at first
@@hrishavkhaware you get your knowledge first
I really waiting for this session... Thx for clearing your concept. 🎁
Thank you so much for explaining us the true side, the legal perspective of these laws. We need you to make more such videos🙏
Great effort ma'am... appreciate your explanation skills... having seen your other videos on legal matters I have learnt about certain common topics with which I always felt confused... suggest you to simplify the legal words like OA, WP, MA REJOINDER, RE-REJOINDER, etc....this will help non legal guys to understand these terms in simple language....Keep up your good work....this topic has provided me with a good insight on pros and cons of Farm Laws....
Ma'am, What a lovely explanation...
Thankyou for your valuable information.
I used to think that I know a lot about three farm laws but I was wrong.. Thank you, for explaining everyone's perspective..
Earlier I was very perplexed about this law...Why there is tussle between Govt and Farmers ? Why farmers are protesting and Why Govt is not revoking this law. But Now I'm happy that all my doubts cleared through your lecture 🙏😊. Really It helped me to understand the crux of the matter 🙏. You r such a outstanding teacher. 🙏❤️
Chlo kisi ko to pta chla.. Nai to kanoon raddd kro yehi chilate ha sn
Hats off, what a great way to make us understand the matter
1. New market is already there and why an enactment is needed additionally to avail that.
2. Contract Farming is possible without any acts then why to bring this new regulatory act which looks more beneficial to the affluent contract farmer (Farming Companies).
3. Delisting these from essential commodities will lead to hoarding and market monopoly. This ethically against Competition Act.
Americaz 80% wealth is generated by about 8-10 companies
Japanz and Koreaz 80% wealth is created by about 5 companies
Nobody can stop monoply creation is a dvelepoing and capitalist environment and monoply doesn mean social unrest. Its the law of nature
can you please explain more on your 3rd point. what exactly is Competition Act and how will new farm laws be impacted
Objective of to prevent monopolies and to promote competition in the market. After the amendment to Essential Commodities Act, Hoarding of food grains will be easier and in case of such competition will be restricted
Above is about Competition Act 2002.
Adani has worked on food grain Silos in Punjab. Such mega storage of food grain can easily bring monopoly in food grain pricing. Adani van spend 1000s crores to purchase and store food grains from small farmers and hoard. Later the pricing control will go to him.
Excellent teaching skills, as expected from you..
NOW THAT'S WHAT I CALL A UNBIASED OPINION 👍👍👍👍👍 . FAVORITE CHANNEL ON UA-cam ✌️✌️❤️
being a UPSC aspirant i can say that after debating reading and discussing for 3 months I can say with few little changes it will change the Indian agriculture forever
For the better or worse?
@@toshikakushwah7454 it depends on your view, but in my opinion this bill will be better for sure
@@saketsharma9302 yeah I think both the parties should keep the ego aside and indulge in finding a middle way.
@@toshikakushwah7454 YA RIGHT BUT WHAT ABOUT THE POLITICAL GAME PLAYED THERE
until less politics is out from movement there does not seem any way and I think with time it will also end up like SAAHIN BAGH
@@saketsharma9302 and that seems difficult
India needs people like you who don't blather shit without knowing anything, but think and then speak.
Thanks for making this video💫
she blabbered the shit only 😂
haha koi pada Likha is ruling the country kya 😂 👍
Wow it calls beauty with brain... 🥰🥰🥰
Mam aap bde satik trik se smjhate ho❤️
Such amazing video!!! Opened all the closed horizons of my mind regarding this huge on-going issue. Thank you.👌❤
Glad it was helpful!
kabhi khud khetibki hai ? Kabhi loan k niche aaye ho ? Kabhi apna dad marta hua dekha tension me jab ghar ne bdi beti ki shadi krne wali pdi ho, kabhi tractor me diesal daalte time socha hai k itna diesal lau kha se ? Kabhi socha hai ye sab ? Jin logo k pas farming ka experience hai tum log kese unko bta skte ho k farmerlaws sahi hai ???? How brother how ???? Kabhi rotii muh ne daalne se pehle socha bhi hai k 6 months mitti k sath mitti hokr bnti hai …. Kisaan pagal hai ? Jo apna ghar chod kr bahr khrab mousam me hakk maangne k liye itne mahino se bethe hai ?? Ab aap log btaoge k kisano k liye kya sahi hai or kya galt ? Kabhi socha k is laws se pehle govt ko voting krni chahiye thi ?
Your teaching skills are incredible mam...you always introduce every topic so easy to understand...we are learning so much from your lectures...the way you teach makes everything so easy...Thanku mam ❤️ all the best for future
Thank You Priya Ma'am for this very informative video
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Perfectly explained❤️
Best explanation ever!! Thank you so much mam.🇮🇳
This is by far the most perfect video on this topic!! Every significant point was covered. It's so good.
Thank you 😊
@@_FinologyLegal correct me if I am wrong but bank loan wavier is under central government right??!!
Nahi state kr sakte h ..
Wow!!! Why our media houses never elaborate like this?? Wow mam❤️👍!!
Because this type of elaboration takes time and deep study.
If tv media going to do this . Then concept of breaking news will become a thing of past
Best way to explain in simple language✌
1 of the most underrated channel
Thank you so much... For such excellent explanation
Perfect explanation...now it is clear to me...all about farm bills and it's contrast between government and farmers...
Ma'am, your lecture always attractive and benifisial..
Wow, It was really unbiased.
Thank you Mam.
You are explaining it very beautiful ❤
I will share this video. HOPE IT GETS VIRAL
This video' need more views
No. This video is misleading.
@@amarpreet3519 chup
@@vitaminprotein4868 bhai Mandi tax middlemen dete hain na ki farmers. Yeh madam gumrah kar rahi hai sabko.
@@amarpreet3519 Exactly there is no need of middlemen.
Farmer will have all the rights to sell their crops anywhere and to anyone they want.
@@amitsahoo6745 chal oye. Jo services middlemen farmers ko dete hain woh tu dega fir?
Most effective and neutral explanation by some channel. I am a fan of your channel. Looking forward to more such videos👌👍
Very Informative video.
Thankyou
Thank you the video was the first neutral video I had seen on this topic! You are a very talented person and I hope you keep making such videos
As I saw Priya Di❤ I was like 😳woww🥳🥳🥳 so good to see u again.
we will one-day elaborate these days to our further generation that a lady who brings us the lights of knowledge directly from the sun through her untouchable beauty
Too cringe but still claps
@@nikhilsharma2236 😂
Great Work was done in the interest of the Nation. Congratulations..! May God Bless You. Most of the APMCs are not ready to implement eNAM in the interest of Farmer!
awesome 👏🏻 u really present unbiased view👌🏻 otherwise everyone is putting their own thoughts, conclusions, and solutions
Awesome job. Liked the way how you simplified the laws and their pros and cons.
How to explain ma’am ,I never understand,
That’s means I m know, but you’re tallent is out of way ,,,,,
Superb maam
Your description was unbiased and educative.
I wanna keep one of my story here
A flight ticket cancellation of mine is still pending in flipkart.
I appealed in consumer forum
I called their costomer care
I emailed them tried my best effort to get back my refund of ₹9000.
But I remained still unrepaid..
The thing I wanted to say that
An educated person like me has gone through this condition with corporate. Imagine what will happen with those farmers.. irrespective they're educated or less educated.. but yeah I'm afraid they'll suffer like I did
aap bhout ache se explain krte h ........thank you
Need this much clarity on concept of farm laws. Thanks again to provide us with the way we need as ever. ❤️🙏
My pleasure
Great work ma'am. An impartial perspective is highly needed for a better conceptualisation of any topic . The Indian media including news channels, certain UA-cam channels and social sites must learn to document facts unbiasedly from you.
the best explaination in short period is ausome , your explanation is best
Wow , awesome explanation ❤️thank you ma'am ❤️
Desh de kissana nu ona da aj haq milgeya 😊🙏waheguru ji satnam ji 🙏
Sarbat da bhalla 🙏🙏
Mam , thank you so much for this unbiased information 🙏
India needs more people like you without politicising the facts 👍
Excellent presentation as usual. Keep up the good work.
very nice representation style. Thank u
Thank you Maam ❤Mujhe Ye topic bhut confused kar rha tha 🙏
Watch agriculture laws by amit Sengupta you will get both side unbiased view
great info... thank you...
Thank you so much ma'am for providing all the info regarding the laws in such a broad and beautiful manner..
Thanks for liking!
A really good explanation of ongoing protest . I hope the protest ends when govt WRITE down the provision in new laws
I got to know and understand the whole criteria and issue in just a simple and capsular manner 💛 thanks a ton 💕
Glad it was helpful!
@@_FinologyLegal Please share the proof that government has assured that it will give in writting about MSP guarantee??
Duration 9:00
Please do not spread fake news and wrong information
If government gives in writing guarantee that private outside APMC, anyone and everyone must give MSP legally then only then farmers are benefitted
@@teamofmultitalents yo, the PM himself said that the msp won't be taken out.....
And educate yourself how a law works.... If there is no mention of any issue or concept (like msp)then that law has no power to deal with it or even that law has nothing to do with it...
Some youtubers are spreading negativity against the govt. Without any reason , you are doing good mam..we became educated after this video
My Dear Negativity isn't baseless,
You can see BSNL. Govt didn't Say that we are shutting down BSNL.
Will SDM protect Farmer's Rights in front of giant Private player...??
@Eureka yes off course it is too
@@englishacademy4842 how can you compare bsnl with a market lol🤣🤣.
And govt said they can amend law and will add fast track court option..
I usually do not comment but you effort forced me. Much appreciation ma'am! This was in the simplest way explained. Keep up the good work.
Comments to Kiya phir usually kyu Bola😀
Excellent..u are very much knowledgeable indeed
Didi ajj mein apka old vedio dekha "article 13 " wala tbb app kitni choti thi🤓 ,abb healthy ho gyi he😁
... thanks for your all vedios 🙏💐
your work is commendable. so genuine video i have seen on the internet today. As far as i believe for every problem of the farmers , there is a solution given by the govt. lets see what will happen ?
Beautifully put. God bless you
Very well explained, as usual.
As simple as one can get....Just feeling sad for our beloved farmers, after all they all are ours.
Just awesome can't describe in words.❤️❣️❣️❣️😘😘
Thank you so much 😀
Thank you so much mam aapne bahut easily ye sab clear kiya
You are welcome!
Very important video... this will help those people who misunderstood these laws... and without knowing anything only protest against the laws
Even mid junior students can understand the concept and current situation they provide through their videos........
Thank you! ☺️
@@_FinologyLegal mam apko sch btana chahie ki government farmers k lie or desh k logo k lie kch ni krri ..kya bechaare gareeb farmers jab sdm in government servant k pas jaegi to apke hisaab se vha p kya unki sunvayi hogi un private companies k aage..jab kisi sarkari daftar me jaate to pta h na kitna tym lgta h to apko lgta h ki greeb log jab vha jaenge to unki sunvayi hogi..courts me b nhi ja skti or ap ye kya khre h ki sarkaar aisa bol ri h ki vo aise provisions leke aegi ki agr kisi farmer court ja skte h to phle ye provisions aegi fr bolna or jo aap khre ho ki vo dusri market me jaake dusri state me jaake bech skte h to farmers ko kitni prblmes hoti h ye pta h apko or b boht baatein h araam se likungi atleast ap jaise prhe likhe logo se ye umeed ni h is desh ko
@@purely.logical bhai kahan is gadhi ko samjha rha hai. Jab religion ki hate iski aankhon se hategi to khud samajh jayegi
@@harmanpreetkaur9630 apko kuch pata v hai? Govt kuch nhi kar rahi? Toh note bandi , pulwama case pe action, swach bharat , sanitation improvement woh sab apne kia tha shayad? Economics n civics ka book khola hai kabhi?.Punjab aur haryana ke alawa v bohot jagah pe farmers hai jinko in laws se koi dikkat nhi hai.Woh padhe likhe hai isiliye cheez ko samajh ke thik se cheez ko samjha rahe hai taki aap samajh sako ki isse farmers koi dikkat nhi hogi balki pure deshbhar ke farmers ko faida hoga.
@@purely.logical esa nhi, atleast black money jinke paas thi checking se unko toh pakda gaya
Most informative video on Farm Bill across UA-cam. Keep up the good work! ❤💪
Priya, you are good, collecting so many important an Article and explaining nicely, appreciate may help you.
great video! it's so informative and unbiased. Please don't stop making amazing content
You pronounced so clearly and your way of teaching is so transparent. 👍
By listening this video we have to stand with our farmers..👍
🤷♂️🤷♂️
It would be better if you start farming
@@tejasvi18joshi ok then.. let's go, we start from you
@@pratidnyadeogade4986 I have have already been doing in my five acre land.
I don't use chemical fertilizers, lab seeds.
I do natural/ Vedic/ plural farming.
@@tejasvi18joshi nice job.. Now I also start 😊
very useful information thanks to u.
Till date I was confuse with the above matter but your video helped me lot to come out of these confusion....thanks alot mam...grt explanation