What are the FARM BILLS & Why are farmers protesting? (History & Concepts Explained)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 чер 2024
- Want to tell great stories?: communication.thethinkschool....
Want to Land your dream job?: linkedinmasterclass.thethinks...
Want to Make your Perfect Resume? : resumemasterclass.thethinksch...
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
What is the farm bill and how is it going to change the supply chain of agriculture?
Why are the farmers protesting?
What are the after-effects of this bill?
What is our role in making sure that it benefits our farmers and does not backfire in anyways?
Also, all the 3 Bills explained with examples
Farmers’ Produce Trade & Commerce (Promotion & Facilitation) Act, 2020
2) Farmers (Empowerment & Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance & Farm Services Act, 2020
3) The Essential Commodities (AMENDMENT) Act, 2020.
Think School's Social Media Handles:
Instagram: / thethinkschool
Telegram: t.me/joinchat/TU5_1xwF-Nl30XL...
#thethinkschool #thinkschool #think #communication
Excellent video. Two points: 1. Contract farming could still be exploitive as the farmer bears the risk of reduced production and yet selling at lower than market price. During surplus production, 'quality' clause is loophole that could be exploited by the buyers to avoid buying all the produce the farmer makes. 2. The lack of legal validity of MSP was supposed to be counterbalanced by a govt buyer, the Food Corporation of India which is assured to be outside Cartals because it is not a private entity. The concept of Govt owned corporation to break monopolies or cartels is used in some countries eg France and is anathema in others eg USA. India belonged to former group with companies like BSNL, FCI, AI etc existing to prevent monopoly and cartelization. The current govt seems ideologically inclined towards dismantling this model.
I think you are totally wrong in the objectives of of PSU like BSNL and FCI.
For this you have to look into the five year economic plants under which these companies were formed. The only objective was to to capitalise the existing resources in areas where no private investments were earlier possible. But in later stages all of these public sector units became proving grounds for heavy corruption.
Let me tell you very clearly that no amount of MSP is going to guarantee any economic growth for the industry or for the nation.
I buy wheat for my family consumption at a price of nearly 10 times the market price. Because the wheat I buy is 100% natural in European terms the standard is organic double plus. I would not even give the MSP for chemically grown produce.
@@harshjain2728 1. msp is not for retail price. It is wholesale price for agricultural commodities without processing. 2. Many PSUs indeed owe their origin to an era where they were reserved for govt sector. But this has to with the fact that foreign investment would have been required in some form and liberalization was possible only when our exports were healthy enough. Agreed that state enterprises are vulnerable to corruption and sloth but corporate like accountability is a cure. Private enterprises are vulnerable to greed and competition is a cure. Prospective cartelization is in consideration here.
@Tenton - what you have written is the half truth. BSNL for eg: are Cartals themselves. The way they float tenders and outsource tasks with vested interests is itself a glaring example. Also my relatives work in high posts at BSNL. These Cartals are mostly "communist" unions that prevent any kind of innovation or growth. If you linger around BSNL offices and watch what they do to get a task done, you will understand.
6 months passed and this is still the best explanation of the bills and regulations required. More people need to watch thiss!!
Thank you so much :)
I watched it today!!
Amazing explanation
True
So trueeee
And i swear I haven't seen such a beautiful face😅
Attitude ,eye contact, hand movement, face expression
Communication level 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000
Bad pronounciation!
This channel should be designated as a mandatory curriculum in academia, so that every student knows in detail information on what's happening across World 😀
These bills passed for corporatisations eventually leading to monopolize the market n burning out consumers budget 😢
@@qsinteresting681 as in, the present govt is forcing blockchain agriculture. Do a research on this.
@@byavarsi if govt doesn’t then y should i 😂😉
@@qsinteresting681 Because blockchain is the future. Soon or later it will be in every field and it has potential to replace professionals like chartered accountants too.
I agree totally
Why the hell, this video is so underrated, it should be viral at the time of farmer protest!
viral hojayega to propoganda kaise chalega ...being honest.
@@aryansingh59 right
... English
I wish Our Media was atleast half as informative as You sir 😔....... You really explained this in manner that doesn't provoke any community ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thank you so much :)
Worth the half an hour summary. Media clutter kills clarity. Amazing flow of explanation with so many legal terms simplified...❤ oversimplified😉
Thank youuu!
you surely watch wion😅
Watching after scraping of bill,
Before I thought privatization is gud. But now after watching it, need some terms and conditions of every bill. Well explained bhai ❤️.
Now I'm gonna explain this detail to every person in the world who is getting into discussion with me anytime anywhere, Like I'm genius 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
I just binge watched all your videos.
Madness!!!
Thank you so much :) means alot bro ❤️
@@ThinkSchool Thank Jio🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Same here 😂😂😂😂
Doing the same thing today.! He is a Gem 💎
Me too
I was in search for such person for long time. Who would look at things as they are and present them as they are. I was just sick of pro government media houses and pro anti-government media houses. Thanks a lot bro.
The OLA story is so interesting that i forgot the topic itself
I was disappointed when he went to the topic 😂
Totally agreed what an explanation ❤️❤️
But the reality is they are not protesting for MSP . They want to scrap the all three laws fully . So farmers don’t get freedom to sell anywhere else 🙏🏻
This is the best explanation for the so-called "CORPORATISATION" that the media and others were worried about. I have watched N number of discussions on this but it was never as clear to me before. Yes, the govt truly needs to keep a close watch and regulate the market accordingly.
Amazing work done Think School
The Corporatisation will happen automatically with bill or without bill , without bill the Farmers will be at loosing end. they will not get the real income that they are supposed to get.
Absolutely correct.
@@ACE-hg1os what are they getting now?
@@ACE-hg1os not if the government legalise the MSP and give them better MSP in future.
@@OkarinHououinKyouma MSP isn't removed so these corporates won't be able to exploit farmers.
These bills are a good step in the right direction, but a lot of work to do!
What’s soo right about those bills ??? Selling only to govt approved people??
@@raja6691 looks like you didn't watch the video
Yes they are but the problem is with these loopholes
@@HS-fv2nf So? People should protest against loopholes not the bill as whole..
Rakesh Dakait is partying in tents on borders..
@@elonramsay2406 hmm of course you don't ask anyone , you don't discuss and simply make a bill in mid of pandemic like covid and then you expect people not outraging....and yeah for your knowledge people in punjab protested and demanded for changes in these bills...but when no one was listening...then they marched Delhi with a demand of complete repeal.......
The demand right now to to repeal these laws make a committee having representative from every front that is from kissan union , government , agriculture scientists etc and then make a law which is accepted by everyone....
Bro you can't deny people from their demands we are in democracy
Democracy is
By the people
For the people
Of the people......
This is the most insightful and balance presentation on the implications of the bills. Instead of agreeing to include the exploitation preventive regulations you mentioned, the bills were simply withdrawn. The farmers are back to square one. The farmers always bear the brunt - in India and most parts of the world. This has been historically been the case for most part of human civilisation.
The best channel so far for unbiased explanations along with absolutely flawless communication with minimal cuts. Hats off. Keep up the good work.
Zomato and Swiggy have become Ola and Uber in the restaurant industry.
These 3 bills + guaranteed govt handholding will be amazing. 🙏
Thanks for video. 👍
Surprisingly farmers are not right to aproach courts, in case of any default by contractor corporate. Decision of a SDM was decided as final verdict. And u know our beurocrats.
@@amarjitbhullar yes. Govt did take give farmers the power to go the courts 'in written' afterwards I think. But yes, I agree on the bureaucracy part
@@amarjitbhullar 🤦♂️ everyone has right to go to court. And read new change done in legislation
@@harshjain3122 bro let alone SDM level bureaucracy tell me how much top tier judiciary is trustworthy all these sounds fine on paper but on the ground its as hard as touching nose with the tongue
@@amarjitbhullar lol. Atleast there will be many bureaucrats empathizing with poor farmers but farmer cartels think that it would be wise to fight case against a big corporate with 100 top most lawyers!!!
I bet you haven't gone for a single hearing in any court ever. Cases drag on for years and entirely depend on how good and well connected your lawyer is.
Now enjoy farmers fighting cases against corporations.
But the government is not ending the MSP system. The opposition is lying to the media ,thus creating a sense of fear among the farmers. Btw loved your video , finally I can understand the whole thing .
Hey Sumona .... Yes the government is not ending the MSP system BUT as has been pointed out in the video, it is not a legal mandate even today and it is applicable only to APMC market not to the private markets that will be established....
Now, what if the farm laws proceed as they are today without a legal mandate of MSP-
The corporates will initially offer good rates above MSP to farmers, thereby slowly moving the business from APMC to Private markets.
Slowly and steadily, the APMC will loose business and might go defunct because note that no matter how much they try, being a government suported organisation it can never compete with a corporate.
As APMC fade away from the market so will the MSP, as it is only applicable to APMC and even there is just a mere guideline, not a legal mandate.
Classic example of this is what happened to BSNL after entry of Jio in market. Bsnl is almost on the verge of collapse. It has lost so much business.
APMC might meet a similar fate.
Hope this helped.
PS : I am not against the farm laws but we must have a long term vision
It doesn't need anything to end msp. Just do not buy and it will end then loot.
@@siddharth7651 Bsnl is still coping up every other company collapsed when jio entered
@@sanjeevbalyansb do u work at bsnl or have a stake in it?
Most simplest and unbiased explanation about the farm bills.
By far this is the most informative and clear explanation I've seen about this topic. This skill of yours is pure talent. Please keep educating people about such various topics, us youths are lucky to have people like you pushing out quality content of utmost importance for free.
Ps: I suggest you should ask viewers to support you through Patreon or YT membership so that you don't fall into YT algorithm's trap. I've seen some talented creators going out of their skillet and cutting down on quality to grow channel faster.
Thanks alot bro. ❤️ This means alot :) Will definitely think over it :)
Well said!
@@ThinkSchool
Bottom line is : a country cannot be industrial power house with 60% of its population living on the farm land and continue feudal way of life, productivity per capita in our country is dismal.
Adam Smith was right, free markets works, ola and Uber is not a problem as long as new players are allowed to get into the marketplace, and contrary to popular belief Uber still hasn't been able to post profit on a consistent basis they are still burning through a lot of cash to stay alive , it's very difficult to build a monopolistic moath around service industry in which anybody with a little bit of technical know-how and little bit of capital can start competing established players eroding their profit margins.
I have never seen any UA-camr or news channel anchor explaining with such a ease without any bias.
I am from a farming family and I can say it , this video is by the most clear and impartial one.
Can you simply say if these reforms are good or bad?
Genuinely asking, Do you support bill?
What I get from this video is, everything can go right only if the rules are written rather than just be a guideline.
Think school rocks.💯
at last i got a clear understanding of the bills ,i really like this kind of deep analysis...
♥️♥️
After 9-10 months of the protest being started, I listened to several people on internet and this is by far the most amazing explaination to Farm bills I ever listened/watched. Also I came across this channel a week ago and I must admit the content here is superb. More power to you!
My mind started hurting when gov agreed upon all of their requirements, some of which were nonsensical, but farmers said that they don't want nee farmers laws at all.
I think more politics is also involved here. The unions who has shares in apmc along with punjab gov will lose crores of rupees due to this. That's why they want the monopoly of apmc to stay.
Have you used Burnol ?
They are not just fighting for MSP but scraping all the 3 farm acts. This is making situation more complicated as government can't step back.
Hit the nail on the head. Thats the problem. Thry dont want to talk about it. They just want KAALE KANOON WAPAS LO
Bunch of opposition stooges Disguised as farmers terrorising people, state and blocking roads for political gains through anti-state kisan-virodhi politics.
They have to take back next time bjp will definitely loose in Punjab and Haryana
@@rohitmittal8196 lol😂 BJP has na ke barabar presence in Punjab. Its just between akali, aap and congress
Because govt. Has taken their part from all these tycoons lol as promisery to have them ideal situations to grow their business irrespective of the taking farmers &common man interests into the consideration..
We are either against or with the bill but not discussing how to keep the balance within the bill. Glad that you have explained it very well 👍🏻
You were awesome. Best of luck to you and your channel. Literally no nonsense video from start to end.
10 months after the video, Adani offered mere 17rs per kilo in the place of 63rs before farm bills owing to low quality. Quality of the crops depend on climate as well.
Awesome Detailed Video. Thank u
You should have a prime time show! Best explanation of the bills so far
Thank you so much :)
He still didn't dig deep enough, some of his statement in this video was so theoretical & vague just like any expert who has no background to the ground situation & have less exposure to the agriculture sector in india, would do ,,so not blaming him but theres much more to that.his verdict was tip of an iceberg but surely 10, times better concluded than conventional media does..
@@vipan1231 specify please. What exactly was abstract according to you
@@ashutoshpadhi2782 these fanatic Sikhs wanna see him blame modi they aren't up for a factual debate you could visit any punjabi news channels and see their comments they are like a dead cult praising one another
@@sanskargupta7615 i have no idea about these issues and even not willing to put my time to understand. I am glad you took your time to reply. Thank you 😊
I can't describe the hesitation i have in watching 30 min of video on the same topic for which i already have watched tons of.videos.....
But .....after watching 5 minutes...i got immersed into the video and...glad that I'm now informed and aware citizen...
Plzz keep it up bhaiya...♥️♥️
Thank you so much bro ❤️
Watching at 1.75x is the hack!😅
Its been a long time since a UA-cam video made me forget how much time passed. 32 minutes just whizzed past. No fancy video production, no frills, no bells and whistles. Just 32 minutes of solid fact based discourse. I loved it. Will share this channel so that your subscriber count increases manifold. All the best to you mate.
I am addicted to this channel for many reasons : To know facts, to understand case studies, learn to think & wonder how to be excellent in communication skills ❤️❤️❤️
A great Eye-Opener! all the three bills are explained in simple terms. Keep opening more eyes
Thanks bro :)❤️
Explained very succinctly. I agree with the assessment that these bills need to be tweaked; particularly in view of the experience of the American farming communities who have not only faced the adverse issues of corporatisation of agriculture, but also tremendous harassment and exploitation from companies selling farm equipment.
In India, most of what is passed off as journalism, like everything else, is essentially armchair journalism and/or ajenda driven propaganda masquerading as journalism; bereft of independent research and fact checking...and hence the utter substandard reportage.
In this context, your analysis is original and refreshing. I also agree that the federal government seems to have been wrongly advised to adopt a very obstinate and head strong approach to the problem. In a democracy, the government require to resolve issues expeditiously without allowing the problem to fester indefinitely and be exploited by vested interests. Hopefully, saner counsel prevail...
Really endorse each and every word of urs.
😂 the vegetable stuff is crazy, we stopped going to mandi, now going to AC showroom to buy vegetables 😭 this is irreversible. Oh god you explained Ola Uber and vegetables the best ever way possible.
Your more frequent uploads have made this my go to channel for news with a splash of entertainment at the start.. Keep it up!!! A lot has changed and that's on everything but the truth is I don't even care much about bullish or bearish market anymore because Bryan Anderson got me covered as I am comfortably making 13.1B T C monthly......
I have heard a lot about this guy on so many channels here on UA-cam, some call him the crypto messiah! could he be the new wolf on crypto street.....
Bryan taught me to utilize the volatility of the Crypto world, I make gain from trading despite the price chart
I remember when I started trading 3years back, my former colleagues were in doubt. Now they still work and I make big buck trading everyday
Too good. Nobody would have explained it so beautifully. Thank you
Thank you so much Lakshmi :)
Well explained but Which farmer has wearhouse ? It's middleman who stockpiles, farmers need imidiate money to sowing for next season and 85% farmers are small and marginal.
True bro. That little part is applicable to those top 6% farmers only
@@ThinkSchool and that 6% sometimes become the middleman themself as they are financially powerful hence have buying power and social power in that comunity consisting small farmers.
@@adityaprakashverma963 One reason is that govt. also wants to push those 94% farmers out of farming business and move to some other industry.
@@avinatoora 1 reason for what?
@@adityaprakashverma963 For farm bills. Lucrative only to people with sufficient capital and land.
We need cheap labor force in manufacturing sector but disguised unemployment in agriculture sector consumes too much human capital.
Brother your explanation is the most unbiased on youtube , but you must also give the information about MSP , how much it costs the taxpayer and what percentage of the entire gdp will be consumed by only MSP if it is made legal . Hope you see this message and educate your audience with most unbiased reports as you do . Thanks for this explanation.
When you spend on your luxury then it does not cost GDP? When you buy ashirwad ata at Rs. 37 to Rs. 40 per kg. It cost you not the government. And these companies force to farmer to sell their product at low cost. A farmer sell at 15 to 16 Rs. Per kg. And companies sell at around 37 to 40 Rs. Per kg and eat the farmer profit. If farmer will get 20 to 22 rs. Per kg of their wheat then how it will going to hurt GDP? You can spend lakh of rupees on your luxury but can not spend money on your basic needs. What a hypocrisy? And if you do not know about farming then keep away from this topics.
@@free_hindu_temple_from_gov4776 which pesticide come with subsidy tell to farmers. Government distribute FCI food to poor and FCi is symbol of government miss management, why FCI can not work like private company. And how you relating FCI with subsidy ? Who pardon telecom taxes from Vodafone idea, airtel? And this loan is much more than farmer loan and if government will provide MSP to farmers then this loan waive off will not require. Do not follow blindly anyone. Use your mind. Farmer comes from primary sector but do not get even their crop price while primary sector allied service earning billion of dollar. Have you ever think about it. Do not use political language. If your uncle would be farmer then you do not write like this. I challange you on these farm bill and on farmer issues. Do some research and come with facts, and if you do not have facts then do not dare to write like this.
@@prashantbalyan First of all you are no one to tell me what can I write and what I can't . Second whenever I go to my village I have seen people ( farmer ) getting fertilizer and seeds sold them at subsidized rate , if you are not getting that's your problem . Third don't give bogus argument like why this or that can't work like private , no government company can works like private company , every single government company is loss making and is burden on taxpayer bcoz private companies work on merit and incentive model whereas government runs on seniority model and that is why privatization is important , that is what government is doing , making the market more efficient . Fourth you don't know me or my family so don't use your labeling tactic with me .
@@free_hindu_temples_from_go7324 you are do not know anything about farming. I asked you, tell me pesticide name or place where it's available on subsidies rate, but you are not able to provide. Second I asked what is the logic of FCI with subsidy. Third how MSP will burdon on GDP? Fourth income tax is not the only tax in india, and farmer also pay tax in GST form, whenever they buy some thing. ONGC, Hindustan Petroleum, Bharat Petroleum and all navratan Maharatan companies making profit but Modi government want to sell each and every company even after making profit. Almost all government Bank making profit. You are talking on baseless logic and even you do not have proper proof to prove your logics.
If you have guts give me proper reply, what I have asked? Else people are free to talk nonsense.
@@prashantbalyan HDFC market cap 8.5 lakh crore , SBI( Largest Bank ) market cap 3.5 lakh crore , if these are your facts , God should save you .
Acharya Chankya rightly said " If you debate with a fool , they will drag you down to their level " . And that is why I'm ending this discussion from my side here and now .
If people from all across the country could just get to see your content, then no matter who shouts in their ears people will always wait for your words on anything!
A true and sharp point of view on things
Man....you just nailed it..
You are more informative than our economics teacher 🔥🔥
This was bloody BRILLIANT. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you ❤️
Thank you for thinking about the farmers and portraying their side in the correct way
Unbiased, simple explaination, real issues, satisfying answer to the issue ♥️🔥 Need to binge watch this channel and someone please make this man an official mediator between Farmers and Govt 💫
The best video on youtube to understand farm bills and farmer protest all together... 👌🏻
Beautiful, since long I was waiting for this beautiful. Going to share it with my friends and family but 2/3 things you have smartly ignored. 1 Govt tax. On farmers and middleman. 2. Employment created by Pvt players. 3. Formalising the farm/agriculture economy. These are huge factors. That’s why I support this Farm bill.
You support tax system on farmers
@@JEET_GAMING07 you don’t? India is diverse. We have eastern part 15ppl depend on small amount of land and rich western farmers. We need some tax to justify both.
@@TuhenduDasmail2tonnie than what is deference in British and indian govt and bro I really think your illiterate about things faced by farmers so keep your knowledge within your limits🙏
@@TuhenduDasmail2tonnie and what if due to bad weather he dint grown a single peice of grain from were do farmer will pay tax ?
@:-O bro there is no proper inspection and on the name of subsidies they give 100rs check me myself had been involved in such process and witness these situations 🙏
I have watched so many videos on this, but by far, this is the best explanation for all three farm bills. Kudos!
The most accurate and detailed analysis I've watched so far on this issue! You're amazing.
Have watched many explainers and read many articles and I know what this exactly is but the way you explained is just awesome. Cheers to Think School, Ganesh Sir and everyone who are behind the video has just put in a lot of great efforts.
Thank You so much.
The best youtube video on this topic.
Unbelievable, the level of research done!
AMAZING EXPLANATION, earlier I used to think the government is doing wrong but now its crystal clear.
Brilliant, what in-depth analysis.
The OLA equivalent example was too good.
Overall problem is people are not Honest
And Monopoly honi nhi chahiye
high prices can be controlled by competition in Market
When there are firms who can sink money in for years, they will eventually kill all competition because the competitor cant afford to have those losses. For eg. The vendors will run out of business in a few days if jio mart starts selling vegetables at half the price !
They will never get honest bcz these monopolies are business people ,what they understands is profit and it's the govt's responsibility to keeps up the balance between these things ...thats why we have mandis ....mandi system in itself is a regulatory entity in india ....and shutting it down will create more problems ....or the problems we had in the past ....In my view what govt could have done is have more transparent storage system ....that's the simplest solution to agriculture ....but corporate have links with the govt so 😂
@Shashi Yadav like they stopped jio. now we have to pay for even incoming calls. enjoy
@@cnhtol1586 ..... major chunk chargeable for incoming international calls .... for Domestic ones, usually gets adjusted from the minutes included in the plan you bought .... its meager, doesn't make much difference ....
@@rohitchandran1381 point is you need to "buy" that plan in order to receive calls. For example. Jio and airtel minimum monthly plan is +120 INR. If you don't then you won't receive calls.
Poor people can't afford that every month just to receive calls!?.
There is different cost for SMS. You can't send or receive SMS on plans below 100 for airtel. Practices like these are the result of so called market competition. Just because net packs are cheaper for middle class that doesn't mean calling plans are cheaper too. I know many people who just bought simple phone and left it as it is for incoming calls only.
Everyday I am watching a video of yours, I am Loving it. What efforts you put, it's amazing.
absolutely epic vid!! I am lowkey freaking out after learning the deep and dark mechanics of these MNCs. but I fail to understand why the government is so hesitant on imposing the MSP rule when it clearly seems to be the best choice...
One of the most beautiful video I have seen. You just didn't explain the problems and provided the solution but even incorporated examples of Ola and explained them also. Kudos to you. 👍
I don't know why ur channel is most underrated.I will share with others as much as I can.Dont lose your hope!
Thank you so much :)
Kyoki ye channel bika hua nahi he...
Pure gold he ye channel..
Too good. Worth watching. Explanation Simplified! Thank you for your efforts.
Thanks man, you've offered an easy to understand explanation of the whole issue. I really needed to know this 👍
This is such a good video man!! Really appreciate the work and research that has gone into this. Keep up the work 🙏
Well done! Finally, someone with sense!
This is an excellent explanation with regards to this issue!! Great Work Think School!!
One of the best, unbiased and balanced take on these 3 bills! Watched a few of your other clips too which are extremely well presented. Way too go and all the best!
One of the most unbiased video I watched on farm bill
Stunningly impressive. Keep doing the great job. Wish you huge success!
Well informed, wish our media channels were like these!
Such a complex issue made so understandable. We need much more channels like you to make india a better place. Creating awareness and simplicity both at the same time. A difficult skill yet a much needed one, thank you loads of support and love from us viewers❤️
This the reason I love your videos bro. Points are upto the point of who don't have knowledge in the those specific area. The one channel help on improving knowledge.. 👏
You really made it crystal clear! Need more people like you in this country where the young generation with a rational mind is afraid to have a political opinion because we don't know whom to trust! No one here in the mainstream media is willing to give such a simple compilation of all the necessary details honestly! I personally would hate to build an opinion and choose sides in politics without knowing all the facts beforehand and you sir have given me the facts today. Hope you thrive and find alot of success with this wonderful UA-cam channel of yours, your contributions will be lauded by the genuine rational thinker of India!
I discovered your channel very recently from 'Zomato- Gold mine'. And here I'm binge watching all of your videos. Even shared them to a couple of friends. Good going man !! All the best .
Also thanks for sharing information in such a beautiful and simple way !!
Same thing goes with me toooo
Bro your channel is PURE GOLD mann!!
How did I miss this guy for so long... I'm seriously surprised and shocked at the same time
So perfectly explained. Thanks. The politics I've been exposed to has taught me a tip to aid fight against any social exploitations. Promotion of education and promotion of participative politics among common citizens which together empower bargaining power of everyone in spite of which strata of society someone is. It's easily said than done as fighting any injustice is an team sport that we need to practice sitting with real persons having different opinions. Which organization or party you select to practice it doesn't matter as long as the group is neutral to gender, race, creed etc and you are ready to question even the organization you r part of to practice fight against injustice. It's just an opinion out of my learnings and very well debatable.
This is most awesome video on the farm bills tht I have watched... Supperb .
Thank you so much ❤️
Great content. Just started watching your videos. Great job in breaking down topics in such a simple manner. Thanks!
after 6 months i finally found a detailed yet simple explanation.......Hope this video goes viral somehow.
This is such a complex topic and you explained it so easily! 👌
You have explained it very nicely and your video shows the amount of effort that you have put in the making of this video. Good job and thank you for the detailed information 👍
Thank you so much Shriya :)
Amazing. This is by far the best explanation I have got for Farmer's Bill (and one of the few videos that I watched without skipping anything). Thank you Think School guy for making this video. Keep it up.
this is the best video I've watched so far on the topic! Just an amazing explanation! Keep up the great work :)
This was worth of my time.best video on this topic i have watched.good job.wish you get what you deserve 😊.
Thank you :)
The simplest explanation I came across..with just the right examples.
Thank you :)
It's good to come here after a year and listen to your opinions. I am also glad people forced the government to change their bill. Democracy and belief prevailed..
Lavde ka democracy. It was really really great bill and were prevailed by middleman.
Hats off to the best ever detailed information and explanations about the farm bill and amendments, felt really good, thanks once again
By far the best explanation I have seen on the farmer's protest.👏👏
Few points that can still be thought of
1) Even though the corporates can have contracts with farmers but at the same time, farmers have the choice to either sell it to the company or to market as per their profitability.
2) In the case of Ola or uber the product used in the transaction is expensive to possess i.e. a car. But in the case of food items, it is difficult to do that as the products are cheap and it is relatively easy for the farmer to go and sell partial goods in Retail Market. Retailers will also adapt to new challenges.
3) A factor we always forget is that corporates may want to buy products but at the same time lot of digital markets are increasing which can give farmers ample opportunity to sell them in the market throughout India in one click.
4) I think we are also underestimating the intelligence of farmers even they can form a cartel. In many developing cities, many farmers become builders and exploited the buyers. Or another example could be they hoard onions during election season😅
5) lastly the good amount of money the farmer will get (even in the initial days)can be used by the farmer to build secondary income like cattle farming, poultry or a processing plant etc. Or educating their children which will then create a new breed of highly educated farmers. 🤟🤟
Overall the main pain is for the middlemen who used to get a massive commission without any effort. Keeping this in mind then we should look at the farmer's protest.
The only con which I can see is - Farmers generally rotate the crops to keep the soil fertile. but if the price for a certain crop is lucrative then farmers may repeatedly go for the same crop which can damage the soil in long run.
In ur 2nd point you mentioned that the product used is expensive in Ola and cheap in the farmers market.
The inflation of prices of household goods and grocery , vegetable etc. all skyrocketed in many states, the farmers were in tatters that lead to the suicides of many in the southern states and in the northern section as well. All of these incidents spurred from the initial stages of the COVID situation and gradually worsened the condition of markets affecting small scale traders and as a result the farmers as well. This was echoed all around especially the goods and trading, manufacturing industry, or secondary institutions in the industry.
This was a situation that was happening in parallel with the creation and passing of these laws.
That is among the chief reasons for the farmers solidarity in this issue. This side coupled with the privatization of government sectors and their alleged monopolies also spurred their belief in that aspect.
The Jio telecom service is a fine example of this strategy in its Irreversible phase now in the present context of its growth, plans with the same price are offered with less validity duration, the price of data charges increased etc. The data rates prices became higher because they offered up many of it for very minimal and at time free of charge in its initial phase.
This is the wide scenario that is seen in India ryt now. That is also a blaring sign as to why the farmers have every right to contest these decisions.
Just my view in the general perspective
Also the con you mentioned can also be termed as a pro, because of digitalization as u urself pointed out.
Let's take the same example of Starbucks, they have a wide range of customers now with different tastes as compared to when they started out. As these evolve now using AI they are able to discern their customers taste and so as not to stay stagnated, produce new blends and styles in their ecosystem, this may come from a variety of beans. Crop rotation is an effective method in which the soil is suitable as such for the farmers to grow it, these companies have a sizeable amount of R&D teams to do their research for them. They could help these farmers properly make use of government subsidies in fertilizers and such to regulate the overuse of a singular crop.
This is the main reason that digitalization, privatisation, foreign investments of major companies like Google, Amazon ( was in an investigation recently), helped boost clothing brands, electronics, jewellery, cars etc. in the Indian Marketplace. This could lead to the government's success as well if implemented well.
Because the current trend of major players excluding maybe a few like Tata and so on, in India owing to the current wave of privatisation the competition among players are limited to just 1 or 2. This is what he meant by loophole in my reflection of this video.
bro u have explained it in detailed i have watched it completely i read in news paper they are also saying same. so nice of u. keep it up.
Hats off to you man!!!!
May the teachers of commerce side be like you!!!!
2nd bill is for everybody not only for farmers, middlemen are the final beneficiary of this bill, because farmers don't have that much storage facilities but the middlemen have.
Middlemen = Government
What a Great effort! Hats off to you!
Amazing bro, your explanation, examples, articulation, clarity is amazing.. keep up the good work, you are going to reach great heights!!! God bless you and your team!
Thank you so much 💖💖
This is undoubtedly the best and thorough explanation of the farm bill till date. Thanks a lot Ganesh sir. You made it so simple with past references and described all the loopholes in the process.👌
Knowledge is always more than the money. Im glad i came across this page. Well explained buddy. A big shout out for explaining difficult things so briefly without having any biased thoughts.
Thank you so much for the information 💯
There is another loophole with msp ( my thoughts, plz enlighten if otherwise) msp is to encourage farmers to grow specific crops that otherwise are not so lucrative. If msp is enforced will it not stop the farmers to try new crops and be in the loop of ensured msp crops. We were importers of wheat and paddy and now we are growing them in excess. Probably it's high time to give msp on pulses and oil seeds instead. ( Or similar crops which come under basic needs and are imported)
Msp is input cost+ reasonable(not lucrative) margin. It was adviced by father of green revolution himself. Also these laws does not provide access to courts (right to justice). Then the conflict managent is limited to SDM rank officer only. And you know our beaurocrats. And access to store unlimited crop output will give right to corporate to overprice or create shortage in market. For eg. Adani agro want to dominate in four staple eatbles namely; wheet, rice, edible oil and pulses. If they are able to control these, then can u imagine plight of consumers?
@@amarjitbhullar but government agreed on having an option to go to court
@@amarjitbhullar there can be no monopoly, farmers will sell to whoever offers more money, if there is a monopoly of a single company and they decide not to pay reasonable price, other private companies will enter. It is pretty simple. why shouldn't farmers be allowed to sell their own produce to anyone they want. the so called Aadat system of Punjab is shameful. Modi government has made it clear that MSP will no longer go to middlemen but directly to farmers in their bank accounts. It is funny that Congress & Akalis are against it. The reason that the permission to store crops and produce has been given is due to the fact that in last 5 years more than 38000 Metric Tonnes of produce just was rotted in FCI godowns. the prices are effected, government can anytime remove a certain crop from the the list of produce allowed to be stored. it is not something permanent. so this is just a lame excuse.
Contract farming too is not new, sugarcane farming is an example for that, In the end no one is forcing anyone to sell it to anyone, if a farmer want to go to AMPC, they will, the one who offers more money will take the produce. Punjabis should stop shielding APMCs
@@yoyohoney1270 no such amendement is made in laws.
@@sumbajumba3037 its APMC system of Punjab nd Haryana, where state govt levies taxes from buyer to develop rural infrastructure, thats why rural roads nd village connectivity in these states is far better than other Indian states, so APMC s contribute positively to whole society.
But ur talk abt building sillos is again favouring few favourites, how can adani agro build storage sillos before these laws were passed through parliament, its clearly shows that that company is favourite of politicians, you tell me any other company which constructed setup of that scale and provided with train connectivity too????
And I again reiterate that MSP must be given as law abiding values, as adviced by MS Swaminathan (father of green revolution in India). I am not agri expert, but I know following experts recommendations are always fruitful.
As far as corporate purchase competition is talked about, these laws are already there is Bihar from 2006, and still no such touted benefit is delivered to Bihar state nd its farmers. Thats a failed pilot from one state, and still you want that to be pushed to whole nation.
Since I started using UA-cam , I have watched numerous videos regarding different topics but I can say this is the best explanation ever ever ever ever on a topic which is most important🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
What i understood from your analysis is no matter how strict we make rules, there are always loopholes where an individual can always exploit