Farm Bills 2020 Explained - Are All 3 Agriculture Bills Anti Farmers? StudyIQ IAS

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 777

  • @StudyIQEducationLtd
    @StudyIQEducationLtd  4 роки тому +329

    Clear UPSC with StudyIQ’s Courses :- studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/c3EOEpiCCk
    Call Us for UPSC Counselling- 76-4000-3000
    UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I September Pratigya+ Morning Batch :
    studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/c3EOEpiCCk
    UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I September Pratigya+ Morning Hindi Batch : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/em8MODUdnZ
    UPSC IAS Long Term P2I Foundation LIVE 2026 Pratigya+ Morning Batch : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/4ekxQyFxsI
    UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/9ahtTDzlmA
    UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I September Pratigya+ Morning English Batch : studyiq.u9ilnk.me/d/zWqYhPqDge

  • @trumpamerica9444
    @trumpamerica9444 4 роки тому +2791

    में एक किसान हूं, आपने निष्पक्ष जानकारी दी है इसके लिए आपको दिल से धन्यवाद ।

  • @harshrajchoudhary4009
    @harshrajchoudhary4009 4 роки тому +5363

    The farmer is the only man in our economy who buys everything at retail, sells everything at wholesale, and pays the freight both ways.
    - John F Kennedy

  • @rzzvtravelblogs7496
    @rzzvtravelblogs7496 4 роки тому +3838

    I am not an IAS aspirant. But, I was desperately waiting to know study iq point of view. There is too much noise on social and mainstream media. Everyone is biased. Thank God we have the unbiased view available now

  • @sushmasingh9432
    @sushmasingh9432 4 роки тому +9

    खान सर आपको बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद। मैं किसान नहीं हूं लेकिन जितनी बारीकी से आपने हर पक्ष को उजागर किया वह किसानों के प्रति आपकी संवेदनशीलता का परिचायक है। आपकी हर बात सच्ची है। मुझे इस विधेयक के बारे में कुछ भी नहीं मालूम था लेकिन मुझे आपके बोलने का अंदाज इतना अच्छा लगता है कि मैं जब तक आप के वीडियोस देखती रहती हूँ। इतनी महत्वपूर्ण जानकारी देने के लिए बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद। आशा करती हूं कि देश का किसान जीतेगा।

  • @AwadhwasiNEERAJ
    @AwadhwasiNEERAJ 4 роки тому +1598

    Siddhant sir ने काफ़ी confuse कर दिया था इस कानून को लेकर but आपने clear कर दिया.....thank u sir

  • @PoojaVerma-mc3lh
    @PoojaVerma-mc3lh 4 роки тому +4450

    जो खाये महीपाल आटा, वो करदे doubts को टाटा.... 😅😅😅

  • @ajitauchare6957
    @ajitauchare6957 4 роки тому +104

    Study IQ without Mahipal sir is like food without Salt. You are the best educator ever I have seen.

  • @BalwinderSingh-bz3dv
    @BalwinderSingh-bz3dv 4 роки тому +615

    Best video ever 👌🏻... --- *A SON OF FARMER FROM PUNJAB* ❤️

  • @alokkumarnyati
    @alokkumarnyati 4 роки тому +677

    Govt should impose a line in bill that whether FCI, APMC or pvt companies... Anyone who is buying crop from farmers is can't buy at a price lower than MSP.

  • @virendersingh8166
    @virendersingh8166 4 роки тому +83

    Sir you are the voice of millions of poor farmers. Thanks a lot.

  • @paul.pranjal
    @paul.pranjal 4 роки тому +834

    I too had the same example in mind of BSNL AND JIO

  • @dynamic.explorer
    @dynamic.explorer 4 роки тому +3795

    पडोस वाली आंटी: तुझे तो सब ज्ञान हें बेटा, किस चक्की का आटा खाते हो?
    मी: "महिपाल आटा"
    😏🤣

  • @binitapanda6927
    @binitapanda6927 4 роки тому +390

    Fav faculty from Study iq... To the point explanation. Perfect clarity

  • @Himanshu7564
    @Himanshu7564 4 роки тому +1752

    BSNL's performance went down because it was restricted by not allowing to offer latest services read 3G and 4G (Spectrum was not provided) but no one talks about it.

    • @adityabakshi5492
      @adityabakshi5492 4 роки тому +342

      How many people used BSNL post Tata docomo's 1p/sec scheme came into existence?

  • @meghabiswas1967
    @meghabiswas1967 4 роки тому +394

    I still use bsnl because in Andaman only bsnl network is available except 1-2 islands...

  • @samantaarijit
    @samantaarijit 4 роки тому +625

    Mahipal ata . Sir rocks 😂😂.
    Sir explained the best. Ye channel agar india k 50% log bhi dekhe to bohot jagruk ho jayenge indian public .

  • @theroadhittervlogs
    @theroadhittervlogs 4 роки тому +49

    Maine abhi tak 3-4 videos dekhi thi iss topic pe, lekin ab jaake saari baat samjh mai aayi. Thank you sir ji🙏🏼

  • @DS-oh1kd
    @DS-oh1kd 4 роки тому +1844

    Kash ..... Indian media ye sachai....logo ko dikhati

  • @Vaibhavpanwar20
    @Vaibhavpanwar20 4 роки тому +745

    The example of sugar cane private factories.... Even though the MSP is there but, sugar cane farmers are at the marsy of private factories in terms of payment of their crop... payment can be delayed upto 8 to 9 month and sugar cane take 1 year in field... So indirectly farmers receive the fruits of their hardwork in 21 months... After that much waiting, that fruit also becomes rotten… because the farmer has so much debt that the money goes to repay the debts of the banks...
    I am the son of a farmer… and we have received payment till now till January 7...We have to sell our crop to the bajaj factory… It is very bad situation, please make a video on this subject sir.
    🙏🙏🙏

  • @nitish2018
    @nitish2018 4 роки тому +172

    बहुत बेसब्री से इंतजार था इस मुद्दे पर आपके वीडियो का ।।😊😊

  • @shivendrapatel443
    @shivendrapatel443 4 роки тому +31

    I was searching for such video since it all started. And you articulated it very well without any bias.
    I am pretty sure there is no video or article on the internet which makes all the things so clear.
    Bcz most of the people who are explaining this matter are biased and have no idea about the real situations of farmers.
    You considered almost everything.
    I salute to you sir.. Especially for this video

  • @soldier3514
    @soldier3514 4 роки тому +55

    I heard a lot of lecture but i didn't
    Understand
    It is first time i know form bill
    Thanks sir

  • @sunilmishra1736
    @sunilmishra1736 4 роки тому +275

    Sir you are the voice of millions of students and poor farmer

  • @ravalvarun610
    @ravalvarun610 4 роки тому +17

    I am son of farmer .. its really helpful bill for us ... ek ek step pe positive negative hogi ... focus only positive... middle man ka corruption hadd par tha ... yeah jaruri tha ... bahut acha hua .... MsP to sirf name ka hi hai ... everything depend on quality .. quality pe paisa milega..

  • @saurabhkumargupta5579
    @saurabhkumargupta5579 4 роки тому +173

    Get ready for privatization and also capitalization
    And Jio is the best example for you. See her plans from beginning

  • @rahulpatil42434
    @rahulpatil42434 4 роки тому +49

    Finally i found the Best explanation for these Farm Bills problems. 👍🏽

  • @virendersingh8166
    @virendersingh8166 4 роки тому +39

    Unbiased lecture. Thanks sir. Wonderful video.

  • @pratiksha3693
    @pratiksha3693 4 роки тому +280

    Nobody else could've explained this topic better!

  • @sunesarakunal3508
    @sunesarakunal3508 4 роки тому +1541

    मेरी राय में बिल पर सुधार की आवश्यकता है.
    निजी हाथों में यह सब देना खतरनाक हो शकता है

  • @chamansoni1216
    @chamansoni1216 4 роки тому +38

    I have seen many videos on these bills, including dhyeyaias channel, agnihotri sir on Study IQ, but these lectures hardly stuck to my mind. This is the video that i wanted to be from very beginning. Thanks alot sir for explaining such a confusing lecture in so simple way. Whole heartedly gratitude to you.

  • @binitapanda6927
    @binitapanda6927 4 роки тому +1836

    Where were you, sir... Missed you

  • @Shubham0514
    @Shubham0514 4 роки тому +301

    Only 5-6% farmer sell grains at MSP price.

  • @unofficialtalks3027
    @unofficialtalks3027 4 роки тому +370

    Hello sir, I am from harayana. Agree with your explanation. Farmers are literally crying. ye bill ek sword ki tarah h. Like jab tak cover me h to acha h when it will be applicable for farmers it will impact even a normal human being.

  • @brocklesnar1605
    @brocklesnar1605 4 роки тому +89

    *Watched a lot many videos to understand these bills..But this was truly the best and feasible to understand among all.*
    *Thanks Mahipal Sir 🙏🙏*

  • @nikhilpatel6852
    @nikhilpatel6852 4 роки тому +257

    After a long time sir, it's good to see you again.
    Sir it's a sincere request please make at least one video on a daily basis.

  • @surajdeepsingh9014
    @surajdeepsingh9014 4 роки тому +137

    Farmer bill need improvement in it.
    Sir I agree with you,
    About 70% population of our country is working in it.
    Surely Farm bill need to review in farvour of Indian farmers.
    Thanks

  • @philip7288
    @philip7288 4 роки тому +26

    I fumbled on this video somehow..... Good I watched.... It was well researched, clearly explained in lucid manner for a lay man to understand.... Very well done...superb!! Already a fan now.....

  • @mukeshshaw359
    @mukeshshaw359 4 роки тому +56

    Private airlines was introduced, it resulted in better service and cheap price.
    Same method will apply in agriculture also. Vested interests are fear mongering of corporate takeover of agricultural produce.
    Healthy competition is always good

  • @Jaymahakalbabaki
    @Jaymahakalbabaki 4 роки тому +145

    *...Success is no accident. It is hard work, perseverance, learning, studying, sacrifice and most of all, love of what you are doing or learning to do...,,,.*

  • @saswatmishra3536
    @saswatmishra3536 4 роки тому +229

    MSP should be made compulsory even in private contract.......if pvt companies want to have the products directly from farmer they can bid higher than MSP

  • @digitaleyes9973
    @digitaleyes9973 4 роки тому +26

    Good Analysis.
    Apmc me pahle 6 percent farmers fayda uthate the.
    Ab 94 percent farmer fayda uthayenge.....apni marzi se sell krke.
    I know PRIVATE companies may do monopoly (as u said examples Jio) but they will increase competition and healthy environment for farmers ( as Jio did). Farmers will start taking its benefit by cultivating many crops rather than Rice and wheat and sell them in market.

  • @maneshshinde4932
    @maneshshinde4932 4 роки тому +19

    Beautifully covered sir... examples given are nice...hope the things will go as per scenario A..
    Bhavato sabba mangalam...
    May the rule of King Bali start again....Bali-Rajache rajy yevo🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @RAHULSHARMA-xo6iv
    @RAHULSHARMA-xo6iv 4 роки тому +30

    Aap education system me vardan h sir hmare liye... Thanks for explain

  • @avidali4960
    @avidali4960 4 роки тому +26

    Really amazing explanation . I'm seeing this news till gov announce ordinance but could not understand what is fact behind the game . Now all aspect have been cleared। Thanks sir

  • @TheForce07
    @TheForce07 4 роки тому +5

    किसी भी channels पर समझ नहीं आता जब तक study iq ना देखे , धन्यवाद् सर

  • @pinkydeka9358
    @pinkydeka9358 4 роки тому +12

    Wonderful lecture Sir..jab aap samjhate ho tab sabse jyada samaj aati hai. thank u so much Sir

  • @sonjitahmed4103
    @sonjitahmed4103 4 роки тому +6

    FARM BILLS 2020 pe study iq mae 2-3 video aa chuka hae sir , par kuch samajh nehi aa raha tha...thank u sir...apne asani se samjha diya..

  • @abhishekjain7685
    @abhishekjain7685 4 роки тому +2

    Bahot acchi line boli aapne ki middleman hat nhi skte chahe private ho ya govt ka ho.

  • @aqeebiqbal3764
    @aqeebiqbal3764 4 роки тому +63

    15:00 Sabse jyada cinta ka vishay

  • @laalbuildingzindabad7713
    @laalbuildingzindabad7713 4 роки тому +259

    Jai Jawan , Jai Kisan
    My Grandfather is a Farmer
    My Uncle is a soldier

  • @snehaphadte4573
    @snehaphadte4573 4 роки тому +96

    And the King of study iq is back....sir plz make atleast one video every day🙏

  • @kingbhopali9253
    @kingbhopali9253 4 роки тому +96

    Excellent mahipal sir. I understood only one face before this video. Now everything is crystal clear. #digitalsofthub

  • @rishabhnigam7320
    @rishabhnigam7320 4 роки тому +57

    Private contracts will eventually bring a competitor and farmers will have a choice to whom he wants to sell and to whom not. If you are not getting MSP in the private contract you can go for APMC's

  • @manish_mishraa
    @manish_mishraa 4 роки тому +73

    finally lecture from mahipal sir.

  • @kpcricketer6614
    @kpcricketer6614 4 роки тому +40

    If govt really wants to improve the condition of farmers then why not it increase the price of msp and make it a legal right

  • @kushalwani4336
    @kushalwani4336 4 роки тому +245

    Not a Bhakt,but BSNL was already finished by congress before JIO came.

  • @tkrath8348
    @tkrath8348 4 роки тому +4

    Haven’t found any video which is so concise, crisp and clear with case study.
    Thank you Mahipal Sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @Darkyagami07
    @Darkyagami07 4 роки тому +255

    There is a solution to scenario b tho,if the govt sees that farmers begun to get less price in the long term ,govt and just make a simple adjustment and and make msp for private market too.

    • @mirirfan1318
      @mirirfan1318 4 роки тому +81

      There will be a time in future when govt will have no control over Capitalists and govt will be on the mercy of their choice....

  • @ravis5613
    @ravis5613 4 роки тому +335

    ना कचरा,ना भाटा,आज ही लाओ "महिपाल आटा"😜😜😜
    वाकई में मजा आ गया हुकुम ।
    👍👌👌

  • @anandnandudkar1419
    @anandnandudkar1419 4 роки тому +2

    one of the finest teacher. ek bar me hi sab kuch samajha aajata hai.eye sach me mujhe bohot diff. lag raha tha ...

  • @jaydippaul5295
    @jaydippaul5295 4 роки тому +33

    Crystal Clear.
    Thank you, Sir.

  • @meghashukla7323
    @meghashukla7323 4 роки тому +64

    Thanks for making everything clear.

  • @sankum11
    @sankum11 4 роки тому +79

    BSNL was never upto the expectations! Service and their behaviour were very poor! So private players took advantage

  • @pravesh5013
    @pravesh5013 4 роки тому +14

    Farmers need to accept the fact that privatisation is the only thing which can make farmers Prosper in the long run, how inefficient the bureaucracy is can be seen from the fact that since past 50 years just farming has not led to anh good for the farmers..

  • @maithlijha4400
    @maithlijha4400 4 роки тому +56

    Finally interviews are over and vedioes are started thank you sir🙏

  • @vandanamalik3196
    @vandanamalik3196 4 роки тому +10

    Sir i want to add one more point here...... On papers these bill are like a long pending reforms but the ground reality (mainly i am talking about small farmers) is that farmers have mainly two time income in a year. Somewhere it is three too but mainly they got money twice a year. But expenditure is not limited to twice a year. There are school fees every month, they also have to buy ration, medical expenses, on festival times, marriage n many more. These farmers are dependent on middleman (aadhtis) for money throughout the year. For sure private companies will not lend money to farmers in advance if farmer has any unforeseen situation like if a farmer need money very urgently his or her family member is hospitalized ( god forbid), here aadhtis help them although they charge rates higher but atleast farmer got money at that specific time. This is how the life of small n marginal farmers actually is.

  • @shehbazdhillon6672
    @shehbazdhillon6672 4 роки тому +163

    If gov first implement M S Swaminathan report's recommendation...then these acts will surely serve the agriculture sector

  • @mukeshsharma-hp6nz
    @mukeshsharma-hp6nz 4 роки тому +73

    Conclusion is..m.s.p should be compulsory for all transection.. otherwise private company will be monopoly and act like. English east india company...and now Indian ministers are already like pupet... nawabs under the hands of corporates.

  • @mysterious_soul1997
    @mysterious_soul1997 4 роки тому +193

    I think govt should modified the bill properly. It have so many loop holes.

  • @Niks-sg4ig
    @Niks-sg4ig 4 роки тому +124

    In future this bill not only affect farmers but middle class and lower class people also......then only private companies will have power to decide the prize

  • @unknown-us5vs
    @unknown-us5vs 4 роки тому +128

    I think scenario B as it’s more common in india, And everyone knows corporates rule politics.May be it will beneficial to some ,But maybe it will be life ending to some,MSP should be there compulsory.

  • @sanjeevmishra7717
    @sanjeevmishra7717 4 роки тому +5

    Jio or bsnl...wah sir wah...kya example diye h aise sateek example aap hi de skte hain. thank you🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @ambienceclasses2076
    @ambienceclasses2076 4 роки тому +5

    First of all, thanks for this clear information. Sir, kahi na kahi ham achhe se jante hai ki es bill ke aane se aage chalkr kisano ko10% hi fayda k chance hai, 90% sure hai es bill se kisano ka shoshan hi hoga, private company ke marketing ka ye fanda hi hai ki ve hamesha " max benefits" hi chahti hai, agar thoda bhi chance hai anaj ko1700 me kharidne ka to kishan unke kaon se sage - smbandhi hai jo ve 2200 denge, sarkar ki to majburi hoti hai kyuki use "vote" lena hota hai.
    Kisano ka ho n ho, Modi ji ka private companies se kafi gahara nata hài,tabhi to sb kuchh dan me dete ja rhe hai rhe hai.

  • @worldvschinachuje3751
    @worldvschinachuje3751 4 роки тому +284

    Government should make illigal for private players to buy farm products for less than MSP.

  • @rishabhsharma585
    @rishabhsharma585 4 роки тому +47

    18:37 he says ye dono separate example hai.
    Inside him: hoga to yahi isme bhi...

  • @alokbarman550
    @alokbarman550 4 роки тому +4

    Gehu Price in West Bengal at local market approx 1700/ quintal...... Sir you clarify everything... Thank you

  • @Sadashiv_bhau
    @Sadashiv_bhau 4 роки тому +80

    So conclusion is to destroy govt Mandis and promote corporate players in agriculture marketting sick govt, why don't they appoint adani as PM

  • @ronakparmar20
    @ronakparmar20 4 роки тому +4

    Kaan Taras gaye the yeh aavaj sunne ko sir..😭..... really I Miss you sir 🙏

  • @adarsh00
    @adarsh00 2 роки тому +2

    I think government should understand the situation
    The word perfection never exist

  • @anjalipanwar9349
    @anjalipanwar9349 4 роки тому +9

    Sir middleman emergency me kisaan ko money bhi provide krata h
    Interest pr deta h vo alag baat h
    But agr adati (middleman )nahi hoga to kisaan emergency me kiske paas jayega
    Kheti me har time paise ki jarurat hoti h
    Chhote kisaan ke paas itna paisa nahi hota ki vo sara kharch apne paas se kre
    Agr kisaan apmc me apni crop sale krta h to middleman uske paise ka guaranter hota h, private mandi me uske sath fraud ho skta h
    Ground reality me ye bill kisaan ki income ko or kam kr skte h

  • @lipsamalik6077
    @lipsamalik6077 4 роки тому +181

    Jai Jawan jai kisan❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @kundanverma4359
    @kundanverma4359 4 роки тому +279

    पसीना बन के बदन से लहू निकलता है। जमीन और मुकद्दर की एक है फितरत कि जो भी बोया है वही हूबहू निकलता है।' Zimidar Life 🌾💪🚜

  • @MrDNair-nn4dd
    @MrDNair-nn4dd 4 роки тому +62

    Now i understand y there was a lot of opposition from the farmers... And i support their view...

  • @HOLLOWMIND432
    @HOLLOWMIND432 4 роки тому +205

    Thank you sir i was having lot of confusion on this topic.

  • @TheBeast_is_here
    @TheBeast_is_here 4 роки тому +15

    Thank u sir fr ur explanation!!!! Aab bohud kom आते है आजकल!!!!

  • @ayanmandal3099
    @ayanmandal3099 4 роки тому +431

    Farmers ko agar really help karna cahtahe sarkar Toh Government ko fertilizer, pesticides ke cost low karne ko kaho,,,,Main Kissan family se hoon pera pitaji Kissan haa🙇

  • @NajoomiJi
    @NajoomiJi 4 роки тому +17

    कृषि कानून से संबंधित सिर्फ़ पांच प्रश्न :
    1) बिल की ड्राफ्टिंग कमेटी के सदस्य कौन थे ?
    2) कॉरपोरेट और किसान के विवाद की दशा में न्यायालय जाने पर प्रतिबंध क्यों ?
    3) MSP पर ख़रीद की गारंटी बिल में क्यों नहीं?
    4) कॉरपोरेट को फसले (Essential Commodities) स्टोक करने के इजाज़त क्यों दी ?
    5) एग्रीकल्चर स्टेट सब्जेक्ट है फिर भी इस पर केंद्र सरकार ने कानून कियो पास किए।
    ये पांच सवाल किसान आंदोलन के हर उस विरोधी से...
    #WeStandWithFarmers
    #kisanektazindabaad
    #KisanAndolan
    #किसान

  • @Anand2010ist
    @Anand2010ist 4 роки тому +48

    Thank god, finally a video from your channel which raises Farmers concern. Thank You Sir

  • @brijwheels3258
    @brijwheels3258 4 роки тому +18

    Happy to see you again making video instead of interviews

  • @mukeshjoshi1567
    @mukeshjoshi1567 4 роки тому +9

    The only video that cleared my all doubts regarding farmer's bill 😇😇 tysm sir

  • @bhupendrakumarkashyap9389
    @bhupendrakumarkashyap9389 4 роки тому +92

    Aap jo examples diye ho wahi hoga future me kisano ke sath ...msp private company m bhi follow hona chahiye....

  • @dhirendrapalsingh33
    @dhirendrapalsingh33 4 роки тому +1

    Really sir.. Very nicely explained... Ab mujhe samajh aaya why farmers are Protesting.

  • @savikumari4703
    @savikumari4703 4 роки тому +47

    Private company never think about the customer . They always think profit but in gov. Think about both . Like jio company first give everything free thn all Indian allure for it nd now prices going up nd in the future again it will up . U will use the net ,call or not it doesn't matter for the company . Company matters always profit. In this case indirectly loss of customer . So in a same way farmers get loss in the future .

  • @SonuSandhu88
    @SonuSandhu88 4 роки тому +3

    Study iq k jitne b vedio aye es topic pe usme se sabse bdia vedio..thoda practical experience lgta hai sir ko kheti ka

  • @diwakaryadav2536
    @diwakaryadav2536 4 роки тому +33

    I am telling on my opinion that all these is happening because of jio mart to give more benefit ambani with these bill he will directly entered in farming sector and he will earn more profit in these sector

  • @brucewayne2224
    @brucewayne2224 4 роки тому +49

    Sir. This bill also says. You can't go to court to solve the matter. Please mention that too.

  • @viveklal2327
    @viveklal2327 4 роки тому +14

    Thanks to youtube and study iq ..
    Bcoz tv media continuesly just praising this bill ..like dna 😂

  • @Faraaz_Ahmed99
    @Faraaz_Ahmed99 4 роки тому +4

    Sir u r the best.. expalined in so beautifull way.. jo jo logically khi clear nhi hua pross and cons ye video pe clear hua. Thanks God bless u..

  • @HemantKumar-lv2iy
    @HemantKumar-lv2iy 4 роки тому +6

    Very well explained. जय श्री राम 🙏