Muslim who fled Russia on his new life in Ukraine
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лис 2024
- While Moscow spreads false propaganda narratives about an alleged rise of neo-Nazism in Ukraine, representatives of predominantly non-Christian national republics within Russia are subjected to systemic pressure from the government. Ali Charinskiy is an activist and professional martial artist from the Republic of Dagestan who advocated for the rights of Muslims in Russia and criticized Moscow’s aggression against other countries until Russian authorities opened a criminal case against him and threatened to kill his family.
The Kyiv Independent spent a day with Charinskiy in his new home, a southern Ukrainian city of Odesa, where he talked about his experience of being a Muslim in Ukraine and his fight against Russian imperialism.
Subscribe to our channel for more independent reporting from Ukraine.
Become a member of our community: kyivindependen...
Your support allows us to bring independent, locally sourced news about Ukraine to the world.
God Bless this man and Ukraine
God bless Ukraine 🇺🇦 🙏 ❤️
Thank you, Kiev Independent. Slava Ukraini. Dona nobis pacem. (God grant us peace.) 💖☮🙏💙💛
A very good and important story thanks to all the personal at Kiev independent for showing us how life in unkraine is
Thank you for sharing this with the rest of the world. x
Россия - тиранический режим.
Ano-klepto-plutocracy.. Pretends to be a democracy on the surface but isn't, elites steal from the people, and ruled by the wealthy
Не росія а московія бо раху Петро вигадав
More freedom than in The Russian Federation 😌
Thank you Kyiv Independent. Ukraine and Russia are not one monolith of culture. Important story to share. Freedom to be. ✨🇺🇦
Kyiv Independent is an oxymoron.
The video is absolutely false. There are millions of local Muslims living in Russia, plus millions of Muslim migrants coming. In many areas there are more of them than locals, they can be aggressive, It is about the same in Europe. Russia is fighting only Islamic extremism and terrorism.
@@zima2389чепуху не болтай. Для тебя все мусульмане экстремисты
Quite the opposite, Ukraine is only historical Russia on this planet and should not be mistaken with Muscovy. There is another common mistake in this video: the Muscovites are neither Slavs nor Russians..
@betterdonotanswer false manipulated propaganda. Kyiv is older city and cultural center than Moscow.
@@zima2389 = ignorant, shallow, fearful, hateful, bigoted and racist. Did I miss anything you sad little troll.
Good ppl are good ppl; everything else is window dressing.
A very insightful interview .Thank you!
In a world where anti-Muslim propaganda is growing fast (even where I live in Canada), his report of living freely in Ukraine is telling! I am an Agnostic Christian, but above all a Human Rights activist, so I want ordinary Muslims to live in peace without repression, intimidation, etc. Like many progressives, I don't like the Hijab, but I refuse to tell women what to wear or not wear; it is their choice (complicated I know, but I have to remain coherent and not reduce their freedom of choice).
Ма ша Аллах.
Кавказ будет свободным!
But islamist insead? Not convinced fundamentalism & patriarchy are freedom, either. =(
Thank you, interesting video!!!👍🏻💪🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇬🇧
Подтверждаю: у нас в Одессе очень много Кавказских народов, я никогда не слышала "хач" и "чурка". Люди разговаривают на своих родных кавказских языках на улице, в общественном транспорте - я никогда не слышала чтобы кто-то сделал замечание.
Я сдаю в аренду три квартиры в Одессе: никогда! Никогда даже в голову не приходило дать объявление " только славянам". И я не видела в одесских объявлениях таких надписей.
Вообще Одесса - это очень многонациональный город. Очень. И я - украинка, не чувствую себя там каким-то привилегированным коренным населением.
Мне бы очень хотелось, чтобы каждый, кто выбирает Одессу как город для жизни - чувствовал себя комфортно.
Спасибо вам большое. Победы Украине 🇺🇦 . дагестанец (даргинец) из Москвы РФ это тюрьма народов чем быстрее распадается тем будет лучше для всех
I'm worried about where I live. There is a push to Christianize the schools by requiring Bibles, posting the 10 Commandments, and teaching Creationism. 1a says "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion"
Freedom of religion for all people means the government stays out of people's personal lives and doesn't play favorites. This is how we live together in peace, in a fair and equal way. America has slipped back to 1930's and it's maddening.
Yes - but: This style of Islam is like your christian fundis, too. Sorry, religion is part of most peoples lives, and part of culture, but it needs to be modernized, and tamed if we really want human rights, equality, egality & a meaningful kind of freedom.
I know I sound awful, but Islam is no better than Christianity and can go wrong, too! (Same as Judaism, Hinduism..)
We need to debate religious doctrine again, not just accept it all, until it takes over schools & politics.
Отличное интервью, грамотно осветил проблему
Thank you for this report! it clearly shows who are the good ones and the bad ones in the current war.
Thank you for this video. The only thing that's missing from it in my opinion, considering the moment in history that the world is going through, is this man's opinion on the situation in the Middle East. I've had so many arguments - even before October 23 - with people who feel it's only possible to support either Ukraine or Palestine, and it's really important to overcome that, to keep voicing the simple truth that Palestinians and their supporters are not inevitably anti-Ukrainian, while Ukrainians and their supporters are not inevitably anti-Palestinian. Some of us are doing that but we need as many voices as possible.
@1midnightfish You’re so right. I support Ukraine and its right to its own identity, decision making and independence 🇫🇮❤🇺🇦
At the same time I do not accept Israel’s blind oppression of the Palestinians.
What I’m trying to say is that killing another person, other than in self-defence, is not acceptable under any circumstances. Things should be able to be resolved through discussion.
Well, I know it’s not so simple.
We must understand that the wars that are going on today go back a long way to history.
All that need now are civilized, wise leaders who would be willing and capable of submission and building peaceful societies 😌
@@PapilioArgiolusЭтот человек неоднократно озвучивал свое мнение по ситуации на ближнем востоке на своём канале Ali Charinsky. Вкратце скажу, что его мнение заключается в праве палестинцев защищаться от израильской агрессии, и также он сравнивает Израиль с Россией и считает их во многом похожими и оккупантами
@@kacak8262 Спасибо
I myself support justice and humanity, respect for other people, nations and cultures.
I’m unable to choose a side on the issue of Israel and Palestine, because I don’t know enough about their history.
But when it comes to Ukraine my opinion is completely clear.
As a Finn, I am downrigt obligated to support Ukraine
Слава Україні, навіки 🇫🇮❤️🇺🇦
@@kacak8262 Thank you, I had a strong feeling this may his position. I hope that in time (and not too much time!) channels like this one will start giving a platform to people who are not afraid to voice the parallels between the actions of russia and israel, and between the ideologies underpinning those actions.
However I have never felt entitled to judge the Ukrainian government for not making a statement in support of Palestine, because they simply can't afford to alienate the USA, which as we know has a strongly zionist lean. I even understood the initial solidarity of Ukrainians with israel straight after October 7, but I doubt that many Ukrainians can look at Gaza now, and not see Mariupol 😓
Yes! To me it's about fairness & pointing out injustice. Human rights are human rights, no matter if you are Ukrainian, Israeli or Palestinian.
Great story. thank you Kyiv Independent..bless this man 👍🙄
Born in Ukraine, lived whole life, couldn't notice Muslims from Ukrainians, felt like a part of community, with a little difference from average Ukrainians, but when i went to russia in 2000 they hated Muslims, not everyone, but generally, made jokes of them etc, when I went again in 2018, same stuff still there.
Yes - but with islamism it's not all good, either. Fundamentalist religions are all quite authoritarian & in the long run a danger to society. No, what Russia do is not right, but I see it a bit like how the Nazis oppressed the communists in Germany - that didn't make the communists & Stalinists great or harmless. =/
Thankyou for your video,God bless you and your family 💓🙏💓🙏🙏🙏 amen ❤️🥰 Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦🙏✌️✌️
Аьли уссуй Аллагьнал цlуллушиву дулуннав вингу, щаллагу зул кулпатран🤲🤲🤲. Аллагьнал зу буруччинав чув бикlарчангу🤲🤲🤲.
Амин Усей
Али Чаринский капитальный красавчик!
Достоин 🥇 достоин достоин
Truly!
🙏💙💛🙏
Please bring Syres Bolean on! He is Erzyan from Mordovia
It's very impressive
There is a typo at 1:57. Against not vagainst.
Очень интересно Дякую
This was in WW II the same
Odesa not far enough
سبحان الله
what he thinks about Palestinians and Izrael>>? why don't you ask that ///
Because he’s from Dagestan and now living in Ukraine. Neither have to do with Israel and Palestine. Do you ask every Christian Yankee about Ireland-UK because they’re both English-speaking Christians?
I like him, but sorry, neoconservative Islam is slavery of sorts, too. Only his children are shown, his wife is invisible? I'm fine with modern interpretations of religion & equality (proper equality!), not with patriarchy & authoriatrian interpretations of Islam, nor any other religion. God is a decent kind of entity, and culture needs to be reinterpreted with modern knowledge & information.
Извините но вы очень мало знаете про религию Ислам чтоб познать почувствовать на себе, надо узнать пророка Мухаммада ﷺ и его сподвижников тогда у вас всё станет на свои места и поймёте что женщина и жемчужина должны одинаково храниться ) как то так😅мир вам
@@ДоминикТоретто-к2я Oh, no, darling, that is EXACTLY what Islamists propagate, and it is wrong, outdated & awful. You sell slavery to girls by calling them "pearl"! this isn't even much of Islam, this is modern day fundamentalism, Islam used to be much more diverse , more spiritual & much less obsessed with controlling people. Today it is all rules, rules, rules, fake dogma & fundamentalism. I know Islam can be beautiful, but it needs to reform, not oppress people & dehumanize female persons!
😮го
Це лякає. В західній Європі ісламізація теж так починалась. До речі, він розмовляє арабською? Не схоже.
Ти божевільна. Ні щоб порадіти за людину яка втекла з росії в Україну та тепер політактивіст, ти будеш казати що воно тебе лякає коли одночасно ніяк і не впливає. Ніякої ісламізації країн західної Європи не існує, навпроти існує небезпечне збільшення ультраправого впливу, впливу партій та людей які використовують ісламофобію і расизм щоб розділяти та лякати людей. Остання твоя фраза не має взагалі жодного сенсу, але я не здивований що людина яка схвильована за таку глобальну "проблему" як ісламізація не вміє ясно виражати свою думку.
He is a Tartar, (edit: Tatar?) from Tatarstan in Russia. (It used to be a Khanate - and Crimea used to have lots of muslim Tatars, too.) There are Tatar Muslims in Poland, btw., that have their own kind of practicing the religion.
I agree with you, though, it's odd everybody here is applauding a fundamentalist kind of Islam. I'm against the oppression that happens in Russia, but I also see Islamism as a big danger!
@@lukandrate9866 No, that's not crazy. While this man is really nice, Islamism & global neofundamentalist rise of Islam is a big danger, too. In theearly 20th century, communists were oppressed in Germany. When Hitler came to power, he brutally suppressed socialists & communists. But that does not equal Stalinism being a benign force.
The world is quite complex, and all fundi religions are at some point dangerous to society. Be they christian, muslim, hindu, buddhist or jewish, or even sikh.
@@lolakauffmann freaking "tartar", give me a break, you can't even spell it right!
@@lukandrate9866 Who cares, so I spelled it like this food . I thought it was the same etymology somehow 😁 The content is still true, no matter if I spel it rite or rong!
L'absurdité la mensonge la propagande
C'est complicité 😮
You mean the islamism? Yes, that's odd. Not okay how Russia suppress them, but not great to pretend neoconservative Islam is a great idea, either..
When I was in Ukraine about 10 years ago, I noticed how few Ukrainian men were there and I noticed many Asians, Muslims and Africans. Wonder what the war has done for this trend?
Liar you have never been outside of russia- jellebrinkhuis4004 = russian troll. We've all seen your other anti Ukraine comments. Be gone propaganda troll.
Ukraine used to have many universities accepting paying overseas students, there were a lot of stories about international expat students who went home when the war broke out. And some poor Indian guys, who got stuck & were not treated very well. Many didn't have EU Visa, and had trouble getting out of the country - as they were not accepted as ukrainian refugees, either, in the beginning. (I guess it has been sorted out, since..)
8:43 Nobody see a problem there? At all?
Poor Muslims are so misunderstood.....LOL
This is Ukrainian propaganda
@@AbdulSoomro-kj5lt How about you go for a walk in Odessa, like he suggested? Are you open to the possibility that this may simply be the truth?
i’m catholic born in america. i love my musIim brothers and sisters. As well people of any other religions, ethnicity, nationality or race -as god commands.💛🙏
@@Dovelunaloveexcuse me, may I ask you one thing? If you are brother/sis of people whose religious belief deny God has a Son, who is your common father? (To be brethren means to have a common father).
(Asking this not in enmity to that muslim man to whom my solidarity against a false Christian country, Russia)
@@edoardo_roncelliAre we not all the children of Adam and Eve?
Если ты мусульманин, почему оскорбляешь всех русских ?
русские сами себя оскорбили, развязав захватническую войну
@ все русские свинья из-за этого?
Али типичный нацик, черт и провокатор. Такие как он сеят рознь и ненависть сидя в других странах. В Исламе нет нацизма.
.... at least he can quote the sharia in relative quiet...
Yeah of course 🤣🤣
I am a Muslim and I support Russia. I stand with Russia 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
Russia has colonized a lot of Muslim minorities like: Chechens,Dagestanis, Bashkirs, Tatars and so on. Russia is still oppressing a lot of Muslim minorities in Russia who want to break away from Russia. Have you ever heard of Chechen war? This man actually one of them by the way. In daily life Russians are also very racist and hateful toward Muslims and people of color. Poor fool
В чем правда росии в этой войне?
Glory to Emirates Islamic of Afghanistan 👌
Glory to Russia
РФ это тюрьма народов чем быстрее распадается тем будет лучше для всех
We will help Russia
Your God order you that do not be friend with the enemy of Islam
Glory to Russia 🇷🇺
MaşaAllahu ! MaşaAllahu Ali ! La kuvvete illa biLlah !
As-Salamu Aleykum va RahmatuLlahi Birader
Shame on you for lies
Glory to Emirates Islamic of Afghanistan 👌