WTF is TV on the Radio??

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 бер 2023
  • #tvontheradio #tvotr Fan-made documentary covering the Brooklyn-native experimental rock band TV on the Radio.
    Nine Types of Light Video Documentary:
    • TV On The Radio - Nine...
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 119

  • @142doddy
    @142doddy Рік тому +24

    Okay, this came on my homepage and I assumed it was going viral. Apparently it isn't. So I'm gonna write some shit I assume the creator is gonna read.
    So I thought I loved TV on the Radio. But I don't think I did. Or at least not at the same level Poster Shot does. I've talked them up to my friends, played their music at parties, but still I'm bereft.
    As a white boy from England, the experience of a black man from the USA isn't something I instinctively would register, so hearing this interpretation turned their early work into something very new for me which I appreciate immensely.
    And I only found them a little later when Wolf Like Me was used in a British TV show but it got me to listen to their back catalogue. But fuck me year after year do I hope they'll play at download festival.
    Thank you for making this and I've encouraged all my rock friends to watch it

    • @libby4419
      @libby4419 4 місяці тому

      I love them. Return to CM was when I heard them first. Always and forever TVOTR. ♥️

  • @pauly260
    @pauly260 Рік тому +36

    "Wolf Like Me" is a fantastic introduction to these guys.

  • @dianaparkss
    @dianaparkss 7 місяців тому +13

    TV on the Radio is a gift for anyone who discovers and embraces them. Thank you for highlighting their talent 🧡

  • @nickciluaga4158
    @nickciluaga4158 3 місяці тому +7

    I heard their EP young liars in a little juke box at our local bar/music venue. Blind was playing and I immediately knew this band was special. Usually if you hear something unique from a specific area, then usually there is a great scene building up. So then I went down this Brooklyn alternative rabbit hole, I found santigold and Apollo heights. I can’t seem to find the Apollo heights album online and I don’t even know if they even still play together. I still have their album on my old iPod it’s called everlasting gobstopper find the whole album and you will be in for a treat if you love TV on the radio like I do.

  • @WebbTech1
    @WebbTech1 4 місяці тому +6

    I am a "black alternative musician", to put it into perspective, and yes TVOR was and is impactful just on the merits of the music itself. I MET Tunde here in Atlanta when they performed at what was called The Echo Lounge...he simply came up to the bar after the show and we talked. It was awesome. It's weird for me that I haven't really followed them that much...my favorite songs are "Dreams" and "Staring At The Sun", but there are more. Thanks for this!

  • @txdave13
    @txdave13 2 місяці тому +3

    Thank you for bringing more attention to one of my favorite bands. I was in the gym, sometime in 2005 or so, when "Wolf Like Me" came on the in-house music video channel. I stopped everything just so I could figure out who these guys were. Still loving them almost 20 years later.

  • @yseson_
    @yseson_ 6 місяців тому +7

    I was working at a record store when Young Liars came out, one of the guys put on the cd and it was a revelation the arrangements and harmonies blew us away, we listened to it three times that day. Not back to back mind you there was a ton of the Strokes and Interpol that needed playing, but it altered something in us that day, it sounded like something special was happening. When three of my friends came to pick me up from work to play d&d one paused and looked at the poster and said that could be us. The awe in his voice sounded naieve and earnest in a way none us were comfortable with being. But we were three nerdy thriftstore attire wearing radiohead listening to nappy afro having black kids in art school, "that could be us" no one disagreed

  • @142doddy
    @142doddy Рік тому +7

    This fuckin deserves way more fuckin heat

  • @Musique61414
    @Musique61414 2 місяці тому +3

    Thanks for this. I've been wanting some kind TVOTR content for some time. But what I really want is more of their fantastic music. It's no surprise that Bowie loved them.

  • @DustinBowlin-ub1he
    @DustinBowlin-ub1he 3 місяці тому +4

    Young Liars has been my favorite song of all time since 03 and they better play it at my funeral.

    • @douglasstephens6693
      @douglasstephens6693 2 місяці тому +1

      The first time I heard Young Liars was live at one of their shows, and I couldn't believe I hadn't heard it ( I guess I wasn't that familiar with their back catalog at the time) , and it completely blew me away. Bought all their albums/eps the next day.

  • @mjadams002
    @mjadams002 9 місяців тому +6

    As a white dude from Austin I discovered Tv on the Radio from their live version of Dreams with Nine Inch Nails (2006) I knew they were something special. I checked out a few more tracks and kind of dropped off… until Seeds dropped. What a banger of an album front to back too to bottom Seeds is a master piece. Since then I’ve grabbed every album on vinyl, dug up digital versions of Ok Calculator, the single Wallz, and their collection of B-sides and covers. Love seeing a video that highlights how amazing this band truly is. Great job sir!

  • @GammaRaie
    @GammaRaie Місяць тому +2

    Yeah, I’m one of those dumbasses who just discovered them in 2021. I’m now even more blown away after watching this. I can’t wait to go watch the documentary! Thank you so much for the amazing content!

  • @jonsnow5907
    @jonsnow5907 2 місяці тому +2

    9 types of light is my absolute favorite album. It’s so good. We need more tv on the radio content!

  • @akapaf
    @akapaf Місяць тому +1

    Seen live in Rome in small clubs. One of the greatest band ever, live and on record. Always hoping for a reunion and new material!

  • @BELLAoBARTALK
    @BELLAoBARTALK 7 місяців тому +4

    My favorite band since 2005. First time I heard staring at the sun change my life.

  • @michalkorzeniewski9213
    @michalkorzeniewski9213 Місяць тому +1

    One of the most underrated and slept on bands. I saw them live at 2009 Bonnaroo and fell in love. Rip Gerard Smith.

  • @ianguy85
    @ianguy85 7 місяців тому +3

    “Young Liars” deserves a mention, and the live performance on David Letterman from his finale episodes is amazing and available on UA-cam

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  7 місяців тому +1

      "It's cold and it's quiet and cobblestone cold in here
      Fucking for fear of not wanting to fear again"
      Epic🫡

  • @RuinFierro
    @RuinFierro Рік тому +8

    The most unique american band of the 2000's

  • @WaseLannos
    @WaseLannos Рік тому +4

    Bravo!! Here's my ranking
    1. Dear Science
    2. Return to Cookie Mountain
    3. Seeds
    4. Desperate youth
    5. Nine types of Light

  • @LeonWash
    @LeonWash 7 місяців тому +6

    Amazing video you deserve so much more attention man❤

  • @8billiondoomed
    @8billiondoomed 4 місяці тому +2

    YES! FINALLY tvotr gets a whole video to themselves
    true geniuses. i really hope we’ll be blessed with another release soon.
    i always interpreted “the wrong way” as a police brutality scene. “teaching folks the score” (in my opinion) translates to a cop abusing his authority and taking advantage of systemic racism.
    kyp’s line in “crying” gives off vibes of: “money is the focal point of our culture, it leads to gluttony past the point of no return. we become dependent on wealth, and those who are wealthy, so we can’t make a name for ourselves.”

  • @jeremyashton55555
    @jeremyashton55555 Місяць тому +1

    I am glad I caught this. Loved it! I am always hoping for more from this glorious band.

  • @user-vr7xr8de6x
    @user-vr7xr8de6x 6 місяців тому +2

    i fell for this band when i first heard mercy, it's been 5 since then it became my favorite song and my favorite band, always praying for them to come and play in my country🙏🙏🙏 love the video i enjoyed it, thanks for making it !!! i learned more about them

  • @fechont
    @fechont Місяць тому +1

    Моё знакомство с этой замечательной группой с песни "Wolf Like Me", которую случайно нашёл в подборке с музыкой к фильмам "Fast and Furious" (не знаю как и почему). Вот уже как три года являюсь преданным фанатом. Признаться, я не силён в английском и пока еще плохо воспринимаю лирику на слух, но это значит, что мне предстоит еще много удивительных открытий, чему я очень рад.
    Мои любимые песни группы: "A Method", "Family Tree" и "Satellite"
    Очень долго искал контент с анализом группы и вот наконец-то нашёл. Огромное спасибо автору за видео и интерпретацию лирики. Мне было очень интересно смотреть и слушать.
    Иногда мне кажется, что о TV on the Radio знает неприлично мало людей.
    Надеюсь, что это видео увидит как можно больше людей.

  • @douglasstephens6693
    @douglasstephens6693 2 місяці тому +1

    I love TVotR and have since Cookie Mountain, and I'm surprised I only now came upon this video. I know all their music and lyrics but you taught me some stuff I didn't know about them. Great job!

  • @whatiswe
    @whatiswe 18 днів тому

    I dig it! Moments ago I got turned on to TV For The Radio by reading an interview in The Hollywood reporter with frontman Tunde Adebimpein. He's in the movie Twisters.

  • @a.b6396
    @a.b6396 2 місяці тому +2

    This was a great production and review!

  • @142doddy
    @142doddy 7 місяців тому +3

    Dude I'll be real, I've shown this to everyone who I can convince to sit in a room with me for long enough to hear it out, even my mates who don't like rock think this documentary is great, the same way Top Gear appeals to people who don't like cars, it's just really compelling, being a fan of the music only adds to what's already great

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  7 місяців тому

      It's definitely one I'm proud of... thanks for sharing!!!

  • @Maalstrom
    @Maalstrom Місяць тому

    Nines types of light grabbed me outta nowhere. Great stuff.

  • @WayaWolf
    @WayaWolf Місяць тому +2

    Satellite is hands down one of their most underrated songs…

  • @tundrabee119
    @tundrabee119 5 днів тому

    I caught up with the release of 9 Types of Light which absolutely was life-changing 10/10. My husband and I went on a road trip right after it's release and we had to listen to it three times a day or else we would go nuts😂 there was a wind turbine area on the highway in lower Minnesota where the music went with the beat of passing the wind turbines and power lines for miles. Unforgettable imagery. They became one of my favorite bands of all time and I await any new music because everything I've heard of theirs is amazing. My repetition is this!

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  5 днів тому

      I love hearing personal stories regarding one's connection to a project and how it heightens my perspective... NTOL didn't hit me like it did for you but that insight is why this video exists... thanks for sharing

  • @TomasHradckyComposer
    @TomasHradckyComposer 16 днів тому

    Great work. Much appreciated. Love these guys. There’s not enough out there on them so thank you.

  • @MrFox32993
    @MrFox32993 Місяць тому

    TVOTR is one of the most nostalgic bands for me. It was so foundational to my taste in music and my ability to like things that were unpolished and raw. I still have a huge place in my heart for the band, and your perspective on what it meant to you was really interesting to hear. Thanks for making this video.
    I think CM is my favorite full album but there is something about desperate youth, and particularly the EP version of staring at the sun that made me have the strongest connection to them.
    While we’re on the subject: do any fans here know why there’s no streamable version of dry drunk Emperor anywhere?

  • @toddcarignan1529
    @toddcarignan1529 2 місяці тому

    I found them through the Wolf Like Me video as well. I agree with most of what you have said. I didn't know about the solo projects, though. That gives me more to look forward to. Thanks!

  • @vanessathurlow68
    @vanessathurlow68 Місяць тому

    OK CALCULATOR MENTIONED!!!! as a huge TV on the Radio fan I am obsessed with this album

  • @psychokitty444
    @psychokitty444 4 місяці тому +1

    Me: (Hears the Satellite riff) Oh, this video's not going to play around.

  • @Artlas16
    @Artlas16 12 днів тому

    DLZ is what got me hooked, then made me love lots of their other songs!

  • @jayjaycow1
    @jayjaycow1 Місяць тому

    Finally a video on these guys (i am aware its over a year old)

  • @winterwonderland7445
    @winterwonderland7445 Рік тому +2

    Damn I wanted to make a video on them before seeing yours !! Very nice work I don’t think that I could make something better than that

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  Рік тому +1

      Wow... as thankful as I am for your compliment never doubt yourself... inaction is the only obstacle 🫡

  • @ericharper6454
    @ericharper6454 24 дні тому

    Finally!! Nice work love these guys

  • @dabigweav
    @dabigweav 3 місяці тому +1

    cant front man -- when u said u wasnt rocking w a method or let the devil in I sighed. lol
    deep cuts -- also super duper obscure and abstract.

    • @mediumvillain
      @mediumvillain 3 місяці тому

      A Method is one of my favorites off that record.

  • @142doddy
    @142doddy Рік тому +1

    This is brilliant, love these guys

  • @michaelhall4712
    @michaelhall4712 5 місяців тому +1

    Great documentary! I'm friends with Jaleel, I'll send him a link

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  5 місяців тому

      Thank you! This band deserves their flowers

  • @ff8ramirez
    @ff8ramirez 2 місяці тому

    Bowie presented TVOTR and Arcade Fire to me in 2005/ 06. So glad I paid attenrion. They're amazing!

  • @johnschlaefflin2100
    @johnschlaefflin2100 5 місяців тому

    Thanks for such an in depth analysis of one of the all time greats that no one has ever heard of. I don’t remember my ah ha moment of discovery, must of heard them on the radio, or perhaps Letterman? I do remember getting the CD one afternoon, and that night turning my friends on Wolf Like Me, as we drove through downtown Portland OR, blasting the volume, with our heads hanging out the windows, watching for a literal full moon between the tops of the buildings, as we raced to another bar before closing! Lucky enough to see them live in of all places Salt Lake City. Still one of my all time favorite shows.

  • @Jp-kr1fj
    @Jp-kr1fj Рік тому +1

    Dope video my guy

  • @shyguy.654
    @shyguy.654 6 місяців тому +1

    Best songs by TV On The Radio:
    1 - DLZ
    2 - Wolf Like Me
    3 - Staring At The Sun
    4 - Love Dog
    5 - Test Pilot
    6 - Young Liars
    7 - Second Song
    8 - Trouble
    9 - Will Do
    10 - Happy Idiot
    11 - Careful You

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  6 місяців тому +1

      Killer list!!! I'd throw Satellite, Playhouses and some other cuts in there but not a bad list at all

    • @shyguy.654
      @shyguy.654 6 місяців тому

      @@POSTERSHOT I'll listen to those again, maybe I didn't give enough attention

  • @_OopsieDaisies
    @_OopsieDaisies 7 місяців тому

    the algo blessed me with this doc and man i'm pumped to listen to them all day now. wolf like me was big on the radio when i was in high school and was big into diy and k recs stuff so that single stood out as more than a banger from the nu-rock from ny (tho it is that too.) it was when i heard i was a lover was when i knew i was hooked. thanks for putting this out there for us and reigniting my love of these dudes :)

  • @TimesOfTheSines.official
    @TimesOfTheSines.official 8 місяців тому

    Thank for going thru some of their lyrics... When u really get your teeth into what is being said, sung & written down for us to find in their art. That's when the light shines in on ya like a metaphor... They are well wise to the ways of metaphysical understandings & knowledge. So are NIN & Radiohead too. I've learnt as much of it myself, by studying the work of these artists as well as pursuing study to it myself along the way.

  • @Johnny.Karlsson
    @Johnny.Karlsson 5 місяців тому

    It’s been almost 10 years since Seeds came out. I pray to god they release new music again soon.

  • @bl4980
    @bl4980 7 місяців тому

    Thank you for this!

  • @ryanthegreat805
    @ryanthegreat805 8 місяців тому +1

    TV on the Radio are boundless

  • @maddogOsrs
    @maddogOsrs 7 днів тому

    Their songs are bangers

  • @yseson_
    @yseson_ 6 місяців тому +1

    Great review BTW

  • @highspeedtarantado
    @highspeedtarantado Місяць тому

    love their song mercy got it from Krunkidile then following DLZ, Wolf like me, Happy Idiot, You, staring at the sun and Will do

  • @superintelligentapefromthe121
    @superintelligentapefromthe121 4 місяці тому

    Beautiful band. "I Was a Lover" is hard as hell.

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  4 місяці тому

      This an Halfway Home are neck and neck for sure!! Very strong album openers

  • @alt-hipster
    @alt-hipster 6 місяців тому

    Man it’s such an experience when you listen to the band. I discovered them on a playlist of a video game and I felt in love first listen. Their music has left me an imprint just of how unconventional they are. And back as younger guy who was just starting life, they inspired me to be just as unconventional. TOTR will always be that band for me! This vid just made me crave and appreciate the band even more!

  • @Ellesor2864
    @Ellesor2864 19 днів тому

    TV On The Radio were brilliant. They should have gotten more notoriety.

  • @vsmith6109
    @vsmith6109 6 місяців тому

    Tv on the Radio has an awesome vibe. Loved that they included Karen Gillian in one music video as a Doctor Who fan and their accapella cover of the pixies Mr. Grieves as a big Pixies fan.
    When I was struggling to quitting smoking at 35 I read that Gerard Smith died of lung cancer at 36. That he was found as a subway musician by Tundre. Its devestating knowing he lived a stressful life looking to cigarettes to keep away the stess and hunger likely. Then he was found to travel the world.
    People said that Gerard was a fan of everyone kinda like a quiet beatle chillness and everyone became of his when they heard him play. He had a young son and had a part in "the lottery".
    I would tell myself a story to quit smoking. I struggled with breathing and landed in the hospial twice. My dad had lung cancer. Gerard smith lost his life to cancer when his life was on path with purpose to his son and in his passion.
    Even as its hard and still holding on to smoking for habit to keep away the stress and hunger... I should make the choice now and follow through on quitting before the damage comes in soo deep that there is no turning back.

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  6 місяців тому

      Appreciate you sharing your story and providing some additional insight on Gerard Smith... we all have vices and I wish you success with conquering yours.. salute!

  • @mediumvillain
    @mediumvillain 3 місяці тому

    my question is WHEREtf is TVotR? Been missing these guys.
    They have an amazing catalog. Definitely do not skip their EPs, New Health Rock & Young Liars have incredible stuff. Their b-sides are typically great too (so album bonus tracks and singles like Province are worth hearing), and they even got some fantastic ppl for remixes like El-P, Jneiro Jarel, & Prefuse 73.
    I dont consider Nine Types of Light any kind of disappointment. I would pick songs out but it's pretty much good end to end; Keep Your Heart has particular relevance for me. I enjoy it a bit more than Seeds which felt like the more commercial record, but isnt bad by any means either. The discography at that stage feels like a pretty clear trajectory for a band that's been together awhile, getting older, settled into a comfortable groove and is getting a bit less experimental, which might be part of why they hit the brakes since they were typically a very freewheeling, genre-bending act and maybe werent feeling the spark?

  • @tedthevillain
    @tedthevillain 11 місяців тому

    I saw them for the first time in sxsw. I saw a bunch of black dudes wearing jerseys get on stage then absolutely blow me away with such a grippingly unique sound. They played ambulance and staring at the sun. To this day they are one of my favorite bands and that was one of my favorite live music experiences.

  • @Angel-bs1hm
    @Angel-bs1hm 5 місяців тому

    Great video.

  • @user-hu6sb2jt5w
    @user-hu6sb2jt5w 6 місяців тому +1

    "Hours" is an anagram of "Horus".

  • @dantrav1927
    @dantrav1927 Рік тому

    Wow fantastic video, only 358 views, sure hope it gets a lot more.

  • @tjcoledrumming5903
    @tjcoledrumming5903 9 місяців тому

    I 100% agree with your interpretation of The Wrong Way. And your input on the Magical Negro character trope was new to me but I do believe that seals the deal with what TVOTR wanted to say. (James Earl Jones’ characters in Field of Dreams AND Sandlot come to mind when thinking of the characters for me). I guess I always thought it talked about how black people are represented in Hollywood but I never knew there was a whole BOOK about this level of typecasting.
    It’s like a wake up moment, then a rationalization of values “I won’t cast pearls to swing, no I won’t march peacefully. No negro politician is stirring inside me…but an angry heartbeat”
    And yeah the whole tone is eerie and sinister, and the groove and whole feel of the songs sounds like fast marching of several pairs of feet.
    And the last line “your guns are pointed the wrong way” sounds like a call go action for people to come together and fight the powers up top, instead of looking sideways at your neighbors.

  • @parkercushingable
    @parkercushingable 4 місяці тому

    TVOTR never got it's due but I had them on repeat the second album. It just is so heavy and fun.

  • @Lyndanet
    @Lyndanet 6 місяців тому

    This is weird but I like it it’s random and hilarious

  • @TimesOfTheSines.official
    @TimesOfTheSines.official 8 місяців тому

    The masters of the metaphysical, are back & there magical & musical... There has been no other act as lyrically wise & musically artful as a fusion than tvotr imo.

  • @abangwu
    @abangwu 5 місяців тому

    Thank you.

  • @shyguy.654
    @shyguy.654 6 місяців тому

    very underrated channel, hope you succeed.

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  6 місяців тому +1

      Define success.... your comment means a lot to me.. thank you!

  • @maryannappiagyei4277
    @maryannappiagyei4277 5 місяців тому

    Favorite song by tv on radio
    1. Starting at the sun
    2. Dlz
    3. Wolf like me.
    4. Golden age
    5. Will do
    6. Caffeinated Consciousness

  • @danidotthemusicman
    @danidotthemusicman 9 місяців тому

    Nice video but as an OK Calculator super-fan, I’m pretty sure they hid CDs places and not tapes but I do know they sold OK Calculator CDs at their first tour

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  9 місяців тому +1

      You're correct! I mispoke... cheers

  • @johnytwotimes4072
    @johnytwotimes4072 8 місяців тому

    Your voice is a satellite spinning next to me❤

  • @spitre5456
    @spitre5456 4 дні тому

    ❤❤❤❤ TVOTR!!!!

  • @WolfVanTrack
    @WolfVanTrack 6 місяців тому

    Great video, the band really deserves more attention than they're given. I have a couple video playlists up on my youtube homepage for alternative and indie bands from around the world. You should give them a look, I'm pretty sure you'll find something you'll like.

  • @PearlHarbor138
    @PearlHarbor138 5 місяців тому

    absolutely

  • @samanthatumlin4981
    @samanthatumlin4981 4 місяці тому

    How he sings "on your TONGUE" in Playhouses sounds like someone/another artist and I cannot put my finger on it

  • @muzicman171
    @muzicman171 9 місяців тому

    God I miss this band

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  9 місяців тому

      They earned a shout out!!! Appreciate the support!!

  • @zzgun288hay5
    @zzgun288hay5 2 місяці тому

    Dare science, is a crime of passion....?

  • @Cityboy.84____________________
    @Cityboy.84____________________ Місяць тому

    I wanna give you your flowers

  • @rirkc
    @rirkc 3 місяці тому

    My dad, oh my dad. Racist, bigoted Mexican American. Yeah, I know. How can a Mexican American be a bigot, you may ask? Well, I was nine years old when I realized he was a bigot. You're not even a white man, I thought. He was a U'SAF Airman for all his life and I think he had something to prove. Anyway, I grew to understand race differences and embrace them. I discovered "black" music and I love it. My dad hated it. I didn't care. So, TV On The Radio simply fits in with my life, my love of music and I really didn't give a crap what my dad thought. Still, after all these years (I'm sixty five now}, I gravitate towards the music that moves my soul. And that's TV On The Radio.

  • @TheGlyde18
    @TheGlyde18 3 місяці тому

    WTF is TVOTR? The greatest band of their generation

  • @estebandiaz9123
    @estebandiaz9123 2 місяці тому

    Tv on the radio has been goated since inception

  • @AntonioGarmsci-cy5vt
    @AntonioGarmsci-cy5vt 2 місяці тому

    Just ordered "Dear Science", let's see.
    BTW, just turned 61.

  • @valkammeron8634
    @valkammeron8634 3 дні тому

    Yo are you on IG?

    • @POSTERSHOT
      @POSTERSHOT  3 дні тому +1

      It's obsolete.. I'm off grid... YT only

    • @valkammeron8634
      @valkammeron8634 3 дні тому

      @@POSTERSHOT Word! Asking because I wanted to follow you(I’m already subscribed) and send you my Album. We seem to have similar taste in music and I love how you covered one of my favorite bands In this video. These dudes showed I can do me no matter what.

  • @AntonioGarmsci-cy5vt
    @AntonioGarmsci-cy5vt 2 місяці тому

    Hey MF'er don't talk to me like that, I been enjoying shit like Seun Kuti!

  • @tjcoledrumming5903
    @tjcoledrumming5903 9 місяців тому

    I 100% agree with your interpretation of The Wrong Way. And your input on the Magical Negro character trope was new to me but I do believe that seals the deal with what TVOTR wanted to say. (James Earl Jones’ characters in Field of Dreams AND Sandlot come to mind when thinking of the characters for me). I guess I always thought it talked about how black people are represented in Hollywood but I never knew there was a whole BOOK about this level of typecasting.
    It’s like a wake up moment, then a rationalization of values “I won’t cast pearls to swing, no I won’t march peacefully. No negro politician is stirring inside me…but an angry heartbeat”
    And yeah the whole tone is eerie and sinister, and the groove and whole feel of the songs sounds like fast marching of several pairs of feet.
    And the last line “your guns are pointed the wrong way” sounds like a call to action for people to come together and fight the powers up top, instead of looking sideways at your neighbors.