Spirituality, Dhikr & Salafi vs Sufi Issues - Dr Shadee Elmasry

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 32

  • @AbdullahMikalRodriguez
    @AbdullahMikalRodriguez Рік тому +5

    The importance of Tassawuf at 7:52 and the issue of group dhikr at 11:18

  • @idolwrecker
    @idolwrecker Рік тому +2

    No matter what the differences are. WE ARE ONE UMMAH. ALLAH O AKBAR.

  • @joelfisher2433
    @joelfisher2433 8 років тому +25

    في عقد الأشعري وفقه مالك
    وفي طريقة الجنيد سالك
    In the Believe of Imam Asha'ary and the jurisdiction of Imam Malik and in the way of tasawuf of Imam Junaid

    • @falilusuleiman671
      @falilusuleiman671 8 років тому +3

      Joel Fisher I have seen ur sentences that you made in ibn ashar book

    • @Gog3453
      @Gog3453 7 років тому +1

      Joel Fisher alhamdullah I'm shaffiy , ashariy

    • @AliMadoobe
      @AliMadoobe 7 років тому +3

      Be a Muslim with good aqeeda.
      Wake up for Fajr prayers & pray other prayers on time, give sadaqa, look after the orphan.
      Don’t let Sufi, salafis or ikhwanis groups owned you.

    • @muhammadamirasyraf5728
      @muhammadamirasyraf5728 4 роки тому +1

      I am the makmum of imam abul hasan al asy'ari in creed, imam muhammad bin idris assyafi'ie in islamic jurisprudence, imam junayd al baghdadi and abu hamid al ghazali in tasawwuf. May God end our life with the right faith.

    • @hasinhasnat9225
      @hasinhasnat9225 3 роки тому +3

      This is written in "Murshid al Mu'in" of Sidi Ibn Ashi'r.

  • @sulemansyed4277
    @sulemansyed4277 3 місяці тому

    Great Ma sha Allah ❤

  • @worldp3ac3
    @worldp3ac3 7 років тому +12

    Dr. Elmasry is great mashallah

  • @HamzaKhan-jn2rf
    @HamzaKhan-jn2rf 4 роки тому

    Very well said mashallah. Much needed

  • @Tahawi12
    @Tahawi12 11 місяців тому

    where was this clip taken from, I am interested on the whole discussion

  • @talexander2842
    @talexander2842 8 років тому +8

    what is this fantastic talk? A podcast? someone hook me up!

    • @SafinaSociety
      @SafinaSociety 8 років тому +4

      Yes we have the Safina Society podcast on iTunes and SoundCloud.

    • @qamarunshadow
      @qamarunshadow 8 років тому +2

      This is not the Mad Mamluks podcast. This is the Safina Society Podcast.
      sspodcast.co

  • @soau
    @soau 3 роки тому

    jazakallahkhairah simply the best

  • @Mahmoodbanafe
    @Mahmoodbanafe 5 років тому +1

    22:00 he is talking about the John cena commercial

  • @pointdot09
    @pointdot09 5 років тому +7

    God I’ve been looking for something like this. Open, honest and upon Haq. Balanced approach. No crazy pseudo Sufi stuff nor the extremist pseudo Salafi slander and intolerance and ignorance.
    The one school I’ve found personally to be balanced is the Deoband school mashaAllaah great scholars defending the Sunnah.

    • @SKhan-kq9zz
      @SKhan-kq9zz 4 роки тому +2

      Deobandis are influenced by salafis

    • @mughal_r9374
      @mughal_r9374 3 роки тому +3

      Deobandism is wahaabi creed mixed in hanafi fiqh

  • @adms8169
    @adms8169 4 роки тому

    Among those was Imam, Hafiz, Taqi-ud-Din ‘Ali Ibn ‘Abd-il-Kafi as-Subki. In "ad-Durrat-ul-Mudiyyah", he said what means: Ibn Taymiyyah innovated the foul things in the Usul of belief and infringed the foundations of al-'Islam, after he was covering himself with following the Book (the Qur'an) and Sunnah, showing outwardly that he is a caller to truth and a guide to the Jannah. Consequently, he deviated from following the Book and Sunnah to innovation, and deviated from the Jama’ah of the Muslims [The Jama’ah is the Muslim group following the Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad, sall-Allahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, and his Sahabah

  • @ak52892
    @ak52892 4 роки тому +6

    Believe it or not, the deobandis in South Africa are so scared of bida, that they refrain from uttering the takbir in unison on the days of eid!!

  • @-Ahmed8592
    @-Ahmed8592 2 роки тому

    10:00

  • @TheMercifulAndJust
    @TheMercifulAndJust 7 років тому

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    *THE ABSOLUTE ONE & ONLY SINGLE MUST-EXISTENT BEING: ALLAH* WHO ORIGINATED CREATED AND ORGANIZED WAHYYED HIS KALAM & WAHYY TO US ONTO VIA THE ANGEL JIBRAEEL UNTO THE BEING, SOUL , HEART, MIND, AND TONGUE AND BODY OF THE MESSENGER: MUHAMMAD --- THE ABSOLUTE BALANCED CENTER - ESTABLISHING THIS UPON THE SOCIETY THROUGH BY HIMSELF & HIS COMPANIONS & HOUSEHOLD
    [ to the *right* extreme of the Center, is the *ABSOLUTE INFINITY* at right end of the Scale, which represent the Far Right Movements: The Polytheists, The Jews, The Khawarij , The Anthropomorphists,
    AND, to the *left* extreme of the Center, is the *ABSOLUTE ZERO* at the left end of the Scale, which represent the Far Left Movements: The Atheists & Agnostics, The Sheaa, the Extreme Sufis. ]
    and to bring the following [below] upon the Full Complete Deen, with the 70 some Stations of Iman and the 360 Virtues of Islam and beyond, for each Divine Epoch-Zone (نفحة) ; Allah SWT had Sent His Last Messenger , who was the First Primodial (soulful) creation of Allah SWT
    0- The Created Being 's Belief The Intention The Will The Sincerity and relative course he or she will take - as it should securely set itself upon The Absolute One & Only and His Order: Deen ; or he disturbs by placing it upon infinity or he drowns by placing it upon zero , both of which will not be able to make it passed the 9th stage , whereas those who are weak on the Absolute Balanced Center, who didn't solidify their faith and conviction as the Prophet SAAWS taught and established a lasting connection with Allah SWT , he or she will have a great difficulty while crossing the Siraat, a number falling into the blazing fire , whereas others will cross by the Grace of Allah SWT and what they had earned from His Satisfaction and their connection established with Him equating to the measure of their success in crossing the Siraat. This is what my Teacher, may Allah sanctify his noble soul, has taught , And Allah SWT Knows best !
    1- Soul
    2- Heart
    3- Mind
    4- Body
    5- the Person
    6- the Society
    7- the other life forms & the Environment
    8- the Qiyamat/the death
    9- the Hshr / the Hisaab
    / the Siraat /
    10- the Nar
    / the Siraat /
    11- the Jannat
    Allah SWT
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  • @adms8169
    @adms8169 4 роки тому +3

    Ibn taymia is NOT Shaykh Al Islam... Better you saying that according to the Salafi Wahhabi cult that he's consider Shaykh Al Islam

    • @abdullahaa9191
      @abdullahaa9191 2 роки тому

      Read the books of Ibn Taymiyyah and see for yourself. Salafi means following the path of the “salaf”, Following the path of the prophet peace be upon him and the path his companions, and the companions of the companions, and anyone who follows the teachings of the prophet peace be upon him.
      And we don’t accept any innovation in Islam. And Ibn Taymiyyah May Allah have mercy on him did not accept innovations in Islam.

    • @dxxnish7170
      @dxxnish7170 Рік тому +1

      Shaykh Ibn Naasir al-Deen al-Dimashqi wrote a book called al-Radd al-Waafir ‘ala man za’ama anna man sammaa Ibn Taymiyah Shaykh al-Islam kaafir, in which he refuted one of the fanatical Hanafis who claimed that it was not permissible to call Ibn Taymiyah “Shaykh al-Islam”, and that the one who did that was a kaafir. In it he mentioned eighty five imams, all of whom described Ibn Taymiyah as Shaykh al-Islam, and he quoted their words from their books to that effect. When al-Haafiz Ibn Hajar (may Allaah have mercy on him) read this book - al-Radd al-Waafir - he wrote an introduction to it

  • @adms8169
    @adms8169 4 роки тому

    Ibn Taymiyyah's Deviations from the Muslims
    Know that, although Ibn Taymiyyah had many writings and a fame, he is as the Muhaddith, Hafiz, Faqih, Wali-ud-Din al-’Iraqi, the son of the Shaykh of Huffaz, Zayn-ud-Din al-’Iraqi, in his book "al-'Ajwibat-ul-Mardiyyah" said about him: His knowledge is bigger than his mind. He also said: He infringed the Ijma’ in many issues, which was said to be sixty issues, some of which are in the Usul and others in the Furu’ [Al-'Usul is ‘Ilm-ut-Tawhid, the Science of the belief in Allah and His Messenger.

    • @Yesterdaywas17
      @Yesterdaywas17 6 місяців тому

      Ibm taymiyyah was human
      And every humans does error
      Don't call him deviant
      He is Muslim
      And hopefully died with the shahada
      And repented
      So leave him alone
      I am not salafi supporter
      But respect is important