The purpose of today's video is to enlighten the nation so that we are able to learn from our mistakes and not repeat them. Understanding correct and fact based history instead of Jingoism will be our first step towards course correction, which we badly need.
Excellent analysis! Thanks BookBuddy! Hum yeh soach ke sabr kar lete hain ke humare khilaf sazish hotee hai. Jab tak yeh soach rahegi hum kabhee bhee apne ko improve nahee kar sakenge. Please soach badly aur haqeeqat ka samba karen.
And in India too , buying a mobile phone does not constitute progress. Indian remains a third class society where people are born on footpaths and die in slums, a country with the highest rate of child labor, pollution, prostitution and sexual harassment of women , country is invariably ruled by illiterate politicians by default.
I am a Kashmiri and we like Bangladeshi people. That is why Kashmiri Muslims send their children particularly girls to Bangladesh for education as they feel they are safe there.
Some Kashmiri sisters look like our own sisters. So we see them as our sisters. Though they have little difficulty to speak Bangla. But they can easily handle it. Moreover there are many Kashmiri boys and Palestinian boys, Bhutani boys come here to study medicine and MBBS. Palestinian boys also come to become a cadet or an army officer and by taking training they go to filistin(palestine). Best of luck for all of them, May Allah help them to gather the best knowledge and help their own nations
I am from Bangladesh . Now I am 60 years Old. Your Statement Absolutely right . alhamdulillah, Bangladesh is independent . Bangali nation always Hero. Allah the Almighty .
For the first time I'm seeing a Pakistani man talking with such much observed unbiased fact-checked concepts about the liberation of East Pakistan as Bangladesh from West Pakistan. Thanks & kudos for that. It really takes huge guts to have a hot take like that. Huge respect for you from us Bangladeshi's 🇧🇩
Every Muslim who calls himself a Muslim and is proud of being a follower of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) is worthy of respect in this nation, but a Muslim who supports the enemies of Islam is actually the greatest enemy of the nation. Allah protect us all from the dirty eye's of enemies اللهم امين يارب العالمين 🇸🇦
Bangladesh forgot that Pakistani kill 8 millions of Bangladeshi Muslim and Bangladesh people's when Bangladesh is less powerful than Pakistan in gdp Pakistani public think Bangladesh are lower class people just think 😢 India 🇮🇳 and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 are friends and brother not Pakistan why India and Bangladesh are brother because we fight for you and we lost many hero for you
Our Army still learnt no lesson from past . Now once again they r playing with fire to sideline and eliminate Imran khan . The consequences will b dire and of far reaching effects on stability of Pakistan .
@@Angel_priya5667Why are you so excited? A whopping majority of Bangladeshis are anti India ,they have forgotten India's help in capturing 93000 Pak Army men and India's role in their liberation.
We are Apologizing to all of my Bangali Brothers we hurt you Alotttttt... But we are happy for you that you are going Better than Pakistan... Long Live Bangladesh🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩... Lots of love from 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Thanks, brother. We don't hate Pakistanis who accept what happened in 1971. It's not your fault for the crime of your forefathers or some from your country. But we just want new-gen Pakistanis to accept the atrocities that have happened!!
@@ishwardevi134 Well we can't leave Pakistan lekin un sab Ghadaro ko zaroor Yahan se bhaag denge Pakistan hamara hai in chutiyay leaders ya army generals ka thori hai nikalenge to wahi hum nahi
I am a Bangladeshi and I am watching your video.Thank you for tell the true story of Pakistan. You tell Pakistani people the right story.I think every Pakistani should watch this video
@@aliraza4241as an Indian tum logo ne religion ko kuch jyada serious le liya hay religion ko dill me rako hindu muslim nahi sabko pakistani samjho sabke religion ka respect karo tum log bhi aage badho ge
Bangladesh forgot that Pakistani kill 8 millions of Bangladeshi Muslim and Bangladesh people's when Bangladesh is less powerful than Pakistan in gdp Pakistani public think Bangladesh are lower class people just think 😢 India 🇮🇳 and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 are friends and brother not Pakistan why India and Bangladesh are brother because we fight for you and we lost many hero for you
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was one of the most talented and prudent political leaders of South Asia! There is no doubt about it. Today's Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina is taking Bangladesh forward in all aspects as her worthy daughter. Thank you brother From Bangladesh ❤️🌺
This video is such an eye-opener for every Pakistani. It makes you realize India has much less to do with the separation of East Pakistan, mostly it is our own doing. We've been taught the wrong history in Pakistan Studies for 'someone' else's benefit.
I will clear 2 points. 1. Many countries have two or more official languages. For example: Canada has 2 state languages and India has 22 official languages. 2. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a student of political science and also studied law. So his 6-point claim is not a figment of his imagination. He made this demand knowingly for the good of the country. Interestingly, Pakistan's 18th Amendment Bill is the essence of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's six points. The law that Pakistan implemented in 2010, Sheikh Mujib said the same things 50 years ago in six points
India has Hindi as national language and 22 or so regional languages (8th schedule languages). Official work is done in English and Hindi at the national level and regional languages and English at state levels. Hindi is promoted to be link language similarly as Urdu is promoted in Pakistan.
@@mohammadfarooqshah3796 If you want to justify your Urdu incrementation by bringing Hindi and Urdu language dominance in the same line then you're wrong. In West Bengal, India, state affairs are in Bengali, in Tamil Nadu, state affairs are in Tamil and across India, national affairs are in English. But due to the dominance of Hindi language in North India, especially in the capital Delhi, all government work is done in Hindi. So that's why Hindi is also made the national language. But your Jinnah clearly said Urdu and only Urdu will be the national language of Pakistan and no other language. But Bengalis demanded that Pakistan should have two state languages, Urdu and Bengali (the mother tongue of 56% people of a country). Now, if the government of Pakistan announces that the national language of Pakistan will be French from tomorrow, will you accept it?
Brother you are absolutely wrong. India dont have a national language. If make national language, India will be separated as parts of pieces. That's why, India cannot establish Hindi as national language.
@@makelifeeasy6006 Article 343(1) of indian constitution mentions that official language of union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script. Please recall riots against imposition Hindi in Tamilnadu in 1965. It is a fact that at present official work is done in local state language in addition to English. A day, Hindi Devs day, is celebrated all over India every year to promote Hindi.
I have asked this question myself, what was the need for east Pakistan and hijack Bengali identity as if the Indian Bengali aren't Bengali enough! I guess Islamic Bangla and Hindu Bangla have nothing in common. Only then such an outcome arise!
Masha Allah brother, hats off to you for such unbiased facts and figures you gathered and presented in just 20 minutes, bilkul aisay jese samandar ko kuzay main band kar dia ho. I can't stop myself to share my personal journey here. My father belongs to Bangladesh so I got a chance to visit BD back in 2000. I observed that they were so hard-working, very down-to-earth, and humble people. They have a love for their mother tongue which is Bangla as they do not prefer English, they keep English at the secondary level as opposed to us where English-speaking people can be judged as highly educated. I used to have tea in the evening at the nearby hotel where a few oldmen told me that your Pakistan army did lots of unfair with us and believe me brother there are much more things they told me that I can't mention here due to feeling shame and sorry for our leaders of that time. Aur bad kismati se aaj tak kuch nahi badla yahan sab wese ka wesa hi hai. I wish my Bengali brothers many more successes because Bangladesh has suffered a lot in that time so today Allah's blessing is with them and a big lesson for us.
An excellent and factual analysis of Pak and BAN. This should be watched by every Pakistani who mostly do not read books or have no idea about the economic and social indicators that explain a country's stature. Well done!
Bangladeshi people, we love you and we did not want to lose you but whatever you did and seceded from us was a good move. God bless you and make you all superpowers. Love from accursed and God-forsaken failed state of Begistan.
100% true information, bro... pakistan did bad ver very badly things in BD . one Muslim nation with other Muslim nations can't do this ... But the past is past go ahead... Again, it's 100 % true all the words this vlog. Thanks for this information. Pakistani people need to know the real truth. Love from BANGLADESH 🇧🇩 all the best for pakistan 🇵🇰
You keep forgetting the 7 milliion Bengali Hindus who suffered and were forced to be refugee in 1971. I am always reminded by Bangaldeshis that its Hindus who were the main targets of Pakistani army. I am a second generation refugee with all my attachment to ancestral land of Pabna eliminated. Now I have no past.
Kanglakatar refugee are not Bengalis. Whole world recognize Bangladeshi Bengali as Bengali. No one even know about 2nd class refugee of poor west kangla.
Only Bengali living in Bangladesh are Bengali. Bangladesh is the country of bengali. India is the country of indian not Bengalis. Traitor west kangla refugees are not worthy of being Bengali
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a great leader of Pakistan and the founding father of Bangladesh. We love him. Proud to be a Bangladeshi. Long live Bangladesh.
@@Emonhasan-nl7yw Corrupt people are our foes. We would not become japan but we could be Malaysia. Japan had rich history, they were not ruled by others.
Very good analysis. To be honest, it is the most reacheched, documented data analyzed and very bold video I've ever seen on this topic ! People should know the correct history and reason without any type of political propaganda. Thank you so much for this extraordinary video.
May Allah bless you brother Nadeem for your honesty. As a Bangladeshi it really made me wonder that you as a Pakistani, how much deep study you've done about 1971 & provided so accurate information. Jazakallah! Sometimes it's really disappointing to know how immoral Pakistan was that time as a Muslim nation, may be even now. After doing this amount of discrimination & genocide, still trying to hide truth! Worst enemy like Japan & USA,Germany become friend now just because of sincere apology & indemnity for their war crimes. Bangladesh & Pakistan could be same, but still after passing 52 years, Pakistan is shamelessly hiding truth.
Now Pakistan needs to save itself from Pashtuns like Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Ghulam Muhammad, Justice Munir, Musa Khan, Akbar Khan, Gul Hassan Khan, Imran Khan, Molana Fazlur Rehman, Popalzai, Sirajul Haq, Wajahat S Khan, Mullah Fazlullah, Mullah Omar, Noor Wali Mehsud, Ehsanullah Ehsan, Shakil Afridi, Zalmay Khalilzad, Pervez Khattak, Manzoor Pashteen.
From Bangladesh 🇧🇩,,, We all Bangladeshi love Pakistani 🇵🇰 people because we are United Muslim Ummah. We should ally and help each other for Islamic world.
Thanks for reveal the harsh truth of our Bangladesh 's remarkable history of 1971 's liberation war! And ofcourse it's such a big relief that we 're not in the unite by two nations! I wanna say your positivity is on top people like you can do something each n every nations raise their voice or other things bigger or small no matter. Good work man and respect from bottom of my heart! 🇧🇩
Thank you brother for highlighting the truth. Inshallah Bangladesh will improve more. Because we Bengalis are hardworking and intelligent. We love our country.🇧🇩❤️🇧🇩 From Bangladesh
@@tashin7636ei madarchod ekhon bheekari hoiya gese abong dekhtase Bangladesh onek age chole gese. Ei Jono ora ei sob boltase. Pakistan bheekari desh. They are not considered as a human.
Don't you think it will be better for the people. If Bangladesh got better and people lives improved then it is better. Our goal should not be cruel State but better lives for the people.
Kudos to Book Buddy for a non bias video on the history of Bangladesh & Pakistan, we need more open minded and intellectual people like him and Syed Muzzamil who look at facts and not feelings, coz facts don’t care about your feelings. When the truth hits hard it hits hard. As Book Buddy correctly said, they (Pakistan) made fun of East Pakistan now modern day Bangladesh only for it to do a U-Turn and hit them (Pakistan) back and boy did it hit them back. Remember the history and don’t try act like you don’t about it because the truth will always prevail in sha Allah... Ameen
It is evident that during the time of East Pakistan, a significant portion of money flowed towards West Pakistan, resulting in substantial progress in that region. Unfortunately, as a consequence, we fell behind in various sectors day by day. However, after winning the war in 1971, Bangladesh emerged victorious not only in terms of military success but also in economic and social development. Conversely, Pakistan has lagged behind primarily because we were unable to retrieve the resources that were rightfully ours. It is important to note that our people possess great knowledge and are hardworking individuals. Nonetheless, I appreciate your candid video on this matter. Good luck to Pakistan.
I am a Bangladeshi, born a decade after our liberation, and I am amazed how you have illustrated those harsh facts to the point. Even any one of our governments, or academic history books ever taught us those facts and figures like you did. We were always told that we were oppressed and mis-treated by the West Pakistan. My millions of thanks to you on behalf of all Bangladeshi for such a honest undertaking. Frankly, I am no fan of Pakistan at all. But, keeping aside our past, I still hope that this present Pakistan would success economically. There are lots of talented people in your country now. Hope all of you can work on those past flaws and wrong doings and make it a better country.
India and Bangladesh settled their boundary and have a great trade going on. We just concluded a India-Negal-Bangladesh energy tripatrite agreement for Nepal to supply Bangladesh with energy through the Indian grid. Soon, we will have a BIMSTEC free trade zone and then, India-Bangladesh-Nepal-Bhutan-Sri-Lanka-Maldives customs union.
Tell me why did the need for East Pakistan arise, when you as bengali muslim feel safe around Hindu Bengalis? If I ask Bangladeshi muslims, they give all silly excuses, as if Bangla culture needed to be saved and all, but I hope you can give me a honest answer.
@@sreyanshuchaterjee3962 Bangladeshi Muslim doesn’t want to partition of India. All caused for only extremist hindu jamidhars. They always use & behave with us such as cult. Even Bengal partition also done before India’s partition. In 1905 Bengals hindus & some hindu Leader want hindu majority Bengal that's why they Force & turchard us brutally. Then british make partition of Bengal wast Bengal become Hindu majority. United Bengal was Muslim Majority state with 77% of Muslim population.
@@fahimmrf111 Your madrasa education is why you will continue to fail at life. Stop peddling false information. My ancestral family belonged to Pabna. What you momins have done prior to 1971 and after 1971, caused a human crisis far worse than your two cent Palestine. All of you will pay your misdeeds.
@@fahimmrf111 your kind destroyed all temples and build mosques and dargahs on top of them. Defile our places of sancity and have the galls to put the blame on hindus?
The purpose of today's video is to enlighten the nation so that we are able to learn from our mistakes and not repeat them. Understanding correct and fact based history instead of Jingoism will be our first step towards course correction, which we badly need.
Still we are not learning from our mistakes 😔
Excellent analysis! Thanks BookBuddy!
Hum yeh soach ke sabr kar lete hain ke humare khilaf sazish hotee hai. Jab tak yeh soach rahegi hum kabhee bhee apne ko improve nahee kar sakenge. Please soach badly aur haqeeqat ka samba karen.
Very True.
Yahi sara zulum sindh mein muhajir o ky sath horaha ha aur mulk ki doaulat sirf 500 kahndan ky pass ha
Pakistan mein sara faida sirf punjabio ko milta ha baqi sary sobay bhooky mar rahay ha
I am from India, Pakistan needs people like you who accepts reality. Such positive mindset will be good for region's stability
❤❤❤
Accha mind set dekh do taka aurat ko bolta hai
True
And in India too , buying a mobile phone does not constitute progress. Indian remains a third class society where people are born on footpaths and die in slums, a country with the highest rate of child labor, pollution, prostitution and sexual harassment of women , country is invariably ruled by illiterate politicians by default.
But bro
Beggars can't be choosers
اللّٰہ پاک مزید ترقی عطا فرمائے بنگلہ دیش کو
I am a Kashmiri and we like Bangladeshi people. That is why Kashmiri Muslims send their children particularly girls to Bangladesh for education as they feel they are safe there.
Welcome to our 🇧🇩....we r brother ❤
Oh you mean Indian muslims, got it 👍
Some Kashmiri sisters look like our own sisters. So we see them as our sisters. Though they have little difficulty to speak Bangla. But they can easily handle it.
Moreover there are many Kashmiri boys and Palestinian boys, Bhutani boys come here to study medicine and MBBS. Palestinian boys also come to become a cadet or an army officer and by taking training they go to filistin(palestine). Best of luck for all of them, May Allah help them to gather the best knowledge and help their own nations
@@greenweed3253 Kashmiri Muslims
Imagine sending someone to Bangladesh for education 😂😂
I am from Bangladesh . Now I am 60 years Old. Your Statement Absolutely right . alhamdulillah, Bangladesh is independent . Bangali nation always Hero. Allah the Almighty .
For the first time I'm seeing a Pakistani man talking with such much observed unbiased fact-checked concepts about the liberation of East Pakistan as Bangladesh from West Pakistan. Thanks & kudos for that. It really takes huge guts to have a hot take like that.
Huge respect for you from us Bangladeshi's 🇧🇩
Every Muslim who calls himself a Muslim and is proud of being a follower of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) is worthy of respect in this nation, but a Muslim who supports the enemies of Islam is actually the greatest enemy of the nation.
Allah protect us all from the dirty eye's of enemies اللهم امين يارب العالمين 🇸🇦
Me ss well
Bangladesh forgot that Pakistani kill 8 millions of Bangladeshi Muslim and Bangladesh people's when Bangladesh is less powerful than Pakistan in gdp Pakistani public think Bangladesh are lower class people just think 😢 India 🇮🇳 and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 are friends and brother not Pakistan why India and Bangladesh are brother because we fight for you and we lost many hero for you
Our Army still learnt no lesson from past .
Now once again they r playing with fire to sideline and eliminate Imran khan .
The consequences will b dire and of far reaching effects on stability of Pakistan .
your respect will not unkill or unrape the men and women!
proud to be a Bangladeshi.... 🇧🇩🇧🇩
such a relief that we are not on the edge of default
🇮🇳🫂🇧🇩
Joy bangala
Wande mataram
@@Angel_priya5667Why are you so excited? A whopping majority of Bangladeshis are anti India ,they have forgotten India's help in capturing 93000 Pak Army men and India's role in their liberation.
Yes brother you wete lucky to get rid of this shit
@@Angel_priya5667thanks bro
@@pt-7890shut up. You don't know
Proud to be Bangladeshi.thanks our leader sheikh mujibur rahaman🇧🇩🇧🇩❤❤
আলহামদুলিল্লাহ আমি একজন বাংলাদেশের মানুষ। I'm proud to be a Bangladeshi
I'm Pakistani and I'm so sorry and sad and ashamed 😢I'm so sorry my brothers and sisters may Allah bless you more
We love you from Bangladesh
No problem vai . We love Pakistan from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️🇵🇰
No problem brother but always remember that about 3000000 people shed down their life for country....
Love u too🇧🇩😍
❤😊@@Technical_gurdian
We are Apologizing to all of my Bangali Brothers we hurt you Alotttttt... But we are happy for you that you are going Better than Pakistan... Long Live Bangladesh🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩... Lots of love from 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Thanks, brother. We don't hate Pakistanis who accept what happened in 1971. It's not your fault for the crime of your forefathers or some from your country. But we just want new-gen Pakistanis to accept the atrocities that have happened!!
We r one nation boundaries can not divide us 🇸🇦💚
L
@@IshratLubna what's mean L?
@@hasnainbinsulaimaan2359 wrong typing. Sorry
Alhamdulillah i am proud on you Bangladeshi peoples ❤
They kicked Pakistan army
When will you kick
@@ishwardevi134 Well we can't leave Pakistan lekin un sab Ghadaro ko zaroor Yahan se bhaag denge Pakistan hamara hai in chutiyay leaders ya army generals ka thori hai nikalenge to wahi hum nahi
जिसने बॉर्डर बनाया बह महा चूतिया था।
" আমার সোনার বাংলা আমি তোমায় ভালবাসি....
" এমন দেশটি কোথাও খুঁজে পাবে নাকো তুমি সকল দেশের রানী সে যে আমার জন্মভূমি.....
বালোর দেশ বগার দেশ
আলহামদুলিল্লাহ ভাই। অনেক ধন্যবাদ
আলহামদুলিল্লাহ ভাই। অনেক ধন্যবাদ
বাংলাদেশ এর উন্নতি করুক। আমরা সমস্ত ভারতীয়রা তাই চাই !! 👍👍👍
@@ArindamGangulyKolkatadhonnobad❤❤
I am a Bangladeshi and I am watching your video.Thank you for tell the true story of Pakistan. You tell Pakistani people the right story.I think every Pakistani should watch this video
We indians always stand with bangladesh 🇧🇩 love from india 🇮🇳 ❤️
Take love from Bangladesh brother❤
@@nomayersakib8277 🇮🇳 ❤️ 🇧🇩
@@NishantKumar-ny4yo🇧🇩❤️🇮🇳
Take love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩❤️🇮🇳❤
Take love from bangladesh my brother❤❤❤
Alhamdulillah for being separated. But good luck to Pakistan. Hope Pakistan will give equal rights to everyone. Learn from mistakes. 🇧🇩🇧🇩
Pakistan mein abi bhi aisa hi ho raha hai, jaisa 1971 sy pehly hota tha
No Pakistan will never stand he'll begging forever people and government are curroupt everyone is doing currouption so impossible to stand
@@aliraza4241 Sorry to hear that.
@@aliraza4241Instability kuch jada hi hai pakistan me
@@aliraza4241as an Indian tum logo ne religion ko kuch jyada serious le liya hay religion ko dill me rako hindu muslim nahi sabko pakistani samjho sabke religion ka respect karo tum log bhi aage badho ge
Well done bro Pakistani youth ko hakikat se rubaru krane k liye...
Don't stop your mission
Love from India🇮🇳
Tu bus kr zayda,hath india ka tha bangla desh ko alag karnay mein🇵🇰
@@mirzaaamir633 Broo bangalis are powerful
One of Greatest leader ever born . The Sheikh Mujib ur Rehman . Getting 98% vote in then East Pakistan .
Love from Bangladesh. We have lot of respects for our brother Pakistan. ❤
Bangladesh forgot that Pakistani kill 8 millions of Bangladeshi Muslim and Bangladesh people's when Bangladesh is less powerful than Pakistan in gdp Pakistani public think Bangladesh are lower class people just think 😢 India 🇮🇳 and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 are friends and brother not Pakistan why India and Bangladesh are brother because we fight for you and we lost many hero for you
Mashallah 🗿 Terrorist
apner ma bo re rape korse era r apni ore respect den lol
Thank you bro such bolneka himmat rakhnekalia... I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩 I love Bangladesh and Pakistan also....
That silver button 💚
Your channel deserves SO MUCH more!
Thank You 👍
Ok plz ban on RSS Hindu extremist groups ok don’t kill Muslims in India 🙏🙏🙏
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was one of the most talented and prudent political leaders of South Asia! There is no doubt about it. Today's Prime Minister of Bangladesh Sheikh Hasina is taking Bangladesh forward in all aspects as her worthy daughter. Thank you brother From Bangladesh ❤️🌺
He was killed by their army, and his daughter is now ruling Bangladesh. We need to learn dynastic politics from Bangladesh.
@@ibratnak Pakistan ko Bangladesh se hi sikhna cahe kuch tarakki kare
This video is such an eye-opener for every Pakistani. It makes you realize India has much less to do with the separation of East Pakistan, mostly it is our own doing. We've been taught the wrong history in Pakistan Studies for 'someone' else's benefit.
I will clear 2 points.
1. Many countries have two or more official languages. For example: Canada has 2 state languages and India has 22 official languages.
2. Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a student of political science and also studied law. So his 6-point claim is not a figment of his imagination. He made this demand knowingly for the good of the country. Interestingly, Pakistan's 18th Amendment Bill is the essence of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's six points. The law that Pakistan implemented in 2010, Sheikh Mujib said the same things 50 years ago in six points
India has Hindi as national language and 22 or so regional languages (8th schedule languages).
Official work is done in English and Hindi at the national level and regional languages and English at state levels. Hindi is promoted to be link language similarly as Urdu is promoted in Pakistan.
Add another
3. He avoid the 21st February 1952 incident.
@@mohammadfarooqshah3796 If you want to justify your Urdu incrementation by bringing Hindi and Urdu language dominance in the same line then you're wrong.
In West Bengal, India, state affairs are in Bengali, in Tamil Nadu, state affairs are in Tamil and across India, national affairs are in English. But due to the dominance of Hindi language in North India, especially in the capital Delhi, all government work is done in Hindi. So that's why Hindi is also made the national language.
But your Jinnah clearly said Urdu and only Urdu will be the national language of Pakistan and no other language. But Bengalis demanded that Pakistan should have two state languages, Urdu and Bengali (the mother tongue of 56% people of a country).
Now, if the government of Pakistan announces that the national language of Pakistan will be French from tomorrow, will you accept it?
Brother you are absolutely wrong. India dont have a national language. If make national language, India will be separated as parts of pieces. That's why, India cannot establish Hindi as national language.
@@makelifeeasy6006 Article 343(1) of indian constitution mentions that official language of union shall be Hindi in Devanagari script. Please recall riots against imposition Hindi in Tamilnadu in 1965. It is a fact that at present official work is done in local state language in addition to English. A day, Hindi Devs day, is celebrated all over India every year to promote Hindi.
Sheikh Mujeeb was very sincere and patriot. Corrupt generals made him separatist. That practice is still going on by them.
I 100% agree
A very genuine demand which cud keep east and weat pakistan together
I have asked this question myself, what was the need for east Pakistan and hijack Bengali identity as if the Indian Bengali aren't Bengali enough! I guess Islamic Bangla and Hindu Bangla have nothing in common. Only then such an outcome arise!
Masha Allah brother, hats off to you for such unbiased facts and figures you gathered and presented in just 20 minutes, bilkul aisay jese samandar ko kuzay main band kar dia ho. I can't stop myself to share my personal journey here. My father belongs to Bangladesh so I got a chance to visit BD back in 2000. I observed that they were so hard-working, very down-to-earth, and humble people. They have a love for their mother tongue which is Bangla as they do not prefer English, they keep English at the secondary level as opposed to us where English-speaking people can be judged as highly educated. I used to have tea in the evening at the nearby hotel where a few oldmen told me that your Pakistan army did lots of unfair with us and believe me brother there are much more things they told me that I can't mention here due to feeling shame and sorry for our leaders of that time. Aur bad kismati se aaj tak kuch nahi badla yahan sab wese ka wesa hi hai. I wish my Bengali brothers many more successes because Bangladesh has suffered a lot in that time so today Allah's blessing is with them and a big lesson for us.
An excellent and factual analysis of Pak and BAN. This should be watched by every Pakistani who mostly do not read books or have no idea about the economic and social indicators that explain a country's stature. Well done!
Mein ik pakistani hon or mujhe Bangla Desh se bohat payar hai❤🇵🇰❤🇧🇩❤🇵🇰🇧🇩❤
Isliye pyar hai 😂 tum bhikhari ho xuke ho aur bangaldesh ko ve ohi karne chahte ho
Hum bi hein from Bd
❤from bd
Love Pakistanis too.But only civilians.Not establishment
Love u too
My home is Bangladesh Dhaka District I watch your video with full attention you are right Joy Bangla 🇧🇩
Very good statistics and valuable discussion... Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I am proud to be a Bangladeshi🇧🇩
Thanks for showing the true facts bro
Thanks for providing accurate information.ধন্যবাদ সঠিক তথ্য তুলে ধরার জন্য।
My golden Bangladesh💙
Sigma rule : When someone underestimate you-
Keep silent and show your success proudly😎
My sincere gratitude for accepting the facts and talking about it openly.
This shows Pakistan has a future.
Maza a gaya bahi app ki video reality,facts,figures per mabnee hai .
Masha Allah an excellent approach to explain facts and figures. Weldone...be considered. Allah bless you
Bangladeshi people, we love you and we did not want to lose you but whatever you did and seceded from us was a good move. God bless you and make you all superpowers. Love from accursed and God-forsaken failed state of Begistan.
100% true information, bro... pakistan did bad ver very badly things in BD . one Muslim nation with other Muslim nations can't do this ...
But the past is past go ahead...
Again, it's 100 % true all the words this vlog. Thanks for this information. Pakistani people need to know the real truth.
Love from BANGLADESH 🇧🇩 all the best for pakistan 🇵🇰
You keep forgetting the 7 milliion Bengali Hindus who suffered and were forced to be refugee in 1971. I am always reminded by Bangaldeshis that its Hindus who were the main targets of Pakistani army. I am a second generation refugee with all my attachment to ancestral land of Pabna eliminated. Now I have no past.
Informative 🇧🇩
Bengalis are always ahead of time. Love from Kolkata ❤️👍🏻
Kanglakatar refugee are not Bengalis.
Whole world recognize Bangladeshi Bengali as Bengali.
No one even know about 2nd class refugee of poor west kangla.
Only Bengali living in Bangladesh are Bengali.
Bangladesh is the country of bengali.
India is the country of indian not Bengalis.
Traitor west kangla refugees are not worthy of being Bengali
@@assassinscreeds-xu9oohow rude 😮.They are also Bengali.😒
@@assassinscreeds-xu9oo We are proud of being an Indian first & then Bengali ...I love my 🇮🇳
@@assassinscreeds-xu9oo it cell
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a great leader of Pakistan and the founding father of Bangladesh. We love him. Proud to be a Bangladeshi. Long live Bangladesh.
I have been watching Sir Shah Rukh's Videos for a long time. What an amazing and unbounded political maturity he has! Appreciate his efforts.❤
Salaam & Love From Bangladesh ❤❤❤🇧🇩
100% right.excellent video.
Jazak ALLAH ho khairan kaseera mein sachi yehi search kr ri the pr ab pori hoi meri search stay blessed
One of the best fact based video I have ever seen on UA-cam. Thank you and keep it up Buddy. All the best wishes for you.
If Pakistan don't waste & distroy our 25 years , we can develop more.
❤️ from 🇧🇩
We would become Japan may be
😂😂😂
@@picatu2667 probably they destroy our 25 years
@@picatu2667 yes maybe why not
@@Emonhasan-nl7yw Corrupt people are our foes. We would not become japan but we could be Malaysia. Japan had rich history, they were not ruled by others.
Very good analysis. To be honest, it is the most reacheched, documented data analyzed and very bold video I've ever seen on this topic !
People should know the correct history and reason without any type of political propaganda. Thank you so much for this extraordinary video.
Really good job and very very information video news ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Great brother , this is the true story..... true information...... lots of love and respect from Bangladesh....
Bravo!! Such an analytical and informative video ❣️
May Allah bless you brother Nadeem for your honesty.
As a Bangladeshi it really made me wonder that you as a Pakistani, how much deep study you've done about 1971 & provided so accurate information. Jazakallah!
Sometimes it's really disappointing to know how immoral Pakistan was that time as a Muslim nation, may be even now. After doing this amount of discrimination & genocide, still trying to hide truth!
Worst enemy like Japan & USA,Germany become friend now just because of sincere apology & indemnity for their war crimes.
Bangladesh & Pakistan could be same, but still after passing 52 years, Pakistan is shamelessly hiding truth.
Very happy for bengali people they saved themselves on time.
Now Pakistan needs to save itself from Pashtuns like Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Ghulam Muhammad, Justice Munir, Musa Khan, Akbar Khan, Gul Hassan Khan, Imran Khan, Molana Fazlur Rehman, Popalzai, Sirajul Haq, Wajahat S Khan, Mullah Fazlullah, Mullah Omar, Noor Wali Mehsud, Ehsanullah Ehsan, Shakil Afridi, Zalmay Khalilzad, Pervez Khattak, Manzoor Pashteen.
@@ibratnakStrongly agreed. Pakistan needs to save itself from some panoties. 🙃👍
From Bangladesh 🇧🇩,,,
We all Bangladeshi love Pakistani 🇵🇰 people because we are United Muslim Ummah. We should ally and help each other for Islamic world.
I am from India.
I listen your videos, our subcontinent need persons like you.
Spot on Analysis. Regards from INDIA ❤
Love Pakistan from Bangladesh
We brothers
Alhamdulillah for being separated
JOY BANGLA🇧🇩
Excellent analysis thanks for sharing 👍
Excellent post, presented with relevant facts figures (not mere opinion). Spoken with clarity and presented very effectively. Great job.
Thank you brother for Sharing true history towards those who didn't ever knew this truth.. Tnq from🇧🇩
I am from India, but this the facts and figures of proudly nation
Proud of my country Bangladesh! 🇧🇩💪
🇵🇰❤️
Thank you so much for share this information about Bangladesh.
Jonab. Im a Bangladeshi bengali living in germany. Your video is very nice and correct. Khush salat roiyega khuda hafiz
Thanks For Saying The Truth 💖 Love From Bangladesh 🇧🇩💖🇵🇰
I must say it was the most free and fair election ever to happen in Pakistan.
Thanks for reveal the harsh truth of our Bangladesh 's remarkable history of 1971 's liberation war! And ofcourse it's such a big relief that we 're not in the unite by two nations!
I wanna say your positivity is on top people like you can do something each n every nations raise their voice or other things bigger or small no matter. Good work man and respect from bottom of my heart! 🇧🇩
Love from Bangladesh dear for speaking the truth. God is great. He is the chief justice and he never discriminates.
Really very very information video news good job Pakistani media ❤❤❤❤❤❤
আমি একজন গর্বিত বাংলাদেশী ❤
আমার সোনার বাংলা আমি তোমায় ভালোবাসি 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
জয় বাংলা জয় বঙ্গবন্ধু। পাকিস্তানিরা অন 971 সালে আমাদের মা বোনদের ধর্ষণ করেছে। তাদেরকে কখনো বন্ধু মানা যাবে না।
Alhamdulilah
BANGLADESH 🇧🇩❤
Also ❤Pakistan
But we are madin in BANGLADESH
Zazakallah kair 🤲
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Mery khyal my hamen ab Pakistan ko dekhna chiy. Bangladesh ki ghaltiyon sy sekhna chiy. Jo k mujhy lagta nahi hy k sekhy
Thank you brother for highlighting the truth. Inshallah Bangladesh will improve more. Because we Bengalis are hardworking and intelligent. We love our country.🇧🇩❤️🇧🇩 From Bangladesh
Oww, what an informative video you made. Thanks for the work you have done behind it. Love from Bangladesh.
You deserve much much more subscribers. You are a gem. Thank you for your effort to make this video.
Appreciated 😍 sending Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
😊👍
Aalag hony ka Duke hy mager 😥Bangladesh ki Taraqi dekh kr Dil Bohat khoosh hota hy 💐🌺 love bangali ❤️brother and sisters from Karachi Pakistan
🙃👍 Do you really love our country?
@@tashin7636ei madarchod ekhon bheekari hoiya gese abong dekhtase Bangladesh onek age chole gese. Ei Jono ora ei sob boltase. Pakistan bheekari desh. They are not considered as a human.
@@tashin7636 Yes, indeed, since you all follow the Islamic faith.
Good..accha hua hum azad ho gae
I am from Bangladesh thank you bro, for historical events
Thanks for true explanation. I am from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Proud to be a Bangladeshi...💚❤️ Risen from blood...💔
@shancricketlover Thanks 💖
Great video as always, God forbid if Pakistan's military establishment continues on this deadly ride we could see many Bangladeshs in the future.
Don't you think it will be better for the people. If Bangladesh got better and people lives improved then it is better. Our goal should not be cruel State but better lives for the people.
@@NewYork0110Jwho thinks about people
They are blind by nationalism
They can imagine Pakistan to break
Kudos to Book Buddy for a non bias video on the history of Bangladesh & Pakistan, we need more open minded and intellectual people like him and Syed Muzzamil who look at facts and not feelings, coz facts don’t care about your feelings.
When the truth hits hard it hits hard. As Book Buddy correctly said, they (Pakistan) made fun of East Pakistan now modern day Bangladesh only for it to do a U-Turn and hit them (Pakistan) back and boy did it hit them back. Remember the history and don’t try act like you don’t about it because the truth will always prevail in sha Allah... Ameen
I am from Bangladesh, Pakistan needs people like you who accepts the horse reality of that's time.
Apki bate bohot achi...lagi kuke Apne sab sach bola.....and.... proudly said i am a bangladesi🇧🇩🇧🇩Joy Bangla joy Bongobondhu
You are the only logical Pakistani I have ever seen .
Proud to be a Bangladeshi ❤
Our leader bangabondhu sheikh mujibur Rahman 👑🇧🇩
thanks brother YOUR analysis is100% correct
Proud to be Indian, and Bengali by descent. And, I think India and Bangladesh will be developed soon. But, Pakistan has no chance.
Why our half Bangladesh should remain under Indian occupation? Let's make free independent greater Bangladesh.
It is evident that during the time of East Pakistan, a significant portion of money flowed towards West Pakistan, resulting in substantial progress in that region. Unfortunately, as a consequence, we fell behind in various sectors day by day. However, after winning the war in 1971, Bangladesh emerged victorious not only in terms of military success but also in economic and social development.
Conversely, Pakistan has lagged behind primarily because we were unable to retrieve the resources that were rightfully ours. It is important to note that our people possess great knowledge and are hardworking individuals.
Nonetheless, I appreciate your candid video on this matter. Good luck to Pakistan.
All fact in one video!
I just love it
Everyone information is true and authentic
I am a Bangladeshi, born a decade after our liberation, and I am amazed how you have illustrated those harsh facts to the point. Even any one of our governments, or academic history books ever taught us those facts and figures like you did. We were always told that we were oppressed and mis-treated by the West Pakistan. My millions of thanks to you on behalf of all Bangladeshi for such a honest undertaking. Frankly, I am no fan of Pakistan at all. But, keeping aside our past, I still hope that this present Pakistan would success economically. There are lots of talented people in your country now. Hope all of you can work on those past flaws and wrong doings and make it a better country.
as a Bangladeshi nothing to say.
Just Joy Bangla
Allah Hu Akbar
🇧🇩☪️
Not Allah hu akbr.... Only jay bangla........... Because Bangladesh 🇧🇩 is secular 😊
Thanks a lot bro... Finally someone speaks the real scenario.
Again a fantastic topic with proper research and you explained it so well to the layman. Loved it
Allah Khair kera ga Inshallah ❤
Vai apko .. bohot Zada thanks.. me . Bangladeshi form Switzerland
India and Bangladesh settled their boundary and have a great trade going on. We just concluded a India-Negal-Bangladesh energy tripatrite agreement for Nepal to supply Bangladesh with energy through the Indian grid.
Soon, we will have a BIMSTEC free trade zone and then, India-Bangladesh-Nepal-Bhutan-Sri-Lanka-Maldives customs union.
Love from India. I'm Indian Bengali Muslim. We are very happy with our Hindu friends 💙💙💙💙
Tell me why did the need for East Pakistan arise, when you as bengali muslim feel safe around Hindu Bengalis? If I ask Bangladeshi muslims, they give all silly excuses, as if Bangla culture needed to be saved and all, but I hope you can give me a honest answer.
Ji sir
@@sreyanshuchaterjee3962 Bangladeshi Muslim doesn’t want to partition of India. All caused for only extremist hindu jamidhars.
They always use & behave with us such as cult.
Even Bengal partition also done before India’s partition. In 1905 Bengals hindus & some hindu Leader want hindu majority Bengal that's why they Force & turchard us brutally. Then british make partition of Bengal wast Bengal become Hindu majority. United Bengal was Muslim Majority state with 77% of Muslim population.
@@fahimmrf111 Your madrasa education is why you will continue to fail at life. Stop peddling false information. My ancestral family belonged to Pabna. What you momins have done prior to 1971 and after 1971, caused a human crisis far worse than your two cent Palestine. All of you will pay your misdeeds.
@@fahimmrf111 your kind destroyed all temples and build mosques and dargahs on top of them. Defile our places of sancity and have the galls to put the blame on hindus?