Has Pakistan Lost Kashmir I Jammu Kashmir Reality Check I Kashmir and Bharat I Col Ajay Raina I Aadi
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 сер 2023
- Has Pakistan Lost Kashmir? Jammu Kashmir a Reality Check . What can we expect going forward in Jammu Kashmir?Kashmir and Bharat the way forward.
#kashmir #jammukashmir #pakistan #deftalks
Get Col's Books www.amazon.in/UNHOLY-JIHAD-Tr...
DEF Talks is a space for clear cut discussions on important subjects of current affairs of the world with a prime focus to the Indian Subcontinent. I cover issues related to conflicts, Geopolitics, Military Strategy and Foreign Affairs.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @deftalksbyaadi
Do support me by clicking "Thanks'.
Connect With me and Interact
EMAIL: aadiachint@gmail.com
TELEGRAM: t.me/deftalksaadi
LINKEDIN: DEF TALKS BY AADI ACHINT
TWITTER: / aadiachint
Copyrights owned. - Розваги
I’m from Jammu born & brought up still I didn’t know these facts thanks for letting me know. 🇮🇳👍🕉
Watching from Jammu
You are right AJ
Sarvangeen ,sarvsparshi, jaankari, Dene ke liye col AJ Raina sir, aur aap Aadi ji meri shubhkamna, aadi sir aapko Mera naman
Dharti Putr ko sunkar bahut nai - nai jankariyen milti hain it’s good to listen him 👍
AJ sir told ground level realities which is hard to listen 👍✔️
Very delicate issue. Needs balanced specific quick solution with vast indepth background of problems cultural history etc. Really thrilling outstanding episode. Thanks a lot to Aadi and col. Ajay Saab. Jai Ho Bharat. Jai Ho Dogra berten.
The podcast was more about local issues of Jammu than strategy about J&K. I think local politics can be avoided.
This is gold! Very balanced - created with the intent to inform rather than with the intent to enrage. Good job, guys!
Jai Hind Col Ajay ! Salute to people like you!
We need some hard decision makers. If these kind of suggestions are taken, hum aise hi uljhe rahenge
Public demand we need this guest again
Wow, that was really an eye-opener. I never expected that Jammu is still vulnerable. The govt of India and the local administration of Jammu should work together to ensure that the vulnerability of Jammu is not cash on by Pakistan, If unrest in Jammu starts then all the progress that was made after removing 370 and 35 A all will be useless.
Nice, very detailed !!!
AJ Sir, Can we take this opportunity to address our Kashmiri brothers and sisters - We had enough of Mufti’s and Abdullah’s they have done nothing for the people except enriching themselves it’s time to say goodbye to them - Satsrikal
Awesome 👍
Good discussion
Dogras have been fighting Gazwa-E-Hind since inception of Islamic invasion.Naman to AJ ji for highlighting the problems dogras have been facing in Jammu.
Neglected since the passing away of Maharaja, sacrificed a lot of Dogras from J&K + HP, in return what do we get, more neglect.
Thank you Ranaji.
Thank you Adi ji
Thank you UA-cam
Absolutely Riveting!! Many thanks from Canada Gentlemen...
Col.Sab is very knowledgeable, logical and very reasonable in his observations and demands.
AR Sirji more important than Chappa-Chappa is to pass on the knowledge (mainly considering the distorted history) to the next Gen for a learning to face tomorrow! On this point Sirji 🫡🫡🫡🇮🇳
Very knowledgeable and practical person. Should invite him more...
Maa tujhe naman ❤🙏
Nice❤
Jai Dogra Jai Hind 🎉
It is disgusting to hear about govts neglect of jammu and dissappointing disillusionment
From south india
You can take back PoJK (and the Gilgit Baltistan area is particularly important for land and air connectivity to AFG and Central Asia) - the local population should not be a deterrent to this - but one thing India will have to show the stomach to do, which is not typical of India, is intentionally fight a war with heavy collateral damage to get rid of as many Muslims (especially Punjabi Sunnis who have been pumped into the region by Pak) as possible.
And then engage in demographic change of your own in those regions by sending in Hindus + rule it strictly with direct control of the Center - possibly also using arrangements like Ikhwan or installing your own version of Chechnya's Kadyrov.
There is a systematic cultural blow that needs stringent action and corrective measures forthwith and it will be done with full honour and valour in Modi 3.0. Vikasit Bharat sub ka saath. Unity in diversity.
AJ sir I'm sure there are issues which you have pointed out very rightly but is it being addressed to the PM or the HM... I think this is very important for responsible Jammuites like yourself to speak to the leadership which i feel will not be unheard.
There are different channels to convey the point. All possible routes are being followed, to include print and media in addition to the personal reach out. Your suggestion is valued. Thanks
Dear Adi, Col Kaul has called a spade a spade.
Share it seriously, so that it should reach at adminstration at centre.
Can we have Maj. Abhay Sapru on the show? He has written some really captivating books.
How much complicated is Jammu, Kashmir and G. B. Societies
Every society has its own complexities. GB, by far, is the most homogeneous of all three. They follow one faith and their only problem is neglect by Pak coupled with the chinese intrusion. Kashmir, after the exodus of KPs, has different sects that create a fault line as a natural outcome. However, this part is manageable. Jammu is a melting pot wherein all kinds of religions and faiths co-habit, thanks to two things--one is Dogra identity and second is neglect that Jammu has been facing for decades.
@@ajaykrraina Wonderful assessment, sir. We, as an Indian have with us perpetual concern for our nation, specially J. K.
Are we weld
Dear Sirs, Jai Bhaarat & Jai Sanatan
When gangrene afflicts a part of a body it MUST to be ✂️removed🗡 in order to save the larger 🕉Body🕉 Similarly the forever spreading☪️cancerous☪️gangrene☪️in the kashmir valley MUST BE 🗡operated&removed✂️ from the larger Jammu province to save the Larger🕉🇮🇳sanatani🇮🇳🕉civization
People from all over india must visit jammu to build pressure upon the governing officials in the form of RTI about each and every department of jammu. These information about what has been done since 75 years a list must be made and given full media publicity so that any government or any official has to wilt under public pressure and things will begin to change.
The jammu traditional industry growth can be showcased in point.
While I don't respond to those who draw their own deductions and start trolling, I write this to clarify the point about Shias and their outlook. There is no dispute when it comes to the generally held belief that many Muslims draw inspiration from their religious literature (esp Hadiths) while choosing a path of violence, there is a need to have a slightly deeper understanding of different sects. To give an example, it is well established that the Shi’as do not believe in the immunity of any writer, commentator or narrator from mistakes, and, therefore, they do not take any collection of hadith to be completely valid and correct. This despite the fact that both Sunni and Shia followers follow same Quran. Beyond literature and scriptures, the ground realities both in Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan area point towards the above distinction.
Thanks
The real problem is, Gilani comes from Gilan, Jilani comes from Jilan.
Hamdani, comes from Hamdan, Bukhari, comes from Bukhara, followed by Individuality, Qadri, Farooqi, Haidari, Siddiqui, Rahmani, Usmani, etc. The people coming from the name of these areas are a higher caste to the rest of the people, ie Sayyid
Sir aap bolte ho k apka podcast hai par aap apna podcast kaha dalte ho agar podcast hai to google podcast pe milna chaheye na
Indeed, Jammu is neglected. The railway bridges at Jammu Railway Station say it all..
Shakargarh should have been in India to have better conneting with Jammu and Punjab
Aadi please don’t podcast with this kind of half truth people. Islam especially Quran is full of violence and discrimination. But your host telling complete lies about Islam.
Please read my comment posted a few moments ago. There is no single template anywhere.
Pmo....apne ministers ki class lijiye...
The centre must be made to hear from u.revered Ex officers of Great India.please.
A countrys development will be Sustainable only when each and every place that belong to it has equal facilities just as each and every body part gets equal and correct blood circulation..
Therefore if jammu is not developed means there is no blood circulation which implies the wound is there and it is not treated fully.
All our defence staff and their related things must be completely stationed in pojkalong with strong surveillance there so that vigil upon pak is made easy.
QQ
At least for 5 years ie upto 2028 jammu people must be exempted from levying any kind of tax either direct or indirect as a tax holiday as they have suffered since 75 years. Hence this relief must be given to jammu people till they form a separate governance from outside jammu ie say tamilnadu people can rule jammu , solve all its problems and then hand over to suitable rightful jammu persons. Like this throughout india where corruption is rampant, these administration reforms from people outside that state becomes nessery.
39:55
Pada hua hai Quran , kuchh peaceful nahi hi.
May like to read my comment posted a few minutes ago.
@@ajaykrraina
Ajay ji , I agree with your comment.
Shias do not believe in many of the hadiths and that gives one more legroom to interpret many Quranic verses differently.
But Quran still has many problems when 'peace' part is concerned.
Yes, degree of fanaticism may differ based on place due to amount of exposure to Madrasas, subsects or other reasons.
True. Through out history we lost Iraq, afganistan Pakistan and Bangladesh because of peace and love 💕
Your channel sound quality is very low
On agreement first, I second Col AJ on his views of Jammu being neglected. Am from Kashmir but done all my education from Jammu since 1970 so seen it all. But his views on Jammu will mor be able to take care of itself due to poor leadership is something like Nehru saying Indian Army officers didn't have experience of running an army. Today we are one of the best. Leadership will rise to the occasion. They will come out of Kashmir dominance when tested independently. We have to come out of this mindset. Then statehood to Jammu. Again it is old N thought, Jammu incapable leadership and Kashmir, what will the world think about Kashmir control from Delhi. No issues or worries on that now. World will mind its own businesses and not interfere. We can have a small Kashmir State or a Union Territory. Jammu will only grow when seperated from Kashmir by their own capable leaders. There are security and demographic reasons also for Jammu to be with the sons of the soil. He covered his reasons in brief, but I think it needs one full episode to discuss its Geograhic, Demographic, Security, development and importance to Pakistan issues. I personally am for its statehood. There will be teething problems but it will be a beautiful state under Dogra politaical administration.
Now about Kashmir, he is again giving those politically correct diplomatic answers. Comparing killed data of Delhi or any other state with Kashmir. It has no relationship at all. We have to consider/compare cause of kills and not numbers. Then again those old reasons of bigday huwe bachhe, unemployment where he puts todays differnt reasons like gundagardi and badla. We as Kashmiri Hindus or Dogras didn't do that. We were worst effected for badla unemployment and land grabbing. We didn't take up arms. So we have to move out of Nehruvian philosophy and thoughts and look at the problem with the new changed world order where India counts, abolition of 370, 35A. What did the world do???? If you can pl organise his discussion on stategood of Jammu and UT/statehood of Kashmir and keep it in a manner where orhers can participate, say Zoom etc it will be more useful. That discussion could include taking back of POJK and Gilgit etc. In my opinion again his apprehensions are N thought, not even a single grain of grass grows there, he says people are not good so don't think of taking it. We have such people all over the country so should we let them go...... Sorry for such long comments, but the topic is such. Have tried to be as brief as i possibly could. Lot more to say, which is difficult to write. God bless.
AJ sir shares a stricking resemblance with Ricky Gervais.
Ha ha... But I am serious😂
Spot on!
Sirf khoon dete hi rahoge?? Lena shuru karo, phir dekho
Sir क्या आप लोग इंग्लिश मे object को explain करते है तो हमे कुछ कुछ समझ आता है कुछ नही आता या तो total इंग्लिश मे या पूरी हिन्दी मे बताय जिससे पुरा समझ सके
Raina sir
Aap to army man hai,personal gruez se upar nilaliye
BZP ne bahut kiya J ND K ke liye
Kuch minute mistakes hue honge maf kar dijiyega
SUFIS OF KASHMIR WERE NOT PEACEFOOL.
Sorry for the rudeness Jammu has no history before 1800,The brother of Raja Dahir Daharsiah was sheltered by the Kashmiri Raja Lalitaditya Karkota dynasty in Jammu region., Therefore, their language is similar to the Multani Sindhi language, later during the reign of Ranjit Singh, Punjabi occupied Kashir,
And they made our geography and history contradictory
It started with the dark side of Kashmir's independence, because the Khalistan independence movement wanted to occupy the territories of Kashmir again, Pakistan is still deadlocked on this matter.
Actually, the movement of Khalistan was going on in Kashmir
Ankur Sharma of Ikkjutt Jammu is leading a Movement for JAMMU Statehood
We should support our Dogra brothers get the honour of a प्रदेश as per 1956 States Reorganization Act
A Jammu state
which is 64% Hindu Majority in its 10 districts
with a
Dogra CM
Dogra State Police
Dogra Bureaucracy
Dogri language & culture protection & promotion
The Genocidal Kashmiri Leadership which didn't even spare their own Kashmiri Hindu brothers and expelled them in 1990s..
will have No Mercy on Dogras also.
For National Security..
Restrict Kashmiri Leadership to 16,000 sqkm of Kashmir only
Take power away from Kashmiri Leadership to destroy Jammu
75 yrs later, this is not just a Statehood issue but the Very Question of survival & existence of Dogra Hindus & Sikhs in Jammu
जय माता दी
Middle class v BJP se algaav rakhne lgi he, sara burden middle class pe, dgovt deti kucch nhi.
Sir, what world are you living in? Itna kuch hone ke baad bhi aapko world kya bolti hai iska chinta hai?? Unbelievable. Jammu ko state banao, local Ekam Sanatan Party ko aane do. Let kashmir be UT, what's the problem
Col. Raina you need to work on speech therapy....
🙏🌹
Sorry to say but Col has no knowledge and understanding of Islam
QQ