This is a brilliant talk on JK history and its current impact by someone who knows the area and the people very well. I have heard so many people speak, and this is among the top. From a Kashmiri 😊
Col AJ Raina is simply brilliant! I love his in-depth and factual analysis. There are very few so called “experts” on J&K who know the ground situation well, most don’t even know the difference between Jammu and Kashmir provinces! And it is true, Kashmiris recognise other Kashmiris very well even without talking to them..! I have visited many places in India and Kashmiris always recognise me, a Kashmiri and come talking to me.
कर्नल रैना की जम्मू-कश्मीर के बारे में जानकारी गजब की है।इससे पहले Tiny Dhillon book on Kashmir,Kitne Ghaji......"ही पढ़ी थी अब कर्नल रैना की Kashmir narratives ऑर्डर कर रहा हूं।कर्नल रैना के साथ बातचीत में संजय सर का योगदान भी अतुलनीय रहा,उनकी जानकारी भी सटीक है।पहली बार कई बातें पता चली। लाख लाख बार साधुवाद है आप दोनो वक्ताओं को।
Thank you sir for raising the issues of Dogras and how we people are neglected since decades in the name of J&k. Sadly even then Dogras never speak for themselves and the agony is it’s we the people of Jammu who made BJP won from the past 15 years and not Kashmir
They are all outsider settled for long in kashmir following their original country's culture and term it as kashmiriat. Kashmir culture is basically hindu based having highly supressed.
@@SUNITASHARMA-yp3br Aap ek Indian ho, bohut achi baat hai... Aap mere ek sawak ka jawab do, Pakistan Indian army per kyu attacks karti hai, aur kashmir mei hi kyu karte hai?
@DarTaffazulthat itself is factually incorrect. Can you trace your origins to the period before Islam. Kashmir belonged to the hindus and Buddhists. We have records of philosophies that were written in the sharada peeth. You can call yourself native but saying that Kashmir has nothing to do with Hinduism is factually incorrect. Infact Islam is the corruption imposed upon the original civilization of this place.
Such a great episode. Col Raina is a unique speaker with expert views on Army warfare, Pakistan and J&K specific issues. It was very insightful to listen to him. Great podcast. Not even a minute was boring.
I have heard lots of expert im defense including retired army personnal but the knowledge and sense of Sir Ajay Raina is something nobody can match it with ❤❤❤
Brilliant podcast & an amazingly knowledgeable guest, Col Raina!! Must watch for everyone who wants a deeper factual understanding of POJK- past, present & path forward.
Col ajay raina, your calm demeanor,anlytical skills,clarity of thoughts and the argument from your end is commendable. while you were discussing about the gilgit baltistan, what accurate geographer and navigator you are! sanjay Dixit g and raina g you both were looking like a NSA , depth of knowledge it was a movie . thank you so much sir
Raina Sir ur full of knowledge n so sweet n well spoken..... True Gem n True Sanatani n True Nationalist..... Only if governments or establishment would hv listened to people like u but sad part is they only listen to characterless guys like Dullat
Maldives was islamic since many many centuries earlier. Arab traders spread islam via trade routs from Saudi Arabia to Indonesia. Islam arrive in Kerala before arrives in Kashmir and yes Satrubodh of neo Buddhist is negligent. They are like useful idiots of olden times which at present liberal Marxist have become for islam jihad
Absolutely I agree. I too believe and express the same. Majority of Asian countries where it is a muslim country. there budhism replaced Hinduism and finally budhism was thrown out by Islam.
Islam spread in Maldives viavArab trade routes. In Kerala, Indonesia(which was hindu before islam, google Majapati empire), Malaysia same story but this did not happened in Buddhist Sri Lanka.. think. If u are neo Buddhist then islam can influence you. But it you have strong civilizational roots in Buddhist traditions like china, sri lanka, myanmar, you will fight islam even more brutally than present day hindus as u can see the way china, myanmar and Sri Lanka handled it's muslim question.
An absolute Master class by a Master!! Brillaint insight Col Raina..we hope and pray that the powers tha be take heed to your extremely sensible advice of paying more attention to Rajouri, Poonch and Jammu
Thanks, JD & Sanjay ji for presenting a wonderful discussion on issues on Jammu & Kashmir. Insights provided by Col. Raina are mesmerizing. Much of the details were unknown. His books should be prescribed as extra reading material. Present LG seems to be fatigued. The Administrative System is still under control of Separatists. Col. Raina has hit the nail on the head by saying, Kashmir's problem is Islamic Jihaad. It's a long way to go. The present day Central Government is moving at a snail's speed. But at least they are doing something. Thanks once again for such an informative session 🙏👌
One of the best podcast on Kashmir on SM. Col Saab with facts, crisp 🙏. Would like to hear more from him about Sheikh abdullah, Jawaharlal Nehru and others role in Kashmir. Let podcast be lengthy of it has to be, it's interesting to hear him. And Dixit sir, you did not interrupt him while he was speaking which is good quality of the host. Want see and hear him more. 🙏
Lala Hardayal in 1925 highlighted that future of Hindu race of Hindustan rests on these four pillars 1)Hindu Sangathan 2)Hindu Raj 3)Shuddhi of Muslims 4)Conquests & Shuddhi of Afghanistan & Frontiers Just as one removes foreign matter from the eyes Shuddhi must be made of Muslims & Christians
हमारे राजनेता ना तो इतिहास से सीखना चाहते हैं और ना ईस्लाम की किताबों से फिर से नरसंहार को आमंत्रण दिया जा रहा है। ऐक्स मुस्लिम आंदोलन को तीव्रता और सुरक्षा देनी होगी तभी मानवता की रक्षा हो सकेगी। हर हर महादेव🙏🙏🙏
Col ajay rainaji is one more gem, I came to know from JD. Thanks
Conl. Ajay. Rainaji is. My. Most. Favorite guest. Jai. Hind. Sir
@@BayPorWahcalm down bro, first set your priorities right, there are many other major issues than bickering over this
धूर्त है ये आतंकियों की मदद करता है
@@chillax360absolutely correct
Namaskaram Col Ajai Raina
Brilliant col rana...what analysis
कश्मीर पर आपके चेनल का अब तक का सबसे बेस्ट वार्ता। धन्यवाद।
इतिहास, भूगोल पर
Anything Indian Army = Col. Raina; Absolutely unparalleled on the ground experience!
Jai Hind Sir
Jai Hind sir I am in total agreement with you.He knowledge is incredible and unparalleled.
Being born and raised in Jammu, I can now relate with everything Col. Raina is explaining!!
Thanks col. Ajay Raina ji. For addressing the problem of Jammu province
Grt to see Col ajay in the show...pl call him more him sanjayji
Col Raina I was the first to cross pirpanjal ranges twice from poonch to Gulmarg and then crossed over to Rajauri way back in 1984.
Col Ajsy at his best again
This is a brilliant talk on JK history and its current impact by someone who knows the area and the people very well. I have heard so many people speak, and this is among the top. From a Kashmiri 😊
Call Him Again
Great Superb Brave Honourable Col.Raina 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
The way ajay sir explain is more easy to learn about history. Jay hind sir ji😊we are great to have you ☀️🙏
Col AJ Raina is simply brilliant! I love his in-depth and factual analysis. There are very few so called “experts” on J&K who know the ground situation well, most don’t even know the difference between Jammu and Kashmir provinces!
And it is true, Kashmiris recognise other Kashmiris very well even without talking to them..! I have visited many places in India and Kashmiris always recognise me, a Kashmiri and come talking to me.
Hats off C Ajay sir, eye opener and very good insight. We in South are unaware.
🙏🙏🙏
कर्नल रैना की जम्मू-कश्मीर के बारे में जानकारी गजब की है।इससे पहले Tiny Dhillon book on Kashmir,Kitne Ghaji......"ही पढ़ी थी अब कर्नल रैना की Kashmir narratives ऑर्डर कर रहा हूं।कर्नल रैना के साथ बातचीत में संजय सर का योगदान भी अतुलनीय रहा,उनकी जानकारी भी सटीक है।पहली बार कई बातें पता चली।
लाख लाख बार साधुवाद है आप दोनो वक्ताओं को।
Kyunki woh swayam ek Kashmiri Pandit hai.
How can you expect this govt to give arms to citizens to defend themselves. These guys can't even tackle opposition while in power.
If you gave arms to citizes😂😂😂 nice joke brother aap kinhe aarms dena chahte ho soch lo ekk baar
@@pawanrajput311To Hindu civilians staying in Jammu my friend, apne kya socha
@@shodangi ohhh ok ok i thought to them 🤦♂️
For VDC
@@omom1542 yes
Proud podcast, I eagerly waiting for the great man col ajay raina saab to deliver talk on Kashmir issue right man for right issue
Col Raina, finally getting recognition on TJD. Please get him more often. No one like Col AJ! Jai Duggar Jai Dogra Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
Thank you sir for raising the issues of Dogras and how we people are neglected since decades in the name of J&k. Sadly even then Dogras never speak for themselves and the agony is it’s we the people of Jammu who made BJP won from the past 15 years and not Kashmir
उपाय तो सरल ही पर भाजपा अपने ब्यूरोक्रेट्स की ही सुनती है, उनके रियल थिंक टैंक को तो विरोधी मानती रहेंगी तब तक कुछ नही होंगा।
Thanku sir aj apne humre dil ki batein ki jammu walu ki sari paashani
was waiting for this guest...lots of respect to you sir...and great work Sanjay sir.. salute to both
Col. Ajay Raina is one of the best military analysts, always a pleasure to listen to his insights. Good to see him on tjd
Kashmir muslim is not changed,they said modi will never come in kashmir.
They are all outsider settled for long in kashmir following their original country's culture and term it as kashmiriat. Kashmir culture is basically hindu based having highly supressed.
@@SUNITASHARMA-yp3br
Aap andbakh log educated hoker bhi kashmir aur kashmiriyon ke maamley mei illiterate banjate ho,
@@SUNITASHARMA-yp3br
Aap ek Indian ho, bohut achi baat hai...
Aap mere ek sawak ka jawab do, Pakistan Indian army per kyu attacks karti hai, aur kashmir mei hi kyu karte hai?
@DarTaffazulthat itself is factually incorrect. Can you trace your origins to the period before Islam. Kashmir belonged to the hindus and Buddhists. We have records of philosophies that were written in the sharada peeth. You can call yourself native but saying that Kashmir has nothing to do with Hinduism is factually incorrect. Infact Islam is the corruption imposed upon the original civilization of this place.
It's wonderful to hear Col. Ajay K Raina Sir. Every word spoken is reality. Great analysis and suggestions. It happen only in Sanjay Dixit Sir's show.
Thank you Col Raina
Col. Raina is well grounded and knows the area as a back of his hand. The best on Kashmir issues
Such a great episode. Col Raina is a unique speaker with expert views on Army warfare, Pakistan and J&K specific issues. It was very insightful to listen to him. Great podcast. Not even a minute was boring.
Amazing facts with Analysis on jammuriyat and kashmiriyat by Col Raina. Very knowledgeable talking points and eye opener. 🙏 Thankyou Sir.
Col raina-the next big name for kashmir expert analysis.salute sir
Jai Hind Jai Bharat Sanjay sir and Con Ajay Raina sir 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏 Jai Jagannath 🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏
What an eye opener by Col Raina and all those who support Congress should hear this Podcast and learn the reality of the party.
Thank you Col. Ajay Raina for the detailed analysis of situation in Kashmir. Would like to read your books. Thank you Jaipur Dialogue team.
Best Military Historian! Salute 🇮🇳
BJP still busy in Appeasement Politics across Bharat, which is Dissapointing!
One of the best podcast on J&K history.. Never taught in school..
Col raina sir.. ❤🙏
Thank you mr.raina.
we jammuities need more people to give clear idea how diverse we are from kashmiri's.
I have heard lots of expert im defense including retired army personnal but the knowledge and sense of Sir Ajay Raina is something nobody can match it with ❤❤❤
Brilliant podcast & an amazingly knowledgeable guest, Col Raina!! Must watch for everyone who wants a deeper factual understanding of POJK- past, present & path forward.
This is the ground realities..i never thought situation is that bad...
Col ajay raina, your calm demeanor,anlytical skills,clarity of thoughts and the argument from your end is commendable. while you were discussing about the gilgit baltistan, what accurate geographer and navigator you are! sanjay Dixit g and raina g you both were looking like a NSA , depth of knowledge it was a movie . thank you so much sir
One of my favourite veteran col. Raina
Ajay Raina sirji
Ache insan hai ❤
Welcome AJ sir to aur JD
Can listen to Col AJ nonstop...no one knows the history, geography and genesis of Kashmir problem better than him🫡🫡🫡
Bring col Ajay Raina sir back, big fan of him. He is knowledgeable and really like the discussion
Favourite Col . Raina ❤
POJK AFTER OCCUPYING SHOULD KEPT IN ICU FOR AT LEAST 5 YEARS
Raina Sir ur full of knowledge n so sweet n well spoken..... True Gem n True Sanatani n True Nationalist..... Only if governments or establishment would hv listened to people like u but sad part is they only listen to characterless guys like Dullat
Buddhism is door to islamization.
Recent example is Maldives
Maldives was islamic since many many centuries earlier. Arab traders spread islam via trade routs from Saudi Arabia to Indonesia. Islam arrive in Kerala before arrives in Kashmir and yes Satrubodh of neo Buddhist is negligent. They are like useful idiots of olden times which at present liberal Marxist have become for islam jihad
Wat mean by Buddhism door for islamization
Absolutely I agree. I too believe and express the same. Majority of Asian countries where it is a muslim country. there budhism replaced Hinduism and finally budhism was thrown out by Islam.
Islam spread in Maldives viavArab trade routes. In Kerala, Indonesia(which was hindu before islam, google Majapati empire), Malaysia same story but this did not happened in Buddhist Sri Lanka.. think. If u are neo Buddhist then islam can influence you. But it you have strong civilizational roots in Buddhist traditions like china, sri lanka, myanmar, you will fight islam even more brutally than present day hindus as u can see the way china, myanmar and Sri Lanka handled it's muslim question.
Will you keep Pomeranian dog to guard your house or some ferocious dog breed like German Shepard/Pitbull/Rottweiler?@@TenzinTsering-ss8zm
This talk is worth treasuring
An absolute Master class by a Master!! Brillaint insight Col Raina..we hope and pray that the powers tha be take heed to your extremely sensible advice of paying more attention to Rajouri, Poonch and Jammu
Very nice discussion sir. Thank you both. Jay bharat.
Main har roj 10 Hinduon ko The Jaipur Dialogues channel deta hoon aur unko jagne ko bolta hoon. 🙂🙂🙏🙏
Waiting for this podcast to start...
Thanks, JD & Sanjay ji for presenting a wonderful discussion on issues on Jammu & Kashmir. Insights provided by Col. Raina are mesmerizing. Much of the details were unknown. His books should be prescribed as extra reading material.
Present LG seems to be fatigued. The Administrative System is still under control of Separatists.
Col. Raina has hit the nail on the head by saying, Kashmir's problem is Islamic Jihaad. It's a long way to go. The present day Central Government is moving at a snail's speed. But at least they are doing something.
Thanks once again for such an informative session 🙏👌
Guru ji, aj ko Lana impotent tha JD ke liye bcz aur all jd group members are wants to see him in conversation with you.
Maharaja Gulab Singh Zindabad
Proud to be Dogra
Jai Hind
Ccl Ajay k Raina is from my hometown but i come to know about him from you tube channels.
This is freaking mind blowing.. So much information in one podcast.. Awesome work. Pls bring more such people to decode unheard history.
Very riveting conversation. Thank you JD
A very knowledgeable and one who know the ground reality exactly . The tone is literally jammu oriented which is ground reality .
Superb podcast Dixit sir🙏👍👌 excellent deep discussion regarding j&k with ajay sir need more sessions 👍
One of the best podcast on Kashmir on SM. Col Saab with facts, crisp 🙏.
Would like to hear more from him about Sheikh abdullah, Jawaharlal Nehru and others role in Kashmir. Let podcast be lengthy of it has to be, it's interesting to hear him. And Dixit sir, you did not interrupt him while he was speaking which is good quality of the host. Want see and hear him more. 🙏
So good to see Raina sir, he is always refreshing when it comes to hearing a view point
Awesomely awesome session with Col. Ajay RainaJi !🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you Raina sir
Sir Ajay shaab ko bhut accha knowledge h jk ka
M enko kaafi din se dekh raha hu 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡✌🏻✌🏻🚩🚩
Gem of a person ❤❤❤ absolutely stuck to screen listening this gentlemen ❤❤
Col. Ajay Raina ji. You are amazing. ❤ Hats off to you sir
Lala Hardayal in 1925 highlighted that future of Hindu race of Hindustan rests on these four pillars
1)Hindu Sangathan
2)Hindu Raj
3)Shuddhi of Muslims
4)Conquests & Shuddhi of Afghanistan & Frontiers
Just as one removes foreign matter from the eyes Shuddhi must be made of Muslims & Christians
Must
Immediately
I never miss any conversation with General Raina. This too was a very informative and good discussion.
One of the most insightful discussion of Jaipur dialogues ever had
Thanks to Ajay ji for history lesson many things I heard first time here..
Nice intellectual discussion from two individuals with strong grasp over their subject material...a fine former IAS and a fine former Colnel 👏👍
Loving this session 👍🏼
wow, what an amazing discussion !!! Thanks
Excellent discussion
Awesome
Really amazing discussion
Thank you
Conl aj Raina is very knowledgeable person, I am listening him on def talks for very long time. His analysis are amazing
Jabardast Col sahab
हमारे राजनेता ना तो इतिहास से सीखना चाहते हैं और ना ईस्लाम की किताबों से फिर से नरसंहार को आमंत्रण दिया जा रहा है। ऐक्स मुस्लिम आंदोलन को तीव्रता और सुरक्षा देनी होगी तभी मानवता की रक्षा हो सकेगी। हर हर महादेव🙏🙏🙏
Outstanding session.
Salute to you sir
Solution is very simple if govt shows some guts .
Brilliant analysis…
Excellent conversation between two intellectuals
Quite insightful discussion
Salute sir
Great conversation
Fabulous video Sanjayji--
Most favourite guest ,a genius....❤❤❤
Jammu needs to be developed more than Kashmir. People of Jammu are nationalists and patriots. 👍
Roka kis ne hai kro taraki baand k thodi rakha hai kisi ne
Execilent Raina- Thanks Sanjay Sir.
Col Ajay....very informative talk...
Thank you for this podcast