Please ignore negative comments. I think you do a great job with your kids. I think they are mature for their age even the little ones. Always a joy to watch your videos
Thank you for taking us along on for your Sunday. I’ve heard about The Milk Bar, so it was fun to see what its treats are like. I’m impressed by how beautiful the tile pictures in the subway station are.
It is so sweet that all of the kids share their treats. I am amazed at all the different stores and shops they have there and the wide variety of items you can buy. Tell Josiah I said he is a handsome Dapper young man. He is also very intelligent. Amber, you and Marc and have done an excellent job of raising your children. I don't think anyone could ask for better kids. Thank you for sharing your Sunday with us. God bless all of you. 🙏 I forgot, I love Josiahs jacket.
As a history buff myself, I always enjoy when Josiah gives a bit of historical information on NY and I am curious to know more! It would be so awesome for him to have a full episode once a week on The Happy Caravan, or even his own channel. He could take us on walking tours and through museums! And it also would add to his academic profile should he decide to pursue graduate school. Go for it Josiah!
I just found your channel over the weekend. You have such a beautiful family! Your voice is so calming, and God’s love shines through you. I love NYC and enjoy the sites that you show. ❤
I just discovered your channel today. Great fun to see your beautiful family enjoying my neighborhood. Milk Bar is wonderful! I look forward to watching more of your adventures and learning more about your unique family. You all have an amazing dynamic that we need more of in this world! ❤
The treats from The Milk Bar looked delicious! As a kid, when I went to Sunday school (when in 5-6 grade, not the younger years), the teacher would teach the class then at the end, ask questions. Everyone who got the answer correct got a candy bar. Made all of us pay close attention to what the teacher was saying because those candy bars looked so good! I wonder how long it took to build all of the connecting NYC train stations ... can't even imagine. Thank you for another great video! 🙏❤
You are doing a good job with these videos. Some of best. I would love to see You all on the high line if it ever stops raining. Should be gorgeous in fall. Maybe also a home school trip to the aquarium and lunch (picnic) on the boardwalk. I really feel like I am in NYC.
It’s always fun to have a treat after church. Thanks for exploring another venue. Melody looked cute with her new sunnies! Chloe’s cupcakes looked divine. It’s great your kids are happy to try new foods .
The way your children treat each other is the sweetest , I’m sure they fight but, 😊 you tell they love each other. Great work 😊 Diane , from Rhode Island
She had that tradition for years going to the donut shop before church on Sunday morning, now I'm by myself and I go to the donut shop four or five times a week, meet my friends there sometimes do my Bible study, work on whatever I'm writing at the time for my UA-cam channel. I enjoy your videos little mo is really starting to talk good❤
Yet another amazing baker in the family!! Super job on the cupcakes Chloe!! Josiah's history lessons are fun!! It is refreshing to see him dress in his own personal style-very stylish!!😊
I love that you take the family for treats after church. Josiah looks great I love how he dresses♥️ Great job with the cupcakes Chole they look fantastic.❤️
You have a beautiful family! Always look forward to seeing the videos! I am a only child and always wanted a brother or sister!! Just one!! Lol! But love watching the busy family outings and the kids interacting with each other! Do the kids ride bikes or scooters? My grandkids love those battery operated ride on toys, and they can ride them in the house! Keeps them entertained for a bit!!
Always love watching your videos, I’m always waiting for the next one!! My husband with Alzheimers loves seeing all your adventures with Moses 2 to Josiah 21 and everyone in between!! Sending very best wishes to you all 🧑🏼🦳❤️⭐️
Awesome Sunday video that looks sooo yummy hope you had a wonderful and fun and safe and Blessed Sunday lots of hugs and love to you all sweet dearest friends The Happy Caravan 😊❤
In Australia we have a "Milk Bar" almost on every corner In the Suburbs a bit like your convenience stores, back in the day it was a kind of local kids hang out we still have them in Victoria 😊
When you all share your food it is just like my family we all take bites out of everything. My daughters boyfriend was horrified that we all share food and eat each other’s leftovers because his family would never do it . They eat from their own plate only.
Hi sweet lovely Amber Marc And their 10 sweet kiddos and one on the way. Hi MY sweet little Angel MELODY. Love❤ You. Tell Melody I love her denim Jacket. And she has her shades .Rock star' She's So COOL 😎 The girl has style. She's such a little rebel. She's a Blast Hahaha. Anna love your denim outfit the girl has good style. Chloe looks so cute in her pretty white dress. O' Boy Josiah IS HE going to a wedding. Looking so sharp for Church God is so delighted with him. Naomi very sweet looking lovely in her white dress Did Chloe and Naomi decided to dress the same. So cute. Done with Church. LET'S FORAGE ON to the milk bar and get our after Church desserts. Yummy! And take a break on the little Rock of Gibraltar . lol Amber I how you are always Glowing like a beautiful rainbow. Or is it the ice cream. lol Is that Chloe or Mama in the hat Little Mama Chloe adorable. Hi Chloe! Hi Moses!, Melody. Home sweet Home. Good catch Naomi sign her up for softball. LOL Time to Relax Enjoy the rest of the day Guys. Peace Love sweet Blessings ✌✌✌🤟🤟🤟❤❤❤🙏🙏 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXOOOOOOOOOOO P.S.''WOW'' Chloe those cupcakes look divine great job sweet girl. Watch out Naomi you have some competition there. lol Amber your girls are such connoisseur's in desserts and baking..
We have worn pants for a while. 5 years ago we went to an IFB church that said women shouldn’t wear pants but when we found out the music director there was a child predator we got out quickly and in the process we realized some things the church taught bordered on being cultish. So we have just looked at the Bible for ourselves and have tried to make the best choices for our family.
@@TheHappyCaravan Oh I see. Just sharing: I am Traditional Catholic since 2017. I used to wear jeans, bikinis, short skirts. Tank tops etc. I have since learned how immodest and displeasing and irreverent wearing mens britches is to Our Lord. I only wear pjs ( pants) in my home. I have never looked back. I wouldnt let a bloody predator interfere with what is pleasing to God. However, it is as you said,.. your decision.
It's good you buy lots of different snacks so you all get to share and taste it all i was in Barcelona few months ago stayed just about hour away and we went on the trains i forgot how much i like traveling by train 🤗🫶🙏
Please ignore negative comments. I think you do a great job with your kids. I think they are mature for their age even the little ones. Always a joy to watch your videos
Aw thanks! I’ve got a lot to learn as a mom still, I know that. I really appreciate your encouragement. ❤️
Thank you for taking us along on for your Sunday. I’ve heard about The Milk Bar, so it was fun to see what its treats are like. I’m impressed by how beautiful the tile pictures in the subway station are.
The children are so patient, loving, and respectful toward each other. That’s the going of great parents 🤍
It is so sweet that all of the kids share their treats. I am amazed at all the different stores and shops they have there and the wide variety of items you can buy. Tell Josiah I said he is a handsome Dapper young man. He is also very intelligent. Amber, you and Marc and have done an excellent job of raising your children. I don't think anyone could ask for better kids. Thank you for sharing your Sunday with us. God bless all of you. 🙏 I forgot, I love Josiahs jacket.
Aw Thank You! I will tell Josiah☺️
Yes! He is handsome, thoughtful, kind and yearns for knowledge ❤
I agree i would love to hear more history from Josiah
You're awonderful !mom Amber. Your children's hapiness and caring for one another are a testament to that! ❤
❤️🙏
Love Milk Bar! You have to try the Milk Bar Pie. Melt in your mouth good!!
A lovely family enjoying a lovely Sunday. It is heartwarming to witness.
I like how you trust ur kids to get to church etc by themselves and to not be afraid. You let them be independent but also have rules❤
I was going to say trust them to actually GO to church instead of decide to do something else lol
As a history buff myself, I always enjoy when Josiah gives a bit of historical information on NY and I am curious to know more! It would be so awesome for him to have a full episode once a week on The Happy Caravan, or even his own channel. He could take us on walking tours and through museums! And it also would add to his academic profile should he decide to pursue graduate school. Go for it Josiah!
Yes! I’ve told him that! He is like history encyclopedia. He remembers everything!
Yay, I hope he gives it a try! Just start with a pilot episode and see how it goes. I think there will be a lot of interest!!@@TheHappyCaravan
I love the snacks your family gets! Yummmm
Everyone’s fashion is so cool. Such a beautiful family.
Your family gives off such a great vibe. I love your videos. Beautiful family. Smart beautiful kids. A joy to watch your videos🦋
I just found your channel over the weekend. You have such a beautiful family! Your voice is so calming, and God’s love shines through you. I love NYC and enjoy the sites that you show. ❤
Thank you!❤️🙏🥰
I just discovered your channel today. Great fun to see your beautiful family enjoying my neighborhood. Milk Bar is wonderful!
I look forward to watching more of your adventures and learning more about your unique family. You all have an amazing dynamic that we need more of in this world! ❤
❤️❤️🙏🥰
Loved this video! Lot of Beautiful scenery of NY
Your eldest boy is so smart he knows a lot of trivial information I like how everyone shares and u go to a different place each week
The treats from The Milk Bar looked delicious!
As a kid, when I went to Sunday school (when in 5-6 grade, not the younger years), the teacher would teach the class then at the end, ask questions. Everyone who got the answer correct got a candy bar. Made all of us pay close attention to what the teacher was saying because those candy bars looked so good! I wonder how long it took to build all of the connecting NYC train stations ... can't even imagine. Thank you for another great video! 🙏❤
Oh my sweet Melody 🌹... rocking with her new sunglasses 👌💯... a little budding fashionista... looove her❤
I think the Sunday excursions are the best.Such beautiful children.I am always impressed.Stay safe.
I love what good eaters your kids are, especially sweet Moses!
❤️❤️🙏
You are doing a good job with these videos. Some of best. I would love to see You all on the high line if it ever stops raining. Should be gorgeous in fall. Maybe also a home school trip to the aquarium and lunch (picnic) on the boardwalk. I really feel like I am in NYC.
Yes! The highline is so fun!
It’s always fun to have a treat after church. Thanks for exploring another venue. Melody looked cute with her new sunnies! Chloe’s cupcakes looked divine. It’s great your kids are happy to try new foods .
The skateboarder in your family is quite talented! While everyone rocked their Sunday outfits!!
The way your children treat each other is the sweetest , I’m sure they fight but, 😊 you tell they love each other. Great work 😊 Diane , from Rhode Island
❤️❤️🙏
She had that tradition for years going to the donut shop before church on Sunday morning, now I'm by myself and I go to the donut shop four or five times a week, meet my friends there sometimes do my Bible study, work on whatever I'm writing at the time for my UA-cam channel. I enjoy your videos little mo is really starting to talk good❤
Yet another amazing baker in the family!! Super job on the cupcakes Chloe!! Josiah's history lessons are fun!! It is refreshing to see him dress in his own personal style-very stylish!!😊
Hello amber thank you for taking us along. I enjoy you taking us to along to yummy looking restaurants for a tasty snack after church.
Wish I was there for this fun adventure!! The treats look yummy!! Nice sweatshirt Elijah!! SDSU!!
I love that you take the family for treats after church.
Josiah looks great I love how he dresses♥️
Great job with the cupcakes Chole they look fantastic.❤️
❤️🙏
Love your parenting style
Fun Sunday! Thanks for taking us along ❤
You have a beautiful family! Always look forward to seeing the videos! I am a only child and always wanted a brother or sister!! Just one!! Lol! But love watching the busy family outings and the kids interacting with each other! Do the kids ride bikes or scooters? My grandkids love those battery operated ride on toys, and they can ride them in the house! Keeps them entertained for a bit!!
❤️❤️🙏
Your kids are so patient with one another! I love it❤
Im curious to learn more about that triangle. I love history and it has sparked my interest. Love all your vlogs cant wait for the next one 💜
I love gluten free snackies, looks super yummy 😋
I love watching all of your videos hi from north dakota
Nice job Chloe on the cupcakes.
Blessings to your family with Love
I’m so happy to hear of Pearl’s chamber music engagements!!! She’s such a beautiful player and will be in high demand!!! ❤️
Oh Amber, i know your a very busy lady but you never seem to rest. I worry about you! Please take care and get some rest!😊
Usually I get a nap on Sunday Afternoon! That really helps!🥰
Josiah carrying Moses is awesome. They are both cuties and so all your kids. Will love to meet them. I live in the Bay Area, Hayward.
Always love watching your videos, I’m always waiting for the next one!! My husband with Alzheimers loves seeing all your adventures with Moses 2 to Josiah 21 and everyone in between!! Sending very best wishes to you all 🧑🏼🦳❤️⭐️
Thank you!❤️🙏
Loving the constant content
This rocks 😊
Donuts after Church. Growing up we always stopped at a bakery the
Awesome Sunday video that looks sooo yummy hope you had a wonderful and fun and safe and Blessed Sunday lots of hugs and love to you all sweet dearest friends The Happy Caravan 😊❤
Thank you Sarah!❤️🙏
@TheHappyCaravan your welcome sweet dearest friends The Happy Caravan 😊 ❤️
In Australia we have a "Milk Bar" almost on every corner In the Suburbs a bit like your convenience stores, back in the day it was a kind of local kids hang out we still have them in Victoria 😊
Hi Amber and family! Greetings from Cleveland ❤
That casserole looks so good. I’m gonna have to make it! ❤
Hello 😍💝🌹 Have a nice day
Hi from Maine ❤ love your family
Mom and Dad great job
🙏❤️
That is a Beautiful Fruit Stand
We have a Milk Bar in DC. It’s good! I see that they sell birthday cakes so now I know where I will get my next one!
Yes! It’s super fun. We didn’t try the cake but I bet they are amazing!
Life is all “giggles”😂
I just love you all, I look for you guys everyday ❤may god continue to bless your family ❤
❤
When you all share your food it is just like my family we all take bites out of everything. My daughters boyfriend was horrified that we all share food and eat each other’s leftovers because his family would never do it . They eat from their own plate only.
Mmmmmm Red Velvet truffles
I get a bit confused with their names .... your son with the bow tie is so handsome!
❤️🙏
All that walking would wear me out.
Hi sweet lovely Amber Marc And their 10 sweet kiddos and one on the way. Hi MY sweet little Angel MELODY. Love❤ You. Tell Melody I love her denim Jacket. And she has her shades .Rock star' She's So COOL 😎 The girl has style. She's such a little rebel. She's a Blast Hahaha. Anna love your denim outfit the girl has good style. Chloe looks so cute in her pretty white dress. O' Boy Josiah IS HE going to a wedding. Looking so sharp for Church God is so delighted with him. Naomi very sweet looking lovely in her white dress Did Chloe and Naomi decided to dress the same. So cute. Done with Church. LET'S FORAGE ON to the milk bar and get our after Church desserts. Yummy! And take a break on the little Rock of Gibraltar . lol Amber I how you are always Glowing like a beautiful rainbow. Or is it the ice cream. lol Is that Chloe or Mama in the hat Little Mama Chloe adorable. Hi Chloe! Hi Moses!, Melody. Home sweet Home. Good catch Naomi sign her up for softball. LOL Time to Relax Enjoy the rest of the day Guys. Peace Love sweet Blessings ✌✌✌🤟🤟🤟❤❤❤🙏🙏 XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXOOOOOOOOOOO P.S.''WOW'' Chloe those cupcakes look divine great job sweet girl. Watch out Naomi you have some competition there. lol Amber your girls are such connoisseur's in desserts and baking..
Thank you! Yes they are very good at baking!❤️🙏
❤🎉 💯☑️
Did Little Melody get any of her cookie
Little Chloe was trying to help Melody get some of her cookie
Yes!
Beautiful family. Little confused. I thought your daughters only wore modest dresses and modest skirts. Did something change?
We have worn pants for a while. 5 years ago we went to an IFB church that said women shouldn’t wear pants but when we found out the music director there was a child predator we got out quickly and in the process we realized some things the church taught bordered on being cultish. So we have just looked at the Bible for ourselves and have tried to make the best choices for our family.
@@TheHappyCaravan Oh I see. Just sharing: I am Traditional Catholic since 2017. I used to wear jeans, bikinis, short skirts. Tank tops etc. I have since learned how immodest and displeasing and irreverent wearing mens britches is to Our Lord. I only wear pjs ( pants) in my home.
I have never looked back. I wouldnt let a bloody predator interfere with what is pleasing to God. However, it is as you said,.. your decision.
Hi
Uptown, Downtown, Midtown in NYC …not north and south
When's the baby due
Dec
December 6th❤️
@@TheHappyCaravan that's when my brothers is
Birthday
Amber is very lucky to have such a helpful family. I guess that's why she just keeps having more kids because everyone does all the hard work for her.
Why don't you create the life you want instead of getting online and whinning about other people's life.
Milk Bar. Yuck.
It was pretty good lol…
It's good you buy lots of different snacks so you all get to share and taste it all i was in Barcelona few months ago stayed just about hour away and we went on the trains i forgot how much i like traveling by train 🤗🫶🙏
Yes! It’s really fun to travel! I bet Barcelona was amazing!
❤