Neil deGrasse Tyson is back on Good Day New York, talking about his updated book, the universe and more! WATCH: ua-cam.com/video/ScAX6tJLgro/v-deo.html
@@KP-ru8fy true. I'm embarrassed as a 27 year old male this day and time. It's like they can't ever just let that shit slide. Embrace the video and science , and appreciate how great the interviewer actually is.
@@jpdseara Yeah man, I cried Because I have sympathy for all of the innocent women and young girls who are abused and raped in this World. I wonder how they feel when they read all of the perverted fucked up comments, one after the other, all over youtube and most of the internet. It's just straight up fucking immature. But hey I'm married and have a child so I guess I'm just a boring peice of shit since I don't want to take a science video and turn it into "filling black holes" and blah blah bullshit. So yeah, I cried. You must be too much of a man to cry. I want to be like you one day.
@David Stoker I smile and laugh all the time. There's nothing funny about reading "filling her black hole" and "I bet he fucked the interviewer after this" bullshit comment after comment, after comment. How about this David Stoker: Grow up.
@@jarnoaaltokoski255 That's inaccurate. An argument is not something you do. Its something you construct and/or offer. An argument is any set of propositions meant to convince someone of a claim statement or idea. It usually consists of one or more premises that work together in such a way that they guarantee the truth of the conclusion.
@@999-g4u Please let it be true and if you become one and make masterpieces just know that I will always be grateful to people like you,sharing your talent with us.
thomas GEORGE thanks bro, I’ll remember y’all when I start writing the script and screenplay. I’ll make a Sci-Fi film for y’all one day just gotta wait 🙏
I like this interviewer because she actually let's Tyson explain everything without interrupting him every other sentence. She also seemed to be really into the explanations and didn't seem bored or uninterested at all. She showed genuine curiosity and I truly appreciate that in an interviewer. Kudos.
@@MrRihanSaleemnah... People interject without understanding what's going on and being ignorant on topics all the time... She's just listening and enjoying the information and being a good host... It doesn't have to be anything more than that
The brain is 5D.. you can remember past events and relive them to the point you remember past knowledge you didn’t remember just a moment previously because you time traveled
I love how he's always enthusiastic talking about space. And loved how he gave the answer to her Black hole question, when it just swept away in conversation.
yeah I thought that too! such a brilliant person.. with new questions from one to another arises you think he just missed it but it's like every question are just being queued on his brain, none must left unanswered.
@@rahadban6442 Because he is hosting an entertainment show, not a scientific Q and A. Granted I don't think he's funny and I much prefer this style of interview, but even though they are both fruits, you are still comparing apples to oranges.
Neil deGrasse Tyson really just explained that you can’t change the past because it’s already there. Neil deGrasse Tyson explained the fourth dimension in a way no one else could, yet made it seem simple. I love this guy.
@@GuyBehindAComputer I haven't seen that movie yet. But yeah, basically same as end game. I don't know if you ever saw the show lost, but yeah same theory as in that movie too.
Same here, I couldn’t rap my head around the fourth dimension until Neil explained it. He is not only a genius but a gifted speaker and teacher. He is eloquent, precise, and knows how to make his talks interesting. Multitalented individual. I’m just happy being a dumbass plumber. It’s a living.
He ripped that off from Carl Sagan. Like everything else NDT does, it’s derivative. I’m just surprised he didn’t crap all over the movie because he’s the king of buzzkills.
The great part, of having him in an interview, is that he will explain why a movie had a certain part in it. He will explain the science in Science- Fiction. I actually felt better, after he said what a good job the director did, showing the science behind Interstellar.
@@science-y9209 Typical ignorance of a child. It's probably why you name yourself pricess and not queen. Lesson 1: If a woman is attractive a man will always want to dive into that hole (as long as she isn't related to him) Lesson 2: Attractives to a man is purely physical/chemical. It isnt controlled and it cant be turned on or off. It isnt mental like howwomen are attracted to men with money. If she is physically attractive a man will always be aroused. It is like a fundamental constant of our species (or all speceis on this planet). Lesson 3: The longer a man has gone without sex the more attractive every female becomes to him until eventually he will be aroused by any woman. It's like a sliding scale - the body needs what it needs. Think of food - when you are not huingry you don't want anything to eat. When you are a little hungry you are still fussy. When you are absolutely starving you can smell food from a mile away and will devour anyting. Women need mental stimulation I(man with more money than her to be preciws) whereas men only desire pysical qualities. A well proportioned body and reasonably symetrical face. Take this as a futue lesson for when you get married - deprive a man of sex and he will naturally look elsewhere. Dont become spiteful when he does. Lesson 4: The longer you have been married the less sex you probably get. Neil de grasse probably isnt getting any so yh he definitly wants to explore that hole. Lastly wanting to and doing are two different ttings.
The way he explained the waves in such a simple way that I couldn't understand before but now do just blew my mind..."The tide doesn't come in, we rotate around them"
@rakarimusic give me some cold hard facts about this hand shaking theory and I will totally give it a listen... right now it sounds like a whole lot of BS
@rakarimusicIt was a fictional movie that Neil was explaining...about a black hole that a planet revolved around. the tide was a tidal wave that the planet revolved around and also the time change was present which the black hole would account for...Also I'm not a religious person, I just had it pushed and ingrained into my mind from a young age...
Neil’s ability to communicate his concentrated understanding of reality is so advanced, that it somehow manifests its own gravity and pullt her to him.
except that the sun and moon don't have anything to do with tides. gravity is a constant but still no one can predict the tides. the only way is to observe and interpret the past levels
***** the only thing funky about pork chop chasing clown is his smell. FUNK CITY he is part of the big belly old farts club trying to keep America stupid. Teaching people to not think at all just do and think what we tell you is ok.
Interstellar is my favorite movie, I’ve seen it hundreds of times but one scene that always makes me emotional is when Murph asks her Father if her left her there to die because I know every child’s worst fear is to be abandoned by their parents, it doesn’t matter how old they are.
As a science teacher myself, somehow this movie slipped under my radar, and I never saw it until about a year ago. My mother had recorded it, and insisted I watch it since that's my field. In particular, she asked me to pay attention and see if I could understand the ending, because she was completely confused by it. So, I sat down and watched it with her, and I was impressed that I guessed what was going to happen at the end about an hour before the movie ended. I'll admit I was a bit confused at the start, but soon caught on to the main idea. She couldn't believe it, LOL. She was like, "There's no way you can know how it's going to end." Anyway, I thought it was a phenomenal film, from multiple points of view. All of the actors did an amazing job, the story was powerful and compelling, and the special effects, wow, absolutely mind blowing. I need to watch it again. Have a good one.
Still is my favorite movie! Not one part of the movie I don’t like, the part that tugs my heart every time is when he finally sees his daughter again. Such a pure moment for a movie , feels so real every time
Mine too. I lost my father 20 years ago but so much of the father-daughter interaction made me bawl my eyes out. And somehow helped to assuage my own grief.
I love how Neil deGrasse Tyson explains complicated matters to such a degree that anyone can understand them and adds a bit of humor into the mix. I could listen to this guy talk all day long without getting tired.
What a lovely interviewer. By that, I do not mean her looks but she actually let her guest speak. No fake laughing, no irritating interruptions. She was clearly a match for him.
+Executor009 i got it without ever reading that sorta stuff lol... i must say i preferred the alleged original planned ending where they went into the black hole and then rolled the credits. they died leave it there. the more happy go lucky one that takes from the over all sacrifice just seemed to take away from an over all good movie.
+Eddie Bryant somehow it seems 99% of the internet (maybe exaggerated) was "mind fucked" and didnt know how to explain the end. I don't see whats not to understand since everything is explained pretty well in the movie even for those who don't read stuff like this.
+Wealthy Pepsi It still doesn't make sense. If you're in the time dimension, you can "view" the timeline on Earth, but he influenced/changed it from the time dimension itself.
+PinYee Chin The Cosmos Series is great in many ways, including that soothing voice of Tyson's. So interesting that science information can come out sounding so gentle when it isn't about gentleness at all.
This is literally my favorite interview with Neil deGrasse Tyson. The woman is obviously enamored and into him, but in some ways we all are. I love her emotions and glances and arm movements. She is flirting with him, but he keeps it cool and scientific throughout the interview. I just like seeing it. This is what life is all about. Enjoy life everyone.
to me, it seemed like Neil was flirting with some of his touches, those might have been touches of an unconscious man while he is talking about his interest ( I do this mostly, yes, to females, a lot ) but nonetheless, maybe it just seemed to me this way.
@@jprtech1867 Lol I see where you're coming from, but if you watch interviews with other people male or female, he's always touching people like when he's laughing or when he's about to blow their mind with some crazy shit. I think that's just how he is
@@ViperOfMino I have wrongly commented my thoughts on this) sure, he is very reactive when he is absorbed by the question and tries to explain and grasp the attention of interviewer by doing such movements. Startalk episodes where he is interviewing in person rather than on Cam are a proof of that, Richard Dawkins interview as well. Anyways, this Mann doing a great job. Hope I'd be able to meet him in person someday!
How do the future humans build a wormhole for the past humans if they wouldn't exist if the past humans didn't already have the wormhole? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_paradox
msul78 he did not sayd that. he sayd an alien inteligent species could make, as a posibility, a warmhole. remember Cooper sayd 5th dimentional humans did that. as that IS possible in a long, long, long term future, there could be another alien species far more advanced THAN ours so they could be in a 5th dimentional life
@@thepowerofmyth being a prisoner of our own mind is the worst. Think about it this way. Being stuck in a room with the worst monster ever created by God and yourself. That is a fate worse then death.
i mean if u have fun doing science ur entire life u might as well have more fun speaking out everything u learnt its like how u would much rather share a happy memory than a sad memory
sorin bunea I liked it, but had a lot of issues with the inconsistencies of technology, particularly when they are leaving Earth they use a traditional rocketship, but when they get out of the Endurance to the other planets they are using very sleek science-fiction spaceships. And this is from Earth about 50 years from now when technology has totally declined.
@@jondstewart The rocket you saw in the movie, It is an actual launching of space craft from earth mounted with i max camera. he wanted the movie to be so realistic, So he did that. Anyway bro, you struck the right point.
I love how positiv and enthusiastic Dr Tyson is.. you can see he loves what he’s talking about and he explains everything so damn good!! You gotta love him!!
+chillhomie7 ye that is scientifically correct but that wount be you... and even if someone tells you about your life in lower dimension you wont be interested in it .. that life will look so limited to you.. example your are three dimensional creature .. and hypothetical two dimentional life seems crude to you right? ... like in 2d plane you can only move forward backward right lef...not up down ...so you will start to love 4 dimentions i 4d ..and forget old 3d ....
Interstellar is the best film ever to be made, not only is it a masterpiece by every micro-elemental film aspect, along with the mesmerising film score by Hans Zimmer but the effort, time, hard work and SCIENCE put into this film is fucking mind-blowing I'm scared we'll never have a film maker like Nolan after he goes... Living God.
They way Tyson describes science with his passionate hand motions, I think it would be complete acceptable for him to start describing porno's in the same manner.
We need more films like Interstellar and people like NDT. Interstellar is mindbending af but has so much amazing stuff in it. And Neil is just so damn good at explaining some of the craziest (astro)physic themes with enthusiasm in an understandable manner for someone with basic education.
The best interviews are the ones where both people are engaged and interested in what each other are saying. She's interested in talking to him and asking the questions, just as much as he's interested in answering the questions. Fantastic
I see passion everywhere in this video. Tyson talking about science and the movie so passionately. And interviewer so passionately learning on the spot.
This is what I love about the internet. You have all this science available to you. You could just check the latest science discoveries while eating breakfast.
Mathias Storm You have no idea, we can actually visit the Star Mall too. You simply go to NASA or Area 51 for the fancy shit and then blast off to the sun.
Tyson is great at explaining something so complex to a lamens term. He breaks everything down and makes it simple to understand what goes on in our universe. It's awesome.
I’m having hard time focusing myself on this interview because: 1. Neil’s hand gestures were very exciting 2. This girl is too damn hot 3. I’m pretty sure she wants to get nailed by Neil
ART GALLERY sure space is fake the only real thing is SPACE CAKE and i know you’re probably consuming one right now. Sorry I didn’t bother reading the rest after you said “space is fake”
I recently found a potential solution to the, "Why would the only viable planets be near a black hole?" complaint, because all that question really reveals is a misunderstanding of the plot, as recall, *SPOILERS* it was 5th dimensional *humanity* who put the wormhole there in the first place, and similarly it was 5th dimensional *humanity* who built the tesseract within Gargantua's gentle singularity. Its very likely that the reason 5th-dimensional humans sent the astronauts to *that* system -- to *those* planets around Gargantua -- is *because* its where the tesseract was built! Without which, none of the quantum data could have been relayed to Murphy back on Earth, and humanity could have never escaped their own extinction using 5th dimensional technology (manipulation of, or control over, gravity). Its true that in normal circumstances a black hole would be a very unlikely place for habitable planets to orbit, and would be a very unlikely place to call a new home, but these were *NOT* normal circumstances. Its even plausible that the 5th dimensional humans never intended the humans to settle those worlds at all!! They only needed to get Cooper to Gargantua for the successful end result
;) The first time I saw this film I didn't pick up everything despite loving it overall, but the more times I saw it, the more I understood its deeper layers, and the more it became one of my favorite films of all time.
Is it humanity, though? As far as I could tell, that was merely Cooper's speculation. There's no real evidence for that is there? They could be anyone/anything.
Well strictly speaking its true we never see the "Bulk Beings," but what we DO see is Cooper bring himself there via the tesseract they built for him, and subsequently speaking to his daughter through it to relay the quantum data, and as soon as he does so they close it down and send him back through the wormhole, implying heavily, along with the fact that the tesseract seemed to be exclusively feeding into Murph's bedroom, that he and his eventual connection with, and relaying the data to, Murph was the primary purpose of all that effort. And if you know anything about exobiology, or are familiar with the Drake equation, you know that it would be spectacularly less plausible for him or anyone to assume it was extraterrestrial beings who managed to find Earth, managed to understand Cooper and Murph's relationship, and who went to considerable lengths (wormhole, tesseract, etc.) to save humankind. Assuming it was God also isnt much better, as it gets us into "God of the gaps" territory, whereby historically speaking nearly *every* gap in our scientific knowledge has been used as a vessel for now-demonstrably fallacious religious explanations. In addition, it stands to reason that the quantum data, which we saw revolutionized our understanding of gravity in the film, served as the jumping off point that would foreseeably propel humanity toward the end Cooper speculated upon; that *WE* are the Bulk Beings, just not yet. The data discovered inside the singularity are the proverbial Oldowan tools if you know your anthropology (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldowan#/media/File:Oldowan_tradition_chopper.jpg), but if that data is primitive - as in a mere whisper of the technological power that is to come - then the Bulk Beings are the eventual end; they're the 50-foot supercomputer to that data's Oldowan hahaha and its likely Cooper realized that as well and used it to draw his conclusion; remember his speech when he got back? "I don't wanna know where we've been, I wanna know where we're goin..." I've often pondered the possibility, in these words, that "God exists, and heaven exists, just not yet." That is, the proposal of God-like powers in all of our religious posits may not need to be taken so literally, and can instead be seen as a kind of artifact of human intuition; an intense feeling that those capabilities are possible, somewhere and somehow, but I've always considered them more plausibly realized by ourselves (or even alien species) and not by an almighty, absentee God. In philosophy we call em "Omniqualities." Omnipotence (All-powerful over the forces of nature), Omniscience (all-knowing; insight into every fabric of the cosmos, which for the bulk beings is presumably complete control over where and when they want to go), Omnibenevolence (all-good, though what is ethically "good" is a more dicey discussion), immortality, etc. We tend to see these things are far-flung, inaccessible states of being for humanity, but there are many who believe technology is racing us toward that point at an exponential rate thanks to science in general, and apparently Cooper is one of those people, having assumed, as you said, that the Bulk Beings are human. It *IS* true we're never given a satisfying confirmation of who or what they actually are, as sufficiently advanced alien civilizations are just as likely to end up with those capabilities as we are, but now we're back to the "How would an alien species be able to find us, understand us, understand Cooper and Murph, conclude that they - being a spectacularly more advanced species - should *help* us as opposed to use us an livestock, etc." Even within NASA there was the starting assumption that they were aliens until Cooper made it inside the tesseract and garnered a different perspective, which could have been a point of further mystery and conflict in the film (who was right? Nasa or Cooper?), but apparently Nolan felt that definitively showing us one way or the other was unnecessary for the story he wanted to tell to. I tend to side with Cooper however. Its more plausible for me to assume the quantum data are the proverbial Oldowan tools; a whisper of the technological splendor that awaits in humanity's future. In real life, a lot of this stuff hinges on how humanity handles climate change and if we survive this sixth, human-caused mass extinction event if you wanna know the brutal truth! Hahaha
Argumentum Ab Auctoritate: One of the weakest forms of argument. It doesn't matter if Neil DeGrasse Tyson says something or my two-year old nephew. Truth is truth. Neil DeGrasse Tyson can be wrong, my nephew can be correct, only the truth of the statement matters.
David Benner Is it an argument from authority or asking people to show they possess the necessary skills to make a valid and informed argument against the points being made here? Argument from authority would be: Dr Tyson said it so you are all wrong. Whereas many here are calling the points made by a person who possesses the necessary skills wrong. The name of the person as you say is irrelevant, however many try to make it relevant. Here is can be argued it is, as the person involved obviously has the skills to make informed statements. Rebuttals to these points could be incorrect or not, but if the dissenters do not possess the skill sets to make informed statements about a VERY deep subject, the likelihood they are correct is quite low. It is a fair question to ask others to prove they possess the skills, which could be demonstrated by having a degree. I know for one I do not have them. I do the same boiled down reading like the rest of us do. The two seem similar, but they are not.
David Benner is there a fallacy defined by the act of someone identifying fallacies as the sole means of diminishing an argument? i see this all the time from kids who just took philosophy 101. science is filled with assumptions. they are humanities best assumptions from people who know more about a subject than anyone who doesn't study professionally.. but they are still assumptions. the fact that scientists assume things doesn't mean your 5 year old nephew's ideas hold equal weight to the leading scientists in a subject. people who dedicate their lives to intensively studying a physical science are going to be able to avoid the initial logical pitfalls that every layman will make. tl;dr you're nephew is a dumbass child while tyson is pretty smart
mank demes yes, it's the fallacy fallacy. It says you can't conclude that an argument is incorrect just because the speaker committed a logical fallacy. However, he is correct that the OP used an argument from authority. Yes, tyson is a very knowledgeable person about the subject but that doesn't mean he doesn't make mistakes and people can't correct him.
Ricardo Amendoeira I dont know. Argument from authority is a fallacy, yet what if you are a layman debating that authority, especially with such an advanced field? It would be like me debating operating procedures with a neurosurgeon. Your chances of being right do exist, but they are vanishingly small.
I just love Neil, 😂 such a great personality. Hes talking about an astronomical event and a everyday event blowing my imagination up and then he says " ...well fine." 💓
I like how NDT is visually trying to explain something, with hand gestures and general body actions. It's like he's seeing exactly what he's explaining ☺ The way the lady is following that is absolutely epic!!!
I liked how he was able to answer every question using the 7 basic soul train dance moves...if he didn't end up balls deep after that performance, she's just an ice queen
Girl: I'm so awestruck, nice to see you. Can you survive falling into a black hole? Neil: No, you'd be split in part, probably starting at the base of your spine, then in half until you're just atoms. Girl: Nevermind.
love the way he explains things, anyone could understand it, and love his positive energy . Just bought his book, cant wait to read the shit out of it . much love Neil
This man is awesome, I like how HE likes explaining Interstellar. He definetely liked it. And Nolan is awesome. And Interstellar is incredible, a masterpiece. And the interview Tyson-Nolan should be incredible. Everything is amazing =)
I would rather talk to her than my own girlfriend about this stuff as my girlfriend just tells me to shut up. This woman at least listens and from what i saw in this video, she takes it all in. The added bonus that she is an attractive girl.
This is pure gold. I am freakin out right now. Stunning! His way to explain is incredible. And the pure possibility that we could "visit" a black hole some day/minute/second/etc...
ive never played Bioshock or seen much of it , im generally a RPG loving person , but since i found it in the comment section of this video i might try , coz are you saying its science heavy and stuff ?
Nah it's not. It's imaginative but from a science standpoint it's very inaccurate and makes up most stuff. I'd rather you play the original Bioshock with the underwater city tho.
I think Bioschock Infinite is a masterpiece, though I haven't played with the original, but I really prefer the sandbox-like sunny, beautifully grotesque environment in Infinte to the slightly claustrophobic, darkish one in the Original. This is definitely subjective. Infinite' story is awesome and the action is great too if a bit repetitive, but it's is almost as innovative as bullet time in Max Payne
play bioshock infinite. if you like crazy sci fi based stories, you will LOVE bioshock infinite. its not too hard of a game, and if you are feeling overwhelmed, you can just try a lower difficulty.
Loool i read the comments after commenting and no one talks about what they are talking about but instead they talk about neil being into her and how she is on it from start :))
![Neil deGrasse Tyson on Aliens, Mars & Why an Asteroid Might Flatten Earth [Full Interview]](/img/n.gif)
Neil deGrasse Tyson is back on Good Day New York, talking about his updated book, the universe and more! WATCH: ua-cam.com/video/ScAX6tJLgro/v-deo.html
That lady was an awesome interviewer. She asks questions and then shuts up to let the guest speak. Kudos to her.
finally a comment related to her intelligence and not about him "filling her black hole" from disgusting male youtubers
@@KP-ru8fy true. I'm embarrassed as a 27 year old male this day and time. It's like they can't ever just let that shit slide. Embrace the video and science , and appreciate how great the interviewer actually is.
@alexandra sounds easier than it is
@@jpdseara Yeah man, I cried Because I have sympathy for all of the innocent women and young girls who are abused and raped in this World. I wonder how they feel when they read all of the perverted fucked up comments, one after the other, all over youtube and most of the internet. It's just straight up fucking immature. But hey I'm married and have a child so I guess I'm just a boring peice of shit since I don't want to take a science video and turn it into "filling black holes" and blah blah bullshit. So yeah, I cried. You must be too much of a man to cry. I want to be like you one day.
@David Stoker I smile and laugh all the time. There's nothing funny about reading "filling her black hole" and "I bet he fucked the interviewer after this" bullshit comment after comment, after comment. How about this David Stoker:
Grow up.
The way Neil simplifies things to an easy understanding makes you feel smart enough to have a conversation with him
But u can't! He argues so well!!
@@praneet4078 If it's a conversation, then you don't have to argue with him. If you have to argue, then it is a debate. At least partly so.
Self deprecation at its best
@@jarnoaaltokoski255
That's inaccurate. An argument is not something you do. Its something you construct and/or offer.
An argument is any set of propositions meant to convince someone of a claim statement or idea. It usually consists of one or more premises that work together in such a way that they guarantee the truth of the conclusion.
@@mig-stallion1359 😭😭💀 wtf
We need more movies like "Interstellar"
Josua Bosch I don’t think we’ll ever get
Nikil Kc I’ll make a movie one day for y’all lol, I always want to be a future filmmaker gotchu boys
@@999-g4u Please let it be true and if you become one and make masterpieces just know that I will always be grateful to people like you,sharing your talent with us.
@@999-g4u what's your name sir?
thomas GEORGE thanks bro, I’ll remember y’all when I start writing the script and screenplay. I’ll make a Sci-Fi film for y’all one day just gotta wait 🙏
I like this interviewer because she actually let's Tyson explain everything without interrupting him every other sentence. She also seemed to be really into the explanations and didn't seem bored or uninterested at all. She showed genuine curiosity and I truly appreciate that in an interviewer. Kudos.
cool
Its because shes trying hard to understand. If she knows beforehand what he says then only can she contribute
@@MrRihanSaleemnah... People interject without understanding what's going on and being ignorant on topics all the time... She's just listening and enjoying the information and being a good host... It doesn't have to be anything more than that
And she had perky nipps
I like this interviewer for other reasons
Trying to understand interstellar 5D in my 3D world . Watching on a 2D screen and understanding in my 1D brain
The brain is 5D.. you can remember past events and relive them to the point you remember past knowledge you didn’t remember just a moment previously because you time traveled
Unoriginal
if this ain’t me
☺️Haha... Very well put! Thanks for putting a smile on my 1D Face ☺️
Isn't that from Sciencephile ? 😂😂
I love how he's always enthusiastic talking about space. And loved how he gave the answer to her Black hole question, when it just swept away in conversation.
I was so happy he went back to that question, because I wanted to hear the answer and it did get initially get swept away in coversation
yeah I thought that too! such a brilliant person.. with new questions from one to another arises you think he just missed it but it's like every question are just being queued on his brain, none must left unanswered.
It's always really nice seeing someone who loves what they do.
Black hole theory was wrong.nasa found light emission from black hole.just opposite of what we knew.so they soon gonna update the black hole theory
It takes a smarter person to clearly explain intelligence while respecting the person while not patronizing them. Thank you, Neil deGrasse Tyson!
donnell outlaw Brian Green is really good that way too
If the interviewer was Jimmy Fallon, he’d constantly interrupt Neil with dumb jokes and fake laugh way too much
Shut up you stupid bastard, I'm WAY smarter than you!!
@@rahadban6442 Because he is hosting an entertainment show, not a scientific Q and A. Granted I don't think he's funny and I much prefer this style of interview, but even though they are both fruits, you are still comparing apples to oranges.
It takes somwone who studied and inderstood the material. Thus is proof he is smart but not proof he is smarter than her.
Neil deGrasse Tyson really just explained that you can’t change the past because it’s already there. Neil deGrasse Tyson explained the fourth dimension in a way no one else could, yet made it seem simple. I love this guy.
Like Avengers Endgame
@@kbanghart More like TENET..... whats happened, happened !
@@GuyBehindAComputer I haven't seen that movie yet. But yeah, basically same as end game. I don't know if you ever saw the show lost, but yeah same theory as in that movie too.
Same here, I couldn’t rap my head around the fourth dimension until Neil explained it. He is not only a genius but a gifted speaker and teacher. He is eloquent, precise, and knows how to make his talks interesting. Multitalented individual. I’m just happy being a dumbass plumber. It’s a living.
He ripped that off from Carl Sagan. Like everything else NDT does, it’s derivative. I’m just surprised he didn’t crap all over the movie because he’s the king of buzzkills.
Interviewer: Can I have a hug
Neil: Oh, arghublugudughud, okay!
Dallas Finley 😆😆😆
🤣
Hahah
😂😂😂😂
I heard him: "Oh, I'm a hugging boy, okay". Not sure but makes sense 😂
Well if Tyson agrees with the science of Interstellar, you know the movie is awesome.
And he knows where science ends and film-making begins and acknowledges those liberties.
The great part, of having him in an interview,
is that he will explain why a movie had a certain
part in it. He will explain the science in Science-
Fiction. I actually felt better, after he said what
a good job the director did, showing the science
behind Interstellar.
Best Movie of All-time, Nolan masterpiece
Ross Coe but the film is considered one of the best
callmecatalyst Wait did you just write all that
“If there’s a black hole here and not over there, go over there” - Neil deGrasse Tyson
This guy commented for comedy, and everyone took it seriously
There was a black hole right next to him. Bet he wished he fell straight into it.
Hahahahahahahah Man
@@bastadtroll8922 no he did not...
None of the two ever wanted to fall into each other..
@@science-y9209 Typical ignorance of a child. It's probably why you name yourself pricess and not queen.
Lesson 1: If a woman is attractive a man will always want to dive into that hole (as long as she isn't related to him)
Lesson 2: Attractives to a man is purely physical/chemical. It isnt controlled and it cant be turned on or off. It isnt mental like howwomen are attracted to men with money. If she is physically attractive a man will always be aroused. It is like a fundamental constant of our species (or all speceis on this planet).
Lesson 3: The longer a man has gone without sex the more attractive every female becomes to him until eventually he will be aroused by any woman. It's like a sliding scale - the body needs what it needs. Think of food - when you are not huingry you don't want anything to eat. When you are a little hungry you are still fussy. When you are absolutely starving you can smell food from a mile away and will devour anyting. Women need mental stimulation I(man with more money than her to be preciws) whereas men only desire pysical qualities. A well proportioned body and reasonably symetrical face. Take this as a futue lesson for when you get married - deprive a man of sex and he will naturally look elsewhere. Dont become spiteful when he does.
Lesson 4: The longer you have been married the less sex you probably get. Neil de grasse probably isnt getting any so yh he definitly wants to explore that hole.
Lastly wanting to and doing are two different ttings.
The way he explained the waves in such a simple way that I couldn't understand before but now do just blew my mind..."The tide doesn't come in, we rotate around them"
@rakarimusic I'm sorry but that doesn't make any sense that my mind can even try to relate to the physical world
@rakarimusic ooohhhh... So it's like GOD is a child or a baby and Earth is a toy...Okay I get it now
@rakarimusic your no Neil but I'm pretty sure you can teach kindergarden
@rakarimusic give me some cold hard facts about this hand shaking theory and I will totally give it a listen... right now it sounds like a whole lot of BS
@rakarimusicIt was a fictional movie that Neil was explaining...about a black hole that a planet revolved around. the tide was a tidal wave that the planet revolved around and also the time change was present which the black hole would account for...Also I'm not a religious person, I just had it pushed and ingrained into my mind from a young age...
that 18 minutes went by in 2 seconds. i could listen to this man talk fo rthe rest of my life.
Right? Time dilation
Due to Neil's magnetic personality.
He could do it too
Neil’s ability to communicate his concentrated understanding of reality is so advanced, that it somehow manifests its own gravity and pullt her to him.
65 years old and now I finally understand the tides, thanks Neil.
stop being old.
except that the sun and moon don't have anything to do with tides. gravity is a constant but still no one can predict the tides. the only way is to observe and interpret the past levels
Mark Edwards except that the moon and sun have everything to do with the tides and we can predict them
man, the way neil moves, he's officially the funkiest scientist on this planet
lol
+Ben Knight (KnightVision) probably because this is the only scientist you know of.
Sean RobinsonJR
the only funky one, find me a funkier one (non fictional) and i'll happily name him the new funkiest scientist on the planet
It's a huge shame that he's a massive asshole.
***** the only thing funky about pork chop chasing clown is his smell. FUNK CITY he is part of the big belly old farts club trying to keep America stupid. Teaching people to not think at all just do and think what we tell you is ok.
Interstellar is my favorite movie, I’ve seen it hundreds of times but one scene that always makes me emotional is when Murph asks her Father if her left her there to die because I know every child’s worst fear is to be abandoned by their parents, it doesn’t matter how old they are.
As a science teacher myself, somehow this movie slipped under my radar, and I never saw it until about a year ago.
My mother had recorded it, and insisted I watch it since that's my field. In particular, she asked me to pay attention and see if I could understand the ending, because she was completely confused by it.
So, I sat down and watched it with her, and I was impressed that I guessed what was going to happen at the end about an hour before the movie ended. I'll admit I was a bit confused at the start, but soon caught on to the main idea.
She couldn't believe it, LOL. She was like, "There's no way you can know how it's going to end."
Anyway, I thought it was a phenomenal film, from multiple points of view. All of the actors did an amazing job, the story was powerful and compelling, and the special effects, wow, absolutely mind blowing.
I need to watch it again.
Have a good one.
Still is my favorite movie! Not one part of the movie I don’t like, the part that tugs my heart every time is when he finally sees his daughter again. Such a pure moment for a movie , feels so real every time
Mine too. I lost my father 20 years ago but so much of the father-daughter interaction made me bawl my eyes out. And somehow helped to assuage my own grief.
If the interviewer was Jimmy Fallon, he’d constantly interrupt Neil with dumb jokes and fake laugh way too much
i get cancer every time i watch him and then i watch him again get another more painful cancer
Amziah you're the dick for not getting a fucking joke
You mean Jimmy Kimmel?
Mayowa Ilesanmi both but more Jimmy Fallon
@@amziah8028 I love you too amziah
I love neils hand gestures when he laughs, he always has to touch the person next to him if he's in range. I love him hes my goddamn hero.
It's only to females I think (I say I think because I haven't looked into it). It's a sexual thing.
LMFAOOO
Verbal Vertigo so what is he bisexual now?
He did this in an interview with MKBHD also, so it is not just with women. ua-cam.com/video/pqQrL1K0Z5g/v-deo.html
NOOOO It's NOT a sexual thing. He does it to men all the time as well. Do your homework before you making silly statements.
I loved interstellar
And it's very cool to hear it getting a 8 or 9 out of 10 from the great neil degrasse tyson
That's awesome
CheesyPnut98 I mean kip Thorne is just as great as Neil maybe even better
He said it’s an 8 or 9 out of 10 based on realism. He probably gives the actual movie a 10/10
@@weepo2651 it would be unfair to compare two scientists who have specialised in two completely different fields, or maybe branches of the same field.
@@weepo2651 not maybe dude. Kip is one of the smartest individuals on the planet. A tv astronomer such as Dr. Tyson realises this as well.
If it wasn't for this guy, I would never have understand some of these concepts. He always makes it so easy to understand. Thank you Sir for that.
I think Dr T would be very happy to know that. Im in the same boat.
I would love to see Tyson explain something with his hands tied on his back.
What do you expect...He's Italian.
Hand gestures are great for presentation what do you mean?
He looks Black/Latino cross to me.
he means it would be hard for him to explain something without his hand gestures
You woudn't understand a thing...
I love how Neil deGrasse Tyson explains complicated matters to such a degree that anyone can understand them and adds a bit of humor into the mix. I could listen to this guy talk all day long without getting tired.
Yes, his ability to explain complex science in an understandable manner is a true talent! It’s a major reason for his successful career.
He to me, is like a teacher in elementary school. Full of passion and loves everything about science. Him and bill nye are two great educators!
Dr. Tyson entered some "black holes" later that night. XD
Multiple?
anus, vagina and mouth
so ''yes'' multiple xD
DankMaster this guy knows what I'm talking about ;)
***** i am dank what u expect :p
Funniest comment I've ever seen on the youtube
What a lovely interviewer. By that, I do not mean her looks but she actually let her guest speak. No fake laughing, no irritating interruptions. She was clearly a match for him.
Can you imagine you being at the same theatre as Neil when watching Interstellar, and everybody asking him to explain the movie in the end
Am I the only one who understood the end the first time?
+Felis the Weirdo i got it too. read some about M-theory years ago.
+Executor009 i got it without ever reading that sorta stuff lol... i must say i preferred the alleged original planned ending where they went into the black hole and then rolled the credits. they died leave it there. the more happy go lucky one that takes from the over all sacrifice just seemed to take away from an over all good movie.
+Eddie Bryant somehow it seems 99% of the internet (maybe exaggerated) was "mind fucked" and didnt know how to explain the end. I don't see whats not to understand since everything is explained pretty well in the movie even for those who don't read stuff like this.
+Wealthy Pepsi It still doesn't make sense. If you're in the time dimension, you can "view" the timeline on Earth, but he influenced/changed it from the time dimension itself.
I wonder what it would have been like to interview Albert Einstein
She would squirt right in his face
@@littledgy4316 you won the internet
@@ronaldoquintos1675 Not even close. God VS dust.
@@hamzaelbezzaf8881 yeah and dust have gone.....
It depends at what stage of Einstein's life before or after he became coocoo
His voice is so sooooothing. Is it weird i play this in the background when i need to get work done
+PinYee Chin The Cosmos Series is great in many ways, including that soothing voice of Tyson's. So interesting that science information can come out sounding so gentle when it isn't about gentleness at all.
+SANKOFA X Thanks so much for telling us about this!
+PinYee Chin Neil is my Spirit animal. He breathes inspiration :D
+Jean ii Symphony of Science. Look that up
Kyle Walker I did, so thank you, Kyle Walker. Nice.
This is literally my favorite interview with Neil deGrasse Tyson. The woman is obviously enamored and into him, but in some ways we all are. I love her emotions and glances and arm movements. She is flirting with him, but he keeps it cool and scientific throughout the interview. I just like seeing it. This is what life is all about. Enjoy life everyone.
to me, it seemed like Neil was flirting with some of his touches, those might have been touches of an unconscious man while he is talking about his interest ( I do this mostly, yes, to females, a lot ) but nonetheless, maybe it just seemed to me this way.
Oh my god, I thought I was the only one who noticed that! They were both into each other (but I think Neil is married - uh oh!)
@@jprtech1867 Lol I see where you're coming from, but if you watch interviews with other people male or female, he's always touching people like when he's laughing or when he's about to blow their mind with some crazy shit. I think that's just how he is
@@ViperOfMino I have wrongly commented my thoughts on this) sure, he is very reactive when he is absorbed by the question and tries to explain and grasp the attention of interviewer by doing such movements. Startalk episodes where he is interviewing in person rather than on Cam are a proof of that, Richard Dawkins interview as well.
Anyways, this Mann doing a great job. Hope I'd be able to meet him in person someday!
"Yes I said 8 planets" Shots fired
LOL 😄 Shots fired! Fuckin A right!
Shots fired indeed
Sheldon loves Pluto
More like planets fired. One no longer has a job.
Derelict Friend LOL
If I understood the movie correctly, It's not aliens it's the future humans who built the wormhole.
msul78 how do you build a worm hole though? How did they build the tesseract?
***** They scienced the shit out of it.
msul78 They also manufactured the reality in which we live in
How do the future humans build a wormhole for the past humans if they wouldn't exist if the past humans didn't already have the wormhole? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_paradox
msul78 he did not sayd that. he sayd an alien inteligent species could make, as a posibility, a warmhole. remember Cooper sayd 5th dimentional humans did that. as that IS possible in a long, long, long term future, there could be another alien species far more advanced THAN ours so they could be in a 5th dimentional life
You are a Prisoner of the present, forever transitioning between the past and the future.
BOOM 🤯
technically , There's no past or future its just cusuality.
I feel like prisoner is a harsh context for the riches of life. The only thing we fall prisoner to are other humans and their decisions and actions.
@@SABbrew I wish that were true. But you can be a prisoner of your mind all by your youself
I read this just as he was saying it.
@@thepowerofmyth being a prisoner of our own mind is the worst. Think about it this way. Being stuck in a room with the worst monster ever created by God and yourself. That is a fate worse then death.
This man is a master pickup artist with his cosmo talk
W rizz
Quantum rizzics
This is a good example of how the degrasse performs his mating dance and hypnotize his prey.
Dude you just killed me!!!!!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hahahahaha, I hoped that I would not be the only one thinking that
Time Traveler ...she liked him before she met him.
I agree; this woman is FINE!!
Here we see a wild DeGrasse spit that science game in order to find a mate. The females willingness to mate is evidenced by the dropping of panties.
brought to you in high quality VHS
This has to be the best science teacher EVER. I could listen to this guy for hours.
Absolutely true!
Neil is just a genius he can answer you while doing his tai chi workouts lol
3:44 on Mute. You're welcome.
LMFAO
hahahaha. my man
HAHAHAHA OMFG
LMAO i choked on my own spit from laughing man
you sir are a fucking legend...someone make a gif of this
Neil degrasse Tyson reminds me of an enthusiastic child excited to share the new thing he learned in school.
If I had had a science teacher like Neil, I would have loved it enough to devote my life to it, as I'm attemping to do now.
Bingo, you hit that nail on the head with a sledgehammer. Child like enthusiasm , bingo
@@lesodell3489 easily and well said
i mean if u have fun doing science ur entire life u might as well have more fun speaking out everything u learnt its like how u would much rather share a happy memory than a sad memory
Interstellar, best movie ever
sorin bunea I liked it, but had a lot of issues with the inconsistencies of technology, particularly when they are leaving Earth they use a traditional rocketship, but when they get out of the Endurance to the other planets they are using very sleek science-fiction spaceships. And this is from Earth about 50 years from now when technology has totally declined.
@@jondstewart The rocket you saw in the movie, It is an actual launching of space craft from earth mounted with i max camera. he wanted the movie to be so realistic, So he did that. Anyway bro, you struck the right point.
notchjohnson1 okay millennial!
Jon Stewart you dropped the ball with the millennial thing...damn boomer🤣
Thomas Haney I’m a generation X’er born in 1967
I pity everyone who doesn’t know.. never heard of this guy. He’s such an unbelievable legend
He is awesome. He loves his line of work so much, that he enjoys telling ppl and does so in a interesting way to keep you locked on to what he says.
Every time am all ears when he's talking with so much passion and enthousiasm about astronomy.👏
I love how positiv and enthusiastic Dr Tyson is.. you can see he loves what he’s talking about and he explains everything so damn good!! You gotta love him!!
I really hope when i die i will wake up in the 4th dimension and be able to live through any part of my life again.
+chillhomie7 ye that is scientifically correct but that wount be you... and even if someone tells you about your life in lower dimension you wont be interested in it .. that life will look so limited to you.. example your are three dimensional creature .. and hypothetical two dimentional life seems crude to you right? ... like in 2d plane you can only move forward backward right lef...not up down ...so you will start to love 4 dimentions i 4d ..and forget old 3d ....
+chillhomie7 ... not any, every
Douglas Smith Very interesting. Thats what I believe will happen when we die.
+chillhomie7 So you want to be trapt in a paradox?
Thesamurai1999 Being able to move between dimensions and through time sounds like freedom to me.
I wish I could spend a year learning from this man. He is one of my role models.
Tyson: *explains science*
Interviewer: 😃⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂
that's literally me whenever anyone is explaining anything to me
?,......
When Neil speaks everybody listen...
kirby march Barcena when I speak nobody listen
even chuck norris
kirby march Barcena including beautiful women wearing black and white dresses on UA-cam channels...
kirby march Barcena ,when he farts everyone smells .
kirby march Barcena Amen
7:43 Her name is Simone Boyce
Yes and she hasn't posted on her Facebook since August 21, 2019 as of the time of this comment :-)
David C. The fuck
@@David-zj3bp 😅😂😂😂
@@David-zj3bp Time is relative folk
Maybe for her it's just a few minutes since 21 august 2019.
@@David-zj3bp you took it too far
This was the best explained interstellar ending... "Accessing the time line at will". Superb Neil
Interstellar is the best film ever to be made, not only is it a masterpiece by every micro-elemental film aspect, along with the mesmerising film score by Hans Zimmer but the effort, time, hard work and SCIENCE put into this film is fucking mind-blowing I'm scared we'll never have a film maker like Nolan after he goes... Living God.
Totally agree! Interstellar is a masterpiece
Best film gotta be Saving Private Ryan bro. Not a day should go by where we don't remember those men.
They way Tyson describes science with his passionate hand motions, I think it would be complete acceptable for him to start describing porno's in the same manner.
+1 and if you don't get more thumbs up, I will slice my testicles with dental floss.
( please guys, I really appreciate my testicles )
Turn down the volume and see if you can imagine him talking about porn.
*****
...jup, it really works ^^
science through interpretive dance
*****
3:20 5:35 10:00 10:45 most especially my favorite part @ 11:00
"no no no, you're rotating towards the wave" - mind blown.
Oh wow; who but scientist knew.
We need more films like Interstellar and people like NDT. Interstellar is mindbending af but has so much amazing stuff in it. And Neil is just so damn good at explaining some of the craziest (astro)physic themes with enthusiasm in an understandable manner for someone with basic education.
When I first saw this movie I thought the ending was stupid....now I realise that I was stupid
Edit: thank you for all the likes!
It's purely theoretical, so you are stupid, the ending is nonsensical.
@@MarkMcDaniel no fuck off
@@theambergryphon4266 yep
When I first saw the movie I knew it was stupid. Later I realised that movie really is stupid
@@AydarBMSTU no fuck off
I can listen to whatever Neil is gonna say for months and never get bored. This guy has the entire galaxy on his head..
Some of this comments are the reason humans won't last long
Your right usually when there is a video about science comment be flooded with science but here I can’t see anything
"Some of these comments..."
@ prince Herod ....i like you!
@@Mavrik9000 right.. alot of unwanted babies being made.. and I'm not saying unwanted by us, but by the parents themself
good one XD
The best interviews are the ones where both people are engaged and interested in what each other are saying. She's interested in talking to him and asking the questions, just as much as he's interested in answering the questions. Fantastic
I see passion everywhere in this video. Tyson talking about science and the movie so passionately. And interviewer so passionately learning on the spot.
A useful rule of thumb: When you don't understand what the other person is talking about, just smile and nod. Always works.
Yeah? Until the other person asks you what you think. Nodding don't work for that.
'I think it's cool' works everytime
Akinlolu Oderinde The point of the joke was that she was nodding and smiling so much it just seems like she doesn't understand any of it
It's like watching Hillary Clinton
Akinlolu Oderinde
"Yes"
damn i just watched an 18 min. video and felt as if only 5 min. passed
+Samuel Gonzalez Are you in a worm whole bro?
+Samuel Gonzalez thats relativity folks!
No folks, that's called marijuana LOL
+Israel 😂😂😂
+Israel I am smoking weed tho...
I love how she appears to be so engaged with him. That is an awesome sense of respect to the speaker.
It's just a movie man 😌
Did you hear any other movies talking about that deeply
That's the greatness of
CHRISTOPHER NOLAN
@@thetoothbrushfromnisemonog8340 wrong, Interstellar is a better version of 2001 a space Odyssey
Can we stop comparing Movies & start enjoying them all
@@thetoothbrushfromnisemonog8340 doesn't that matter they have both made plenty of masterpieces.
@@thetoothbrushfromnisemonog8340 just to pay respect to Kubrick doesn't mean to degrade or any other movie maker in modern times
This is what I love about the internet. You have all this science available to you. You could just check the latest science discoveries while eating breakfast.
Exactly hehe.
Neil degrasse Tyson: How to pick up hot chicks with science 101
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
She's a cupcake 🤩
I was just thinking, I bet he wanted to give her one of his now-legendary "special" handshakes.
Damn, how did they stay in space for 18 minutes without a suit, and without dying. Civilization has come far
Mathias Storm You have no idea, we can actually visit the Star Mall too. You simply go to NASA or Area 51 for the fancy shit and then blast off to the sun.
niels only sexual tension here is him and the science tbh
Mr.Misklanius 😂😂😂😂😂
Very true 😂😂
This interview is superb! Both of them made this video seem shorter than 18mins, impressive.
Tyson is great at explaining something so complex to a lamens term. He breaks everything down and makes it simple to understand what goes on in our universe. It's awesome.
He learned/motivation from the best:)
I’m having hard time focusing myself on this interview because:
1. Neil’s hand gestures were very exciting
2. This girl is too damn hot
3. I’m pretty sure she wants to get nailed by Neil
ART GALLERY sure space is fake the only real thing is SPACE CAKE and i know you’re probably consuming one right now. Sorry I didn’t bother reading the rest after you said “space is fake”
OMG!! Who's That LADY? I Wanna Married HER!! :D (Y)
she wants to get Neil’d.
@@lysg9432 this comment needs more appreciation
Can’t blame her nor you for not be able to focus lol
I recently found a potential solution to the, "Why would the only viable planets be near a black hole?" complaint, because all that question really reveals is a misunderstanding of the plot, as recall,
*SPOILERS*
it was 5th dimensional *humanity* who put the wormhole there in the first place, and similarly it was 5th dimensional *humanity* who built the tesseract within Gargantua's gentle singularity. Its very likely that the reason 5th-dimensional humans sent the astronauts to *that* system -- to *those* planets around Gargantua -- is *because* its where the tesseract was built! Without which, none of the quantum data could have been relayed to Murphy back on Earth, and humanity could have never escaped their own extinction using 5th dimensional technology (manipulation of, or control over, gravity).
Its true that in normal circumstances a black hole would be a very unlikely place for habitable planets to orbit, and would be a very unlikely place to call a new home, but these were *NOT* normal circumstances. Its even plausible that the 5th dimensional humans never intended the humans to settle those worlds at all!! They only needed to get Cooper to Gargantua for the successful end result
SystemFreaKk13 I approve this comment.
I approve this aswell.
;)
The first time I saw this film I didn't pick up everything despite loving it overall, but the more times I saw it, the more I understood its deeper layers, and the more it became one of my favorite films of all time.
Is it humanity, though? As far as I could tell, that was merely Cooper's speculation. There's no real evidence for that is there? They could be anyone/anything.
Well strictly speaking its true we never see the "Bulk Beings," but what we DO see is Cooper bring himself there via the tesseract they built for him, and subsequently speaking to his daughter through it to relay the quantum data, and as soon as he does so they close it down and send him back through the wormhole, implying heavily, along with the fact that the tesseract seemed to be exclusively feeding into Murph's bedroom, that he and his eventual connection with, and relaying the data to, Murph was the primary purpose of all that effort.
And if you know anything about exobiology, or are familiar with the Drake equation, you know that it would be spectacularly less plausible for him or anyone to assume it was extraterrestrial beings who managed to find Earth, managed to understand Cooper and Murph's relationship, and who went to considerable lengths (wormhole, tesseract, etc.) to save humankind.
Assuming it was God also isnt much better, as it gets us into "God of the gaps" territory, whereby historically speaking nearly *every* gap in our scientific knowledge has been used as a vessel for now-demonstrably fallacious religious explanations.
In addition, it stands to reason that the quantum data, which we saw revolutionized our understanding of gravity in the film, served as the jumping off point that would foreseeably propel humanity toward the end Cooper speculated upon; that *WE* are the Bulk Beings, just not yet. The data discovered inside the singularity are the proverbial Oldowan tools if you know your anthropology (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oldowan#/media/File:Oldowan_tradition_chopper.jpg), but if that data is primitive - as in a mere whisper of the technological power that is to come - then the Bulk Beings are the eventual end; they're the 50-foot supercomputer to that data's Oldowan hahaha and its likely Cooper realized that as well and used it to draw his conclusion; remember his speech when he got back?
"I don't wanna know where we've been, I wanna know where we're goin..."
I've often pondered the possibility, in these words, that "God exists, and heaven exists, just not yet." That is, the proposal of God-like powers in all of our religious posits may not need to be taken so literally, and can instead be seen as a kind of artifact of human intuition; an intense feeling that those capabilities are possible, somewhere and somehow, but I've always considered them more plausibly realized by ourselves (or even alien species) and not by an almighty, absentee God.
In philosophy we call em "Omniqualities." Omnipotence (All-powerful over the forces of nature), Omniscience (all-knowing; insight into every fabric of the cosmos, which for the bulk beings is presumably complete control over where and when they want to go), Omnibenevolence (all-good, though what is ethically "good" is a more dicey discussion), immortality, etc.
We tend to see these things are far-flung, inaccessible states of being for humanity, but there are many who believe technology is racing us toward that point at an exponential rate thanks to science in general, and apparently Cooper is one of those people, having assumed, as you said, that the Bulk Beings are human.
It *IS* true we're never given a satisfying confirmation of who or what they actually are, as sufficiently advanced alien civilizations are just as likely to end up with those capabilities as we are, but now we're back to the "How would an alien species be able to find us, understand us, understand Cooper and Murph, conclude that they - being a spectacularly more advanced species - should *help* us as opposed to use us an livestock, etc."
Even within NASA there was the starting assumption that they were aliens until Cooper made it inside the tesseract and garnered a different perspective, which could have been a point of further mystery and conflict in the film (who was right? Nasa or Cooper?), but apparently Nolan felt that definitively showing us one way or the other was unnecessary for the story he wanted to tell to.
I tend to side with Cooper however. Its more plausible for me to assume the quantum data are the proverbial Oldowan tools; a whisper of the technological splendor that awaits in humanity's future.
In real life, a lot of this stuff hinges on how humanity handles climate change and if we survive this sixth, human-caused mass extinction event if you wanna know the brutal truth! Hahaha
For those of you trying to correct Neil deGrasse Tyson, please, present your astrophysics degree and not your Wikipedia link.
Argumentum Ab Auctoritate: One of the weakest forms of argument. It doesn't matter if Neil DeGrasse Tyson says something or my two-year old nephew. Truth is truth. Neil DeGrasse Tyson can be wrong, my nephew can be correct, only the truth of the statement matters.
David Benner Is it an argument from authority or asking people to show they possess the necessary skills to make a valid and informed argument against the points being made here?
Argument from authority would be: Dr Tyson said it so you are all wrong.
Whereas many here are calling the points made by a person who possesses the necessary skills wrong. The name of the person as you say is irrelevant, however many try to make it relevant. Here is can be argued it is, as the person involved obviously has the skills to make informed statements. Rebuttals to these points could be incorrect or not, but if the dissenters do not possess the skill sets to make informed statements about a VERY deep subject, the likelihood they are correct is quite low. It is a fair question to ask others to prove they possess the skills, which could be demonstrated by having a degree.
I know for one I do not have them. I do the same boiled down reading like the rest of us do.
The two seem similar, but they are not.
David Benner is there a fallacy defined by the act of someone identifying fallacies as the sole means of diminishing an argument? i see this all the time from kids who just took philosophy 101. science is filled with assumptions. they are humanities best assumptions from people who know more about a subject than anyone who doesn't study professionally.. but they are still assumptions. the fact that scientists assume things doesn't mean your 5 year old nephew's ideas hold equal weight to the leading scientists in a subject. people who dedicate their lives to intensively studying a physical science are going to be able to avoid the initial logical pitfalls that every layman will make.
tl;dr you're nephew is a dumbass child while tyson is pretty smart
mank demes yes, it's the fallacy fallacy. It says you can't conclude that an argument is incorrect just because the speaker committed a logical fallacy. However, he is correct that the OP used an argument from authority. Yes, tyson is a very knowledgeable person about the subject but that doesn't mean he doesn't make mistakes and people can't correct him.
Ricardo Amendoeira I dont know. Argument from authority is a fallacy, yet what if you are a layman debating that authority, especially with such an advanced field? It would be like me debating operating procedures with a neurosurgeon. Your chances of being right do exist, but they are vanishingly small.
2021 here. Great lecture from one of the greatest and the interviewer is amazing. Asks/listens: period!
Perfect!!!
The comments here have nothing to do with the video which is oddly unsurprising.
SWAPAN JAIN if its unsurprising, then surely it isnt that odd.
There is a lot of sexually frustrated guys in these comments as we can see.
notchjohnson1 speaking of nerd virgins
"Can I have a hug coz my brain hurts". She's so cute ❤️
Ah she is haha!
3:25 pause and watch till 4:00 ON MUTE
dude.. hahahaha
😂😂😂
oh my god, I loved that!!!
thank you
Baahahaha
I just love Neil, 😂 such a great personality. Hes talking about an astronomical event and a everyday event blowing my imagination up and then he says " ...well fine." 💓
I like how NDT is visually trying to explain something, with hand gestures and general body actions. It's like he's seeing exactly what he's explaining ☺ The way the lady is following that is absolutely epic!!!
He is the Louis Armstrong of Physics... an absolute treasure. G*d and the Universe bless this man
I wish I had deGrasse as my high school science teacher. His explanation of how tidal waves work was wonderful. And the girl clearly wanted DeGrasse
His hotel room door got a knock about 6 hours after this interview.
It was a "go".
lol wowwwww
For sure. She was throwing it at him.
MUSICMUSIC MUSIC
Yeah for real...no famous married dudes have ever cheated on their wives.
I was thinking of this same shit man! Lol
DAVID BAKER you checked the facts it is some science right there congrats 🎈🍾🎉!
I liked how he was able to answer every question using the 7 basic soul train dance moves...if he didn't end up balls deep after that performance, she's just an ice queen
Nah man not every scenario is meant for reproduction
6:02
Neil: It happens daily.
Interviewer: *NO!!!*
Neil: What the hell is wrong with you?!!
I Lol'd
😂
Soma Chakraborty for a split second he stopped and looked at her ugly.
She was excited lol cringeeeeee
"No" here is meant as a short for "no way" depicting disbelief lmao calm down xD
I love how passionate Tyson speaks about this stuff
me: watches interstellar
me: goes on UA-cam to compare my thoughts with Neil
Girl: I'm so awestruck, nice to see you. Can you survive falling into a black hole?
Neil: No, you'd be split in part, probably starting at the base of your spine, then in half until you're just atoms.
Girl: Nevermind.
love the way he explains things, anyone could understand it, and love his positive energy . Just bought his book, cant wait to read the shit out of it . much love Neil
Are u in a hurry
😂😂
This man is awesome, I like how HE likes explaining Interstellar. He definetely liked it. And Nolan is awesome. And Interstellar is incredible, a masterpiece. And the interview Tyson-Nolan should be incredible. Everything is amazing =)
I totally agree. This man is my model... I wish I could reach him one day!
Whoever tagged your comment as spam is a dick bro. I agree with your point of view; deGrasse Tyson is awesome!
why is a positive comment spam
Watching this high at 1am in 2020 😂
Beat ya, 2am
coronavirus
2am too, lol
3:27 here!
Damn what's good guys kinda early here.. 12:17
fantastic dr Tyson now its 2021 and I miss your tv shows so much please try to get a new show.
Reporter is like: "Yeah, mm hmm! Oh yeah! I have no idea what the fuck you're talking about." :)
I would rather talk to her than my own girlfriend about this stuff as my girlfriend just tells me to shut up. This woman at least listens and from what i saw in this video, she takes it all in. The added bonus that she is an attractive girl.
***** She certainly takes it all in. ^_^
***** That's for sure! Ha! :()
***** yes because a female reporter wants the D every time she interviews a guy
crossxfuse this one does lol
3:26 I love how see follows Neil's hands movements with her eyes hahaha. She's so concentrated in what he is saying
Who's watching in 2018 and not being able to sleep after what he said about the tidal waves?
2020
while i watched the movie the first time i knew they were tidal waves made by gargantua only, because i know why the tide is forming by our moon
2020 quarantine
Anoni Moo same here
@@anonimoo2158 yea me too 2020 qurantine!! thinking how a mere fuckin virus is threatning the whole humanity!!! what a joke!
This is pure gold. I am freakin out right now. Stunning! His way to explain is incredible. And the pure possibility that we could "visit" a black hole some day/minute/second/etc...
I'm sure she would give him time in her space.
rlly niguh
very good.
man I want to travel to the center of that black hole, if you know what I mean ;)
I wonder if she would mind if i was to ask her if "I could enter Uranus?"
Hot Potatoes hahaha!
I'd pay to watch Neil play Bioshock Infinite.
He will have a heart attack XD
ive never played Bioshock or seen much of it , im generally a RPG loving person , but since i found it in the comment section of this video i might try , coz are you saying its science heavy and stuff ?
Nah it's not. It's imaginative but from a science standpoint it's very inaccurate and makes up most stuff. I'd rather you play the original Bioshock with the underwater city tho.
I think Bioschock Infinite is a masterpiece, though I haven't played with the original, but I really prefer the sandbox-like sunny, beautifully grotesque environment in Infinte to the slightly claustrophobic, darkish one in the Original. This is definitely subjective.
Infinite' story is awesome and the action is great too if a bit repetitive, but it's is almost as innovative as bullet time in Max Payne
play bioshock infinite. if you like crazy sci fi based stories, you will LOVE bioshock infinite. its not too hard of a game, and if you are feeling overwhelmed, you can just try a lower difficulty.
Besides many topics, he explained the ocean tides in a way so easy to understand--thanks. Incredible insights in this awesome interview!
How awesome would it be to be born in another thousand years with all the memories of now and see how far we've come.
Loool i read the comments after commenting and no one talks about what they are talking about but instead they talk about neil being into her and how she is on it from start :))
Erdinc Ayse Now we can tell how stupid people nowadays they dont have any proper knowledge of Science
leo paoulo corpus You forgot to include "are" in "stupid people ARE nowadays" sir.
You say problem, I say purpose. You think everything aside from reproduction is intentional?
i never get tired of hearin him preach
Watch this video on mute and look at Neil's hand gestures. LOL
He looks like he's using the force at some points
+PyschoLllama 9:57 on mute
+PyschoLllama she looks impressed
+PyschoLllama she looks impressed
+isaias gomez One one the few youtube comments that made me laugh out loud... Nicely done sir
His non-verbal communication is straight up poetic.