Horn of Africa Origins of Proto-Afro-Asiatic

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 55

  • @jamesstewart917
    @jamesstewart917 Місяць тому +1

    Excellent video. Much needed.

  • @carlakimmons5020
    @carlakimmons5020 3 роки тому +6

    Hallelujah thank you my brother for your time and effort that you put into your presentation you truly are a blessing thank you so much

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      I will explain how haplogroup debunk ham Sam and Japheth.
      DE and CF came From CT
      And CT have ony two sons wich is CF and DE
      and CT came from BT
      and BT had 2 sons wich is B and CT
      And you say
      Ab is ham
      And de is ham
      And cf is Japheth
      Bro your meaning about ham , Sam and Japheth dosent make any sense when talking about haplogroups
      Bro CF. and DE came from one single father wich is CT.
      Now you can see it doesn’t make sense
      ------------------------------------
      But here is Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade.
      While Hamitic lineage e1b1a is the responsible haplogroup for Bantu languages and Niger-Congo languages
      Skriv til

    • @مااجملالقططفيالمنزل
      @مااجملالقططفيالمنزل 9 місяців тому

      ​@@Football-ko1ji😂😂😂😂سلالة j1 هذي سلالة ليست ساميه ..
      سلالة j1 قوقازية روسيه وهم خزر لا اصل لهم وهم غجر نور بدو لا علاقه لهم بالانبياء سلالة j1 سلالة اسميها سلالة الشيطان هم منبع الفساد في الارض وهم قتله وهم نسائهم يتعرون عرق عورات لا مانع عندهم الدعارة بنسائهم لكي يتوصلو الى مايرغبون اليه بحيث من المعلوم ان اكثر ابناء الخزر كانو رق عند ابناء سام

  • @amirblack3149
    @amirblack3149 3 роки тому +4

    Everyone is now using the phenotype site since I put them on to some things I see, by the way this was a good video, and makes the most sense for a African Model. This is Ngozi

  • @maxcali863
    @maxcali863 3 роки тому +7

    They may have been closed to Eastern Ethiopid based on the location rather then central Ethiopid based on how Semitic populations look now phynotipicly.

    • @mahadomar5944
      @mahadomar5944 3 роки тому +2

      Eastern ithiopia is somalis region ..ogadenia..the largest part of ithiopia..most dominant dna e1b1b...cushite Hamitic...originals are somalis afar oromo and other kushites, but heshaba and tigryna came from Yemen and they are semtics.....

    • @sofias6681
      @sofias6681 2 роки тому

      @@mahadomar5944 Somalia afar oromo cushtic people orginal India and Africa you are 💯 the semetic people tigrey and amhara origin from south arabian Yemen oman 💯

  • @BeiAbedanAfrikayim
    @BeiAbedanAfrikayim 3 роки тому +4

    Very informative

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      I will explain how haplogroup debunk ham Sam and Japheth.
      DE and CF came From CT
      And CT have ony two sons wich is CF and DE
      and CT came from BT
      and BT had 2 sons wich is B and CT
      And you say
      Ab is ham
      And de is ham
      And cf is Japheth
      Bro your meaning about ham , Sam and Japheth dosent make any sense when talking about haplogroups
      Bro CF. and DE came from one single father wich is CT.
      Now you can see it doesn’t make sense
      ------------------------------------
      But here is Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade.
      While Hamitic lineage e1b1a is the responsible haplogroup for Bantu languages and Niger-Congo languages
      Skriv til

  • @thehebrewofisrael
    @thehebrewofisrael  3 роки тому +6

    11:25 - Video Starts
    This video covers the Horn of Africa Origins of Proto-Afro-Asiatic. Leon Bender (1997) proposed a scenario upon linguistic grounds wherein Semitic languages originated in Ethiopia in the Horn of Africa and crossed the Red Sea. Christopher Ehret, S.O.Y Ketia and Paul Newman (2004) proposed placed the Afro-Asiatic homeland in the Horn of Africa as well. The geography of the E-M35/E-M215 lineage could be of Horn African origin which largely is concordant with the range of Afro-Asiatic.

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      I will explain how haplogroup debunk ham Sam and Japheth.
      DE and CF came From CT
      And CT have ony two sons wich is CF and DE
      and CT came from BT
      and BT had 2 sons wich is B and CT
      And you say
      Ab is ham
      And de is ham
      And cf is Japheth
      Bro your meaning about ham , Sam and Japheth dosent make any sense when talking about haplogroups
      Bro CF. and DE came from one single father wich is CT.
      Now you can see it doesn’t make sense
      ------------------------------------
      But here is Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade.
      While Hamitic lineage e1b1a is the responsible haplogroup for Bantu languages and Niger-Congo languages
      Skriv til

    • @thehebrewofisrael
      @thehebrewofisrael  2 роки тому

      @@Football-ko1ji There are other models that you can check out that have your belief concerning phylogeny.
      ua-cam.com/video/oPs5WlcF5vc/v-deo.html
      However Haplogroup J is not Semitic. Haplogroup E is Afro-Asiatic.

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      @@thehebrewofisrael Here I will make myself very clear
      j-p58 is responsible for semetic language. As all Arabs and the Cohen( descendants of Aaron) are j1c3d. And j1c3d is Abraham lineage because it fits very well.
      E1b1* is nearly 40-50 thousand years old so it’s not Abraham.
      The natufians were all exact e-z830 within only E1b1b
      While e1b1a people spoke Proto-niger-Congo-languages and bantu languages
      and e1b1a has absolutely nothing to do with Afro asiatic languages because e1b1a never ever was in levant. E1b1a was always in west/central Africa since e1b1 spiltet 50.000 years ago.
      Now Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade
      Very simple.

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      @@thehebrewofisrael Bro stop making yall own science and stop lying to people
      BT have 2 sons wich is CT and B
      B never ever came from CT it’s impossible
      CT have only 2sons wich is CF and De
      You know very well ham and Shem and Japheth don’t even make sense when we use haplogroups😊

  • @Poopick
    @Poopick 8 місяців тому +1

    Thank you for this journy, it was facinating to finaly find out another historical points of my roots. I have heared a hundred times in school about stories from our first big compiled collection of folklore, the TN"K. But i recently realized the other side of the story. A few months ago i found out about this meme culture of "proto-indo-european pride" of some sort. And i wanted to emerse myself in it, but it felt wrong. I dont even look indo european in any way.
    So finaly i know what happened. Now i need to find what their culture was like

  • @gutemaguutuu5117
    @gutemaguutuu5117 6 місяців тому

    My ancestors used to live 400years, 460 years, 360 years. It's like 10 to 20 generations ago. Great great great ... grand parents. This history told in our community.

  • @supercigar123
    @supercigar123 3 роки тому +3

    Nice

  • @Afro_CreoleFBA
    @Afro_CreoleFBA 3 роки тому +3

    Very good 👍

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      I will explain how haplogroup debunk ham Sam and Japheth.
      DE and CF came From CT
      And CT have ony two sons wich is CF and DE
      and CT came from BT
      and BT had 2 sons wich is B and CT
      And you say
      Ab is ham
      And de is ham
      And cf is Japheth
      Bro your meaning about ham , Sam and Japheth dosent make any sense when talking about haplogroups
      Bro CF. and DE came from one single father wich is CT.
      Now you can see it doesn’t make sense
      ------------------------------------
      But here is Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade.
      While Hamitic lineage e1b1a is the responsible haplogroup for Bantu languages and Niger-Congo languages
      Skriv til

  • @ohali5668
    @ohali5668 2 роки тому +2

    Semite orgin is Northeast africa or the horn Eritrea and Ethiopia then the ethioeritrean people migrated to arabia to expand the semite language and then came back to horn of africa

    • @mohbulshaawi597
      @mohbulshaawi597 2 роки тому +2

      No that not true the semitic speaking people in horn are cushitic people that shifted their language into semitic 3000 years ago after they colonized southern arabia that people was ancient Agaw

    • @ohali5668
      @ohali5668 2 роки тому

      @@mohbulshaawi597 Yeah agaw people are the father of habeshas

    • @mohbulshaawi597
      @mohbulshaawi597 Рік тому

      @@ohali5668 yes and still there is Agaw/Awi speaking their cushitic language

    • @ohali5668
      @ohali5668 Рік тому

      @@mohbulshaawi597 One Habesha 💚💛❤️, if we Ethiopian and eritrean re-unite we will be one of the strongest country in the world #MEGA Make Ethiopia Great Again.

    • @poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276
      @poorindiansanddogsarenotal1276 Рік тому

      @@ohali5668 the greater somalia will emerge soon

  • @johnhill9445
    @johnhill9445 2 роки тому +4

    One Love ETHIOPIA

    • @Football-ko1ji
      @Football-ko1ji 2 роки тому

      I will explain how haplogroup debunk ham Sam and Japheth.
      DE and CF came From CT
      And CT have ony two sons wich is CF and DE
      and CT came from BT
      and BT had 2 sons wich is B and CT
      And you say
      Ab is ham
      And de is ham
      And cf is Japheth
      Bro your meaning about ham , Sam and Japheth dosent make any sense when talking about haplogroups
      Bro CF. and DE came from one single father wich is CT.
      Now you can see it doesn’t make sense
      ------------------------------------
      But here is Afro asiatic languages and it’s many haplogroups
      Here is the haplogroup that is responsible for the languages
      Semetic languages =. J1c3 / j-p58 known as j1e they all the same sublade.
      Ancient Egyptian= E1b1b / em78 subclade
      Cushitic languages(son on Cush)= E1b1b/ ev32 sublade
      Berber-Libyan =. E1b1b / em81 subclade
      All Chadian languages =. R1B. / R1b-v88 subclade.
      While Hamitic lineage e1b1a is the responsible haplogroup for Bantu languages and Niger-Congo languages
      Skriv til

  • @Jackrobert28
    @Jackrobert28 3 роки тому

    What about paternal haplogroup T-M70 ?

    • @thehebrewofisrael
      @thehebrewofisrael  3 роки тому +2

      Haplogroup LT en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haplogroup_LT

    • @Jackrobert28
      @Jackrobert28 3 роки тому +1

      @@thehebrewofisrael This one specifically . en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haplogroup_T-M184
      I have this haplogroup family. Is this Semitic ?

    • @skp8748
      @skp8748 Рік тому

      @@Jackrobert28 lool I got that wtf does it mean...

  • @maxamedabdiabukar2567
    @maxamedabdiabukar2567 3 роки тому +2

    👍👍👍

  • @gutemaguutuu5117
    @gutemaguutuu5117 6 місяців тому +1

    I have East African Hunters and gatherers, Natufian and Nilots DNA.

  • @zealousforyah1008
    @zealousforyah1008 2 роки тому

    Any videos explaining the haplotypes of the Nephelim offsprings who are still with us?👀

  • @shawnharris8637
    @shawnharris8637 3 роки тому +2

    YAAAP+

  • @abanduazar2612
    @abanduazar2612 3 роки тому

    Tamazight does not belong to the Afro-asiatic languages, but the Berber language is related to the language of the Greeks
    And the Basque and the Songhay language

    • @NONEOFYOURBIZ69
      @NONEOFYOURBIZ69 2 роки тому

      Tons of E y chromosome out in that part of the world... So basically they are genetically close to semites in a sense