fantastic rendition. The same kriti by mr.shankaran namboodri is also worth appreciative on the same lines. India has great talents for which all of us are proud of
Nice performance. It is nice to see youngsters taking to carnatic music. The entire orchestra is a novel idea. With little more SAADHNA they can scale very high. Very novel and nice program. We should encourage such young and talented musicians.
Nicely rendered by the whole team. Original song had devotion..and love for the divine. Im searching for it in this song. IF anyone found it, pls let me know
Depends on your sense of devotion. Some say its in hymns, some in songs. We can easily find the devotion, Your ability to find divinity is Lord;s gift if we are not able to find it , it is our ignorance, not the creator's mistake.
Pallavi నగు మోము కన లేని నా జాలి తెలిసి నన్ను బ్రోవ రాదా శ్రీ రఘువర నీ (నగు) Anupallavi నగ రాజ ధర నీదు పరివారులెల్ల ఒగి బోధన జేసే వారలు కారేయ్3అటులుండుదురే నీ (నగు) Charanam ఖగ రాజు నీయానతి విని వేగ చన లేడో గగనానికిలకు బహు దూరంబనినాడో జగమేలే పరమాత్మ ఎవరితో మొరలిడుదు వగ జూపకు తాళను నన్నేలుకోరా త్యాగరాజ నుత నీ (నగు)
i am not against karthik, but his attempt is appreciating...but none of his classical songs had the feel in it...just people bow there head because of his establishment in field of music... feel so sad things are changing in wrong way and hope indian classical music will be lost in few years!
Though I am not a critic of blending two different traditions of music and it is pleasant listening.. what is really saddening is the SOUL of Sri Thyagaraja pleading to Lord Rama through this song is completely lost in our need to blend!! Encourage to write your own lyrics and fusion the music the way you want.. but leave the great composers lyrics who have ENLIGHTENED our spirits and invoked LORD RAMA through such soulful kritis.. For Lord Rama's sake.. please STOP this conFUSION. Pranams!!
Absolutely right! The singing is not bad per se, but the arrangement is horrible! The bass lines are totally off-base! The drum pattern does violence to the spirit of the song. Either the flute or the key-boards are off-tune. The bassist has no clue what to do.....looks like he is desperate to do something with the time that has landed on his lap. I just finished commenting how good their "aasai mugam marandhu pochche" only to find this travesty. To all those who say "so many people like therefore it should be good" is like telling that there is a market for illicit drugs, therefore, it must be good! Good music should elevate and soften the mind. This looks like a masala dosa being offered as prasadam.
Having heard many versions definitely better than Yesudas , however while improvising with other instruments, should have drifted from the traditional song, still feel nothing like the Nadaswaram , Tavil combination you hear during marriage, those proffessionals do much better
Carnatic music has his fragrance mainly in gamaka...flat swaras are just flowers and gamaka is like garland made of fresh flowers...so please don't spoil..
sir guitar makes this song more beutiful.. without chords the song woud not be beutiful as you think.... and it helps the singer to sing comfortably........
different feelings sir.. piano is more romantic smooth... guitar is little aggressive... take it as a diferent segment sir... please dont mix up this with claasical music.... both of it have their own beuty and we feel good after hearing the music that's all i wanted ###generation gap.....
Saint tyagaraja's compositions are soulful, When hearing the same composition in Balamurali's voice was soooo divine... this seems to be like light music... a very bland rendition. The emotion and feel is missing. It seems like he is singing in a wedding reception rather than a carnatic concert. Innovation is good, but in the name of innovation killing the original jeevan of a composition is not appreciable. and the singer himself is distracting us from unflavored gestures.
there are lot of new singers and musicians are forming in TAMIL NADU, most of them trying something new and spoilling the the whole carnatic music, please give respect to your own carnatic music, don't mix all carnatic music uising with western instruments into it,, world is changing but you people never change....every country have their own music, but your Tamil nadu copy western, arab music and mix into carnatic why? don't try it respect your own carnatic and hinduistan music it's enough for all
The violin and the harmonium are Western in origin, but we use them in our music, just as we use the mandolin, mouth organ and so on. Just as we all use any number of Western equipment in our daily lives, including the recording instruments this video was recorded on. Stop being so backward looking. God is not interested in how you were dressed when you died, but in how you lived your life,
Most of the songs (all) of Tyagaraja's kirtis were composed in Tamil Nadu, a fertile ground for classical music. Even today we have only few guy in Tanjavoor who can make Veena... It will soon fade away as we don't buy them enough and patronize them... Lalgudi Jayaraman and Kunnakkudi Vaidyanathan made violin a popular Carnatic accompaniment.. Adapt to change or perish..
Below avg level of singing and backing .....swara singing too ....the real fragrance of abheri comes only when it ornamented with its own unique gamkas..for understanding that need lot of good listening and practice....plz dont try to mix hindustani in this beautiful composition or if u want to fuse it do it without insulting the tradition of both system and raga bhavam..sorry to say.
Too bad. Lame attempt. He should listen to Balamurali's to understand and learn where to break the words in lyrics. Flute is thousand times better. He's marvellous.
Having heard many versions definitely better than Yesudas , however while improvising with other instruments, should have drifted from the traditional song, still feel nothing like the Nadaswaram , Tavil combination you hear during marriage, those proffessionals do much better
fantastic rendition. The same kriti by mr.shankaran namboodri is also worth appreciative on the same lines. India has great talents for which all of us are proud of
OMG.. amazing . luvly
Brilliant in every sense. Loved it to the core. Hats off Karthik.
There is noteven a single note that has been missed.Fabulous improvisation. .kudos Mr.Karthik you have a unique style...love your singing.
అద్భుతం అంటే ఇదే నెమో సూపర్ సాంగ్
fantastic song , congrts to the whole team..........
Nice performance. It is nice to see youngsters taking to carnatic music. The entire orchestra is a novel idea. With little more SAADHNA they can scale very high. Very novel and nice program. We should encourage such young and talented musicians.
You can complain all you want but look at the number of listeners for this video. Proof is in the pudding.
Flute is amazing ! Congrats to the whole team ! (even though a bit difficult to digest a mix with Western Instruments ! )
A veshti would have been better!
Rama Chandran Please critic the music, not sure your comment is very relevant!
awesome flute
i think the bass guitar steals the show!!!
I think it is Keith Peters on Bass Guitar
Super raag sir & so very very good voice
awesome..without any rough...
Awesome!
Excellent Brighas.
Nicely rendered by the whole team.
Original song had devotion..and love for the divine.
Im searching for it in this song. IF anyone found it, pls let me know
Depends on your sense of devotion. Some say its in hymns, some in songs. We can easily find the devotion, Your ability to find divinity is Lord;s gift if we are not able to find it , it is our ignorance, not the creator's mistake.
good one.
Pallavi
నగు మోము కన లేని నా జాలి తెలిసి
నన్ను బ్రోవ రాదా శ్రీ రఘువర నీ (నగు)
Anupallavi
నగ రాజ ధర నీదు పరివారులెల్ల
ఒగి బోధన జేసే వారలు కారేయ్3అటులుండుదురే నీ (నగు)
Charanam
ఖగ రాజు నీయానతి విని వేగ చన లేడో
గగనానికిలకు బహు దూరంబనినాడో
జగమేలే పరమాత్మ ఎవరితో మొరలిడుదు
వగ జూపకు తాళను నన్నేలుకోరా త్యాగరాజ నుత నీ (నగు)
6
Chemin, I agree
Romba sumaar
Also, lacking sruthi in the swaras.....overall, a lousy job. You are very kind with your remarks.
i am not against karthik, but his attempt is appreciating...but none of his classical songs had the feel in it...just people bow there head because of his establishment in field of music... feel so sad things are changing in wrong way and hope indian classical music will be lost in few years!
Though I am not a critic of blending two different traditions of music and it is pleasant listening.. what is really saddening is the SOUL of Sri Thyagaraja pleading to Lord Rama through this song is completely lost in our need to blend!! Encourage to write your own lyrics and fusion the music the way you want.. but leave the great composers lyrics who have ENLIGHTENED our spirits and invoked LORD RAMA through such soulful kritis.. For Lord Rama's sake.. please STOP this conFUSION. Pranams!!
Absolutely right! The singing is not bad per se, but the arrangement is horrible! The bass lines are totally off-base! The drum pattern does violence to the spirit of the song. Either the flute or the key-boards are off-tune. The bassist has no clue what to do.....looks like he is desperate to do something with the time that has landed on his lap. I just finished commenting how good their "aasai mugam marandhu pochche" only to find this travesty.
To all those who say "so many people like therefore it should be good" is like telling that there is a market for illicit drugs, therefore, it must be good! Good music should elevate and soften the mind. This looks like a masala dosa being offered as prasadam.
This is a good experiment so please do not blame
Yo Lord Ram! Whatzup my man? Long time no see bro?
please call to him more soulfully... lord Ram will not understand you lingo... :D ... jai shri ram....
and the worst part is he is not seen in the vid!!!
Having heard many versions definitely better than Yesudas , however while improvising with other instruments, should have drifted from the traditional song, still feel nothing like the Nadaswaram , Tavil combination you hear during marriage, those proffessionals do much better
Fusion or confusion ? :-)
Without doubt. Confusion.
Karthik should know the meaning of the lyrics.
Carnatic music has his fragrance mainly in gamaka...flat swaras are just flowers and gamaka is like garland made of fresh flowers...so please don't spoil..
guitar could have avoided
sir guitar makes this song more beutiful.. without chords the song woud not be beutiful as you think.... and it helps the singer to sing comfortably........
different feelings sir.. piano is more romantic smooth... guitar is little aggressive... take it as a diferent segment sir... please dont mix up this with claasical music.... both of it have their own beuty and we feel good after hearing the music that's all i wanted
###generation gap.....
Pity this...
"ogibOdhalu chEsEvAralu gArE" Karthik singing this portion wrongly
ఒగి బోధన జేసే వారలు కారే
The use of drum and 'bee sound' kind of instruments should have been avoided. It spoils divinity.
Saint tyagaraja's compositions are soulful, When hearing the same composition in Balamurali's voice was soooo divine... this seems to be like light music... a very bland rendition. The emotion and feel is missing. It seems like he is singing in a wedding reception rather than a carnatic concert. Innovation is good, but in the name of innovation killing the original jeevan of a composition is not appreciable. and the singer himself is distracting us from unflavored gestures.
there are lot of new singers and musicians are forming in TAMIL NADU, most of them trying something new and spoilling the the whole carnatic music, please give respect to your own carnatic music, don't mix all carnatic music uising with western instruments into it,, world is changing but you people never change....every country have their own music, but your Tamil nadu copy western, arab music and mix into carnatic why? don't try it respect your own carnatic and hinduistan music it's enough for all
Sir No music is one's own right and Ragas were composed thru innovation by experimentation
The violin and the harmonium are Western in origin, but we use them in our music, just as we use the mandolin, mouth organ and so on. Just as we all use any number of Western equipment in our daily lives, including the recording instruments this video was recorded on. Stop being so backward looking. God is not interested in how you were dressed when you died, but in how you lived your life,
Most of the songs (all) of Tyagaraja's kirtis were composed in Tamil Nadu, a fertile ground for classical music. Even today we have only few guy in Tanjavoor who can make Veena... It will soon fade away as we don't buy them enough and patronize them... Lalgudi Jayaraman and Kunnakkudi Vaidyanathan made violin a popular Carnatic accompaniment.. Adapt to change or perish..
Below avg level of singing and backing .....swara singing too ....the real fragrance of abheri comes only when it ornamented with its own unique gamkas..for understanding that need lot of good listening and practice....plz dont try to mix hindustani in this beautiful composition or if u want to fuse it do it without insulting the tradition of both system and raga bhavam..sorry to say.
a very bland rendition....totally missing the point of the bhaava of this composition......and the percussion definitely doesn't go with this.
Aadarsh Kadambi U said it right on the dot.
Too bad. Lame attempt. He should listen to Balamurali's to understand and learn where to break the words in lyrics. Flute is thousand times better. He's marvellous.
Pity Carnatic Songs goes to dustbin with western backgrtound. sorry
Rather than issuing unhinged statements, kindly elaborate sir.
A mockery of clean thyagaraya krithi with immature body language.
total version spoiled
There is noteven a single note that has been missed.Fabulous improvisation. .kudos Mr.Karthik you have a unique style...love your singing.
Having heard many versions definitely better than Yesudas , however while improvising with other instruments, should have drifted from the traditional song, still feel nothing like the Nadaswaram , Tavil combination you hear during marriage, those proffessionals do much better