How Venmo Makes Money
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2019
- Venmo has revolutionized the way pay each other back. From sending roommates the rent check to reimbursing friends for dinner, people ‘Venmo’ each other all the time. But have you ever wondered how this fun, emoji laden payments app actually makes money? Well, for years, it hasn’t. But now Venmo is on the cusp of profitability for its parent company, Paypal.
Concerns remain about privacy for users and security for their money. And many on Wall Street are still waiting to see whether this millennial digital payments phenomenon is just flash in the pan or if it’s really here to stay. Bill Ready, Paypal's COO and the man who brought the once no name app to mainstream fame invited CNBC to Venmo's New York offices to get a look inside how the payment app works.
NOTE: On April 24, 2019 (a day after this video was published), PayPal revealed for the first time that Venmo has 40 million users. In the video above, CNBC cited eMarketer, which had estimated 27.4 million Venmo users as of April 2018..
In its first-quarter 2019 earnings report, PayPal said it now has a total 277 million total customer accounts - including 22 million merchant accounts. Total payments volume for Venmo grew 73 percent year over year to $21 billion in the first quarter, the company said. The company said Venmo is still on pace to do $100 billion in payment volume this year.
» Subscribe to CNBC: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBC
» Subscribe to CNBC TV: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCtelevision
» Subscribe to CNBC Classic: cnb.cx/SubscribeCNBCclassic
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Connect with CNBC News Online
Get the latest news: www.cnbc.com/
Follow CNBC on LinkedIn: cnb.cx/LinkedInCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Facebook: cnb.cx/LikeCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Twitter: cnb.cx/FollowCNBC
Follow CNBC News on Instagram: cnb.cx/InstagramCNBC
#CNBC
#Venmo
#PayPal
How Venmo Makes Money
Which digital payment app do you use?
For privacy, I don't post any information that touches personal finances online.
I don’t use a digital payment
TWINT (the same Idea, works only in Switzerland)
I don’t have any money
DANA and OVO
A very VERY VERY well put together video. Describing the business, history, competition, scandals. This is like a very well written essay. Props to CNBC. I look forward to more videos. Some ideas would be shining light on some start-ups or rising ones if there isn't a large of enough background.
I enjoy how it's not just a one sided argument but a critical look on how a company like Venmo operates and if it will be profitable in the future.
_A very VERY VERY well put together video._
The music is loud, grating and distracting.
They are always really engaging
Especially for business students!
And she's hot
wow his name is BILL READY.. how ironic !!
GangstaInLaw lol
It's actually *apropos* that that's his name. It'd be *ironic* if his name was something like BILL IAMBROKE.
How thematic!
Haha wonder where the idea of venmo came from lol
GangstaInLaw he was born to do this! Lol.
Let me summarize this 11:29 video.
How Venmo Makes Money? It doesn't.
Thank you. I watched the whole thing as well, basically to hear that they function as a rent-seeking middleman...that's still not profitable.
Your summary is pretty bad. Is Venmo making money right now? It isn't.
Is Venmo going to make money in the future? It may.
Many tech companies is doing business or going IPO with a lost. This is typical. They are not going to make money now because of the high initial investment cost and they accepted losses to expand their market reach. Once they are big enough (like Facebook or Google) and hold large enough market shares, they can start making profits by economies of scale, start charging small fee on transactions or charging banks a small percentage to get access to that money for investment.
For example, if your operating cost is 300 millions and you are generating $10 each per person with consumer base of 20 millions, you will be making a loss. If your base continue to growth and your cost remain the same, you are making huge profits the next year. Lyft is making loss the same way. Same for Facebook when 1st first started and called itself free social network. Same for Uber.
Every cent that you leave in your venmo account is a cent that a bank can lend out without paying you a damn shilling of interest rate. You are giving them money to do business for free.
Whether it makes money or not is irrelevant. The whole point of these startups (back then and now) is to get bought out by someone bigger. Venmo did make money...for the people that founded it. That's all that matters to them.
Gain volume, screw the consumer and merchants later.
It makes money in lots of ways (as described in the video). They’re just not profitable
Didn't think much of CNBC back then, as with other cable new networks. But seems they are smart enough to know what media outlet gets people's attention these days. I love these quality videos
Its crazy that how PayPal will probably buy every upcoming money transfer company that seems promising.
Is that Monopoly I hear
Don't Touch Me PayPal is not failing I use PayPal faithfully just because it’s less popular method doesn’t mean they’re not the best
Alexander Anderson Thats why the banks created Zelle. Paypal cant buy that.
@@uno9331 the only thing PayPal is best at is screwing over sellers with ever increasing outrageous fees, thus increasing the price of must stuff you buy on the internet. PayPal had long been a cancer and even eBay reached that same conclusion
Buy paypal stock?
Video: “not insured”
Me stops video and transfers funds
06:55 "Explore what the *WORLD* is searching"
07:00 shows only the U.S. lol
🤣🤣🤣
But that's where these 2 app operate. I think the upi system used in India can help US direct transfer of money from bank account to bank account, super smooth. And yeah any app can apply this system and not just the banks.
@@karanjoshi2662
Blockchain will destroy these outdated technologies
@@norpriest521 block chain is still too young but upi offers a bridge kind of thing which reduces hassle for both banks and payment apps. Let's see how block chains make it to the masses.
These people talk about Venmo as a social network like I'm actually scrolling through the feed liking people's transactions or even reading them in the first place.
You keep saying "millennials" like we're not all almost 40 years old, struggling to survive, and think this is stupid. The generation you're trying to describe is apparently Gen Z.
The millenials generation are people born from mid-80s to mid-90s. Those are the people with disposal income that are using this app. Gen Z are either in college are just getting out. That's not the major demographic that's using venmo.
@@maplenerd22 I know which generation is which. It IS the privileged college kids who like Venmo. Us millennials DO NOT have much disposable income, this economy is a mess.
@@JRKonungrinn Learn a skill that pays.
@@ChrisGilliamOffGrid I work in the medical industry. The economy still sucks.
@@JRKonungrinn Booming here. Has been for years.
I love these videos! So informative and well put together!
I like my e-transfers linked to and deposited in my bank and vice versa.
I agree with Dan, it’s scary how so many people make it obvious who they pay and how much they pay. When I used it, I would make my transactions private so nobody else could this on the ui
Pretty much the “underbanked” is a nice way of saying the hood 😂❤️🤞🏽
I agree, any infro on why Cash App is more popular with the "underbanked" than Venmo? Are there different requirements to join?
@@godfathaofyo cuz cash app is cooler
blck ppl*
It would probably also include rural communities
Rooney your videos are awesome! Very informative, very objective.
great questions for Bill Ready! excellent video, thanks.
Oh boy it's owned by PayPal... Get ready for payment holds, fraud, and abysmal customer service.
Lol yeah
and data sold and money laundering at your cost lol people so fool
@@wild_taco_gonecrazycorona9112 +15133860766
@@wild_taco_gonecrazycorona9112 +15133860766
@@wild_taco_gonecrazycorona9112 I got $3k
Thanks so much CNBC, i really needed to be reminded every few seconds that the man's name is Bill Ready
another great video. been using Venmo since it’s inception and had no idea it was not a bank. was also unaware that the money you hold in your Venmo account isn’t insured 🤯 helpful information. glad I watched this. I wonder how the growing crypto market is going to effect Venmo’s user base in the next decade.
So "millennial" pretty much = " young people" now... Just say "young people"!
well i think they're referring to a specific group of young people who are more "tech savvy" and "liberal"....i dont think they mean the young people in africa or southeast asia for example.
I agree with hamads first statement, you have mellennials that as of now are 24-37 years old and younger than 24 are gen z
LetoDK no my generation are young, you guys are too old.
@@peterlangalanga4234 forgot your meds?
I definitely do NOT like people knowing who I am paying. So I have my account on private, duh.
Lost me at Wells Fargo.
I love it when companies say we are not in the business of selling personal data and then three month later you get an email that says our terms and agreements are change in order to enhance your experience aka we have now selling your personal data
Bill Ready dude is the most consumer-friendly COO I've ever seen
1:00 I don't. But Venmo has that "social" aspect public by default. Mostly to show people that your friends are using it. But seriously, I always change it to private every time.
LOL at how they speak about these "millenials"
Yeah, millennials are under your bed and are coming for you!!
Also, to the guy at 1:00 (who looks suspiciously millennial aged btw) we don't all like the social media component of venmo. I'm a milennial and it also freaks me out. Of course they don't mention that you can make payments privately.
weirdos
Jon Mitchell Agreed. I always make the transaction private... but most people don't care/don't know about making them private unfortunately.
"Pampered" Hated that
Ok boomer
Is Google pay (tez) and Brno Venmo the same in the way they work?
Banks and other institutions are coming for Venmo hopefully they are making a lot of 💰
InvestingWisely They already have. Zelle. And Zelle is pretty good I must admit. Much faster than Venmo to get into your bank acct.
@@552mustang and ppl don't know about what you spend money on.
I prefer Cash App myself but have pretty much all the money transfer apps. Makes it easier when someone needs to pay me and they only have one of these and I have an account with all available money transfer apps.
In India we have UPI and we can actually transfer money to someone and they can spend it real-time. And it's here for over years now.
Are you saying that this type of real time money transfer system doesn't exist in US? :|
A corgi! Literally makes everything better 🥰
But thank you for the informative video.
I’ve never heard of Venmo in my life
And now I have
Same
Its a younger generation peer to peer money exchange app. Good if you dont carry cash and ask friends fro cash when i venmo what i owe
Basically owned by PayPal, but a better version. Like a child who surpasses the parent in job skills.
I use it all the time in college 🤷🏽♂️ UMass Amherst
-4 Subscribers with a hammer addiction damn that’s crazy. I found it in December of 2017 and it’s easily one of the best apps I have ever downloaded
Id rather use Apple Pay I trust Apples commitment to security more than PayPal. Plus that whole broadcasting your payments in a social feed thing is just weird. I'd never do that and Im a millennial.
i agree, their "Millenials" statements are ignorant generalizations
I am actually a hard working millennials.. thank you very much
Why not just use PayPal?
xan page-brown Venmo is marketed toward millennials. PayPal is more oriented toward casual users, or business owners
They charge fee
Because it has TWO capitalized letters.
i wish you would ask the guy from Nomura more about how different socioeconomic classes play a role in square cash vs venmo
"A ahh small amount" in corporate-speak equals "one of our revenue-generating pillars"
I personally prefer my finances to not be social. I’m more of a cash app girl but I still have it on my phone ready for those two friends
You can hide it in the settings
Lord of the Jungle 😂 exactly
Why is it so slow in the US? In sweden we have Swish that is direct. Have you made comparative software around the world?
In Kenya we had peer to peer payments almost 15 years ago, MPESA. America has alot to catch up
This dude could sell bottled water to a drowning man 🤔
Literally never heard of venmo til this video lmaooo, Cash app and apple pay is king
Lol just because you live under a rock doesn't mean that Venmo doesn't dominate both of those apps.
I absolutely LOVE apple!
This reporter did a great job on transparency
Venmo can be in the business of market data by analyzing what people buy or what is preferred to split payments for. Other companies may be willing to buy that information.
@0:13 Cringe is at 100%
hahaha, I choked on my coffee when I watched that part. Too good.
I can get a venmo payment and withdraw cash from an ATM within a minute, how does that work?
Imagine that there are digital placeholders on funds exchanged depending on the service. That's how.
benny wolf just get the Venmo debit card. Once you receive money in Venmo walk to an atm pay the fee and withdraw cash, or better yet use cash back at the grocery store for no fee
In Sweden we have swish that is totally free and you use your mobile number to send money to other people. The Money does also transfer direct
I love this content
It was a headache to use wouldn’t take My credit or debit card wanted me to link it to my bank account
In australia we have Beem_It. Its instant deposit into your bank account. Someone pays you and as soon as its received on the app, its in your account. No fees, no wait time. Its a partnership between all the big banks. As an American in australia, it is so nice. Blows venmo out of the water
So it's basically the equivalent of Zelle at the big banks. Venmo is usually used as a social paying platform and it's easier to split bills among friends
Pretty much everyone outside the US will have a system like that
In other countries such as in Vietnam, Malaysia, we have Grab, Boost, all with zero fees, and all can be used for ride hailing, buying goods, restaurants, bus tickets, air tickets, hotels.
It takes a lot of scrolling to find a comment appreciating the beauty of the presenter /reporter. A great job is noticed straightway, however, the beauty is being ignored.
One word. Zelle. If you don’t know it’s bc you’re a child without a bank account
andy I've had bank accounts for 20 years. WTF is Zelle?
What an absurd generalization to make
Is venmo instant yet? cause if not im sticking to google wallet. When my friends owe me it at least i get it the same day
Ron Reyes yes it’s instant try it out I did and I enjoy it now
"Receiving" the money is instant, and if you plan to use that same money to pay others/buy other things through venmo, then there are no delays.
However, if you want to transfer the money to your bank account, then you will have to go through the standard ACH transfer process which usually takes one business day, unless you specifically ask for an instant transfer and are willing to pay venmo's fee.
Why would you not use cash? It's instant. And private.
Great content as always from CNBC. Also the female on air talent is hotttt, like Kate in this video and Jennifer Elias on others I have watched. Love the ladies at CNBC.
My biggest takeaway is that you can go to Google trends and check what people are searching
man wechat alipay been doin this for years
well.. venmo came out in 2009 and we chat in 2011.
Isn't wechat only available in Asia?
Only r/repfam will understand 🤑
china surely good on implementing cashless payment using alipay and we chat, other countries followed by created its own payment. but in the end, the most used and has most merchant will win.
i love venmo coz in can split bill lol
@@amvin234 the only reason America even has ideas is because of China. China has every right to steal everything from the USA, and they will destroy the USA in the coming war. USA is about 1/50th of the population compared to China, Russia, Pakistan and Indian populations
I just use zelle because my bank is affiliated
Maria Rodrigainz can you hits up hackercraigballard on this number 315-840/0385 he's giving $300 randomly
I still have a prepaid card that's FDIC insured and can make instant transfers with for those who have the same card. Looking to get an actual bank though for the sake of credit and renting a car should I travel. Prepaid cards usually can't be used with services like Cash App, which my workplace uses as an option for paying our monthly potlucks, lol.
In Indonesia, if I were to move my money from our version of venmo (for example gopay) to my bank account, it shows up that instant when I transfer it through my phome into mobile banking. But I do get charged a small amount for the transfer. I'm surprised that in the US you have to wait one day.
$100B in your account, if you get a 0.01% bank interest is that $100M that is not small.
$100B is the total volume of transactions in a year. No interest for that
0.01% of $100 B is $10M not $100M.
100 Billion is the amount of total transaction, not what they made.
So true over the difference between cash app vs venmo demographics!!!
ghettos use cashapp for drugs
there so many digital payment apps that's why I'm letting them all fight it out and stick to the one that comes out at the end lol we all need to use one universal payment app like in china where everyone uses wechat
edit: by the way great work on utilizing youtube for up to date news media 👌 I hardly ever watch normal news channels lol
Have been using Venmo for close to three years. Everyone I know has also been using it for years too. Didn't even occur to me that it isn't a common thing elsewhere. The network effect is real
Honestly it's a pretty garbage product by international standards. It's third party app, not even the banks doing got themselves and the money is not immediate going from bank account to bank account
*laughs in Canadian * how tf you guys don’t have etransfer 😂🤣😭
China has been doing this for YEARSS NOWW
No one cares...it's all about how it makes it money...not who created it first...
paula Still funny how it was shown as a new tech
@@boomafoo9 no it's not ..the app is created in 2009..that's 10 years ago...they just show the history of the app and the entire mobile payment industry...
Good vid 👍
Talk about the ability to wear your credit worthiness on your sleeve ;)
My Venmo card allows me to pay for things at stores and restaurants sooooo it's essentially cash.
Nope. Cash is untraceable.
It's not ftic insured.
Why not just utilize it with the existing PayPal? I already use PayPal for everything.
Phatastic Meemo Probably some legal issue, and this is a way foe pay pal to continue the operations. But I agree. Regular bank transfer or pay pal work just as well.
M Detlef explain why?
@M Detlef how so? All app of such nature is the same as PayPal. All carry fees and takes your information. To think that no app does either of these things is VASTLY STUPID, as you put it.
@@timothyhorton1457 Because they already have my bank account info and charges the same fee as all these other apps. What makes Venmo any different aside from the name?
@M Detlef And what about the others? You think NO ONE can hack into them? There is no protection period for anything if you're using anything via internet connection. CashApp, Venmo, Zelle and etc they're all susceptible to fraud and hacking.
The number one thing I can see that's holding venmo back is the name. The name doesn't explain what the app does. Like cash app does.
Great video!!
i was just thinking how creepy it is receiving a notification about my coworker paying his girlfriend for movie tickets.
Just imagine if there was a peer to peer system of transferring value without banks?
Or that actually is integrated with the banks making it 100% immediate
It will never catch on 👍
👍
@CNBC Even though it goes through the ACH you can opt for instant transfer for a fee and that is instant. Even though not cleared yet, you can use that money in your bank account--same day, within minutes. Not like traditional bank transfer.
In its current form Venmo will not last long term but if they refine it from people begging to pay them on tinder it'll have way more potential and applications
When I tell my friends and family Venmo comes Vendere and Mobile Im gonna sound sooo smart 😂
Zelle as is instant to your bank account and no fees. Also FDIC's insured.
Thanks for the tip! I’ll have to look into Zelle. Have you been using it long?
What they should be trying to do is partner with as many vendors as they possibly can by undercutting Visa and MasterCard's transaction fees, and offering rebates for consumers. Similar to what Alipay, Wechat Pay and Yandex Money did in other markets.
can you make payments on Venmo with gift cards? kinds skeptical in using my Credit card
Hahaha 😂😂 at first I thought it was the wine and spirits store !
First time of hearing Venmo
Firebeast Gaming you’re either lying, or you really need to get out more with friends.
Andrew Lee seriously, I just heard of it and I have basically no friends
Great Video @CNBC! I however think you should let the world know what a revolution M-pesa is. Venmo could learn a thing or two from it. It's been in existence for about 2 decades in Kenya, and is far more advanced than Venmo. M-pesa generates billions for Safaricom, a Vodafone-owned business in Kenya. Venmo could eventually become a bank, offering loans, etc... Just the way M-pesa is today...
Tonnes of competition? I've only heard of the ones you mentioned, so.... What other companies are there?
jon doe Facebook, Snapchat, Venmo/PayPal, square, zelle, cash app, google wallet, Apple Pay, western union. There are also apps by traditional banks which allow the transfer of money between non members and/or transfer between a member and non member such as chase quick pay and the Bank of America mobile app. I would say that is a lot of competition
Edit: and I am sure there are many more I didn’t think of/ haven’t hear of
Edit2: turns out snapcash is no longer available
never heard of square cash app....
It’s apparently very popular with drug dealers
@@chrisd6736 also instathots and ewhores
@@BenMarvin How are you verified?!!?!?!?
@@dkracingfan2503 I'm important
I love Venmo it's amazing not sure if I would use it as much if they started charging for it though. Only time will tell.
Would you pay a flat fee of 1 USD per month? or what's the highest you would be willing to pay for the service?
migueleo17 I wouldn’t pay for it.
@@CapnCody1622 not even 1 USD per year? and why not pay for Venmo or Cash App, etc but pay way more in fees when using the same features in a bank? just curious.
migueleo17 I don’t pay fees through my credit union. I’d never pay a fee to transfer money to someone else. Cash app started charging me a fee because I used it so much they thought I was a business so I quit using it.
@@CapnCody1622 I see your point. I nteresting, is there a feature you can think of you would really like to see in any of those apps that will make sense for you to pay? stats? budget tracking? bill pay? etc?
So. I went to China and there is a system of payment where people have qr codes and people can transfer money to each other and you can use that to pay for stuff. Everyone has it, consumer and merchants alike. I really hope something like that can happen here. It's so convenient
Would be nice, but the older generations need to die out first. They are all grumpy old heads that constantly consider cash as king due to their upbringing. Go to any small mom and pop shop and they will refuse cards most of the time, which is quite annoying.
There should be a cross platform payment system so Venmo users can send money to people on PayPal so they can leverage their high markets share before it's too late.
Wechat Pay: Hold my beer...
jedkoh will never dominate US market.
But yes, DOMINATES CHINA and does a LOT more.
Show of hands, who tf actually uses Zelle?
Aaron Liu I use it with my roommates and friends. 1 less account to hack, just share email or phone to send money.
I would consider it if it didn't force me to log in manually every single time I used it.
HughJazz13 I just Face ID into my bank account, it’s real easy
My landlord tried, but she takes Venmo
I use both.
Aye bro you take cash app?
2 days to transfer money? Dont you have instant payments between banks yet?
Wellllll it's cool, but if you prefer safety of your information, there isn't nothing like cold hard cash 😅
Yea that's a fantasy. Your online presence being monetized and sold to information brokers has long destoryed any sense of privacy.
I thought PayPal was a cash sharing app🤔
Cry Whit venmo gets around the fees
@@CoinOpTV OH! Well they FDIC insured a portion of their app, does that have anything to do with this?
normal young ppl dont use paypal. thats always been an ebay only thing or random online website purchase
Yes, your life is a TV show, you are the star of that show and everyone thinks you are just amazing. Why else would you want people to see what you paid and got paid?
We've been doing mobile payments in Kenya using Mpesa for the last 10 years....its not a new idea. However, ours is more efficient. You can use the cash in your account to make direct payments e.g. in the supermarket, shops, pay for fuel etc. You can transfer that cash to someone else who can withdraw it instantly into actual cash
Yeah, I don't like venmo. Inconvenience because it's my money that I can't use. I'd rather just use Chase QuickPay
Cody Schlenker you get your money right away with a small fee now
Cody Schlenker my brother sent me $50... was only charged $3 for instant transfer
@@Chitown18 I'd rather have all my money
@@Chitown18 that's a 6% fee. that's crazy.
@@aboucard93 it should be free. Why would you pay to transfer your own money? Americans are crazy...
6:03 Nice bubble. You're welcome.
Pancakes
In Russia you don't need to use special third apps or go to the traditidional bank. Banks' apps are amazing, work fast everyday, with many functions and great customer service, many banks don't take percents for getting cash in any ATM and include everything and everyone use Apple and google payments with their cards/phones/watches. Also many banks don't have clients offices and everything's online.
How does Venmo make money? Skip ahead to the answer at 4:08
If you keep watching you'll also hear that outside of merchant partnerships they also monetize your account balances by investing in Government Bonds, and other secure investments.