EP:18 | ETALIN HYDRO ELECTRIC PROJECT | A boon for the region ?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @orunasolcitizen1169
    @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому +12

    Without any doubt, you've always been my favourite UA-camr of Arunachal Pradesh ,I want to tell you that even if your channel don't grow, whatevr you did since 2018,till today, you have contributed well enough for the youth and the state. Before you trust me there was no one who could speak like u or deliver info like you on this platform . For me you are the torchbearer among Arunachalee youtuber. I knw you uploaded this video after a long gap, koi baat nahi, Sabka life me busy kam hotai, aap continue karo na karo, trust me there won't be another JPT, there are many knowledgeable person in our state, but very few can deliver it like u, Hardwork, sincerity, sabkuch video me dekai detai. Quality content.
    About ETALIN PROJECT.
    U r right, kuch panekeliye kuch khona partai
    Bohot danger he humlog ka earth quake prone area keliye
    U have tried ur best to deliver it. I wish ki oppose wala party bhi Jada honese achatha
    AnD yes i knw i saw ur post , on fb, many months ago asking people to speak , corona LOCkdwn toh excuse he, Aramse video banake bheksaktatha.
    Admi log bhi upainai
    Anyway good wishes for ur exam, I wish u pass it pass everything, ✌

  • @AjatiMimi
    @AjatiMimi 4 роки тому +13

    If I'm not mistaken, the study that the EIA conducted was supposed to be over the span of four seasons which never happened. What happened instead was that we got short-changed with an incomplete survey conducted in a very slipshod manner.
    The Etalin Hydro-electric Project IS THE LARGEST SUCH PROJECT IN THE WHOLE OF INDIA, not just in the state of Arunachal Pradesh or in the North-Eastern region of the country.
    Consider this, the total strength of the Idu-Mishmi community lies in the range of a meagre 12-15 thousand people, that is taking both the Dibang Valley and the Lower Dibang Valley into consideration. If you just consider Dibang Valley then it's less than half of that number. It is obvious that a project of this scale will require a lot of manpower which will naturally be brought from the outside, last I heard there was talk of bringing in around 10 thousand labour force into the area which will easily render the local people a minority in their own land.
    You've stayed in Roing and have an understanding of how things are here, in Roing, and so I had hoped that you would highlight such issues in your video. I hope you'll take such issues into consideration the next time you make a video on this subject.

  • @achilimihu1802
    @achilimihu1802 4 роки тому +23

    The video leaves out the most concerning and deadly impacts of these projects on our community. The entire population of the Idu Mishmi community is under 14,000. The Etalin project alone will bring around 12,000 people into Dibang Valley and they will stay there for at least 10 years. And this is just one of the 17 such dam projects planned in Dibang Valley!
    Many Idu Mishmi fear that the voting constituency of the migrant labourers will subvert the political will of the native residents, making the Idu Mishmi a landless minority in their own, and only, homeland. The Idu language, recently declared endangered by UNESCO, is also likely to be disappear. Please try to make an unbiased video next time 🙏

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому +3

      Exactly ....idu mishmis are only a handful, not in powerful positions of administration...so they think they can bully us. And all for what? The post of an electrician? Laughable.

    • @drexryugin1139
      @drexryugin1139 4 роки тому

      Your chattering doesn't evoke any sense of truth in it, if bullying is what you've faced then why whining as if you can't do anything about it, be strong enough to overcome it, cause it might be less than a handful ones. the reason is that it's not in our domain of intrest. It is as if you're intimidated for some gruelling reason. I have concern for your regard because you chose to neglect the real trouble here and else opted to speak on something that isn't crucial at all.. (RSVP)

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому +2

      @@drexryugin1139 did you understand what i wrote?😂😂😂i stated a fact that we arent yet in a position where we can fend for ourselves ...at least not most. And i said , i quote" they think they can bully us" .....here the word "they" is used for the corporates and govt. And word " bully" is used in the context of the present EIAdraft 2020. So for the love of god, first read , comprehend and then make decisions😂 . Also i'd like to point our that my " whining" was still a shorter whine than yours. And if it ISNT in your domain of interest , keep mum nah , enjoy the show. As for the question of me being intimidated ...😂😂😂let it be , shall we??

    • @drexryugin1139
      @drexryugin1139 4 роки тому

      I'm kind of bolted out right now😅 i did think it through and was agitated, I presumed somethingelse actually i couldn't help myself fend off an intrusions opinion on this matter.(well That is what i thought.Some other neighbouring tribe person maybe) .. . Sorry for being reckless and clumsy🙏😬

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому

      @@drexryugin1139 its alright. We all make mistakes✌✌

  • @tripdairy9421
    @tripdairy9421 4 роки тому +10

    Itne Dino baad 😊😊😊😊😀,so happy to see u again 🌻🌼🍁

  • @BhanuTatak
    @BhanuTatak 4 роки тому +11

    The financial non viability of the project has been expressed by the Jindal CEO themself with high cost due to uncertainty of the project, levelised tariff, over 70% of the revenue generation will go towards debt servicing according to a financial analysis made by professional bankers who are advocating for the future financial loss companies WILL have to face with the project. Failed projects like Teesta III, Maheshwar hydro projects are good examples of why discoms are terminating Hydropower investment. With most economic and sustainable alternatives like solar photovoltaic and wind energy in compare to thermal or hydropower, we are also looking at 80% discounted rate of the former to the latter, when you cut the cost of transmission and raw materials. According to a study by Manthan Adhyayan Kendra, the 6 year delay in the project will indeterminately impact the market dynamics as supply-demand will change over these coming 6 years which are to determine the future of the project and the place/people, add tariff to that and comparing overall costs, the study finds the project to be economically irrational besides other major issues that should be first priortised-- the demographical shifts and socio cultural impacts on the communities (both PAPF and the downstream). It is terribly wrong to presume PAPF is only the villagers in Etalin when in reality, all of us have to bear the future consequences of such poorly anaylsed idea of 'development'. We are well aware of the fragile terrain and that arunachal falls in earth quake zone V, our economy has started to open up but sheer exploitation of our sentiments and violation of basic tenets of social responsibility by corporates cannot be passed off as development. I request John to please consider a remake of this video with a proper nuanced understanding for the public. Thank you for your time and efforts to speak on the subject, none the less.

  • @sumitratamang2412
    @sumitratamang2412 4 роки тому +5

    There is positive and negative in every development. Precaution should be taken before establishing the dams. It will give growth in every aspect but there is negative impact also. Govt should take care the people of that area. Very informative video. Good to see u aftr a long gap.

  • @charanjitprasad3574
    @charanjitprasad3574 4 роки тому +3

    Really helpful video.. Keep making videos #Appreciate all the hardwork

  • @TheRowlingStone
    @TheRowlingStone 4 роки тому +13

    Please do proper research before bringing your videos in public domain.
    Your description of EIA here is absolutely incorrect. The EIA had a lot of wrong datas with manipulation. I recommend you to go through the paper by 29 scientists and researchers, they reviewed the EIA presented by WII (available online). With current issues of EIA draft 2020 and climate change conditions you being an educated person should understand the gravity of the situation. Dont play neutral here. We really need to understand how much of development we actually need.
    Please understand that the rise in zoonotic diseases are directly linked with extreme deforestation and human interference. Covid-19 should have opened your eyes.
    You have focused more on pro dam people here.
    Do not undermine the effect of earthquake (there are many earthquake epicenters at the immediate vicinity of the project site) and landslides, not to forget the "glacial lake outbursts" ( hope you remember the kedarnath flood).
    Experts have questioned the financial viability of the project.
    Please dont play neutral here.

  • @HoMeOfAweSoMeViDeOs
    @HoMeOfAweSoMeViDeOs 4 роки тому +5

    It's so good to see you after a long time #Achey✌️

  • @sian4480
    @sian4480 4 роки тому +5

    Very informative video 👍 well done bro,god bless you.

  • @konipotom2675
    @konipotom2675 3 роки тому +1

    Very Informative videos.. I heard there is building a dam but didnt know that deep about that.. Thank u

    • @JPTVIDEOS4U
      @JPTVIDEOS4U  3 роки тому +1

      Keep watching my old videos😊😊😊 do let me know how you find my videos. Thank you for being there on my live video.

    • @konipotom2675
      @konipotom2675 3 роки тому

      @@JPTVIDEOS4U sure..

  • @aguelaramsay7714
    @aguelaramsay7714 4 роки тому +18

    Get ur facts straight plz!!
    EIA survey: mandatory assessment of the affected area over mutiple seasons,but this requirement was cut short to less than 5 months(details available.plz study the review of 29 scientists over this topic)
    Employment:see the context of the locality/place.idu mishmi people are very less in no.'s and qualifications are not so outstanding,and even if there are people with considerable qualifications they r very few in no.'s,and when compared to any other tribe's qualification levels they become as light and unimpressive as feather,so no point comparing with the likes of the mainland people who are certainly going to compete for the jobs(Q.why would any one take an insufficiently qualified/unskilled person for any job,and even if jobs are being provided that will be to a handful no.of people who r insufficiently equpped but admitted under the obligation towards the affected locality.or do we have the chance at manual labouring which will be required?hard to think of such outcome)
    Some people rooting for dam are not the entitled representatives of entire idu mishmi community,and please show the whole story!
    Earthquake risk:some areas are not easily susceptible to earthquake attacks or some of the mountains are strong enough to withstand earthquake's???it is obviously for a reason that the subject region is mapped under earthquake prone regions and more obviously why the disastrous earthquake of 1950 happened in the region that decimated a good no. of lives.finding ur cake ruined after u finsh making it one can always start it again,but if one thinks this analogy fits well with the construction and collapsing of dams as it can be rebuild again if u want to just like remaking damaged cake,I suggest such a person to rebuild a sense of balance between thought and actual action(constructing a dam and arguing it will last is not sufficient,promise with credible proof that it is going to hold.until one does not feel confident enough to guarantee that it is never going to break it is apt to discuss the pros and cons and deliberate as thoroughly as possible taking into account the benefits and risks and come to a fruitful conclusion whether the project is worth the bargain.if one still thinks that from a macroscopic perspective it is worth risking the existence of such a small community I strongly pray that u find ur own River and mountains and experiment with it all u like. it is a very big project and the risks are equally big and every possible loopholes should be eliminated before actually executing the project.it is especially important to sufficiently satisfy or fulfill the security concerns of the affected community and affected areas/places based only on factual study).
    Prayer:let the people support or oppose with their own understanding of pros and cons,and,as an influencer ur duty is to share the accurate facts,and if u find oddities on govts part it is ur job to bring it forward.it would be in the best interest of everyone if the facts are checked and cross checked again and again before being uploaded.however if the facts are dubious even after a thousand times of checking just drop the idea rather than providing incomplete and biased factual details.
    There r still many relevant points like heavy influx of labourers and chances of permanent settlement,and consequent growth of competition for resources and space, growth in violence,loss of security of the native people,change in voting scenario,and even the risk of becoming numerical as well as political minority in one's own place,and the possibility of loss of culture in the longrun etc..
    Thanks!

    • @BhanuTatak
      @BhanuTatak 4 роки тому +2

      Thank you so much for clearing the air of misinformation being circulated. We, the people in the valley are opposed and it should be rightly addressed. Was expecting more from the video.

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому

      Please make a video and upload we want to see

    • @aguelaramsay7714
      @aguelaramsay7714 4 роки тому

      @@BhanuTatak welcome

    • @aguelaramsay7714
      @aguelaramsay7714 4 роки тому

      @@orunasolcitizen1169 sorry...mein UA-camr nahi hoon.yeh video bhi bura toh nahi hai..par yeh topic ko aur behtar explore karke Pura aspects samajh ke dobara banane sey jyada better hoga.

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому

      @@aguelaramsay7714 youtuber hona jaruri he kia, video toh koi bhi bansaktai.. Please make a video and upload. We want to knw more. Since u seems to belong from that region.

  • @MILI_UPE
    @MILI_UPE 4 роки тому +10

    O bhai... for electricity we don’t need 1000+ megawatt dams. We need small hydels, that will also be more than enough if it is functioned properly. And for your points please keep humans before aquatic life. For those people accepting the project please explain to them that Dam is not only way for development. Did Itanagar and pasighat developed with dams??? What future we have.....?.? Our resources drained for others.? Our land being polluted by dams and its workers.? Or stripped off our tribal rights and diminish like many central Indian tribes.?
    Or what job are they going to give us......?? 25% bruuuuh......
    I really appreciate your effort but since you have decided to put it up on UA-cam at least do a prior research and that’s too a proper one.

  • @nyatolendo1181
    @nyatolendo1181 4 роки тому

    The only youtuber who keeps us updated with Current affairs and provides us with prominent knowledge. 👍 Keep Going💪

  • @nejingragyor8908
    @nejingragyor8908 4 роки тому +1

    Informative.... Quality content... Long awaited video... Always appreciate your work and also you are one of the most reliable source of information in AP... Update part 2...

  • @soumendraghosh4381
    @soumendraghosh4381 3 роки тому

    Love from West bengal to Arunachal Pradesh . Bro I really loved your channel . Your channel will grow very quickly if everyone share your video

  • @biduboje67
    @biduboje67 4 роки тому

    Most genuine and best youtuber JP TATO ❤️ of our state.

  • @blackforest1132
    @blackforest1132 4 роки тому +1

    Hi brother I am ur new subscriber from Himachal, so nice to see your videos they are so informative. Keep it up.🙏

  • @YashSharma-wu7kr
    @YashSharma-wu7kr 4 роки тому +3

    "I'll see you again in near future"
    wish ye "near future" jldi aaye, bhot time lga diya aapne video daalne me. but accha video tha 💕💕

  • @BRIAN4870
    @BRIAN4870 4 роки тому +3

    Nice video good goinh

  • @lastking6377
    @lastking6377 4 роки тому +2

    Really good one

  • @moonman5319
    @moonman5319 4 роки тому +8

    STOP COMPARING A 68 METRES DAM TO A 278 METRES DAM ...DONT MAKE A FOOL OF YOURSELF.

    • @nikto7297
      @nikto7297 3 роки тому

      Just calm down bro

  • @tangsatv9435
    @tangsatv9435 4 роки тому +2

    Great Content

  • @takartoko353
    @takartoko353 4 роки тому +2

    Wonderful

  • @oyangtayor61
    @oyangtayor61 4 роки тому +1

    Always appreciate ur vedio...😍😍😍😍😍😍

  • @madapwahge3871
    @madapwahge3871 4 роки тому +2

    Nice..!!

  • @EshaMimi
    @EshaMimi 4 роки тому +13

    I appreciate your effort in trying to sound as objective as possible, but your bias shows. Would've appreciated the video more if you had actually done some research, given valuable insights, of both the sides, rather than provide us with face value-impressions of such a sensitive issue.

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому

      I didn't find any biasness, you people comment while commenting half way of watching the video .
      Our Takar toko neither supported nor he gave validation of dams both negative and positive ,after him a scientist spoke.. After him a woman... Onam perme also spoke for the environment concern.

  • @ganeshxonar6153
    @ganeshxonar6153 4 роки тому +1

    Amazing 👍

  • @taninitomdoyi.9715
    @taninitomdoyi.9715 4 роки тому +2

    Good work bro...👍

  • @JIM-ur4si
    @JIM-ur4si 4 роки тому +1

    The video is good bro..don’t worry

  • @jibokomiuli
    @jibokomiuli 4 роки тому +5

    Dibang valley = least densely populated district in while of india

  • @HIDSIPS
    @HIDSIPS 4 роки тому

    Bro... The thing is, we can not stop human evolution and development... It has to go on... It's the need... But the thing is... The risks and vulnerabilities should be monitored and corrected. For that... Channels like yours are there...

  • @richonarang15
    @richonarang15 4 роки тому +1

    Etalin will generate huge revenue for the state of Arunachal Pradesh.

  • @adarsh252
    @adarsh252 4 роки тому +2

    will you do a video about Article 371 A & How it is enacted

  • @nangramnai5306
    @nangramnai5306 10 місяців тому

    Hello bro,, whats the name of intro song?

  • @nickyaquariusgal975
    @nickyaquariusgal975 4 роки тому +2

    Hmko ye dekhne mann tha... Etalin ka

  • @nikto7297
    @nikto7297 3 роки тому +1

    Next video ?!!!!!

  • @rajeevjain2061
    @rajeevjain2061 3 роки тому

    Please stand up everyone and raise your voice against them otherwise project will be completed . It's too late already

  • @guugu4198
    @guugu4198 3 роки тому

    Bro need your cover video song.. Plz link

  • @doryoheki710
    @doryoheki710 4 роки тому +1

    As always quality content

  • @pranamirajbangshi7441
    @pranamirajbangshi7441 2 місяці тому

    Project should be vehemently opposed

  • @leoayalla9164
    @leoayalla9164 4 роки тому +2

    We cannot keep fearing that what will happen to us in future. We will have to take risks in our lives and not remain poor and ignored for the whole more generations to come. This is the time we take our own course by welcoming the project for the boon of the whole of Arunachal as this project is economically viable and can provide huge revenue, job opportunities, contracts, development of educational institutions, hospitals, transportations etc. to the locals and the state in whole. We must remember that some day, Govt. will scrap out our ST preference and when this happens, what source do have left for the time being?

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому +1

      So here's what you are doing...you are saying we dont need to fear but at the same time you are expressing your fear that govt would scrap reservations? Really ? Do you see it ? Contradicting your own comment? Basically what you are saying is "we should not fear because we fear something else". Also competing in an examination or competing in your own home for identity and survival ...what do you prefer

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому +1

      Sources will have to be made ....we will need to work harder , more honestly, more diligently to uplift our society...we dont necessarily have to sell off our homes for development.

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому +1

      Dialogue Sirf mat do.. Kam karo... Recently we have seen ur AIMSU protest

    • @moonman5319
      @moonman5319 4 роки тому +1

      @@orunasolcitizen1169 oh dont worry honey...i am not from the AIMSU. See this is the problem -you and your ill conceived prejudiced assumptions. So please read all the other comments ....research on a dam of a similar scale ,cost benefit analysis, present status , and all and then come talk. PS. The world's largest dam the three gorges is still about 90 m smaller than this proposed ...so think about that.

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому +1

      @@moonman5319 woh sab dialogue humko deke faida nai, you better watch your own people. Itna himmat he toh video banake dhaliye
      Humlog bhi dekega... On social media all we can see is your own people supporting it. Abhi bhar ka log kiahi karsaktai.

  • @gdragondissedmama3497
    @gdragondissedmama3497 4 роки тому +2

    Dear brother
    You need to study more
    Try reaching out to more people from both sides
    Dig deeper
    Sorry "ye video kafi nahi hai"😌

  • @takhedoding1088
    @takhedoding1088 4 роки тому +4

    Our Arunachal version Dhruv rathee......
    Anyway ...its very much informative Keep it up bro!

    • @YashSharma-wu7kr
      @YashSharma-wu7kr 4 роки тому +3

      Apna Jon original h 💕

    • @takhedoding1088
      @takhedoding1088 4 роки тому +1

      Obvious its original..!
      Did I mention anywhere "MADE IN CHINA

    • @YashSharma-wu7kr
      @YashSharma-wu7kr 4 роки тому +2

      @@takhedoding1088 Why are you being racist?

    • @orunasolcitizen1169
      @orunasolcitizen1169 4 роки тому +4

      @@ebimipi2463 no need to compare him with DHRUV OR who else in the world or elsewhere. He is among us, he is our Arunachalee brother. Who has always worked hard to provide Good videos , he has build up his own image so no need to compare. We are proud to have youtubeR like JPT

    • @takhedoding1088
      @takhedoding1088 4 роки тому

      @@YashSharma-wu7kr Its just a joke!