INDIA - USA - BANGLADESH IN A TANGLED WEB / MR SREE IYER/ LT GEN PR SHANKAR

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 140

  • @saptarshi7587
    @saptarshi7587 Місяць тому +3

    A nice session by Gen. Shankar. We should not forget that the British came and settled in Bengal, conquered Bengal, and finally ruled India for nearly 99 years. So, we can not take Bangladesh lightly.

  • @BhatPara-g7o
    @BhatPara-g7o Місяць тому +2

    This is a very important discussion for Bharat

  • @AnilGadi1
    @AnilGadi1 Місяць тому

    Thanks for a quick response

  • @mdmortuza3266
    @mdmortuza3266 Місяць тому

    Gen Shankar is blunt and logical. He has foresight.

  • @JB_JP_विचार
    @JB_JP_विचार Місяць тому +1

    45:40
    "I would advise you to believe those
    Two Goras"
    😂😂😂😂
    This is best statement about us,
    People in our country
    Will believe things said by
    गोराs
    It is result of
    Very Strong
    Colonial Legacy,
    Colonial Control over about Minds
    The Greatest Achievement
    of
    British Empire
    from
    Britishers point of view has been making us versions of
    Brown Englishman
    and the
    Legacy lasts very strongly still today

  • @qavii2988
    @qavii2988 Місяць тому +1

    If you want to present a substantial case regarding parallels between Iraq and Bangladesh, then I would suggest you make a thorough comparison. Right now, it seems to be nothing more than confirmation bias coupled with the inability to access more nuanced political discussions happening in Bangladesh (which are, unfortunately, almost always written in bangla).

  • @AnilGadi1
    @AnilGadi1 Місяць тому

    Please share the link to the program ‘history of Indian warfare’. Will be most interested to see it

    • @gunnersshot
      @gunnersshot  Місяць тому

      THE STORY OF INDIAN WARFARE / COL AJAY SINGH
      ua-cam.com/users/live8F3TYLinT2c?feature=share

  • @rajenlama.6850
    @rajenlama.6850 Місяць тому

    Jai Hind sir. Description on tangle issue of mentioned countries in your channel is apparently educational and appreciable one.

  • @djrandomwalker7656
    @djrandomwalker7656 Місяць тому

    saw a comment from an american on twitter, "The US would shoot down missiles fired over the Black Sea, but cannot replenish missiles. A port is being built in Romania to allow the US to help Ukraine like we help Israel. Ukraine was cozy with russia. It will take time to integrate with the west. " USA is planning same against India vs ban+pak.

  • @shrithikkothari8220
    @shrithikkothari8220 Місяць тому

    Awesome show sir.

  • @someshbiswas2071
    @someshbiswas2071 Місяць тому

    The placards shown on the slide was to stop Durga Puja that are being arranged by closing roads and immersion of idols in river leading to pollution....all government should support. It is so for Durga Puja being celebrated in Europe also...

  • @MohammadHabib-j1e
    @MohammadHabib-j1e Місяць тому +5

    Prof. Younus declared that the the reform committee will compile reform proposals within 3 months. The proposals will then be discussed with all the political parties. The political parties will decide whether interim govt or elected govt will carry out reform. If the consensus is the political party to reform then election will held immediately. Otherwise, interim govt will carry out the reform and then conduct election. Majority in Bangladesh supports the proposal. Why Indians are freaking out?

    • @gunnersshot
      @gunnersshot  Місяць тому +1

      All the best to you….

    • @dungavhai3319
      @dungavhai3319 Місяць тому

      @@gunnersshot Sir as a Bangladeshi I request you to not to listen to these one sided comment radicals from Bangladesh. You will see them every where and to support them some Pakistanis also take their sides. Your views are straight forward and it should remain so. Bangladeshis with good intellect and proper education will understand you. All the best sons of our Bangladesh now suffering. When Shakib Al Hasan was playing cricket in Canada false cases were lodge against him in Bangladesh. His cricket skills helped Bangladesh to win so many cricket match but again Islamists are ungrateful. Same with Mashrafe Murtaza, proud cricketer from Bangladesh. His house was burned because he supported Awami League. Sir soon you will see how Awami League deal with these Islamist. Awami League means entire Bangladesh irrespective of any religion. These radical Mullahs will be taught the lesson of their life. While you have time please close or reform all the Madrasas. Best thing if India can close these backward education centres as soon as possible. These Madrasas are the real Zombie making centres of Asia.

    • @BhatPara-g7o
      @BhatPara-g7o Місяць тому

      All the Hindus who are being killed, mob lynched, ra**d are AI generated in your opinion? May be your govermemt will not stop until 0 hindus are left in Banglafesh ooh East Pakistan, when you are switching urdu as your national language and declare Jinnah as father of the nation. Good luck all the best on your future plans.

    • @aravindshadishkumar9256
      @aravindshadishkumar9256 Місяць тому

      Your question, why Indians are freaking out. I pity for the common Bangladeshis. Have a good luck for the worst feature of Bangladesh

    • @sunnyj6068
      @sunnyj6068 Місяць тому

      Indians freak out because the Bangladeshi people decides their fate and India is not dictating it

  • @dr.abulhossainahmedbhuiyan9122
    @dr.abulhossainahmedbhuiyan9122 Місяць тому +1

    General you have a very wrong conception. You must examine the role ex PM who was blindly supported by your government. She was clearly a modern fascist.

  • @masumtanna4856
    @masumtanna4856 Місяць тому

    Bangladesh people has really understand Pakistan in 1971, India in 2024 when they are silent about genocide.

  • @sureshtally6731
    @sureshtally6731 Місяць тому

    Today General sir was on war footing, really great to hear from you sir ,my salute to you sir.

  • @abubakersiddik2698
    @abubakersiddik2698 Місяць тому

    If you realeas Short video
    5 minutes to 10 minutes.
    it's helpful for viewer

  • @BhatPara-g7o
    @BhatPara-g7o Місяць тому +1

    JAI HIND , JAI BHARAT

  • @swapanbasak7490
    @swapanbasak7490 Місяць тому +1

    The comment by "Z ar" shows the true colour of a section of Bangladeshis. God help such people.

  • @kumarbishwajitdas3428
    @kumarbishwajitdas3428 Місяць тому

    Jai Hind!

  • @jadumootu6816
    @jadumootu6816 Місяць тому

    This was not a revolution or a Regime change by definition. It was initially a student limited protest, then turned in to mass protest due to killing of students, then finally turned in to Mass Unrest and protest due to more killing (1400+). The regime could very well stay in power just if they wish to. But the Regime head escaped for which entire regime has collapsed.
    Here all US, China, Indian role is got confused before the regime fell. India tried ita best to support but failed.
    Yunus did not say, that student was the brain behind the entire things, he was coordinating once it got out of regime's hand. Only ignorant people will believe its possible by two young person to overthrow a regime like BAL which used all powers of military, RAB, police, Detective brance and foreign intelligence. Definitely there are somebody else. Possibly the biggest looser from this change is India. Because they invested lots of time to bring the regime up to this level which has given everything to India. BD people are furious on this.
    Awami League is possibly gone atleast for 15-20 years or could be longer, as all its 300 MP, all Ministers, all politicians either escaped or captured. And most of them under trial including big fish for serious crimes and genocides. Last time Awami league fell in 1975, it took them 21 yrs to return. But this time their all leaders are gone or hidden.
    There is no section that they are anti India. Its 80% people. Many local mainstream media polls shows so. Because its India itself brought this misfortune to them. Like all her neighbors.
    Since my boyhood I attended 20+ durga pujas. We all enjoy the prasad and music, dance played dyring the festivals. The hindus came under attack were mostly Awami local leaders who abused their community by political power. Durga puja will be comoleted as it used to be. Possibly you mever visited BD and mixed with people. Thats why you have such a wrong perception on BD society.
    BD people also hates any imperial foreign power like US, UK and so on.
    The general finally said, India has to deal with people of BD. Which India never did. They only engaged with Awami regime. It has failed. If they do so again, it will fail again.

  • @satyam_108
    @satyam_108 Місяць тому +2

    Hmm..about iraq i remember reading about Iraqi fathers escorting their daughters to college with AK47..also I have read Ma Anandamoy's autobiography..growing up in her villlage in present Bangladesh in early 20th century she recounts adult Hindus & Muslims didn't socialize with each other.. my friends who have studied with Bangladeshis say that they hate India & also strangely the Indian army who they claim looted them..we should make plans for worst case scenarios..if Kamala Harris wins then its very bad news for India..as an Indian & Bengali what matters to me are the Hindus and other minorities in Bdesh..

  • @bapycy
    @bapycy Місяць тому

    👍👏🇮🇳

  • @aldievoice
    @aldievoice Місяць тому +3

    😂🤣😂 As Bangladeshi I am really enjoining the broken heart of this General and the moderator. The fact which they never acknowledge on their discussion that India’s irresponsible policies towards Bangladesh last 15 years and the blind support towards Hasina’s regime is main reason for the recent people revolution in Bangladesh . There are no other way that regime could be changed.

    • @DaddyYes-t8x
      @DaddyYes-t8x Місяць тому

      what can you expect from these me ni ac ,,, they are out of reality,, they think themselves as russia that can withstand sanctions

    • @chilarai1
      @chilarai1 Місяць тому

      😁🤣😂You will find out very quickly what real enjoyment is 😅😂😅

  • @berasinghdeswal1131
    @berasinghdeswal1131 Місяць тому

    Sir why mislead your notification showed India , Russia,Chuna. But now. You talk something else .All U tube channels are doing it .

    • @gunnersshot
      @gunnersshot  Місяць тому +1

      Where is the notification of India Russia China ? I never sent it!

  • @devcarnegie
    @devcarnegie Місяць тому +1

    sir even strong secular countries like turkiye, malaysia and indonesia are turning radical albeit slowly. this is the nature of political islam. if not this time then it will be next year they don't allow durga puja. first they will destroy their own country and then they will become a nuisance to us like pakistan. but we have an obligation to protect hindus. artificially created borders and cheap sovereign words should not matter.

    • @nobrainer-090
      @nobrainer-090 Місяць тому +2

      If India can become a radical Hindu nation, what’s wrong with Malaysia or Indonesia becoming pro-Muslim nations?

    • @rafiquemohammad294
      @rafiquemohammad294 Місяць тому

      It's so funny , Instead of accepting own failings U've tried to follow absolutely absurd n harinduas path to Subdue , "Relatively Better Performing Countries ", Let's be fair about our Thoughts

  • @motimojumder9192
    @motimojumder9192 Місяць тому

    I Hope those who didn't like the discussions understand English. Otherwise, they should write at least one sentence refuting any of the statements made by general Shankar.

  • @srutidebmahakul
    @srutidebmahakul Місяць тому

    Ask.. Pappu about Indian military history..... before he is educated......🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @mdmahfuzahmmed980
    @mdmahfuzahmmed980 Місяць тому

    The revolution was driven by a detailed and strategic plan. Behind it were sharp minds ensuring the movement stayed ahead of intelligence agencies. Every citizen, except a few Awami mafia members, stood with the students. The plan was foolproof leaders were protected, and even if some were caught, others were ready to step in.
    A critical part of the strategy involved sending updates to local and international media, even during internet shutdowns and curfews. The movement was spread to every educational institute and city across Bangladesh. Young students created rap songs, viral cartoons, and wall art to expose Hasina’s dictatorship, igniting the cause on social media.
    The brain behind the plan unified nine demands into one: forcing the mafia regime and killer Hasina to step down.

  • @pmm7268
    @pmm7268 Місяць тому

    Islamic Phobia is in operation. Hindus of BD are Bangladeshi hindus - with Bangladeshi nationalism- india has no & should not have any say in it other than expressing concern.
    Same with Srilanka, there it is Tamil hindus vs the rest. But, they are srilankan Tamils with srilankan nationalism india cannot be custodian of Hindus all over the world, and that is not even possible within India, and it has never been the policy of the GoI, including the BJP.
    The difference between BJP and other parties is that they know they get votes by being anti-hindu & pro-caste groups + minority religious identities, which are also in practice caste groups only. They do it by colonial logic, they convert diversities into divisions and use it for political profit. BJP does not pursue the anti-hindu narrative; nevertheless, it is not pro-hindu either.
    BJP not being anti-hindu is politicized by claims of secularism or social justice by their convenience.
    India is a truely secular nation even beyond the word that is used by 'secular' parties. It will handle Bangladesh & Sri Lanka as friendly or enemy nation as it requires.
    Buddhist Singala vs Hindu Tamils will not go against India because both these are of Indian origin. They have no sectarian phobia as the one Bangladesh has.
    Bangladesh if it exceeds will get its learning from India. Same would not happen with SriLanka.

  • @babarmatin909
    @babarmatin909 Місяць тому +1

    We need stability in India for everyone

  • @rnugra3292
    @rnugra3292 Місяць тому +1

    India's behaviour towards Bangladesh for the eight/nine years has been full of egoistic bombastic utterances, like calling them termites and infiltrators etc , antagonizing the masses ,which gave a handle to anti India, pro Pakistani minority there, who switched indian outbursts to give it a communal colour and the resultant is there for every one to see.
    With democracy gone, from Bangladesh , the security situation on our eastern border is back to pre-1971 state, which, in addition to Pakistan now is China supported too !

    • @rafiquemohammad294
      @rafiquemohammad294 Місяць тому

      It's not Bangladesh in Tangles , "instead India is by virtue of it's wrong n malicious aproach".

  • @babarmatin909
    @babarmatin909 Місяць тому +3

    Khalistan Kashmir and seven sisters West Bengal want to separate from India

    • @chilarai1
      @chilarai1 Місяць тому

      That is some powerful stuff you are smoking. Enjoy.

  • @sachidamudaliar8445
    @sachidamudaliar8445 Місяць тому +1

    BANGLADESHI HIIDUS ARE BANGLADESHI AND NOT INDIAS PROBLEMS!!!!WO ANKHE AUR DIMAAG KHOLKE HAE WAHA!!!!???GOOD LUCK TO THEM!!!!!

    • @metaphoric-j1c
      @metaphoric-j1c Місяць тому +1

      @@sachidamudaliar8445 certainly not. The country had been divided in the basis of religion. Even after 1971 war Bangladesh did not join Indian union. Because they are Muslims. So India has a right to say in favour of the Hindus there.

  • @suvajitroy1816
    @suvajitroy1816 Місяць тому +1

    if anyone one can ans .....why jammat e islami is supported by china in this time ????

  • @sachidamudaliar8445
    @sachidamudaliar8445 Місяць тому +1

    SHREEJI THEY ARE MUSALMAAN AND THEY FOLLOW MO'HD IE WHAT HE DID IN MACCA&MADINA !!!!!!????

  • @moshizaman39
    @moshizaman39 Місяць тому

    General, appears to me you are loosing control of yoirself.

  • @laikahmed6298
    @laikahmed6298 Місяць тому +2

    Pjeets crying

  • @ranabasak8889
    @ranabasak8889 Місяць тому

    We can only pride over our great military history if only can overcome the pain from the huge losses in our intrnal problem generated for centuries by jihady mentality. The great valour of our heros is zerored nullifed by internal problems. So the first targed the internal problems.

  • @ranabasak8889
    @ranabasak8889 Місяць тому +1

    I don't agree with the general. He also showing the same softness by telling that we will not enter Bangladesh. Sorry we are not caring about Hindus neither in Bangladesh nor in India.

  • @kriskapadia9142
    @kriskapadia9142 Місяць тому

    Let's have faith in India's MEA and other agencies to tackle the problems.

  • @mdmahfuzahmmed980
    @mdmahfuzahmmed980 Місяць тому +4

    This lieutenant general is talking nonsense without any understanding. It’s hard to watch-I couldn’t sit through more than a few minutes, skipping here and there. He’s concerned about political parties, but for his information, all the political parties support Yunus, no matter what. Any reforms will happen through discussion, consensus, and agreements with all stakeholders and political parties. The next elected parliament will approve those reforms.

    • @AmalTan
      @AmalTan Місяць тому +1

      Why should unelected people do the reforms?

    • @mdmahfuzahmmed980
      @mdmahfuzahmmed980 Місяць тому +2

      @@AmalTan there is a difference between unelected government and revolutionary government.

    • @mdmahfuzahmmed980
      @mdmahfuzahmmed980 Місяць тому +3

      Yes, the revolutionary government will carry out the reforms because the Hasina regime has destroyed the constitution and all the institutions of the country. We must do this to ensure that countries like India never have the chance to install a puppet government again. This interim government will ensure the safety and security of Bangladesh, and all future governments will follow the spirit of this revolution.

    • @AmalTan
      @AmalTan Місяць тому

      ​@@mdmahfuzahmmed980 If you haven't won the elections then you are a usurper. Anyways if that is what BNG wants then so be it. Hope you are successful!

    • @AjitKumar-lo9yu
      @AjitKumar-lo9yu Місяць тому

      ​@@mdmahfuzahmmed980by reform wat do you mean, did Bangladesh not have a constitution which has laws to deal with corruption, did Sheikh make any amendments to these laws to suit her that now it has to be re-written. Why are you confused if somebody has subverted some laws.
      Srilanka also faced similar situations they did not talk about reforming constitution and other BS.

  • @aspiringscientist5455
    @aspiringscientist5455 Місяць тому +3

    Focus on your own business, Bangladesh is not your vessel state anymore,

    • @manjunathmanjunath1305
      @manjunathmanjunath1305 Місяць тому

      @@aspiringscientist5455 lol, lmao. No financial base. No technological aspiration. No cultural affinity. Taiwan is worlds apart and is a US vassal. You are lower than their dogs. Its your destiny. Your puppet PM dare not announce elections until the US says so.

    • @shrithikkothari8220
      @shrithikkothari8220 Місяць тому

      Vassal* state hota hai. And no use keeping B'desh as a vassal cuz you folks are just empty vessels who make noise. Cheers.

    • @triptirathore9027
      @triptirathore9027 Місяць тому +1

      This is an Indian channel , we can do what we want , you get out from here

    • @aspiringscientist5455
      @aspiringscientist5455 Місяць тому

      @@triptirathore9027 I commenting on my own computer with my own account! Warning those culprits who spread propaganda against Bangladesh

    • @triptirathore9027
      @triptirathore9027 Місяць тому +1

      @@aspiringscientist5455 lol you keyboard worrier warning other people from you little keyboard, God we got scared 😄

  • @mdshofiqulislam2925
    @mdshofiqulislam2925 Місяць тому

    Dear PR Shankar Sir,
    With due respect, I would like to express that many young Bangladeshis including myself do not support Awami League or its political activities. We do not have a favorable view of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, Sheikh Hasina or their families. However, we have great admiration for India as our neighbor and are eternally grateful for India's significant support, both human and military, during the freedom struggle.
    As a young Bangladeshi, I humbly request that India prioritizes building a strong relationship with the people of Bangladesh rather than focusing only on political leaders. It is the people of Bangladesh who value and desire everlasting friendship with India.

    • @chilarai1
      @chilarai1 Місяць тому

      That is your right as it is for all bangladeshis but India will only recognize a government that wins a free and fair election as the legitimate voice of your country. We have no favourite leader or party and we really don't care who you people choose. But you MUST choose through elections. Even pakistan cannot say "we are a dictatorship" because then even their katoras will not be recognized as legitimate.

    • @mdshofiqulislam2925
      @mdshofiqulislam2925 Місяць тому

      @@chilarai1 Thank you for your reply, sir.many young Bangladeshis, including myself, are deeply frustrated that Sheikh Hasina has remained in power for 15 years without fair elections. What upsets us further is that India has never raised concerns about this, and instead, she has been welcomed as a diplomatic guest. Even after the tragic killing of 1,000 students, Sheikh Hasina continues to stay in India without accountability.
      Sir, I would also like to emphasize that Bangladesh gained independence with a Bengali identity, not a Muslim identity like Pakistan. Therefore, any comparison between Bangladeshis and Pakistanis is not accurate or fair.

  • @babarmatin909
    @babarmatin909 Місяць тому +1

    If Muslims are not allowed to exercise their religion then India loses in Nepal Bhutan Bangladesh Sri Lanka Pakistan

  • @Mkk-sl
    @Mkk-sl Місяць тому

    General stop talking about Bangladesh! Is it you peoples habit to talk about others only?? Why can’t you mind your own business???

    • @chilarai1
      @chilarai1 Місяць тому

      You heard it all didn't you? You need to hear it and we want to say it. 😁

    • @Mkk-sl
      @Mkk-sl Місяць тому

      @@chilarai1 no I didn’t hear it all, cause your talks are based on your narrative which is far removed from reality. Come visit Bangladesh, hear the pulse of the people and form a narrative! That would be more acceptable. But you would never do that because your closed mindset is entangled in fundamentalist and racist strings and the belief that what you say , what you do or what you comprehend is on the top of every one else despite the fact that you are currently governed by a racist regime, a tea boy as a leader, who is a champion of communal politics!!!

    • @Mkk-sl
      @Mkk-sl Місяць тому

      In fact I haven’t ! What’s the point when your parroty narrative is far removed from reality!

    • @mostafazaman1734
      @mostafazaman1734 Місяць тому

      ​@@Mkk-slI wish i could emblem your comment with gilder❤️❤️❤️

  • @mahmoodmalik6784
    @mahmoodmalik6784 Місяць тому

    One sided, propaganda video. The situation of minorities in Bangladesh is much much better than India. Try to be a good neighbor. Look around your relationship with your neighbors.

    • @rafiquemohammad294
      @rafiquemohammad294 Місяць тому

      It's an Absolutely True Perspective which leads to Sincere Thought

  • @im-4733
    @im-4733 Місяць тому

    maan it's not about what's written in newspaper, it's about narrative you guys are not getting 😂.
    we both seeing the same news but you have failed to see the ground narrative

  • @mostafazaman1734
    @mostafazaman1734 Місяць тому +1

    Dr. Youus invited Modi to have chat from the sideline. But that thickhead refused. Now when Dr. Yunus is talking with Pakistani leader why are you complaining now? You had yoiur chance!! Seems like everey nation but India are happy for Bangladesh and greeting him in open arrns.

    • @AjitKumar-lo9yu
      @AjitKumar-lo9yu Місяць тому

      Modi does not have to go to new york to meet yunus

    • @rafiquemohammad294
      @rafiquemohammad294 Місяць тому

      Let's Face it , India has lost it's Chance , Now Bangladesh will Decide It's Future as to Where n How To Go About ?

    • @ysmalik8690
      @ysmalik8690 Місяць тому

      ​​@@rafiquemohammad294 Sure. Yunus will get groceries from Pakistan, vegetables from Sri Lanka, needles from China, thread from Taiwan, cloth from HK and chicken from Laos.....and your garment buyers are substantially Indians in New York. Enjoy 😂

    • @mostafazaman1734
      @mostafazaman1734 Місяць тому

      @@AjitKumar-lo9yu it’s not about where he meet and where not to with Dr. Yunus. It's about the complain mr. General is making for talking Pakistani leader in sideline. Indian communities over the edge attitude towards Bangladesh matter is utter childish and nonsensical.

    • @AjitKumar-lo9yu
      @AjitKumar-lo9yu Місяць тому

      @@mostafazaman1734 it wasn't childish to lose the life 4000 soldiers and 10000 injured soldiers apart from money that India had committed in that war, and now to see where that country is headed with radicalization and deep hatred for India and Indians and particularly Hindus iss very worrying for the General which is not just present in the so called intellectuals, politician, teaching class, TV analyst but has now seeped into the ordinary public.
      We are a bigger country and there is a lot of depth and capacity in the Indian foreign policy and we can deal with it but in this scenario wat sort of future can one foresee.

  • @bapycy
    @bapycy Місяць тому

    👍👏🇮🇳