Haters gonna hate. But ER fans have been saying SOTE is a full game since release. The Game Awards just agrees with the majority opinion of tarnished. Rise tarnished!
@@brandenlucero Hard disagree. Then you start getting into the territory of how do you measure "substantial difference?" In my eyes, FF7 Rebirth is a DLC for FF7 Remake. The original game released in the 90s as a single game, yet somehow people are cheering SQEnix on as they drip-feed bloated, convoluted pieces of it every few years. I forced myself to finish Remake and got burned out with Rebirth. Simply too much bloat and awful side quests. Meanwhile I completed Shadow of the Erdtree twice, then platinumed Elden Ring and Stellar Blade.
@@michaelharrington5860 categorizing rebirth as a dlc to remake is crazy. If you think that rebirth is bad that’s fine but other then personal preference, there’s no way that it shouldn’t at least be up for nomination bc it changes so much from the original, and is it’s own game. Also rebirth is a sequel to the og not a remake
The fact that none of the Trails games have ever been nominated for music while AAA games with zero memorable songs in them are constantly nominated is an absolute disgrace to gaming. Why am I not surprised there is no sign of Visons of Mana either :s
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year on 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016 and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. Why is nobody mentioning this and instead pretending like this is some new rule or something?
I just came to know the the nomenees through your video, the funniest part is our reactions were basically the same hahaha. I agree with you, despite I love FromSotware, i think SOTE should be a different Category like Best DLC/Expansion. Best Art Direction i can understand because, it's new content with new maps, weapons, enemies and etc, but I wouldn't put it in Best Direciton because it's the same philosphy and game with some new elements but does not innovate, it polishes. Black Myth Wukong between some nomenees is excellent for industry.
There's a lot of whiners in the comments but everyone should just decide for themselves. I personally think the nominees all make sense. I wouldn't have put Elden Ring DLC over a full game but I understand it's not all about me. I'm happy Wukong made it🎉 Good luck to all the nominees hope it's a fun show.
Animal Well was fantastic. Balatro is fun, but I'm not a big fan of card games. As for Shadow of the Erdtree, I think it is perfectly fine that it might win. The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015. Blood & Wine DLC won best rpg of the year in 2016. Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. I'm not sure why people are surprised that SotE was nominated given the precedence of DLCs being nominated for big awards in previous TGAs. To be frank, I think the Elden Ring DLC was better than all of the other games this year, so why shouldn't it be nominated? The real snub for me was Nine Sols not getting a nomination in the indie category. That game is being slept on.
Astro bot probably going win goty. But my goty is definately Metaphor refantizo. But I agree elden ring sote nom goty is definately a slap in the face 😅
They really put a dlc in goty part but left out Hogwarts Legacy from last year which was very loved besides the fake outrage people that's insane but shows how credible this awards show is
I love Elder Ring, but its really unfair for other games to not get any opportunities, DLC should have separate nominations, DLCs are just a part of the game its not a standalone game at all…
i'd give Art to Metaphor , shit looks badass Like A Dragon : Yakuza was the worst adaption i've seen for anything ever and i AM a Like A Dragon/Yakuza fan
I'm sorry but DLC should not be on this at all unless it was a DLC bracket, blood and wine is one of the best DLC's ever made bigger than elden Ring DLC And no one expected it to be in the nominations for game Awards.
@@Pinkfloydeasye187 A DLC isn't "Role Playing Game of the Year" either, and yet, they have done this before. I'm just pointing out the precedence. Not that it is right or wrong.
@@michaelharrington5860 That is true I don't think blood and wines deserve it either I love that dlc but it is not its own game you have to have the base game to play it just like any DLC or expansion.
I am a -massive- fan of Elden Ring. I very much enjoyed my playthrough, and my playthrough through Shadow of the Erdtree. But there is -no- way that Erdtree should win over any of those other games. It has far, far too many issues and falls so far short of the best From can do (apart from art direction. Holy crap, what a masterwork).
We got: The witcher 3 Blood and wines and Earth of stone, Outer Wilds: Echoes of the eye, Xenoblade 3: Futur Redemeemed, Cyberpunk Phantom Liberty, But it’s only after FromSoft’s DLC that DLCs magically become eligible for GotY, I don’t know...
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016, and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. This is nothing new.
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016, and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. This is nothing new.
How we feeling about Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree in the noms??????? :D
I don’t think it shouldn’t be in there for a dlc
It's the best game released this year. Other games need to get better. 🤷♂️
@@Ericutz4thewin I don’t have a problem with it nom,but it should have its own category.
Haters gonna hate. But ER fans have been saying SOTE is a full game since release. The Game Awards just agrees with the majority opinion of tarnished.
Rise tarnished!
I'm happy about the DLC's recognition, but it just seems to me like they really don't want certain games like Wukong from taking Goty lol
Man not in the game of the year category brahh 😭
I feel like DLCs and remakes need their own category but overall I thought the nominations were okay.
Remakes are fine as long as there's a substantial difference over the original.
@@brandenlucero Hard disagree. Then you start getting into the territory of how do you measure "substantial difference?" In my eyes, FF7 Rebirth is a DLC for FF7 Remake. The original game released in the 90s as a single game, yet somehow people are cheering SQEnix on as they drip-feed bloated, convoluted pieces of it every few years. I forced myself to finish Remake and got burned out with Rebirth. Simply too much bloat and awful side quests. Meanwhile I completed Shadow of the Erdtree twice, then platinumed Elden Ring and Stellar Blade.
@@michaelharrington5860 categorizing rebirth as a dlc to remake is crazy. If you think that rebirth is bad that’s fine but other then personal preference, there’s no way that it shouldn’t at least be up for nomination bc it changes so much from the original, and is it’s own game. Also rebirth is a sequel to the og not a remake
The fact that none of the Trails games have ever been nominated for music while AAA games with zero memorable songs in them are constantly nominated is an absolute disgrace to gaming. Why am I not surprised there is no sign of Visons of Mana either :s
WWHHHAAATTT !! Elden Ring ??
Im so happy but ... also very surprised 🤪
Wukong baby 🔥🔥
I can't help but feel like Astro Bot Is just a placeholder for all the other games Sony didn't bring us this year. 🤣
And yet it is one of their highest scoring games. Dumbass
So they just happened to make DLC eligible for GOTY after SOTE came out?
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year on 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016 and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. Why is nobody mentioning this and instead pretending like this is some new rule or something?
I just came to know the the nomenees through your video, the funniest part is our reactions were basically the same hahaha.
I agree with you, despite I love FromSotware, i think SOTE should be a different Category like Best DLC/Expansion. Best Art Direction i can understand because, it's new content with new maps, weapons, enemies and etc, but I wouldn't put it in Best Direciton because it's the same philosphy and game with some new elements but does not innovate, it polishes.
Black Myth Wukong between some nomenees is excellent for industry.
also try Animal Well and Balatro . They are amazing !
Animal Well is one of my favorite game of the year
There's a lot of whiners in the comments but everyone should just decide for themselves. I personally think the nominees all make sense. I wouldn't have put Elden Ring DLC over a full game but I understand it's not all about me. I'm happy Wukong made it🎉 Good luck to all the nominees hope it's a fun show.
Bro Erica's laugh is so contagious. When she laughs i laugh 😂
The tears when erdtree wins is going to be so sweet
They're going to give it Best Direction so that the others can win GOTY
Combat wise Rise of The Ronin should of been listed too. Team Ninja need to upgrade Their Engine.
Animal Well was fantastic. Balatro is fun, but I'm not a big fan of card games. As for Shadow of the Erdtree, I think it is perfectly fine that it might win. The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015. Blood & Wine DLC won best rpg of the year in 2016. Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. I'm not sure why people are surprised that SotE was nominated given the precedence of DLCs being nominated for big awards in previous TGAs. To be frank, I think the Elden Ring DLC was better than all of the other games this year, so why shouldn't it be nominated? The real snub for me was Nine Sols not getting a nomination in the indie category. That game is being slept on.
I'm playing Nine Sols and I agree!
MORE ERICUTZ CONTENT!!! 🔥
Hey haven’t seen you on twitter aka X at all. Hope you’re safe and healthy.
I left twitter like 4 months ago or something like that, I'm good frogs!! How you been
@ Been amazing thinking about leaving also. Due to most people I communicate with I have on social media or their phone number.
I’m personally hoping Prince of Persia the Lost Crown wins best action/adventure game.
Astro bot probably going win goty. But my goty is definately Metaphor refantizo. But I agree elden ring sote nom goty is definately a slap in the face 😅
Hope you're having a good day today. ❤ Also if Elden Ring wins GOTY as DLC is gonna be wild lol
Phantom Blade Zero was robbed
For most anticipated?
@Ericutz4thewin yep
Those are only there as placeholders. Nothing stands a chance against GTA6
God damn it 😂
I was excited but now that elden ring is here, pack it up
They gonna win everything lol
If the dlc is as big as the base game?
DLCs should have their own categories... but whatever...
They really put a dlc in goty part but left out Hogwarts Legacy from last year which was very loved besides the fake outrage people that's insane but shows how credible this awards show is
Hogwarts is mediocre that's why it was left off
I’m glad Zzz got nominated
I love Elder Ring, but its really unfair for other games to not get any opportunities, DLC should have separate nominations, DLCs are just a part of the game its not a standalone game at all…
It's unfair to gamers that AAA devs dropped the ball this year. Why exclude Shadow of the Erdtree for actually delivering?
@@michaelharrington5860not really there’s plenty of great triple a games this year
@Davmac573 There's plenty of AAA games, none of them were particularly good, especially Western games. Just my opinion of course.
i'd give Art to Metaphor , shit looks badass
Like A Dragon : Yakuza was the worst adaption i've seen for anything ever and i AM a Like A Dragon/Yakuza fan
I'm sorry but DLC should not be on this at all unless it was a DLC bracket, blood and wine is one of the best DLC's ever made bigger than elden Ring DLC And no one expected it to be in the nominations for game Awards.
Blood and Wine won RPG of the year in 2016
@@michaelharrington5860 ok you're right but not goty a dlc is not a new game.
@@Pinkfloydeasye187 A DLC isn't "Role Playing Game of the Year" either, and yet, they have done this before. I'm just pointing out the precedence. Not that it is right or wrong.
@@michaelharrington5860 That is true I don't think blood and wines deserve it either I love that dlc but it is not its own game you have to have the base game to play it just like any DLC or expansion.
No DLC and REMAKES. It’s gonna be a woke trash fest
Hate and judgment on video games continues
Stella Blade should of been listed Game of The Year too.
Lol GTA VI is the most anticipated and we've seen 0 gameplay. 😅
That's what happens when Rockstar puts out banger after banger.
If they win the meltdown will be crazy lol
Goty Queen Is Here😚
I am a -massive- fan of Elden Ring. I very much enjoyed my playthrough, and my playthrough through Shadow of the Erdtree. But there is -no- way that Erdtree should win over any of those other games. It has far, far too many issues and falls so far short of the best From can do (apart from art direction. Holy crap, what a masterwork).
Not watching this crap this year. Stupidity for these awards have reached an all time low
I see your favourite game dont have nominees.
@ they are all nominated.
Nope where is Dragon age veilguard and Rise of the ronin ?
We got:
The witcher 3 Blood and wines and Earth of stone,
Outer Wilds: Echoes of the eye, Xenoblade 3: Futur Redemeemed, Cyberpunk Phantom Liberty,
But it’s only after FromSoft’s DLC that DLCs magically become eligible for GotY, I don’t know...
It wouldn't have been as egregious if they had announced this months in advance
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016, and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. This is nothing new.
@@michaelharrington5860 Don't forget Blood & Wine won best RPG against Dark Souls 3
❤
A damn DLC
Go home Geoff. You're drunk.
🤣
The Witcher 3 won game of the year and rpg of the year in 2015, then Blood & Wine DLC won rpg of the year in 2016, and Monster Hunter World Iceborne was nominated for rpg of the year in 2019. This is nothing new.
@@michaelharrington5860 this is new for the game awards, dumbass. That's the whole point.