@@babin214 The day we see the end of Gandhi hegemony in the Congress. Let the Sachin Pilots & Shashi Tharoors take charge of the party. Only then we'll start thinking of Congress as an option. Until then, BJP is there to stay. Take my word.
Great arguments Prabhakar sir😍. These religiously blinded people like Sai and Anand will thrive only on social media. When they encounter intellectuals like Prabhakar sir, they will only get down to Hindu-muslimarguments.
Discriminating hindus is secularism in india Treating Hindus equally is communal in india Thats why those who talk about hindus or instead of Hindus becomes communal 😢
It's other way round rather. India had always respected every religion. Intellectuals never believed in fanatics although he practised his religion at home and never imposed on others. It is purifying the self rather than making it an ostensive show .
@@mansidash78 Muslim appeasement politics are hallmark of Indian secularism . In a secular country why there are special laws for Muslims and why there is waqf board ?
@@mansidash78 ya ya Like wafq board hoarding 8Lakh acres of land..RTE is not applicable to minority institutions..Muslims have their own law regarding to poligamy and marriage
@@varapulasrinivasaraoHe was in the BJP and then PRP. In fact, he resigned from PRP when it merged with Congress. He is more anti-Congress than the BJP, which supported forced division of Telugus by the Congress.
If Dr Anand Ranganathan criticises everyone, then he would be criticising the govt. since they make all the decisions and none by the opposition in Indian democracy.
@@james432ful Did he blast Modi for reducing tax devolution funding to Souther states by implementing the 2011 census at 100% in the 15th Finance Commission?
@@kksastry2319 If you are talking about Dr Parakala, he was in TDP during the previous AP govt. Although his wife is the Finance minister, Dr Parakala doesn't blindly support AP backstabbing party.
As a Telugu guy, I'm yet to see Mr. Parakala say a single positive thing. Speaks ill of everyone since decades including the ones who give him political space and his own wife. Such a waste of human energy filled with negativity all the time.
Could not agree more of your description for Prabhakara garu.. Having known him for decades, he is a person who exudes maximum negative energy in any crowded room, always taking ill of others in a sarcastic manner, back biting, looking for flaws even in a 5-star conference room, the tea is bitter, coffee over-heated, Aircon not working properly, staff is so untrained, even how it rains at wrong time, climate is always bad9 and stuffy in Bangalore, has nasty fights with his car Drivers, that none works with him for more than 6 months.. Would not comment about his internal family relations, as that is personal However one feels sorry for his family. Prabhakara garu has such a bad persona exuding negative vibrations that surprisingly shops and malls get empty when he walks in. Such is his bad karma & negative energy.
@@smritichiti2631 What truth? Which honorable husband rubbishes and makes fun of his wife and her work in a public manner, so as to harm it, and all this out of mere jealousy. Prabhakara himself is too insignificant for Modi to take note of him, but certainly his actions reflect poorly on his wife, who is a self accomplished Lady and must be required to give explanations at some level atleast. It is wisdom & sagacity of Modi, that he knows her value and ignores her husband's illogical rants, However in the dog eat dog world of Indian politics there must be hundreds who will try & poison Modi & Shah's mind against her. Yet she soldiers on, hats off to her in tolerating such a difficult & negative spouse.
@@jaideepc786 If he was really the kind of person you mentioned, Nirmala Sitaraman would have known as Nirmala Parakala. Further, Nirmala Sitaraman did nothing to AP though she has been nominated to Rajyasabha and I am sure he had some influence in her nomination by being in TDP. No sane person from AP would support Modi, who destroyed the state by denying what BJP itself asked for the residual state when AP was divided.
Interesting, when Anand Ranganathan speaks, even audio system of Indian express starts echoing...... (: Rest of time sound system of Indian system works well...
Dr Prabhakar has list of problems and no Solutions .. This is the text book definition of Socialism -- Kolkata gone -- Kerala Gone -- Tripura is limping back after BJP came to power .. CHINA is flourishing since they practiced Capitalism since 1979 .. As Dr Anand said Socialism is failed world wide -- Let us not do that experiment once again . Socialism is widely recognized as DISTRIBUTION of WEALTH WHICH THEY DO NOT HAVE ..
@spg6651 you are absolutely right... Kerala is a sinking ship and the captain is building his own empire for his offspring in Dubai. Kerala banks collapsing due to communists indulging in corruption. Government can't pay salaries to its employees and public transport system is collapsing due to lack of funds.. Situation is grim there... State is moving to Srilankan or Pakistan way...
He made a wrong choice of working for congress . His wife became finance minister and he is still suffering .. what to do . She made right political choice ..
The beauty of democracy,husband ideology may differ,from that of wife.but each go as per their perception and commitment to values.Nirmalaji is sacrificing a lot for the sake of country and passionate of her responsibilities.Her honesty is some thing is unique.🙏💐🙏
. . Promise was sky high in 2914 and manifesto sofar not achieved. Earlier graduates from India went to other countries and it is a record that every organisation was given to an Indian as CEOs. And in ten years graduates are going to other countries as soldiers. This answers the earlier great India. All four pillars of economy was laid before 2014 and no improvement or up grading was done. All this kept under the carpet and chose to blame grandfathers and selecting hindutva making all surrounding countries turned against Indians. This situation never existed and Neghru was respected as best statesmen and he brought many international critical matters solution. The main thing is before 2014 whole world was of there opinion that India will overtake china GDP of 20 trillion in 7 years and we are stuck at 3.8 trillion and world stopped India as overtaking china or equalling. One foreign press recently declared that India takes 250 years to catch up. All these are the results of 10 years efforts
Shocking how passive aggressive Prabhakar is. Super out of place in a Modern India with such closed thought process. He does not want to acknowledge even a bit of positive outcomes. In some instances he is outright lying - for example how many people have slipped into poverty ! On top of it he is an economist :) And the host trying her best to support Prabhakar
American Brookings institute reports(on Mar 1,2024) “India Eliminates Extreme Poverty” . This is the Power of Modi. Within 10 years, the man has lifted poverty & created a Nano Class. This should have been done by INC decades back but mofo are chor.
parakaala prabhakar is husband of seetharaman, but , he is a bootlicker of chandrababu naidu .he back stabbed chiru when he was in praja rajyam. now he is loyal to his pedigree of babu.he always carries hate against modi.
This is like yin and yang. One is worried man with grey hair and other younger one so proud of the progress. It is so uplifting to hear (per Anand- loud and clear), Indians are living in a golden era with best things in life. God bless the prosperity.
its actually the other way! anand R is useful to listen if he points out islams anti-any-other concepts, destruction of actual indian history by the leftists etc. besides that he speaks of modi govt as if they're just municipal corporation hyping up buffeted #s of provision of water, toilet, house, cylinder, bank acct, etc . nothing abt 4k sq kmlost to china, ridicule of the country actually abroad, etc. so anand better stick to his science and history lessons, not economics and future
U r just saying to satisfy your ego. In reality, Prabhakar was much more calm, logical and without religious biased. Anand was also good but not comparable to Prabhar as Anand is blinded by his hatred and has his agenda to support his political papa at all cost. Anand, this is not random reel making. This is intellectual Prabhakar sir against whom u have to pur facts!
@@tippanachandu9928 Fools think everything wrong belong to Gandhi & Nehru and Everything right belongs to Modi and Shah. Modi Shah BJP is a fool making machine
@@TeluguBusinessChannel Fools think India appeared from USA and does not know its own strength. That is the problem with Indians . Even if one of them goes to the Kailasa temple in Aurangabad you understand the greatness of our history and culture. But no , people like to visit las vegas instead
@@TeluguBusinessChannel I think you lives in fools paradise 😝😝😝😝what your nehru and Gandhi did for nation?ho ho, bharat was divided under your Gandhi and Nehru,am i right?
Fantastic, Anand Ranganathan. A handful of people like JSai, Vikram Sampath and Anand and a handful of others, are in the process of extricating us from the false narrative about our country that was assiduously built and ingrained in us all by our early leaders
Crooked Prabhakar, you have no words. Better introspect. How much have you given to the society instead of asking the general public. You call yourself as Economist, right?
In the view of eminent person parakala prabhakarji, till 2014, india was poverty ridden with full of employment with a stunning growth in all fields od science, technolgy, medicine, space etc. Till 2014, there was no animosity on religion basis. Till 2012, every indian were living properously and not depended on government alms. I am astonished to hear that eminent personolity speech. Ridiculous.
Very wise, humble, soft spoken Parikala Prabhakar spoke with full of wisdom & Humility. Unlike Anand, who spoke in agitated manner... no Humility at all 😢
Parakala Don’t care two hoots if Parakala is a known economist. He earned notoriety for his cunningness and backstab. Earlier also, Parakala managed to become the inside man of Praja Rajyam Party and sabotaged them. He should not comment against a govt where his learned wife is the Fin. Min. Most unreliable and erratic spokes person. Earlier also back home, Parakala backstabbed Eanadu Ramoji and Chiranjeevi of Praja Rajyam Party after winning their trust.
Prabhakaran is an Economist and speaks with great clarity. It is important to pay heed to him. Now there is a saying that empty vessels make the loudest noise 😂 and listening to the debate, it is clear who it is. The same hindu-muslim sanatani rhetoric. The echo is because he is speaking fast. You need to speak slowly into a Mike.
Lies presented by Prabhakar must be exposed. Poverty rate in India was slashed, says report, but globally 1.2 bn still poor, according to research published 17 Oct 2022 by the United Nations Development Programme and the University of Oxford. Dr Usha Kanagaratnam, who leads the global MPI estimations at Oxford, shared, ‘In India 415 million people left poverty in 15 years. This finding (which is a lower bound) - that a huge country can more than halve multidimensional poverty in 15 years - really is a cause for hope. * Index shows 1 in 5 people in the developing world living in multidimensional poverty. * Hundreds of millions lack adequate nutrition, sanitation, housing and good cooking facilities. * But, India’s MPI poverty rate fell from 55.1% (colonial Congress Rule) to 16.4% (Muzrim lover Modi Rule) as millions were lifted out of poverty.
@@venkateswarluk5133Pertinent; I would presume that since the free foodgrains coverage has remained static over the last ten years, a number approximating the increase in population, viz 14 crore were uplifted. (Using this lone benchmark).
@@ananthan8951 You said in your previous comment that 415 million (41.5 cr) people left poverty in 15 years, which changed to 14 cr in 10 years in your second comment, which is true. Nevertheless, if 80cr out of 140cr still depend on food grains provided by the Modi govt., will we call it a reduction of the poverty rate from 55% in the previous govt. to 16% in the present govt. Also, what did Modi govt. actually do to reduce poverty and that too by increasing the tax burden on middle-class people?
@@venkateswarluk5133let's assume that the Modi govt did nothing. Then this could happen? If one looks at the situation objectively, it is very difficult to believe that it did nothing, and nothing has progressed from 2014. One other thing I am totally surprised that in none of the debates, the devastating set back due to the COVID and Ukraine war comes up in an i objective way. It would be an achievement even if we stayed at pre-covid level now, but looks like we are better than that.
Such a spineless , confused , dumb mediator & such a lame , pointless argument presented by Mr. Prabhakar. all I saw was an easy debate for the BOSS , Anand Ranganathan sir .
Hello..what this Prabhakar talking about? He claims he is an economist! What did he do with his views when Congress was in power for 70 years? He do not impress at all.
Mr. Prabhakar has to answer, Which Patriot who have participated in freedom struggle are alive to participate from the positions of power and if they are alive what is their age and what is their fitness. Mr. Prabhakar laments these old freedom fighters are present in India. This mean new India has born. Can he expect the o
Dr Parakala Prabhakar is an excellent economist, clear in his views and talks from a space of integrity and goodwill. Thank you Dr Prabhakar. You are very relevant and logical. Stay blessed Sir
Recently a Hindu procession in haryana is attacked with automatic weapons, stones and knives by Muslims without any provocation. Muslims are supposed to be insecure.😮
Sri. Anand Ranganadhan has given a befitting reply to Mr. Prabhakar.. I belongs to Mr. Prabhakar's father's constituency, Narsapur of West. God.Dist. in A.P., who was a hardcore Congress party candidate throughout his life, which was the mother of all misdeeds, mischieves, dark laws against Hindus..
I don’t know which India Mr Prabhakar is talking about?.. Forget the economy the very fact that he thinks India is only for one particular religious group and ppl of other religion get second class citizen treatment is ludicrous! If not anything this is probably the only nation where the majority is fearful of speaking their minds!! Truly disappointing..
Abusing Hindu way of living has become a very convenient way of attracting public attention…….Perhaps,…….why perhaps it is well known that criticising Muslim way of living is sure to invite threats which could make someone’s day-to-day living unsafe
Why would you even think the way you are thinking. Can't you think of something else. Why this sudden shift in priorities. This is simply because the likes of you and million more are financially and economically safe, insulated and sound and as such you have so much time and energy at your disposal to talk about and support a divisive agenda and narrative. Come on, this is not the way progressive minds work. This is nothing but regression and degeneration..
He never claimed, he is the husband of the Finance minister since she became a finance minister, I haven't even seen a picture together as a minister standing with her husband, He stands on his own merit despite being coming from a political family, His both parents were ex members of parliament in lok sabha, He is an alumni of JNU Delhi and has Doctoral degree from LSE ( London School of Economics).
Wow, I can easily say that the place was absolutely filled with mindless, brainless and senseless sanghis with the kind of applause I was hearing when some useless and pointless argument was made against Prabhakar’s points! Also I can see the sheep herd is trying to dominate the comments area also supporting the senseless arguments and comparisons in the name of sarcasm by Anand!
😂😂 Parakala only achievement is he is a husband of Nirmala aunty😂…except that he has no achievements..even his books don’t sell 😂..Anand Ranganathan is a great debater…and INDIAs Number one micro biology researcher just Google his papers
Parakala is a genuine man and superb economists. Please read his books before you judge him. If you are a bakt already, skip ahead, AR type opinion makers(repeats the same thing in 1000 programs like a chant) and rabble rousers are the right choice for you.
Parakala and psick like you would be pissing in pants when the facts are thrown at you by the bhakts AR and the like. Commies/pSickulars are, just like Bedbugs which survive on others blood, who in their entire history any where in the globe could bring in prosperity in any country.That's a slap with a worn-out sandal on their face.
Personal attacks, name calling first, and whataboutery seem to be Mr. Anand's first point of arguments rather than any numbers / facts / lack of datas / any such metrics. I was watching this thinking he was supposed to be an intellectually with knowledgeable arguments. Pretty disappointing, the lack of logical points vs excessive shouting & what-aboutery.
If there is 1 thing u cant croticize ranga about its that he doesnt give facts and numbers He spoke in points and gave very specific numbers and facts as examples to support his argument. He is a scientist and his political analysis is scientific too. On the other hand it was pp who was pulling fake allegation from air filled with heavy bias and lies You are completely wrong
Prabhakar is a hypocrite finding fault only on one side and let other side go scot-free. Anand clearly won the debate beating up pessimistic Prabhakar black and blue
@@mayamenon1616 Well, I had explained that in my previous message also. He finds fault on one side and keeps mum on the other side. He alludes to Yati Narsimhanand's *words* but happily forgets Sar than se juda *actions* in response to Nupur Sharma's retort quoting Hadees. "Dr" for Prabhakar is interesting, might have perhaps earned his doctorate in negativity.
What a ridiculous comment. He finds fault with one side because that side is the government now and is responsible for policy making. There is no other side to find fault with. He talks facts and looks like you are blind like all the BJP supporters who can’t see facts.
Wonderful discussion. Frankly, I listened with great interest Dr Parakala Prabhakar, being a strong critic of Modi Govt Policies. He had laid out his thoughts very clearly. Dr .Anand Ranganathan at his best rebutted the 'subjective thought' process of PP. PP says that those institutions born or non existent during freedom struggle are not patriotic... strange logic! Another goof PP spoke about 35million people were pushed down the poverty line in the last 9½ yrs... wrong! Multidimensional poverty has declined is good news, that was observed by all bodies including UN. As per the findings of the Index, multidimensional poverty (MPI) in India declined from 29.17% in 2013-14 to 11.28% of the population in 2022-23, with about 24.82 crore people moving out of this bracket in nine years to 2022-23. [18 Jan 2024]..
Parakala Prabakar is husband of our Finance Minister . Talking about Indian finance is broken is far fetched -- He is forgetting PANDEMIC in between which crippled entire world for 2 years.
Mr.Prabhakar has, in his quiet, respectful way, made mincemeat of Ranga, whose smirks aren't backed by objective arguments.
Very true 😂😂😂
Not at all.
It’s an Indian trait to try and win points by talking loud. It’s nice to see someone make a point in a calm and respectful manner.
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
@@babin214 The day we see the end of Gandhi hegemony in the Congress. Let the Sachin Pilots & Shashi Tharoors take charge of the party. Only then we'll start thinking of Congress as an option. Until then, BJP is there to stay. Take my word.
Great arguments Prabhakar sir😍. These religiously blinded people like Sai and Anand will thrive only on social media. When they encounter intellectuals like Prabhakar sir, they will only get down to Hindu-muslimarguments.
Anand speech was having an echo sound problem. Why?
Anand's voice is deliberately made to echo whereas other's voice are clear
Yes audio has been buggered up.
subtitles removed too ! that proves their defeat ! 👍👍
@@Sitaram-st3jo16:53
brother subtitle are auto generated and keep winning in your imagination@@jaysahup6563
All these tactics wouldn’t stop ppl from understanding the right from wrong
Why have you disturbed Anand's audio??Deliberate??
Yes it was deliberate
Yess.
Yes it was deliberate
Of course 😡😡😡
Of course
32:42 -Anand Ranganathan: In science, you never repeat failed experiments. But in politics, you do. That's the tragedy.
Epic !!
It's totally wrong that you never repeat failed experiments in Science,
That’s what Ranganathan is good at, talking points, completely devoid of facts
😮@@dandalasuman Pointless to repeat failed experiments
Soft spoken Prabhakar is more intelligent and who has foreseen what you and I can think of in the near future so don't forego his suggestions.
Discriminating hindus is secularism in india
Treating Hindus equally is communal in india
Thats why those who talk about hindus or instead of Hindus becomes communal 😢
It's other way round rather. India had always respected every religion. Intellectuals never believed in fanatics although he practised his religion at home and never imposed on others. It is purifying the self rather than making it an ostensive show .
@@mansidash78
Muslim appeasement politics are hallmark of Indian secularism . In a secular country why there are special laws for Muslims and why there is waqf board ?
@@mansidash78 ya ya Like wafq board hoarding 8Lakh acres of land..RTE is not applicable to minority institutions..Muslims have their own law regarding to poligamy and marriage
Well said Mr.Anand Ranganathan.It’s a befitting reply to Mr.Parakar and all those who think after 2014 everything has gone wrong.
Correct. Parakala Prabhakar is mentally blind.
If he is genuine and honesty, why is he making toolkit videos for Congress at the time of elections. Where was he all the time ?
@@varapulasrinivasaraoHe was in the BJP and then PRP. In fact, he resigned from PRP when it merged with Congress. He is more anti-Congress than the BJP, which supported forced division of Telugus by the Congress.
If Dr Anand Ranganathan criticises everyone, then he would be criticising the govt. since they make all the decisions and none by the opposition in Indian democracy.
AR has criticised the Government too.
Did you not hear him? He blasted modi government for going back on farm laws
He is a party changer like siddhu .Last party he joined was Praja rajyam of actor Chiranjivi.
@@james432ful Did he blast Modi for reducing tax devolution funding to Souther states by implementing the 2011 census at 100% in the 15th Finance Commission?
@@kksastry2319 If you are talking about Dr Parakala, he was in TDP during the previous AP govt. Although his wife is the Finance minister, Dr Parakala doesn't blindly support AP backstabbing party.
As a Telugu guy, I'm yet to see Mr. Parakala say a single positive thing. Speaks ill of everyone since decades including the ones who give him political space and his own wife. Such a waste of human energy filled with negativity all the time.
Could not agree more of your description for Prabhakara garu.. Having known him for decades, he is a person who exudes maximum negative energy in any crowded room, always taking ill of others in a sarcastic manner, back biting, looking for flaws even in a 5-star conference room, the tea is bitter, coffee over-heated, Aircon not working properly, staff is so untrained, even how it rains at wrong time, climate is always bad9 and stuffy in Bangalore, has nasty fights with his car Drivers, that none works with him for more than 6 months..
Would not comment about his internal family relations, as that is personal However one feels sorry for his family.
Prabhakara garu has such a bad persona exuding negative vibrations that surprisingly shops and malls get empty when he walks in. Such is his bad karma & negative energy.
He is speaking the truth...and truth bitters for the ppl who cant even have the guts to think over the circle
Yes he is an honest man who says it like it is! He is not pandering to any one's distorted ideas.
@@smritichiti2631 What truth? Which honorable husband rubbishes and makes fun of his wife and her work in a public manner, so as to harm it, and all this out of mere jealousy.
Prabhakara himself is too insignificant for Modi to take note of him, but certainly his actions reflect poorly on his wife, who is a self accomplished Lady and must be required to give explanations at some level atleast.
It is wisdom & sagacity of Modi, that he knows her value and ignores her husband's illogical rants, However in the dog eat dog world of Indian politics there must be hundreds who will try & poison Modi & Shah's mind against her.
Yet she soldiers on, hats off to her in tolerating such a difficult & negative spouse.
@@jaideepc786 If he was really the kind of person you mentioned, Nirmala Sitaraman would have known as Nirmala Parakala. Further, Nirmala Sitaraman did nothing to AP though she has been nominated to Rajyasabha and I am sure he had some influence in her nomination by being in TDP. No sane person from AP would support Modi, who destroyed the state by denying what BJP itself asked for the residual state when AP was divided.
Interesting, when Anand Ranganathan speaks, even audio system of Indian express starts echoing...... (: Rest of time sound system of Indian system works well...
Dr Prabhakar has list of problems and no Solutions .. This is the text book definition of Socialism -- Kolkata gone -- Kerala Gone -- Tripura is limping back after BJP came to power .. CHINA is flourishing since they practiced Capitalism since 1979 .. As Dr Anand said Socialism is failed world wide -- Let us not do that experiment once again . Socialism is widely recognized as DISTRIBUTION of WEALTH WHICH THEY DO NOT HAVE ..
Gone gone gone and now the country is limping and on crutches.
@spg6651 you are absolutely right... Kerala is a sinking ship and the captain is building his own empire for his offspring in Dubai. Kerala banks collapsing due to communists indulging in corruption. Government can't pay salaries to its employees and public transport system is collapsing due to lack of funds.. Situation is grim there... State is moving to Srilankan or Pakistan way...
Yes ❤
Why he give the solution? He told how the way it should not be done , why not they implement that way?
We dont want china. We want India
Parakala Prabhakar is THE husband of our Finance minister Nirmala Seetharaman…it seems he is not being heard at home too…🤔
Exactly. A jealous man wants to vomit venom about everything good that is happening to India.
Sad for the country.
@@kumark214
Why?
Prabhakar chap has a complex. He must see a good Psychiatrist
He made a wrong choice of working for congress . His wife became finance minister and he is still suffering .. what to do . She made right political choice ..
The beauty of democracy,husband ideology may differ,from that of wife.but each go as per their perception and commitment to values.Nirmalaji is sacrificing a lot for the sake of country and passionate of her responsibilities.Her honesty is some thing is unique.🙏💐🙏
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
"New India"n Express, adding echo when Anand is speaking 😂.
He lives in a echo chamber any way
@@patrioticindian57Touchè😂
Which wasn't there before 2014 till even upto the speaker before Anant😅
@@patrioticindian57 Similar to the one you inhabit or perhaps you were just projecting your own experiences....
What a first class answer by Dr Anand. Truly incredible.
Did You mean first class answer by third class man😂🎉
What is your class to judge Dr. Anand ranganathan
Ture, he recently passed the kindergarten !!!
What is your class to think he give answer above prakala prabhakar? That ananad chuthiya is nothing but bj party mouth piece@@prabharao1950
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
There is alwary a clarity in the speech of Dr Parakala Prabhakar.
on false narrative 😁
. . Promise was sky high in 2914 and manifesto sofar not achieved. Earlier graduates from India went to other countries and it is a record that every organisation was given to an Indian as CEOs. And in ten years graduates are going to other countries as soldiers. This answers the earlier great India. All four pillars of economy was laid before 2014 and no improvement or up grading was done. All this kept under the carpet and chose to blame grandfathers and selecting hindutva making all surrounding countries turned against Indians. This situation never existed and Neghru was respected as best statesmen and he brought many international critical matters solution. The main thing is before 2014 whole world was of there opinion that India will overtake china GDP of 20 trillion in 7 years and we are stuck at 3.8 trillion and world stopped India as overtaking china or equalling. One foreign press recently declared that India takes 250 years to catch up. All these are the results of 10 years efforts
Mr Parakala, what is your solution for our "eradication", a PFI DK combine? But it was the same in your past freedom fighters' Century.
It is very much appreciated to see the dynamic and well educated persons on this stage to speak about new india.
Is there a video of this event with better audio
4 saal ke bachho ke vlogs ki bhi production quality isse achhi hoti h. gawar log.
The sound problem experiencing here is intentional?
New India is like Anand Ranganathan's speeches. The way in which TV Channel presented.
Shocking how passive aggressive Prabhakar is. Super out of place in a Modern India with such closed thought process. He does not want to acknowledge even a bit of positive outcomes. In some instances he is outright lying - for example how many people have slipped into poverty ! On top of it he is an economist :) And the host trying her best to support Prabhakar
It is obvious that the host is biased
American Brookings institute reports(on Mar 1,2024) “India Eliminates Extreme Poverty” . This is the Power of Modi. Within 10 years, the man has lifted poverty & created a Nano Class. This should have been done by INC decades back but mofo are chor.
Prabhakar was all over the place after Anand roasted him 😂😂
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
@@babin214 it’s better you move out of the country if you think India is not on the right path… bjp will be in power for at least another 15 years !!!
parakaala prabhakar is husband of seetharaman, but , he is a bootlicker of chandrababu naidu .he back stabbed chiru when he was in praja rajyam. now he is loyal to his pedigree of babu.he always carries hate against modi.
Prof Ranganathan is on fire.
Propagandist
This is like yin and yang. One is worried man with grey hair and other younger one so proud of the progress. It is so uplifting to hear (per Anand- loud and clear), Indians are living in a golden era with best things in life. God bless the prosperity.
A fool with his head in the sand can pretend everything is rosy. It’s not. Wake up.
New India will also have SATI : so be prepared
Anand just criticized modi govt and congress+opposition for bad actions. He is balanced in his criticism. He is no way saying we are at the best
Prabhakar got exposed. Fumbling. Poor guy, he should not confront Anand and Sai.
Yes❤
its actually the other way! anand R is useful to listen if he points out islams anti-any-other concepts, destruction of actual indian history by the leftists etc. besides that he speaks of modi govt as if they're just municipal corporation hyping up buffeted #s of provision of water, toilet, house, cylinder, bank acct, etc . nothing abt 4k sq kmlost to china, ridicule of the country actually abroad, etc. so anand better stick to his science and history lessons, not economics and future
U r just saying to satisfy your ego.
In reality, Prabhakar was much more calm, logical and without religious biased. Anand was also good but not comparable to Prabhar as Anand is blinded by his hatred and has his agenda to support his political papa at all cost.
Anand, this is not random reel making. This is intellectual Prabhakar sir against whom u have to pur facts!
Also, Anand has just 1 dimension in his speech i.e. "hindu-muslim"
Mr.Anand appears to be a devout bhakt, he might be thinking we got independence in 2014 only
What you think when Bharat was divided by nehru and Gandhi from that day India got independence?
@@tippanachandu9928 Fools think everything wrong belong to Gandhi & Nehru and Everything right belongs to Modi and Shah. Modi Shah BJP is a fool making machine
No Hindus like you admire western values and ideologies more than Indian ones because you don’t know your own religion and culture
@@TeluguBusinessChannel
Fools think India appeared from USA and does not know its own strength. That is the problem with Indians . Even if one of them goes to the Kailasa temple in Aurangabad you understand the greatness of our history and culture. But no , people like to visit las vegas instead
@@TeluguBusinessChannel I think you lives in fools paradise 😝😝😝😝what your nehru and Gandhi did for nation?ho ho, bharat was divided under your Gandhi and Nehru,am i right?
Fantastic, Anand Ranganathan. A handful of people like JSai, Vikram Sampath and Anand and a handful of others, are in the process of extricating us from the false narrative about our country that was assiduously built and ingrained in us all by our early leaders
You’ve successfully named all the hypocrites spreading a false information without real tangible proof.
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
These are all assholes spreading lies
Dr Parkala an outstanding person who doesn't hesitate to tell the truth. A true patriot .
Wrong person. Mentally blind
Biased people who have problems but no solutions. Not a positive personality
@@vidyamadamanchi7091like gasbag Anand Ranganathan.
Parakala Prabhakar was very civil in his discussion while Anand was trying to annoy and mock him.
Crooked Prabhakar, you have no words. Better introspect. How much have you given to the society instead of asking the general public. You call yourself as Economist, right?
We need more people like Parakala to speak truth
We need more people like you who doesn’t know Hinduism or the greatness in its texts. One day the west will teach you and I would be ashamed.
You and paraakala on same wavelength..full of problems and negativity and no solutions
Solutions please 🙏🏼. Problem with everything does not lead you anywhere
2 month back tomato was sold at Rs 200/- kg but today it is sold at Rs 5/- now. Had we permitted 3 farm laws they could have got minimum price .
when 200 blame blame modi...when 5 blame modi....modi..modi..modi...modi
Come to my farm
Bad audío
Please tell us where in India you can get tomatoes @Rs 5/ retail.
No it cannot be because in our country everything is politics
Prabhakar is acting seriously like yogendra yadav, which has same agenda sung in jnu.
That’s been him for over 30 years. Egotistical Brahmin boy - who thinks he is intellectual and everyone knows he is for for nothing guy.
Prabhakar changed track after Anand gave him a taste of his own medicine.
Accha 😂
It is a great pleasure to watch how Anand destroys his opponents with facts and sarcasm!
Destroyed? Where? Both gentlemen put their arguments forward, both countered eachother's points, agreed on some points.
@@Nintendo_fanboy87anand criticized both sides for bad things. Pp spoke heavily biased. Anand gave numbers and facts. Pp only had rhetoric
Pp had not a single positive thing to say about last 10year rule. That's why congress booted him and now engaging him to talk ill about BJP rule
Prabhakar is boring... couldn't watch over 4.5 minutes.🙏
I think Mr. Prabhakar should stop coming to debates, to save himself from the disgrace. High time such people are ignored, done and dusted.
In the view of eminent person parakala prabhakarji, till 2014, india was poverty ridden with full of employment with a stunning growth in all fields od science, technolgy, medicine, space etc. Till 2014, there was no animosity on religion basis. Till 2012, every indian were living properously and not depended on government alms. I am astonished to hear that eminent personolity speech. Ridiculous.
Product of eminent University and top School.
Spinner would have made it in Tirupur or Kanchipuram.
I am surprised, since when did he become eminent?
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
@@babin214 tolerated ravan and thuglak rajs for the last 65 years, why don't you enjoy ram raj for 40 - 50 years.
Very wise, humble, soft spoken Parikala Prabhakar spoke with full of wisdom & Humility. Unlike Anand, who spoke in agitated manner... no Humility at all 😢
Content is more important. No amount of humility and humbleness will make it up!
Yes spitting poison in a hushed tones is so humble and mature.
Little man Parakala is so jealous of his wife 😂
Parakala
Don’t care two hoots if Parakala is a known economist. He earned notoriety for his cunningness and backstab. Earlier also, Parakala managed to become the inside man of Praja Rajyam Party and sabotaged them. He should not comment against a govt where his learned wife is the Fin. Min.
Most unreliable and erratic spokes person. Earlier also back home, Parakala backstabbed Eanadu Ramoji and Chiranjeevi of Praja Rajyam Party after winning their trust.
Prabhakaran is an Economist and speaks with great clarity. It is important to pay heed to him. Now there is a saying that empty vessels make the loudest noise 😂 and listening to the debate, it is clear who it is. The same hindu-muslim sanatani rhetoric. The echo is because he is speaking fast. You need to speak slowly into a Mike.
What sort of economist?
Do your homework. Find out 😅
He is husband of nirmala tai. If his own wife doesn't listen to him, why should anyone else?
Anand is speaking fast second time too but there is no echo. So don't come up with idiotic science and engineering issues with a mike 😅
@@bmniacpar excellence
Channel deliberatly echoed Ranganathans voice...pl answer. Many people asking.
Reload the vedio with apologies.
Lies presented by Prabhakar must be exposed.
Poverty rate in India was slashed, says report, but globally 1.2 bn still poor, according to research published 17 Oct 2022 by the United Nations Development Programme and the University of Oxford. Dr Usha Kanagaratnam, who leads the global MPI estimations at Oxford, shared, ‘In India 415 million people left poverty in 15 years. This finding (which is a lower bound) - that a huge country can more than halve multidimensional poverty in 15 years - really is a cause for hope.
* Index shows 1 in 5 people in the developing world living in multidimensional poverty.
* Hundreds of millions lack adequate nutrition, sanitation, housing and good cooking facilities.
* But, India’s MPI poverty rate fell from 55.1% (colonial Congress Rule) to 16.4% (Muzrim lover Modi Rule) as millions were lifted out of poverty.
Lies??! What do you see as truth? The fake news that's doled out to us through compromised TV channels?
If poverty is really slashed in India, why Modi govt. still claiming to give food grains to 80cr of people in India?
@@venkateswarluk5133Pertinent; I would presume that since the free foodgrains coverage has remained static over the last ten years, a number approximating the increase in population, viz 14 crore were uplifted. (Using this lone benchmark).
@@ananthan8951 You said in your previous comment that 415 million (41.5 cr) people left poverty in 15 years, which changed to 14 cr in 10 years in your second comment, which is true. Nevertheless, if 80cr out of 140cr still depend on food grains provided by the Modi govt., will we call it a reduction of the poverty rate from 55% in the previous govt. to 16% in the present govt. Also, what did Modi govt. actually do to reduce poverty and that too by increasing the tax burden on middle-class people?
@@venkateswarluk5133let's assume that the Modi govt did nothing. Then this could happen? If one looks at the situation objectively, it is very difficult to believe that it did nothing, and nothing has progressed from 2014.
One other thing I am totally surprised that in none of the debates, the devastating set back due to the COVID and Ukraine war comes up in an i objective way. It would be an achievement even if we stayed at pre-covid level now, but looks like we are better than that.
What is thenumber of demat acvounts ooened during thevlast ten years?
This guy should not be doing all this till his wife is the FM… Itna to loyalty Hona chahiye
Prabhakar appears to be pappu's guru. He makes no sense and disconnected in thoughts. Anand simply destroyed his views in minutes.
Why lot of echo with severe sound disturbance when Dr Anand was speaking. Every syllable was with double sound.
5:40 100% correct New India is going back to Indus valley 😂😂
When the prestitude media couldn't suppress the opinion then it suppresses the audio quality...true supporters of Indira Gandhi's emergency policies
😂😂 U r taking about Godi Media right 😂😂
Such a spineless , confused , dumb mediator & such a lame , pointless argument presented by Mr. Prabhakar. all I saw was an easy debate for the BOSS , Anand Ranganathan sir .
Seems that Anand Rangnathan's turn has been purposely echoed so that what he says cannot be understood.
swamynathan committe asked to provide MSP. why Bjp is reluctant?
BJP is always selective. The neo guy is blindfolded to see that 😂
Anand and Sai are very very tough nuts to crack. 😂😂
When would we see the end of Modi Regime? We are all eagerly waiting for that day. Really tired of seeing Modi’s Hypocrisy for last 10 years.
Accha 😂 1 gao wala will defeated him
Hello..what this Prabhakar talking about? He claims he is an economist! What did he do with his views when Congress was in power for 70 years? He do not impress at all.
She asks how many public enemies you have.. 😂
Mr. Prabhakar has to answer, Which Patriot who have participated in freedom struggle are alive to participate from the positions of power and if they are alive what is their age and what is their fitness.
Mr. Prabhakar laments these old freedom fighters are present in India. This mean new India has born.
Can he expect the o
suddenly audio goes bad with dr anand.
30:52 hear it bhakt don't cry
Good valid arguments Mr Prabhakar
Entire political science 😂😂😂😂 ….. can anyone guess who’s he referring to?
Dr Parakala Prabhakar is an excellent economist, clear in his views and talks from a space of integrity and goodwill. Thank you Dr Prabhakar. You are very relevant and logical. Stay blessed Sir
Majority of us thinks that Mr.Prabhakar has extreme left radical who always side with Muslim radicals under the name of minority.He is ridiculous.
Recently a Hindu procession in haryana is attacked with automatic weapons, stones and knives by Muslims without any provocation. Muslims are supposed to be insecure.😮
This block Ranganath keeps talking about Muslims only ,he forgets to counter Mr Prabhakar on facts lol, so typical sanghi lol 😅😅😅😅😅
Sri. Anand Ranganadhan has given a befitting reply to Mr. Prabhakar.. I belongs to Mr. Prabhakar's father's constituency, Narsapur of West. God.Dist. in A.P., who was a hardcore Congress party candidate throughout his life, which was the mother of all misdeeds, mischieves, dark laws against Hindus..
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
I don’t know which India Mr Prabhakar is talking about?.. Forget the economy the very fact that he thinks India is only for one particular religious group and ppl of other religion get second class citizen treatment is ludicrous! If not anything this is probably the only nation where the majority is fearful of speaking their minds!! Truly disappointing..
Abusing Hindu way of living has become a very convenient way of attracting public attention…….Perhaps,…….why perhaps it is well known that criticising Muslim way of living is sure to invite threats which could make someone’s day-to-day living unsafe
Why would you even think the way you are thinking. Can't you think of something else. Why this sudden shift in priorities. This is simply because the likes of you and million more are financially and economically safe, insulated and sound and as such you have so much time and energy at your disposal to talk about and support a divisive agenda and narrative. Come on, this is not the way progressive minds work. This is nothing but regression and degeneration..
Heard of the much bandied word Crypto Christian but millions of Crypto Hindus who end up as secularists and circus clowns.
Why was Rangarajan audio messed up?
Brilliant exposition programme
I have heard 'doom' Parakala Prabhakar before
Amazing - he can see doom everywhere except in the congress
Painful listening to parakala shallowness.
Every debate in which Dr.Anand is a speaker,people will come out with more information.
What calm composure by Dr Prabhakar, elegance personified compared to the jolted, petrified and insecure co-panalist Mr Anand😂😂😂
Parkala prabhakar is identified as the husband of our finance minister rather than his work as economist says lot about his talent
He never claimed, he is the husband of the Finance minister since she became a finance minister, I haven't even seen a picture together as a minister standing with her husband, He stands on his own merit despite being coming from a political family, His both parents were ex members of parliament in lok sabha, He is an alumni of JNU Delhi and has Doctoral degree from LSE ( London School of Economics).
Ranga lying with a straight face is Modern India 😂😂
Ohh. Really
@@udaysrikarof course he’s lying.
Wow, I can easily say that the place was absolutely filled with mindless, brainless and senseless sanghis with the kind of applause I was hearing when some useless and pointless argument was made against Prabhakar’s points! Also I can see the sheep herd is trying to dominate the comments area also supporting the senseless arguments and comparisons in the name of sarcasm by Anand!
The moderator brushed aside the mentioning of Stalin Jr.
Befitting reply by Dr Anand Ranganatham
Anand Ranganathan doesn’t deserve to be on the same stage as Dr. Parkala Prabhakar.
😂😂 Parakala only achievement is he is a husband of Nirmala aunty😂…except that he has no achievements..even his books don’t sell 😂..Anand Ranganathan is a great debater…and INDIAs Number one micro biology researcher just Google his papers
You are saying opposite.
@@tejesheconomics4072Anand Ranga Nathan is great gasbag full os bs and a lot of untruth.
Independence struggle should be owed to 1957 war , Savarkar and Subhash
Savarkar was an asshole. How was he responsible for the freedom?
And he is the husband of Nirmala Sitaraman 🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼
Her misfortune
Anand ji is rocking❤❤❤🙇♂️🙇♂️🙇♂️🙇♂️🙏🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌🔯🔯🔯🕉🕉🕉
Parakala is a genuine man and superb economists. Please read his books before you judge him. If you are a bakt already, skip ahead, AR type opinion makers(repeats the same thing in 1000 programs like a chant) and rabble rousers are the right choice for you.
Parakala and psick like you would be pissing in pants when the facts are thrown at you by the bhakts AR and the like. Commies/pSickulars are, just like Bedbugs which survive on others blood, who in their entire history any where in the globe could bring in prosperity in any country.That's a slap with a worn-out sandal on their face.
Andhbhakt can’t read books they only belong to Whatup university
Mr Prabhakar should learn to segregate economic issues and religious issues………Religiously Hinduism is much more tolerant than Islam…….
Personal attacks, name calling first, and whataboutery seem to be Mr. Anand's first point of arguments rather than any numbers / facts / lack of datas / any such metrics. I was watching this thinking he was supposed to be an intellectually with knowledgeable arguments. Pretty disappointing, the lack of logical points vs excessive shouting & what-aboutery.
That's what this new India has thrown up. If you don't have a point, scream at the top of your voice and go on the offensive.
If there is 1 thing u cant croticize ranga about its that he doesnt give facts and numbers
He spoke in points and gave very specific numbers and facts as examples to support his argument. He is a scientist and his political analysis is scientific too. On the other hand it was pp who was pulling fake allegation from air filled with heavy bias and lies
You are completely wrong
Mr. Parakala prabhakar is one hundred percent right.
Ranganathan Ji was fantastic at countering prabhamar ji😂
Could we have debate between Nirmala Sitaraman and Prabhakar Parakala.
Prabhakar is a hypocrite finding fault only on one side and let other side go scot-free. Anand clearly won the debate beating up pessimistic Prabhakar black and blue
You are so wrong... Dr. Prabhakaran is an economist of some repute. He gives facts and shares his opinion. How is that hypocritical?
@@mayamenon1616 Well, I had explained that in my previous message also. He finds fault on one side and keeps mum on the other side. He alludes to Yati Narsimhanand's *words* but happily forgets Sar than se juda *actions* in response to Nupur Sharma's retort quoting Hadees.
"Dr" for Prabhakar is interesting, might have perhaps earned his doctorate in negativity.
@@mayamenon1616So are people like Amartya Sen and others. Funny to see these "economists".
@@mayamenon1616 It would be hypocritical for those who blindly support the AP backstabbing party.
What a ridiculous comment. He finds fault with one side because that side is the government now and is responsible for policy making. There is no other side to find fault with. He talks facts and looks like you are blind like all the BJP supporters who can’t see facts.
Long live Dr Ranganathan. Salute Sir
Mr Anand talking like a hallucinated guy...... Nobody is questioning Modi but the process which our honourable PM Modi practice.
Silly It is the sound system.
Wonderful discussion. Frankly, I listened with great interest Dr Parakala Prabhakar, being a strong critic of Modi Govt Policies. He had laid out his thoughts very clearly. Dr .Anand Ranganathan at his best rebutted the 'subjective thought' process of PP. PP says that those institutions born or non existent during freedom struggle are not patriotic... strange logic! Another goof PP spoke about 35million people were pushed down the poverty line in the last 9½ yrs... wrong! Multidimensional poverty has declined is good news, that was observed by all bodies including UN. As per the findings of the Index, multidimensional poverty (MPI) in India declined from 29.17% in 2013-14 to 11.28% of the population in 2022-23, with about 24.82 crore people moving out of this bracket in nine years to 2022-23. [18 Jan 2024]..
Lovely viewpoint with facts,
How is it that a scholar like PP missed this. Selectivity Padma Bhutan to him.
Parakala Prabakar is husband of our Finance Minister . Talking about Indian finance is broken is far fetched -- He is forgetting PANDEMIC in between which crippled entire world for 2 years.
The economic rot had setup even before the pandemic.
Boss, look at the GDP growth rate before Covid. It was ruined. Medicore typical argument..
Who is this Prabhakar? Who was the lady anchor? Such lame and mediocre crap.